2
Anja sto)erg: Ro#erdam University of Applied Sciences, School of Social Work, Netherlands j.stofberg@hr.nl
Steven Howle3: Roehampton University, UK s.howlett@roehampton.ac.uk Silvia Cannonieri: Ciessevi Milano, Italy cannonieri@ciessevi.org Ole Madsen: CFSA, Denmark ocm@frivllighed.dk Angel Sola: Cibervoluntarios FoundaGon, Spain angel.sola@cibervoluntarios.org
3
CHAPTERS 1.‐ INTRODUCTION ….………………………………………………………………………..….………….….6 2.‐ Linking Volunteering MoGvaGon and RecogniGon ……………………….………………15 3.‐ Learning through Volunteering …………………………………………………….………………19 4.‐ Analysing Learning Needs ………….…………………………………………………………………27 5.‐ Learning OpportuniGes ………….……………………………………………………………..…..…34 Appendix A Tool descripGon sheets ………….……………………………….………46 Appendix B Web resources ………….……………………………………………….……61 Appendix C Glossary ………….………………………………………………………………64 Appendix D An InspiraGonal Checklist ………….…………………………..………66
4
5
Introducing INVEST
The INVEST (INvesGng in your Volunteers by creaGng EducaGonal opportuniGes Small scale and Tailor made) project is a European project funded by the European Commission through the Lifelong Learning Programme under the acGon Grundtvig Learning Partnership. The overall aim of this learning partnership was to pool a wide variety of resources and experiences within our different organisaGons to enhance the learning opportuniGes of volunteers. Our main objecGve was to apply different methods and tools for facilitaGng these educaGonal opportuniGes and share the experiments and experiences among the partners. By applying a "learning by doing" approach we intend to encourage our volunteers into making more of the voluntary work they perform, raising their awareness of the many competences and skills they are obtaining during the process and insGl a sense of fun in working on
serious lifelong learning skills which they can apply in many different contexts and in their working life. In order to support personal development, we wished to sGmulate (among others) volunteers to work on their (extended) CVs, more specifically by developing a poraolio. Poraolios provide opportuniGes to sGmulate people to reflect on experiences and achievements and get to grips with assessing their own capabiliGes and connecGng this to their ambiGons. Overall the project is meant to encourage volunteers to get the most out of their volunteering experience and also focus on the learning possibiliGes and their employment prospects, besides driving their learning needs towards more learning opportuniGes and / or further / higher educaGon pathways. Poraolio work is, moreover, one step away from the recent developments towards an e‐poraolio.
6
Ro#erdam University (HR) is one of the major UniversiGes of Applied Sciences in the Netherlands with currently 30,000 students working on their professional future. The university has 11 schools, offering more than 80 graduate and undergraduate programmes in 7 fields: art, technology, media and informaGon technology, health, behaviour and society, engineering, educaGon, and business. The INVEST project is run by the School of Social Work which offers four accredited course programmes and a professional master programme of Urban EducaGon. Within the school students are prepared for job roles in which they design and organise programmes and projects which invite people to parGcipate in cultural and social exchange. The purpose of the Cultural Social Work programme is to provide students with the foundaGons of the cultural and social work profession which guides and supports people in giving shape to their lives in the context of culture and our increasingly complex society. The majority of students develop educaGonal acGviGes of any kind for (disadvantaged) groups and those with specific needs and deliver those tailor‐made courses during their work placements in the Ro#erdam organisaGons, but also abroad. Many of these students are ready to coordinate volunteering programmes and acGviGes upon graduaGon.
Website: www.hogeschoolro#erdam.nl
Volunteering context in the Netherlands In the Netherlands voluntary work is mainly the responsibility of local governments. Under the Dutch Social Support Act municipaliGes have the task of deciding on their own volunteering policy based on the five core funcGons as defined by the Ministry of Health, Welfare and Sport. The five core funcGons are the following: translaGng social developments, creaGng connecGons, strengthening, expanding and anchoring. The Ministry of Health, Welfare and Sport defines “parGcipaGon” of all ciGzens as the major goal of its policy on volunteering. As such, it plays an important role in a#aining social inclusion goals. The city of Ro#erdam for example decided to create approximately 4,000 volunteering jobs for people with poor chances on the labour market on an annual basis. Through this iniGaGve people are taken out of their socially isolated posiGons and are offered opportuniGes to start developing new competences which can increase their self‐esteem, and subsequently their chances on the labour market, as individual training and coaching is an integral part of the iniGaGve. In this way these volunteers are empowered by staff involved in volunteering organisaGons who invest in their personal development.
7
Over 5.6 million Dutch people are acGve in the voluntary sector. Society as a whole benefits from their unpaid acGviGes, so in general the idea is that volunteers deserve professional a#enGon and support by offering them learning opportuniGes to develop themselves. At the same Gme the trend is that increasingly higher demands are being made on volunteers, partly as a result of the economic crisis. CFSA is the naGonal knowledge centre of voluntary work in Denmark. The Centre was established in 1992 as a self‐governing insGtuGon under the Ministry of Social Affairs, to promote and support the development of volunteering in Denmark. The status of the centre as an “independent” insGtuGon and its professional focus and neutrality in relaGon to poliGcal and organisaGonal interests allows the centre to network and dialogue across the structural, organisaGonal and poliGcal boundaries. The funding of the centre comes from government grants. The centre works for an independent and diverse voluntary sector which contributes to the development of the welfare society in interacGon with public authoriGes and private companies. Its aim is to support and develop the volunteering area and to gather knowledge based on pracGce and research. CFSA offers a range of services to support volunteers and voluntary organisaGons. Besides offering services to public authoriGes and others co‐operaGng with volunteer organisaGons, CFSA provides informaGon on voluntary social work for the public and the press. The main areas of acGvity are consultancy, learning and educaGon, networks and conferences, knowledge, development etc. The Volunteer Centre in Denmark has a range of educaGonal acGviGes and offers those to key persons engaged in voluntary work. The courses tend to focus on organisaGonal work, personal limits in voluntary social work, and challenges of volunteering. Moreover, CFSA offers a variety of courses which provide skills and tools that are relevant in voluntary work on all levels. An example is the courses for volunteers funded by the Danish Training Grant Programme. These courses are designed for acGve volunteers and staff employees in voluntary social organisaGons or support funcGons in relaGon thereto. Another example is The NGO Folk High School, an educaGonal programme open to all, offering qualified educaGonal opportuniGes for all actors in the voluntary social field who wish to strengthen their skills in different areas. There are no academic requirements for admi#ance and there are no exams, but the course parGcipants get a diploma as proof of a#endance. Website: h#p://www.frivillighed.dk
8
Volunteering context in Denmark In Denmark approximately 1.8 million people (approx. 40 % of the entire population over the age of 16), have participated in voluntary work at some point through the last twelve months. Even though the majority are volunteering in areas such as sport and culture, lot´s of volunteers participate also in social voluntary work (approx. 32 % of all volunteers in Denmark). Most surveys which are conducted on the issue of volunteerism in Denmark conclude that the majority of the volunteers are men. A survey produced in 2012 by The National Knowledge and Development Centre of Volunteering in Denmark on behalf of The Ministry of Social Affairs and Integration concluded that 42 % of men who participated in the survey were volunteers as opposed to only 38 % of women. Collaboration between public and voluntary organisations has become stronger throughout the last 20 years. The collaboration is beneficial for the organisations as well as the administration in the way that the organisations get financial support for rent and other necessities, as well as educational support for volunteers. The municipalities get a helping hand in the production of welfare services.
Ciessevi is a non profit organisaGon whose members are voluntary and social organizaGons based in Milan and in its province. Ciessevi has managed the Volunteering SupporGng Centre for the province of Milano since 1998. Volunteering SupporGng Centres (CSV) are a NaGonal Network. They were provided for the Italian law on volunteering with the goal to support and qualify volunteer organizaGons’ acGviGes. Ciessevi offers the following acGviGes and services: consultancy, organisaGon of training courses, documentaGon, study and research, communicaGon, informaGon, logisGcal support and events organizaGon. Ciessevi believes that volunteering promotes acGve ciGzenship, solidarity, subsidiarity, human rights, inclusion and social cohesion. Ciessevi aims to empower volunteers and voluntary organizaGons’ capacity in promoGng innovaGon and posiGve relaGonships in the local communiGes. This is done by supporGng civil society iniGaGves and by strengthening partnerships between voluntary, private and public sectors at a local, naGonal and European level. Ciessevi’s mission consists in three things: promoGng a wide volunteering culture, supporGng and qualifying volunteers and voluntary organisaGons and in making volunteers improve their capaciGes and awareness about the role they play in the society as they represent an important resource for the whole community. Ciessevi wants to support the voluntary sector to increase its visibility and its proacGve antude and also enhance management and organisaGonal competences.
9
Ciessevi’s acGviGes are addressed to: • Volunteer organisaGons for different acGviGes of consultancy, training, project planning and communicaGon; • Volunteers and people who would like to volunteer for acGviGes of informaGon and training; • Students, youth, and all ciGzens for acGviGes to promote volunteering (these acGviGes are open organised in collaboraGon with other local organizaGons); • Public and private Sector on specific projects. Website: h#p://www.ciessevi.org/
Volunteering context in Italy In Italy volunteering today is essenGally an organised phenomenon which has undergone an enormous development since the mid 1970s, following the modernizaGon and decentralizaGon of the welfare system. Since then, the phenomenon has passed through a transiGon of tradiGonal assistance services to pursue pracGces of prevenGon and social promoGon with the intent of contribuGng to remove the causes that produce marginalisaGon, degradaGon and poor quality of life. In 1991 the framework Law No. 266 defined the requisites of volunteering and the aspects that regulate the relaGonship between the VO and the public administraGon, together with the juridical recogniGon of public enGty partners. More recently, an ulGmate legiGmizaGon came about with amendments to Title V of the ConsGtuGon (ConsGtuGonal Law no.3/2001 Amendments to Title V of the ConsGtution, Art. 118 last paragraph). Volunteering of single ciGzens and organisaGons has become the object of numerous naGonal research projects and surveys. As regards to the extent of voluntary parGcipaGon, many esGmates have been provided and various studies have a#empted to define the phenomenon. All the research and public opinion poll insGtutes deal with this issue, though they generally do not share a common method, a common delimitaGon of the sector or a common definiGon. This in turn does not allow data from the various research groups to be compared. According to ABACUS and Eurisko‐IREF, there are 7 million ciGzens acGvely parGcipaGng in solidarity, while ISTAT MulGscopo indicates a figure of 4 million. Such great variaGons are due more to the inhomogeneous layout of the research rather than the different periods in which the studies were conducted. In any case, all the data highlight the evident upward trend of volunteering and, recently, even the desire towards individual volunteering. When considering the ISTAT MulGscopo data, which are of a considerable enGty considering the sample populaGon taken and the territorial distribuGon, the rate of volunteers today is 8.4% of ciGzens over 13 years of age; this means 4.1 million persons. In the province of Milan there are 40,983 volunteers acGve in formally recognized from the Local Authority Voluntary OrganisaGons. 26,307 of them volunteer regularly, and 14,676 do so occasionally. These numbers do not take into account of cultural, civil protecGon and sports volunteers. The la#er in parGcular are not considered in the NaGonal and Local StaGsGcs about volunteering.
10
The University of Roehampton is the only campus university in London, located in the south‐ west of the city, it is about 30 minutes from the West End. The university offers a self contained site for learning, teaching and working and aims to give a wide range of opportuniGes for students to get involved including volunteering but also through playing sport, or the many student socieGes. The University has a strong research profile which underpins teaching. Some 9,000 students a#end the University, 25% of whom are postgraduates. There is a cosmopolitan atmosphere, with more than 130 different naGonaliGes on campus. The history of Roehampton stretches back 170 years through four Colleges and the strong values come from this rich collegiate history, built on community, engagement and partnership. Community engagement comes through course placement requirements, but also through a strong volunteering programme run by the student union. The University recognises that engagement is a key strand of the University’s emphasis on enhancing employability. Website: h#p://www.roehampton.ac.uk
Volunteering context in United Kingdom Volunteering in the UK is mostly carried out in voluntary organisations, but volunteers can be found too in the public sector; in schools and hospitals for example. Volunteering England (which in 2013 became part of the National Council for Voluntary Organisations) define volunteering as any activity that involves spending time, unpaid, doing something that aims to benefit the environment or someone (individuals or groups) other than, or in addition to, close relatives. From this definition comes the core idea that volunteering must be a choice freely made by each individual. Volunteering is identified with a number of benefits, from community cohesion, to skills development, to service delivery, to just enjoying yourself. It is little wonder then that there are alarm bells rung – not least by policy makers – if participation rates fall. That said, volunteering rates have remained reasonably constant over the past 20 years and In 2008/09 41% of adults volunteered formally (giving unpaid help through a group, club or organisation). Given that this has been calculated to contribute an estimated £22.7 billion to the UK economy it is little wonder policy makers are interested. Although the rate has remained constant, there is some evidence of less input with the average number of hours spent volunteering per volunteer declined by 30% between 1997 and 2007. Further evidence suggests that there is a trend towards more episodic volunteering, which may also
11
dovetail into the idea that more people are volunteering for learning and skills and choosing shorter periods in a range of opportunities in order to maximise this.
Fundación Cibervoluntarios (Cybervolunteers FoundaGon) is an atypical non‐profit organizaGon made up of social entrepreneurs whose vision is to use new technologies as a means for social innovaGon and ciGzen empowerment, alleviaGng in this way social gaps. This means that the foundaGon works to increase the rights, opportuniGes and capabiliGes of each person within their environment, through the social use of technological tools and applicaGons within their reach. To achieve this goal, the FoundaGon counts on around 1,500 cybervolunteers. Curious, proacGve persons willing to learn, with a passion for sharing and enthusiasm about ICTs, who offer part of their Gme and knowledge to teach other people the possibiliGes of the use of technology tools and applicaGons to improve lives in a simple and useful way. They do this through both online and onsite courses, lectures, workshops, events… etc. They direct their acGon to groups of people that may be excluded from the informaGon society based on gender, age, professional and social environment, lack of Gme, knowledge, skills, moGvation and/or material or economic resources... and they manage to adapt the use of technological applicaGons to alleviate these social gaps at working, parGcipaGon or health levels, among others. Aper 11 years of work the foundaGon received from the hands of the Prince and Princess of Asturias a recogniGon for “the creaGon of new forms of parGcipaGon and social innovaGon in support of groups at risk of exclusion”, as well as the economic and social recogniGon of Google.org, for being one of the entiGes that are changing the world, the first and currently the only organizaGon recognized with such merit in Spain. During the last four years the FoundaGon has focused on spreading across Europe, where it has four ongoing projects, and into LaGn America, where there is already representaGon in ArgenGna, Brazil and Ecuador, and shortly in Mexico and Colombia. Website: h#p://www.cibervoluntarios.org
Volunteering context in Spain Spain has a total of 873,171 volunteers, only in the field of social acGon, of which 63.1% are women, according to a study conducted at the iniGaGve of the Ministry of Health, Social Policy and Equality released in 2011, on the occasion of the inauguraGon of the European Year of Volunteering in Madrid. According a report, enGtled "Diagnosis of Volunteers in Spain", the profile of volunteers in recent years has diversified, although it maintains a majority presence of young women. Thus, by age, the largest group corresponds to a range between 18 and 35, which accounts for 42.6%
12
of the volunteers in Spain, followed by those between 36 and 55 years, accounGng for 32.5%, and finally the 56 and older, with 22.3%. The youngest (18‐35 years) develop their acGon as volunteers in the field of leisure, social acGon and integraGon. For its part, the seniors (over 56 years) gang acGvity in the socio‐health and social acGon. The report, which has been a#ended by the Volunteer Plaaorm in Spain and the Third Sector experts and volunteers, also indicates that the average Gme devoted to voluntary acGons, within the field of social acGon, is five hours per week. There are about 30,000 non‐profit organizaGons in Spain. Over 70% of them have got volunteers. However, Spain is among the European Union countries where there is relaGvely speaking li#le volunteering. Only 15% of the Spanish populaGon volunteers, according to the Eurobarometer. In recent years figures in Spain have increased with people who volunteer in several NGOs, but spend only a short Gme in each and "converged" volunteering, i.e. ciGzens who, during an emergency situaGon, carry out voluntary acGviGes in NGOs that they had a previous relaGonship with.
Who is this booklet for?
We hope this booklet can be an inspiraGon by focusing on all the competences you are gaining as an engaged ciGzen. The booklet can be used by all people who are engaged in volunteering and especially people who are volunteer coordinators, people who have volunteered and now guide other volunteers, people who are employed within volunteer‐ involving organisaGons or people who have other responsibiliGes for volunteers or within the voluntary sector. Whether new to the role or experienced, all people working with or for volunteers will hopefully find this an easy guide to use with such issues as volunteer recogniGon, learning support or educaGonal opportuniGes. Hopefully you will find inspiraGon and a collecGon of tools, pracGcal small‐scale ideas and Gps on how to empower volunteers in your local context, whatever support structures exist in your area.
13
14
Why do people volunteer ? People volunteer for a wide variety of have struggled with social issues reasons. One of the more obvious reasons themselves usually have a parGcular why people volunteer is because they find empathy for those in a similar situaGon something they are passionate about and and will o_en wish to help out. Others want to do something good for others. who volunteer think that they are very People who volunteer in their community fortunate to live the way they do and have a personal a3achment to the area want to give something back to society, as and want to make it a be3er place for a way of balancing all the possible scales. themselves and for others. People who In fact, the reason why people volunteer may vary according to their needs and aspiraGons. There are however a number of common moGves to engage in voluntary acGviGes and research has broadly established the beneficial value that volunteering brings to the individual (as well as to society as a whole). Based on research done by Clary et al. (1998)1, six moGvaGonal categories for volunteering have been idenGfied, namely: Value, ProtecGon, Career, Social, Understanding and Enhancement. These can be interpreted as follows: • The Value moGve is concerned with expressing or acGng on important values and focuses on the welfare of others; as such it can be regarded as the most altruisGc moGve. •
The ProtecGon moGve wants to deflect from nega%ve aspects of the personality, such as guilt, boredom and isolaGon, in order to reduce negaGve feelings.
•
The Career moGve is a uGlitarian moGve concerned with furthering one’s own career prospects and gaining career‐related experience.
•
The Social moGve reacts to the social expectaGons of an individual’s circle of family, friends and acquaintances, and is about strengthening social relaGonships.
•
The Understanding moGve is concerned with learning new informaGon or skills.
•
The Enhancement moGve is concerned with enhancing posi%ve aspects of one’s personality, in contrast to the ProtecGon moGve. Enhancement is understood as self‐ realisaGon, enhancing self‐esteem and social relaGons.
1
Clary, E. G., Snyder, M., Ridge, R.D., Copeland, J., Stukas, A.A., Haugen, J. & Miene, P. (1998, June). Understanding and assessing the moGvaGons of volunteers: A funcGonal approach. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 74 (6): 1516‐30. These authors developed the so‐called Volunteer FuncGons Inventory (VFI). A central premise of the funcGonal approach is that while different people can perform the same acGons, these acGons may serve different psychological funcGons for different individuals.
15
These six moGvaGon pa#erns clearly demonstrate how much variety there is in doing voluntary work. Volunteer‐involving organisaGons which are well aware of their volunteers’ moGvaGons (by way of a well‐founded intake procedure e.g.) can adapt their matching process to this. The idea is that having volunteers perform tasks with benefits that match their primary moGves will result in a posiGve volunteer experience and in higher saGsfacGon, an outcome favourable to all involved. In order to establish volunteer moGves a standardised quesGonnaire was developed: the Volunteer FuncGons Inventory2, an instrument that generates a clear picture of what moGves are prevalent for a potenGal volunteer. Subsequently, volunteering organisaGons can select volunteer acGviGes that would be a good match, in order words find tailor made tasks and responsibiliGes. In other words, a good intake process will help to ensure that volunteers are placed in posiGons that best suit their abiliGes and interests. The investment of a relaGvely small amount of Gme and effort at the beginning of the volunteer process could return many dividends in terms of saGsfacGon and commitment of volunteers as well as Gme‐saving for the organisaGon in the longer run.
The importance of recogniGon
RecogniGon of the contribuGon they have made is not in itself a reason why people choose to volunteer. SGll, expressing appreciaGon and recognising volunteer achievements are important factors in keeping volunteers moGvated and enthusiasGc. Generally speaking, overall the need for recogniGon is very important to the majority of people. So if contribuGons are not recognised, volunteers may lose moGvaGon and in the end leave. To the volunteer, recogniGon signifies that someone noGces and someone cares. RecogniGon has mulGple funcGons beyond simple human courtesy, and successfully recognising volunteering efforts is one of the most important parts of any volunteering programme, especially in this Gme and age, as volunteer coordinators deal with a more demanding cohort of volunteers on a daily basis. Focusing energy on nurturing relaGonships with volunteers will be Gme and effort well spent. The payback will be quality volunteers who are loyal to the organisaGon and a joy to work with.
RecogniGon opGons
There are many (formal and informal) ways in which volunteer‐involving organisaGons can recognise and reward volunteers for their contribuGons. Although quite a few volunteers would appreciate recogniGon in an open and public way, for example by being given a tangible reward at a public occasion or a staff meeGng in front of their friends, not all volunteers would like that. Some volunteers would be thrilled by having their contribuGon acknowledged by being assigned to more challenging tasks and responsibiliGes, while others prefer to be rewarded by social (group) ouGngs such as lunches, special events, visits to fesGviGes etc. So when recognising volunteer contribuGons, tailor made recogniGon (and reward) to the unique needs of the volunteer involved is key. Having a diversity of recogniGon and reward opGons will enable volunteer coordinators to acknowledge accomplishments in ways 2
See Appendix A for a more detailed descripGon of this parGcular instrument.
16
appropriate to the individual volunteer as well as to the parGculars of a given situaGon. When volunteer coordinators personalise recogniGon, it will mean more to the volunteer receiving the recogniGon and sGmulate the volunteer’s moGvaGon likewise. In other words, linking recogniGon to individual moGvaGon will ensure that volunteers are recognised in ways that are meaningful to them. Obviously, an important precondiGon for a personalised recogniGon system is that a volunteer‐ involving organisaGon must have accurately idenGfied the needs of their volunteers AND kept track of possible changes in this respect.3 Needless to say, knowing your volunteers as individuals and knowing what drives them is imperaGve to making any volunteering programme a success.
It is beyond the scope of this booklet to map all the recogniGon systems available. However, a number of internet resources for volunteer recogniGon have been idenGfied and can be found in the appendix. The focus here is on one specific way to recognise volunteers and their contribuGons, namely by invesGng in them by offering them small scale and tailor made learning opportuniGes.
3
This can be done in a variety of ways, one of which can be uGlising the Volunteer FuncGons Inventory as part of the intake process.
17
18
The previous chapter outlined the many different moGves for volunteering. A number of these have an explicit or implicit link to learning. Many people volunteer because they care about issues bigger than themselves, but they end up learning new skills, improving exisGng ones and using exisGng skills in new ways, as well as finding out things about themselves that they never knew before. Simply put, volunteering is a powerful source of learning. Now let’s take a look at how learning can be defined.
What is formal learning ?
Learning that is typically provided by an educaGon or training insGtuGon, structured (in terms of learning objecGves, learning Gme or learning support) and leading to cerGficaGon. Formal learning is intenGonal from the learner’s perspecGve.
What is informal learning?
Learning that is not organised or structured in terms of goals, Gme or instrucGon. This covers skills acquired through life and work experience, for example. It is never intenGonal from the learner’s standpoint and is open referred to as learning by experience or learning through doing.
What is non‐formal learning?
Broadly, it is learning outside the formal school/vocaGonal training/university system, taking place through planned acGviGes that are not explicitly designated as learning, but which contain an important learning element (something described as semi‐structured learning). It is intenGonal from the learner’s perspecGve and involves some form of learning support. For the majority of authors non‐formal learning is rather organised and can have learning objecGves, whether it occurs at the iniGaGve of the individual or whether this happens as a by‐product of more organised acGviGes, whether or not the acGviGes themselves have learning objecGves.
What is lifelong learning ?
All learning acGviGes undertaken throughout life, with the aim of improving knowledge, skills and competences within a personal, civic, social and/or employment‐related perspecGve. Having defined learning, we can establish that the kind of learning taking place through volunteering will by and large fall under the definiGon of informal learning and when turned into intenGonal learning with some degree of learning support, it is seen as non‐formal learning. Learning throughout life is a commonsensical principle nobody will argue about, but implemenGng this in a volunteering organisaGon is sGll an innovaGve idea that has a lot of potenGal for further development. Despite an increasing interest in lifelong learning, learning is sGll not generally considered within unpaid or voluntary work, and especially older adults are not generally viewed as learners. Given the wealth of informal learning taking place through
19
volunteer work, volunteering organizaGons can fulfil a crucial role in realizing a sGmulaGng alternaGve learning environment. This specific role can well be considered in line with the EU Commission’s drive to promote strategies which make learning more accessible, strategies to bring learning opportuniGes closer to learners. Overall, at the societal level, access to learning, the capacity to acquire knowledge and competencies, and the opportunity and moGvaGon to conGnue updaGng one’s cogniGve, social and creaGve skills throughout life are the key not only to economic success, but also to individual fulfilment, and social cohesion. Knud Illeris (2004)4 states that learning is an essenGal part of human life. According to Illeris, learning is an innate skill, and the desire to learn is inherent in individuals. It is important to state that this desire to learn is inherent in individuals of all ages, across the lifespan. Although informal learning and volunteering has received li#le a#enGon from researchers5, some posiGve evidence has been established. In a study, How Volunteerism Shapes Professional Success, professional women in a leadership capacity stated they gained many leadership skills through their volunteer acGviGes6. Eighty‐three percent of parGcipants reported that they acquired, improved or developed their leadership skills due to volunteer parGcipaGon, while 78% reported improvement in their communicaGons skills.7 In another research study that drew on the experience of 546 employees in 16 businesses operaGng in the city of London, the majority of respondents reported that volunteering had developed their skills and competences across a broad range of business relevant areas. These competences were strongly related to an individual’s personal effecGveness in their work role and included communicaGon skills, coaching, adaptability and influencing and negoGaGng.8 4
Illeris, K. (2004). The three dimensions of learning. Malabar, FL: Krieger Publishing Company. Cook, S. L. (2011) : RedirecGon: Using Career Development Theory to Interpret the Volunteer AcGviGes of ReGrees. Retrieved from: h#ps://tspace.library.utoronto.ca/bitstream/1807/29690/6/Cook_Suzanne_062011_PhD_Thesis.pdf 6 Voluntary acGvity is here defined as: a voluntary‐offer‐based acGvity done without remuneraGon, which is always carried out for the benefit of a third person (not family member) or group within the frame of an organisaGon. 7 h#p://www.issuelab.org/resource/power_skills_how_volunteerism_shapes_professional_success 8 h#p://www.cityoflondon.gov.uk/NR/rdonlyres/3B227B67‐63F5‐4D18‐A406‐ 57BE8B04DD0F/0/Volunteering_The_business_case.pdf 5
20
21
A Canadian researcher focused on learning among older adults engaged in volunteer acGviGes during reGrement.9 By examining informal learning among these reGrees during their volunteer acGviGes a greater understanding of their openness to learning and their learning goals could be provided. Key finding was that cogniGve sGmulaGon, learning, and being mentally acGve were important to them. They were interested in lifelong learning through their volunteer acGviGes. They described ways in which they conGnued to learn new things and be mentally challenged. Learning that is focused on the social dimension is very powerful, providing many benefits and enabling learning through volunteering supports adults in meeGng their developmental needs for feeling connected within the self, feeling connected with others, and feeling connected with something or someone larger than the self (Sinno# & Berlanstein, 2006).10 Regardless of age, volunteering can serve as an introducGon to new professional paths or further studies. It can be an excellent way to learn more about a parGcular sector, workplace, office culture or cause. Volunteering can also offer opportuniGes for networking and meeGng people from across a diversity of communiGes, providing hands‐on opportuniGes of learning about new issues or undiscovered methods. In short, volunteering can be an excellent way to helping you develop a whole range of addiGonal skills, such as people skills (teamwork, good communicaGon, networking and empathy),management skills (leadership, use of iniGaGve, delegaGon, planning and organising) and business skills (commercial awareness and an understanding of how organisaGons operate).
9
h#ps://tspace.library.utoronto.ca/bitstream/1807/29690/6/Cook_Suzanne_062011_PhD_Thesis.pdf Sinno#, J.D., & Berlanstein, D. (2006). The importance of feeling whole: Learning to “Feel connected,” community, and adult development. In C. Hoare (Ed.), The handbook of adult development and learning (pp. 381‐406). New York: Oxford University Press.
10
22
Uncovering this learning repertoire is however not a straighaorward process: a large part of this learning is “tacit”, “unconscious”, unplanned, so open unintenGonal. Volunteers do not open recognise the fact that they are developing themselves through volunteering for all sorts of reasons. Naturally, the life trajectories of volunteers are varied and people have different needs in terms of learning, recogniGon of learning outcomes and qualificaGons, depending on their situaGons and paths. SGll, if they take the Gme to reflect on their experience, learn how to capture and idenGfy the skills developed and present that informaGon to current and future employers, this surplus value of volunteering experience can become explicit, visible and valued. By reflecGon on what was learned as a volunteer, people can add to their CV, punng down new roles, skills and abiliGes alongside qualificaGons. And this is how a volunteering organisaGon can offer learning or developmental opportuniGes to its volunteers. Although the key roles of volunteer involving organisaGons are, by and large, sGll to provide and coordinate volunteering acGviGes, these organisaGons can take it a step further, namely to provide volunteer development iniGaGves and facilitate learning opportuniGes for their volunteers. In that sense a volunteering organisaGon provides an alternaGve senng for non‐ formal (and informal) learning. The volunteer organisaGons that take learning through volunteering seriously and invest in their volunteers by providing learning opportuniGes may well have an edge over their counterparts who disregard this important aspect and therefore miss out on an interesGng instrument for volunteer engagement and retenGon. As was menGoned before, the concept of and the approach to learning through volunteering differs from one European country to another. Let’s now have a closer look at the naGonal context within two of the five parGcipaGng countries in the INVEST project, namely the Netherlands and Denmark.
23
NaGonal context: the case of the Netherlands Over 5.6 million Dutch people are acGve in the voluntary sector. Society as a whole benefits from their unpaid acGviGes, so in general the idea is that volunteers deserve professional a#enGon and support by offering them learning opportuniGes to develop themselves. At the same Gme the trend is that increasingly higher demands are being made on volunteers, partly as a result of the economic crisis. Overall, volunteers are open coached or (learning) opportuniGes are offered to exchange experiences in an informal way, sGmulaGng reflecGon and learning from each other. To support their volunteers some volunteer‐involving organisaGons award cerGficates, other organisaGons are experimenGng with portfolios, including online poraolios. NaGonally, a number of good pracGces are being developed in different parts of the country. As an example, a 10 step plan was developed in order to make recogniGon of volunteer competences more accessible and to sGmulate volunteering organisaGons to support their volunteers in this development. Another is using Europass Mobility for volunteers, a new idea that was developed by the NaGonal Europass Centre in the Netherlands and is meant to record knowledge, skills and competences.11 In April 2012 the naGonal centre for social development, MOVISIE, developed a toolkit for competence development in the volunteering sector, to provide useful materials and methods to facilitate the start of volunteers’ competence development and provide solid and pracGcal informaGon about procedures in the Netherlands for informal and formal recogniGon of volunteer experiences. NaGonal context: the case of Denmark Denmark has a strong tradiGon of volunteering. Around 1.8 million people are volunteers in Denmark which corresponds more exactly to 40 % percent of the populaGon, with around 18% of volunteers in the social field. Over the last decade there has naGonally been – due to the general crisis – a strong focus on volunteering and strengthening the sector and a strong wish to professionalise the capacity of the NGOs. This resulted in a greater demand for formal learning inside the organisaGons, but also a greater wish to get formal recogniGon for competencies gained through volunteering. Over the last two decades naGonal funding is offered to provide non‐formal learning to volunteers in social work, for instance The EducaGon Pool. Especially strengthening voluntary social work ranks high on the Danish government agenda and in October 2010 the Danish government presented a new strategy for civil society. The aim is to involve civil society and voluntary organisaGons more systemaGcally in the field of socially vulnerable people and families, a strategy that is financed by 100 million Danish kroner (15 million Euros) from public funding annually. Some of this funding is being earmarked for non‐formal learning acGviGes such as specific courses for volunteers free of charge. 11
The experiences gained in this new project can be seen in the light of new developments at the European level around Europass, leading to a European Skills Passport, a folder assembling together Europass and other documents a#esGng qualificaGons and skills, and another new document: the Europass Experience, a template enabling ciGzens to describe and record skills acquired at the workplace or during other informal and non‐formal learning experiences such as traineeships and volunteering. It is envisaged that these EU documents will become available at the end of 2013.
24
Due to this naGonal focus not only large organizaGons work with competence development in a more strategic way. Some demand that their volunteers take formal courses, but most of the organisaGons provide informal learning opportuniGes like coaching, supervision and non‐ formal training in their specific field. Smaller organisaGons tend to arrange short seminars, non‐formal courses or award their volunteers by referring them to naGonally funded courses. Denmark has a very strong tradiGon in informal and lifelong learning. Much of this is due to the influence of N.F. S. Grundtvig12 who is considered the father of the Danish Folk High School‐ movement. He fundamentally changed the views on learning, even in the Danish educaGonal system, and created the “Folkeoplysningsforbud” working only with non‐formal learning open to all ciGzens. This system has a strong presence in every community in Denmark and has led to the creaGon of a recogniGon system and a naGonally recognized e‐poraolio as well as a recogniGon system that permits recogniGon of non‐formal learning acGviGes (i.e. volunteering) in the formal educaGonal system (Realkompetencer). This iniGaGve was taken by the Minister for Children and EducaGon in collaboraGon with DAEA (a naGonal umbrella organisaGon for non‐formal adult learning in Denmark) and a wide range of NGOs in order to pave the way to get formal recogniGon of competencies gained through volunteering. 12
Grundtvig’s thoughts on schools and teaching profoundly altered the Danish school system. He considered it of great importance to educate young people on naGonal culture and history as well as teach people to take acGve part in society.
25
26
The goal of this chapter is to offer insights and tools to idenGfy and analyse the developmental needs of volunteers in such a way that they provide volunteer‐ involving organisaGons and volunteer coordinators with new and valuable ideas to shape the support, recogniGon, appreciaGon and most of all, the learning of their volunteers. With the ulGmate goal of empowering them in their competence development while they are volunteers. Over the years volunteer‐involving organisaGons have been punng into place training structures, intervenGons and courses in order to effecGvely prepare volunteers for their volunteer experience and for volunteer contribuGons that require specific skills. And many volunteering organisaGons have developed excellent training programmes (varying in types and duraGon) to support their volunteers in their acGviGes. Depending on the volunteering organisaGon’s mindset and approach toward volunteer
involvement, increasingly the realisaGon is taking shape that invesGng in volunteers by offering them (addiGonal) learning opportuniGes is an interesGng recogniGon tool to meet the new realiGes in society and people’s lives. Offering such learning opportuniGes can go a long way in making volunteers feel valued and important as well as in retaining them as volunteers. In the past nobody considered the issue of what volunteers were genng out of their volunteer involvement, but recent developments show that Gmes have definitely changed in that respect. Another ship that is taking place at this moment in Gme is the transiGon from supply‐driven training to demand‐driven training. Any learning acGviGes overall work best if they are tailored to the learners’ needs. So instead of offering a “one size fits all” workshop or programme to your volunteers, organisaGons are well advised to analyse their volunteers’ (someGmes hidden) learning needs.
Word of mouth has always been a powerful tool and in the case of volunteering it is no less strong when it comes to making a raGonal decision to commit your Gme, skills and energy as a volunteer in a parGcular organisaGon. Good news travels fast and while some organisaGons are struggling to find volunteers, others need to draw up waiGng lists! RecogniGon and the quality of support make all the difference, it appears. Each volunteer is unique. The success of any volunteer development programme is based on an understanding that individuals come in all shapes, sizes, colours and ages and have a wide range of skills and abiliGes to contribute. The challenge is how to develop appropriate and tailor made learning opportuniGes based on these individual moGvaGons, needs and preferences in order to become a tangible benefit for volunteers. The first issue is the learning format: how can this match with moGvaGons? What would best suit a volunteer’s needs? How to go about this and analyse the individual developmental needs of your volunteers? How can volunteer‐involving organisaGons arrange these learning opportuniGes, for example to serve as a sGmulaGng recogniGon tool? A number of opGons are available and some may be preferred to others, for example Gme wise13. 13
Learning opportuniGes can vary from half day workshops during week days (or in the evening) to whole day events at weekends to longer running accredited courses.
27
As an illustraGon of this, research on volunteers’ training needs carried out in Milan, Italy, among a sample of 357 volunteers and representaGves of associations, underlined some important aspects that should be considered in organising workshops for volunteers. Despite the fact that 84% of volunteers think that training is important for associaGons, 68% of volunteers regard a lack of Gme as the first and foremost reason for not a3ending programmes, followed in second place by a lack of funds (33%) and thirdly, the difficulty to find a learning opportunity that really fits their interests and needs (26%). Here are some more specific results from this survey:
a) Timing
According to the Study on Volunteering in the European Union: (h#p://ec.europa.eu/ciGzenship/pdf/doc1018_en.pdf), a large percentage of volunteers falls in the age range between 30 to 50 years old. This means that programmes should be planned in such a way that they fit well into their regular working hours. It was found that most people prefer a#ending workshops aper 6 pm. (50.6%) or during weekends (48.4%) combined with a preference for short‐term learning sessions (expressed by 43.3% of the Italian sample), lasGng 10 to 20 hours a year.
b) Methodologies
67.4% of the Italian sample prefers workshops and group work, 58.2% plenary sessions followed by a further 48.4% who likes interacGve methodologies (e.g. role playing). 22.8% prefers online training and 29.1% thinks that personal experiences of other people are very useful (peer to peer educaAon).
c) Contents
From the point of view of volunteering associaGons, workshops should mainly be aimed at: Psychological and social aspects; Project planning and fund raising; Technical and administraGve aspects.
d) Competences
Considering sop competences, 81.5% of volunteers are interested in gaining interpersonal and relaGonship competences; 66.5% are interested in growing in interpersonal communicaGon; 54.9 in management and 53.5% in problem senng and problem solving competences. There is no reason to believe that volunteers in other European countries would respond differently. All this confirms the importance of designing “tailor made” learning programmes or demand‐driven workshops. Because volunteer‐involving organisaGons, generally speaking, are not part of the adult educaGon or lifelong learning sector, it is not evident that they are well equipped for the task of easily idenGfying or analysing learning needs of their volunteers. Nor do individual volunteers on the other hand, expect or ask for any learning opportuniGes inside volunteering organisaGons as a ma#er of course.
28
29
To encourage volunteer‐involving organisaGons to take a bo3om‐up approach and have them encourage their volunteers to develop their full potenGal, here is a list of possible methods to inspire them. However, there is no easy recipe. Neither is there a best way to undertake any learning acGvity or workshop, as the nature and scope of volunteering organisaGons vary. In other words, the following suggesGons and approaches are meant to provide inspiraGon and examples and are meant to be adapted as appropriate to your own realiGes, purposes and situaGon. 1. Approach your volunteers and ask The most important resource for any (learning) acGvity with and for volunteers is to approach and involve them in the planning process from the start. This is the first , most obvious, step: acGvely and purposefully approach your volunteers and discuss ideas with them, even though this is open overlooked.
2. Introduce a volunteer wish box (or suggesGon drop box)
Open volunteers walk in and out at any Gme of the day and week, open people have loose or sca#ered appointments, open people are busy, open there is no formal (volunteer) consultaGon structure. These are all circumstances that prevent good ideas from spreading inside the organizaGon. In order not to lose this valuable input, an easily accessible soluGon is to put into place a volunteer wish box or a drop box for suggesGons. Volunteers may get good or brilliant ideas at any Gme, following an acGvity they were involved in or having read or seen something interesGng in another context, and wish to make suggesGons or pass on valuable insights in order to follow up on these ideas. Taking this unexpected input seriously, by discussing it with volunteers, may consGtute the basic idea for an effecGve workshop that fulfils volunteer needs felt at that precise point in Gme. A wish box has the added advantage of being an anonymous channel, if a volunteer chooses to stay in the background. In any volunteering organizaGon the Gp is to provide accessible ways to idenGfy developmental needs in order to turn them into flexible development programmes, wish boxes could be an ideal channel.
3. Enhance or nurture relaGonships via ongoing supervision, support and evaluaGon An important linking pin between the volunteers and the organisaGon is the volunteer coordinator. Genng to know your volunteers as individuals is one of the most important responsibiliGes of such a role. This is the person par excellence to idenGfy what (addiGonal) support and learning his / her volunteers need. Any volunteer coordinator should not only coordinate voluntary acGviGes and volunteers, but also (and more importantly) establish the right connecGon and relaGonship with his volunteers. Knowing to what they will respond posiGvely, as ways of recognizing their contribuGons and efforts, but also knowing what barriers there are towards a#ending learning acGviGes or workshops is all part of that. Following the idea of volunteering moGvaGon and adopGng a tailor made support mode towards volunteers, it is the volunteer coordinator who is in the best posiGon to keep track of changes or modificaGons in a volunteer’s moGvaGon.
30
Aper all, moGvaGon is a dynamic concept: a volunteer who started out with a social moGve may gradually evolve into one with an enhancement or understanding moGve, within a year or two. Monitoring these changes periodically is essenGal. One valuable instrument for keeping tabs on your volunteers is the annual evaluaGon talk or interview. Key aspects of a good volunteer evaluaGon system include self‐assessment, feedback from staff working with volunteers, and the volunteer's saGsfacGon in relaGon to the evaluaGon experience, allowing for feedback from the volunteer, idenGfying future roles and responsibiliGes as well as goals, and idenGfying where help (such as specific learning programmes) can be obtained to meet the goals. Most volunteers are interested in knowing the extent to which they are doing their jobs well, most volunteers want to do their best and regard evaluaGon talks as a posiGve form of recogniGon and a way to opening the path to open communicaGon about what they do. For them this is an opportunity to grow closer to staff and to receive recogniGon, coaching and counselling. Jill Friedman Fixler, a well‐known leader recognised for her innovaGve approaches to re‐ invenGng, re‐engineering, and re‐vitalizing nonprofit and public sector organisaGons, sincerely wonders if performance evaluaGons work for volunteers, and if they are moGvated by such feedback. She writes on her website14 that in a collaboraGve volunteer involving organisaGon with an adequate supervision process, volunteer performance evaluaGons are not only redundant, but out of place. Volunteers are looking for validaGon for the work that they do. To capitalize on this, why not eliminate evaluaGons and start a "valuaGon" process for volunteers, she suggests. A valuaGon le#er reinforces the behaviours that supervisors or volunteer coordinators want to culGvate, and captures the essence of the volunteer's moGvaGon. She is convinced that volunteers will appreciate the effort and the posiGve, individualised feedback.
4. Debrief a_er any learning acGvity / workshop
Any of the workshops that are organised as part of a volunteer development programme can be a springboard for further learning suggesGons, especially if a debriefing is done at the end. Not only the content of a new workshop idea can spring from this, also the ideal format (Gme wise), the style (serious / fun / interacGve / passive listening) and tone (formal/informal) can be discussed and idenGfied in order to tailor future learning opportuniGes to the volunteers’ needs. Besides, they can also encourage volunteers to seek further learning opportuniGes among themselves (peer to peer). An exchange of experiences and informaGon or moments of reflecGon among each other can heighten (unsuspected) personal skills and awareness. This in turn can lead to volunteers senng up learning acGviGes among themselves (or for other volunteers outside their own circle), all this facilitated by the volunteering organisaGon. 14
h#p://www.jffixler.com/volunteer‐valuaGon‐not‐evaluaGon
31
5. Seek inspiraGon with others On an annual basis conferences are held on the topic of volunteering. It is at those conferences that plenty of networking opportuniGes are offered. Open, by connecGng your volunteer‐ involving organizaGon with others, the odds are that you can take away valuable insights and tools that will benefit your organizaGon as well as your volunteers. Sharing and networking: trendy concepts, yes, but they can go a long way, especially if you involve your volunteers in this process. Together with your volunteers, meeGngs and interacGve sessions held naGonally or internaGonally can be powerful ways of broadening perspecGves and finding surprising soluGons to (development) issues. As new formats for informal and non‐formal learning opportuniGes are being developed on a regular basis, these will be shared and demonstrated at seminars and conferences. It is up to the volunteering organisaGon to keep abreast of these new developments and keep invesGng in staying up to date.
32
33
The INVEST project idenGfies that there are skills and competencies that every volunteer will gain from their volunteering. Skills can be different from competencies – the former tend to be an idenGfiable ability acquired where the la#er is more of a behaviour.15 Through volunteering people can develop competencies that they can then show enables them to do tasks effecGvely – whether it be in their volunteering, through volunteering in another organisaGon, in paid work or in civic life. This chapter looks at some examples of training that organisaGons may wish to add to what they already do. As the previous chapter noted, many organisaGons (though by no means all) already have well developed and structured training programmes. O_en these are determined by the issues the organisaGon is acGve in, mixed with some more procedural training. So an organisaGon that facilitates people to visit the elderly may train volunteers in how to develop a relaGonship with elderly housebound people, alongside training in more procedural ma#ers that the volunteer needs to know – such as who is in charge of compiling the work roster, paying expenses and so on. Some organisaGons may take the training further – for example the organisaGon menGoned which may give training in demenGa, so that volunteers can spot early signs, act appropriately with people with demenGa etc. Such training will help volunteers both in their work, but also more broadly. 15
See relevant literature on the difference between skills and competences, for example here: h#p://www.ecompetences.eu/2173,Competences,+skills,+jobs....html
34
But organisaGons can go further, and the INVEST project is suggesGng that organisaGons think of other training for volunteers, and that this training can be thought of two ways. The first way is training that helps to build competences. This, for example, could be training that looks not just at building a relaGonship with the organisaGons ‘clients’, but considers communicaGon more generally‐ communicaGon can be a skill, but can also be a competency when for example someone is able to show how that he can communicate well with very different audiences. Or another example may be when volunteers are taught the principles of project management in order to help organise events; from this could spring wider organisaGonal skills and the competencies of resourcefulness, flexibility and organisaGon. The second way, and linked to the first is then, idenAfying competences. Volunteers can be helped to idenGfy how their work demonstrates that they are competent at communicaGon, planning, etc., idenGfying all competences including those recognised as knowledge, skills and antudes, but also focusing on self‐image, values and traits. Volunteers can be encouraged to idenGfy how they can show they have competencies and soon they will be able to show examples, through their volunteering, of the ability to make decisions, what moGvates them, how they communicate in different situaGons, how they react to being given responsibility, how they show loyalty, can solve problems and show organisaGonal leadership. But why might organisaGons want to do this? A_er all, won’t this be an added cost when all organisaGons really want is to do is to ‘ get the job done’? There are many reasons why organisaGons might get involved, for instance: • Because the tasks you want volunteers to accomplish are varied and not always predictable. •
Because your organisaGon sees the role volunteers play in service delivery as only part of the relaGonship – your organisaGon wants to invest in volunteers as part of your organisaGonal ethos.
•
Because you want volunteers to idenGfy new competencies – for example if you are a university which gets involved in volunteering, service learning or community parGcipaGon at least in part to develop volunteers (likely to be your students).
•
Because you see invesGng in volunteering as a way to posiGon your organisaGon to a#ract the best people to volunteer with you.
Tools for Volunteering Competencies This booklet takes you on a journey to inspire your volunteers to reap as many of the benefits of life‐long learning as they can get from volunteering. We assume that if you have read the introducGon then you have an idea of the booklet is leading you along that path. But the booklet can be accessed in parts, you may have come straight to this chapter because your specific interest is to find out about tools and techniques developed for idenGfying competences.
35
But to re‐cap, it is the intenGon to help volunteer organisers and managers and volunteer involving organisaGons to help their volunteers access, explore and use the learning they have absorbed while they have been working with your organisaGon. The chapter on moGvaGons (see chapter 2) urged you to explore with your volunteers why they parGcipated, to be#er match them to tasks, but also to help volunteers access the opportuniGes that will help them in future. We began from the assumpGon that volunteering offers a ‘win‐win’ scenario. Volunteers may have decided to parGcipate with learning high on their agenda. This may be, for example, someone at the beginning of a career who views volunteering as a way to gain experience. It may be someone changing careers who sees parGcipaGon the same way. It could be someone who volunteers in a subject simply because that parGcipaGon offers a way to access learning that is a pleasure – for example volunteering in a museum. Or it may be that learning is incidental – a volunteer performs a task and is almost unaware that learning is also taking place. So far (see Chapter 4 Analysing Learning Needs) we have suggested some simple ways to ensure that the support volunteers receive and the access they have to learning opportuniGes can help enhance the impact. It takes training to the next level, not simply learning ‘to do the job’, but learning as a part of parGcipaGon, and one that can integrate the experience of learning and reflecGon with other aspects of a volunteer’s life. The quesGon for this chapter then becomes, how do we capture that learning? What is the range of tools that are available to help organisaGons and volunteers uncover the types of learning that have happened? We would like to stress that the methods and tools we have looked at should not just been seen in terms of employability. At the Gme of wriGng employment, especially for young people in Europe is one that presents too few jobs and opportuniGes. As a result volunteering is open talked of in terms of employability. But we want to envelope that in life‐long learning. Volunteering has a role to play in helping people learn skills and competencies for paid employment; but it also has a role in being the vehicle for learning just for the pleasure of learning. Broadly speaking, in our look at what is available, we see a pa3ern of four types of tool. These are: • Those that work to value and reward volunteers •
Those that sGmulate an awareness of volunteers’ personal learning
•
Those that idenGfy personal competences to support steps towards recogniGon of skills and
•
Those that seek to transfer volunteer competences to finding a job or training.
36
The tools are listed in the table at the end of this chapter, and links are provided to them. We are not going to describe each tool, but rather we will give the reader a flavour of what set of resources might be helpful to you in looking to support your volunteers. Clearly there is overlap between these categories. One of the key aspects is how formal or informal your organisaGon and your volunteers want the process to be that they engage with. There are also various ways we can represent the tools. We have presented these as a form of progression from valuing volunteering to the concrete idenGficaGon and validaGon of skills. We have also characterised this as a steady increase in commitment to learning. We are aware of the inadequacy of this; a volunteer parGcipaGng in a knowledge day, or volunteering at a museum to saGsfy a personal desire for knowledge may be as commi#ed to learning as a volunteer looking to complete a poraolio to showcase their transferable skills. What we mean is that if you are supporGng a volunteer who is parGcipaGng in your organisaGon to gain something like a Europass there will be a commitment needed to see that process through, whereas a learning day can be a much more informal one‐off event. We found that the tools we looked at are, by and large, suitable for most volunteers. Some are meant explicitly for school age children (and therefore in the context of this exercise can be seen as capturing the idea of life‐long learning and a young age), but many are equally suitable for all volunteers. The caveat to this is that using some of these tools with for example immigrants might need extra support form organisaGons to help with languages.16
Valuing and rewarding volunteers
These tools are the ones to look at if you are incorporaGng the idea of learning as a way of giving volunteers a richer experience within the organisaGon. These include innovaGve schemes like the ‘Andalusian volunteering card’ and the ‘Solidarity Passport’ that are found in Spain (see table and links). These act to recognise and reward volunteers and although the connecGon with learning may seem tenuous, it is one way in which volunteers have ‘proof’ of their parGcipaGon. Should you or your volunteers want more concrete evidence of parGcular tasks or skills then one of the other tools (see below) may be more useful. But this kind of card is relaGvely low cost and low input but serves to show others that a person is volunteering to change their community. AlternaGvely there are events like master classes, or knowledge days which do a number of things. They show volunteers that they are valued and, again act as a form of reward. They do not need to be expensive, but they do demonstrate a willingness on the part of organisaGons to plan and invest in special events for volunteers. An example of a knowledge day is genng together people who have an interest in the work of an organisaGon – maybe one that works in a parGcular neighbourhood that has a diverse ethnic background. The knowledge day could include volunteers and ‘clients’ of the organisaGon and may be about an aspect of work. But the day could also include some form of cultural awareness and maybe finish with cooking from the various communiGes represented. That way there is both a social aspect but also 16
Plus, because this is a European search, partners found tools in their own languages. We describe them here assuming they will be of most use to naGve speakers, but that anything of parGcular interest might spur organisaGons to translate tools that they can then use.
37
38
learning about other cultures.This form of unplanned or general learning may not be the sole reason for a#ending an event, but is a way to encourage learning through an organised event. A concrete example is a museum which every year before the start of the busy summer period gathers its volunteers together to talk through new artefacts acquired for display and new procedures within the museum. The event though is also a chance for the museum director to deliver a lecture on the new artefacts. The idea is that volunteers get to know about what is in the museum, but the lecture goes beyond what any one volunteer would need to know about the museums contents. In fact, the volunteers get a free lecture from a respected historian and they add to their knowledge.
SGmulating awareness of volunteers’ personal learning
Now we step up a gear and move from the idea that volunteer learn simply through parGcipaGon but without always being conscious of that learning. The next stage is how organisaGons can sGmulate volunteers to be aware of their learning and help develop the process of learning. Once again we have noted a few examples of how this may happen and tools that can help – the links to which appear in the table below. In fact, we consider this to be relaGvely easy and low cost because what we have idenGfied is that learning can be sGmulated just by examining the work organisaGons do already crystallizing the learning aspect. Most organisaGons are keen to know what moGvates volunteers to join them. It may be the case that an organisaGon will take on board any volunteer, but even then, managing volunteers will be enhanced if an organisaGon knows why someone wants to volunteer. So why not ask them? QuesGonnaires are available to help (see below), and something like the Volunteers FuncGons Inventory (VFI) can give a broad idea whether someone is volunteering because they want to learn skills, or because they want a new social experience. Sounds simple – and it is. It may be that the obvious quesGon is ‘just ask them’. SomeGmes people don’t know, or can’t arGculate why they want to join and so a tool like VFI can help. Aper all, if an organisaGon places a volunteer who wants social contact in a role archiving, on their own, in a dusty basement, how likely is it that this volunteer will be saGsfied and stay? Helping idenGfy moGvaGons can lead on to idenGfying a) how to saGsfy these moGvaGons and b) how a volunteer might want to develop himself both in his role at the organisaGon, but also as a learner. Following on from this are a set of volunteer management procedures that again can have a learning aspect. It is increasingly common that volunteers have supervision in their role, and here is a chance to review tasks, accomplishments and look for where assistance for development and learning could be given. In our review of pracGces we note that supervision can play a role in helping idenGfy learning and that this can be moved on a step into mentoring and coaching. We characterised the type of learning as moving from the previous secGon’s (see above) unintenGonal learning to intenGonal, planned and focussed learning. But we also noted that this is not a didacGc relaGonship, such an approach to helping volunteers learn is empowering for volunteers. Of the tools we suggest (and list in the table below) for this we looked at examples such as the master class and knowledge days (as above where this was used to introduce unintenGonal learning, so it can be focussed on intenGonal learning); but we also want to draw a#enGon to tools such as the on‐line e‐learning plaaorms where training
39
can take place via virtual educaGon and the Dutch example of City trainers which facilitate young volunteers into sports opportuniGes in their communiGes. Master classes and the knowledge day ideas noted above can also be used to sGmulate volunteers’ awareness of their own learning. Indeed, rather than a day that results in unfocused, unplanned and unconscious learning, master classes and knowledge days could be organised with the specific intenGon of introducing volunteers to new subjects or new ways of learning. From Denmark comes a resource that is extremely useful to enable a fun way to explore personal development and learning for volunteers by way of success stories. At the same Gme it allows ways of accessing feedback from volunteers to the organisaGons – a useful way to combine developing volunteers with checking how the organisaGons is measuring up to volunteers’ expectaGons. These tools take support for volunteers beyond the first stage of unconscious learning, through the beginnings of reflecGon and help to empower volunteers to take control of personal development and learning. The next rung of the ladder changes direcGon slightly. Although the next set of tools support the volunteers’ learning, they are parGcularly useful to idenGfy competences and begin the process of having skills and competences recognised. IdenGfying volunteer personal competences to support steps towards recogniGon. While any of the tools we have categorized under this heading would be generally useful, they are parGcularly good for using with volunteers to help idenGfy skills and competences that can be demonstrated to employers. Volunteering affords parGcipants the chance to learn a great many skills and competences that are in demand in the paid labour market. SomeGmes volunteers are moGvated to volunteer knowing that it will help their CV, but not sure how. The previous secGon has some tools that can help volunteer managers support volunteers to idenGfy development and learning needs. This secGon deals with more fine‐grain tools that help volunteer to think through what skills and competences they have developed in their volunteering. We have already noted that volunteers may be unaware that the skills they develop when volunteering are transferable and could help them secure a paid post if used well on a CV. Quite simply, many volunteers are unaware that their parGcipaGon is imbuing them with a range of transferable skills and competencies. CH‐Q is a method for recogniGon of competences designed to be applied in a training situaGon . It is therefore a tool which may be more suitable for organisaGons that have a structure that can organise and deliver training. The developers of this method parGcularly draw a#enGon to its use with students and the unemployed, but also with employees, because this tool was developed to help people think about future steps in their career. Equally however, the tool has been recommended for refugees, helping women who have been out of the paid (and unpaid) labour market to once again engage with thinking about career development. The tool is also marketed as being suitable for volunteers. The developers argue that, by going through training, parGcipants will be be#er moGvated, they will be more conscious of their career path and have learned how to turn the idenGficaGon of competencies into material they can use in their CVs.
40
The tool works through being a trainer led event where parGcipants use a range of techniques such as using photos of good memories to prompt discussion of qualiGes and competencies, interviews with family, friends and colleagues about qualiGes. The result is the producGon of a poraolio that gives an overview of competences acquired through formal and informal learning. Many tools use a similar idea with a poraolio being the outcome. What may be of interest is then the degree to which the process is guided by organisaGons for volunteers. In this instance a cerGfied CH‐Q trainer is needed as is the payment of a licence fee to use the tool. The Assessing Voluntary Experiences (AVE) tool has some similariGes. It starts by asking volunteers to reflect on why they came to be volunteers, what are the rewards they feel they get and what have been the challenges. Then it looks at their educaGon and training to date and asks them to sum up what those experiences mean to them in terms of skills gained and competencies achieved. It then asks volunteers to reflect on their volunteering. The tool is set out to lead volunteers through a set of competencies. These have been mapped against competencies most open outlined by employers and for vocaGonal style awards. The task for the volunteer is to reflect on how their volunteering role matches these competencies. The competences cover aspects of communicaGon, administraGon, markeGng, organisaGon, fundraising, negoGaGon, decision making, being proacGve among others. The tool offers a summary sheet for the volunteer to list the skills and competencies achieved and examples of work done to achieve them. The volunteer then invites their volunteer manager to sign the sheet as evidence that the volunteer has performed these tasks. The result of working through this exercise is an acGon plan (what acGviGes would you need to look for now in order to enhance and develop these skills?), they have skills listed that they can incorporate into their CV and evidence that they performed these tasks. This tool has several strengths, it is in English, it would suit any volunteer – old, young, whatever background and it is free. Working through the booklet results in a poraolio. It is also less formal which may suit organisaGons – and volunteers – that do not wish to get drawn into a formal validaGon process. But that is also its weakness. While providing a good reflecGve tool, the skills and competences are not validated. Volunteers and organisaGons that are looking to link into formal validaGon will need to look for different tools (see below). The tool is designed in such a way that a volunteer can work through it by himself. However, some volunteers, for example those with language difficulGes or those that lack some confidence might need some support from the volunteer coordinator. Other tools that do similar jobs exist across Europe, and we encourage you to follow the links in the table below to review them in more detail to decide which may be of more use to your volunteers. The Toolkit Competence Development Volunteering Sector developed by MOVISIE, an organisaGon with specialist knowledge in moGvaGng, supporGng and development of volunteers provides a range of resources. These include checklists and guidelines which outline skills and competences gained though volunteering. Although it deals with steps for formal recogniGon in the Netherlands, the tools can be used to help volunteers idenGfy skills whether or not a system exists for formal recogniGon. Similarly the STAR format tool takes volunteers through a pracGcal strategy that highlights the ability to accomplish tasks and goals and can therefore be used as evidence for employers of competences gained.
41
The RecogniAon 10 steps programme provides another variaGon on this. Developed by a scouGng organisaGon in the Netherlands it provides 10 steps to uncover skills and competences ready for eventual recogniGon. It should be clear by now that there is a plethora of tools available which assist in reflecGng on and idenGfying skills. We believe that although some tools work towards formal recogniGon which may only be relevant in the country of origin of the toolkit, there is value in using these tools to help volunteers increase awareness of the learning and skills they have developed regardless of whether they get these formally recognised. As for which to use, a lot will depend on how much support volunteers need. Many of the tools reviewed so far work best when organisaGons assist volunteers. Where volunteers can work autonomously, the poraolio is a good way to keep a conGnuous record of development. A good plan could be to use a combinaGon of resources; for example using the Assessing Voluntary Experiences Toolkit to idenGfy skills that may be added into poraolios. But the development of e‐poraolios is such that most help volunteers through the whole process. Many organisaGons – from universiGes to government departments ‐ have invested in poraolio templates. It is worth checking with local volunteer support agencies or maybe local universiGes to see if a poraolio is available that volunteers can use. But we would draw your a#enGon to two examples which characterise how poraolios can help explore, capture and document learning. The e‐poraolio created by the Danish Ministry of Children and EducaGon and the ‘Invest in Volunteers’ poraolio created in the Netherlands (see links of table below) show the work involved and the kind of commitment needed. The European Poraolio for Youth Leaders and Youth Workers provides another example. This one is Europe wide and focused on non‐formal educaGon, learning and youth work, to help youth workers and leaders expound on their skills. Like all poraolios it provides a list of skills and asks for reflecGons and assessment of what level the parGcipant feels they are at. It asks for reflecGons of the skills that have been applied and what evidence is available to show that the skill has been demonstrated. The European Youth Pass is another example again showing how to reflect upon non‐formal learning but specifically supporGng the employability of younger people aged 16‐30 years old. The European Mobility document records skills obtained in another country. There are many, many poraolios available, too many to review all of them. But we want to stress the usefulness to applying these to volunteers and argue that the examples we have linked can be seen as templates to use in full or part to support volunteer reflecGon.
Transfer of volunteer competences to find a job or training
This is our final step and is the one in which the competences gained are recognised. In some ways therefore this is very much a ‘local’ step. This depends on the different naGonal frameworks about competences recogniGon. The differences between European countries are set out in the European Inventory 2010 reports, describing the systems for ValidaGon of Non‐ formal and Informal Learning (European Inventory17), which illustrates the present different levels of development in Europe. As can be seen in the table we reproduce below, according to the European Inventory 2010 Report, the systems for validaGon of non‐formal and informal 17
Can be accessed via: hPp://www.cedefop.europa.eu/EN/about‐cedefop/projects/validaAon‐of‐non‐ formal‐and‐informal‐learning/european‐inventory‐scope.aspx )
42
learning present different levels of development in Europe. So if you are in Finland, France, Netherlands, Norway and Portugal you will recognise they have a high level of development of ways to validate non‐formal and informal learning. Denmark, Germany, Romania, Spain, Sweden, UK are also well versed in the idea of validaGon, but do not have the range of methods of the aforemenGoned countries. Austria, Belgium, Czech Republic, Estonia, Iceland, Italy, Ireland, Liechtenstein, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Slovakia, Slovenia and Bulgaria, CroaGa, Cyprus, Greece, Latvia, Malta, Poland, Hungary are not so familiar with the validaGon of informal learning. Whereas the tools above can be used to reflect upon and arGculate competences and learning, if volunteers want to have these formally recognised, the chances are that this needs to be done in the country where the volunteer is. However, there are some Europe‐wide publicaGons that can be consulted. For example the European Guidelines ValidaGon tool is a comprehensive document outlining how naGonal and local systems can be developed to be#er reflect and support competence recogniGon. Perhaps of more immediate use is the Europass, this is a document where knowledge and skills are recorded and which is recognised across Europe – a useful way to take competences from one country to another.
43
44
45
46
http://www.leidsevrijwilligersacademie.nl/ paul@i-doe.nl
http://www.uma.es/oficina-voluntariado/cms/menu/programas/pasaporte-solidario/
47
http://www.juntadeandalucia.es/administracionlocalyrelacionesinstitucionales/cms/ocms/portal/ Voluntariado/ContenidosEspecificos/carnevoluntarios.html
http://www.rico.com.au/training/life_skills/supervision.htm http://www.frivillighed.dk/Webnodes/da/Web/Public/Publikationer/Frivilligfronten/Supervision+s om+metode+i+frivilligt+socialt+arbejde
48
http://gullestrup.dk/fakta-helhedsplanen/det-er-en-aftale/mentorprojekt/ http://www.vejledning.net/Sider/Projekter/Projekt%207.1/Undervisningshaefte_1_7.pdf http://www.sheffield.ac.uk/polopoly_fs/1.110468!/file/cipd_mentoring_factsheet.pdf http://www.une.edu.au/od/files/mentoringpresentation.pdf
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UY75MQte4RU
49
http://www.csev.org/en_GB/home http://www.csev.org/ultimos-proyectos;jsessionid=50B3CD49439D276DC9DB47B2C66BCF13
http://www.serviceleader.org/virtual
http://www.whatisorange.org/orangeleaders/blog/?p=4733
50
http://www.lederweb.dk/Strategi/Organisationsudvikling/Artikel/79550/Om-AppreciativeInquiry---succeshistorier-som-udviklingsressource http://www.pelerei.com/pdf/articles/Pelerei_Storytelling-at-the-Heart-of-AppreciativeInquiry.pdf http://appreciativeinquiry.case.edu/
http://www.outofservice.com/bigfive/
51
www.citytrainers.nl
r.bieckmann@s-hertogenbosch.nl
http://www.fetzer.org/sites/default/files/images/stories/pdf/selfmeasures/HELPING_OTHERS.pdf
52
http://www.ivr.org.uk/images/stories/Institute-of-VolunteeringResearch/MigratedResources/Documents/A/Assessing_Voluntary_Experiences_Sept_06.pdf
http://www.euroguidance.nl/uploads/CHQ%20loopbaanbegeleiders%20MKB%20v2_20120320114239.pdf
http://ec.europa.eu/dgs/education_culture/consult/vnfil/chq_en.pdf or via : info@ch-q.ch
53
https://minkompetencemappe.dk/Default.aspx
http://www.ug.dk/Programmes.aspx
http://www.investereninvrijwilligers.nl/ Contact via e-mail: info@arcon.nl
54
www.coe.int Weblink to the portfolio: http://www.coe.int/t/dg4/youth/Source/Resources/Portfolio/Portfolio_en.pdf To order a paper copy: youthportfolio@coe.int
http://www.ciessevi.org/servizi/promozione/scuola-volontariato/il-passaporto-del-volontariato
55
http://www.movisie.nl/140525/def/home/publicaties/publicaties/toolkit_competentieontwikkelin g_vrijwilligerswerk/ Contact the information desk at: Tel: +31(0)307892112 E-mail: kennislijn@movisie.nl
http://careerweb.leeds.ac.uk/info/19/cvs/216/star_method http://www.drexel.edu/scdc/resources/STAR%20Method.pdf
56
http://www.valuenetwork.org.uk/Documents%20for%20Website/Conference/Powerpoints/Reco gnition%20in%2010%20steps%20JoPeeters.pdf Contact via: J.Peeters@scoutinggelderland.nl
https://www.youthpass.eu/en/youthpass/ https://www.youthpass.eu/en/youthpass/guide/
57
http://prezi.com/a3h5jofugwyd/recognition-workshop-europass-mobility-for-volunteers/
58
Weblink to document: http://www.cedefop.europa.eu/EN/publications/5059.aspx Via CEDEFOP: http://www.cedefop.europa.eu/EN/
59
60
Volunteer MoGvaGon and RecogniGon Volunteers have different moGvaGonal styles. Tapping into volunteer’s individual moGvaGon increases his or her level of engagement, success, and impact in volunteering. This tool is designed to assess moGvaGonal styles and idenGfy types of volunteer posiGons matching those styles. h#p://www.jffixler.com/files/MoGvaGonal_Analysis.pdf This tool is designed to help develop effecGve interview quesGons to use when matching candidates to volunteer posiGons. h#p://www.jffixler.com/files/Interview_QuesGons.pdf The Individual Volunteer Plan (IVP) is a tool designed to customize a volunteer engagement career to meet both the volunteer's aspiraGons and the organizaGon's needs. h#p://www.jffixler.com/files/Individual_Volunteer_Plan_IVP.pdf Way to go: ideas for volunteer recogniGon. h#p://www.lsuagcenter.com/mcms/relatedfiles/%7Bf20da153‐16f7‐45da‐a4f8‐ 1aac5cebfcc4%7D/way+to+go+recogniGon+guidemargin.pdf Discussing two basic types of recogniGon: extrinsic and intrinsic. h#p://www.worldvolunteerweb.org/resources/how‐to‐guides/manage‐ volunteers/doc/recognizing‐volunteers.html Volunteering resources from Canada h#p://www.nald.ca/literacybasics/volunt/profile/01.htm
Learning Needs Analysis instruments Australian example of online volunteer learning needs survey (for a nature‐based visiGng programme). h#p://www.jobssouthwest.com.au/welcome/index.php?opGon=com_content&view=arGcle&i d=254&Itemid=237 An evaluaGon form for the monitoring of volunteers, either to be used for volunteer‐involving organizaGons or as a self‐assessment form for volunteers themselves. h#p://www.volunteertoday.com/PDF/VOLUNTEER%20PERFORMANCE%20EVALUATION.pdf
61
Volunteer Workshop Ideas A selecGon of tools ranging from icebreakers and group energizers to orientaGon, including arGcles, videos, (electronic) books and internet resources, from around the world h#p://www.energizeinc.com/art/subj/train.html From Volunteering Australia: free skills, training and educaGonal resources for volunteers, volunteer coordinators, trainers and not‐for‐profit organisaGons. h#p://www.volunteeringaustralia.org/Skills‐and‐Training/‐Training‐skills‐resources.asp Also from Volunteering Australia: what every volunteer needs: a mix of informaGon, training and educaGon. h#p://www.volunteeringaustralia.org/files/ID8VYL83PC/What%20every%20volunteer%20nee ds%20final_280208.pdf Again, from Volunteering Australia: for trainers, volunteer‐ involving organisaGons wanGng to develop conGnuous improvement strategies in workshops. h#p://www.volunteeringaustralia.org/Skills‐and‐Training/‐Training‐skills‐resources/EvaluaGng‐ Volunteer‐Training‐Toolkit.asp Mapping funcGons of volunteer training, inducGon and further training. h#p://www.acGvelink.ie/node/803 A valuable resource for training packages and assessment is the Australian site: www.cshisc.com.au
Experiences from the INVEST partnership Here is a visual recording and the final video of the INVEST partners, staff and learners, expressing what they have learned from the INVEST project: h#p://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cw0bq44awTI
62
63
64
65
What about learning opportuniGes in your organisaGon? YES 1.
Our volunteer coordinators keep in touch with all volunteers so that we know pretty well what their learning needs are.
2.
We have a so-called wish box in which any volunteer can drop a(n) (anonymous) suggestion for more learning opportunities and workshops. We have good and transparent methods for announcing and publicizing our learning opportunities to all our volunteers.
3. 4.
We can offer workshops to interested volunteers on a regular basis.
5.
We have a clear understanding of the motives for volunteering inside our organisation and act upon this by offering tailor made learning opportunites to those volunteers with learning motives. We are always open to suggestions for workshops coming from volunteers.
6. 7. 8. 9.
Written descriptions of various types of learning events and workshops for volunteers are available in digital and hard-copy format. We have a clear operational plan in our organisation for volunteers to apply for learning events and all volunteers are aware of that. Each year new concepts for workshops and learning events for volunteers are prepared on the basis of a learning needs analysis.
10. We review existing workshops on a regular basis to check whether or not they still make sense. 11. We develop new workshops to keep up with new developments and trends, like social media. 12. Volunteers take an active part in the continuous improvement of the range of learning opportunities by providing feedback about the quality. 13. Many of our learning opportunities have been designed in such a way that they are available to professionals inside the organisation as well, in order to promote interaction between volunteers and professionals. 14. A specific budget is available for the volunteer development workshops. 15. We have appointed someone responsible for all matters relating to volunteer development, who is an excellent networker and easily accessible. 16. Offering learning opportunities is a matter of course in our organization and we promote lifelong learning as much as we can. 17. During the (annual) volunteer development talks / interviews we get valuable information about the learning needs of our volunteers. 18. We draw the attention of specific volunteers to specific learning events and opportunities, in case we feel they can benefit from them. 19. We are stimulating our own volunteers to design workshops for fellow volunteers on a “felt need” basis and offer these as a joint volunteer – professional co-production. 20. We are actively promoting the idea of “peer to peer learning ” among our volunteers. 21. We promote the idea of volunteer portfolios and offer support in creating and maintaining them, including e-portfolios.
66
Partly
NO