CoP practical peer review

Page 1

Leeds College of Art BA (Hons) ILLUSTRATION OUIL601 Context of Practice 3

Level

06

Credits 40

Practical Response Peer Review & Formative Feedback Illustrator’s Name: Aggie Overarching Theme

Gender equality, education, feminism

Specific Subject

Children’s perception of gender roles

Research Question Product(s)

The influence of fairy tales on children’s perceptions of gender.

Proposed Outcomes

Short children’s picture book about Malala Yousafzai for ages 7+ (see boards for more details). What I’m submitting: • Book manuscript. • Dummy book (refined sketches, black and white, printed – smaller than actual book size) • 3 double pages (but maybe more if time permits) - fully rendered. Printed in actual book size. •

Related merchandise – bookmarks, posters, stickers, badges

(Plan for after graduation) Series of books based on real stories of success and liberation about other girls around the world, to raise awareness of issues happening in parts of the world and to encourage people to act – overarching aim is to break the cycle of global poverty. – Potential collaboration in the future with organisations like Girl Effect (see boards for more details).

Media Processes

Digital/pencil – most time effective process for me.

Question 1

Is practical response substantial enough? What do you think of story? Please let me know if there are any grammar mistakes haha.

Question 2

I’m still not 100% decided on the title. Any suggestions? Or do you think its okay? Is story suitable for proposed age range?

Question 3

Do you think there are any improvements that could be made?


Peer Feedback 1 by Abby. Comment on the appropriateness, scope, and ambition of the proposed outcomes in relation to the subject. Strengths

Suggestions

It is good to see that you have proposed to continue this project. It’s a great way to fight against the traditional children’s books – a good message.

I’d love to see how it’s going to look – it will be good to get experimenting with media and colour. Perhaps make sure you’re pushing yourself to the limit with how much you produce.

Comment on the quantity and quality of visual investigation and development of idea in response to the theme and subject. Strengths

Suggestions

You’ve experimented with character and shown how each page will look compositionally. Handy to have a book to hold too.

Show how you’ve considered text, layout and colour. I know you don’t like it as much but do experiments in your sketchbook based on what you’ve gained from artist research.

Comment on the documentation of the conceptual and practical development of the work evidenced on the blog. Strengths

Suggestions

You’ve thoroughly shown your process, from Blog play and say why you will be making getting inspiration to working out a choices that you want to make. manuscript.

Comment on the decisions regarding the production and proposal of outcomes. Strengths

Suggestions

You’ve done so much already – it’s basically Go for it and be as ambitious as you can to ready to be drawn out/made now. show development in L6.

General Comments


Peer Feedback 2 by Emanuel. Comment on the appropriateness, scope, and ambition of the proposed outcomes in relation to the subject. Strengths

Suggestions

Thinking big – good. Definitely substantial Maybe begin to list other stories of enough in response to question 1 as you can inspirational girls around the world to show always keep going if you have time left over. when you submit so that what you do submit in terms of products looks like part of something bigger or more to come.

Comment on the quantity and quality of visual investigation and development of idea in response to the theme and subject. Strengths

Suggestions

Lots of thumbnailing – good.

Begin to think about relevant colour palettes, even just applying these to the rough thumbs.

Comment on the documentation of the conceptual and practical development of the work evidenced on the blog. Strengths

Suggestions

Lots of visual and written research.

Practical development seems to be going slow but there is a lot of contextual research that is backing up.

Comment on the decisions regarding the production and proposal of outcomes. Strengths

General Comments

Suggestions


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.