THE PEER-REVIEWED FORUM FOR EVIDENCE IN BENEFIT DESIGN ™ FOR PAYERS, PURCHASERS, POLICYMAKERS, AND OTHER HEALTHCARE STAKEHOLDERS
AUGUST 2011 I VOL 4, NO 4 I SPECIAL ISSUE
ASCO 2011: Payers’ Perspectives
Can Episode Payments Reduce Cost Get Ready for the New Era of Maintain Quality Cancer Care? “Genomic Chaos” in Cancer Care and UnitedHealthcare is testing how to fix the broken system By Wayne Kuznar Courtesy of ASCO/GMG/Todd Buchanan 2011
By Caroline Helwick
F
or containing the cost of cancer care while maintaining or even enhancing quality, UnitedHealthcare is betting that payment for episodes of care, rather than fee-for-service (FFS), is a viable strategy. “Episode payments are by no means a perfect model, or the only solution, but it’s one solution,” said Lee N. Newcomer, MD, MHA, Senior Vice President of Oncology Services with UnitedHealth Group, who described his company’s program at 2011 ASCO.
“The system is badly broken. In 1970, a minimum-wage worker with a family of 4 could buy health insurance with 15% of his income. By 2005, it took 100% of his income to buy the same policy, and this percentage is now at 170%. The problem has gone from the minimum-wage worker to the middle class,” Dr Newcomer said. “We also have a drug pricing problem,” he stated. “The cost of prostate cancer care has doubled in 8 months because the drugs that extend survival Continued on page 7
A
new era of cancer care, in which genomic advances alter the landscape of cancer care and clinical research, is emerging. As “genomic chaos” rules this landscape, the healthcare system must be prepared to incorporate genetic technology into cancer care, and clinical trial design
must adapt as well, said George W. Sledge, Jr, MD, American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) President and Professor of Oncology, Indiana University Melvin and Bren Simon Cancer Center, Indianapolis, in his presidential address at the 2011 ASCO Annual Meeting in Chicago, IL. Continued on page 6
Novel Approaches to Therapy in the Oncology Pipeline By Caroline Helwick
T
he cancer drug pipeline is bursting with promising new therapies for a variety of tumors. Of the many investigational drugs presented at ASCO 2011, some of the most promising agents now in phase 2 or 3 clinical trials are discussed below and throughout this special issue. Cabozantinib—an oral inhibitor of MET kinase and the vascular endothe-
lial growth factor (VEGF) receptor— produced high rates of disease control in several solid tumor types and fully or partially eliminated bone metastases in a randomized phase 2 study that was spotlighted at a press briefing during the meeting. Disease control rates (demonstrated by response rate and stable disease) were 76% in liver cancer, 71% in Continued on page 5
Patients Want to Discuss Cost of Care, Oncologists Often Avoid It But OOP share should not affect clinical decisions By Wayne Kuznar
P
atients are more willing than their oncologists to discuss the cost of cancer care, according to a recent survey of patients with cancer. Discussion of cost has been promoted as a way to decrease spending on cancer care, and although oncologists recognize the importance of cost discussions, many are uncomfortable and ill-equipped to initiate them, according to Erin W. Hofstatter, MD, Assistant Professor of Medicine in Medical Oncology, Yale Cancer Center, New Haven, who presented the survey
Continued on page 6
IN THIS ISSUE HEALTH ECONOMICS
...........
11
High OOP costs degrade quality of care Bankruptcy rates greatest for cancer survivors
BREAST CANCER
...............
PROSTATE CANCER
19
Exemestane: new option for prevention METASTATIC MELANOMA
.....
Novel agents boost survival
MULTIPLE MYELOMA . . . . . . . . . . .
21
A new paradigm for drug development from bench to bedside
Medicaid reimbursement for cancer screening
©2011 Engage Healthcare Communications, LLC
results. In previous surveys, only 36% of oncologists reported feeling comfortable discussing Andrea J. cost with their patients. Bullock, MD “I’m not sure that fellows in general receive much training about how to talk to patients about the topic. As a result of that, oncologists even 10 to 20 years in practice aren’t used to talking about it,” said Dr Hofstatter. She and colleagues surveyed 256 patients from an academic ambulatory clinic in Massachusetts. Approx-
20
............
24
New treatments for castrationresistant disease RECTAL CANCER
...............
30
Patients with insurance often overtreated PAYERS’ PERSPECTIVE
........
34
What do payers want in oncology diagnostics?