AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
3
Members Directory
www.amcham.org.hk
AMCHAM Means Business
Over 500 pages in three major sections, including a complete guide to chamber services, corporate sponsors and AmCham Charitable Foundation. This directory lists about 1,350 members from about 660 companies and organizations. ISBN 978-988-8519-04-0 NON-MEMBER PRICE Local Delivery HK$1500 Overseas Delivery US$195 Shipping costs: Local HK$45 (per copy) US/International US$50 (per copy)
MEMBER PRICE HK$800 US$105
AmCham Member Name:
Title:
Company: Address: Tel:
Fax:
Email:
Website:
copy(ies) of Members Directory Total: HK$/US$ (postage inclusive) check# Bank: Charge to AMEX (US$)
payable to The American Chamber of Commerce in Hong Kong Diners (HK$)
Visa (HK$)
Master Card (HK$)
Cardholder's Name: Card# Expiry Date:
Signature:
AmChamHK
The American Chamber of Commerce in Hong Kong 1904 Bank of America Tower, 12 Harcourt Road, Hong Kong. 7-8 • 2019 Tel: (852) 2530 6934 Email: hchung@amcham.org.hk
Issuing Bank:
(Not valid unless signed)
4
President’s Memo its people that the time for rational and constructive dialogue is now. Urgent action is needed before the city’s hard-won standing as Asia’s leading international financial and commercial center suffers severe damage.
A very warm welcome home to those of you who managed to escape the heat and simmering tension of Hong Kong this summer. If you did take a vacation, you probably have returned to find that the tension in Hong Kong has risen dramatically and weekend protester skirmishes with riot police are starting to feel like a new and disturbing normal. AmCham continues to relay a core message to Hong Kong’s leaders and
views from leading scholars, diplomats and policymakers with voices from global business. And let’s hope Thanksgiving this year lives up to its name and we can celebrate real progress in bridging the deep divisions in Hong Kong society. This is always a special day, when the American business community comes together to break bread with Hong Kong government officials and colleagues.
That said, we have a lot to look forward to at the chamber. As we went to press, AmCham was preparing to host a welcome breakfast for new US Consul General Hanscom Smith at the Ocean Park Marriott Hotel. We were also set to host a dynamic and highly popular event for this year’s Women of Influence Awards, and we’re eagerly anticipating another inspiring day in November.
We look forward to seeing you there.
In September we will host our 27th annual China Conference, which this year focuses on the global impact of the shifting Sino-US relationship. Former US Trade Representative Charlene Barshefsky, President Barack Obama’s Asia adviser, Evan Medeiros, and Goldman Sachs Japan Vice Chair Kathy Matsui are just three names from our customary stellar lineup, marrying
Regards, Tara Joseph AmCham President
BOARD OF GOVERNORS CHAIRMAN Robert Grieves VICE CHAIRMAN Diana David TREASURER Owen Belman
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
GOVERNORS Donald Austin
Anna-Marie Slot
Leonie Valentine
Sanjeev Chatrath
Jennifer Van Dale
Simon Ogus
Jenny Wong
David Cruikshank
Mark Green
Anne O’Riordan
Pat-Nie Woo
EX-OFFICIO GOVERNOR
Seth Peterson
Matthew Hosford
Eric Szweda
Patrick Wu
Jack Lange
Karen Reddington
Christopher Laskowski Kevin Tranbarger
Richard Weisman
Sabrina Lin
CHAMBER COMMITTEES
Vice-Chair
Tara Joseph
Lennard Yong
Rick Truscott
Working group
Apparel, Footwear & Supply Chain
Education
Food & Beverage
Intellectual Property
Gareth Brooks
Virginia Wilson
Veronica Sze
Gabriela Kennedy
Sally Peng
Abigail DeLessio
Future of Work
Ball
Energy
Peter Liu
David Cruikshank
Joseph Jacobelli
Wei Jie
Lynne Sprugel
John Zadkovich
China Business Ben Simpfendorfer
Ling Jin
John Siu Communications & Marketing Anita Davis
Lauren Chung
Corporate Social Responsibility Genevieve Hilton Hans Leung
Janice Lao
Creativity & Arts Anita Cheung
6
Chair
PRESIDENT
David Andrews
Thomas Lui Environment & Sustainability Jim Taylor Financial Services Rebecca Terner Lentchner Michael Frank Financial Services-Fintech Jean-Remi Lopez Daniel Warelis
Healthcare & Insurance
Victor Tse Jasper MacSlarrow Invest in USA Eric Szweda
Amelie Dionne-Charest
Law
Hanif Kanji
Chiann Bao
Stephen Leung
Jessica Bartlett
Innovation & Technology
Real Estate
Jen Flowers Lucy Werner Infrastructure & Construction
Robert Johnston Edward Noble Sports Loron Orris
Trade & Investment Barrett Bingley Tatman Savio David Chao Trade & Investment-Shadow Economy Ming Lai Cheung Michael Wong Amita Haylock Jeremy Birch Transportation & Logistics Geoffrey Siebengartner Gavin Dow Steven Suh Women of Influence Anne LeBourgeois Jennifer Parks
Ian Chung
Taxation
Steve Lewis
Peter Guang Chen
Young Professionals
Wade Wagatsuma
Jamie Ford
AmChamHK
Nicholas Gordon
7-8 • 2019
st
New Business Contacts The following people are new AmCham members: Company Name
First Name
Last Name
Position
5+design
Linda
Reilly
Marketing Director
Agnus Consulting
Tor
Mesoy
Managing Director
American Express
Ryan
Norine
VP & GM of Global Commercial Services
Bao Arbitration Office
Chiann
Bao
Independent Arbitrator
BASF East Asia Regional Headquarters
Sebastian
Schenk
Head of Digitalization of Businesses and Functions, Asia Pacific
DBS Bank (Hong Kong)
Brit
Blakeney
Executive Director
Matthew
Ng
Senior Vice President
Brata
Yudha
Senior Manager
Yongwen
Cao
Manager
Peter Guang
Chen
Partner, Tax & Legal
EY
Tania
Flanagan
Associate Director
Geelong Sales Company International
Alistair
HansonCurrie
Director of Operations
Gerson Lehrman Group (GLG)
Minh
Do
Head of Greater China
Serene
Lim
Head of Events & Marketing, APAC
Joyce
Ling
Head of Client Solutions, Hong Kong
Andrew
An
Partner
Rod
Haire
Partner
Joyce
Ng
Partner
Ann
Haydon
Head
Annabel
Davies
Principal Deputy Head (Curricular)
Brian
Murphy
Assistant House Master/Head of Expeditions/ Teacher of Mathematics
Edward
Nightingale
Senior House Master/Teacher of English
Madeleine
Ponting
Human Resources Manager
Nishel
Turpin
Director of Communications, Admissions & Development
Harvest Global Investments
Robert
Chen
Head of Asset Allocation & Passive Investments
Hong Kong University of Science & Technology
Helen
Chen
Head, Communications & External Affairs
Hongkong International Theme Parks
Jacky
Yu
Director, Corporate Alliances
International Justice Mission
Miwa
Chan
Director of Strategic Partnerships
Kimberly-Clark (HK)
Dominic
Iacono
Managing Director
Lion Brothers Far East
Judy
Tai
Merchandising Manager
Mitsubishi Corporation Hong Kong
Kosaku
Kawai
President & Managing Director
MOTIF HK
Catherine
Cole
Chief Executive Officer
Nike
Michele
Lau
Global Sr Product Creation Director - Apparel
Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu
Global Sage
Harrow International School Hong Kong
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
9
Origin X Capital
Sandra
Wu
Founding Partner
OutSystems
Mark
Weaser
Vice President, Asia Pacific
Anthony
Lam
Head of Architecture Solutions
Rosa
Wong
Regional Sales Director, Greater China Region
Sally
Xin
APAC Field Marketing Manager
Paypal Pte
Michelle
Chui
Head of Government Relations, Hong Kong, Korea and Taiwan
Philip Morris Asia
Caness
Chan
Manager, Corporate Communications - Asia
Ashwin
Nair
Director, Fiscal Affairs & International Trade Asia
Royal Pacific Hotel
Robert
Hon
General Manager
State Street Bank & Trust Co
Abigail
Jones
Senior Vice President - Head of Legal Asia Pacific
Telstra International
Paul
Abfalter
Head of North Asia & Global Wholesale
Ellen
Chu
Head of Marketing, North Asia
Lauren
Ellison
Legal Business Partner, Asia & EMEA
Matt
Lough
Head of Global OTT
Alice
Ting
Country Managing Director, Hong Kong
Peter
Woo
Head of North Asia Enterprise
Mark
Barnekow
Executive Director
Lily
Lee
Senior Associate Director, Employer Relations, Career Services
Cerise
Miller
Associate Director, Global Engagement
Joni
Coughlin
Director, Executive Education Open Enrollment Programs
Timothy
Ringrose
Managing Director - Executive Education
Visa Hong Kong
Maaike
Steinebach
General Manager, Hong Kong & Macau
Visichain
Richard
McGirr
Founder/Managing Director: Client Services
University of Chicago Booth School of Business in Hong Kong
University of Michigan Ross School of Business Asia-Pacific Regional Office
10
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
MEMBERSPOTLIGHT Name: Simon Buckby Job title: Managing Partner Company: Instinctif Partners (Hong Kong) Industry: Communications AmCham member since: February 2019 Where is home? I am from London and I relocated to Hong Kong with Instinctif Partners, an international communications agency, just before Christmas in 2018. So everything is still shiny and new, exciting and daunting.
‘Don’t rush on the stage, you might fall off it’
What do you miss most about home? The constant news about Brexit. And I am delighted to miss it. Other things, it’s too soon to say; but HK and the wider region seem to have everything I need to take my mind off London. Tell us something not many people know about you. I own two season tickets at Manchester United and I am making friends in HK by lending them to nice people who would like to enjoy some of the very best views at Old Trafford the next time they are in Britain. In another life, I would be… Scoring the goals, not watching from the stands at Old Trafford. Or writing extremely meaningful yet best-selling novels. First ever job? Skivvying in the office of a British Member of Parliament. Best advice you’ve ever received? Don’t rush on the stage, you might fall off it. I have just arrived in this amazing city and following this advice I am patiently spending time trying to get to know people here, to listen and learn, to understand the niche in which I can make a useful contribution. What do you like to do in your time off? I teach scuba diving and I am trying to get round as many places in Asia as possible. Having spent two weeks in North Korea a couple of years ago, I
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
am open to all suggestions for somewhere different and interesting to explore. Something on your bucket list for 2019. I completed the Tokyo marathon at the start of March. What attracted you to Amcham? First arriving in HK, I mostly need advice on where I can fit in, as well as help in expanding my network of work contacts and social friends. AmCham is a great support in all that. Which AmCham event are we likely to find you at next? I’ve already been to a big evening reception and a small policy breakfast so I will keep on coming until you’ve had enough of me!
11
MY FAVORITE AMCHAM EXPERIENCE
JESSICA CUTRERA Capital Company
MY FAVORITE AMCHAM EXPERIENCE 12
“AmCham events sponsored by the Financial Services and Tax Committees have provided access to top industry professionals and facilitated engaging dialogue. These events have been a great source of knowledge and dialogue for our employees. The networking at AmCham events has also been a great way to connect with other industry professionals.”
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
COVER STORY
THINKING OUTSIDE OF THE
BOX
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
Far from being in terminal decline, the opportunities for Hong Kong as a transshipment and maritime hub are limitless, says Modern Terminals' Peter J Levesque. All it takes is a change of mindset
13
COVER STORY
In the world of shipping, big is beautiful. So Hong Kong has enjoyed something of a beauty pageant in recent weeks, with the mega vessels OOCL Hong Kong and Cosco Shipping’s Galaxy both making their maiden calls to the city. For Modern Terminals Group Managing Director Peter J Levesque, the port calls were an emphatic symbol of Hong Kong’s future prospects as a global transshipment and logistics hub. They were also an opportunity to showcase the newly rationalized cargo handling facilities of the four Kwai Tsing terminal operators that have grouped their operations under the Hong Kong Seaport Alliance (HKSPA). “The four parties to the Seaport Alliance will no longer compete against each other in Hong Kong. Instead, we’re joining together so that Hong Kong can compete with the other big transshipment ports in the region,” said Levesque. “The alliance is not a loose-handshake agreement. It’s a contractual joint venture. We share revenue, we share costs and we share profit. And when you share profit, by definition you don’t compete.” Formed in January this year, HKSPA’s members have completed their berth and yard-planning strategies to improve the level of services they provide customers, squeezing out extra cost savings by eliminating unnecessary inter-terminal trucking.
14
AmCham President Tara Joseph pictured on a recent tour of MTL's facilities at Kwai Tsing.
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
COVER STORY
Already, inter-terminal trucking has been reduced by 34 percent. The members’ 23 berths are divided into three terminal zones to provide greater efficiency to shipping alliances and individual carriers. That means the HKSPA can accommodate up to eight mega vessels of similar size to OOCL Hong Kong simultaneously. But while big may be beautiful, it is also a symptom of the long-term decline in Hong Kong’s port business that the alliance seeks to reverse. Just two months after Orient Overseas (International) Ltd took delivery of what was then the world’s largest container ship in May 2017, Hong Kong’s leading shipping line was snapped up in a US$6.3 billion takeover by China’s state-owned Cosco Shipping Holdings. As of January last year, the top 15 container lines accounted for just over 70 percent of global container ship capacity, according to United Nations Conference on Trade and Development data. Six
When OOIL Chairman Tung Chee-hwa stepped down from the firm his father founded to be Hong Kong’s first post-colonial leader in 1997, more than 90 percent of southern China’s overseas shipments went via Hong Kong. The city would soon oust Singapore as the world’s busiest container port. But signs of the coming decline were clear: in Tung’s first five years as Hong Kong chief executive, container traffic grew by an annual average of 5.6 percent; in Shenzhen, that figure was 46 percent. By the time Tung stepped down in 2005, Singapore was back on top and Hong Kong had begun its slide to the seventh place it holds today. Shanghai now leads a world top 10 that includes five other Mainland Chinese terminals. Mainland ports are cheaper, closer to factories and have largely closed infrastructure and knowhow gaps that had compensated for Hong Kong’s higher costs. After peaking in 2008 at 24.5 million twenty-foot
‘There are about 700 ports in the world, and 690 would like to be in the top 10’ months later, the top 10 controlled about the same share, the data show. “Our customers consolidated from 20 major carriers down to 12, and the major East-West global alliances consolidated from four down to three,” Levesque said. As customers and their alliances turned into giants, so too did their ships: OOCL Hong Kong was the first to break through the 21,000-TEU mark. There are now around a dozen, led by the 23,756-TEU MSC Gulsun. OOIL’s demise marked a final twist for a company whose fortunes have closely mirrored those of Hong Kong itself. The unique combination of deep, natural harbor on China’s doorstep and rule of law enabled the city to ride the explosion of trade that followed Beijing’s market-opening reforms. In 1970, trade accounted for about 5 percent of China’s gross domestic product; it is about 40 percent today.
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
equivalent units, or TEU, Hong Kong last year handled 19.6 million. And in the first three months of this year, volumes fell 9.5 percent year-on-year to 4.42 million TEU, government data show. “The Hong Kong port had been so successful for so long that it really took quite a bit of courage for the four major terminal operators to get together and say that, for the future of the Hong Kong port, we really need to do things differently,” Levesque said. None of which dents his enduring optimism. “There are about 700 ports in the world, and 690 would like to be in the top 10,” he said. “The opportunity for the Hong Kong port is limitless. I don’t think it’s an infrastructure issue. I think it’s a mindset.” By refocusing on the holistic picture of what Hong Kong has to offer, the HKSPA reckons it can win back about two million TEUs in trade. It will do that by targeting leading regional rivals in the
15
COVER STORY
transshipment segment of the market, rather than through internecine competition between Greater Bay Area ports. Such a strategy neatly dovetails with Beijing’s strategic development plan for the GBA – comprising nine Mainland Chinese cities and the Special Administrative Regions of Hong Kong and Macau. First, there had to be a top-to-bottom realignment of Hong Kong’s port business model. There are three key segments of business for the container port in Hong Kong, he explained. Hong Kong was primarily designed to handle “gate” trade, in which containers are trucked from factories in southern China and shipped out to international markets. As China’s port infrastructure grew, more and more of that business left Hong Kong. “Instead of trucks coming down from China we now have a lot of barges,” Levesque said. “The port was not designed for massive barge traffic, and it was never really intended to be a transshipment hub. “You only handle the box once in gate shipment. In a transshipment you can handle the same box two or three times, but you only get paid once,” he said. “We need a cost structure that supports this kind of operation.”
16
A ship typically holds containers for several shipping lines. Prior to the HKSPA, many of these boxes would need to be trucked between terminals for onward shipment. Rationalizing port visits is expected to result in about 275,000 fewer transfers of containers between terminals. The alliance also estimates that improved port efficiency will save vessels more than 1,000 hours a year – which translates into 37,000 tons less marine fuel consumed. Together, these savings would reduce CO2 emissions by more than 130,000 tons. Joint operations will also mean less pressure to find more land. “We are trying to get more land to increase our competitiveness,” Levesque said. “The HKSPA should help us be more efficient with the land that we have.” Another major benefit from the new arrangement is that each terminal is sharing its best practice: “It will bring bring all four terminals up to the highest standards,” he added. Gauging the success of the alliance is complicated by the ongoing trade tensions between the US and
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
COVER STORY
China, and headwinds from the global economy. China’s industrial output grew 4.8 percent in July, its slowest pace since February 2002. At the same time, Germany’s economy contracted in the second quarter, while yields on long-term US and UK debt both dropped below those of short-term bonds – an indicator of possible recession. Meantime, Hong Kong remains the world’s busiest air-cargo hub – reflecting the growing share of ever smaller, lighter components in the mix of global trade. But rather than a zero-sum game in which maritime's loss is aviation's gain, the sum of the whole far exceeds the value of the parts. “If you’re a global logistics company, you need a world-class airport and you need a world-class seaport, because 80 percent of cargo moves by sea. So you need both air and ocean infrastructure to be a logistics hub,” Levesque said. “We’re way ahead in Hong Kong because we have a world-class airport, we have a world-class seaport, we have other worldclass infrastructure, and when you combine this with our freeport status, rule of law, transparency, and
ease of doing business, you have something really powerful and competitive in the region.” So where is Hong Kong slipping up? “I think one of the mistakes we make is that we tend to have a myopic view of what Hong Kong has to offer.” Hong Kong’s government is pushing the city as a global maritime hub, aiming to attract shippingrelated enterprises to set up shop and to promote the depth and range of expertise already at hand. It points to the “vibrant maritime cluster” of more than 800 companies providing ship management, ship broking and chartering, marine insurance, ship finance, maritime law and arbitration services. Hong Kong’s Shipping Register is the world’s fourthbiggest, with 2,628 vessels as of June, almost double the number at the beginning of 2009. “You wouldn’t try to be an aviation hub without airplanes. Why would you be a maritime center without ships, especially when you have something as valuable as this port in your backyard?” he said. “So yes, we need to develop the maritime center and all
'You wouldn’t try to be an aviation hub without airplanes. Why would you be a maritime center without ships, especially when you have something as valuable as this port in your backyard?'
17
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
COVER STORY
secure source we can be much more certain about what’s in the box.” Technology also offers the opportunity for increased automation. Crane operators can do the same job sitting in front of a computer screen at an ergonomically optimized desk, using a joystick not dissimilar to a gaming console and with nothing but the whir of air-conditioning to disturb the peace. Still, retrofitting one of the world’s busiest ports poses a massive challenge. “It has to be done in stages and it takes longer than a greenfield project,” Levesque said. The HKSPA is “well on its way in this area.” “I don’t think the carriers look and say, ‘I’m going to go to the world’s number one port today and then to the world’s number seven port tomorrow.’ They only look at which ports provide the best service and can get their ships in and out of port as fast as possible,” he said. Tara Joseph, with Peter Levesque bringing up the rear.
the ancillary services that go along with that because they add tremendous value. But at the same time, we must continue down the road to becoming a 21st century smart port. We’re already a world-class port, but we need to get our mojo back.” Bringing the port into the 21st century means investing into state-of-the-art technologies, including artificial intelligence, internet of things and automation. “The industry itself has been pretty slow at taking up new technology. Now the industry is in a position where it must adopt new technology in order to become more efficient,” Levesque said.
“That’s what our customers look for in a port, and that’s what we’re creating with the Hong Kong Seaport Alliance. A new value proposition for global carriers. One step at a time.”
WHAT MAKES A PORT GREAT? Freeport status
Blockchain is one technology that promises immediate benefits, both in terms of more efficient, transparent and reliable tracking of cargoes and record keeping, as well as in fighting illicit trade and reducing the risks from poor monitoring of hazardous cargoes.
Location – cargo hinterland Frequency of shipping/barge services Rule of law/well-established legal system Tax benefits and ease of doing business High operational efficiency
“By putting it all on the blockchain you’re able to authenticate the documentation process, and to me that’s a major step in supply chain security,” he said. “If the shipping documents are coming from a
18
State-of-the-art physical infrastructure
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
SPORTING CHANCE
SPORT & GENDER
A look inside the fight for pay parity, by Mathew Scott
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
19
SPORT & GENDER
The longer the FIFA Women’s World Cup progressed the more it became apparent that soccer wasn’t the only thing being played out in front of a global audience of millions. Megan Rapinoe (pictured on the previous page) was among those who made sure of that.
“Well it’s not good for them is it?” she told reporters when asked how the result may affect the lawsuit. “Obviously, it’s huge… We have a case no matter what, but this just sort of blows it out of the water. It’s, like, is it even about that anymore? Or is it just about doing the right thing?"
The 34-year-old from California has never flinched when it comes to championing the causes she holds close. As the tournament went on, and the USA moved close to a final – and a title – that somehow seemed predestined, co-captain Rapinoe used the spotlight to bring into the open a conversation over pay parity in sport that has too often and for too long been carried out behind closed boardroom doors.
The federation finds itself in a unique position, she said: “Ride this wave of good fortune and get on board and hopefully set things right for the future.”
Rapinoe and her teammates came into the World Cup in France at loggerheads with the US Soccer Federation over pay, launching a lawsuit that claims “institutionalized gender discrimination.” When the USA beat the Netherlands 2-0 to win the final at Stade de Lyon, Rapinoe seized her chance.
20
Crowds all through the month-long World Cup tournament had also warmed to the cause, and by the end of the July 7 final were chanting “Equal pay!” Out on the pitch, the American women did everything that was asked of them, winning all seven of their games. Off the pitch, people were talking about statistics that reveal just how wide the pay gap between the genders in sport remains. For winning the World Cup the USA team were each set to receive US$250,000. If the USA men’s team ever did the same, each player would receive
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
SPORT & GENDER
‘There's no secret that we're sort of the leaders in the women's game on a lot of different issues – equality, pay equality, gender issues’ – Megan Rapinoe, World Cup-winning US soccer player
US$1 million. Only, the American men failed to even qualify for their last World Cup.
Rapinoe left the World Cup ready to dig in for the fight ahead.
Overall women’s teams shared US$30 million across the World Cup, and they left with a promise from FIFA president Gianni Infantino that the figure would increase to US$60 million for the next edition in 2023. Last year, men’s teams shared a kitty of US$400 million for their version of the event.
“There’s no secret that we’re sort of the leaders in the women’s game on a lot of different issues – equality, pay equality, gender issues,” she told CNN.
Attorneys for the USA women say the national team generated US$50.9 million in revenue between 2016 and 2018 while the men brought in US$49.9 million. Detractors point to smaller crowds at events and, traditionally, less sponsorship available when it comes to women’s sport. Those pushing for equal pay say that things are changing. Last year’s US Open women’s tennis final drew more viewers than the men’s; Visa got in behind the women’s World Cup and in December signed a multi-year deal to promote the women’s game in Europe, estimated to be worth around US$12.5 million. AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
Love All: Tennis leads way Tennis is the only global sport where women’s pay either equals or even comes close to men’s. The US Open at Flushing Meadow was the ground-breaker, offering equal prize money to both sexes as far back as 1973, while the only woman to make the annual Forbes list of sport’s top 100 earners for 2019 was American star Serena Williams, at 63rd with US$29.2 million from prizes and endorsements for the year. While that makes for an impressive earn by anyone’s standards, the reality check comes when it’s compared to Forbes’ top two male earners – soccer stars Lionel Messi (US$127 million) and Cristiano Ronaldo (US$109 million).
21
SPORT & GENDER
Outside the global game of soccer, massive disparities exist in the likes of basketball, where players in North America’s National Basketball Association (NBA) receive US$7.4 million on average, compared with US$75,000 for their counterparts in the Women’s National Basketball League (WNBA). In Asia, women have long been at the forefront of sports such as badminton – India’s P V Sindhu was seventh on Forbes’ Asia list last year with US$8.5 million – and volleyball, where China’s Zhu Ting has been earning millions playing with Turkish outfit VakıfBank in the European Championship. Women’s professional golf has meanwhile been dominated by Asian players over the past two decades but, again, the wage gap is wide. Last season saw Thailand’s Ariya Jutanugarn top the Ladies Professional Golf Association prize list with almost US$2.8 million; in the men’s Professional Golf Association, Englishman Justin Rose came out on top with just over US$18 million. 22
How the success of the American women’s soccer team – and their ongoing court case – affect sports globally remains to be seen. But there are positive signs emerging elsewhere. Australia were another of the teams to shine at the Women’s World Cup, reaching the last 16 and in captain Samantha Kerr, who plies her trade in the US with Chicago Red Stars, having one of the most exciting talents in the game. Football Federation Australia’s top W-League last season instigated a 33 percent rise in minimum pay for its players, and brought in the “same base hourly rate for same base work” plan so W-League and the men’s A-League players receive the same minimum remuneration based on an hourly rate. “Over the past two years, FFA, alongside Australia’s professional clubs, players, and other stakeholders, has made significant strides in progressing the remuneration available to Australian female AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
SPORT & GENDER
footballers. FFA is committed to continuing to work diligently within this space,” an FFA spokesperson said. “FFA is currently bidding to host the 2023 FIFA Women’s World Cup. By 2027 it is our goal to reach fifty-fifty in registered players, and make football the clear sport of choice for women and girls both on and off the field. Hosting the tournament on home soil would help FFA to reach that target, and open commercial doors, inviting greater investment in the women’s game.”
23
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
SPONSORED CONTENT
Turbocharging an economic dynamo: Why the Greater Bay Area matters Peter Wong, Deputy Chairman and Chief Executive, The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited Announced by the Chinese government in February, the plan is ambitious and sweeping. It spans nine cities in the Pearl River Delta, plus neighboring Hong Kong and Macau, special administrative regions that have their own judicial, regulatory and financial systems. By proposing to boost economic links between these cities, it aims to shift what is already a regional economic dynamo up a gear.
Once, it was a rural backwater. Then, it became the factory floor of the world. Now, the area around the mouth of the Pearl River is at the epicenter of China’s shift towards high-tech and innovative manufacturing and services, and ranks among the most economically vibrant areas in China – if not the world. The Pearl River Delta’s transformation has been four decades in the making. Now, the Greater Bay Area development framework starts the next chapter of the story.
22
The size of the region means the plan amounts to one of the most important economic integration initiatives in the world. Its economy, for one, is already similar in size to Canada’s. The Pearl River Delta alone generated US$1.1 trillion of GDP in 2017; the number rises to US$1.5 trillion when Hong Kong and Macau are included. The GBA’s population of almost 70 million is larger than the UK’s. Its relative affluence (per capita GDP is well above the national average) makes it an enormous consumer market in its own right. So companies around the world should take note. Whether you are a German car-parts maker, an Australian retailer, or a Swiss company seeking to source from, sell to or manufacture in China, your operations – or those of your suppliers and business
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
SPONSORED CONTENT
partners – are already likely to be directly or indirectly connected to this economic area. Going forward, greater connectivity and improved harmonization of regulations – core tenets of the new GBA blueprint – will make it easier to do business and seize new opportunities within the region. The various jurisdictions involved will begin to smooth out labor-market and residency policies, environmental protection, regulatory standards, visa requirements, for example, and seek ways to coordinate infrastructure networks and smart-city development. Progress is already being made in the area of taxation, with certain professionals from Hong Kong recently being offered tax subsidies to work in Guangdong cities. We are also starting to see targeted capital account liberalization that makes it easier for Hong Kong residents to set up bank accounts in Mainland China and make payments for household expenses. Such measures will allow for much more fluid movement throughout the GBA. The Greater Bay Area is special. Perhaps nowhere else in the world can rapidly evolving high-tech manufacturing capabilities, a huge consumer base and talent pool, and an international financing and logistics hub be found in such close proximity. In Shenzhen, Guangzhou and other Pearl River Delta cities, the made-for-export manufacturing of lowend garments or toys for which the region was once famous has rapidly given way to gleaming factories and design centers that can turn out anything from advanced electronics and clean energy systems to battery technologies and aerial drones. Macau has grown into an international tourism and leisure center, and can act as a platform for trade with Portuguese-speaking countries such as Brazil.
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
Hong Kong’s contribution to the mix is providing the capital, education and research, entrepreneurial know-how and international connectivity that is crucial to companies in the neighboring Mainland. As a global financial center, the city can also help bring international standards of business, innovation and entrepreneurship to the rest of the region. It is also a tried-and-trusted gateway for businesses and investors heading the other way – from overseas into the Mainland – including through a pair of schemes that link its stock exchange with those in Shenzhen and Shanghai. As China’s currency becomes more widely used overseas for trade and investment, Hong Kong and the GBA will be at the cutting edge of further measures to liberalize capital flows between Mainland China and the rest of the world. True, the GBA vision is a long-term one, and changes won’t come overnight. The blueprint foresees substantial coordination across the region by 2022, paving the way for it to become an internationally competitive, efficient and innovative economic hub by 2035. Still, the fact that the different cities’ complementary strengths have been building connections within the region for decades means that the new GBA blueprint builds on solid foundations. Businesses in the region already see the potential. A survey conducted by HSBC, KPMG and the Hong Kong General Chamber of Commerce last year found that nearly 80 percent of executives operating in the region expect it to grow faster than the rest of China over the next three years. Companies that are not already there might want to join them in taking a closer look.
23
THROUGH THE OPEN DOOR Hopewell Holdings founder Sir Gordon Wu recalls in this extract from a 2006 biography his first foray into China following Deng Xiaoping’s historic 1978 declaration that China needed foreign expertise and capital to build a ‘modern and prosperous’ society
China rarely entered Wu’s thoughts during the busy 1970s, when he had numerous construction projects, the erection of the Hopewell Centre, and a young family to deal with. Until one day in 1978 when supreme leader Deng Xiaoping announced the “open door policy,” a change that would begin a major shift in world geopolitics. Wu read and reread Deng’s historic speech and came to believe that serious changes were in the offing. He had already seen what Chinese entrepreneurs could do in Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Malaysia and the Philippines. The opening up of China allowed the Chinese their first glimpse of the outside world for 30 years, and for many it must have been profoundly unsettling. Everything foreign seemed better – and usually was. Everyone yearned for something from outside, even if they didn’t quite know what to do with it. One businessman relates the story of going to one of the new foreign restaurants on the Mainland and seeing young people eating bread and jam with chopsticks.
26
‘I never really asked what they thought about America and its ways, and they didn’t tell me their views. But I know they liked the hamburgers’ – Gordon Wu, on his tour of American highways with Guangdong officials As soon as he could, Wu started projects over the border. Several people told him he was mad. He replied: “Hell, I’m Chinese and I want to build a relationship of trust with these people on the Mainland.” When in China Wu sometimes went for an evening stroll around the city. At night, the streets were completely deserted. The crowds of cyclists returning home from the fields or factories had reached their homes and stayed there. There was no electricity for AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
streetlights, so who would want to go for a walk in the dark? Even if they did, there was really nothing to do other than sit in the park. Most people were poor. Those who had money had nothing to spend it on. There were no shops, no cinemas, no bars, few restaurants and poor transport. Wu strolled through the gloomy, silent streets and grappled with the key question: How could he make people understand that everything would change dramatically, and in many cases remarkably quickly, as China began her modernization program? Red China, red tape Wu quickly learned that the key to being successful in China was to have support at the right level. The villains, he found, tended to be at the middle levels of government. He would often find himself under pressure from them to procure building materialsof questionable quality from certain suppliers. He hated underhand dealing and flatly refused to pay any bribes. “Once you start down a crooked path, it never ends,” he told his staff. But much of the work in China was frustrating, after his experience of efficient Hong Kong. He discovered that to build anything on the Mainland almost certainly meant every stage of the process would require months of negotiations with provincial government officials. Hopelessly naive in his first meetings, he eventually hit upon a technique that worked: he made sure his joint-venture partners in China always made as much money as he did – or more. “I win some points and I lose some. But at the end of the day, I feel both sides will come out winners, and that’s what’s important.” Never intimidated by rank, Wu contacted the highest grade officials he could and told them some hard facts. China needed three things and she needed them fast: telephones to improve communication, working power stations to supply electricity, and a decent road system for transport. As an engineer he weighed up his experience and decided to concentrate on infrastructure for transport and power. From his very first visit back to Guangdong Province, Wu envisaged how a superhighway and an interconnected system of roads between Hong Kong and Guangzhou and around the Pearl River
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
Delta would speed up development. The logic of the idea was clear and compelling to Wu, but it proved impossible for Chinese officials to understand. Most of them did not own cars and did not know how to drive. “Chinese people can hardly afford bicycles. So why would they need a highway for cars?” one asked. Wu thought back to the first time he had seen the New Jersey Turnpike as a student in 1954. It was clear to him that highways were playing a key role in economic development, and creating huge opportunities in America and the rest of the West, just as the canals had done in the 18th century and the railways had done in the 19th century. A quarter of a century after that American journey, Wu was invited to Beijing. He had his letter of intent to proceed with his projects, but a higher authority was needed to give the stamp of approval to really get things moving. Finding friends in high places On December 9, 1981, Wu met Vice Premier Gu Mu, who was responsible for foreign and economic cooperation in China. It was noted by those who attended the meeting that Vice Premier Gu complimented Wu on “being a fine scholar, a highly organized entrepreneur and a brave and courageous Chinese.” Gu agreed with all of Wu's proposals and urged him to press on. He immediately arranged for Wu to meet Premier Zhao Ziyang that same afternoon. The two men found common ground straight away and would go on to form a close bond over the next decade. Zhao, a warm, forward-looking man, got on well with Wu. They shared an engineering background, as well as a determination to make major progress in China. Zhao warned Wu that his visionary projects would require a lot of stamina because whilst China wanted to change there would be many obstacles. Zhao offered his full support. He wanted China to reform and he could see that Wu could help bring muchneeded infrastructure to the country. Gaining this level of support for the superhighway and his other projects was an extraordinary feat in those early days of foreign investment. The officials realized that Wu probably did not even begin to understand the magnitude of the problems he would face, but they were impressed with his bold ideas and commitment.
27
Back in Guangdong, Wu was directed to start discussions with the head of the Guangdong Travel and Transport Bureau, Li Wu. The Hong Kong builder found him a fascinating man with an extraordinary history: he was a long-term Communist Party member; he had been a guerrilla fighter during the Japanese war in China; he was a union organizer who had tried to destabilize Hong Kong in the 1940s; and he was a survivor of the worst excesses of the Cultural Revolution. Yet although he had lived a remarkable life, Wu was not sure why the government felt he was qualified to be the head of the travel and transport bureau. He didn’t own a car, nor did he know how to drive. He had never traveled outside China. The transport chief led Wu out of his office and showed him his own personal transport – a bicycle in the standard two-tone local style: black paint and orange rust. They kicked the tires together and laughed. In that moment, they formed an instant bond.
28
‘Even if they did venture out, there was really nothing to do other than sit in the park. Most people were poor. Those who had money had nothing to spend it on. There were no shops, no cinemas, no bars, few restaurants and poor transport’ Li Wu was one of the few people among the authorities that understood the benefits a good road system could bring to the underdeveloped province. But the bureaucracy remained a nightmare. The difficulties of trying to get approval to build the highway kept mounting, and reached a peak when Wu was attempting to obtain the land that would be required to construct it. His plan caused a revolt
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
in the travel bureau, an unheard-of event. People working in the bureau complained vigorously to their bosses that this man Wu was a very bad person. For a start, he was a capitalist. Look at his plans. He wants to build a highway which would only be used by a few rich people with cars. Staff pointed out that the teachings of Mao Zedong enshrined the land for agriculture and growing food. Giving it away to a rich capitalist to build a road was a travesty. Besides, they argued, China already had railways. They should just concentrate on building more railways that everyone could use, rather than a highway for cars that only a few idle rich could use. Wu knew then that even though China was starting to undergo economic reforms, he was still The Class Enemy. He wondered how he could communicate his ideas better. He had shown everyone photos of highways from around the world, he had shown them his plans, he had done endless sketches and diagrams, but he could see they really did not understand. One night, when Wu was sitting on the train returning to Hong Kong, the solution presented itself. If people could see and experience what he was talking about, then they might begin to understand it. That’s why they understood trains, because they used them themselves.
memories for him of when he had first stepped off the boat in San Francisco 30 years earlier. After Los Angeles, they headed south to the Mexican border to inspect the customs and immigration procedures. Wu wanted to show them how efficiently this worked, in the hopes they could learn from this and improve the border crossing between Hong Kong and China. After a short stopover, they headed east on a US interstate highway across Arizona, New Mexico and Texas, before driving right through the heart of Middle America to New York, a journey of thousands of miles that took 14 days. The party stayed in bad highway motels and ate greasy hamburgers from fast food joints. “It was great,” Wu said afterwards. At one point the vicemayor of Guangzhou turned to Wu and said: “This road is so smooth that I can write in my diary as we travel – I couldn’t do that on the rough roads of China.” Throughout the trip – which took in a visit to his 25th anniversary reunion at Princeton University – Wu made a point of never discussing politics or capitalism. He said afterwards: “I never really asked what they thought about America and its ways, and they didn’t tell me their views. But I know they liked the hamburgers.”
Capitalist roaders? Wu organized a tour, to fly a group of provincial government representatives all the way to the United States to see first hand what big roads were all about. In June 1983, Wu and four senior managers from Hopewell flew to the United States with a group of six Communist Party officials. After a 14-hour flight to San Francisco, Wu purchased a large Dodge van for US$17,000 which seated 15 people. They loaded up the car and after a pleasant tour around the bay on a balmy Sunday morning, he headed for Los Angeles. Over the next two weeks, the Hong Kong builder drove them all over the great highways of America. Their eyes were as round as saucers. They couldn’t believe what their eyes showed them: the cars, the people, the shopping malls, the big buildings, and just the sheer noise and pace of Los Angeles. Wu knew exactly what they were feeling. It brought back
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
At the end of the two-week tour, Wu had convinced the Chinese officials they simply must start to build a highway system like America’s. On their return home, these officials became advocates within the Chinese government for the project. They genuinely wanted China to have what America had. Wu continued his mission to convert powerful officials to his point of view – but now had support from inside. After numerous meetings, Wu felt that he must have drunk about five gallons of maotai. But it proved worth it. Formal approval to build his highway was granted in 1984. It was a major step for Wu, but the battle to turn the dream into reality was just beginning. Superhighwayman... Wu signed up to build the 122-kilometer highway under a build-operate-transfer (BOT) scheme, a concept then new to Asia, where infrastructure projects were undertaken by governments. But lack
29
of funds in many developing countries meant there was a need to involve the private sector and foreign investors. A BOT project was essentially a partnership between the private sector and the government of the host economy. The government provided necessary land and approvals. The foreign investor provided the capital and the expertise to get the project built.
Once the word got around the press that Gordon Wu planned to build a world-class expressway between Hong Kong and Guangzhou, there was much discussion – and wide skepticism. Commentators found the uncertainties and ever-extending timetables of the superhighway construction plan too much to contemplate, and believed Wu was destined to fail.
Wu said he would raise the cash, build and then operate the highway for a period of 30 years. It would then be handed over to the ownership of the state. In those three decades, Hopewell would receive 40 percent of all toll profits for the first 10 years and 30 percent for the remaining 20 years. Wu told the media that his road would be completed “in two or three years.”
But Wu was looking far ahead. He was already envisioning a time when there would be easy border crossings in and out of China, and major cities all over the Mainland would be linked by major transport routes. In his mind, he saw himself developing arterial routes to link the eastern and western part of the Pearl River Delta with Hong Kong. The superhighway would be just the beginning. Wu believed that this future was inevitable.
He naively figured that since it was a communist country, and the state owned everything, the authorities would simply give him the land. But farmers occupied it, and there were huts, crops, trees and other property. The plan was almost immediately bogged down. “I have to pay off each person individually,” he told colleagues on his return from China. “I’m flabbergasted.” Local bureaucrats also proved difficult, by holding up land deliveries and looking for favors or control over construction contracts. It would take a further six painful years, and the powerful influence of Premier Zhao, who had become a big Wu fan, to acquire the right of way to all the land he needed.
30
This excerpt is taken from Chapter 5 of The Man who Turned the Lights on: Gordon Wu, a 2006 biography written by Rosemary Sayer and published by Chameleon Press. The reprint is made with the generous permission of the author and publisher. Sayer spent a large portion of her career as a business journalist before working in PR – including stints with Jardine Matheson and Standard Chartered Bank. More recently, she has decided to focus on refugee issues and the not-for profit sector.
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
GORDON WU SHOWED AMCHAM SOME OF THE ENERGY THAT POWERED HIM THROUGH AN EXTRAORDINARY CAREER Sir Gordon Wu graduated from Princeton with a degree in engineering, returning home to Hong Kong to help run the family’s taxi empire before putting his ivy-league education to good use in construction. He founded Hopewell in the early 1960s, taking the group public on the Hong Kong stock exchange in 1972. Wu and his team pioneered new methods of construction and financing for groundbreaking transport and power projects in China, including the Guangzhou-Shenzhen Superhighway and Shajiao B and C power stations. At a sprightly 83, Wu knows how to play his audience, scoring rounds of laughter with his trademark quips and home-spun common sense that over the decades have marked the Hong Kong infrastructure tycoon as a plain-talking scourge of lazy thinkers and purveyors of glib solutions.
“In 1983, I said Hong Kong needs a bridge to connect Zhuhai and Macau… after 1997 I still pushed, and ultimately it was built. But the bureaucrats in Hong Kong said, ‘We don’t want that number of cars on that bridge,’ … very fortunately I was not an investor, otherwise I would have declared bankruptcy. “They listened to the consultants,” he said, getting set to skewer one of his favorite targets. “The Hong Kong government is a government of the consultants, by the consultants, and for the consultants.” Sir Gordon Wu spoke at an AmCham event on July 3. For a full writeup and to hear the speech in full, see our website.
Take his views on the recently opened Hong KongZhuhai-Macau Bridge – a project that must be both a source of chagrin as well as pride: it was, after all, his brainchild, but one that didn’t turn out quite as he had envisioned.
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
31
SPONSORED FEATURE
FLYING HIGH HOW UNITED AIRLINES IS TAPPING INTO CHINA’S AIR TRAVEL BOOM
C
hina is poised to overtake the United States as the world’s largest commercial aviation market in the next three years. The country’s economic progress has led to a rising middle-class with more disposable income looking for long-haul travel outside of China. With a growing number of Chinese traveling abroad for business and leisure, competition among the airlines to lure them is also heating up. One of the people responsible for steering Chinese travelers to the United States is United Airlines’ managing director of Greater China and Korea, Walter Dias. He is responsible for the development and execution of sales and promotion programs, advertising and public relations for United Airlines in China, Hong Kong, Taiwan and South Korea. Dias, a 37-year veteran of the aviation industry, was previously managing director of Greater China and Southeast Asia for Continental Airlines, where he covered offshore sales in Thailand, Vietnam, Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia. “It has been fascinating to watch the transformation of China and the large growth in Chinese customers wanting to visit the US,” he said. “China has experienced an economic miracle that’s unprecedented in human history. When people become economically
32
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
SPONSORED FEATURE
independent and successful, one of the first things they want to do is travel and see the world. In the last 15 years there’s been such an increase in the middle class in China. It’s driving this huge amount of desire to go abroad.” China already has more than 200 airports. But with more and more Chinese travelers taking to the skies, the central government is pouring billions of dollars into building new airports across the country to meet soaring demand. The highly anticipated Beijing Daxing International Airport is slated to open in September this year, and is expected to process 100 million passengers by 2040. The International Air Transport Association estimates that Chinese airports will serve a total of 1.5 billion passengers by 2036.
their tour guides around the world have become a thing of the past. Young travelers are seeking deeper engagement with more novel destinations. “With China, travelers would typically buy a package and they would go into the US and then bounce around six cities in nine days or a jam-packed itinerary like that. I call it the ‘ping pong itinerary,’” said Dias. “We’ve been trying to convey to customers for the last 10 years or so that you don’t have to have that type of itinerary.”
International airlines like United are rolling out initiatives and tapping into emerging aviation trends to increase their foothold in the world’s fastest growing aviation market. “United happens to be the largest airline between the US and Asia,” said Dias. “We also happen to be the largest airline between the US and China and so we’re enjoying seeing such a fast-growing market.” For Dias, China’s increasing demand for international travel has created a ripe environment for foreign carriers to innovate and provide expanded services and options. One of the many factors shaping future aviation trends is China’s changing demographics, according to Dias. Today’s travelers are comprised of millennials and “Generation Z,” who already have a lot of overseas travel experience, he said. “Millennials and Gen Z are looking for different things. They’re not looking for a trip to go sightseeing. They want an experience. The millennial market is 32 percent of the total marketplace and Gen Z is just surpassing it by a little bit. Those two markets are most dynamic and keen on traveling the world. You have to work on enticing them to come to your destination, and you have to come up with something unique,” said Dias. Young peoples’ preference for accumulating memorable moments over material goods has created what many today call the “experience economy.” Younger travelers are looking for unique, local experiences – cultural, natural, artistic or culinary. The days of large groups of tourists following
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
33
SPONSORED FEATURE
Destinations are now expanding their experiential offerings to cater to changing demographics. “When they [Chinese travelers] were thinking about travel to the US, they were thinking this is a once-ina-lifetime kind of trip so they had to fit everything in – LA, Washington, Vegas. But now we’re saying that you don’t have to do this. You have arrived. You’re successful. You’re part of the middle class. You can savor the destination,” said Dias. One example of the changing desires of Chinese travelers, and their interest in more experiential travel, includes picking up sports such as skiing. Spurred on by Beijing winning the bid to host the 2022 Winter Olympics, China’s central government has said it wants to see 300 million of its citizens take up winter sports before that day arrives, Xinhua News Agency reported.
To support this, United has been working with the ski industry over the last five years in northern China, a region with many ski resorts. The airline flies in top ski instructors from Colorado to northern Beijing, where they spend a week training local instructors in the sport’s best practices. In the past, United also sponsored one junior ski contest per season, the winners of which received a free trip to Vail in Colorado – one of the most popular ski destinations in the US. United, for one, sees the huge business opportunity in this market. “We’re sitting at the ground floor of this incredible opportunity to bring skiers together at the great ski resorts of the US,” said Dias. Another opportunity that United is capitalizing on is in the emerging technologies that are reshaping the flying experience for passengers. Social media, online booking platforms and mobile apps have become indispensable tools for planning and booking trips. Airline mobile usage, in particular, is on the rise, he said. “Everyone is going mobile. Ninety-six percent of access to the internet in China is [through] mobile,” Dias said. In a move to embrace the new digital era, United now offers its customers a downloadable mobile app with real-time flight tracking services and customizable flight status alerts. In the event of a delay or cancellation, its passengers can use the United app to rebook themselves on to another flight. United joins the ranks of international airlines that have started using Chinese social media platform WeChat to reach their Chinese clientele. Dias said the company is developing its own WeChat mini programs to allow for more interactive communication with its customers. As for Dias, having access to Wifi on planes is the main thing that has changed his personal experience of flying over the past decade. “It’s a double-edged sword,” he said. “When I used to travel, it was the one time I was not connected to anything, so I felt a little free. But now you’re still tethered to the internet. Sometimes I will still work on planes because of this.”
34
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
WEALTH MANAGEMENT
IT’S A FAMILY AFFAIR Carret Private co-founder Kenneth Ho demystifies the multi-family office and how Asia’s uber-wealthy like to invest their money, writes Jennifer Khoo
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
35
WEALTH MANAGEMENT
“Old investment bankers go to the banking graveyard and die away,” says Kenneth Ho, managing partner at the Asian arm of multi-family office Carret Private on why he made the switch to wealth management almost two decades ago. Prior to joining Carret, the Taiwanese American MBA holder enjoyed a decade-long stint as one of five founding partners of Julius Baer’s Asia Pacific platform, helping expand the business into the fifthlargest private bank in the region. But as the franchise grew, Ho says he found himself becoming a victim to his own success as the highly personalized, tailored approach possible in the early stages of growth became unsustainable. So when offered the opportunity in 2015 to build New York-founded Carret Asset Management’s Asia franchise from the ground up, he jumped at the chance. With help from a couple of former Julius Baer colleagues, Carret’s first Asian multi-family office was born the following year in Hong Kong. “When we were growing JB it was fun, entrepreneurial and exciting,” he says during our 40-minute interview at the Garage Society co-working space in Wanchai. “But when you get bigger and bigger you lose that,
36
you become a supermarket. My partners and I don’t want to create a private-banking supermarket.” Multi-family offices typically take on fewer clients than private banks, operating on the principle that ultra-high net worth families prefer highly catered and customized investment services. That certainly seems to be backed up by data from the most recent Capgemini World Wealth Report, which found that almost half of high net worth individuals polled in the benchmark annual survey of the sector said they didn’t connect “very well” with their advisers. “Our whole platform is built as a boutique where we’re not meant to take on 5,000 clients,” says Ho.
'WE'RE NOT MEANT TO TAKE ON 5,000 CLIENTS. WE’RE MEANT TO TAKE ON 50 CLIENTS AND SERVICE THEM REALLY, REALLY WELL'
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
WEALTH MANAGEMENT
“We’re meant to take on 50 clients and service them really, really well.”
KEEP IT CLEAN…
Wealth management and private banking are interchangeable terms, says Ho, in that they both involve managing wealthy people’s money. The main difference is that private banks have a banking license and their employees bring money into the company. And investment options are mostly limited to the bank’s own products.
“Don’t judge a book by its cover” ought be an industry slogan.
Carret doesn’t have a banking license, and its employees don’t bring money into the company. Instead it operates a multi-custodian business model
‘TRUST ME, WHEN MARKETS GET HIGH PEOPLE START FORGETTING THAT THEY NEED TO PUT THEIR KIDS THROUGH COLLEGE’ that assesses and recommends the best products on the market, allowing for a “highly catered, highly customized” wealth management service for the firm’s UHNW clientele. “This is part of our power, because we can find the best custodians for our clients,” says Ho.
“Everyone in China is literally one generation away from farmer,” Ho says. “I remember at Julius Baer, on any given day there would be some guy wearing shorts and flip flops coming in from Szechuan who’s a billionaire. “The toughest job in our industry, apart from dealing with changing regulations, is figuring out how this guy got his money. How he got it offshore, is it legal, who’s he working with.” Hong Kong presents its own, different challenges. Potential clients will likely have inherited their money, which makes it tough to meet today’s evertighter rules on “know your customer” – or KYC. “For example, a wife inherits money from her husband who sold their business 20 years ago. [Before investing it] she has to prove how she got the money from her husband, how he sold the business and show the proof of sale. Who is going to have that from 20 years ago?” says Ho. “It’s really hard to get ahold of that information. It’s not like today where everything is electronic and can be downloaded for a fee. Banks and financial institutions have to get all that information and trace it back to the first dollar,” he says. Strong client relationships that are built on mutual trust aid the crucial KYC process, Ho says. That’s particularly important in Hong Kong, which was ranked fourth globally in the Tax Justice Network’s 2018 Financial Secrecy Index. “Most people anywhere you go are reluctant to tell you too much about how they made their money. But if someone walks in with a billion dollars, you’ve got to figure out how they’ve made a billion. The last thing we want is to be seen as enabling money laundering.”
So like an independent financial adviser? And if anything fishy is discovered? “I don’t like using that term, it’s more retail, but yes, from your perspective. The difference is that our clients are typically in the 50-plus million dollar range whereas IFAs typically deal with clients in the 500,000 dollar range,” he says. AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
“We turn people away every day. I want to grow my business, but I also have to maintain my company license,” he says. “If I lose my license I lose my breadwinner.” AmChamHK
7-8 • 2018
37
WEALTH MANAGEMENT
Crazy rich Asians Carret’s service offerings are catered to Asian clientele, a degree of specialization that Ho says the bigger banks aren’t able to provide. “Private banks take global models and try to apply them to Asia, which alienates Asian clients,” he says, adding that this has only been reinforced by tighter regulations in the wake of the global financial crisis. “Banks have become very strict in all their processes,” he says. “But as such, the investments they put on their platform are what I call ‘supermarket investments’ – everyone is offering the same.” As an analogy, Ho points to the world’s biggest wealth manager, UBS, which he likens to Walmart: “They are only going to take Lays potato chips, whereas I’m able to find Korea’s best potato chip shop, which is fantastic and has a great track record, even though it is very regionally focused,” he says. A real-life example of Carret’s greater freedom and flexibility in sourcing investment opportunities for clients is Gaw Capital Partners. The Hong Kongbased real estate fund bought the InterContinental Hong Kong hotel for US$940 million in 2015 and a sizable chunk of the multibillion portfolio of Link
38
REIT, Asia’s biggest real estate investment trust, in March this year. “When customers at private banks want to invest in real estate they only have access to well-known, global private equity firms like Blackstone, for example,” he says. “The banks can’t use Gaw Capital because it’s relatively too small, a regional player.” Brushing off the suggestion that smaller or lesserknown means riskier, Ho says the sourcing of investment products at the bigger banks tends to be done from centers such as New York, Zurich or London, and so they simply aren’t able to evaluate some Asian prospects that are more regional in focus. “These bigger banks offer investment products with more of a global focus. If you invest into Blackstone, you’re investing into a global real estate fund. We’re investing into the Asian real estate portfolio of Gaw Capital,” he says. “That’s the only explanation I can give. It’s not because it’s more risky.” Regardless, Ho says Asian clientele do tend to be more adventurous with their money than their counterparts in Europe and America, where more of the wealth has been handed down over generations.
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
WEALTH MANAGEMENT
“The mentality of those [US and European] clients is ‘you guys take care of it and report back to me in six months. Don’t take too many risks. Don’t lose my money,’” says Ho, who spent an earlier part of his career working for Salomon Brothers in New York. “In the US, when you invest, you don’t trade and punt, like, five stocks. But here in Hong Kong everyone’s always talking about individual stocks,” he says. “Out here, a lot of people have successfully made their own money and think they are smarter than the rest of us. And they might be right.” Ho says China’s wealthy tend to take a “barbell approach” with their money – an investment strategy that is hyper-aggressive at one end of the scale, mildly conservative at the other, and avoids the moderate middle ground. “These clients will invest in high-risk private equity and also keep money in the bank,” a strategy that makes sense in countries like China where bank deposit rates remain high, but which raises the bar on yields Carret has to offer. “I’ve got to reach for returns of at least 3 percent to be able to even attract these people,” he says. Still, the team at Carret invests a lot of time into building risk profiles of clients, taking a fundamentally long-term view. “We tend to look for outstanding investments in more risky areas that banks can’t offer, but the core of our business is putting together very safe, sound portfolios for the future.” Which means being a consistent counsel of caution against “irrational exuberance” for the more yieldhungry clients. “Trust me, when markets get high, people start forgetting that they need to put their kids through college.”
CARRET FOUNDER PHILIP CARRET’S
12
COMMANDMENTS OF INVESTING
1
Never hold fewer than 10 different securities covering five different fields of business
2 At least once every six months, reappraise every security held
3 Keep at least half the total fund in incomeproducing securities
4 Consider (dividend) yield the least important factor in analyzing any stock
5
Be quick to take losses and reluctant to take profits
6
Never invest into securities about which detailed information is not readily available
7 Avoid inside information as you would the plague
8 Seek facts diligently, advice never 9 Ignore mechanical formulas for value in
securities
10
When stocks are high, money rates rising and business prosperous, at least half of the portfolio should be placed in short-term bonds
11
Borrow money sparingly and only when stocks are low, money rates low and falling, and business depressed
12
Set aside a proportion of funds for the purchase of options in promising companies
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
39
ICYMI
Ignite Light blue touch paper and retire… AmCham held its first round of Ignite talks on July 18, an opportunity for new members to mingle over a few nibbles and drinks and, if they were game, tell their company’s story in short, punchy presentations of no more than 20 slides. Loron Orris, co-founder and Chairman of Asia Sports Tech and who heads the newly formed Sports committee, is seen here taking his turn.
40
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
ICYMI
Charitable Foundation Lunch Six of the best… Six high-achieving students were handed awards from the AmCham Charitable Foundation at a luncheon reception in the Grand Hyatt on July 5 hosted by eight former chamber chairmen, who sit on the Board of Trustees, and President Tara Joseph. Joanna Lu, who was represented by her father (top left with 2005 Chairman John Zinke), Kyoji Fukuda and Hok Hei Fung each won HK$15,000 Scholar Awards for full-time MBA students. Diocesan Girls School students Helen Yeung and Vivian Looi, and Chih-Ning Kuo of Chinese International School were winners of Lyn Edinger US Studies Scholarships – with each taking home HK$24,000.
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
41
SPONSORED CONTENT: ENTREPRENEURS
Action vital to future of Hong Kong start-up culture, KPMG says Entrepreneur ecosystem is at a ‘critical juncture,’ with concrete steps needed in the next few years to ensure future vibrancy, joint study with Alibaba finds Hong Kong has made steady progress in the past year in its journey to develop a dynamic and vibrant startup ecosystem. However, growth may be constrained if support is not better targeted at start-ups moving from early to growth stage. A recent study by KPMG China and Alibaba Hong Kong Entrepreneurs Fund suggests more needs to be done to ensure that founders and potential employees receive sufficient support from family, friends and the general community. Now in its second year, the Transforming Hong Kong Through Entrepreneurship study surveyed 393 locally based entrepreneurs and students, in addition to interviews with key opinion leaders and analysis of venture capital. The study summarizes the state of development in four priority sectors identified by
42
the Hong Kong government: artificial intelligence, biotechnology, fintech and smart city. The results show that Hong Kong’s start-up ecosystem is at a critical juncture, with action in the next few years crucial to future vibrancy. This especially means investing in education and the development of local talent while doing more to change existing attitudes and nurture an entrepreneurial mindset among the next generation. Please scan to read the full report:
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2018 2019
SPONSORED CONTENT: ENTREPRENEURS
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
43
SPONSORED CONTENT: ENTREPRENEURS
44
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
Schlock it to me, baby The Hollywood blockbusters may grab the limelight, but there are plenty of rich pickings to be found investing in Asia’s thriving genre movie industry, former Columbia/TriStar head Chris Lee tells Mathew Scott AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
45
FILM INDUSTRY
Chris Lee carries with him a unique perspective on the state of the Asian cinema industry. First, he was the head of a major Hollywood studio (Columbia/ TriStar) in the late 1990s and early 2000s, right at the time the region was first emerging as a box office force in its own right. Then, for the past 15 years, Lee has directed the development of the University of Hawaii’s Academy for Creative Media in his home state, helping guide new generations of filmmakers who look to Asia for opportunities as revenue and production numbers across the region continue to swell. The 63-year-old recently took the chair at the Bucheon International Fantastic Film Festival (Bifan) for its annual Fantastic Film School, a program designed to inspire young filmmakers and to finetune their pitching skills. Bifan takes place over 11 days in the early summer of each year the satellite city of Bucheon about 16 kilometers outside Seoul. The town’s other main claim to fame is the Korean Comics Museum, which is a fitting complement to the film festival’s focus of genre cinema – everything from horror to sci-fi and all stops between. There’s a palpable buzz about the place we can put down to a combination of the festival’s focus on helping people get their films made, and the fact that the geeks here are really let off the leash, given the weird and wonderful nature of the program. It’s an opportunity to tap into Lee’s views about what’s going on in Asia – and where the best opportunities for investment are emerging. 46
“Things are happening everywhere,” says Lee. “Fox have just been in Indonesia [to make the co-produced hit 212 Warrior], I’ve toured the studios in Iskander [Malaysia].Then we are here in Korea, which is the big pop-culture driver... It’s incredible when you think about that we’re in a country where [only] around 50 million people speak the language and yet their pop culture speaks globally. It’s remarkable. “In terms of film, production values are great, creativity is great, the films are often ripe for remaking, and I think they’ve cracked the code of creating popular culture that is true to them but speaks to the broadest possible audience.” Festivals like Bifan offer platforms such as the Network of Fantastic Asian Films (NAFF), where ideas can be shared and – the hope is – connections made that might lead to ideas coming to life. A good example, Lee says, is the 2013
of my smarter Hollywood friends know that because of the genre focus there are often a lot of really viable projects here that you can get behind.” They come from all over Asia at a time when smaller markets outside of the traditional “big three” of China, Japan and South Korea are growing rapidly. While fragmented markets and sometimes opaque accounting or disclosure make it difficult to estimate the total amount of money being invested into Asia films, a rough proxy can be found in the share of box office takings by non-Hollywood movies and the number of cinema screens – on the latter measure, Asia had about twice as many screens last year than the US and Canada, the world’s biggest market and, for now, the global benchmark. Malaysia is coming off the first year where three films drew in 30 million ringgit (US$7.2 million), and
‘The films that I was most associated with at TriStar – Jerry Maguire, As Good As It Gets, My Best Friend’s Wedding, Philadelphia – none of them would get made today. I don’t know if that’s good or bad, because at the end of the day there’s still more content being made, there’s still more movies’ – Chris Lee, former president of Columbia/Tristar Korean thriller, The Terror Live. First pitched at Bifan, it proved a big box office hit with an estimated US$37 million in takings – and all on a budget of just over US$3 million. “Coming here can make that difference just in terms of getting the funds needed to give the film the push it needs,” says Lee. “A lot
the horror Munafik 2’s US$9 million made it the biggest domestic hit of all time. Indonesia’s box office is being transformed as an easing of foreign investment laws has seen a surge in new cinemas. Even the relatively tiny Vietnamese market has seen records tumble, as the thriller Furie became the nation’s biggest hit ever with about 200 billion dong (US$8.6 million) and
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
a successful limited run in North American cinemas (US$600,000). Hollywood-driven co-productions also continue to head east – heavyweights Spike Lee (Da 5 Bloods, for Netflix) and Michael Mann (Hue 1968, for FX) are shooting in Vietnam. Thailand had 74 international productions shot around the country in 2018, helped no doubt by government rebates of 15 percent for more than 50 million baht (US$1.6 million) spent by filmmakers locally. Malaysia’s rebate is a whopping 30 percent for more than US$1.5 million spent. Still, in terms of local box office, the gains have been driven by local genre films.
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
“Genre films are in the one last sweet spot that studio films are still looking for,” says Lee. “Everybody is still looking for that genre-driven, high concept, low budget picture that brings people into the theater.
There rapid growth – and reach – of streaming platforms such as Netflix and HBO has altered the way people consume cinema, and other content such as TV series, and Lee says the onus on creatives is simply to adapt.
“People have basically written off the romantic comedy,” he says. “Everything there has migrated to Netflix. The films that I was most associated with at TriStar – Jerry Maguire, As Good As It Gets, My Best Friend’s Wedding, Philadelphia – none of them would get made today. I don’t know if that’s good or bad, because at the end of the day there’s still more content being made, there’s still more movies.”
“The collective experience seems to have dissipated,” says Lee. “While there are occasional breakouts like Crazy Rich Asians, you have all these other films that have fallen by the wayside because we are being conditioned to watch them on Netflix. “But that’s just change. While I find it hard to recommend a film people have to watch these days, I can talk endlessly about why
47
FILM INDUSTRY
people should watch Fleabag [Amazon], or Dead to Me [Netflix]. The viewing habits have changed and the industry has adapted to meet that change. It has to or we wouldn’t be sitting here talking today.” China, of course, has been the story of the film industry for the past 20 years, coming from virtually nothing to establish itself as the world’s second-largest market, with annual box office returns now of around US$9 billion and with eyes on knocking North America (US$11.9 billion) from the perch it has held onto since cinema first became a thing. But in this regard Lee readily admits to being just like everyone else – unsure of what is going on in China, given the ongoing Donald Trump-Xi Jinping trade war. “Nobody seems to know right now,” says Lee. “It’s just up in the air. I only know what I read, same as everyone. So I guess we all just have to wait and see.”
48
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
MARK YOUR CALENDAR Towards a Water-Smart Hong Kong - September 10 When compared to other cities in the world, how is Hong Kong doing in terms of water consumption? How well do we manage our water use? How much water does each Hong Kong household use compared to that in other cities? Is our water infrastructure smart enough? With the business sector consuming a third of Hong Kong’s fresh water, what role can businesses play in conserving water?
10
Independent think tank Civic Exchange will share their recent findings on Hong Kong’s water consumption pattern and impact, as part of a research project on modernizing Hong Kong’s water management policy. This project examines the implications of increasing pressures on our fresh water supply, due to population and economic growth as well as competition for water resources in the Pearl River Delta region.
Venue: AmCham 1904 Bank of America Tower 12 Harcourt Road Central, Hong Kong
Time: 12pm - 1.45pm
Tickets: Member: HK$300 Non-member: HK$480
Future Proofing the US-China Relationship - September 20 In the four decades since China began opening its economy, we have navigated past waves of US engagement followed by confrontation, of guarded optimism subsiding into grim troughs of skepticism. Sino-US ties now deliver impact at a truly global level. How that relationship unfolds over the next 40 years will likely have a profound impact on every corner of our planet. Are we locked into the narrative of a dominant US yielding to a resurgent new power? Or will a more complex interplay of trade, politics and societal changes lead us to write new and unexpected chapters in the story?
20
Topics this conference will address: • Greater Bay Area – Opportunity or marketing hype? • The next 40 years of US-China relationship • 5G: Myths & realities • Boom or bust – Is the China model sustainable? Venue: Island Ballroom 5/F Island Shangri-La Hotel Pacific Place Hong Kong
Time: 8.15am - 4.30pm
Tickets: Member: HK$2,300 Non-member: HK$2,700 Corporate table: HK$25,000
Malaysia Boleh! Consul General to Hong Kong speaks at AmCham September 25
25 AmChamHK
AmCham is honored to host Malaysia’s Consul General to Hong Kong and Macau Yap Wei Sin, who will provide a briefing on his country’s economic and trade prospects. Malaysia received a record 21.7 billion ringgit (US$5.3 billion) of foreign direct investment in the first quarter of this year, almost double the amount from a year earlier, as a slew of positive economic indicators shone through the gloom of US-China trade tensions to highlight the continued growth and opportunity the country and wider region offer. As for Hong Kong: the city’s importance as a financial and commercial hub not just for China but for the entire region is well-illustrated by Malaysia. Hong Kong accounted for almost a fifth of last year’s net FDI flows, and remained the biggest source of funds from Asia as investors focused on the country’s services sector. At year’s end, Singapore, Japan and Hong Kong were the top sources for FDI position. Venue: AmCham 1904 Bank of America Tower 12 Harcourt Road Central, Hong Kong
7-8 • 2019
Time: 12pm - 2pm
Tickets: Member: HK$300 Non-member: HK$480
49
The colorful front cover from October 1994, a special issue on the China infrastructure boom, features a work by Zhao Ming, courtesy of China Oil Painting Ltd.
50
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
51
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019
52
AmChamHK
7-8 • 2019