สรุปสภาวะเศรษฐกิจไทย
Monthly Economic Brief for Executives
31 July 2012
Charting Thailand’s Economy®
| Monthly Economic Brief for Executives |
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
About Charting Thailand’s Economy
Different ways to utilize us
Editor’s talk
Charting Thailand’s Economy® is a subscription‐only magazine providing monthly economic brief for executives.
For busy business people, this is an easy and very objective way of keeping up with the economy. If you are really busy, we also provide executive summary. You might also use this as your macro economic ‘desk reference’.
Dear readers,
We believe that following and understanding the economy should be exhaustive yet easy for everyone. Yet in reality it is so hard to make sense of all the information (news, opinions, etc.) presented to us. This is where we come in and offer an easy way to follow the Thai economy. Our report includes test results (economic indicators) and summary. All the data used in our charts are from official sources, but we try to present them in a way that make sense and easy to understand. We hope you like us, and if you do and want to learn more about the economy, visit our website at www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
For professionals, this will be your oasis with ready‐to‐use charts for all important macro indicators. You can copy and use them in your presentations, as long as you show that there are the work of ChartingThailandEconomy.com and keep out from editing.
For students and self‐learners, this is a great educational tool for you to further your understandings of the economy.
Charting Thailand’s Economy belongs to Chart Maker Co., Ltd.
We have been in e‐magazine format for 6 months already and I am proud to announce that we are starting the paper format with this issue. I also think that it’s a good time to recap why we exist at all, starting from our mission and the methodology that we believe will save you time in following the economy. For our regular check on the health of the Thai economy, June saw another set back in production sectors especially in Manufacturing. Private consumption and investment, which grew impressively so far this year, also cooled down. Export situation has not improved. Looking forward, Business and Industrial confidences are less optimistic. Concerns over budget and balance of payment deficits are still there. We hope you enjoy our new way of helping you making sense of all economic data. See you again next month.
Saroj Khongkhaprasertsin Managing Editor Editor@chartingthailandeconomy.com
Registered No. 0135555002491 Address: 19 Moo 11, Lamlukka rd., Lamlukka sub‐district , Lamlukka district Pathumthani 12150, Thailand Tel: +662 987 0919, Fax: +662 987 0917, Email: admin@chartingthailandeconomy.com
2
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Our way to save you time in following the economy Current problems
Our way to solve them
Understanding
• Many experts’ insights, not sure whose to believe
• Produce your own insights from a good understanding
Interpretations
• Explanations here and there
• Exhaustive and fact-based explanations
Information
• Information over load
• Only those that matter are selected • Visual graphic presentation
Data
• Multiple sources
• One source, one stop
3
OVERVIEW OF THAILAND’S ECONOMIC INDICATORS
Monthly Health check On the economy
GDP & Real sector
Wealth distribution
• Economic structure • Growth projections • Historical growth • Production side indicators • Expenditure side indicators • Leading indicators
• Income distribution (GINI) • Poverty line • Per Capita income • Unemployment • Household wealth
Monetary sector • Interest rates • Bank’s loan and deposit • Bank’s capital ratio • Bank’s NPL • Stock markets • Inflation
Fiscal sector • Budget balance • Public debt
External sector • Balance of Payment • Current Account • Trade balance • Export • Import • External debt • International reserves • Foreign Direct Investment • Exchange rates • Tourists 4
Why we call this
A Monthly Health check on the economy How is my daughter?
How is the economy?
She recovered quite well from the accident and will continue her development this year. Medicines and supplementary food worked well.
The economy recovered strongly and quicker than expected. Monetary and Fiscal policy have been promoting growth well.
She’s still growing disproportionately compared to other kids.
Income distribution, although improving, is still below international standard.
She’s quite healthy, only a little concern on her high sugar level.
Overall Economic stability is good. Low inflation, stable exchange rate, but budget deficit is still worrying. 5
OUR ONLY MISSION:
Saving you time, in following the economy “Charting Thailand's Economy provides a complete 360 degree viewpoint of the Thai economy and is extremely easy to follow. I would highly recommend it to anyone interested in Thailand's economy” Mr Gancanapol Van Compernolle Director, L.V. Technology Plc.
"Simple, Understandable, & Practical" Mr Sivakorn Srisuwan CEO, Pan Asia Insurance Brokers Co., Ltd.
"It's exactly what I'm looking for to update on Thai economy in a few minutes. Really save my time.“ Ms Pikun Phitya‐isarakul Fund Manager, Phillips Securities (Thailand) Plc. 6
Executive summary Growth Real GDP in 1Q/2012, grew 0.3% y‐o‐y or 12.6% q‐o‐q despite manufacturing having not fully recovered from the flood damage. The strong growth was driven mainly by the service sector on the production side and Investment on the expenditure side. Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement . Export situation has not got better as there is only 0.5% growth in the first half of 2012 while Import grew 12.7%. FDI, on the other hand, grew 112% in the first 5 months of 2012 compared to the same period last year. BOI’s net application grew 66% in the first half of 2012, with Japan as the biggest source. Lastly a good sign from tourism, a 8% increase in tourist arrivals in the first half of 2012. Looking forward, both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro‐growth. Government spending in the first half of 2012 has increased substantially with compensation for flood victims and new investments among the extra items.
Policy rate is still at 3%, a rather low level. Bank’s loan continued to increase in May, reacting positively to the policy rate cuts earlier this year. Both Business and Industrial sentiments dropped slightly in June, but their respective levels are still considered healthy. Consumers are less pessimistic. The consensus projection is still between 5.7‐ 6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7‐5.8% for 2013 Employment and wealth distribution Thailand’ unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. Thailand’s per capita income was at USD 4,420 in 2011, ranked83th in the world. An average Thai is slightly poorer than an average Chinese but more than three times richer than an average Indian. Income distribution in Thailand is among the worst in Asia but the trend has been slightly improving. Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard.
Stability Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. This is very low by historical and international standards. Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Budget deficit for Thailand is still expected to be ‐2.3% of GDP. Public debt as percentage of GDP increased slightly this year due mainly to direct government debt. Majority of the public debt is domestic based. Thai Baht depreciated slightly against a basket of key currencies in July . Balance of Payment deficit in the first half of 2012 due largely to deteriorating Trade Balance. External debt increased slightly this year but capability to repay is not a concern as debt service ratio continued to decline and international reserves is at healthy level.
7
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
CONTENT
Executive summary Page
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013
9 12
• Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard.
45
• Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
57
18 24 35 39 42
48 52
61 65 71
8
Thailand waking up from the flood crisis
Chart 1.05 – Historical Real GDP growth rate Annual growth, percent
7.8% 7.1% 6.3%
CAGR* 2000‐2011 = 3.9%
5.3% 4.8%
4.6%
2.2%
5.1% 5.0%
2.5% 0.1%
0.3%
-2.3%
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Note: (*) Cumulative Annual Growth Rate Source: NESDB; CTE analysis
1Q12 2Q12 3Q12 4Q12
9 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Trading, Transport, Utilities among others have contributed positively to 1Q12 GDP growth Chart 1.06a – Real growth by sector, 1Q12
Chart 1.06b – Sectoral contributions, 1Q12
Year‐on‐Year percentage change
Contributions to total Real GDP growth
GDP
GDP
0.3
Utilities
9.1
Financial
6.5
Hotel&Res
5.2
0.3
Trading
0.6
Transport
0.4
Utilities
0.3
Trading
4.1
Agriculture
0.3
Agriculture
3.9
Financial
0.3
Transport
3.8
Hotel&Res
0.2
Health&Social
2.5
Education
0.1
Education
2.3
Health&Social
0.0
Construction
0.8
PublicAdmin
0.0
PublicAdmin
0.7
Construction
0.0
Other social
-0.3
Private HH RealEstate Mining Fishing
-1.0 -1.3 -2.0 -2.4
Manufacture-4.2 Source: NESDB; CTE analysis
Private HH
0.0
Other social
0.0
Fishing
0.0
Mining
0.0
RealEstate
0.0
Manufacture -1.7
10 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Investment and Private consumption have been key growth engines in 1Q12 Chart 1.08a – Real growth by expenditure, 1Q12 Chart 1.08b – Expenditure Contributions, 1Q12 Year‐on‐Year percentage change GDP
GDP
0.3
I
20.5
‐M
4.5
C
G
X
Contributions to total Real GDP growth
2.7
-1.6
-3.2
0.3
I
4.0
C
1.3
G
-0.1
Discrpncy
-0.2
X
-2.3
‐M
-2.4
11 Source: NESDB; CTE analysis
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Executive summary
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013 • Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard. • Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
12
Agriculture production dropped in June from the month before but increased strongly compared to last year Chart 1.10 – Agriculture production index (2005=100)
Monthly Average 250.0
CAGR
2.5%
116.0
200.0
M‐o‐M ‐5.8%
113.1 111.8
112.0
110.2
Y‐o‐Y 7.0%
150.0
106.7
2012 100.0
2011 100.0 50.0
0.0
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
J F M A M J J A S O N D
13 Source: Office of Agricultural Economics, Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Big set back for MPI in June
Chart 1.11 – Manufacturing Production Index (2000=100)
Monthly Average 250.0
CAGR
5.1% 190.1 172.4 159.5
179.1 166.3
172.6
200.0
2012
149.9 137.6
150.0
123.9 109.9 100.0
M‐o‐M ‐3.5%
2011
Y‐o‐Y
‐9.6% 50.0
0.0
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
J F M A M J J A S O N D
14 Source: The Office of Industrial Economics
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Set back from prior month in most sector MPIs
Chart 1.12a – Y‐on‐Y change in MPI by sector
Chart 1.12b – M‐on‐M change in MPI by sector
June 2012, percent
June 2012, percent
Vehicles
40.3
Tobacco
16.7
Electrical
7.4
15.0
Basic Mat
-3.6
12.4
Wood products
2.7
10.0
Machineries
6.0
Chemical
5.0
Mineral
4.4
Food & Bev
4.3
Furniture
1.5
Precision instru
0.7
Petroleum
-1.1
Paper
-2.4
Rubber&Plastic
-3.1
Transport Equip
-6.9 -3.4 -7.2 -4.9 -9.5 2.2 -0.6 -8.4 0.2 -0.6
-8.9
Metal products
-12.1
Apparel
-16.5
Textiles
-16.6
Leather OA
0.7
-2.5 -13.7 -0.3 4.7
-23.3
-2.0
-31.4
Electronic -39.8 Source: The Office of Industrial Economics; CTE analysis
-1.6 -10.4
15 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Slight drop in Capacity utilization rate with some industries running over normal capacity Chart 1.13a – Overall Capacity Utilization Rate
Chart 1.13b – Capacity utilization rate by sector
Percent
June 2012, percent 74.3
72.4
67.2 62.4
61.1
58.3
Jan-12
Feb-12
Mar-12
Apr-12
May-12 Jun-12
Electronic Precision instru Vehicles Machineries Transport Equip Chemical Electrical Petroleum Mineral Paper Rubber&Plastic OA Food & Bev Metal products Basic Mat Apparel Tobacco Textiles Furniture Leather Wood products
139.8 113.8 107.1 90.8 84.7 79.0 72.6 72.5 71.0 69.7 65.9 62.6 58.0 55.3 49.2 44.8 43.5 41.5 35.3 32.5 20.7
16 Source: The Office of Industrial Economics
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Thailand ranks lowest in the latest round industrial production growth Chart 1.14 – Manufacturing Production Index Latest, percent change on year ago China ‐ Jun
9.5
Taiwan ‐ Feb
8.4
Singapore ‐ Jun
7.6
Malaysia ‐ May
7.6
Japan ‐ May
6.0
US ‐ Jun
4.7
Australia ‐ Q1
4.7
Indonesia ‐ May
3.0
South Korea ‐ May
2.6
India ‐ May
2.4
Russia ‐ Jun
2.0
Hong Kong ‐ Q1
-1.7
Pakistan ‐ Apr
-2.0
Euro Area ‐ May
-2.6
Brazil ‐ May Thailand ‐ Jun
-4.3 -9.6
17 Source: The Economist
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Executive summary
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013 • Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard. • Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
18
Despite a little set back compared to last month, Private consumptions continued its impressive growth from last year Chart 1.15 – Composite Private Consumption Index* (2000=100)
Monthly Average 155.0
CAGR
M‐o‐M ‐2.5%
3.1% 150.0
118.1 105.9
126.0 121.9 124.1
130.5
134.1
138.9
2012
127.1 145.0
Y‐o‐Y
4.4%
111.4 140.0
2011
135.0
130.0
125.0 02-Avg 03-Avg 04-Avg 05-Avg 06-Avg 07-Avg 08-Avg 09-Avg 10-Avg 11-Avg
Note: (*) seasonally adjusted Source: Bank of Thailand
J F M A M J J A S O N D
19 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Strong recovery in consumptions across the board so far this year despite a little set back in June Chart 1.16a – Y‐on‐Y change
Chart 1.16b – M‐on‐M change
First 6 months of 2012 vs 2011, percent
Jun vs May 2012, percent
Commercial Car (Unit)
46.2
Passenger Car (Unit)
4.7
30.5
NGV (kg.)
19.0
LPG (litre)
17.7
HH electricity (kilowatt/hour)
3.9 0.0 1.0
14.5
Real VAT (2000 prices, baht)
-5.7
12.1
Real import of consumer goods (2000 prices, US$)
7.8
Diesel (litre)
7.1
Motocycle (Unit)
2.6
Benzene & Gasohol (litre)
1.5
-6.3 -18.4 5.6 -13.6 1.6
20 Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Private Investment is stronger than ever
Chart 1.17 – Private Investment Index (2000=100)
Monthly Average 300.0
CAGR
250.0
6.1%
2012
202.2 169.6 172.2 171.9 154.4
186.4
178.0
2011 200.0
156.6 150.0
132.4
M‐o‐M 0.0%
118.3 100.0
Y‐o‐Y
18.3%
50.0
0.0 02-Avg 03-Avg 04-Avg 05-Avg 06-Avg 07-Avg 08-Avg 09-Avg 10-Avg 11-Avg
J F M A M J J A S O N D
21 Source: Bank of Thailand
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Impressive Private Investment growth across the board in the first 6 months of this year Chart 1.18a – Y‐on‐Y change
Chart 1.18b – M‐on‐M change
First 6 months of 2012 vs 2011, percent
Jun vs May 2012, percent
Domestic commercial car sales (unit)
25.3
Import of Capital Goods (2000 prices, Baht)
Construction Area permitted (sqm)
19.6
6.2
Domestic Machinery sales* (2000 prices, Baht)
4.6
Domestic Cement sales (ton)
4.5
Note: (*) figures are 1‐month delayed Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
2.9
-1.2
-1.7
7.1
3.3
22 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Improvements in Property indicators in May
Chart 1.19a – Y‐on‐Y change
Chart 1.19b – M‐on‐M change
First 5 months of 2012 vs 2011, percent
May vs Apr 2012, percent
Condo unit registered
66.5
New housing unit
Value of land transaction
Constr. Area in municipal
12.4
26.8
-62.7
-0.6
-11.8
33.8
-17.0
23 Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Executive summary
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013 • Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard. • Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
24
FDI grows 112% in the first 5 months of 2012
Chart 5.14 – Foreign Direct Investment Million USD
Monthly cumulative FDI 12,000
11,331
9,690
9,460
10,000
9,511
8,547
8,000
8,048
6,000
2012
4,000
4,853
2011 2,000
0
-2,000
05FY
06FY
07FY
08FY
09FY
10FY
11FY
J
F M A M J
J
A S O N D
25 Source: BOT
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
BOI’s net application for the first 6 months of 2012 grew 66%
Chart 5.15 – BOI net application of foreign direct investment* Billion Baht
396 351 297
278 236 167
08FY
09FY
Note: (*) Foreign investment (foreign equity>=10%)
Source: Board of Investment
10FY
11FY
2011/6M
2012/6M
26 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Japan has been the biggest source of FDI for Thailand
Chart 5.16 – BOI net application of FDI* breakdown by country group Percent of total
Others
20%
17%
USA ANIEs
3% 6%
10%
15%
12%
ASEAN
3% 6% 6%
17% 27% 3% 6% 2% 7% 8%
12%
Europe
23%
17%
7%
23% 27%
Japan
11% 0%
63% 44%
49%
35% 22%
08FY Note: (*) Foreign investment (foreign equity>=10%) (**) ANIEs: Taiwan, Hong Kong, South Korea
Source: Board of Investment; CTE analysis
09FY
10FY
11FY
2012/6M 27 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Tourist arrivals increased 8% y‐o‐y for the first 6 months of 2012
Chart 5.18 – International Tourist Arrivals Million visits
Monthly cumulative 25.0
19.1
CAGR
6.5% 15.9 13.8 11.7
14.5
14.6
20.0
14.1 15.0
11.5
10.8 10.0 10.0
2012
2011
5.0
0.0
02FY 03FY 04FY 05FY 06FY 07FY 08FY 09FY 10FY 11FY
J F M A M J J A S O N D
28 Source: Department of Tourism
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
More European tourists so far this year
Chart 5.19 – International Tourist Arrivals breakdown by country of nationality Percent of total
Rest of world
14.0
14.3
15.3
15.6
15.0
14.2
Americas
6.4
6.2
6.0
5.3
5.0
5.2
Europe
27.0
27.3
28.7
27.9
25.9
28.3
East Asia
52.6
52.1
50.0
51.2
54.1
52.3
07FY
08FY
09FY
10FY
11FY
2012/6M 29
Source: Department of Tourism; CTE analysis
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Worsened trade balance so far in 2012
Export**
Chart 5.03 – Trade balance* decomposition Billion Baht
6,897 5,302
5,851
6,176 5,195 3,466
593 432 320
07FY
─
08FY
09FY
10FY
12/6MO
Import***
-77
-111
11FY
6,974 5,962 -363
4,870
5,857 4,602 3,829
07FY
08FY
09FY
10FY
11FY
12/6MO
07FY
08FY
Note: (*) Not equal to the one in Balance of Payment decomposition due to few adjustments (**) Excluding Electricity and aircraft export, adjustment for Balance of payment and exchange rate conversion (***) Excluding Electricity and military import, adjustment for Balance of payment and exchange rate conversion
Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
09FY
10FY
11FY
12/6MO
30 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Slow growth in Export after 6 months in 2012 Chart 5.05a – YTD annual change in Export in Baht Chart 5.05b – Sectoral contributions First 6 months of 2012 vs 2011, percent Total export Re‐exports Petroleum Mining Automotive Forestry Toiletries Agro products Photo instru Machinery Jewellery Aircrafts Fishery Chemicals Electronics Metal -0.5 Electrical -0.8 Petro‐chemical -1.2 Furniture -3.8 Apparels -13.4 Optical instru -15.1 Footware -16.5 Other export -20.1 Agriculture -22.4 Other manufacturing -39.4 Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
Contributions to total export growth
0.5 77.7 39.5 35.4 19.3 17.9 14.0 10.7 10.5 7.5 6.6 5.6 4.8 4.8 0.2
Total export Automotive Petroleum Agro products Machinery Mining Jewellery Chemicals Toiletries Photo instru Forestry Aircrafts Fishery Electronics Re‐exports Metal Furniture Electrical Petro‐chemical Footware Optical instru Apparels Other export Other manufacturing Agriculture
0.5 2.0 1.7 1.3 0.5 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 -0.1 -0.1 -0.2 -0.5 -0.7 -2.2 -2.4
31 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Middle East, ASEAN and NAFTA are the best performing export markets so far this year Chart 5.07a – Export by country
Chart 5.07b – Change in Export
Percent of total export in Baht term
First 6 months of 2012 vs those of 2011
฿ 5.9
฿ 5.2
฿ 6.2
Middle East
5.4
5.7
4.9
4.5
EU
13.2
11.9
11.2
10.6
Japan
11.3
10.3
10.4
10.5
NAFTA
12.2
11.6
10.9
12.7
Rest of the world
16.6
18.4
East Asia ex‐Japan
18.3
20.1
100% =
18.0
21.2
฿ 6.9 (Trillion) Middle East
10.9%
ASEAN
10.9%
NAFTA
16.9
22.9
Rest of the world
-1.3%
Japan
-1.7%
East Asia ex Japan
ASEAN
22.5
21.3
22.7
6.4%
-7.4%
23.7
EU -10.5% 08FY
09FY
10FY
11FY 32
Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Capital goods has contributed most to import growth so far this year Chart 5.09a – YTD annual change in Import in Baht Chart 5.09b – Sectoral contributions First 6 months of 2012 vs 2011, percent
Total import
Contributions to total import growth
Total import
12.7
Others
25.9
Capital goods
23.3
Intermediate ‐ Fuel
21.0
Consumer goods
Intermediate ‐ Non fuel
16.8
-0.3
12.7
Capital goods
5.1
Intermediate ‐ Fuel
3.9
Others
2.6
Consumer goods
Intermediate ‐ Non fuel
1.2
-0.1
33 Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Capital goods have gained its importance in overall import so far this year Chart 5.08 – Import by economic classification Percent of total import in Baht term ฿ 4.9
฿ 6.0
฿ 4.6
฿ 5.8
฿ 7.0
฿ 3.8
Others
6.7
8.0
7.8
10.2
12.4
11.1
Capital goods
20.4
19.3
22.3
20.9
21.3
23.8
100% =
Intermediate – Non‐Fuel
47.5
44.8
43.0
44.0
40.0
37.6
Intermediate ‐ Fuel
18.4
20.7
18.6
17.4
18.8
19.9
Consumer goods
7.0
7.1
8.3
7.5
7.5
7.6
07FY
08FY
09FY
10FY
11FY
12/6MO
(Trillion)
34 Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Executive summary
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013 • Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard. • Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
35
Policy rate was held at 3.0% in July
Chart 3.01a – BOT’s policy rate
Chart 3.01b – Inter bank overnight rate 3.6% 3.5% 3.4% 3.3% 3.2% 3.1% 3.0% 2.9% 2.8% 2.7% Jul-12
Aug-11
Chart 3.01c – Saving deposit rate
Jul-11
Chart 3.01d – Commercial bank MLR 1.0%
Max
Max
0.9% 0.8%
Min
7.5%
6.0%
0.5%
5.5%
0.4% 0.3% Jun-12
8.0%
Min 7.0% 6.5%
0.7% 0.6%
Jul-11
3.6% 3.5% 3.4% 3.3% 3.2% 3.1% 3.0% 2.9% 2.8% 2.7% Jun-12
Jul-11
5.0% Jun-12
36 Source: Bank of Thailand
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Bank’s loan continued to increase as well as the L/D ratio Chart 3.02a – Commercial Banks’ Loan THB billion 9,000 8,500
M‐o‐M 1.2%
8,000
Y‐o‐Y
7,500
14.6%
7,000 Jun-11
Jul-11
Aug-11
Sep-11
Oct-11
Nov-11
Dec-11
Jan-12
Feb-12
Mar-12
89.5%
90.2%
Apr-12
May-12
91.7%
92.7%
Chart 3.02b – Commercial Banks’ Loan/Deposit* ratio Percent 100% 95% 90%
88.9%
89.6%
86.7%
87.5%
Jul-11
Aug-11 Sep-11
88.7%
89.3%
89.8%
89.5%
85% 80% 75% Jun-11
Oct-11 Nov-11 Dec-11 Jan-12
Feb-12 Mar-12
Apr-12 May-12
37 Source: Bank of Thailand
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
22% increase in fiscal expenditure in the first half of 2012 compared to the same period last year Chart – Monthly cumulative Fiscal expenditure Billion Baht 2500
2000
1500
2012
2011
1000
500
0
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
38 Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Executive summary
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013 • Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard. • Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
39
Drops in business confidences in June
Chart 1.21a – Business Sentiment Index* 100
Chart 1.21b – Thai Industries Sentiment Index** 200
Better
50.8 50
Better 52.7
55.5
53.8 47.7
51.5
99.6
102.1
104.0
106.0
102.7
100
Worse
0
100.9
Worse
0 Jan-12 Feb-12 Mar-12 Apr-12 May-12 Jun-12
Note: (*) Below is the interpretation of the index: Index = 50 indicates that business sentiment remains stable Index > 50 indicates that business sentiment has improved Index < 50 indicates that business sentiment has worsened
Jan-12 Feb-12 Mar-12 Apr-12 May-12 Jun-12
Note: (*) Below is the interpretation of the index: Index = 100 indicates that industries sentiment remains stable Index > 100 indicates that industries sentiment has improved Index < 100 indicates that industries sentiment has worsened
40 Source: Bank of Thailand, The Federation of Thai Industries
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Improving consumer confidence in June
Chart 1.20a – Consumer Confidence Index 200
Better On future income 100
On job Overall
Worse
0 Jul-11
Aug-11 Sep-11
Oct-11
Nov-11 Dec-11
Jan-12
Feb-12
Note: (*) The index ranges from 0 to 200 100 means consumer confidence is equal to those of the prior month Over 100 means consumer confidence is better than those of the prior month Under 100 means consumer confidence is worse than those of the prior month Source: The Center for Economic and Business Forecasting, UTCC
Mar-12
Apr-12 May-12 Jun-12
41 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Executive summary
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013 • Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard. • Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
42
No change in GDP growth projection consensus
Chart 1.03a – Real GDP growth projections
Chart 1.03b – Real GDP growth projections
For 2012, Annual percentage change
For 2013, Annual percentage change 7.00
NESDB
The Economist poll 6.00
7.00
BOT
6.00
BOT FPO
5.00
4.00
5.00
The Economist poll
3.00
3.00
2.00
2.00
1.00
1.00
0.00 Feb-12 Mar-12 Apr-12 May-12 Jun-12
4.00
Jul-12
Forecast as of, month ending
0.00 Feb-12 Mar-12 Apr-12 May-12 Jun-12
Jul-12
Forecast as of, month ending 43
Source: NESDB, Fiscal Policy Office, Bank of Thailand, The Economist
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Thailand’s growth for 2012 is expected to be behind only China and India Chart 1.04a – Real GDP growth projections
Chart 1.04b – Real GDP growth projections
2012, Annual % change, as of July 28th
2013, Annual % change, as of July 28th 2012
2012
China
8.2
India
6.6
Thailand
6.0
Indonesia
5.9
Malaysia
6.5 5.4 3.3
3.8
Australia
3.9
3.3
Singapore
3.1
South Korea
3.0
Taiwan
3.2 4.2 4.0
2.8
4.8
2.6
4.6
2.3
US
2.1
Brazil
2.0
Euro Area -0.4
4.7
4.2
Russia
Japan
7.4
4.4
Pakistan
Hong Kong
8.5
1.5 2.1 4.2 0.4 44
Source: The Economist
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Executive summary
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013 • Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard. • Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
45
Unemployment dropped slightly in May
Chart 2.7 – Unemployment rate Percent 2.4
2.2
2.1
1.8 1.5
1.4
1.5
1.4
1.0 0.7
02-Avg
03-Avg
04-Avg
0.68
05-Avg
06-Avg
0.82
0.75
09-Avg
0.81
0.56
0.52
Jul-11
08-Avg
0.66
10-Avg
11-Avg
0.97
0.92
Apr-12
May-12
0.73
0.43
0.42
Jun-11
07-Avg
Aug-11
Sep-11
Oct-11
Nov-11
Dec-11
Jan-12
Feb-12
Mar-12
46 Source: National Statistical Office, Bank of Thailand
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Thailand’s unemployment rate is lowest comparing to other leading economies Chart 2.8 – Unemployment rate Latest, percent Thailand ‐ May Singapore ‐ Q1 Malaysia ‐ May
0.9 2.1 3.0
South Korea ‐ Jun
3.2
Hong Kong ‐ Jun
3.2
China ‐ Q2 Taiwan ‐ Jun Japan ‐ May Australia ‐ Jun Russia ‐ Jun Brazil ‐ May Pakistan ‐ 2011 Indonesia ‐ Q1 US ‐ Jun India ‐ 2011 Euro Area ‐ May
4.1 4.2 4.4 5.2 5.4 5.8 6.0 6.3 8.2 9.8 11.1
47 Source: The Economist
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Executive summary
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013 • Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard. • Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
48
Slight improvement in Thailand’s income distribution since 2007
Chart 2.1 – Thailand’s GINI coefficient
0.520
1994
0.513
1996
0.507
1998
0.522
2000
0.507
0.493
2002
2004
0.515
2006
0.499
2007
0.485
2009
Note: (*) The Gini coefficient is a measure of inequality of a distribution of income. It is defined as a ratio with values between 0 and 1 Here, 0 corresponds to perfect income equality (i.e. everyone has the same income) and 1 corresponds to perfect income inequality (i.e. one person has all the income, while everyone else has zero income). Therefore, the lower the ratio the better the income distribution.
Source: National Statistics Office, NESDB
49
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Not much has changed for income (in)equality in Thailand
Chart 2.2 – Quintile by income Percent of total income
Top 20% Bottom 20%
11.9
13.3
14.9
14.1
13.5
13.1
14.6
13.2
12.1
13.9
12.5
11.3
Top 20%
54.4
57.0
59.0
57.2
56.5
56.1
57.5
55.9
54.9
56.1
54.9
54.2
Second 20%
20.6
19.5
19.7
19.9
19.8
19.8
20.1
20.2
20.0
20.2
20.1
18.9
Third 20%
12.4
11.7
11.1
11.7
11.8
12.0
11.5
12.1
12.4
12.1
12.4
12.6
Forth 20%
8.1
7.5
7.4
7.6
7.8
8.0
7.7
8.0
8.4
4.6
4.3
4.1
4.2
4.3
7.3 4.0
7.7
Bottom 20%
7.1 4.0
4.2
4.5
4.0
4.4
4.8
1988
1990
1992
1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
2006
2007
2009 50
Source: National Statistics Office, NESDB
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Data from World Bank suggests that income equality problem in Thailand is not as bad as in Malaysia or China Chart 2.3 – Income equality in the world Ratio of the share of national income going to the richest 20% to the share of the poorest 20% Latest, selected countries Honduras Bolivia Comoros South Africa Namibia Brazil Colombia Guatemala Seychelles Central African Republic Paraguay Panama Zambia Costa Rica El Salvador Swaziland Chile Peru Qatar Ecuador Nigeria Venezuela, RB Mexico Malaysia Dominican Republic
29.7 27.8 26.7 25.3 21.8 20.6 20.1 19.6 18.8 18.0 17.3 17.1 16.6 14.5 14.3 14.0 13.5 13.5 13.3 12.5 12.2 11.5 11.3 11.3 11.3
Source: The World Bank; CTE analysis
Argentina Kenya China Philippines Turkey Russian Federation Thailand Iran, Islamic Rep. Sri Lanka Bhutan Maldives Lithuania Malawi Mongolia Cambodia Lao PDR Vietnam Indonesia Nepal India Bangladesh Egypt, Arab Rep. Pakistan Afghanistan Slovak Republic
11.3 11.0 9.6 8.3 7.9 7.3 7.1 7.0 6.9 6.8 6.8 6.7 6.6 6.2 6.1 5.9 5.9 5.1 5.0 4.9 4.7 4.4 4.2 4.0 3.6
51
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Executive summary
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013 • Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard. • Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
52
Poverty reduction, according to figures from NESDB, seems to have been working over the past 7 years Chart 2.4a – Thailand Poverty Line
Chart 2.4b – Number of poor people
Baht/ month/ person
Million 1,678 1,579
1,386
1,586
6.10 5.40
5.80
5.30
5.08
2009
2010
8.1%
7.8%
2009
2010
1,443
2006
2007
2008
Chart 2.4c – Poor people Percentage of total population 9.6%
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2006
8.5%
9.0%
2007
2008
53 Source: NESDB
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Many countries in Asia and especially ASEAN, still have majority of their populations earning less than $2.00 a day Chart 2.5 – Poverty in the world, selected countries Poverty headcount ratio at $2 a day (PPP) (% of population), Latest Congo, Dem. Rep.
95.2
Madagascar
92.6
Nigeria
84.5
Egypt, Arab Rep. Venezuela, RB
12.9
Peru
12.7
Ethiopia
77.6
Brazil
Bangladesh
76.5
Iran, Islamic Rep.
Timor‐Leste
72.8
India
68.7
Lao PDR
66.0
Pakistan
60.2
Nepal
57.3
Cambodia
53.3
Indonesia
46.1
Vietnam
43.4
Philippines
41.5
South Africa
31.3
15.4
10.8 8.0
Mexico Thailand Turkey
5.2 4.6 4.2
Chile
2.7
Malaysia
2.3
Argentina
1.9
Romania
1.7
Bulgaria
0.4
Hungary
0.4
Montenegro
0.3
China
29.8
Poland
0.2
Bhutan
29.8
Slovak Republic
0.1
Sri Lanka
29.1
Slovenia
0.1
Croatia
0.1
Russian Federation
0.1
Iraq Colombia
21.4 15.8
Source: The World Bank
54
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
An average Thai is slightly poorer than an average Chinese but more than three times richer than an average Indian Chart 2.6 – GNI per capita, selected countries 2011, Atlas method (current US$) Norway Qatar Luxembourg Switzerland Denmark Sweden Netherlands United States Finland Austria Belgium Canada Japan Germany Singapore France United Arab Emirates Ireland United Kingdom Italy Hong Kong SAR, China Iceland Spain Israel Greece Source: The World Bank
Rank
Rank (from 166)
88,890 1 80,440 2 78,130 3 76,380 4 5 60,390 6 53,230 7 49,730 8 48,450 9 48,420 48,300 10 46,160 11 12 45,560 13 45,180 14 43,980 15 42,930 16 42,420 17 40,760 18 38,580 19 37,780 20 35,330 21 35,160 22 35,020 23 30,990 24 28,930 25 25,030
Czech Republic Hungary Brazil Turkey Argentina Mexico Malaysia South Africa Colombia China Thailand Ecuador Ukraine Indonesia Iraq Egypt, Arab Rep. Sri Lanka Philippines Bhutan India Nigeria Vietnam Lao PDR Cambodia Bangladesh
18,520 12,730 10,720 10,410 9,740 9,240 8,420 6,960 6,110 4,930 4,420 4,140 3,120 2,940 2,640 2,600 2,580 2,210 2,070 1,410 1,200 1,260 1,130 830 770
29 36 46 47 49 51 53 65 69 78 83 85 100 103 108 109 110 113 115 122 124 127 130 139 142
55
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Increasing trend in household income, expenditure and debt, but debt service year has reduced from the recent peak in 2004 Chart 2.9a – Monthly income per household
Chart 2.9c – Debt per household
Average, Baht
Average, Baht 23,544 17,787
18,660
2006
2007
20,903
104,571
116,585
116,681
2006
2007
134,699
136,562
2009
2011
14,963
2004
2009
2011
Chart 2.9b – Monthly expenditure per household
2004
Chart 2.9d – Debt service year*
Average, Baht
14,311
14,500
16,205
17,861
3.3 2.8 2.3
12,297
2004
2.4 2.0
2006
2007
2009
2011
2004
2006
2007
2009
2011
Note: (*) Avg. debt / (annual income – annual expenditure)
56
Source: National Statistic Office survey; CTE analysis
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Executive summary
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013 • Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard. • Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
57
Core inflation is low and decreasing while headline inflation increased slightly driven mainly by Eggs & Milk Chart 3.07a – Y‐o‐Y change in CPI
Chart 3.07b – Y‐o‐Y change in CPI by product
Percent
July 2012, percent Eggs & milk
4.00% 3.50% 3.00%
3.4%
2.8%
3.4%
Head line
2.8%
2.8% 2.5%
2.5%
2.1% 1.9%
1.9%
1.8%
Core*
1.50% 1.00% 0.50% 0.00% Feb-12 Mar-12
HH consumer food
5.8
Seasoning
4.7
Non HH consumer food
3.5
Non alcoholic beverage
2.9
Clothing
2.5
Rice
2.3
Tobacco & alcohol
1.1
Housing & furnishing
1.1
Recreation & Education
0.6
Veg & fruit
0.6
Transport & Commu
0.5
2.6%
2.50% 2.00%
21.5
Apr-12 May-12 Jun-12
Jul-12
Note: (*) exclude raw food and energy Source: Bureau of Trade and Economic Indices; CTE analysis
Medical care
-0.1
Meat
-1.4
58 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Thailand’s inflation is rather on the lower side, compared to other countries Chart 3.08 – Consumer Price Index Annual percentage change
Latest
2012*
Pakistan ‐ Jun
11.3
India ‐ Jun
10.0
10.0
Singapore ‐ Jun
8.4
5.3
Brazil ‐ Jun
4.4
4.9
Indonesia ‐ Jun
5.2
4.5
Russia ‐ Jun
4.4
4.3
Hong Kong ‐ Jun
5.0
3.7
Thailand ‐ Jul
4.2
2.8
Euro Area ‐ Jun
3.0
2.4
China ‐ Jun
2.2
South Korea ‐ Jun
2.2
2.4 3.6 2.8
Taiwan ‐ Jun
1.8
2.0
US ‐ Jun
1.7
2.1
Malaysia ‐ Jun
1.6
1.9
Australia ‐ Q2 Japan ‐ May
1.2 0.2
Note: (*) The Economist Poll Source: The Economist
2.1 0.2
59 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Stable prices in Producer level
Chart 3.09a – Y‐o‐Y change in PPI
Chart 3.09b – Y‐o‐Y change in PPI by product
Percent
July 2012, percent
3.0% 2.5% 2.0%
1.8%
1.8%
1.5%
1.2%
1.0%
0.8%
0.7%
0.5% 0.0% -0.4% -0.5% -1.0% Feb-12
Mar-12
Apr-12 May-12 Jun-12
Jul-12
Crop Forestry Other manu goods Food Mechinery Textile Transport equip Pulp & paper Wood Leather & footware Electrical equip Metal Basic metals Non‐metallic mineral Chemical Energy Petroluem products Fishing Livestocks Rubber & plastic
8.2 6.9 4.4 2.8 2.4 1.5 1.1 1.0 0.6 0.5 -0.2 -0.4 -0.6 -1.0 -1.8 -1.9 -2.0 -5.6 -9.6 -14.1
60 Source: Bureau of Trade and Economic Indices; CTE analysis
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Executive summary
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013 • Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard. • Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
61
Banks’ capital ratio dropped in May
Chart 3.04 – Capital ratio of all commercial banks % of risk assets 20.0% 15.0%
13.7%
14.0%
2002
2003
13.0%
14.2%
14.5%
15.4%
2005
2006
2007
16.1%
16.2%
2009
2010
14.1%
15.1%
10.0% 5.0% 0.0%
16.0%
15.8%
15.8% 15.6%
2004
15.4%
2008
2011
15.7%
15.4% 15.3%
15.4%
15.4%
15.3% 15.1%
15.2%
15.2%
15.2%
15.3% 15.1%
15.0% 14.8% 14.6% Jun-11
Jul-11
Aug-11 Sep-11
Oct-11 Nov-11 Dec-11 Jan-12 Feb-12 Mar-12 Apr-12 May-12
62 Source: Bank of Thailand
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Gross NPL decreased in 2Q12
Chart 3.03a – Total Financial Institutions’ Gross NPLs Outstanding Billion Baht 592 477
445
458
401
380 317
04YE
05YE
06YE
07YE
08YE
09YE
10YE
269
11YE
274
266
2012/Q1 2012/Q2 2012/Q3
Chart 3.03b – Total Financial Institutions’ Gross NPLs Outstanding Percentage of Total Loans
10.73% 8.16%
7.47%
7.31% 5.29%
04YE
05YE
06YE
07YE
08YE
4.85%
09YE
3.60%
10YE
2.74%
11YE
2.68%
2.55%
2012/Q1 2012/Q2 2012/Q3 63
Source: Bank of Thailand
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Another profitable month for the Thai stock market Chart 3.06a – Monthly performance of SET index
Chart 3.06b – Change since Dec 31st 2011
Percent change from prior month, at month end
Percent, as of July 25th 2012 Pakistan (KSE)
28.3%
Thailand (SET)
7.1%
15.9%
Singapore (STI)
13.0%
US (NAScomp)
9.9%
India (BSE)
9.0%
Germany (DAX) 3.1%
2.7%
2.7%
2.3%
8.3%
Malaysia (KLSE)
6.8%
US (S&P 500)
6.4%
Indonesia (JSX)
4.7%
US (DJIA)
3.3%
China (SSEB, $ terms)
2.7%
HK (Hang Seng)
2.4%
Australia (All Ord.)
-7.1%
Feb-12
Mar-12
Apr-12
May-12
Jun-12
Jul-12
1.0%
Japan (Nikkei 225)
-1.1%
Taiwan (TWI)
-1.3%
UK (FTSE 100)
-1.3%
France (CAC 40)
-2.5%
China (SSEA)
-2.9%
S Korea (KOSPI)
-3.1%
Euro Area (FTSE Euro 100) -4.5%
64 Source: SET, The Economist; CTE analysis
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Executive summary
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013 • Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard. • Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
65
Improvement in budget deficit in June, but still 174 billion worse off than the same period last year Chart 4.2 – Government budget balance Billion Baht Monthly cumulative Budget balance 1,902
100.0
1,751
Revenue 877
1,390 1,013
1,109
1,455
1,498
50.0
1,484
1,241
2011
0.0 -50.0
Budget balance
16
-79
0
110 -36
-174
-75
-100
-28
-100.0
-364 -150.0
-956
-996
-200.0
-1,109 -1,277 -1,280
Expenditure
-250.0
-1,629 -1,598 -1,849 -1,825
-300.0
-1,930
2012 -350.0 -400.0
02FY 03FY 04FY 05FY 06FY 07FY 08FY 09FY 10FY 11FY Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
J F M A M J J A S O N D
66 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Apart from 2010, there were not much differences between budget and cash balance Chart 4.3 – Government cash balance Billion Baht Budget cash balance Overall Cash balance (including non-budgetary deficit/ surplus)
110 16 24
0
88
8 -36 -45
-28
-79 -77
-75
-100 -96
-96
-144
-148
-174
-179
-266
-364 -401
02FY
03FY
04FY
05FY
06FY
07FY
08FY
09FY
10FY
11FY
'12/6mo 67
Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
With a few exceptions, most governments in the world will register huge budget deficit in 2012 Chart 4.4 – Government Budget balance as percentage of GDP 2012*, percent South Korea
1.9
Hong Kong
1.0
Singapore
0.1
Australia
-0.7
Russia
-0.8
Indonesia
-2.2
China
-2.3
Thailand
-2.3
Brazil
-2.8
Taiwan
-3.4
Euro Area
-3.5
Malaysia
-5.2
India
-5.5
Pakistan
-6.1
US Japan Note: (*) The Economist Poll Source: The Economist
-7.6 -9.3
68 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Public debt increased in absolute and relative to GDP this year, due mainly to direct government debt Chart 4.5a – Composition of Public debt
Chart 4.5b – Composition of Public debt
THB Trillion
As percentage of nominal GDP
5.0
50%
4.5
45%
4.0
40%
Public debt from State Enterprises
3.5
Public debt from State Enterprises
35%
3.0 2.5 2.0
30%
Bond to Compensate FIDF's Loss & Prefunding debt
25%
Bond to Compensate FIDF's Loss & Prefunding debt
20%
1.5
15%
1.0
10%
0.5
Direct Government debt
Direct Government debt
5%
0.0
0%
2008
2009
2010
2011
12%
10%
8%
8%
Source: Public Debt Management Office
May-12 7%
2008
External debt as percent of total
2009
2010
2011
May-12
69 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Thailand’s public debt is not high compared to international standard Chart 4.6 – Public debt in the world
Int’l rule of thumb <60% of GDP
Percentage of GDP, 2011 or latest 1 Zimbabwe 2 Japan 4 Greece 5 Lebanon 6 Iceland 9 Italy 10 Singapore 11 Ireland 13 Portugal 15 Belgium 17 Egypt 18 France 20 Canada 21 Hungary 22 Germany 23 UK 24 Bhutan 28 Bahrain 29 Israel 30 Austria 32 United States 33 Spain 38 Netherlands 40 Jordan 42 Pakistan Source: CIA fact book
231 208 165 137 130 120 118 107 103 100 86 86 84 83 82 80 79 75 74 72 69 68 64 61 60
44 Vietnam 47 Brazil 48 Malaysia 49 Switzerland 51 India 53 Philippines 56 Norway 67 UAE 69 China 72 Argentina 73 Turkey 78 Thailand 82 Mexico 86 Sweden 87 Bangladesh 91 South Africa 93 Taiwan 95 New Zealand 96 Korea, South 100 Australia 108 Indonesia 121 Iran 122 Hong Kong 123 Saudi Arabia 126 Russia
57 54 54 52 52 49 48 44 44 43 42 41 38 37 37 36 35 34 33 30 25 12 10 9 9
70
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Executive summary
Growth
Income distribution
Stability
• Thai economy recovered faster than expected with 1Q12 GDP growth of 0.3% Y-o-Y. • Another set back in Real sector’s recovery in June especially for Manufacturing production. • Private consumption and Private Investment also cooled down but the current level is still higher than a year ago. Property sector shows signs of improvement. • High FDI and tourist growth, but Export situation has not improved. • Both Fiscal and Monetary policies are pro-growth. • Latest round of surveys show Businesses and Industries being less optimistic, and Consumers less pessimistic. • The consensus projection is still between 5.7-6.0% for 2012 and between 4.7-5.8% for 2013 • Thailand’s unemployment rate decreased slightly in May 2012 to 0.92%, the lowest among major and emerging economies. • Thailand’s Income distribution is among the worst in Asia but has been improving in the past 5 years. • Absolute Poverty reduction seems to be working over the past six years as number of poor people decreasing and current level is low by international standard. • Price stability is maintained with Head line inflation at 2.8% and Core inflation at 1.8% in July. • Banking system is quite healthy. Bank’s capital ratio is at 15.1% in May. Total system’s NPL decreased to 2.55% in 2Q12. • Fiscal stability is still worrying as budget deficits in the first half of 2012 is THB 174 billion worse off than the same period last year. Public debt is increasing but not too worrying just yet. • Balance of Payment deficit is also worrying. THB depreciated slightly in July. External debt has been increasing but still not dangerous.
71
Balance of Payment deficit so far in 2012 due largely to deteriorating Trade Balance Trade Balance (F.O.B) 1,120
Chart 5.01 – Balance of Payment decomposition
917
Billion Baht
1,015 714
576 84 07FY
08FY
09FY
10FY
11FY
12/6mo
-351
-142
11FY
12/6mo
987 812
Net service income & transfer
825
586
-508
+ 35
07FY
-19 07FY
-366
-377
08FY
09FY
10FY
11FY
08FY
-587
09FY
10FY
Net Capital Movement + errors and omissions 744
12/6mo
559 70
47
39
-328 07FY
08FY
09FY
10FY
11FY
12/6mo
72 Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Strong Asian export engines reflecting in huge current account surplus Chart 5.02 – Current Account balance As % of 2012 GDP* Singapore ‐ Q1
17.9%
Malaysia ‐ Q1
53.2
9.4%
Taiwan ‐ Q1
29.7
7.3%
Hong Kong ‐ Q1
41.9
7.0%
Russia ‐ Q2
8.3
4.5%
China ‐ Q1
2.3%
South Korea ‐ May
1.7%
Japan ‐ May
1.5%
Euro Area ‐ May
0.0%
Thailand ‐ Q1
-0.5%
Indonesia ‐ Q1
-1.4%
Brazil ‐ Jun
-2.8%
US ‐ Q1
-3.2%
Pakistan ‐ Q2
-3.2%
Australia ‐ Q1
-3.5%
India ‐ Q1
-3.7%
Note: (*) The Economist Poll Source: The Economist
Last 12 months, USD Billion
104.6 196.4 28.3 90.7 41.8 6.5 -3.8 -51.8 -483.2 -4.5 -38.9 -78.2
73 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
External debt level increased in both absolute and relative to GDP terms Chart 5.10a – External Debt Level Billion USD 160 120 80 40 0 03YE
04YE
05YE
06YE
07YE
08YE
09YE
10YE
11YE
12/1Q
Chart 5.10b – External Debt as % of GDP
40.3%
03YE
40.9%
04YE
37.0%
05YE
38.5%
06YE
35.4%
07YE
31.4%
28.8%
08YE
09YE
35.2%
34.2%
10YE
11YE
37.4%
12/1Q
74 Source: Bank of Thailand
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
More public debt and more short‐term debt in external debt composition so far in 2012 Chart 5.11a – External debt breakdown
Chart 5.11b – External debt breakdown
Private vs Public
Long‐Term vs Short‐Term
Private Public = General Government and Monetary Authorities
4%
96%
08YE
8%
92%
09YE
13%
87%
10YE
15%
85%
11YE
Long term Short term
17% 44%
44%
56%
56%
08YE
09YE
50%
46%
50%
54%
50%
11YE
12/1Q
83%
12/1Q
50%
10YE
75 Source: Bank of Thailand
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Capability to repay external debt is not yet a concern as debt service ratio continued to decline and reserves at healthy level Chart 5.12a – International reserves
Chart 5.12b – Debt service ratio*
As % of ST external debt
Percent
418% 10.3% 360% 340%
330%
300%
7.7%
257%
07YE
08YE
09YE
10YE
11YE
12/1Q
Note: (*) Debt service payment / Export of goods and services
Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
07FY
08FY
7.3%
09FY
3.7%
3.7%
3.9%
10FY
11FY
12/1Q
76 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
International reserves decreased slightly this year but the current level is still considered excessive Chart 5.13a – International reserves level Billion USD 172.1
175.1
174.7
10YE
11YE
Jun-12
9.2
8.7
11YE
Jun-12
138.4 111.0 87.5 42.1
49.8
52.1
03YE
04YE
05YE
67.0
06YE
07YE
08YE
09YE
Chart 5.13b – International reserves as number of months of import*
12.4
6.7
03YE
6.4
04YE
5.3
05YE
6.2
06YE
7.5
7.4
07YE
08YE
Note: (*) For the last period using average monthly import value during the last 12 months
Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
09YE
11.3
10YE
77 www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Slight depreciation of THB in July
Chart 5.17a – Nominal Effective Exchange Rate
Chart 5.17b – Y‐o‐Y change in FX rate*
2007=100
Percentage change, as of July 31st 2012 103.0 102.5
PHP ‐ 0.766
7.1
USD ‐ 31.7196
101.5
JPY ‐ 40.7956
101.0
SGD ‐ 25.594
2.6
100.5
GBP ‐ 49.9919
2.0
TWD ‐ 1.0568
1.9
99.0
AUD ‐ 33.4926
1.6
98.5
VND ‐ 0.0015
0.0
98.0 Jul-12
MYR ‐ 10.1984
-0.2
KRW ‐ 0.0279
-1.8
IDR ‐ 3.6599
-3.4
99.5
Note: (*) Positive numbers mean the Baht has been depreciated against those currencies, the opposite applies to negative numbers USD = US$, GBP = Pound Sterling, EUR = Euro, JPY = Yen (per 100), CNY = Yuan Renminbi, SGD = Singapore $, MYR = Malaysia Ringgit, PHP = Philippines Peso, IDR = Indonesia Rupiah (per 1,000), INR = India Rupee, KRW = Korea Won, TWD = Taiwan $, VND = Vietnam Dong, MXN = Mexico Peso, AUD = Australia $
Source: Bank of Thailand; CTE analysis
7.1
102.0
100.0
Aug-11
CNY ‐ 5.0388
6.1 5.5
MXN ‐ 2.3908
-6.3
EUR ‐ 39.0415 INR ‐ 0.6034
-9.0 -16.8
Baht appreciates
Baht depreciates 78
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Charting Thailand’s Economy® |Macro Economy Made Easy www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com
Our only mission: Thai & Eng
Saving you time in following the economy •
• •
• •
1‐page executive summary answering the most important question, “how is the economy?”. 1‐hour “Monthly Brief Podcast” Our well selected and constantly updated economic indicators for your references Visual graphic, plus fact‐based explanation for each indicator Two‐way communication via DISQUS
www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com Saving you time in following the economy
INTRODUCTORY OFFER ORDER FORM (only until August 31st, 2012!) www.ChartingThailandEconomy.com I wish to start my annual subscription with the package indicated below (please tick box)
12 issues of Monthly Economic Brief for Executives THB 9,900 per year (45% off normal price or only THB 825 per issue) 12 issues plus web access THB 15,000 per year (50% off normal price or only THB 1,250 per month)
(please write clearly either in English or in Thai)
Name:___________________________________ Position:_________________________________ Company:________________________________ Mailing Address : __________________________ ________________________________________
I want my reports in ภาษาไทย English
PAYMENT OPTIONS
________________________________________ _____________________Post code:___________
My cheque is enclosed made payable to: Chart Maker Co., Ltd.
Tel:________________ Fax: _________________
I paid by direct bank transfer to Chart Maker Co., Ltd. via
Email: ___________________________________
o Siam Commercial Bank’s Saving Account No. 354‐229625‐4 (Nimitmai rd. branch) o Kasikorn Bank’s Saving Account No. 523‐2‐18131‐3 (Big C Lamlukka branch) o Bangkok Bank’s Saving Account No. 861‐0‐16435‐5 (Big C Lamlukka branch) o Thanachart Bank’s Savings Account No. 139‐6‐01219‐3 (Tesco Lotus Lamlukka Klong 6 branch)
Signature [X]:_____________________________ SEND THIS FORM AND PAY PROOF TO: 1. Email: admin@ChartingThailandEconomy.com 2. Fax: +66 2 987 0917 3. Mail: Chart Maker Co., Ltd. 19 Mu 11 Lamlukka rd., Lamlukka district, Pathumthani 12150