March 2018
clinical initiatives, research and current updates in treatment
Getting to the Guts of Cancer Immunotherapy Response Kate Siede, Epic Pharmacy Newcastle Over the past decade, interest in the human microbiome, bacteria, viruses and fungi found in and on the human body, has increased considerably.1 A significant driver has been the realisation that the microorganisms that populate the microbiome are not simply passengers in the host. Technological advances have facilitated large-scale analysis of the genetic and metabolic profile specifically of the gut microbiome.1 Through these insights, the gut microbiome can be thought to direct immune system function and can either promote health or initiate chronic disease.1,2,3 Both animal and human studies have also investigated how the gut microbiome can influence response to different classes of medications.4,5,6,7,8,9 This article will focus primarily on the influence of the gut microbiome composition on checkpoint inhibitor immunotherapy, drugs that activate the immune system to attack tumours e.g. ipilimumab, nivolumab and pembrolizumab. Preclinical studies have examined the relationship between gut microbiome composition and T cell response to checkpoint inhibitor therapies in mice with melanoma.5,10 Two studies have demonstrated that the anti-tumour effect of these agents was influenced by the microbiome composition; in these cases efficacy was particularly dependent on bacterial species B. fragilis and Bifidobacterium.5, 10 In each of these preclinical mice models, transfer of the “responder” microbiome profile to “non-responder” mice through faecal transplant elicited improved tumour control, suggesting that the gut microbiome modulates tumour response.5,10
Two new clinical studies have further explored the relationship between the gut microbiome and immunotherapy response in humans being treated for melanoma and epithelial tumours.6,8 The results are in line with previous animal models and further demonstrate that composition of gut bacteria can influence response to immunotherapy. Firstly, the oral and gut microbiomes were examined in patients undergoing checkpoint inhibitor immunotherapy to treat melanoma.6 Significant differences were observed in the diversity and composition of the patient gut microbiome in treatment responders versus non-responders. Patients with high Faecalibacterium abundance, meaning a greater diversity in their gut bacteria, had a significantly prolonged progression free survival (PFS) versus those with less diversity. However, patients with a high abundance of Bacteroidales had a shortened PFS compared to those patients with less Bacteroidales.6 Analysis of the patients’ immune responses revealed that those with the beneficial microbes tended to have more immune cells, which may be more likely to infiltrate and kill tumours. Transplanting the microbes from responding patients into germ-free mice and monitoring their response to immunotherapy treatment yielded similar positive results as was observed in humans.6 Another study explored the possibility that dysbiosis, or an imbalance in the microbiome associated with either malignant disease or due to concomitant antibiotic (ATB) use, could contribute to immunotherapy resistance in both tumour-bearing mice and cancer patients.
It was identified that mice treated for 14 days with a broad spectrum ATB had significantly compromised anti-tumour effects and decreased survival when treated with checkpoint inhibitor immunotherapy. ATB use was then examined in human patients with advanced non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), renal cell carcinoma (RCC) or urothelial carcinoma being treated with check point inhibitor immunotherapy. Out of a total of 249 patients, 69 (28%) received antibiotics ( -lactams, fluoroquinolones or macrolides) within two months before or one month after the first administration of immunotherapy. ATBs were generally taken for common indications, such as dental, urinary and pulmonary infections. Both median PFS and overall survival (OS) were significantly shorter in the ATB-treated group compared to the non-ATB-treated group, with a median PFS of 3.5 months versus 4.1 months, respectively, and a median OS of 11.5 months versus 20.6 months, respectively.8 These studies show that the composition of gut microbiome significantly influences the response to immunotherapy in both human and animal models. Of note is the trend of improved response rates to immunotherapy where gut microbiomes were more diverse suggesting that potential therapeutic modulation of the gut microbiome may be of benefit to patients about to initiate treatment. Lifestyle factors such as judicious use of antibiotics, introduction of high fibre diets containing pre and probiotics and exercise may be ways of improving patients underlying gut health to assist in potentially enhancing checkpoint inhibitor immunotherapy response. References are available on request.