schoolbusiness california
California Association of School Business Officials
DON’T MENTION IT SACROSANCT ISSUES HAMPER CALIFORNIA SCHOOLS
Can-Do CASBO
REFLECTING ON FIVE YEARS OF STRATEGIC PROGRESS
Winter 2009
2 | California School Business
Winter 2009 | 3
4 | California School Business
contents
Volume 74 Number 4 Winter 2009
departments
9
Checking in What we all need is more recess Brian Lewis
13
Bottom line Think outside the box and invest in you! Sharon Ketcherside
15 45
In focus CASBO member profile: Laura Gower
46
Book club The UPside of the Downturn
47
First person The perfect storm Dennis Meyers
50
Last words
cover story
26
Don’t mention it Sacrosanct issues hamper California schools Julie Sturgeon
interview
17
ASBO chief weighs in on value of associations, leadership and change John Musso: Change is inevitable but growth is optional Julie Phillips Randles
feature
34
Can-do CASBO Reflecting on five years of strategic progress Julie Phillips Randles
15
Out & about Photos from CASBO events statewide
17
34
Winter 2009 | 5
ABOUT CASBO A private, nonprofit corporation, CASBO was founded in 1928 and is the oldest statewide school administrator’s organization in California. Association members are the voice of the industry and oversee all areas of school business management and operations, including finance, accounting, payroll, human resources, risk management, transportation, school nutrition, maintenance and operations, information technology, purchasing, school safety and school facilities.
publisher editor in chief features editor contributors
Brian Lewis Jodi Jackson Julie Phillips Randles Linda A. Estep Dennis Meyers Julie Sturgeon Kevin Swartzendruber
editorial assistant design/layout cartoon advertising art
Kristen Jacoby Sharon Adlis Shawn Turner Lori Mattas
casbo officers
CASBO MISSION The mission of CASBO, the leader in school business management, is to set the standard for best business practices and policies that support public education through high-quality professional development and effective advocacy, communication and collaboration.
president president-elect vice president immediate past president
advertising sales manager
STRATEGIC PLAN In April 2007, the association adopted its new strategic plan that will serve as a road map for the organization’s activities for the next several years in the areas of administration and governance, professional development, advocacy and policy, marketing and communications, and membership and partnerships. For more details on the strategic plan, visit our Web site at www. casbo.org. The plan can be found under the “organization” link.
Sharon Ketcherside Sacramento County Office of Education Renee Hendrick Orange County Department of Education Gary Matsumoto Hacienda La Puente Unified School District Eric D. Smith Santa Barbara School Districts CiCi Trino Association Outsource Services, Inc. 115 Spring Water Way Folsom, CA 95630 916.990.9999
www.casbo.org California School Business (ISSN# 1935-0716) is published quarterly by the California Association of School Business Officials, 1001 K Street, 5th Floor, Sacramento, CA 95814. (916) 447-3783. $2 of CASBO membership dues goes toward the subscription to California School Business magazine. The subscription rate for each CASBO nonmember is $20. Periodicals postage paid at Sacramento and at additional mailing office. Send address changes to the CASBO membership department at 1001 K Street, 5th Floor, Sacramento, CA 95814. Articles published in California School Business are edited for style, content and space prior to publication. Views expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent CASBO policies or positions. Endorsement by CASBO of products and services advertised in California School Business is not implied or expressed. Copyright 2009 CASBO. All rights reserved. The contents of the publication may not be reproduced by any means, in whole or in part, without the prior written consent of the publisher. Published December 2009
6 | California School Business
Winter 2009 | 7
T HE TPA A DMINISTRATION T EST WHY CHOOSE ZUK AS YOUR THIRD PARTY ADMINISTRATION/MANAGEMENT (TPA) RESOURCE FOR 403(B) AND 457(B) PLANS
True or False (Circle One)
I would feel nervous if the local paper was writing an expos´e on my district’s retirement plan administration. A LONG TRACK RECORD
A NAME YOU CAN TRUST
You may be familiar with Zuk Financial Group and
Zuk does not charge fees or receive compensation
our 35 year history in personal retirement planning
for Zuk Solutions. While the primary objective of the
services. What you may not be aware of, is that we
program is to provide education, enhance awareness
also provide Zuk Solutions – A premier Third Party
and raise financial literacy, Zuk Solutions may
Administration/Management resource for 403(b) and
also save employers money, eliminate conflicts of
457(b) plans to help ensure total transparency as
interest, elevate compliance and improve employee
well as the latest and best business practices.
satisfaction.
ZUK
SOLUTIONS We’ve Got Answers www.zuksolutions.com Securities and Advisory services offered through National Planning Corporation (NPC), Member FINRA/SIPC, a Registered Investment Adviser. Zuk Financial Group and NPC are separate and unrelated companies. 2/09
To See How Zuk Solutions Can Help Be Your Solution C ONTACT Z UK
8 | California School Business
AT:
888-488-8480
OR
E MAIL :
INFO @ ZUKSOLUTIONS . COM
checkingin
What we all need is more recess “There’s never enough recess.” So said the son of my sister’s good friend after the first few days of kindergarten earlier this fall. Wiser words have never been spoken. It seems that when the boy, Elijah, compared his kindergarten experience to that of preschool, he just didn’t think there was enough time for fun and social interaction with his classmates. Clearly, he’s onto something. Kids do know things that we seem to forget. We may be tempted to think we have things all figured out, but a quote like this tends to snap us back into reality. And it takes effort to stay in that reality because it’s way too easy to slip back into autopilot and into the groove of our hectic lives. When I heard this story it made me think of CASBO members all over the state. You’re all working harder than ever with fewer resources, trying to ensure that the stage is set for learning. And there’s little time for recess. But from everything virtually every CASBO member has ever told me, it’s the times when you all get together, whether at the section or state levels, that the opportunity to recharge, re-engage and reinvigorate happens. It’s your recess - your opportunity to connect, network and collaborate on the challenges you share in common. At a time when school business officials are busier than ever doing the impossible to support student learning, some form of recess is a must. Recess isn’t just about going out to play or creating down time, though those things in themselves are good for us. Recess is also about experiential learning, sharing time with friends, taking the pulse of what’s going on in your world. Kids call it hanging out. Adults refer to it in more formal terms – mingling, meeting and greeting, socializing. When we “grow up,” “going out to recess and playing with your friends” can be thought of as “networking with your peers.” No matter what you call it, the benefits are the same. Studies tell us that smiling and laughing are good for our health. Research also shows that some of kids’ best school memories involve recess. So why do we as adults seem to feel that smiling and laughing while we do the hard work that must be done is a bad thing? Perhaps a little adult recess will help blur the bad memories of these challenging times, replacing them with pleasant memories of a struggle handled together. A struggle that, like recess for children, taught us to better interact with each other, to create new rules and customs and to relate to each other without the strictness that sometimes seems to be required during the work day. Listen…I think the recess bell just rang. Meet me on the playground.
Recess is also about experiential learning, sharing time with friends, taking the pulse of what’s going on in your world.
Brian Lewis Executive Director
Winter 2009 | 9
10 | California School Business
Winter 2009 | 11
or over 75 years, Stone & Youngberg has financed school districts, community colleges and other public institutions in California. Whether your needs are for new construction, modernization or renovation, our customized solutions will help you:
F
• Choose the right financing techniques: General Obligation Bonds, Certificates of Participation (COPs), Short-term Leases, Mello-Roos/Special Tax Bonds, Bridge Financing, GASB 45/Other Post-Employment Benefits Bonds (OPEBs), Green Financing Solutions, Clean Renewable Energy Bonds (CREBs) • Plan for bond elections • Determine the lowest-cost funding alternative • Coordinate the issuance of bonds • Provide ongoing advice on facility financing
Copyright © 2007 Stone & Youngberg LLC. Member FINRA/SIPC.
12 | California School Business
LET US HELP YOU ACHIEVE YOUR FINANCING GOALS. Visit www.syllc.com or contact a member of our School Finance Group for personalized service: BRUCE KERNS (415) 445-2332 bkerns@syllc.com DAWN VINCENT (213) 443-5006 dvincent@syllc.com JOHN R. BARACY (213) 443-5025 jbaracy@syllc.com
bottomline
Think outside the box and invest in you! By Sharon Ketcherside CASBO President
If ever there was a time to think outside the box, this is it! These are critical times that call for creative solutions.
That’s why your casbo colleagues
from all over the state are working to deliver to you an outstanding 2010 casbo Annual Conference & California School
Business Expo; one that serves you and
your schools like never before. The conference will be upon us in a blink of an eye; April will be here before we know
it. Your attendance and participation at this year’s conference is more important than ever.
with the latest information – and then go
to casbo.org, click on the conference icon, download the conference brochure and
find those workshops that directly relate
to your work. Write a short memo that
outlines how those specific conference offerings relate to your work and how they will help you serve your schools even
better than before. Show how attending these sessions and meeting these people
will help you contribute to your organization’s strategies to address critical issues.
And as for paying for the con-
ference… is your position funded by
ence will provide grass-roots workshops
Don’t let the economic times prevent you from becoming even more valuable to your schools.
to network with your colleagues. As we
facilities bond monies? If so, tap into this
programs. Also, look for scholarship
ing has proven to be invaluable to school
attendance. There’s a full offering of
many offer this type of assistance.
How can we maximize the avail-
able resources in our district or county office with efficiency, while maintaining
effectiveness? This year’s annual conferacross all disciplines, and the opportunity
all know from experience, that networkbusiness officials across this state. I
myself am a product of these opportunities, having advanced from a classified
position to management within a few years of initially attending and actively participating in our organization.
We are all faced with budget cuts,
and we know professional development
is one of the first areas to be reduced. But if we put our heads together, we can
revenue stream to fund your conference
facilities workshops presented by the best
opportunities in your local sections; It’s time to think out of the box about
of the best in the business. And this is just
how you can be a part of the tremendous
remember that professional development
April’s conference. Invest in yourself
one potential funding source. In addition, is a tax write-off. This is a two-fold
benefit, because you’re investing in your professional future and your tax future at
professional growth opportunities at next and prepare for your future when the economy rebounds.
Don’t let the economic times prevent
the same time! Who couldn’t use a little
you from becoming even more valuable
If you’re working toward your cbo
they need your fine-tuned skills and
extra help at tax time?
to your schools. Now more than ever,
come up with extremely creative ways
certification, this year’s conference offers
conference.
tion renewal. Don’t forget – Districts and
Sharon Ketcherside, of the Sacramento
offer professional development stipends
president.
and means by which to attend this year’s
Think about the areas where your
schools need your expertise – where they
need you to be at the top of your game
18 sessions that qualify for cbo certifica-
county offices throughout California upon completion of professional growth
leadership.
County Office of Education, serves as casbo
Winter 2009 | 13
14 | California School Business
infocus
Laura Gower Innovative thinking key to her success, attraction to CASBO Laura Gower likes the idea of out-of-the-box thinking. Perhaps that’s what attracted her to a career with American Fidelity Assurance Company, named one of Fortune magazine’s “100 Best Companies to Work for,” and to CASBO, an organization she says is appealing due to its current “big and brave thinking.” Gower, California region vice president for American Fidelity, began with the firm 20 years ago as an account representative, working her way up to manager, then regional manager and on to regional vice president. In her current position, she oversees 90 California employees and orchestrates and manages the day-to-day operations of the four offices in the state. She also spends time at school districts speaking to CBOs, union leaders and employees about American Fidelity’s products and services. The firm, a CASBO platinum-level associate member, offers the education industry a product portfolio of supplemental insurance programs that include disability income insurance, annuities, cancer insurance, life insurance and Section 125 Plan services. American Fidelity also provides dependent verification audits under which account reps visit districts at no charge to verify documentation of employees’ dependents for insurance programs. “Districts are looking for every dollar under every rock, and American Fidelity wants to help,” Gower commented. Gower currently serves on CASBO’s Associate Member Committee (AMC) and last summer was appointed to the Strategic Planning Team. She says she sought out inclusion on the AMC after seeing firsthand her company’s longtime dedication to the association. “I thought, ‘this is a great organization, and I am sure there are things I can do to help and support it.’” Once active, she found her instincts were on target. “It’s fun contributing your time alongside others who want to make something fantastic,” Gower said. “There’s a lot of heart and soul in CASBO. From my bird’s-eye view, there’s this extreme dedication.” Another draw, and benefit, to participating in the association is that it makes good business sense. “I’ve been reading a lot lately that if you are in business today and trying to survive hard times, the secret is to have relationships with people who are able to make decisions. Find someone else to do the paperwork; get out and build relationships,” Gower recommended. She said her dedication to CASBO is in response to the support from AMC members who have been outstanding teachers. “The sky’s the limit on what the AMC can do. It’s a new day, and CASBO members are really out-of-the-box thinkers right now. That’s attractive, and that is what’s required to survive these days,” said Gower.
Photography by Hope Harris
Winter 15 Winter 2009 2009 || 15
16 | California School Business
interview
ASBO chief weighs in on value of associations, leadership and change John Musso: Change is inevitable, but growth is optional By Julie Phillips Randles
John Musso has more than 30 years experience in public education, including roles as a teacher, principal, deputy superintendent and chief financial officer. For the past three years, Musso has worked in the
business of schools at the international level as the executive director of the Association of School Business Officials International (asbo), an association that provides programs and
services to promote the highest standards of school business management practices, professional growth and the effective
use of educational resources. casbo is a state affiliate of asbo
International.
Prior to joining asbo, Musso was the chief financial officer
for the District of Columbia Public Schools, a district with more
than 12,000 employees and 167 schools and learning centers serving 60,000 students. In this position, Musso oversaw a bud-
get of more than $2 billion in annual operating, grant and capital
funds, and was charged with working daily with public officials, including city council members, the mayor and Congress to strengthen the fiscal state of the d.c. Public Schools system.
In his 15 years as a school business official, Musso secured
more than $14 million in competitive grant funds and led the
successful passage of bond issues totaling more than $100 mil-
lion, which resulted in the remodeling of 43 school buildings and the construction of five new schools.
Musso has served in leadership and director capacities
with various nonprofit organizations including Colorado asbo, Colorado Liquid Asset Trust and the Colorado Association of School Executives.
He has earned the designations of Certified Association Ex-
ecutive through the American Society of Association Executives
and Registered School Business Administrator through asbo
International. Musso also holds a bachelor’s degree from the
Photos by Nicole Burkart
University of Southern Colorado, a master’s degree in public
administration from the University of Northern Colorado and a school administrator credential and license from Western State College in Colorado.
Winter 2009 | 17
John Musso
ASBO chief weighs in on value of associations, leadership and change
CSB: What is one of your hidden talents? Musso: Something most people don’t know about me is that my
CSB: What is the best advice you’ve ever received? From whom? Musso: The best advice I’ve ever received came from my father
past includes a career in the medical field. At one time, I was a
and mother. My mother made me understand the importance of
with an ambulance crew and as a clinical therapist in a hospital’s
She advised me to go to school rather than becoming a farmer
certified paramedic. I worked in a hospital emergency room, mental health unit working with troubled adolescents. During
my 32 years in education, I have been able to put the skills I learned during my medical career to use, responding to medical
emergencies in schools, and understanding the physical and
forging ahead and giving everything that extra push it needed. like my father, grandfather and great-grandfather. She pushed
me through my bachelor’s program, my master’s program and my school administrator certification. Her advice: Never quit.
My father gave me two important pieces of advice. The first
emotional needs of students.
was to never put my eggs in one basket and the second was to
CSB: What three things are essential to your life? Musso: Without hesitation, my God and faith, my family and my
background certainly opened up many opportunities in my life
work. I had to learn the hard way that family is what matters as I went through some difficult times in my education career –
difficult times that only my faith and my family helped me get
through. Being a school district cfo is probably one of the most
rewarding jobs anyone could have, but it is also one of the most challenging. After several very difficult community meetings,
not be afraid to take risks. Having a diverse education and career and made me a better educator, so I am glad I followed my father’s advice to “diversify.” With regard to risk-taking, my father reminded me often that if you fall, the farthest you will go is the floor. When faced with a decision, I learned to ask myself, “What is the worst thing that can happen? How far can I really fall?”
CSB: Earlier this year, the American Society of Association Executives
for example, I wanted to go home, sit down in the middle of the
spoke to the new administration and Congress about the power and
got me through so I could make the best possible decisions for
in various industries and often have solutions to the tough issues of the
living room floor, and cry. During those times, faith and family the children in the school system.
value of associations, the idea that these groups represent the best minds
day. In these challenging economic times, what are you telling folks about the importance and value of association membership?
Musso: Everyone needs to belong, to feel a part of something.
CSB: What do you do to manage stress? Musso: As strange as it may seem, sometimes chaos tends to
We all need to belong to some sort of group where we all share
I know that I have to become as centered as I can in order to deal
association. Associations provide opportunities for us to connect
bring me to focus – I guess because during those stressful times
with whatever issue or issues are presenting themselves. I try to exercise as much as I can during stressful times. I make sure I eat properly and do not go off on the “junk food circuit.” I also try to
smile and laugh a lot. Smiling creates endorphins that help the body deal with various stressors. I also focus on the three most important things that are essential in my life.
CSB: What is the best thing you have ever bought? Musso: The best thing I ever bought was my wife’s engagement
and wedding rings. For the past 32 years, she has been the backbone of my career, supporting me in whatever direction or
path I decided to take. She has been there to help counsel me and pick up the pieces during difficult times. She never hesitates to
bring me back to focus when I head in the wrong direction. We have the best daughter a father and mother could ever ask for,
a common bond: a church group, a community group or an with each other. I maintain that any success I have had in my
career is because I knew who to call for help – the colleagues I met through my professional association.
Associations also provide opportunities for us to grow
personally and professionally. During tough budget times, professional development is often the first item on the hit list.
Unfortunately, tough economic times are the times when we need professional development most – to help us get through
those rough waters. These are the times we should be networking with each other, finding out what has worked for others and what has not. Your association can provide you with solutions to
your problems that will not only help you do your job, but will also make your school district a better place.
CSB: What are some of the key issues that school business leaders will
and we believe we have raised her to maneuver through life’s
likely have a hand in solving?
life would have taken an entirely different path – one that would
after year, we make rabbits appear out of hats that were once
good times, as well as bad. Had I not purchased those rings, my not have brought me to the point where I am today. 18 | California School Business
Musso: School business officials are magicians. Year after year
continued on page 20
Winter 2009 | 19
John Musso
ASBO chief weighs in on value of associations, leadership and change continued from page 18
thought empty. In the current economic conditions, those
Musso: Associations are not immune to the downward spiral in
rabbits are much more difficult to produce. The present state of
the economy. Looking at how we do business internally and how
challenges, as well as unprecedented opportunities. All of us
for our members becomes paramount. A good association
the economy has created a paradigm shift with unprecedented are thinking about school funding in much different ways and
considering new and, we hope, more innovative ways to fund public education. This is what we call the “new normal.”
we can maximize resources and provide programs and benefits
should be nimble enough to change course quickly to meet the current needs of its members.
No one particular change to governance or operations can
Our challenge is making the right decision today that will
be considered the silver bullet for every association. The key is
“low-hanging fruit” and identified which reductions will have
do business as usual, it must find ways to continue to provide
affect how we do business tomorrow. We’ve already cut the the least impact in the classroom. Instead of looking for ways to make it through the next budget cycle, school business officials
recognizing that while the association may no longer be able to valuable and unique services to its members.
need to look at ways to make these cuts sustainable and generate
CSB: You’ve had the opportunity to participate in some casbo events
of all.
observations about casbo as a nonprofit association?
revenue from other sources. This will be the greatest challenge
and observe the association in recent years. What are some of your
Musso: casbo has been around for more than 80 years, and,
CSB: School districts nationwide, and particularly in California, are
like most of the other asbo affiliates, focuses primarily on
what changes to governance and operations should associations cur-
programs and services its members need. What’s also impressive
facing the toughest times they’ve seen in 30 years. With that in mind, rently be considering?
professional development and does a great job providing the
is the degree to which casbo has taken on growth and change
as an organization through strategic planning. As a result, the
association has accomplished what many other associations only hope to achieve – a growing, thriving organization.
I’ve seen firsthand how casbo focuses on its members and
their needs. The board’s leadership, combined with Brian’s leadership and that of the entire staff, have made that strategic focus and growth possible. That’s critical to move any association
forward. It’s easy for an organization rich in history to keep the
status quo. Those organizations often are unable or unwilling to identify those things they need to let go of; things that once had a
place in the organization but have served their purpose and need to be set aside to make room for new and innovative programs
and best practices. I’ve seen casbo make those changes over the
past few years, which signals an organization that’s not only rich in history, but adaptable and responsive to its members.
Yours is an organization that will survive these tough
economic times. One of my favorite quotes is “change is inevi-
table, but growth is optional.” casbo has made a commitment to grow. z z z
Julie Phillips Randles is a freelance writer based in Roseville, Calif. Do you have an opinion or a comment on this article? California School Business magazine welcomes “Letters to the Editor.” Please send your letters to jjackson@casbo.org. All letters are edited for content, space and style considerations.
20 | California School Business
Winter 2009 | 21
Vavrinek, Trine, Day & Company, LLP has been a leading provider of audit, tax and advisory services for the Education market for over 60 years. Our professionals understand the unique needs of school districts, county offices of education, higher education and special agencies. CaLifOrnia LOCaTiOns: rancho Cucamonga, Palo alto, fresno, Laguna Hills and Pleasanton. VaLuE THE DiffErEnCE Of V TD! for more information, log on to: www.vtdcpa.com
22 | California School Business
The U.S. Communities program, sponsored by CSBA and CASBO, helps stretch your finite resources. No cost to participate. No minimum purchases. Just real savings through competitively solicited contracts and volume pricing. What can you buy? Supplies. Furniture. Technology products. Science/labware supplies and equipment. And more, much more. How do you participate? Go to www.uscommunities.org and sign up. No pressure. No commitment. Just savings. It’s that easy.
TM
Winter 2009 | 23
24 | California School Business
Winter 2009 | 25
Don’t mention it
26 | California School Business
cover
SACROSANCT ISSUES HAMPER CALIFORNIA SCHOOLS
By Julie Sturgeon
T
here is a large, long-term guest in the home of public education in California.
This guest sits perched on the living room sofa, taking up tons of space, only visiting with the residents about select issues and generally tying the education family up in knots.
His needs and distraction techniques can make it impossible to address the chal-
lenges in public education, and like a disruptive guest bent on stirring up siblings, this tenant tends to reinforce petty arguments and infighting instead of encouraging the family to face the issues head on.
“It’s almost like there are unwritten rules of decorum that those in education have
agreed to over time – rules that stand in the way of getting down to the issues,” described casbo Executive Director Brian Lewis. “We’re splintered as a community, and
we’re collectively unable to talk about the core issues.”
All of this begs the question – actually quite a few questions – when it comes to the
chance for meaningful dialogue about the future of California’s schools and students.
When will all involved get to the point that they agree that whether the topic is curricu-
lum, policy or finance, the focus should be on students? How many more decades will
drift by as education leaders continue to hover at disparate points on myriad issues? When will the children come first for all the players?
There’s an elephant in education’s living room. Perhaps it’s time to address
the beast.
Education leaders and experts attempted to do just that in recent interviews – talk
about the unmentionables, face the issues and explain their positions.
Winter 2009 | 27
Don’t mention it Picking the battles
“It has always amazed me that
and policy with casbo and currently
First among the unmentionables is that
education ‘reforms,’ by whatever name,
the chief legislative liaison to the super-
are often seen as self-serving. Add to that
is hardly a recognition of, or serious dis-
Education. “We aren’t interested in shar-
the various groups involved in education
an overall disdain for change, and thus the battle begins.
Consider, for example, the fact that
the Obama administration has dangled financial incentives totaling nearly $500 million for California school districts if
the state can agree to change some of its
often tinker around the edges. And there
cussion about, what is already in place,” commented Lewis. “Once a law passes,
piling on. Issues and programs become
work. “It’s a formula of a high level of
protect it and new programs just keep sacred.”
For those involved in categorical
this case, change with a capital “C.”
were created in the first place by interest
eliminated, it is a survival issue. And they
YOU GET PEOPLE WHO HAVE A PERSONAL EXPERIENCE IN A SPECIFIC SCHOOL OR DISTRICT, THEN GENERALIZE THAT TO THE WHOLE SYSTEM. The idea is not getting much traction
groups within education who felt their
tion. “I think the long arm of the federal
“Emotions are running very high as
government reaching all the way down
to the local school districts is going to
be hard,” said Joe Nunez, cta’s associate executive director of governmental
relations. And he’s been to Washington,
d.c., to meet with Education Secretary Arne Duncan and Rep. George Miller to
It doesn’t help that schools don’t
have a strong history of practice to build a
programs that just saw all of the strings
with the California Teachers Associa-
ing solutions that move us all forward.”
it’s in for good. A constituency forms to
education system’s status quo. What’s
required is change to the system – and in
intendent at Riverside County Office of
programs didn’t receive enough support.
they compete for dollars. Flexibility is ok
consensus around what does and doesn’t
emotion, a high level of perceived interest, and a low level of answers that carry
any strong evidence,” said Campbell. “No wonder we’ve reached the point we have now.”
Digging your heels in is a good tactic
for individual concerns, as Silberstein
admitted. “I totally get it. But people would rather win than be happy,” she added. “We’re taking our battles, fight-
ing them to the death, and they’re the wrong battles.” Not to mention they create enemies that erode any future rescue. Leaders who announce they will talk to the other side to find an agreement rather
than pound the other viewpoint into submission “are often seen as traitors to the cause,” she said.
Such demonizing then forces cre-
for the other guy, but one person’s reform
ative thinkers out of the system and into
interest program,” said Davis Campbell,
seen, leaving the education community
or critical need is another person’s special senior fellow for the Center for Applied
Policy in Education at uc Davis and president of the California School Boards
alternative “safe” places, as Campbell has spinning its wheels on logjams like these:
Association Governance Institute.
Proposition 98
tangle up education and support the sta-
self-interests at work, which is glaringly
passed in 1988 was intended to ensure
more raveled, according to Nunez. “Our
try to craft a state budget. “You ask why
say just that.
Instead of unraveling, the issues that
tus quo in California seem to be coming
frustration is you get people who have a personal experience in a specific school
or district, then generalize that to the whole system.”
There’s plenty of frustration to go
around whether the topic is how we got here, the definition of reform or whose interests outweigh another’s.
28 | California School Business
Sound selfish? There’s plenty of
The Proposition 98 funding mechanism
evident each time elected representatives
school districts had a floor on their
you don’t get education reform in the
Legislature. It’s because I’m all about me, my interests and I don’t care what
happens to your program even though it also serves my kids. I just want to go
to Sacramento, get my fair share and go
home,” said Sandra Silberstein, former assistant executive director for advocacy
monies so budgets didn’t bounce wildly.
In a perfect world, it would remove education from being at the mercy of politicians’ whims, said Draza Mrvichin,
a management consultant who has spent 40 years in labor relations in schools.
Most players agree the reasoning was
sound, but the practicality is missing. continued on page 30
Winter 2009 | 29
Don’t mention it continued from page 28
For one thing, it’s tied to state revenues,
Still, focusing on the dollar fight is
you, we would give you the world if we
“Nothing can be done about the world-
union has very smart business agents.
which are too precarious to be a good
a red herring if you ask Nunez at cta.
“No one ever expected an economy
wide recession we’ve found ourselves in
safety net.
like the one we have now. Legislators and the governor say they are protecting
schools as they cut to the ‘guarantee.’
Well the guarantee, with all the manipu-
and the traumatic impact it’s having on all services,” he said. “So we’re certainly right in line with everybody else there.”
In downturns as big as what we’re
lations, isn’t providing enough support
seeing now, you’d expect cuts to schools.
But it is a hard sell within our own com-
tee, it has been too easy to lower funding
to students and needs to be reworked. munity,” Lewis said.
Second, the action puts handcuffs
on California’s policy leaders. “To say
you will always give X number of dollars to schools, I don’t care if there was a
big earthquake, I don’t care what’s happening on the health and welfare side or
criminal justice. I get my fair share,” Silberstein said. “I have always questioned
broader conversation about what schools
need in order to do the job expected of
them by the state and the children we serve, and then a funding commitment
needs to follow; that’s where a re-envisioned Proposition 98 comes in.”
every time money becomes a topic, the
underpaid in the system. Silberstein
“I don’t think in a diverse state that
needs to come together in the middle and find ‘yes’ answers to complex problems that a simplistic formula like this is wise,”
Silberstein said. “Another price you pay for this protection is that it builds a wall
between you and potential collaboratives.”
highest paid teachers in the nation with the 50th percentile in funding.”
It’s also patently unfair, in his view,
lows them to stack the deck, as it were,
No doubt about it, collective bargaining
it – or are greedy.
more money, and now you have the third
to the guarantee,” Lewis said. “We need a
fallout is that voters think they’ve taken
assumption is that schools have wasted
districts where they could afford to give
because teachers can vote at the polls
whether Proposition 98 is good public
care of schools with this stroke and now
They [union representatives] showed the
“But beyond suspension of the guaran-
Collective bargaining & merit pay
policy.” That’s because one common
could afford it,” he explained. “And the
brought fair pay to jobs that were definitely puts teachers in that category.
for school board members, which alfrom the private citizen side, too. “If the
United Auto Workers could control the
board of directors at Ford, they’d have even better contracts than they have now, I would imagine,” he said.
But things really reached a deadlock,
said Mrvichin, because the Legislature has left a state code in place when it comes
to wages, hours and working conditions in education; language that dictates to the
school district what percentage of their budget has to be spent on teachers, how sick leave is to be used, and so forth. “So
management is at the bargaining table
WE’RE TAKING OUR BATTLES, FIGHTING THEM TO THE DEATH, AND THEY’RE THE WRONG BATTLES.
And then there’s the fear factor.
But the process of negotiation in Cal-
with one arm tied behind their backs
munity would likely say Proposition 98 is
to leave behind good feelings. At the
requirements, only above,” he said.
While a large part of the education comnot working well, the idea of not having a constitutional guarantee is scarier still.
Therefore, the passion for Proposi-
tion 98 is reaching theological levels in Campbell’s observation. “It’s perceived as
a firewall protection; the only thing stand-
ifornia, insiders say, is too adversarial end of the wrangling, teachers and
because they can never go below code “It’s almost as if school is about
administrators have squared off, called
adults and not children,” he summed
cares enough about kids. A year later, the
ment and not so much an educational
each other cheats, and questioned who rebellion repeats.
School district management egged
up. “It’s turned into a place of employinstitution.”
Lewis pointed to a personal experi-
ing in the way of dismantling the school
on this attitude, Mrvichin believes, by not
ence to illustrate Mrvichin’s point. Sever-
tend to rally around the notion this is the
place. “They [management] historically
a point-blank comment that literally took
finance system,” said Campbell. “People last stand against [deeper] cuts.”
30 | California School Business
understanding how to bargain in the first
came at this from a position that we love
al years ago an education lobbyist made Lewis aback. The lobbyist told Lewis that
will be, about children. It’s a fundamental
IT’S ALMOST AS IF SCHOOL IS ABOUT ADULTS AND NOT CHILDREN. IT’S TURNED INTO A PLACE OF EMPLOYMENT AND NOT SO MUCH AN EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION.
humans and professionals to serve what
state standards to base teachers pay,
in Sacramento. But the problem of Cali-
Nunez said he doesn’t understand
complement of valid, reliable matrices
people in the Capitol are stubborn, most
it was her job to look out for the adults
whom she represented; that her life’s work was about supporting the schools as effective local employers of adults.
“It was the first time I had heard
it said with such frankness,” recalled
Lewis. “My only thought was ‘that’s
where we differ.’ Schools are, and always
place from which we need to operate as should be our only constituency.”
the uproar over collective bargaining.
As he reads the code, bargaining law provides a way for local districts to hammer out pay for performance in terms of
extra pay for extra work. He also says cta
we have a problem. But let’s have a full
on which to do that evaluation, have our
locals bargain that, and we’re good to go,” he contends.
isn’t automatically opposed to merit pay.
California’s Legislature
developed to test children once a year on
the shoulders of elected representatives
“To the extent we use a test that was
Sure, a chunk of the blame also falls on
fornia’s ungovernablility isn’t that the insiders agree. Silberstein instead points the finger at term limits.
She’s preaching to the choir with
Nunez. He says cta spent nearly 12 years to create and deliver perfomance standards for the classroom. But after
aligning the materials and posting positive increases on the grading matrix,
Winter 2009 | 31
Don’t mention it
staunch Democrat or Republican dis-
REFORM SAYS YOU ARE BROKEN. REDESIGN SAYS THE STRUCTURE AND SYSTEM NO LONGER WORKS AND THE PEOPLE IN IT ARE PART OF THE SOLUTION, NOT THE PROBLEM.
They force politicians to constantly run
proach these questions with a perspective
what moves people to wanting a more
people every few years to start over
or wrong,” he said. That translates to
While there is little agreement on
term limits meant the original politicians were replaced with representatives who were now using data from Adequate
Yearly Progress and others to judge progress.
Redistricting is the other bugaboo.
Voting lines have been dissected to
the point that families live in either a trict, and never the twain shall meet. for re-election, and bring in uninformed
without background notes, partnerships or mentors. “Imagine in your own
business if you cleaned out and hired new people every six years,” Silberstein
that does not assume good or bad, right
dropping the term “sacred cows” for
exactly what needs to be done to oust
“redesign.”
attempting to come up with solutions for
“elephants” and replacing “reform” with
“Reform says you are broken. Re-
illustrated.
design says the structure and system no
and it is in the middle that people find
of the solution, not the problem,” Camp-
“We don’t elect moderates anymore,
workable compromises,” she explained.
“They are the ones that say, ‘You have a point and you have a point and here’s common ground.’”
There may be hope for improvement
moving forward due to the passage of
latest entities to step up with ideas to
working with a program at uc Davis to
bring the best thinkers on the practical redesign concept to meet with small groups of superintendents.
Meanwhile, Silberstein selects mod-
look for somebody who agrees with
the governor with bipartisan support from legislators on both sides of the aisle.
Where’s the leadership? What do these stand-offs say about edu-
cation’s leadership? “I’m not impressed,” Mrvichin commented bluntly.
But those looking for a knight in
shining armor to ride in and save the day are looking in the wrong direction,
Campbell contends. The answer begins
government. Also at it is the Bay Area Council, a group pursuing the idea of a
Constitutional Convention to address the state’s governance issues.
Perhaps one of these groups will find
me, I want somebody who can think on
idea of “redesign.”
his or her feet, who’s smart, brave and politically savvy enough to do it,” she
described. Also in the action column, she encourages Riverside County school
officials to take a problem-solving role
and direct leaders toward Campbell’s Not convinced? Perhaps then it’s
time to head to the kitchen to make our
pachyderm pal a snack while we wait. z z z Julie Sturgeon is a freelance writer based in
with legislators, offering suggestions on
Indianapolis, Ind.
the “don’t cut our funding, cut the other
Do you have an opinion or a comment on this article? California School Business magazine welcomes “Letters to the Editor.” Please send your letters to jjackson@casbo.org. All letters are edited for content, space and style considerations.
ways to help the district as opposed to guy’s” message.
“I don’t think we’ll ever be holding
hands and singing Kumbaya on everything,” she said. “But we can be flexible.”
Then again, there’s something to be
without alienating the parties who have
much worse, it is going to blow up,”
32 | California School Business
fix what ails the state’s current state of
a way to disrupt the political apple cart
said for a nuclear option – say, a state
such a deep commitment to them? Ap-
motes government reform, is one of the
“people that want to get to ‘yes.’ I don’t
with something as innocuous as language. “How do we address these issues
California Forward, a bipartisan,
bell explained. For his part, Campbell’s
of legislative districts in the hands of a
politicians. The measure was backed by
improving how California governs itself.
foundation-supported group that pro-
erates when she’s in the voting booth,
citizens’ commission, rather than with
the elephant, various organizations are
longer works and the people in it are part
Proposition 11, a measure approved two years ago that puts reapportionment
productive debate.”
bankruptcy – as well. “If this thing gets
Silberstein warned. “And that may be
The California School Boards Association partners with highly qualified consultants to provide districts/county offices with a comprehensive one-stop, low cost GASB 45 Solutions Program. We have a GASB 45 compliant and an Internal Revenue Service approved Section 115 trust.
1.800.266.3382 | www.csba.org
Sponsored by: Piper Jaffray & Co. Public Agency Retirement Services (PARS) U.S. Bank Institutional Trust FAF Advisors CSBA and the California County Superintendents Educational Services Association
Winter 2009 | 33
34 | California School Business
feature
CAN-DO CASBO Reflecting on five years of strategic progress
By Julie Phillips Randles Ever-changing budget numbers, out-of-control mandates, constantly modified business practices; with all of the constant
activity in the business of schools, today’s deadlines and tomorrow’s to-do list leave little time for reflection.
Between day jobs and volunteerism as association members,
most casbo members are so busy moving forward full speed ahead that little time is spent looking back.
But reflecting is exactly what’s in order periodically, accord-
and earning a prestigious national publishing award for this quarterly magazine, California School Business.
A more in-depth examination of the five-year track record
of the association nets additional strategic successes, along with the acknowledgement of a few bumps in the road.
Strategic progress
ing to Patricia Koch, casbo’s volunteer strategic plan facilitator
casbo’s long-term commitment to strategic planning, combined
to a member-driven association that is guided by an active stra-
in association governance and leadership, has poised the
and a retired member. That’s especially the case when it comes tegic plan.
“We need to occasionally stop and reflect on what we have
accomplished, both to acknowledge our successes and to inspire
with a commitment to a growing body of best practices association to accomplish a remarkable slate of achievements in a relatively short period of time.
Such is the nature of strategic planning. By creating a plan
us for the tasks ahead,” noted Koch. “Otherwise we tend to think
approximately every five years which spells out the course of
have done. Sometimes we surprise ourselves when we realize
implemented. casbo has seen strategic progress in the follow-
only about all that we have yet to do, and we lose sight of all we
the organization, member-driven goals are established and
we have achieved so much.”
ing key areas:
the association has much to celebrate.
strategic planning
casbo can boast about a trio of recent successes – advancing
the driving force behind the initiatives that are addressed on
purchasing office space in a key Sacramento redevelopment area
its attention and dedication to the process, ensuring that the
Such is the case at casbo, where a backward glance shows Despite the most challenging economic times in 30 years,
strategically as a nonprofit while other organizations struggle,
Strategic planning is a cornerstone of casbo’s philosophy, and
behalf of members. In the last half-decade, casbo has increased
Winter 2009 | 35
CAN-DO CASBO member-driven and professionally staffed system creates a strong vision for the future of casbo.
casbo President Sharon Ketcherside of the Sacramento
and electronic delivery; and the renaming and positioning of the casbo Annual Conference & California School Business Expo.
County Office of Education says that strategic planning is be-
association governance
the association for the future. “It pushes us to perform better, to
area of governance practices. The association has seen significant
hind the host of successes, while at the same time positioning
Noteworthy progress has also been made in recent years in the
think on a broader scale and to set aside individual agendas and
governance change driven by the strategic plan that sought
consider what’s best for casbo.”
legislative advocacy In 2005, casbo ’s first in-house advocacy program was established (as directed by the previous strategic plan), resulting in a highly recognized advocacy effort that gave the association
its own voice in all things political and legislative. Recognizing
the need to establish direct e-mail communication with members
on legislative issues, the then-new executive director, Brian Lewis, envisioned the
casbo
Newsbreak and the organization
brought it to life. Today members rank it among the association’s strongest benefits.
According to Gary Pickavet, assistant superintendent,
administrative services as the Santa Barbara County Office of
Education and chair of casbo’s Legislative Committee, one of
the association’s biggest successes in the past five years has been “putting casbo on the map as far as the Legislature goes.”
While in the past casbo had single inroads with legislators
to align casbo’s governance with both strategic goals and
association best practices. This includes the “re-engineering” of the association’s bylaws which were passed by a vote of 85 percent of voting members in March 2009, and the current rewrite of the Manual of Procedures.
We need to stop and reflect on what we have accomplished, both to acknowledge our successes and to inspire us for the tasks ahead.
through individual member’s relationships, bringing legisla-
membership
focus in its advocacy efforts. “It became casbo’s opinion only
ority five years ago. This goal triggered a review of the associa-
unique position to evaluate not only the pros and cons of a bill,
dues structure by the board of directors in spring 2007.
tive advocacy in-house provided the association with a singular
influenced by casbo members,” said Pickavet. “casbo is in a
but the fiscal impact, and lots of legislators like to implement
bills without consideration of how it gets paid for. The motiva-
tion when casbo takes a position on a bill is what’s best for school sites and school districts.”
communications & marketing Communications and marketing were a key priority of casbo’s
Increasing casbo’s membership numbers was also a high pri-
tion’s membership offerings and the eventual adoption of a new
The new structure was adopted after a review by the board
determined that while casbo had grown in depth, breadth and
scope, the existing dues structure was not keeping pace with
the services the association was providing. With this in mind,
the board sought to establish a new dues structure that was fair, equitable to all members and timeless in its application.
To meet these goals, the board created a dues structure that
strategic plan in 2004-05, and Lewis was charged with leading
is more reflective of the type and size of association casbo is,
Successes in this area include: the creation of a branding
equitable dues system; and built in incremental increases to al-
the efforts to revitalize the association’s communication efforts.
platform for the association with a new marketplace position, logo and federally trademarked tagline; a complete redesign of
the former casbo Journal into the national award-winning Califor-
and the association casbo is going to be; implemented a more low the dues structure to get to where it needed to be over time, avoiding a huge one-time increase.
With the July 2007 implementation of the new structure,
nia School Business magazine; the creation of a user-friendly and
new member numbers increased by 10 percent in less than one
association’s bi-weekly newsletter to include editorial content
continued on page 38
constantly evolving Web site; the renaming and redesign of the
36 | California School Business
year and revenues from dues were strengthened.
C
Purchase Lease or Rent, o t ay tod l l a
The XYZs of California School District Debt Financing
For over 30 years Mobile Modular Management Corporation has been providing modular buildings to meet the temporary and permanent space needs of the education market.
Who we A.R.E.: Availability We offer the broadest and deepest selection of modular buildings with an unmatched ability to customize our buildings to your needs. Response We offer the quickest and most thorough response to your questions and needs. Execution From start to finish, you have a team of modular building experts to ensure successful execution of your project.
www.MobileModularRents.com
800.944.3442
We are proud to present The XYZs of California School District Debt Financing, Third Edition. The XYZs has been revised to reflect the many changes that have taken place in the world of school district debt finance since the publication of the second edition in 1996. To obtain your free copy of this publication, please contact publicfinance@orrick.com. For more information, visit www.orrick.com/public_finance.
orrick, herrington & sutcliffe llp los angeles new york orange county pacific northwest sacramento san francisco silicon valley washington dc
www.orrick.com
Winter 2009 | 37
CAN-DO CASBO continued from page 36
office acquisition In another acclaimed achievement, casbo closed escrow on a
single floor of office condominium space at 10th and K streets in downtown Sacramento in October 2008. The fifth-floor space
in the K Street West office building at 1001 K Street is located in a key revitalization area in the city’s downtown area, and near
association in both the near and long terms. And, due to several
years of conservative fiscal management, the association was
positioned to put a down payment on the space while maintain-
ing a meaningful reserve.
casbo moved into the improved space in February 2009.
the Capitol and sister education associations.
fiscal oversight & revenue generation
in buildings owned by the California Lottery in the 700 block of
also been a key initiative for the association.
While the association had expected to maintain its offices
The creation of sound reserves and effective fiscal oversight has
North 10th Street until 2010, the lottery decided in January 2008
In a three-year period, the association’s reserves increased
that it would be demolishing the buildings at the site, forcing casbo out of its leased space.
An Office Space Task Force composed of casbo members
was established to determine where, when and how to relocate casbo’s offices. After exploring all the options for leasing and
purchasing office space in a variety of Sacramento-area locations,
170 percent to in excess of $1.4 million in mid-2008. The exis-
tence of those reserves made it possible for the board of directors to authorize the purchase of the new casbo office space.
Not without controversy
the task force recommended the purchase of the K Street space.
While casbo has committed to embracing change and has
board of directors, to be the most sound fiscal decision for the
those changes has not been without controversy.
Purchasing space was found by the task force, and later the
38 | California School Business
shown itself to be more nimble than many associations, facing
Such was the case with a strategic plan component that
called for the re-engineering of the association’s governance
structure. In the end, that re-engineering will lead to changes in the make-up of the association’s board, and its bylaws and operational policies.
The changes to the make-up of the board of directors
has caused somewhat of a split, according to Michael Dodge,
regional director for associate member company California Financial Services, former chair of the Professional Development
Committee and a past strategic plan action team member. “We
don’t know yet if it’s good or bad; I know a lot of people are concerned. They are trusting in the process.”
Nancy Axelrod, a governance consultant and founding
president of BoardSource, assures that controversy over changes to governance is typical. “Often the greater the proposed
change, the greater the resistance from members. Members are
often quite wedded to the status quo,” she said. “Too many
organizations that need to make governance changes wait until the pain of inaction exceeds the uncertainty of making the change. It takes courage and it takes clarity, and it should be
done in response to what’s best for members, not in response to a crisis.”
Another “sore topic,” Dodge suggested, is the purchase of
the office condominium to house the association. “At the time it
was a good idea, but given where the economy has gone, it could
It pushes us to perform better, to think on a broader scale and to set aside individual agendas and consider what’s best for CASBO.
be a struggle for us now,” said Dodge.
at every area, even what we think we are doing well, to see if it
the purchase to the board of directors when the association was
way it’s been for 50 years.”
Damon Smith, chair of the task force that recommended
given its walking papers by the state lottery, said that while
“there is a lot of dust and the picture isn’t as clear or as comfortable as many would like with regard to the building purchase,
if we take a moment to clear the air, I believe the visage casbo
members will see is one to be proud of.”
Smith, assistant superintendent, business services, for the
can be improved upon. A lot of people are comfortable with the “The bumpy road has been minimal compared to our
achievements,” noted Ketcherside, adding, “other organizations have come to us and asked us how we do it.”
What’s behind the progress?
Imperial County Office of Education, noted that the association
With a host of achievements to tout, some might wonder how
decision to purchase a building were not made because the
stagnated. The answer can be found in members’ dedication to
would have been paying substantially higher rent even if the
lottery lease was at a below-market rate. “When the task force
evaluated that incremental difference between renting a new
casbo has managed to evolve while other associations have the association.
Brett McFadden has served on casbo’s strategic planning
place and owning a new place – the decision was unanimous.
team for the last two summers, is a school board member and the
too, was decisive. The board understood the long-term benefits
School Administrators. He has a 10-year history of collaborating
When the casbo board likewise reviewed those facts, its action, and ramifications of ownership.”
In the same vein, the entire idea of strategic planning was
controversial when introduced some 15 years ago, Pickavet recalled. “The strategic plan challenges the association to look
director of management services for the Association of California
with casbo and says today’s casbo is more focused and more
organized than the association of the past.
“It’s got more sense of mission and purpose. It’s much more
courageous now and much more willing to have difficult con-
Winter 2009 | 39
CAN-DO CASBO versations, and through those conversations is willing to lift up
rocks and say ‘we’ve been doing it this way for a while – how it is working?’”
McFadden noted that casbo’s members have a tendency
to look for silver linings; a trait that bodes well for the group. “There’s a saying that a crisis is a terrible thing to waste, and
that’s what the strategic planning process has given casbo; the mechanism to say ‘our world is changing rapidly and how can casbo best support members?’”
Another piece of the success puzzle – “You’ve had coura-
geous leaders willing to ask ‘why are we doing this?’ and Brian has a set of skills that encompasses the full range of what an
executive director needs to have. The board has been willing to take courageous steps, and Brian has been willing to push it where it needed to be pushed,” McFadden said.
Larry Wonder, a past chair of the Associate Member Com-
mittee and vice president of sales with Virco Inc., a platinum-
level associate member company, noted that casbo has long had
innovative and professional elected leadership and said that the current staff is equally talented.
“Since Brian Lewis joined the team, the face of casbo has
dramatically changed. I’m involved with many national associations, state associations and their publications, and what
Brian has done with casbo and the look and content of its
publications is outstanding,” Wonder said. “There is also more
professionalism in the day-to-day management which, in the long run, will enhance casbo overall and influence people joining casbo.”
Also key, consultant Axelrod noted, is the ability of an as-
sociation to be nimble. “It’s hard to keep pace with the pace
outside of the organization. It moves faster than most organizations are able to be adaptable. Associations have to navigate the
faster pace of change by harnessing the collective power of their boards. Effective boards shape direction and allocate time to
what matters most to the organization and hone the organiza-
Too many organizations that need to make governance changes wait until the pain of inaction exceeds the uncertainty of making the change. In recent years the leadership has moved the organization to
creating a robust relationship with membership – a connection that has moved the association forward, said Murai.
Adds Dodge, “Our strength is that our own peers in the
trenches are telling us how to do it.”
Pragmatism vs. prestige
tion’s direction.”
It is casbo’s practical nature, as opposed to an association that
ing to Ketcherside. “In school business if you are not flexible, you
according to J. Clarke Price, immediate past-president of the
That nimble nature is ingrained in casbo members, accord-
are no longer in school business.”
An additional indicator in casbo’s progress is its member
orientation, said Susan Murai, a retired member and former
trades purely on reputation, that also sets it up for future success, American Society of Association Executives and president and ceo of the Ohio Society of cpas.
Associations that provide tangible value, not just prestige
casbo president. She called the group’s member orientation
in membership, will thrive in today’s challenging times and in
can get lost in the nitty-gritty of an association and one thing
has the association moved the needle on the issues that are
“its greatest success in the past couple of years,” adding, “you
that stands out is the importance of maintaining contact with membership.”
40 | California School Business
years to come, Price contends. “Members ask themselves ‘how important?’ When members can look back and say ‘I did get
continued on page 42
The California School Boards Association, in association with Piper Jaffray & Co., has partnered with the California Association of School Business Officials, and enhanced the Certificates of Participation program.
û Fixed and variable interest rate options û Flexible prepayment provisions û Capitalized interest û Flexible repayment schedules û Low cost of issuance û Education Code 17406 financings
California School Boards Association
3100 Beacon Blvd. | West Sacramento, CA 95691 | 800.266.3382
Winter 2009 | 41
CAN-DO CASBO continued from page 40
training, I did get answers, it did help me get another job, I read the magazine, I had my interests represented, I used the Web site’ – if members do that kind of evaluation and say, ‘this is a
good dues payment I’m making,’ that’s when an association has a sustainable future.”
Pickavet described casbo’s pragmatic personality this way:
“When you look at other associations, you subscribe to them.
You’re a member because it furthers your cause. You belong because it moves forward not necessarily the industry, but your
group. casbo represents our group, but its purpose is to help us
in what we do every day. It’s there to take the collective knowl-
edge of a statewide group of people and funnel it into a product that helps everyone.” z z z
Julie Phillips Randles is a freelance writer based in Roseville, Calif. Do you have an opinion or a comment on this article? California School Business magazine welcomes “Letters to the Editor.” Please send your letters to jjackson@casbo.org. All letters are edited for content, space and style considerations.
Driving resources to the classroom
With budget restrictions growing tighter, now is the time to look to PARS for cost-saving retirement plans to achieve fiscal savings while helping you drive resources back to the classroom. Contact us today and let us develop one for you!
Retirement Incentives CSBA GASB 45 Solutions Program Alternatives to Social Security
800.540.6369 ext 127 www.pars.org © 2008 Public Agency Retirement Services (PARS). All rights reserved
42 | California School Business
NEW!
MORNING GENERAL SESSIONS
Annual Conference FIRST GENERAL SESSION
SATURDAY, APRIL 17 9:15 AM CHRIS BLISS Comedian, juggler and nonprofit activist – audiences get all three in Chris Bliss, a satirist who delivers “smart comedy for the information age.”
CASBO Califªnia School Business Expo s ac ra me nt o
APRIL 16-19 SECOND GENERAL SESSION
SUNDAY, APRIL 18 8:30 AM BRUCE JENNER Perhaps best known as the Olympic athlete who broke the world record by scoring 8,634 points in the decathlon at the 1976 Olympic Games in Montreal. As a motivational speaker, Jenner uses his wide variety of experiences to show listeners how to find the champion he believes lives within each of us.
BE THE PERSON YOUR SCHOOLS CAN’T DO WITHOUT These are unprecedented times in school business. Never before have you been asked to do so much with so little. The good news is that you’re not alone. Nearly 200 hours of content-rich workshops have been designed by your peers throughout California to support you in all aspects of your job…the job you’re doing today and the job you may be asked to do tomorrow. CASBO. Smart business. Smart schools.
REGISTER TODAY!
Winter 2009 | 43
44 | California School Business
out & about
Busy at work during the annual Strategic Planning Team meeting in Sacramento are (l-r) CASBO President Sharon Ketcherside, Sacramento County Office of Education; Strategic Planning Facilitator Tish Koch; and Lora Duzyk, assistant superintendent business services, San Diego County Office of Education and past CASBO president.
Eastern Section organizers of the Southern/Eastern Section Vendor Show in October include (l-r) Mary Jane Andersen, program manager, purchasing/contracts, San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools; Jamie Lightsey, contract specialist, San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools; Adrienne Becerril, office specialist, San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools; Carolyn Burleson, purchasing/contracts supervisor, San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools; and Barbra Newlin, manager, purchasing services, Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified School District.
Taking a break between sessions at CBO Boot Camp in Sacramento in October are (l-r) Ralph Alba, program manager, San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools, and Martin Lonza, principal, Wasco Union High School District.
Southern Section CASBO volunteers at the Southern/Eastern Section Vendor Show include (l-r) Martha Alvarado, buyer, Palm Springs Unified School District; Deborah Harris, procurement services manager, Los Angeles County Office of Education; Joshie Cox, director, purchasing/risk management, ABC Unified School District; and Diana Field, director, purchasing, Palm Springs Unified School District.
Pictured at CBO Boot Camp in Sacramento in October are (l-r) Charlene Essigand and Cathleen Serna, both accountants at Gateway Unified School District in Redding.
Please send in your Out & About photos from CASBO events along with the names of the people in the photos and the event where the photo was taken. Digital photos may be sent to jjackson@casbo.org.
Winter 2009 | 45
CASBO book club
The UPside of the Downturn
BASIC DESIGN
CHILD RESTRAINT
10 management strategies to prevail in the recession and thrive in the aftermath
STUDENT SAFETY SEAT C.E. White’s renowned Child Restraint Seat is available as an integral part of the new 3-point Student Safety Seat™. This double-duty design gives you safety and versatility. • For children 20 to 60 lb. • Exceeds all Federal, State and Canadian safety standards • Standard school bus vinyl and colors, or Kevlar, Prevaill™ or ProForm™ fireblock. � �������������������������������������
Author Geoff Colvin, a business journalist, claims that even the most terrifying recession can have an upside – the opportunity to emerge from the downturn stronger and more dominant than before the lag.
™
In his book he urges readers
C.E. White’s Basic Design Student Safety Seat™ is comfortable, durable and features an integrated 3-point lap and shoulder harness that is easy to use.
to never waste
• A single frame seat back design features a twostep “Controlled Collapse” for safety of compartmentalization • Meets all current FMVSS and Canadian standards for school buses • Standard school bus vinyl and colors, or Kevlar, Prevaill™ or ProForm™ fireblock.
the current
417 Kibler Street • New Washington, OH 44854 • 419.492.2157 Fax 419.492.2544 • www.cewhite.com
a crisis and tells us that recession is a turning point into a new economic world. He asserts that some businesses – and some people – will emerge from this downturn better off than when it started. Others will weaken and fade. It all depends on the critical choices they make right now. In interviews with dozens of top-performing leaders, Colvin found that real leaders see the recession as an opportunity to reinvent their organizations and prepare for future growth. The best managers are taking smart, practical steps to stay strong today and keep them ahead of the game in years to come. In this book, Colvin shares 10 strategies he says will increase an organization’s competitiveness and build long-term value. The key tip: even during difficult times, keep an eye on the long term, trimming the fat but not the muscle and spending where it makes sense. Join your CASBO colleagues in reading this book and find out what critical choices you should be making right now in preparation for the better times ahead.
46 | California School Business
firstperson
The
perfect storm Dennis Meyers CASBO Assistant Executive Director, Advocacy & Policy
We’ve all heard references to “the perfect storm,” where two or three
separate weather patterns converge to create a once-in-a-lifetime superstorm. In
non-weather terms, Webster’s Dictionary describes a perfect storm as “a critical or
disastrous situation created by a powerful concurrence of factors.”
It’s a lot like what we’re witnessing
here in California where the fiscal crisis is
crashing head-on with a seriously polarized Legislature.
The perfect storm. California style.
The Legislature’s inability to address
the deficit with anything more than shortterm baling wire and chewing gum fixes,
was and still is, one proof that we are in the midst of the perfect storm in state governance.
Currently, applications are being ac-
the June 2010 ballot; sca 4, authored by
reapportioning legislative districts. The
proved by the Legislature as part of the
cepted for a citizens’ panel to work on panel, adopted as part of Proposition 11
in 2008, will replace the Legislature as the primary body drawing legislative
district boundaries. The last time the Legislature worked on reapportionment, it created safe districts that resulted in
conservative districts becoming more
conservative and liberal districts becoming more liberal. Since then, there has been little movement toward the center
Republican Sen. Abel Maldonado. ApFebruary budget deal, this constitutional amendment proposes an open primary
system where voters will be able to vote
for any candidate in a primary without
regard to party registration. If this passes and withstands legal challenges from the
two main political parties, it has the great-
est potential for changing the political landscape of California.
Why are these two changes so impor-
on any major issue facing the state, espe-
tant? They will force movement toward
result of Proposition 11.
change. They will also lessen the chances
cially the budget. That will change as a
One more positive move toward a
more moderate Legislature will be on
the center. Positive change. Climate
that the perfect storm will hit this great state again.
Proposals to address the perfect
storm are many. California Forward has
proposed a series of changes, includ-
ing performance-based and multiyear budgeting. The Bay Area Council has
proposed a Constitutional Convention to address the governance gridlock. The
governor created a special commission Even the Legislature has gotten into the
act by discussing bipartisanship and
strengthening the integrity of the legislative process. All of the proposals could be
summarized by the oft-heard question: “Can’t we all just get along?”
We can all get along. There are
changes coming that will result in a more
responsive Legislature; one where its
members are more politically centered rather than miles apart at opposite poles.
We will see one of the more dramatic
sudoku
to look at restructuring the tax system.
8 9 9 3 2 8 7 8 6 5 1 8 1 6 5 9 7
2
6 8 4 6 9 4 3 7 9 6 5 2 4 1 4 5 answers on page 49
changes in time for the 2012 elections.
Winter 2009 | 47
advertiserindex 403b Investment Advisors
Eye Care
ZUK Financial Group (888) 488-8480 www.zukfinancial.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
VSP (800) 852-7600 www.vsp.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42
Accounting, Auditing & Financial Services
Financial and Human Resource Software
Vavrinek, Trine, Day & Co LLP (909) 466-4410 www.vtdcpa.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
Infinite Visions/Windsor Management Group (888) 654-3293 www.infinitevisions.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
Vicenti, Lloyd + Stutzman LLP (626) 857-7300 www.vlsllp.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 & 21
Smartetools (760) 242-8890 www.smartetools.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
Architects
Financial Consulting Services
WLC Architects (909) 987-0909 www.wlc-architects.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44
PFM Financial Services (800) 891-7910 www.casbo.org Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51
Bond Counsel
Financial Services
Miller Brown & Dannis (562) 366-8500 www.mbdlaw.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
Jones Hall (415) 391-5780 www.joneshall.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
Piper Jaffray & Co. (800) 876-1854 www.PJC.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe, LLP (413) 773-5494 www.orrick.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37
Construction Management
RBC Capital Markets (213) 362-4138 www.rbccapitalmarkets.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37
SGI Construction Management (626) 395-7474 www.sgicm.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31
Consulting / Advocacy School Innovations & Advocacy (800) 487-9234 www.sia-us.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
Consulting Services GASB 45 Solutions (916) 371-4691 www.csba.org Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 Vicenti, Lloyd + Stutzman LLP (626) 857-7300 www.vlsllp.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 & 21
Contractors / Construction Management Bernards (818) 838-7923 www.bernards.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38
Cooperative Purchasing The Cooperative Purchasing Network (713) 744-8133 www.tcpn.org Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
Emergency 24 Hour Services American Technologies, Inc. (800) 400-9353 www.amer-tech.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29
Stone & Youngberg LLC (800) 447-8663 www.syllc.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 Willdan (800) 424-9144 www.wildan.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44
Fire & Water Damage Restoration American Technologies, Inc. (800) 400-9353 www.amer-tech.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29
Furniture Virco Manufacturing Corp. (800) 813-4150 www.virco.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Back Cover
Insurance Benefits and Services American Fidelity Assurance Co. (866) 523-1857 www.afadvantage.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49 ASCIP (562) 403-4640 www.ascip.org Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 Keenan & Associates (310) 212-0363 www.keenanassoc.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 Schools Excess Liability Fund (SELF) (916) 321-5300 www.selfjpa.org Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44
48 | California School Business
Self Insured Schools of CA (SISC) (800) 972-1727 www.sisc.kern.org Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 Standard Insurance Company (800) 522-0406 www.standard.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
Legal Services Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo (562) 653-3200 www.aalrr.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 Jones Hall (415) 391-5780 www.joneshall.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
Mandate Reimbursment School Innovations & Advocacy (800) 487-9234 www.sia-us.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
Program Management Capital Program Management (916) 553-4400 www.capitalpm.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42
Program/Construction Management Seville Construction Services (626) 204-0800 www.sevillecs.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33
Public Finance RBC Capital Markets (213) 362-4138 www.rbccapitalmarkets.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37
Public Finance Stone & Youngberg LLC (800) 447-8663 www.syllc.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
Rentals of Modular Buildings Mobile Modular (925) 606-9000 www.mobilemodularrents.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37
Retirement Benefits Public Agency Retirement Service (800) 540-6369 #127 www.pars.org Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42
advertiserindex Risk Management Services
Student Information Services
AD PAGE INDEX
Schools Excess Liability Fund (SELF) (916) 321-5300 www.selfjpa.org Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44
Eagle Software (888) 487-7555 www.aeries.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
American Fidelity Assurance Co. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49
School Bus Sales Service & Parts
Student Safety Seats
Bernards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38
Creative Bus Sales (800) 326-2877 www.creativebussales.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
C.E. White Company (239) 218-7078 www.cewhite.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46
C.E. White Company . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 Creative Bus Sales . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
School Construction
Transportation
Northern California Carpenter’s Regional Council (510) 568-4788 www.nccrc.org Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
Tyler Technologies (800) 433-5530 www.tylertech.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
Educational Resources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
Services/Utilities
Wheelchair & Occupant Securement Systems
The Southern California Gas Company (800) 427-6584 www.socalgas.com/business/rebates/onBillFinancing.html Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
Q’straint (954) 986-6665 www.qstraint.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
Software Educational Resources (800) 852-8266 www.edresources.com Please see our ad on page . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
American Technologies, Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 ASCIP . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46
Capital Program Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42 Eagle Software . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 GASB 45 Solutions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 Jones Hall . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 Keenan & Associates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 Miller Brown & Dannis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 Mobile Modular . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 Northern California Carpenter’s Regional Council . . . . . . . . . . 16 Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe, LLP . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 PFM Financial Services . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51 Piper Jaffray & Co. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 Public Agency Retirement Service . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42 Q’straint . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 RBC Capital Markets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 School Innovations & Advocacy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 Schools Excess Liability Fund (SELF) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44 Self Insured Schools of CA (SISC) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 Seville Construction Services . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 SGI Construction Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 Smartetools . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 Standard Insurance Company . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 Stone & Youngberg LLC . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 The Cooperative Purchasing Network . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 The Southern California Gas Company . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Tyler Technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 U.S. Communities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 Vavrinek, Trine, Day & Co LLP . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 Vicenti, Lloyd + Stutzman LLP . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 & 21 Virco Manufacturing Corp. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Back Cover VSP . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42 Willdan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44 Windsor Management Group . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 WLC Architects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44 ZUK Financial Group . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
sudoku 4 9 2 7 3 5 8 6 1
8 3 1 6 4 2 7 5 9
5 6 7 8 9 1 4 2 3
9 5 8 2 6 4 1 3 7
from page 47
3 7 4 5 1 8 6 9 2
2 1 6 9 7 3 5 8 4
1 2 5 4 8 9 3 7 6
6 8 3 1 2 7 9 4 5
7 4 9 3 5 6 2 1 8
Winter 2009 | 49
lastwords
By nearly every measure, our public schools continue to struggle to serve our most vulnerable children well. ~ Education Trust-West
94%
In the annual CASBO membership survey, 94 percent of respondents said they were “satisfied” or “very satisfied” with CASBO.
65vs.35%
In the annual CASBO membership survey, 65 percent of the respondents were female and 35 percent were male. Source: CASBO membership survey, October 2009
Sometimes I lie awake at night, and I ask, “Where have I gone wrong?” Then a voice says to me, “This is going to take more than one night.” ~ Charles M. Schulz
Source: CASBO membership survey, October 2009
It’s never too late to be who you might have been. ~ George Herbert
$1.3 MILLION Association members gave an average of 71,255 volunteer hours in 2005 – or more than $1.3 million in service. Source: American Society of Association Executives
© CASBO 2009
50 | California School Business
Offered through PFM Financial Services LLC CO-SPONSORED BY CASBO AND ACSA
Winter 2009 | 51
52 | California School Business