Electric system developments near you
November 2011 Volume 2
Picture Butte to Etzikom Coulee Transmission Project Preferred and alternate route selection
Did you know? The average four-person family in Alberta today has 20 ‘instant-on’ electronics such as laptops, DVD players, music device chargers and cell phone chargers. This is in addition to the other appliances necessary to run a home – fridges, stoves, microwaves, washers and dryers – all of which require a reliable supply of electricity.
Location map Picture Butte to zikom Coulee Transmission Line
Location map Picture Butte to You are receiving this Etzikom Coulee Transmission Location map Picture ButteLine to newsletter because you are Location map Picture Butte Transmission to Etzikom Coulee Linenear the proposed Picture Butte to Etzikom Coulee Etzikom Coulee Transmission Line 845
36
864
519
Old
CPR Reservoir
man Ri ve
r
845
man Rive Johnson's Old r Addition
CPR Reservoir
845
Chin 519
845
COALDALE
36
864
519
3
864
36
Cranford
Taber Lake
36 TABER
864
Barnwell er Old
Location map Picture Butte to Etzikom Coulee Transmission Line 519
CPR
Johnson's 512 Addition
Broxburn
845 Tempest
519
LETHBRIDGE 512
Horsefly Lake 864 512 Reservoir
LETHBRIDGE
Stafford Reservoir
er
O
4
513
LETHBRIDGE
Wilson
508 Chin
Wilson
COALDALE
Tempest
52
Broxburn 4
512
Stirling
845
Cranford 845
3
4
Stafford Reservoir
Stirling 61
Reservoir
Craddock
844
61
LEGEND
Judson
New Rockport
61
Stirling Potential TABER Judson Etzikom Coulee New Barnwell 4 to Whitla Rockport Horsefly 846 Transmission LineLake RAYMOND
Chin
508
Taber Lake
Johnson's Addition
Lakes
LETHBRIDGE
845
Chin Lakes
Wilson ldman Riv
508
Wilson
36
52
Stirling 845
Judson
Wrentham RAYMOND
846
61
Judson
513
New Rockport
New Craddock Preferred Journault Chin 844 Rockport Lakes
Lake
Taber Lake
TABER
Barnwell
Horsefly 513
513
Lake Reservoir
Approv ed Chin Bowmanton to Whitla Lakes Transmission Line Potential Etzikom Coulee 513 to Whitla Transmission Line
Stafford Reservoir
508
CPR Reservoir
Cranford
3
Tempest
Cranford Barnwell Broxburn
3
TABER
Horsefly Lake Horsefly Reservoir
Barnwell
Johnson's Reservoir Addition
Stafford Reservoir Chin
Taber Lake
COALDALE TABER
Chin
Cranford
Tempest
Stafford Broxburn Reservoir
512
Chin
3
Riv COALDALE er
m Old
Reservoir Broxburn
COALDALE
CPR Reservoir
Tempest an
Taber Lake
Johnson's man Riv Addition
Potential Chin Lakes Etzikom Coulee Potential to Etzikom Whitla Coulee to Whitla Transmission Line Wrentham 36
Transmission Line Approv ed Bowmanton to Whitla Transmission Line Wrentham
Wrentham 36
Approved MATL 846 RAYMOND Substation Transmission Line LETHBRIDGE 52 Potential 36 Craddock RAYMOND LEGEND 844 508 Etzikom Coulee Approved Picture Butte Existing 52 36 Craddock to Whitla Wilson Substation Transmission Line Transmission Line LEGEND 844 Approved MATL Preferred Journault Potential Journault Existing Substation 4 Transmission Line Substation Substation Target Area Potential Transmission Line Approved MATL Preferred Journault Approved Picture Butte Existing 61 Hamlet or Locality Line Transmission Line Substation Judson Stirling Substation Wrentham Transmission Preferred Existing Approved 845 Picture Butte Railway New Potential Journault Existing Substation Preferred Variant Rockport 846 Transmission Line Substation Substation Target Area Approved MATL Preferred RAYMONDJournaultPotential Transmission Line Road Alternate 52 36 Potential Journault Craddock Existing Substation Hamlet or Locality 844 Transmission Line Substation Preferred Urban Area Substation Target Area Alternate Variant Potential Transmission Line Railway Preferred LEGEND Existing Water Body Approved Picture Butte Hamlet Locality Variant OtherorTransmission Line Preferred Road Railway Alternate Transmission Line Substation Preferred Variant Preferred Journault Approved MATL Urban Area Alternate Variant Road Substation Transmission Line Alternate Potential Journault Existing Substation Water Body Approved Picture Butte Existing Other Transmission Line Urban Area Alternate Variant Substation Transmission LineSubstation Target Area Potential Transmission Line Water Body Other Transmission Line 846
LEGEND
LEGEND
Transmission Project and we Approved to Whitla antoninput. Bowm want your Transmission Line
Approv ed Bowmanton to Whitla Transmission Line
More information about the Approv ed proposed project is included Bowmanton to Whitla Transmission Line in this information package. We want to provide you with: • preferred and alternate route selection information • project details • maps of the proposed development • project schedule • information about how you can provide your input
CONTACT US 1-877-269-5903 satrinfo@altalink.ca www.altalink.ca/satr
We are currently determining potential structure locations for the preferred and alternate routes. Once these locations have been identified, we will mail area specific maps to all landowners who may have structures on their property. These maps will also be available at the upcoming open houses in December.
Preferred Picture Butte to Etzikom Coule Preferred and alternate route selection Transmission Line Iron
Springs Preferred Route
845
PICTURE
36
864
BUTTE Preferred Etzikom Coulee to Whitla Transmission Line 519
r Oldm an R i ve
CPR Reservoir
864
36
O ld man R i v er
Tempest
3
Fairview
Johnson's Broxburn Addition Cranford
Purple Springs
Taber Lake
Chin
u th S a s k
Grassy Lake Juno
Antonio
Fincastle
So
c hew a n R i v e r at
Burdett
3
Cranford
Jensen
BOW ISLAND
885
Maleb
61
Wilson
Horsefly Lake Reservoir
Chin Lakes
LETHBRIDGE Judson Wrentham
TABER
513
513
ChinLakes
New Dayton
Barnwell
Reservoir
Reservoir
508
3
Yellow LakeStafford
Sherburne Lake
TABER COALDALE Barnwell 512 HorseflyLake
Stafford Reservoir
Johnson's Addition
Winnifred
Taber Lake
Skiff
Conrad
Nemiskam
Legend
Foremost
61
36 Tyrrell Lake
Crow Indian Lake
4
879
506 McNab
Sunnysite
Warner
504
4
52
Stirling
Verdigris
845 Lake Welling
61
877
RAYMOND
846
LEGEND LEGEND
844
501
Judson
Wrentham
New Rockport 880
36
Craddock
844
Preferred Journault LEGEND Substation Approved Whitla Substation
Preferred Existing Substation
Existing Transmission Line Hamlet or Locality
Journault Railway Substation Preferred Transmission Line Road Approved MATL Approved Picture ButteUrban Area Transmission Line Substation Water Body Existing Substation
Preferred route (east route) Preferred
Approved MATL Transmission Line Existing Transmission Line Hamlet or Locality Railway
Line as the preferred route because it poses a The eastTransmission route was selected Road Preferred lower overall level of potential impacts when compared to the other Urban Area Transmission Line Variant proposed routes. Water Body
To avoid a sensitive pelican feeding site and high-risk avian conflict zone at the Chin Coulee Dam crossing identified during consultation, we have moved the route approximately one kilometer to the west. This change reduces not only potential impacts to this site, but also increases the distance from the residences located near the Chin Coulee Dam, and reduces other potential environmental impacts. A site specific route option (dashed red line) would cross the reservoir in the same location as our originally proposed routing at the base of the dam. 2
Bowm a Tran
To avoid environmental issues associated with the CPR Reservoir (located east of Highway 845 at the northern portion of the preferred route), the preferred route will deviate to the south. A site specific route option (dashed red line) that would locate the line north of the CPR Reservoir remains in our routing options. The preferred route would potentially impact more residences in this area, but would avoid construction of lines north and south of the CPR Reservoir. When combined with the MATL transmission line in close proximity, Alternate Picture Butte to Etzikom this site specific option would create a ‘boxing in’ of the reservoir, which has Transmission Line been assessed as posing environmental impacts to birds in the area. Alternate Route 845 845
Alternate route (west route)
The alternate route for this project is the west route. While potentially impacting more agricultural lands and residences than the preferred route, the alternate route would avoid crossing the Stafford Reservoir. As well, the agricultural impacts on the alternate route are viewed as largely mitigable or compensable, particularly in relation to the irrigation systems present. However, the costs associated with mitigating the large amount of irrigation systems would be higher than on the preferred route. The alternate route represents the next best option from an overall impact perspective and is a viable route. Highlighted in dashed green is the alternate variant route. Compared to both the preferred and alternate routes the variant has higher overall impacts, but still represents a viableRoute route given that it will parallel an existing transmission Previously Proposed Option Previously Proposed Route Option line. However, paralleling the MATL transmission line requires our route to Etzikom Coulee to Whitla Picture Butte to Etzikom Coulee be located approximately 40 metres Transmission TransmissionLine Line into the adjacent lands, resulting in Dropped Segments a higher overall level of agricultural impacts given the amount of irrigation systems present. There is also a higher number of residences along this route compared to the alternate route, resulting in a higher level of potential residential impacts. 864
845 36
O ld man R i v er
So
519
CPR Reservoir
Antonio
Fincastle
3
Johnson's Addition Cranford
Barnwell
Stafford Reservoir
u th S a s
Chin Chin
COALDALE COALDALE
TABER
HorseflyLake Reservoir
COALDALE
3
513 Tempest
ChinLakes
Broxburn
Cranford
Barnwell
Barnwell Barnwell
Stafford Stafford Reservoir Reservoir
512 512
Horsefly Horsefly Lake Lake Reservoir Reservoir
513 513 Chin Chin Lakes Lakes
LETHBRIDGE LETHBRIDGE 508 508
Wilson Wilson
44
61 61
Stirling Stirling 845 845
RAYMOND RAYMOND 844 844
846 846
Judson Judson
Wrentham Wrentham
New New Rockport Rockport
36 36
Craddock Craddock
LEGEND LEGEND Preferred Journault Journault Preferred Substation Substation Approved Picture Picture Butte Butte Approved Substation Substation Existing Substation Substation Existing Preferred Preferred Transmission Line Line Transmission Alternate Alternate Transmission Line Transmission Line Alternate Alternate Transmission Line Line Variant Variant Transmission
Approved MATL MATL Approved Transmission Line Line Transmission Existing Existing Transmission Line Line Transmission Potential Journault Journault Potential Substation Target Target Area Area Substation Hamlet or or Locality Locality Hamlet Railway Railway Road Road Urban Area Area Urban Water Body Body Water
885
Taber Lake
Johnson's Addition
Chin
33
Tempest Tempest
Broxburn Broxburn
Taber Taber Lake Lake
TABER TABER
3
Yellow Lake
Lake
Johnson's Johnson's Addition Addition Cranford Cranford
Winnifred 36
BOW ISLAND
Burdett Grassy a n River Juno LakeOldm
Purple Springs Sherburne
Taber Lake
864 tc hew a n R i v e r Jensen ka
Rive maann R ldm iverr Old O
CPR CPR Reservoir Reservoir
52 52
Alternate variant route (MATL parallel)
36 36
864 864
519 519
TABER
Maleb
Horsefly Lake Reservoir
Approved Bowmanton to Whitla Transmission Line
Stafford Reservoir
512
513
Judson
Conrad
Wrentham
Chin Foremost Lakes
LETHBRIDGE 36
New Dayton 508
Crow Indian Lake
TyrrellWilson Lake
506 McNab
61
Dropped segments
879
4
Sunnysite
Warner 845 4
52
Nemiskam
Legend
Skiff
504
Verdigris Lake
RAYMOND 844
LEGEND LEGEND LEGEND
61
Stirling
Judson 877
846 Craddock
Preferred Journault Preferred Journault Substation Substation Approved Whitla Substation Approved Picture Butte Existing Substation Substation Current Potential Existing Substation Transmission Line Current Potential Previously Proposed Transmission Line Transmission Line Previously Proposed Approved MATL Transmission Line Transmission Line
New Rockport
Wrentham
501
880
36
Existing Approved MATLLine Transmission Transmission Line Hamlet or Locality Existing
Coule
Route segments that have been removed due to their higher relative impacts as compared to both the preferred and alternate routing are highlighted in pink.
Railway Transmission Line Road or Locality Hamlet Urban Area Railway Water Body Road
Urban Area Water Body
3
Bowman Bowman Trans Trans
Definition
Substation Substations are the connection point between high-voltage transmission lines.
Project details The proposed transmission developments in your area include: • upgrades to the Picture Butte Substation • a new 240 kV (240,000 volts) double circuit transmission line approximately 66 to 80 kilometres in length from the Picture Butte Substation to the proposed Journault Substation A double circuit 240 kV steel lattice transmission structure is shown below. A typical structure will have a: • height of 44 to 60 metres (147 to 197 feet) • width of 22 to 24 metres (72 to 79 feet) at the widest arm • base of 10 by 10 metres (32 by 32 feet), up to 14 by 14 metres (46 by 46 feet) • distance between structures averaging 365 metres (1,198 feet) • a right-of-way width of 60 metres (197 feet) Cost
The estimated cost for this project is approximately $160 to 250 million, which would be approximately 16 to 25 cents per month on the typical residential utility bill. Journault Substation
We have determined a preferred location for the proposed Journault Substation to be on the NE-15-7-17-W4. An alternate substation target area is still being explored for other possible substation locations. Both the preferred location and alternate target area for the Journault Substation are shown on the attached map. Preliminary engineering work indicates that the fenced area for this substation will be approximately 115 by 110 metres (377 by 360 feet). Picture Butte Substation
The footprint of the Picture Butte Substation needs to be expanded to allow the termination of the new 240 kV line 991L, which is coming from Journault Substation. To accommodate for new equipment the Picture Butte Substation will be expanded approximately 20 metres (65 feet) to both the southwest and northwest for a total fenced area of approximately 95 metres by 115 metres (311 feet by 377 feet). 4
Route identification The table below outlines general criteria we take into account when identifying and refining potential routes.
Important criteria
Agricultural
• Loss of crops • Reduced efficiency of field operations
Residential
• Proximity to residences • Loss of developable lands and constraints on future development
Environmental
• Alteration of natural areas and interference with environmentally sensitive areas
Cost
• Construction cost and land acquisition costs
Our transmission lines transport the power you use every day. AltaLink’s transmission system efficiently delivers electricity to 85 per cent of Albertans. Dedicated to meeting the growing need for electricity, AltaLink connects Albertans to renewable, reliable and low-cost power. With a commitment to community and environment, AltaLink is ensuring the transmission system will support Albertans’ quality of life for years to come. Learn more at www.altalink.ca
Edmonton Red Deer
Electrical
• Reliability and reparability of the line
Calgary
Lethbridge
Visual
• Visual impact of structures and lines as seen from residences and recreational areas
Special considerations
• Electrical interference with radio transmitting stations and other telecommunication equipment etc.
AltaLink Service Territory
5
Providing your input Stakeholder input is critical to identifying the best solution for this transmission project. You can provide your input by: Attending our open houses
Please join us at our open houses below. We will be available to share information, gather your input and address any questions or concerns you might have. Coaldale, AB
Dec. 6 4 to 8 p.m.
Coaldale Community Centre 1217 20 Ave
Stirling, AB
Dec. 7 4 to 8 p.m.
Stirling Lions Club Community Centre 417 2 Street
Foremost, AB
Dec. 8 4 to 8 p.m.
Foremost Community Hall 802 1 Ave W
Participating in a one-on-one consultation
We will contact occupants, residents and landowners who are on or directly adjacent to the proposed transmission line route options to gather their input. Through these discussions we will gather detailed information that will help us determine the best solution for this project. Contacting us directly
You can also contact us by phone, e-mail, mail or through our website. Our contact information is on the back page of this newsletter.
Next steps Definition
Alberta Utilities Commission The Alberta Utilities Commission (AUC) ensures the fair and responsible delivery of Alberta’s utility services. AltaLink submits applications for new transmission projects to the AUC and the AUC reviews them in a public process.
6
After consulting with stakeholders, we will use the input gathered to finalize the preferred and alternate routes as well as potential substation locations. After the consultation process is complete we will file an application with the Alberta Utilities Commission (AUC). The AUC will review the application through a process in which stakeholders can participate. We will notify stakeholders when we file the application and again once the AUC has reached a decision about the project. To learn more about the AUC process and how you can become involved, please refer to the brochure included in this package titled Public Involvement in Needs or Facilities Applications.
Did you know?
Project schedule AltaLink will communicate and consult with stakeholders throughout the project steps listed below. Summer/ Fall 2011
Notify and consult with stakeholders
Winter 2012
File application with AUC
Fall 2013
Start construction if project is approved
Essential services that are critical to Albertans, such as hospitals and schools, rely on large amounts of power. On average, hospitals use 1,875,000 kilowatt hours (kWh) of electricity a month. That’s enough to power more than 3,000 typical homes for a month.
Projects in the area AltaLink is working on several projects in the area to make sure your lights come on at the flick of the switch. Project name
Description
Status
Etzikom Coulee to Whitla Transmission Project
A new substation - to be called Journault Substation - and 87 to 90 km of new 240 kV transmission line
Second round of consultation underway
Goose Lake to Etzikom Coulee Transmission Project
A new 240 kV transmission line from the existing Goose Lake Substation to the proposed Journault Substation
Preliminary siting work underway
Southern Alberta Transmission Reinforcement
The Southern Alberta Transmission Reinforcement (SATR) includes many proposed projects in southern Alberta that will provide Albertans with access to new wind generated power. Existing transmission lines and substations in the southern part of the province do not have the capacity to connect power generated from new wind farm projects. To connect this wind generated power to the electric grid, new transmission projects are being proposed to move the wind power from where it’s generated to you. The Alberta Electric System Operator (AESO) filed the need for SATR with the AUC in December 2008. The AUC held a public hearing to review the need for these projects in 2009 and approved the need later that year. The Picture Butte to Etzikom Coulee Transmission Project is part of SATR.
Definition
Alberta Electric System Operator The Alberta Electric System Operator (AESO) is the independent, notfor-profit organization responsible for the safe, reliable and economic planning and operation of the Alberta electric system.
7
Included in this information package • Project map • AUC brochure: Public Involvement in Needs or Facilities Applications
More information To learn more about the proposed project, please contact: AltaLink
AltaLink at 1-877-269-5903 (toll-free) Email: satrinfo@altalink.ca www.altalink.ca/satr To learn more about Alberta’s electric system and the need for the project, please contact: Alberta Electric System Operator (AESO)
1-888-866-2959 (toll-free) Email: stakeholder.relations@aeso.ca 2611 - 3rd Avenue SE Calgary, Alberta T2A 7W7
To learn more about the application and review process, please contact: Alberta Utilities Commission (AUC)
780-427-4903 (You can call toll-free by dialing 310-0000 before the number.) E-mail: utilitiesconcerns@auc.ab.ca 8
Printed on paper using post-consumer content