Page 1 of 2 WHY ALI MIRZA IS NOT A SUNNI
According to Orthodox Ahlussunna theology, Engineer Ali Mirza is a Heretic and an Innovator. Ahlussnnah Theological Orthodoxy identifies three levels :
1.
Necessaries: Doubting any one of them is a Certain Kufr/Cufr.Such believes are Like the Finality of Holy Prophet, Thirty Divisions of Qur’a:n , Eternity of Divine Essence [Dh:a:tul Ba:ri:],Day of Judgement/ Dooms day,The belief that Only Divine Essence is Worshipable and Only Divine Essence can be called for Assistance in issues which are Beyond Reason [Asba:b] Ex: Doubting in Finality of Holy Prophet, Doubting in Day of Judgement/Dooms Day etc. are Kufr in Certainity. 2. Essential: Necessaries: Doubting any one of them is Probebly Kufr/Cufr.Ex: Uncreatedness Of Qur’a:n etc. Ex: Doubting inUncreatedness of Divine Attribute Of Speech. (without believing these things, you are probably not a Muslim, according to orthodox theology). Doubting them generally expels from the folds of Ahlussunnah. Doubting in the Companionship of Saiyiduna: Mu”a:viah AS(“ALAIHISSALA:M) and Saiyiduna “Ali KAV (K-R-M ‘ALL-H V-JH-). Similarly declaring any Badri S:ah:abi: as Kafir or Muna:fiq either is Kufr with Certainty or Kufr with a Very Strong Probability. 3. Obligetory Doubting in them Certainly Expels from Ahlussunnah but not from Isla:m: Ex: Createdness of Human Acts. Disbelieve in the Createdness of Human Acts and Attributes eg Human Will. (things important and consequential for One to know, but if one fail to understand them, or interpret them in some unusual way, they are not likely to disqualify him from Isla:m but Certainly From ‘Ahlussunnah. You may want to worship with those who agree with you on these matters however). 4.Hemi Obligetory: Disbelieveing in them brings one on the boundary line of Ahlussunnah ,yet in Islam. Doubting in them makes a person partially Heretic yet may be considered as ‘Ahlussunnah but a Great Error . Example. Mu”a:viah AS as a Copyist of Vah:y. Denying Mu”a:viah RD: as a Copyist of Vah:y expels one from ‘Ahlussunnah, and denying that He was a Copyist stated above is to become purely Heretic and out of the folds of Ahlussunnah. 4. Incidental :These are the Matters of Ijtihad. One may differ havinf his own arguments. ( Ijtihad is entirely "unimportant."If it is not in the Quran and Ahadith: THIS MEANS, God did not want as definite and certain and did not reveal about it, for some Divine Wisdom and Reason. These items are not likely to either keep you out of heaven, nor make it difficult for you to be of like mind with other believers). Page 1 of 2
Page 2 of 2
Moderate Sunnism Consider matters like Taqli:d etc in this category. According to the vast majority of Muslim denominations, Ali Mirza denies Important like Necessaries and Essential. Thus, most would not consider any group that rejected this teaching "Ahlussunnah" That's why, to most Ahlussunnah denominations, Ali Mirza ,Jmaatul ,Masudis etc. are not Sunnis, but separate sects/cults.But Ali Mirza also constitute a separate faith other than Islam.
Page 2 of 2