11 Effective Instructional Practices that Work PRESENTED BY
Dr. Jacob Francom
&
Dr. Drew Hinds
Good Teaching is Beautiful TEACHING IS LIKE FISHING‌ You use different lures for different fish.
You use different methods for different learners.
Good Teaching is Beautiful TEACHING IS LIKE BEAUTIFUL MUSIC… Where, instructional methods are the instruments… When played alone they make sound… When played together in tune, rhythm, and feeling, they become amazing music!
Goal Setting Instructions for Today GOAL SETTING (Logic model) TEMPLATE Inputs Goals Results Outcomes
1. Select your FOCUS (classroom or school wide) 2. Select areas of OPPORTUNITY 3. Select areas of CHALLENGE 4. S.M.A.R.T. Goals
Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic & Time-Bound 5. Select an INSTRUCTIONAL PRACTICE
Research Grounding Tell me, I forget Show me, I remember Involve me, I understand!
DR. JAKE
DR. DREW
Dr. Tate has studied the research of learning style theorists (Gardner, 1983; Sternberg, 2000), and examined brain research (Jensen, 2008, 2009; Sousa, 2006), then synthesized her findings into 20 strategies (Tate, 2003) that appear more effective for understanding and long-term retention of information than doing worksheets or listening to long lectures.
Dr. Robert Marzano, an educational researcher, conducted a metaanalysis (study of studies) of instructional strategies to determine which were the most effective. Roberto Marzano’s 9 Effective Instructional Strategies summarizes the nine instructional strategies that were found to affect student achievement in the meta-analysis.
11 Effective Instructional Practices that Work 1. Movement 2. Identifying Similarities & Differences
3. Games 4. Nonlinguistic
representations 5. Technology 6. Cooperative Learning
7. Role Plays, Drama,
Pantomimes, & Charades 8. Setting Objectives &
Providing Feedback 9. Project-Based &
Problem-Based Instruction 10. Cues, Questions &
Advanced Organizers 11. Relationships
Guiding Students in the Learning Process…
ACTIVE ENGAGEMENT & SOCIAL INTERACTION Guiding students in the learning process… https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uMW-dM-BDu0
Guiding Students in the Learning Process is Difficult
ACTIVE ENGAGEMENT & CLASSROOM MANAGEMENT
HTTPS://WWW.YOUTUBE.COM/WATCH?V=PK7YQLTMVP 8
Overcoming Barriers to Learning BREAKING THE LEARNING BARRIER.
Overcoming Barriers to Learning WHAT ARE THE BARRIERS TO LEARNING THAT YOUR STUDENTS’ FACE? • LANGUAGE • delays due to lack of incidental learning • lack of vocabulary
• LACK OF PERSONAL EXPERIENCES • LACK OF EXPRESSIVE ABILITY
Overcoming Barriers to Learning WHAT ARE THE BARRIERS TO LEARNING THAT YOUR STUDENTS FACE? • NOT PRACTICING • not doing their homework • learning is limited to the classroom
• EMOTIONAL HEALTH • isolation • self esteem
• LACK OF SUPPORT FOR LEARNING
Principles of Effective Teaching for Student Engagement “I expect you all to be independent, innovative, critical thinkers who will do exactly as I say!”
DO YOU WING IT?
Define Instruction
WHAT IS GOOD INSTRUCTION? THINK-PAIR-SHARE
What Works BEST in Raising Student Achievement?
HOW DO WE KNOW WHAT HAS THE MOST IMPACT? >0.40 = student learning accelerates 0.40 = students learn a yearâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s worth of academic material over the course of one school year 0.00 = no effect on student learning <0.00 = student learning is negatively affected
Sources of Variance in Student Achievement: Professor John Hattie (University of Auckland): Meta-analysis of over 100,000 studies
HOME:
5-10%
SCHOOL:
5 - 1 0 % (principals, other leaders as influence)
PEER EFFECT:
5-10%
TEACHERS:
30%
STUDENT:
50%
“It is what teachers know, do, and care about which is very powerful in this learning equation”. – J. Hattie
Reference: Hattie, J. (2003). ‘Teachers Make a Difference: What is the Research Evidence?’, http://www.leadspace.govt.nz/leadership/articles/teachers-make-a-difference.php
Active Engagement Strategies for the Primary Grades
PROCESSING STRATEGY: 10:2 THEORY • To reduce information loss, pause for two minutes at about ten minute intervals. • For every ten minutes or so of meaningful chunks of new information, students should be provided with two or so minutes to process the information. • Students can respond and discuss their current understanding in various ways. (Rowe, 1983)
2
The Value of Rapport
RAPPORT HAS TO DO WITH BUILDING RELATIONSHIPS WITH STUDENTS THAT FORM A BRIDGE THAT HOLDS THE WEIGHT OF
FEEDBACK.
3
The Value of Rapport
STRATEGIES: Home visits Parent conferences Personal connections Analogies/Metaphors Multicultural activities
Guided Teaching to Ensure Visible Learning… - Anita Archer
I do it. – modeling (including thinking aloud) WE
do it.
WE ALL YO U
– teacher guided
do it.
do it.
– partner practice or small group
– modeling (including thinking aloud)
Guided Teaching to Ensure Visible Learning… - Anita Archer
I do it. – modeling (including thinking aloud) WE
do it.
WE ALL YO U
– teacher guided
do it.
do it.
– partner practice or small group
– modeling (including thinking aloud)
Visible Learning
Goal: Make Thinking VISIBLE Wow, in this class I have to THINK and I have to EXPLAIN my thinking!
EVERY STUDENT
EXPLAINS
THEIR THINKING & RECEIVES FEEDBACK FROM PEERS AND THE TEACHER
MULTIPLE TIMES
IN
–
EVERY LESSON!
1. Movement Any task learned when we are physically engaged in doing it remains in our memory for a very long time. (Allen, 2008)
1. Movement “When students move while learning, they put information in procedural or muscle memory. Procedural memory is one of the strongest memory systems in the brain and the reason that one seldom forgets how to drive a car, ride a bicycle, play the piano, type on a keyboard, tie one’s shoes, or brush one’s teeth” (Tate, p. 97).
1. Movement “Having students work quietly at their desks eliminates up to 40 percent of kinesthetic learners who have to be moving to learn” (Hattie, 2009). “Physical performance is probably the only known cognitive activity that uses 100 percent of the brain” (Jensen, 2008).
1. Movement EXAMPLES:
Skip-Count aloud by 2s, 10s, 20s while acting like you are jumping rope (Tate, p. 100). Gallery Walks/Chalk Talks â&#x20AC;&#x201D; things posted to read around the room.
1. Movement EXAMPLES:
When discussing content in a cooperative group for one or two minutes, have students stand and talk rather than remain seated. Four Corners Activity: Students have to choose a point of view and be able to defend it on the corner.
1. Movement ACTIVITY:
Four Corners 1. 2. 3. 4.
1. Movement
REFLECTION & APPLICATION How will I incorporate
Which MOVEMENT
MOVEMENT into
activities am I already
instruction to engage
incorporating as I
studentsâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; brains?
teach the curriculum?
What additional MOVEMENT will I incorporate?
2. Identifying Similarities and Differences The ability to break a concept into its similar and dissimilar characteristics allows students to understand complex problems by analyzing them in a more simple way.
2. Identifying Similarities and Differences
COMPARING – CLASSIFYING METAPHORS – ANALOGIES
2. Identifying Similarities and Differences ASSESSING MYSELF 0 – 1 – 2 – 3 – 4 COMPARING
TO A GREAT EXTENT
I clearly communicate the knowledge students will use for the comparing activity. I make sure students know how to use the process of comparing. I make sure students understand the graphic organizers for comparing.
2. Identifying Similarities and Differences ASSESSING MYSELF 0 – 1 – 2 – 3 – 4 COMPARING
TO A GREAT EXTENT
I give students an appropriate amount of guidance for the activity. I collect evidence about my students’ proficiency at using comparing.
Examples
Compare the Rain Forest and Desert Climate. Compare the Rain Forest and Desert Animals.
2. Identifying Similarities and Differences REFLECTING ON MY CURRENT BELIEFS & PRACTICES
COMPARING
What is the purpose of asking students to compare? What kinds of activities do I use to help students compare? I can think of a time that I asked students to compare, and I was pleased with the results. Why did it go well?
2. Identifying Similarities and Differences REFLECTING ON MY CURRENT BELIEFS & PRACTICES
COMPARING
I can think of a time when I asked students to compare, and I was not pleased with the results. Why did it not go well? What questions do I have using comparing in my classroom?
2. Identifying Similarities and Differences CLASSIFYING, METAPHORS & ANALOGIES Classifying Graphic Organizers
2. Identifying Similarities and Differences CLASSIFYING, METAPHORS & ANALOGIES Classifying Graphic Organizers
Metaphors Uses one thing to mean another Example: All the World is a Stage
2. Identifying Similarities and Differences CLASSIFYING, METAPHORS & ANALOGIES Classifying Graphic Organizers
Metaphors Uses one thing to mean another Example: All the World is a Stage
Analogies Expresses similarities between things that might seem different Example: Having ADD is like wearing a hearing aid on all five senses
3. Games Using games formats encourages students to cooperate with one another, helps them focus and pay attention, and is motivating and loads of fun. (Algozzine, Campell, & Wang, 2009a)
3. Games “Children pay more attention to academic tasks when brief, frequent opportunities for free play are provided” (Dewar, 2014). “Students not only learn more when playing a game but their participation in class and their motivation for learning… increases” (Posamentier & Jaye, 2006).
3. Games EXAMPLES:
Matching Scavenger hunt Bingo
3. Games EXAMPLES:
Ball toss “A ball-toss game not only encourages cooperation, problem solving, and physical movement, but it also enables student to think and act quickly while operating in a safe environment” (Jensen, 2007).
3. Games ACTIVITY:
Name a City Ball Toss London … New York … Krakow …
3. Games
REFLECTION & APPLICATION How will I incorporate
Which GAMES
GAMES into instruction
am I already
to engage
incorporating as I
studentsâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; brains?
teach the curriculum?
What additional GAMES will I incorporate?
4. Nonlinguistic Representations
Incorporate visuals, images, pictographs, and pantomimes to reinforce concepts and vocabulary.
4. Nonlinguistic Representations
ASSESSING MYSELF 0 – 1 – 2 – 3 – 4 NONLINGUISTIC REPRESENTATIONS
TO A GREAT EXTENT
I clearly identify the knowledge students will use to generate representations. I clearly communicate the strategy that students will use to generate representations. I make sure students know how to use the strategy that I want them to use to represent knowledge.
4. Nonlinguistic Representations
ASSESSING MYSELF 0 – 1 – 2 – 3 – 4 NONLINGUISTIC REPRESENTATIONS
Examples
TO A GREAT EXTENT
Over time, I collect evidence about my students’ proficiency at using a variety of methods to represent knowledge. Compare the Rain Forest and Desert Climate. Compare the Rain Forest and Desert Animals.
4. Nonlinguistic Representations
REFLECTING ON MY CURRENT BELIEFS & PRACTICES
NONLINGUISTIC REPRESENTATIONS
What is the purpose of representing knowledge in different forms? When do I ask students to represent knowledge using forms other than words? What questions do I have about representing knowledge?
4. Nonlinguistic Representations
REFLECTING ON MY CURRENT BELIEFS & PRACTICES
NONLINGUISTIC REPRESENTATIONS
Examples
Capital Resources
4. Nonlinguistic Representations
NONLINGUISTIC REPRESENTATIONS
Examples
4. Nonlinguistic Representations
REFLECTING ON MY CURRENT BELIEFS & PRACTICES
NONLINGUISTIC REPRESENTATIONS
Examples
How a Bill becomes a Law in the United States.
4. Nonlinguistic Representations
NONLINGUISTIC REPRESENTATIONS
Examples
4. Nonlinguistic Representations NONLINGUISTIC REPRESENTATIONS • Consider the images used • Consider the video movement used • Identify a data point that you would call into question
5. Technology Students of all ability levels can use technology â&#x20AC;&#x153;to process, demonstrate, and retain and share information and communication.â&#x20AC;? (Karten, 2009, p. 196)
5. Technology “Technology is not an end unto itself but should be used to enrich, enhance, and present content in a more efficient manner” (Sousa, 2011). The use of computers can add a diversity of teaching strategies, increased opportunities for practice, and increases in the nature and amount of feedback to the student (Hattie, 2009).
5. Technology
CONSIDER: 1. Did you see yourself in the pit crew? 2. What tools do we use? 3. Why observe?
5. Technology Possible Video Clip Questions 1. How were the tires removed?
8.
What was the color of the wheels?
2. How long was the car in the Pit?
9.
What was the last thing that was done to the car before it left the PIT area?
3. Were all 4 tires changed? 4. Did he get gas? 5. Were all of the PIT Crew uniforms the
same colors?
10. What was the race? 11. What was the year?
6. What was the color of the number on
12. How many drinks did the driver
7. What was the color of the car?
13. How fire extinguishers were shown?
the car?
take?
5. Technology EXAMPLES:
Google Classroom/tools: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=apCIbV9YKA
5. Technology EXAMPLES:
Google Classroom/tools Google Cardboard: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mlYJdZ eA9w4
5. Technology IDEAS:
Formative
goformative.com
Socrative
socrative.com
Kahoot
getkahoot.com
ScreenCastify
screencastify.com
Online scavenger hunts
5. Technology ACTIVITY:
5. Technology
REFLECTION & APPLICATION How will I incorporate
Which TECHNOLOGY
TECHNOLOGY into
am I already
instruction to engage
incorporating as I
studentsâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; brains?
teach the curriculum?
What additional TECHNOLOGY will I incorporate?
6. Cooperative Learning
Research shows that organizing students into cooperative groups yields a positive effect on overall learning.
6. Cooperative Learning NON-LINGUISTIC PROGRAMMING (NLP) ANIMAL
ROLE
Owl
note taker
Chimp
spokesperson
Lion
time keeper
Koala
includer / encourager
Grouping
Description
Benefit
Heterogeneous
Different animals
Base Camp
Homogeneous
Same animal
Expert Group
7. Role Plays, Drama, Pantomimes, & Charades When learning is physical, it is more motivating, engaging, and likely to be extended. (Jensen, 2008)
7. Role Plays, Drama, Pantomimes, & Charades “The brain based learning strategies of role play and simulations provide students with emotional connections to real life” (Karten, 2008). “Role play motivates students to participate, enhances enthusiasm and recall of information, and stores that information in the body as well as the brain” (Jensen, 2007).
7. Role Plays, Drama, Pantomimes, & Charades IDEAS:
How an atom works… How subtraction/addition works… Dramatize a story of historical significance.
7. Role Plays, Drama, Pantomimes, & Charades IDEAS:
Have students act out geometric terms â&#x20AC;&#x201D; line, line segment, ray, right angle, obtuse angle, acute angleâ&#x20AC;Ś
Have someone come up and re-teach something that was just taught.
7. Role Plays, Drama, Pantomimes, & Charades ACTIVITY:
Dramatize “The Camel’s Nose”
7. Role Plays, Drama, Pantomimes, & Charades REFLECTION & APPLICATION How will I incorporate
Which ROLE PLAYS, etc.
ROLE PLAYS, etc. into
am I already
instruction to engage
incorporating as I
studentsâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; brains?
teach the curriculum?
What additional ROLE PLAYS, etc. will I incorporate?
8. Setting Objectives & Providing Feedback
Set objectives that are adaptable to student learning goals and provide feedback toward those goals.
9. Project-Based & Problem-Based Instruction A great deal can be achieved when the projects that teachers assign pull students into the learning by helping them make personal connections. (Karten, 2007)
9. Project-Based & Problem-Based Instruction “Project–based learning is a 21st Century approach that differentiates instruction while simultaneously encouraging high levels of student engagement” (Bender, 2012). “Problems stimulate brain activity as it seeks patterns, makes sense, finds connections, and functions effectively” (Fogarty, 2009).
9. Project-Based & Problem-Based Instruction
“The more complex the problem, the more complex the brain activity becomes” (Fogarty, 2009, p. 167).
9. Project-Based & Problem-Based Instruction ACTIVITY:
Scientific Method M&M Experiment
9. Project-Based & Problem-Based Instruction REFLECTION & APPLICATION How will I incorporate
Which PROJECT &
PROJECT & PROBLEM
PROBLEM BASED
BASED INSTRUCTION into
INSTRUCTION am I
instruction to engage
already incorporating as
students’ brains?
I teach the curriculum?
What additional PROJECT & PROBLEM BASED INSTRUCTION will I incorporate?
10. Cues, Questions and Advanced Organizers
Use questions, cues, and advance organizers to help students tap into their background knowledge to make sense of information.
11. Relationships
CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT
“It is easier to build strong children than to repair broken men.” – Fredrick Douglass (Dunivent, A. & Dunivent, S., 2007, p. 92)
11. Relationships
Word or phrase that best describes your thoughts on relationships: https://answergarden.ch/
11. Relationships
The Whisper Test: A Message from Mrs. Leonard
11. Relationships
NO WRITTEN WORD NOR SPOKEN PLEA CAN TEACH OUR YOUTH WHAT THEY SHOULD BE. NOR ALL THE BOOKS ON ALL THE SHELVES. IT’S WHAT THE TEACHERS ARE THEMSELVES. –UNKNOWN
11. Relationships
At your school, every student should belong to every teacher.
11. Relationships â&#x20AC;&#x153;As I get older it becomes even clearer to me that the best the world has to offer finds its expression not in ideology, not in doctrine but in simple, caring relationships.â&#x20AC;? - Alexander Solzhenitsyn
11. Relationships ACTIVITY:
Write down the three most influential people in your life as you were growing up.
11. Relationships
BUILD RELATIONSHIPS Every Child Needs a Champion…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFnMTHhKdkw
11 Effective Instructional Practices that Work 1. Movement 2. Identifying Similarities & Differences
3. Games 4. Nonlinguistic
representations 5. Technology 6. Cooperative Learning
7. Role Plays, Drama,
Pantomimes, & Charades 8. Setting Objectives &
Providing Feedback 9. Project-Based &
Problem-Based Instruction 10. Cues, Questions &
Advanced Organizers 11. Relationships
11 Effective Instructional Practices that Work STRATEGIES I WILL APPLY IN MY TEACHING…