December 9th, 2016 Regional Learning Session
Moving From Volume to Value: A Multi-Stakeholder Perspective Keynote Presentations
Over 160 learning session participants had the opportunity to hear a national perspective on moving from volume to value from guest speaker Dianne Hasselman, Executive Director for Federal and New Programs at the Network for Regional Healthcare Improvement. Additionally, participants heard Diana Han MD, Chief Medical Officer and Global Medical Director for GE Appliances, share the GE Appliances journey towards value-based payment.
Keynote #1 Moving from Volume to Value: A Multi-Stakeholder Perspective • Dianne Hasselman, Network for Regional Healthcare Improvement (NHRI), Executive Director, Federal and New Programs
As the health care industry continues to move toward alternative payment models that reimburse providers for outcomes, why is a multi-stakeholder approach so important, and what role does each stakeholder play in this transition? Ms. Hasselman described the ongoing challenges facing communities throughout the country, and how local leaders are working together to improve quality, reduce costs, and create a more patient-centered health care system.
Keynote #2 Waking the Sleeping Giant: One Employers Collaborative Effort in Shifting to ValueBased Payment • Diana Han MD, GE Appliances, Chief Medical Officer and Global Medical Director Diana Han MD has become a national leader on how employers can better leverage their purchasing power and role to move the country away from paying for volume and toward paying for value. Dr. Han discussed the strategic decisions she is making for GE related to health and health care contracting and priorities, and how these decisions are changing outcomes, conversations and partnerships. Session slides can be found here. Please note that GE Appliances restricts the electronic distribution of Dr. Han’s slides but her contact information is included in the packet and she is available for any follow up questions.
Panelist Reaction and Audience Discussion
A multi-stakeholder panel spent time responding to Ms. Hassleman and Dr. Han’s presentations as well as providing their unique value-based payment efforts as well as the opportunities they see for the region. Panelist participants included: Larry Blosser, MD, Central Ohio Primary Care, Corporate Medical Director Michelle Mathieu, Aetna, Vice President Network Management Kendell Sherrer, Cardinal Health, Vice President Benefits Ernest R. Smith, AK Steel, Director, Employee Benefit King Stumpp, Netcare Access, President and CEO
Small Group Discussions
Learning session participants spent time discussing what value-based healthcare means as well as what the opportunities and challenges our region may experience as we shift to value-based healthcare. What does value-based healthcare mean to you and your organization? Accessibility to Providers • Access to providers • Assessing value of providers and rewarding them for their role. • Efficiency
Affordability of Care • Organizationally: lower cost to the patient and organization. • Putting cost into actual care—decreasing barriers for patients to be engaged and have access. • Receiving good healthcare at an affordable cost. • Reduce costs and reward good performance. • Reduced cost and increased quality for all (payers, patients, employers, providers) Collaboration and Engagement of all Stakeholders • A need for real collaboration between providers as well as social workers/care coordinators working with physicians. • Collaboration with doctors/employers/payers. • Employer engagement. • Enable patient engagement and accountability. • Moving toward team-based approach, incentivizing to keep patients healthy and out of office. • Opportunity to innovate • Team-based patient-centered care The Ability to Show Quality Care through Outcomes • Accountability for outcomes. • BWC using FFS and outcome incentive for vocation reward. • Efficiency and reduced cost for those outcomes. • Health outcomes and compensating for them. • Highest quality possible care, safety, efficient, patient perception of this. • Ideally best outcomes at reasonable cost. • Means care that mattersmaking folks better keeping folks well. • Population health • Quality outcomes especially with chronic diseases. • Reductions in readmissions to ERS, inpatient units and increases in linkages between all levels of healthcare in all areas. • Right care, right time, right place. • Triple aim view • Using what we have to provide the best outcome possible for patients. • Value-based healthcare is misleading, should be value-based health. • Which metrics would be best for tracking performance? • Wrap around services are valuable in providing the best care. What are the opportunities and challenges the region may experience shifting to value-based healthcare? Collaboration and Engagement of all Stakeholders • Aligning the patient’s goal with that of the employers. • Behavioral health coordination. • Coordination and commitment… it takes a village. • Coordination of care across care site and system • Engagement of large employers and their perspectives. • How will the change in Presidency/Congress affect the value-based healthcare proposition? • I think we need to consider and bring into the conversation the huge LEP, immigrant and refugee population in our region. How do they factor into the effort? • Identifying stakeholders based on need. • Lack of agreement on what value is • Lack of understanding • Lack of understanding between providers. • Language issue—corporate vs public health approach (understanding one another) • More collaboration, consistency, and standardization across payers to reduce unnecessary variability so provider can deliver higher/lower. • Pharmacists as providers. • Physician to physician collaboration. PCP<-->Specialty opportunity
Continued focus on Practice Transformation • Close gap of theory and practice. Not only money but manage staff for retention • Competing incentives. • Finances • Getting provider to buy into changes. • Giving care individualized to specific patient needs. • How do you get more time for physicians with patient education? • Modify metrics to measure value • Outcomes focus. Are we helping you? • Proving outcomes came from activities or staff. • Strategic improvement in demand management • Time required by PCPs to ask additional questions and provide care. • Tracking value will be hard—how will it be defined? • Variation by injury makes evaluating providers difficult. • Volume is a challenge. • Why focus on a disease? Focus on system and core characteristics of a delivery system that is organized/coordinated/comprehensive. • Workload Education and Patient Engagement • Consumers don’t understand • Education • Education about how to transition. • Education so all healthcare and community members know who to reach out to and who to refer who to. • Engaging patients • How do you get patients engaged? • Incentivizing the patientshow do you motivate them? Carrot vs stick • Lack of workforce (PCP) • Missing the patient voice. • Remembering the patient is the key stakeholder—consider including patients on panel. Incorporating Innovation in Health Insurance Plans • High deductible plans (donut holes) are still putting patients are risk. • In an era of high deductible health plans, more cost and quality transparency needs to be available to the consuming community. • Plan designs tweaking benefits The Need for Data Transparency across all Stakeholders • Cost data • Data overload • Data sharing/analytics for population health management. Takes us outside our four walls. • EHRs that track what we need. • Interoperability • Investment in healthcare infrastructure without better outcomes just serves to drive up costs. • Need for more data and quality staff. • Opportunity by sharing data. • Price transparency. • Siloed EHRs across providers • Technology
What was the value of December 9th’s regional learning session? Very High Value: 31% High Value: 55% Medium Value: 14% Low Value: 0% No Value: 0% HCGC would like to extend a thank you to the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the Network for Regional Healthcare Improvement (NRHI) for their technical and financial support of the December 9th Regional Learning Session. Please save the dates for our scheduled 2017 Regional Learning Sessions All Regional Learning Sessions held at the Nationwide and Ohio Farm Bureau 4H Center from 8:30 – 11:30 AM April 14th, August 25th, & December 8th, 2017 www.hcgc.org/registration
Thank you to all of the participants that were able to attend. We appreciate your time and perspectives. First Name John Peggy Dustin Maria David Carrie Laurence Donald Tiffany Larry Anthony Ernest Chad Tara T'Ria Lori Susan Jackiethia Barbara Hannah Yvonne Shawn Linda Billy Jamie Becky William
Last Name Alduino Anderson Arnette Asbury Aufdencamp Baker Bauer Bennett Blair Blosser Boakai Boyd Braun Britton Brownfield Buehler Butler Butsch Camfield Carlson Christian Clark Clem Cline Corder Cornett Cotton
Organization American Cancer Society Equitas Health Molina Healthcare of Ohio InXite Health Systems Mount Carmel Health Ohio Children's Hospital Association Family Medicine Education Consortium The Ohio State University College of Pharmacy Ohio Association of Community Health Centers Central Ohio Primary Care Association for Developmental Disabilities(ADD) Ohio Pharmacists Association Mount Carmel Health System The Center for Community Solutions Ohio Dominican University National Church Residences The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center Franklin County YMCA of Central Ohio - Hilltop Branch Mount Carmel Medical Group Mount Carmel Health Partners Sunrise Senior Living Mount Carmel Health Partners CliniSync/OHIP Department of Administrative Services The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center Nationwide Children’s Hospital
Maria Patti Derek Jeff Eric Jimmie Krisanna Neeraj Madeleine Harvey Steve Pam Harold Connie Melissa Emily Julie Tonya Jeanette Shannon Michael Andrea Tom Ryan Diana Abigail Dianne Leigh Anne LeeAnn Sue Jennifer Paul Shawna Carly Angie Wayne Lyubomir James Amber Cindy Melissa Gary Michael Thomas John Lisa
Courser Crego Curlee Curran Davies Davis Deppen Deshpande Devitt Doremus Dorman Doseck Duale Emerson Evans Fisher Frazier Fulwider Gaines Ginther Glanzman Green Hadley Haley Han Hartung Hasselman Hehr Helber Helke Hetrick Hicks Hite Hogan Holden Howlett Hristozov Hubbard Hulme Irvin Jefferis Jeffers Johansen Jones Kackloudis Kaiser
Mount Carmel Medical Group OhioHealth Airrosti Rehab Centers Cardinal Health Transformative Consulting Franklin County Public Health OhioHealth PrimaryOne Health Medical Mutual Consultant Ohio Optometric Association The Ohio State University Kare Intellex Concord Counseling Services Aetna Columbus Public Health State Teacher Retirement System Ohio Mental Health America of Franklin County The Ohio State University OhioHealth Group Healthcare leader OhioHealth Physician Enterprise Wells Fargo Insurance The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center GE Appliances OhioHealth Network for Regional Healthcare Improvement American Cancer Society OhioHealth Aetna Immediate Urgent Care OhioHealth Ohio Suicide Prevention Foundation Health Services Advisory Group OhioHealth MedComm Billing Consultants Ohio Dominican University Cincinnati Metropolitan Housing Authority Medical Mutual Boehringer Ingelheim OhioHealth OhioHealth OhioHealth Brandon River Consulting LLC Health Action Council PP 189 Fund Administration
Caitlin Chris Cheryl Jason Khayla John Janell Ray Daisy Kathleen Tani George Scott Jim Michelle John Pat Lauren Julie Dustin Nicole Brent Judith Michelle Teri Jodi Aishwarya Stefanie Susan Gregory Nomsa Beth Evan Kaci Meghan Regina Thomas Georgia James Lynette Stephanie Melissa Malcolm Janice Terri Celeste
Kapper Kloth Kurkowski Laipply LaVeris Leite Lewis Li Luma-Haddison Maedeker Mann Manu Mash Mason Mathieu McConaghy McKnight McKown McMahon Mets Miller Milovac Minaudo Missler Mitchell Mitchell Mohan Morrow Moser Myers Mzozoyana NeCamp Norris Nungesser O'Brien Oladipo O'Leary Oriold Paat Palmer Patrick Pickelheimer Porter Powell Power Prince
Columbus Public Health ChangeWorks of the Heartland Northeast Ohio Area wide Coordinating Agency OhioHealth Aetna Healthcare Collaborative of Greater Columbus Network for Regional Healthcare Improvement Cardinal Health Ohio Dominican University The Ohio State University PCMH The Dispatch Printing Company Ohio Dominican University CliniSync (Ohio Health Information Partnership) Medical Advantage Group Aetna The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center Ohio Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics OhioHealth Komen Columbus CompDrug PrimaryOne Health The Ohio State University Health Plan Central Ohio Primary Care Healthcare Collaborative of Greater Columbus Genesis Healthcare System Health Action Council Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center AbbVie Medical Mutual Ohio Dominican University The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center Network for Regional Healthcare Improvement Wells Fargo Insurance Services Franklin County Public Health Ohio Dominican University Metro RTA OhioHealth Physician Enterprise InXite Health Systems Lower Lights Christian Health Center Syntero The Medical Group of Ohio Healthcare Collaborative of Greater Columbus Ohio Dominican University CSH Doctors Hospital Family Practice
Dianne Cole Caroline Audrey David Susan Mark Anthony Carol Dacia Charles Greg Jason John Katie Jennifer Kendell Theresa Richard Shawn Ernie Kathy Adam Carly Krista Mike King Brina Barbara Steven Staci Lisa Michele Arlene Susan Karen Noelle Amy Lisa Michelle Gregory Beth Emily Luke Ted
Radigan Randolph Rankin Regan Reierson Reif Ridenour Roakai Runser Russell Sanders Sawchyn Scherzinger Schmeling Seringer Sheets Sherrer Shipley Shonk Smith Smith Spencer Spidel St. John Stock Stull Stumpp Sturgeon Sullivan Swart Swenson Thomas Twente Vance Vaughn Vogel Waddle Walton Watkins Watzig Whisman Whitted Williams Woods Wymyslo
Cardinal Health Ohio Dominican Masters of Healthcare Administration YMCA of Central Ohio Columbus Public Health United Way of Central Ohio Genesis Healthcare System the Ridenour Group Ohio Dominican University Mount Carmel St. Ann's Cleveland Clinic Akron General Mount Carmel Health System OhioHealth Anthem The Medical Group of Ohio OhioHealth Group Concord Counseling Services Cardinal Health The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center The Health Collaborative AbbVie AK Steel Corporation OhioHealth Ohio Department of Administrative Services OhioHealth Healthcare Collaborative of Greater Columbus Employers Health Netcare Access Ohio Dominican Graduate Student Franklin County Office on Aging InXite Health Systems PrimaryOne Health Cincinnati Metropolitan Housing Authority Aetna PrimaryOne Health Mount Carmel College of Nursing OhioHealth Grant Family Practice Southwest, OPG PrimaryOne Health The Ohio State University Aetna OhioHealth Group PrimaryOne Health Pfizer Quality Merck Ohio Association of Community Health Centers