How do you define redundancy? Look at the world the way Generac Industrial Power does and you might change your mind.
The corporate headquarters of Saxon Capital in Glen Allen, Virginia, defines redundancy with Generac’s MPS. For this and more case studies, visit generac.com/mt5.
To you, redundancy means repetition, overlap, and duplication. To Generac Industrial Power, redundancy means fully integrated, built-in paralleling technology; advanced digital controls; and rigorous prototype testing on solutions as large as 9MW. That’s just how we see the world. And thousands of mission critical service providers, municipalities and other commercial and industrial facilities that installed a Generac industrial power system, know just what we mean. For more information on our products, call 1-888-GENERAC or visit us at generac.com/mt5.
For more info, enter 61 at www.MT-freeinfo.com For more info, enter 61 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
Over 900,000 products for the ones who get it done. Call. Click. Stop By.速 www.grainger.com For more info, enter 62 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
We can take wind turbines to new heights.
Keep maintenance costs down and send productivity soaring with the complete range of Mobil SHC synthetic lubricants and greases. Each one is formulated to offer outstanding all-around performance, including equipment protection, keep-clean characteristics, and oil life. Take Mobilgear SHC XMP. Used in more than 30,000 wind turbine gearboxes worldwide, it’s trusted by builders, proven in the field, and supported by exceptional application expertise. Just a few of the reasons we don’t simply make things run. We make them fly. Visit mobilindustrial.com for more.
© 2010 Exxon Mobil Corporation Mobil, Mobil SHC, Mobilgear, and the Pegasus design are trademarks of Exxon Mobil Corporation or one of its subsidiaries.
For more info, enter 63 at www.MT-freeinfo.com For more info, enter 63 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
Contents MAY 2010 • VOL 23, NO 5 • www.MT-ONLINE.com
M A I N T E N A N C E
TECHNOLOGY
®
YEARS
Your Source For CAPACITY ASSURANCE SOLUTIONS
FEATURES CAPACITY ASSURANCE STRATEGIES Simplify Your Priority System
© Infinite-source.net STU CORLETT — FOTOLIA.COM
14
Focus in on this low-tech, high-value approach as a cost-effective way to boost your team’s maintenance performance. Doc Palmer, P.E., MBA, CMRP, Richard Palmer and Associates
POWER TRANSMISSION 18
Clearance And Interference Coupling Fits Check out these tips on when to use and how to determine tolerances with your coupling arrangements.
22
Tom Bishop, P.E., Electrical Apparatus Service Association (EASA)
DEPARTMENTS
THE FUNDAMENTALS
6 8 12 30 34 35 38 38 39 40
5 Ways To Cut Costs While Shooting Your Maintenance Effort In The Foot You may not have asked for it, but here’s a list of some sure-fire ways to do in your program. Raymond L. Atkins, Contributing Editor
GEARMOTOR TECHNOLOGY 25
Geared Up For Power New, proven gearmotor technology is helping power plants boost their competitiveness, despite the increasing numbers of regulatory and public-relations challenges they seem to be facing. William C. Livoti, Baldor Electric Company
SUPPLY CHAIN LINK 32
Sustainability And Your Facility: It’s All About Choices You’re not alone in this ongoing journey. Just ask your suppliers. M. Randi Young, LEED AP, Grainger
JUST HOW GOOD ARE YOU?
My Take Uptime Communications The Green Edge Solution Spotlight Marketplace Information Highway Classified Supplier Index Viewpoint
Applications For
The 2010 NORTH AMERICAN MAINTENANCE EXCELLENCE (NAME) AWARD Are Available Online
www.nameaward.com MAY 2010
MT-ONLINE.COM | 3
M A I N T E N A N C E
TECHNOLOGY
®
T his b ank g uar a nt e e s a p o s i t i v e r e t u r n.
YEARS
Your Source For CAPACITY ASSURANCE SOLUTIONS
May 2010 • Volume 23, No. 5 ARTHUR L. RICE President/CEO arice@atpnetwork.com
BILL KIESEL Executive Vice President/Publisher bkiesel@atpnetwork.com
JANE ALEXANDER Editor-In-Chief jalexander@atpnetwork.com
Investing in power system testing will pay dividends—for years.
CR922 5MW Load Bank
RICK CARTER Executive Editor rcarter@atpnetwork.com
Load banking can detect failing conditions before they damage your equipment or disrupt your power.
Director of Creative Services rbuttstadt@atpnetwork.com
Avoid downtime. Contact ComRent® today.
Editorial/Production Assistant gpietras@atpnetwork.com
ROBERT “BOB” WILLIAMSON KENNETH E. BANNISTER RAYMOND L. ATKINS Contributing Editors
RANDY BUTTSTADT GREG PIETRAS ELLEN SANDKAM Direct Mail 800-223-3423, ext. 110 esandkam@atplists.com
EDWARD KANE Reprint Manager 800-382-0808, ext. 131 ekane@fostereprints.com
ComRent
®
888.881.7118 | www.ComRent.com For more info, enter 84 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
Editorial Office: 1300 South Grove Ave., Suite 105 Barrington, IL 60010 847-382-8100 / FAX 847-304-8603 WWW.MT-ONLINE.COM
Subscriptions: FOR INQUIRIES OR CHANGES CONTACT JEFFREY HEINE, 630-739-0900 EXT. 204 / FAX 630-739-7967
M A I N T E N A N C E
TECHNOLOGY
®
Your Source For
CAPACITY ASSURANCE SOLUTIONS
Apply for a FREE FREE,, one-year subscription at
www.subscribeMT.com w b ib MT
Maintenance Technology® (ISSN 0899-5729) is published monthly by Applied Technology Publications, Inc., 1300 S. Grove Avenue, Barrington, IL 60010. Periodicals postage paid at Barrington, Illinois and additional offices. Arthur L. Rice, III, President. Circulation records are maintained at Maintenance Technology®, Creative Data, 440 Quadrangle Drive, Suite E, Bolingbrook, IL 60440. Maintenance Technology® copyright 2010 by Applied Technology Publications, Inc. Annual subscription rates for nonqualified people: North America, $140; all others, $280 (air). No subscription agency is authorized by us to solicit or take orders for subscriptions. Postmaster: Please send address changes to Maintenance Technology®, Creative Data, 440 Quadrangle Drive, Suite E, Bolingbrook, IL 60440. Please indicate position, title, company name, company address. For other circulation information call (630) 739-0900. Canadian Publications agreement No. 40886011. Canada Post returns: IMEX, Station A, P.O. Box 54, Windsor, ON N9A 6J5, or email: cpcreturns@ wdsmail.com. Submissions Policy: Maintenance Technology® gladly welcomes submissions. By sending us your submission, unless otherwise negotiated in writing with our editor(s), you grant Applied Technology Publications, Inc. permission, by an irrevocable license, to edit, reproduce, distribute, publish, and adapt your submission in any medium, including via Internet, on multiple occasions. You are, of course, free to publish your submission yourself or to allow others to republish your submission. Submissions will not be returned. “Maintenance Technology®” is a registered trademark of Applied Technology Publications, Inc. Printed in U.S.A.
4|
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
Make
MAY 2010
Tired of the same routine?
Buy a Vac that lasts!
Stop throwing your money away on electric vacuum cleaners that are sure to fail. EXAIR vacuums have been engineered to withstand the dust, dirt, chips and liquids common to industrial environments. Ours have no electric motors or other moving parts to clog or wear out. EXAIR’s 30 Day Unconditional Guarantee assures your complete satisfaction. Let our five year “Built To Last” warranty give you the peace of mind that your vacuum will always work and end your trips to the dumpster.
Two-Way Drum Pump
Chip Vacuum Has No Moving Parts
Vacuum, Blow and Transfer
Heavy Duty Vacuum Resists Wear
The compressed air powered Reversible Drum Vac™ will quickly fill or empty a 55 gallon drum in 90 seconds. Coolant sumps can be easily refilled, floor spills vacuumed or contaminated liquids transferred to filtration tanks in minutes.
Chip Vac™ is powered by compressed air and vacuums chips directly into a drum. It is easy to move from drum to drum to keep materials separate for recycling. Clean chips from floors, fixtures, work surfaces and machines.
The Vac-u-Gun™ uses compressed air to provide solutions to a wide variety of industrial housekeeping problems. This versatile tool is a vacuum gun, blow gun and a transfer tool all in one. Three Vac-u-Gun systems with tools are available.
Heavy Duty Dry Vac™ attaches to an ordinary 55 gallon open-top drum to turn it into a powerful, industrial duty vacuum cleaner. It has been engineered to vacuum more dry materials in less time than ordinary vacs. Ideal for abrasives.
• Durable stainless steel
• Dust free operation
• Durable die cast construction
• Wear resistant construction
• Lightweight, portable
• No motors to clog or wear out
• No moving parts
• Heavy duty tools
• Low cost
• Dust free operation
• Includes plastic tools
• Quiet - Only 77 dBA!
•
5, 30 and 55 gallon models available
•
5, 30 and 55 gallon models available
• No motors to clog or wear out •
Video demo on web site V
www.exair.com/48/462.htm
• Improved design - half the noise! •
Video demo on web site V
www.exair.com/48/465.htm
www.exair.com/48/4170.htm www.exair.com/48/463.htm For more info, enter 65 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
Manufacturing Intelligent Compressed Air® Products Since 1983 For more info, 11510 Goldcoast Drive • Cincinnati, Ohio • 45249-1621 • (800) 903-9247 • fax: (513) 671-3363 enter 65 at E-mail: techelp@exair.com • www.exair.com www.MT-freeinfo.com
@EXAIR
MY TAKE
Jane Alexander, Editor-In-Chief
Gone Fishing
I
love to fish. Show me an open body of water and I’m in—with a line, that is. For me, there’s nothing like coming home after a hectic day, grabbing my trusty Zebco 33, along with a few night crawlers (both live and Gulp) and wandering out to the lake behind our place to relax and indulge. As I write this column, it’s still too chilly for our bass to be spawning, and, sadly, for me to be hauling them in. (For the record, I am a great bass fisher. And, yes, I bait my own hook.) Right now, we’re after whatever will bite, “we” being the wonderful gentleman with whom I share my life and several old neighborhood geezers. Some evenings, I outlast all of these guys, continuing on my quest long after they’ve “headed to the house.” Except for the rattling of my little red, battery-lit bobber, things get pretty quiet along our shoreline after the sun goes down. The evening hours I spend there are ideal for contemplation—often of matters totally unrelated to Bill Dance’s latest tips on drag ratios, past and future BassPro seminars, what color Chatterstick works best when, etc. Lately, I’ve found myself thinking about last January’s Viewpoint column by MT publisher Bill Kiesel, entitled “Sailing Into 2010 & Beyond.” In it, Bill compared sailing—for which he clearly has a passion—to the business of publishing magazines. Neither pursuit is as easy to master as it might seem. Both, however, can be extremely exhilarating at times. Much like fishing and editing… I came out of industry, into this line of work by sheer accident. I desperately needed a job; someone desperately needed an editor for a newly acquired engineering-based publication. Early on, my first publisher ordered me never to waste time fretting over my lack of editorial credentials. Instead, I was told to simply “find a successful parade and put us in front of it.” I’ve tried to do so ever since. As an editor, I’m constantly trolling for new ideas and content to build magazines around. Yet, despite the phase of the moon, my lure of choice and the utterly perfect spot from which I cast, there’s no guarantee I’ll bring in the types of things that match up with your interests and help you solve problems. No matter how hard I “fish,” I never know what I’ll pull out—or if there is anything to pull out at all. That’s because, just like in sailing and angling, conditions can change quickly and dramatically when you’re editing/growing magazines. I’m lucky, though. Some of you take the time to tell us what you think of our editorial products. A real measure of success for me is in your anecdotal accounts of how and where our publications show up— in pages of selected articles posted on bulletin boards in plants; in shiny magazines seen on airplanes; in dog-eared copies strewn about break shacks and passed around in meetings. Those are my “trophies,” and I thank you and our many contributors for helping us reel them in. So, please stay in touch. I’ll always look forward to comparing notes on how we can best serve your information needs and, if you care to talk about them, “the big ones” that got away! MT jalexander@atpnetwork.com
6|
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
MAY 2010
What if I could have predicted where and when my system might fail?
Get the earliest warning possible with Siemens’ SPPA-D3000 all-inclusive, non-invasive, start-to-finish monitoring and diagnostic suite. Wouldn’t it be great to know how your plant will operate in the future, allowing you to make informed critical decisions? With Siemens’ SPPA-D3000, your entire plant is monitored through all operational cycles to provide the earliest and most accurate warning of abnormal conditions. Our non-intrusive technologies provide realtime, in-depth, critical feedback and our root-cause analysis allows you to optimize your predictive maintenance program. Run your assets with more confidence. Contact us today, and start listening to your plant. www.siemens.com/energy/controls
Answers for energy. For more info, enter 66 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
UPTIME
Bob Williamson, Contributing Editor
Employee Training Often Misses The Mark What happened to employee training? I mean REAL training AND qualification to do specific tasks right the first time, every time. Companies across America invest millions in new equipment, but little (if any) on employee training to set it up, operate it, maintain it or repair it. This is NOT sound business sense. I began developing operations and maintenance training back in the early 1970s—something I continue doing now. I focus on training for apprentices, training for new employees, training to optimize old equipment and training on one-of-a-kind high-tech equipment. As we moved into the 1980s, automation reached new levels with microprocessor controls, PLCs and robotics. Machines “talked” to each other and became an integrated process. Mechanical and electrical components were blended into hybrid devices. Learning ability and mechanical aptitude became critical hiring or job-assignment criteria. Equipment purchases often included specific requirements for structured employee training. This made perfect sense. I believe there is NO excuse for assigning an untrained employee to do a task, especially on state-of-the-art equipment, without job-specific and procedure-based training and qualification processes. Without formal and specific training and qualification, equipment is treated like other—older, less technologically advanced— machinery in the area. Often improperly operated and maintained, it is damaged by default. What to do The National Association of Manufacturers (NAM) and the Manufacturing Skills Standards Council (MSSC) have been defining and attempting to address the critical skills shortage for over 10 years. They’ve made real strides. The general public and school systems, though, have been slow to respond. Individual companies must attract, train and retain the most appropriately skilled and knowledgeable people if they wish to remain competitive. Employees’ skills and knowledge must be developed to allow them to master the unique requirements for operations and maintenance of new equipment as advanced manufacturing technologies are added to the business. Without appropriate skills and knowledge deployment in the workplace, new equipment simply will not perform as designed during its planned life cycle. This sad state of affairs MUST change. 8|
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
How to do it There are many ways to boost employee skills and knowledge. The most frequently used—but leasteffective—process is based on classrooms, teachers, manuals and books or online courses. Formal and structured, this approach tends to be long, drawnout and theoretical, with minimal hands-on applied learning. Another common approach is vendorsupplied training for new equipment. Unless there is a detailed “training specification” unique to your plant and employee needs, vendor-supplied training often doesn’t hit the mark, either. It tends to be of an informal, unstructured, “show-and-tell” nature, with limited print materials (documentation), and almost never a “qualification” component where employees demonstrate their skills and knowledge. The MOST effective workplace training is very focused, fast and sustainable. We discovered this fact during World War II, in our deployment of a structured process called “Training Within Industry” (TWI). From 1940 through 1945, TWI was the predominant method for training U.S. military personnel, as well as for training housewives working in the factories that supported the war effort. Training for job-task “mastery” was essential. Later on, Douglas MacArthur and Dr. W. Edwards Deming used TWI to help rebuild Japan’s industry. Although this method that contributed to ending the war eventually fell out of favor in the U.S., it is still used today in progressive Japanese companies worldwide—including the U.S.-based operations of Toyota, Honda and Nissan. Numerous variations of TWI have been developed and used in our military and manufacturing operations since the ‘60s. Generally, they still follow an “Instructional Systems Design Model” to specifically address business’ and employees’ learning and training needs. Alas, over the past 20 years, countless U.S. firms that once invested in strong training and development programs discontinued them as part of cost-cutting initiatives and reductions of “non-value-adding” activities. Today, many of these businesses are feeling the uncomfortable results of those cutbacks. Meanwhile, most emerging industrial nations (Mexico, India, China, Turkey, etc.) have recognized the value of advanced manufacturing technologies AND formal employee training. Continued on page 10 MAY 2010
UPTIME
In my own experience as a mechanic and tool and machine designer, I’ve personally seen the benefits of training, as well as the downside of no training. Steps to efficient and effective training 1. Focus on “critical assets” as defined in corporate Strategic Goals, or which are identified as constraints in a “Value-Stream Map” of the process flow, as high maintenance cost or as high, unplanned downtime in a critical process. Focus on the critical few and make rapid and sustainable improvements. 2. Perform a “duty-task analysis” to codify targeted equipment skills and knowledge requirements to operate, maintain, setup/changeover, supervise, train and coach. The duty-task analysis results in documents are used for: a) employee training-needs analysis; b) OJT (on-the-job training) guides; and c) on-job performance-qualification checklists. Review/consult the following: • Equipment documentation, manuals, schematics, drawings, etc. • Detailed procedures (operating, maintenance, calibration, repair, changeover, etc.) • Current highly skilled employees (hourly and salary), aka “job incumbents” 3. Compile the duty-task findings in a readily searchable database. Include references to documentation, procedures and highly qualified individuals (current or potential “equipment specialists”). 4. Verify the duty-task analysis findings with the highly skilled job incumbents, supervision and management. Revise as needed. 5. Gather materials to be included in training and development processes for a “training reference library.” Reference these materials in the applicable duty-task lists. 6. Develop new materials for training and development as needed, and reference them in the applicable dutytask lists. These materials include: • Print materials to supplement equipment manufacturer’s materials • Detailed procedures (operating, maintenance, calibration, repair, changeover, etc.) • Audio-visual media: bought or developed in-plant • Supervisory and OJT coaching MAY 2010
7. Develop a company-specific “Training & Qualification Process” guide and process-flow map to show how the new training process should work. 8. Define “Equipment Specialist” roles and responsibilities. These may include: • Being involved in all activities pertaining to the targeted equipment • Serving as coordinator of employee training on targeted equipment • Conducting OJT/coaching on targeted equipment 9. Assign “Equipment Specialist” designation to the one person who is the most skilled and knowledgeable in the equipment and is willing to serve as an “Equipment Specialist” and training coach. 10. Perform a targeted employee-training “needs analysis” (assessment) using duty-task lists to determine the following skill and knowledge levels: • Currently skilled and knowledgeable • Needs training • Needs refresher training • Not needed 11. Develop targeted employee training plan for specific equipment and related processes that includes: • Duty-task lists to be mastered • Training reference library materials needed • Assign “Equipment Specialist” as a resource person, training coordinator, coach • Schedule for self-study time, coaching and OJT 12. Begin your training and qualification process based on priority needs of: 1) equipment; 2) manufacturing process; and 3) people on each shift or crew. Remember to remain focused on the business needs identified in Step #1. 13. Evaluate effectiveness of training and refine as needed to be sure that the business goals are achieved and that training for “qualification” to perform (or training for skill mastery) is achieved. MT-ONLINE.COM | 9
UPTIME
Investing in training Imagine what might happen if you were to give your car keys to a teenager and say: “Figure it out for yourself. I’m confident you can learn to drive this car. Go for it, but be careful. It’s a new car.” In many cases, today’s equipment and processes are more complex than the family car—and as complex as a helicopter. Equipment costing millions of dollars coupled with little or no employee training will fail prematurely and cost significantly more than planned to keep running. Training is NOT a COST, it is an investment. Operating and maintaining equipment WITHOUT employee training is an uncontrollable COST. Therefore, why NOT invest in training? I’ve used this rule of thumb for years: Employee training for new equipment should be budgeted at 5% to 10% of the total installed cost (maybe more depending on the complexity and sheer size of the project). Ongoing equipment- and job-specific training should be budgeted at 2% to 5% of payroll. Training specifications Another message for equipment procurement: Include a “training specification” in the bid, quotation and purchase materials. Describe the prospective training audience
(operators, maintainers, setup/changeover staff, engineers, programmers, et al). Specify type and formats of training documentation to be provided. Specify criteria by which vendor-supplied training will be judged successful. Specify when various training will begin and end (i.e. pre-installation, pre-startup, startup and commissioning, running or steady-state operation). Withhold a percent of the final payment until the specified training is completed. Treat employee training as another project deliverable. To do otherwise is gambling with the reliability and performance of your new equipment—and gambling with your business competitiveness. I believe in very specific employee training to assure that equipment performs as designed throughout its entire life cycle. I’ve seen this type of training work over and over again since the ‘70s—in many different types of companies and industries. It works every time! In my own experience as a mechanic and a tool and machine designer, I have personally seen the benefits of training, as well as the downside of no training. Does your employee training miss the mark…or is it right on target? MT RobertMW2@cs.com
Your Best Solution
TM
Whether you are looking for a precision cleaner, degreaser, lubricant, or sealant product, CRC will always provide solutions that work. CRC has been the brand of choice in the Industrial market for over 50 years! Go online to www.crcindustries.com/ei to see our entire product offering of MRO maintenance chemicals. Use our online product selector guide to easily find the perfect solution for your individual application needs.
Precision Cleaners
Degreasers
Lubricants and Penetrants
Sealants, Adhesives and Threadlockers
www.crcindustries.com/ei For more info, enter 67 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
10 |
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
MAY 2010
International Maintenance Excellence Conference September 22 to 24
Join the Experts in Toronto This sixth-annual gathering of industry and academic experts from around the world will again offer unparalleled insight into modern maintenance and asset-management techniques for plant and facility professionals. Hosted by Dr. Andrew Jardine of the University of Toronto’s Centre for Maintenance Optimization & Reliability Engineering, and co-produced with Maintenance Technology magazine, IMEC 2010 offers two days of keynote presentations and one day of in-depth workshops at the University’s conference venue in the heart of downtown Toronto. With a dinner at the famed CN Tower included, and unlimited opportunity to discuss the issues with international experts, IMEC 2010 provides a well-rounded, exciting learning event for maintenance professionals everywhere. For more information about IMEC 2010, please contact Bill Kiesel at bill@imec.ca / 847-382-8100, ext. 116 IMEC is organized by:
Registration online at www.imec.ca
For more info, enter 68 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
COMMUNICATIONS
Ken Bannister, Contributing Editor
Planner/Scheduler Partnerships Viewing Maintenance as an organizational hub, we have, to date in this Partnership series, explored its relational connection with internal and external partners at the department management level. In reality, Maintenance connects with others on many different levels, something that influences the decisional outcomes of the entire Maintenance organization. These connections take place on a daily basis through actions—and non-action! This high level of connectivity is evident even in a minor, seemingly insignificant, preventive maintenance event such as a simple oil and filter change. Quarterbacking the event is usually the role of the Maintenance planner/scheduler, who is, arguably, the most important person within the Maintenance and Operations groups. It’s the planner/scheduler who controls the field of play with a series of connective actions that must take place to ensure the successful completion of any maintenance event. On any given day within an organization, thousands of decisions are made. Reaching any single decision calls for a series of connective actions or events linked together via established business processes that predetermine at what point a decision is required to make the next connection. For example, a simple PM event requiring an oil and filter change requires the planner/scheduler to set up and execute the PM in three distinctive stages. Stage 1: PM event set-up To execute his/her job correctly with regard to any planned or unplanned maintenance event, a planner/scheduler must develop an initial job or work plan that describes the actions needed to complete the intended event. This simple chronology requires the planner/scheduler to connect with the Engineering Department and the machine manufacturer or the lubricant supplier (depending on the best resource) to determine the required lubricant, the filter,
12 |
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
the recommended change-out procedure and the change-out interval. Once the work plan is established and entered into the CMMS, materials must be ordered and placed in stock, which leads to the Maintenance planner/scheduler having to connect with the Maintenance Inventory Control person, who in turn connects with the Purchasing agent, who in turn connects with the material supplier. If the material supplier is a new one, the Purchasing agent must also connect with Accounting to set up invoicing and payment schedules.
Quarterbacking the maintenance event is usually the role of the planner/ scheduler, who is, arguably, the most important person within the Maintenance and Operations groups. After materials have been shipped and received, the receiver connects with the Inventory Control person, who in turn reconnects with the planner to advise that the oil-change materials are now in stock—and the department can move on to Stage 2, in which the event can now be scheduled. Stage 2: The maintenance event To perform the event, the Maintenance planner/ scheduler must now connect with the applicable
MAY 2010
COMMUNICATIONS
It’s the planner/scheduler who controls the field of play with a series of connective actions that must take place to ensure the successful completion of any maintenance event. Trades foreman, who in turn connects with the technician who will perform the oil and filter change. The technician proceeds to the inventory crib and connects with the Inventory Control person to gather the oil and filter materials. Then, it’s off to the jobsite, where the technician may or may not need to connect with the Production foreman and/or operator to receive control of the equipment on which to work. Once the oil change is completed, the technician again connects with the Production supervisor and/or operator to return control of the equipment, then reconnects with his/her own direct supervisor to deliver the completed work order.
How smooth the connection path is depends greatly on the systems and business processes already in place and on the organizational ability of the planner/scheduler. Stage 3: The paperwork With the event completed and equipment available for work, the Maintenance planner/scheduler may choose to connect with the Trades supervisor and/or the Production foreman and/or equipment operator to perform a work-quality check. Confirming that the work is completed satisfactorily, the Maintenance planner/scheduler then connects with the CMMS coordinator or clerk (if applicable), to have the work order closed and filed within the CMMS.
MAY 2010
During the performance of the oil change, should the technician find a problem requiring additional attention, he/she will connect with the Trades supervisor to discuss the matter or write down the requirements on the work order. The Trades supervisor once again connects with the planner/scheduler to discuss the new or additional work requirements, after which the planner/scheduler repeats the entire connection cycle by commencing with the new work requirement at Stage 1. The power of connection What we see in this scenario calls to mind the lyrics of an old song: “The knee bone’s connected to the thighbone, the thighbone’s connected to the hip bone, the hip bone’s connected to the…” A series of purposeful connective events involving both Maintenance and non-Maintenance Department personnel are charted for a simple oil and filter change. Setting up and executing this simple event requires over 20 connections to take place, all of it carefully orchestrated by the Maintenance planner/scheduler. The connection path will change according to the availability of repair parts, tools, trained resources, equipment availability, communication tools, etc. How smooth that path is will depend greatly on the systems and business processes already in place, at both the departmental and organizational levels, and on the organizational ability of the planner/scheduler. With this kind of connective power, it is easy to understand those who conjecture that a good Maintenance planner/scheduler may be equivalent to three technicians! How well are you connected? MT
Ken Bannister is lead partner and principal consultant with Engtech Industries, Inc. Telephone: (519) 469-9173; e-mail: kbannister@engtechindustries.com.
MT-ONLINE.COM | 13
Taking a straightforward path to excellence…
Simplify Your Priority System
Focus in on this low-tech, high-value approach as a way to boost your maintenance performance.
Doc Palmer, P.E., MBA, CMRP Richard Palmer and Associates
14 |
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
T
he work-order priority system often goes unnoticed as a great opportunity for boosting maintenance performance. We focus our attention on big initiatives and technology, and few, if any, vendors try to sell us a new priority system. Restructuring such a system requires no technology or cost, but it’s one of those little things that can really help—or really hinder— progress toward maintenance excellence. The need for priorities The need to manage maintenance actively is nothing new. John Day of Alumax points out that in order of preference, people would much rather work on what they enjoy, what they are good at or what they think is important—before working on what is actually important [Ref. 1]. W. Edwards Deming states in his Point 11 that management must implement “aids and helpful leadership” [Ref. 2]. The workorder priority system is this type of invaluable aid. Nevertheless, we must see the priority system in context. Priority issues usually go away altogether when facilities begin a solid weekly scheduling effort. That’s because crews noticeably complete more work. Entire backlogs typically disappear when a scheduling effort first takes off. Therefore, the purpose of the priority system is to drive scheduling. Sometimes we forget this obvious concept. So, let’s discuss priorities in the context of coordinating maintenance work with scheduling. MAY 2010
CAPACITY ASSURANCE STRATEGIES
Adjectives vs. Time-Driven The result of poor coordination is less-than-optimum plant performance and maintenance productivity at only 35% (as measured by wrench time), with much work that could improve plant performance left uncompleted (whether identified in the backlog or not). The prevailing maintenance culture is: “Our job is to take care of operations, and backlog is fill-in work.” What we really want, however, is world-class plant performance, driven, in part, by a productive maintenance force whose culture is: “Our job is to take care of the backlog, which will take care of operations. Urgent calls from operations means that we did not do/are not doing our job.” A plant needs a valid priority system to help maintenance schedule the right work and with minimal interruptions. This type of priority system coordinates selecting the proper work out of the backlog for the weekly schedule as a goal to promote productive maintenance work completion. It also coordinates operations and maintenance in properly selecting new work that should rightfully bypass the backlog and interrupt this week’s schedule. Complexity of priorities A priority system may be too simple or too complex. An overly simplistic system would have three or fewer choices. (Many plants only have three.) Regardless of the formal descriptions, having only three choices means “Do it now,” “Do it tomorrow” or “It will never get done,” in the minds of the requestors. A limited selection is the genesis of the prevailing “Our job is to take care of operations, and backlog is fill-in work” maintenance culture. The morning meeting drives the maintenance work for that day. Nearly all the new work orders are level two. We need five levels to drive the planning and scheduling process. (More levels than five are okay because they extend the use of the full five. In other words, even if no one ever picks a 10, more people pick a 4 or 5.) While many other plants may think they have more than three choices, in reality, they only have three. Consider these commonly used choices: Safety, Emergency, Urgent, PM, Routine, Outage. This system appears to have six choices, but PM is not a priority; it is a “Work Type.” Outage is not a priority either; it is a “Unit Condition.” Furthermore, Safety is also not a priority—it is a special consideration we might call “Priority Type.” Obviously, not all safety concerns have the same urgency. Be careful blending in areas of concern (such as Safety, Environmental, Availability, Efficiency and Legal, to name a few) that should be separate issues or fields for sorting. Thus, a seemingly sophisticated priority system of six choices may only have three in practice. This is too simple. On the other hand, priority systems can become too complex. We just cannot seem to keep ourselves from overcomplicating something if we get the chance. The primary culprit seems to be adding other inappropriate codes as discussed above, but to an extreme of having 15 or more choices. Even without inappropriate codes, adjectives seem MAY 2010
The pendulum swings back & forth
Words
Times
Fig. 1. There seems to be a swinging pendulum within each plant favoring adjective-based priorities for a while, then time-driven ones.
to multiply, describing a multitude of different scenarios for various equivalent senses of urgency. Some plants that use a time-driven system also split fine hairs with choices of 1, 2 and 3 days; 1, 2 and 3 weeks; and 1, 2 and 3 or more months, etc. There is nothing wrong with using either an adjective or time-based system (or some combination of the two), but the system should facilitate communication. In addition, some of the adjectives should contain at least an expectation of time. There seems to be a swinging pendulum (Fig. 1) within each plant. Adjective-based priorities may be favored for a while, then the pendulum swings in favor of time-driven ones. Even with appropriate adjectives or times, systems with too many choices encourage users to avoid reading and simply choose a more urgent level, fearing that maintenance will never complete other work. Furthermore, it is very difficult to reason why a work order would require, say, a priority of two months instead of one month. In addition, beware of “aging” strategies where, over time, a work order’s priority rises. A squeaky door will never be more important than a boiler feed pump—no matter how long the door has been squeaking. (Moreover, the improved productivity in weekly scheduling makes aging a moot point.) Another potentially complicated system is a RIME type. These systems bear some responsibility for taking the decision away from the user by factoring in some of a plant’s predetermined knowledge of asset criticality, work-type importance or other factors. RIME stands for the Ranking Index of Maintenance Expenditures, originated by Ramond Associates in Chicago in the early 1980s [Ref. 3]. Many CMMS tools automatically provide such a calculated priority. A RIME type system might multiply the predetermined asset criticality (1-10 with 10 the highest) by the work type criticality (1-10 with safety the highest). Two issues with this system might be the possibility of overlooking safety. A safety work order involving potential death on a non-critical asset might score only a 10 (1 x 10) while a PM on a supercritical piece of production equipment might score a 20 (10 x 2). Simple communication also breaks down with complicated MT-ONLINE.COM | 15
CAPACITY ASSURANCE STRATEGIES
A Reasonable Priority System With At Least 5 Levels
0 1 2 3 4
Now, Emergency <2 Days, Urgent <2 Weeks, Serious <1 Month, Medium Priority >1 Month, Lower Priority
Fig. 2. A typical 5-level priority system
priorities. It is more difficult to explain why one person’s work order only scored a 30 while someone else’s scored a 60. With this in mind, an effective system should have at least five levels (but fewer than 10) with a straightforward (non-multiplied) structure. There seems to be a tradeoff between the science of better determining the “true” relative priority of work using more complicated systems, and the ease of discussing the relative priority using simpler systems. Priority systems should also contain at least an expectation of time. Consider Fig. 2 as a decent system: 0-Start now. 1-Complete in two days. 2-Complete in two weeks. 3-Complete in a month. 4-Takes longer than a month. Including a few descriptive words helps, but don’t overly confuse the levels with areas of concern (such as Safety) without qualifiers. The 5-level system offers enough choices to encourage selection beyond this week, but few enough to promote easy discussion. The requester should select the initial priority because he/she sees the problem and knows how fast it is leaking. However, because the requester might not have a feel for the big picture of other work in the backlog, the plant should allow persons to challenge the priority later. Managers and supervisors in a short morning meeting can scan and easily discuss new work orders saying, “This is not a 2, it ought to be a 4.” Managing with priorities Consider a plant that uses a simple system to manage coordination. In the example 5-level system (Fig. 2), Priority 0s and 1s are defects to be driven out by management. The need for maintenance was not discovered in time to plan and schedule the work. Management develops Pareto charts to see the most common causes of the defects whether they be from engineering (not replacing troublesome equipment), operations (not operating correctly), maintenance (not fixing things to last), or management itself (allowing abuse of the priority system). 16 |
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
Some tips for using a 5-level priority system include considering work with the same priority and PMs, as well as some other ideas to make the priority system more acceptable. Making the priority system acceptable for use coincides with making the weekly schedule acceptable (our overall context to begin with). Among equal priorities, schedule either oldest work orders first or largest work orders first. (The first way helps consider the aging issue better.) The exception is that PMs always come first amid equal-priority work orders. Maintenance PMs generally should have at least two weeks to complete, which allows for better placement in the weekly schedule. (This preference places a burden on operations to do any weekly or daily PMs.) Weekly schedules should follow the priority system, but should include less-urgent work orders for common lockouts. It is also okay to have production, maintenance-supervisor and manager input in the schedule, based simply on preferences. But, schedule 100% of labor hours available; don’t rest with only the preferred jobs. Encourage requesters of new work not to declare false emergencies by selecting priorities 0 or 1—but never prohibit their use. If a real emergency arises or urgent work can’t wait, a 0 or a 1 is appropriate. The work is what it is. Later, during execution of the weekly schedule, inform everyone that it is acceptable to break the schedule—but that any work breaking the schedule should be a 0 or a 1. Management must later analyze the 0s and 1s and relentlessly manage them. Planners should plan work orders within half the time allowed to complete them, i.e. plan a Priority 1 within one day (in our example system). Never insist that a crew wait on planning or scheduling to work any job. The weekly schedule only succeeds in improving productivity when crews are allowed to break it. Oddly, productivity rises even when the weekly schedule isn’t fully met. We meet success in improved productivity—not in perfect schedules, plans or priorities. We aren’t just trying to complete the right work with the priority system, but more of the right work. MAY 2010
Conclusion Granted, many plants that have extensive complaints about their existing priority system may not have a very productive maintenance force. When a maintenance force begins weekly scheduling in earnest, many operations see their complaints shift to finding enough work to keep the maintenance force busy. The conundrum is that without a decent priority system, it is hard to begin the weekly scheduling effort. The lesson is to go ahead and create a simple workable priority system—then start weekly scheduling as soon as possible. Don’t be taken in by a pretty face. A sophisticated priority system is not “the answer.” The answer is to do the right maintenance at the right time. To make this work, we must identify enough of the right work and coordinate it with a productive maintenance group. Using a simple priority system can go a long way in helping you coordinate and boost your maintenance effectiveness. MT References 1. Day, John E. Jr., P.E.,“Maintenance Vision: Total Proactive Maintenance,” presented at Society for Maintenance and Reliability Professionals (SMRP) Annual Conference, October 1993. 2. Deming, W. Edwards, “Who Is Dr. W. Edwards Deming?,” Leadership Institute, Inc. , www/lii/net/deming.html, 6/23/09. 3. Peters, Ralph W., Maintenance Benchmarking and Best Practices, McGraw-Hill, New York, NY, 2006, p 143. Doc Palmer, author of McGraw-Hill’s Maintenance Planning and Scheduling Handbook (on which much of this article is based), is managing partner of Richard Palmer and Associates, based in Jacksonville, FL. Based on his three decades in industry, Palmer currently provides educational and consulting services to help companies achieve successful planning and scheduling programs. Telephone: (904) 228-5700; Web: www.palmerplanning.com; e-mail: docpalmer@palmerplanning.com
. nds e. a h ur opl n yo the pe i r e luke o te, F on a Pow ision t ion. r u i ac c t edit c IV ghly 200 9 AT I I I / h Pre the Na u o r e C c o h u h d t t e m s, and n t w ith are rat while c es Join pro ble, d d ia
e a n reli mpl d an ons . A rt of th tested ed, ully c o tandar i a t g d p a g n s or Ru ,a ef plic s ar PA 70E r i a l ap out all ctured l o o t F t s fa dus arm anu he N of t e in i n tition f ned, m s e g u e.* mp esi for Fluk e c o s are d s . r h e t f er ol of pre e to g ine ans Fluk uke en nici h c e l 0t by F of 1 out ou? 9 t: y rly p ki Nea t about rshi e b a em Wh em firm rch a fre esea t e g rty r tice. a p d o an ut n ion third ent e witho tion nat end dep chang e Na . c o m / in h t o n t by a ject Join . f l u k e cted ns sub ndu w tio y co ecifica e v ww r p u e s tion. S a renc refe Corpor e nd p *Bra 08 Fluk 0 ©2 2333 Ad 0
For more info, enter 69 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
MT-ONLINE.COM | 17
MAY 2010 3409980_02333_ContEng, MainTech, EC-M.indd 1
12/11/08 9:44:26 AM
POWER TRANSMISSION
Clearance And Interference Coupling Fits Fig. 1. A typical gear-tooth-style steel coupling
Check out these tips on when to use and how to determine tolerances with your coupling arrangements. Tom Bishop, P.E. Electrical Apparatus Service Association (EASA)
18 |
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
C
ouplings for connecting shafts (shown in Fig. 1) can be placed in two categories: keyed and keyless. Similarly, the fits of couplings to shafts can be categorized as clearance or interference. A keyless coupling arrangement will always have an interference fit, while a keyed arrangement may have either a clearance or an interference fit. This article will focus on determining when to use a clearance or an interference fit, and how to obtain the tolerances for the resulting fit. Since we are dealing with existing shafts and couplings, the category of keyed or keyless has already been established and will not be considered.
MAY 2010
POWER TRANSMISSION
A
Fig. 2. Set screws over the key may be located on either side of the teeth of a gear-type coupling. If the coupling is a hub type, the set-screw location is usually near the end of the coupling.
Clearance versus interference fits The lower the power rating (actually the lower the transmitted torque), the greater the probability of using a clearance fit between coupling and shaft. Conversely, higher power and torque usually requires an interference fit. Further, as the power and torque requirements become very high, it is more common to find that keyless fits are required. Note that the terms “lower,” “higher” and “very high” are all relative, with no guideline levels associated with them. The questions that often arise are on when to use a clearance fit versus an interference fit, and what tolerance range to use for the applicable clearance or interference. We’ll proceed from applications where a clearance fit can be used, to those requiring progressively greater interference fits. A general rule of thumb: There’s little risk with having more interference than necessary, while there’s more risk in having less. Clearance fit (keys and setscrews) Keyed clearance fit couplings are most frequently used on lower-power applications with shafts under about 2.5 in (about 65 mm). A visual indicator that the fit is clearance rather than interference is that set screws are usually provided over the key when a clearance fit is used (see Fig. 2). The set-screw location “A” of Fig. 2 is more common, but some manufacturers use location “B.” Be sure to remove set screws before trying to remove a coupling. MAY 2010
B
Table I (shown on page 20) reflects clearance fits used for NEMA-framesize motor shafts. The design principle of the clearance fit is that the torque is transmitted through the key, minimizing any sliding of the coupling on the shaft. Whether a clearance fit is acceptable depends on the torque to be transmitted, the coefficient of friction used, the dimensions of the hub and operating speed. If the torque forces or misalignment are excessive, the coupling hub may rock and become loose, leading to fretting. Evidence of this condition will be a fine rust-colored powder at the ends of the coupling fits, often with visible wear to one side of the key and/or keyway. Interference fit (keys) Keyed interference fit couplings are commonly used for applications up to a few thousand horsepower/kW, and speeds up to or slightly above 10,000 rpm. The interference fit standard for most couplings made of medium-carbon steel are 0.00050-0.00075 in/in (mm/mm) interference up to 1800 rpm and 0.00075-0.00100 in/in (mm/mm) over 1800 rpm. Table II (also shown on page 20) reflects interference fits used for NEMA-frame-size motor shafts. The purpose of the interference fit with a keyed shaft is to axially locate the coupling hub and resist forces associated with unbalance and misalignment. A frequently used reference for keyed-coupling interference fits is ANSI/AGMA 9002-B04. Interference fit (keyless) For high-horsepower/kW and high-speed applications, ANSI/ AGMA 9003-B08 or equivalent fits (straight and tapered) are commonly used. The interference for keyless fits needs to be adequate to withstand expected normal and transient loads. Common keyless interference fits range from 0.0015 in/in (mm/mm) to 0.0020 in/in (mm/mm). The Brinell hardness of the hub material is a significant factor in keyless coupling fit. Typical fits for various Brinell hardness (BH) steels are: 0.00175 in/in (mm/mm) for 250 BH, 0.0025 in/in (mm/mm) for 300 BH and 0.0030 in/in (mm/mm) for 330 BH. MT-ONLINE.COM | 19
POWER TRANSMISSION
Coupling bore and key The key is a critical element in successful transmission of torque. The bore and keyway in a coupling hub should be checked before installation. Bores should have surface finishes of 63 to 125 microinches (1.6 to 3.2 micrometers) and must not be eccentric or skewed. If a bore is machined eccentric to the hub axis, the coupling eccentricity may cause vibration. A coupling bore machined askew to the centerline axis will increase the misalignment for which the coupling, shaft and bearings must compensate. The keyway should be cut square and centered to the shaft. The fit of the key is critical in assuring sufficient capacity of the shaft-to-coupling hub interface. Be sure to check that the key fits tightly in the shaft keyway; that the key has a sliding fit (but not be too loose) in the coupling hub keyway; and that the key has a clearance of 0.003 to 0.020 in (0.08 to 0.51 mm) with the hub keyway at the top of the key. The key should have chamfered corners so that it fits in the keyway without riding on the keyway radii. A loosely fitted key can roll or shear when heavily loaded and provide a path from which coupling lubricant can leak. Conversely, too tight a fit will make assembly difficult and increase residual stresses, possibly resulting in premature failure of the coupling hub and/or shaft. A key that is too high in the keyway also could cause the coupling hub to fracture.
Table I. Coupling Clearance Fits for Common NEMA-Frame-Size Shafts
Nominal Shaft size
Decimal Shaft size
Bore Minimum
Bore Maximum
5/8
.625
0.6250
0.6260
7/8
.875
0.8750
0.8760
1 1/8
1.125
1.1250
1.1260
1 3/8
1.375
1.3750
1.3760
1 5/8
1.625
1.6250
1.6260
1 7/8
1.875
1.8750
1.8760
2 1/8
2.125
2.1250
2.1265
2 3/8
2.375
2.3750
2.3765
2 7/8
2.875
2.8750
2.8765
3 3/8
3.375
3.3750
3.3765
Table II. Coupling Interference Fits for Common NEMA-Frame-Size Shafts
Nominal Shaft size
Decimal Shaft size
Bore Minimum
Bore Maximum
5/8
.625
0.6240
0.6245
7/8
.875
0.8740
0.8745
1 1/8
1.125
1.1240
1.1245
1 3/8
1.375
1.3740
1.3745
1 5/8
1.625
1.6230
1.6240
1 7/8
1.875
1.8730
1.8740
2 1/8
2.125
2.1230
2.1240
2 3/8
2.375
2.3730
2.3740
2 7/8
2.875
2.8730
2.8740
3 3/8
3.375
3.3720
3.3735
Coupling heating Steel coupling hubs require an increase of 160 F degrees (90 C) for every mil (0.001 in or 0.025 mm) of interference divided by the hub inside diameter. For example, a steel hub with a 2.125 in-bore with an interference of 0.0015 in will require an increase of 1.5/2.125 x 160 = 113 F degrees (63 C). Thus, if the shaft temperature is 70 F (21 C), the hub temperature must be at least 183 F (84 C). This does not account for potential cooling due to handling time, so as a general rule add about 60 F degrees (33 C) to the calculated expansion temperature to account for these factors. In this example the 20 |
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
target temperature would be 243 F (117 C). If the calculated target temperature exceeds 350 F (177 C), check with the coupling manufacturer to be certain the required temperature will not affect the coupling hub integrity. The hub should be heated on an induction-type bearing heater or in an oven; a torch should not be used. Use of a torch or open flame could cause distortion or a reduction in hardness and strength of the hub material. Before installing the coupling hub, make certain that the inboard and outboard ends have been identified. Removal and reinstallation of an incorrectly installed coupling hub will be difficult or MAY 2010
POWER TRANSMISSION
A general rule of thumb on interference fits: There’s little risk with having more interference than necessary, while there’s more risk in having less. impossible at the installation location. Also, make certain that the grease seals are in place and not damaged before installing the coupling covers. Dynamic balance Don’t simply assume that a new coupling is dynamically balanced. Not all couplings are pre-balanced by the manufacturer—and some are not designed to be balanced. Check with the coupling manufacturer or supplier to determine if a new coupling has been factory balanced. A good practice is to measure vibration levels after replacing a coupling (whether or not it has been balanced) to confirm that the levels are within acceptable limits. The length of the key will affect the balance. To determine the
correct key length, add the length of the shaft keyway to the length of the coupling-hub keyway and divide by two. Lubrication The grease used for couplings is not the same as that used in electric motors. Be sure to use a coupling grease equivalent to that specified by the coupling manufacturer. Lubricant should be replenished when the motor alignment is periodically checked, and the customer should typically replenish the coupling grease on an annual basis. MT Tom Bishop is a technical support specialist for EASA, headquartered in St. Louis, MO. Telephone: (314) 993-2220. For more info, enter 01 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
www.nskamericas.com 1.800.675.9930
When you think “Performance”, you think about maximum productivity. We think about NSK’s HPS™ Spherical Roller Bearings. These High Performance Series bearings maximize uptime and lower maintenance costs with 20% higher limiting speeds and twice the operating life of comparable products. When it comes to motion and control products designed to deliver world-class performance in a wide range of applications, Think NSK. B A L L
B E A R I N G S
|
R O L L E R
B E A R I N G S
|
L I N E A R
M O T I O N
P R O D U C T S
|
T E C H N I C A L
S E R V I C E S
For more info, enter 70 at www.MT-freeinfo.com MAY 2010
MT-ONLINE.COM | 21
5 Ways To Cut Costs While Shooting Your Maintenance Effort In The Foot You may not have asked for it, but here’s a list of some sure-fire ways to do in your program. Raymond L. Atkins Contributing Editor
22 | MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
I
t is quite an achievement to attain lasting success in plant maintenance. So much so, that once a modicum of reliability has been reached in a production facility, the maintenance organization responsible for this achievement would want to solidify its gains. It wouldn’t want to mess with success. It would be loathe to “fix” that which “ain’t broke.” It would be inclined to leave well enough alone. You can bet that if the maintenance manager were in the budgetary decision loop, this is exactly what would occur. As we all know, maintenance reliability doesn’t just happen. Despite the old saw to the contrary, for anybody in our line of work, it is NOT better to be lucky than good. Unfortunately, the maintenance manager frequently is not the only person involved in the maintenance budgeting equation. Consequently, when the economy slows down and times get hard, the reward for a successful maintenance effort can sometimes be expressed as budget cuts. The irony here, of course, is that when a maintenance organization has truly found its stride, it may not seem busy enough to suit upper management. Historic measures of maintenance efficacy—heroic lastminute saves, quick turnarounds on emergency breakdowns and manly all-nighters—are not visible to others in the organization, who may begin to wonder what “those maintenance people” are doing with their time. After all, everything is running along smoothly and quietly, just as it should. “Do we really need all of them?” As another old saying goes, the squeaky wheel gets the grease. By the same token, if that wheel isn’t squeaking, it can be lost in the economic shuffle once the word comes down from corporate to cut costs. If the wheel is rolling as designed; if it is aligned properly; if its PMs are current; if it has been properly maintained by competent maintenance professionals to ensure against surprises and runtime failures; and if it was properly engineered to begin with, installed by a capable contractor and is being supported by a committed staff of professionals who know the process and the equipment, the keepers of the purse might decide that maintenance is as good a place as any to cut costs. When a company is under economic duress, however, financial decisions that look promising in the near term can have long-term negative impact on the health of the process. MAY 2010
A SPECIAL SUPPLEMENT TO MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
Such is the case with the following five sure-fire methodologies—they’re guaranteed to trim dollars from your maintenance budget immediately. Remember, though, that each of these tactics has a hidden cost for your organization in reliability and efficiency, as well as a real cost in dollars that will have to be repaid with interest down the road. #1: Suspend training One of the best methods to employ if you want to have an immediate short-term positive impact on your maintenance budget is to suspend or cancel your training program. Since it’s often difficult to see instant results from training programs, they are often put at risk during economic downturns. Assuming that you’re currently devoting 5% of paid maintenance time to training, that you work a 40-hour week, that you have a workforce of 20 technicians and that your technicians are paid an average of $15 per hour, you can save over $600 per week beginning the very first week, not counting the actual costs associated with training modules, materials and teachers. If your backlog requires attention, these man-hours can be scheduled to other tasks. Or you can simply have your technicians work shorter weeks and take the savings all the way to the bottom line. On the other hand, the first time that a $10,000 bearing goes out because it was not installed properly—due to lack of training—the cost of the replacement part plus production downtime and maintenance overtime will wipe out these savings and more. #2: Reduce staff This popular cost-cutting tactic—aka “Slash and Burn”—is the hands-down favorite in many organizations. While not the approach typically taken by surgical teams, flight crews or fire departments (thankfully), it’s a method that most other industries and enterprises turn to at one time or another. Depending on the geographic location of the facility and the type of industry involved, huge short-term savings can be reaped using this approach, and real money can go straight to the bottom line. If you choose this approach, the tricky part is trying to select which of the current roles and responsibilities on your maintenance team are not actually necessary to the organization’s continued success. To do so, you must assume that you’ve been overstaffed all along, or that you have some unnecessary roles in your organizational structure. Upon making these types of assumptions, you also must acknowledge that you somehow didn’t notice such conditions existed within your organization until the economy slowed and you were faced with reducing your budget. Finding yourself in this situation, incidentally, begs speculation about what you have been doing with your time (but that’s a question for another day). Luckily, the decision to eliminate personnel will probably be made for the maintenance manager by someone who is not actually acquainted with the organizational structure—with just a flick of the pen, based on dollars, not sense. Therefore, the cut won’t really be the maintenance manager’s fault. It will, however, be his/her problem when the plant grinds to a halt and ceases to make product. #3: Postpone or cancel PMs In any well-run maintenance organization, 50%–70% of the technicians’ time is spent on PMs and inspections. This represents a deep well from which you can draw buckets upon buckets of savings, the dollar amounts of which can be quite large. Say your equipment is humming along nicely, and you have a total of 300 hours of PMs coming up for the next week. If you can somehow suspend the laws of maintenance and convince yourself that the reason your operations are running so well has nothing whatsoever to do with your current PM program, you can, with impunity, cut some or all of these hours from the schedule from time to time, particularly on those machines that aren’t giving you any trouble. It’s like finding thousands of MAY 2010
Shaft Alignment
& Geometric Measurement
Rotalign® ULTRA
Vibration Analysis
& Balancing
h WatcOS E D I V ine Onl
VIBXPERT®
Easy-to-use solutions for your maintenance needs! Sales • Rentals • Services
305-591-8935 • www.ludeca.com For more info, enter 71 at www.MT-freeinfo.com MT-ONLINE.COM | 23
A SPECIAL SUPPLEMENT TO MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
dollars of free money lying on the plant floor! Think about it: If you don’t do 150 hours of next week’s PMs—again assuming an average wage of $15 per hour— you can save well over $2000 that week in maintenance salaries alone. That’s without even considering the other costs associated with your PM program, such as parts and materials. If you continue doing this week after week— picking machines that are running well and skipping their PMs—you’ll be into real savings in no time flat. Great! You’ll need that money when it comes time to pay the piper: Sooner than you might imagine, there won’t be any wellrunning equipment to skip. # 4: Only fix what you have to fix Also known as the “Baling Wire & Duct Tape Method,” this cost-cutting avenue is based on the principle that a machine center—or even an entire process—will continue to run long after it has ceased to run well.
Krytox
®
Fluorinated Lubricants
This method assumes that the business gets paid on uptime, not throughput or quality, and relies heavily on the fervent hope that if the maintenance department somehow can just keep things patched together until the economy gets better, “then we’ll be able to afford to fix it right.” It also assumes equipment systems do not wear or break, and even if they somehow did, that replacement parts and components would be free. The problem with this methodology is clear to the maintenance professional—when robbing Peter to pay Paul, that guy Peter will, at some point, want to get his money back. Any machine or process that is not well-maintained will run less and less efficiently over time. It will cease to do what it was designed to do in the manner it was designed to do it in. As it is patched and re-patched, the reliability issues compound, and the machine becomes less and less able to do what it is supposed to do. Eventually, it becomes so out of spec that nothing short of a major overhaul and refit will salvage it. #5: Practice reactive maintenance Best described as the “Laissez Faire Method,” this technique is based on the theory that your maintenance department will spend less money in the short run if it simply sits around waiting for something bad to happen. Oddly enough, if you’ve had any success at all in building an effective maintenance organization over time, you’ll actually spend a good deal less money using this particular strategy—well, at least for a while. The reactive maintenance technique is exceptionally easy to employ. Just hunker down out of sight somewhere and wait to see what happens. The savings associated with this approach have to do with the “don’ts.” When you base your maintenance strategy on running to failure each and every time: ◆ You don’t plan.
◆ You don’t lube.
◆ You don’t schedule.
◆ You don’t perform failure analysis.
◆ You don’t hold high expectations.
◆ You don’t perform PdM inspections.
◆ You don’t follow up.
◆ You don’t track KPIs.
◆ You don’t write SMPs.
◆ You don’t review safety.
Basically, you don’t do anything at all except hope that the plant doesn’t suddenly get quiet. The problem with this approach is that, sooner or later, the plant will—suddenly get quiet, that is—and the longer you employ this method, the more likely this becomes.
Krytox® Fluorinated Greases and Oils are: Chemically Inert. Insoluble in common solvents. Thermally stable. Temperature range (-103˚F to 800˚F). Nonflammable. Nontoxic. Oxygen Compatible - safe for oxygen service. Low Vapor Pressure. Low Outgassing. No Migration - no silicones or hydrocarbons. Krytox offers Extreme Pressure, Anticorrosion and Antiwear properties. Mil-spec, Aerospace and Food Grades (H1 and H2) available! Useful in Vacuum Systems. For technical information, call 203.743.4447 / 800.992.2424 (8AM - 4 PM ET)
m
s
miller-stephenson chemical company, inc. California - Illinois - Connecticut - Canada e-mail: support@miller-stephenson.com www.miller-stephenson.com
For more info, enter 72 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
24 | MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
Stop the shooting There you have the five best methods available for doing in your maintenance program. Each will have a positive short-term effect on the maintenance budget—and each will have a negative long-term effect on your process. The use of just several, or all of them at once, is a guaranteed recipe for failure. Granted, these are extreme examples of poor maintenance management. They were written that way to make a point. Still, as you read back over them, you should ask yourself if you are as removed from these practices as you think. In tough economic times, maintenance managers are under intense pressure to deliver reliability on time and under budget. In your daily search for ways to accomplish this, be sure you don’t end up shooting yourself in the foot! MT
Ray Atkins is a retired maintenance pro (and award-winning author) based in Rome, GA. He spent his last five years in industry as a maintenance superintendent with Temple-Inland. Web: www.raymondlatkins.com; E-mail: raymondlatkins@ aol.com. (Editor’s Note: This article is based on Ray’s Conference presentation for MARTS 2010.) MAY 2010
GEARMOTOR TECHNOLOGY
Geared Up For Power New, proven gearmotor technology is helping power plants boost their competitiveness, despite increasing numbers of regulatory and publicrelations challenges.
William C. Livoti Baldor Electric Company
MAY 2010
© GUNNAR 3000—FOTOLIA.COM
Improving p g reliability y in circulating-water g p pumping p g systems... y
T
he power industry is experiencing unprecedented change. The biggest change is in the restructuring (deregulation) of electricity markets, resulting in a much more competitive business environment. Increased competition, in turn, is spurring greater investment in energy efficiency, improved operating performance and overall reliability. At the same time, owner/operators are being asked to modify plant systems to meet emission standards and/or grid demand. If passed, climate-change legislation will also have a huge impact on power utilities. The additional parasitic load created by carbon capture and scrubbers for emissions control, as well as substantial public resistance to adding new fossil power, have opened a Pandora’s box of challenges. Thus, maximizing plant efficiency and increasing existing capacity is the path of least resistance and most cost-effective route for operations that want to remain competitive.
MT-ONLINE.COM | 25
GEARMOTOR TECHNOLOGY
Fig. 1. A typical circulating-water pump/motor/control system found in power plants
Most thermal power plants utilize large-horsepower, lowspeed pumps for plant circulating-water service. This equipment will most likely require upgrading in order to comply with pending climate legislation. In addition, a majority of these plants have been operating for 40+ years—and are badly in need of major overhauls. This article highlights an innovative solution for improving efficiency, reliability and performance of the existing circulating-water pump/motor /control systems in such plants (Fig. 1). Harsh service The startup and shutdown sequences of any pumping system are very tough on the pump. This is due to the time it takes for the “system” to achieve hydraulic stability, specifically in the case of a long discharge from the water source to the condenser. This transient condition can and will reduce the pump life by as much as 50%.
■ Position MOV to desired control-flow rate (this could require a partially closed valve at pump or at destination, depending on system requirements). The procedure outline here is the conventional method for starting a circulating-water pumping system. By maintaining a closed or partially open valve for any period of time the pump and system (valves, piping, supports and structure) are subject to high levels of vibration and potential damage. If the system is not properly vented, water hammer—an anomaly causing severe damage to the pump and system—also will occur. The results of these events can be seen as: ■ Piping failure ■ Broken pump shafts
Conventional start-up procedure…
■ Motor damage
■ Motor Operated Valve (MOV) at pump outlet is fully closed or 10% open (full open is not an option).
■ Structural damage ■ Broken pipe hangers and/or supports
■ Valve at source is fully closed or 10% open. ■ Start motor. Allow pump to come up to speed and near shutoff pressure (30 seconds to one minute). ■ Slowly open the MOV to full open position (precise time depends on distance from pump to condenser). 26 |
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
Proven technology, in the form of the CST/Gearmotor system, is now available to deal with such issues. It consists of a 4-pole AC induction motor direct-coupled to a planetary gearbox, complete with an internal thrust bearing, hydro-viscous wet clutch and circulating lube-oil system to drive the circulating-water pump. MAY 2010
GEARMOTOR TECHNOLOGY
Integrity
Customer Serv
ice
Fig. 2. The internals of the new Baldor gearmotor
1.
As the motor reaches full speed, the sun gear rotates the planet gears.
Dedication
2. The planet gears rotate the free-floating ring gear. 3. The output shaft is integral to the planet carrier and does not turn.
Systems
4. Hydraulic system applies pressure to the annular piston. 5. The stationary and rotating plates of the clutch pack are compressed together on their free-floating splines. 6. This results in application of torque to the ring gear, braking and decreasing its speed. 7.
This causes the planet carrier/output shaft to increase rotational speed while the planet gears rotate about the ring.
8. Ring-gear speed reaches zero, the output shaft speed will be at 100% of normal operating speed.
Key features of the technology The motor will be directly mounted to the gearbox structure and be connected to the gearbox with a flexible coupling. An integrated wet clutch will allow the motor to achieve motor base speed unloaded. The clutch will then be engaged to gradually bring the pump up to full speed. The 4-pole motor/gearbox can be up to 30% smaller than an equivalent high-pole-count, low-speed direct-drive motor construction. This configuration allows for significantly reduced size and weight, as well as reduced cost for the pump driver support structure. MAY 2010
Technical A bility
Why would you need to use any other lab? Contact Herguth Laboratories, Inc. today to ďŹ nd out what sets us apart.
1-800-OIL-LABS â&#x20AC;˘ www.herguth.com For more info, enter 73 at www.MT-freeinfo.com MT-ONLINE.COM | 27
GEARMOTOR TECHNOLOGY
As shown in Fig. 2, the internals consist of two distinct sections: the planetta output and the clutch. The planetary gearbox and hydro-viscous wet clutch etary provide pr ro for the speed adjustment of the driven pump during startup and shutdown. do o (With the CST controlling the rate of discharge [flow] from the pump, hydraulic hy y instability is minimized.) This CST/gearmotor technology also allows for a stable, controlled startup— ramp raam time is dependent on distance from pump to condenser—and shutdown of the th he circulating-water system, which protects the pump from potential damage due du u to obstructions and reduced NPSH conditions. Startup Stta procedure with new gearmotor solution applied… ■ MOV is fully open. ■ Valve at source is fully open (open discharge). ■ Start motor is unloaded (low inrush motor design). ■ Engage CST gearmotor and begin applying power to driven pump. ■ Slowly accelerate and increase driven pump speed until pipeline is packed and is stable. ■ Adjust pump speed to final desired flow and pressure. ■ Monitor/control speed and flow are at DCS.
Baldor’s CST/Gearmotor System Features…
Benefits…
■ Electromechanical soft start: • Motor starts unloaded • Load accelerated at desired rate (seconds to minutes) • Stable speed control via wet clutch
■ Electromechanical soft start: • Minimizes impact on power system • Lowers duration and amplitude of locked rotor current in accelerating the pump
■ Fast-response control system • Standard communications connectivity ■ Inherently torque limiting (overload protection) for possible intake obstructions ■ Gear ratios selected to optimize pump speed for system efficiency ■ Gearbox flange designed to mate to existing pump structure
28 |
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
• Possible extended acceleration and deceleration times • Capability to completely utilize breakdown torque capacity of motor from 0 to operating speed • Fewer exerted stresses, leading to increased motor life • Repeated system starts possible without restarting the motor
■ 4-pole motor use at any pump speed: • Lower motor cost • Improved motor availability • Reduced maintenance costs • Simple bearing design (thrust handled in gearbox) • Smaller, lighter, easier to handle • Possible efficiency improvements • Possible power-factor improvement ■ Pumps can be designed to run at any desired speed by changing gear ratio (versus operating at a conventional motor’s full-load speed)
MAY 2010
GEARMOTOR TECHNOLOGY
Maximizing efficiency and increasing existing capacity is the path of least resistance and the most cost-effective route for power plants that want to remain competitive. Commentsâ&#x20AC;Ś The typical circulating-water system is friction-dominated, making it well-suited to a controlled startâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;especially during extended startup sequence and/or low-water-level, high-backpressure operations, where system demands may fluctuate and NPSHa may be an issue. Another concern is prevention of load surge through the system. Just as a drive system can input excessive torque into the system under a sudden start, a load surge going through the system can also overload the mechanical drive components. The wet clutch provides an adjustable torque-limiting feature to protect the drive system. An additional benefit of the controlled-start technology is that the motor can be started unloaded. The no-load start minimizes the duration of damaging locked-rotor current starting a loaded motor. The CST drive system also gives the operator the flexibility of stopping the system without stopping the motor. This avoids multiple motor restarts and subsequent rotor overheating.
In order to control heat generated across the hydro-viscous clutch, the CST is configured with a cooling system sized to remove the dissipated heat from the relative motion of rotating and stationary plates in the disc pack. Either an oil/air or an oil/water heat exchanger, this cooling system is operational only during acceleration. When considering replacing or upgrading your circulatingwater system, look at the big picture during the evaluation process and consider the total system cost. Uptime availability and reliability are the primary drivers in the power industry. Why replace equipment with the same old technology that has placed your plant at risk for so many years? Bill Livoti is a fluid power and power industry engineer with Baldor Electric Company. He also is vice chair of the Pump Systems Matter (PSM) initiative. Telephone: (864) 281-2118; e-mail: wclivoti@baldor.com For more info, enter 02 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
For more info, enter 74 at www.MT-freeinfo.com MAY 2010
MT-ONLINE.COM | 29
TTHE HE GREEN GREEN EEDGE DGE
Gulp! Scarcity concerns could have an impact on your operation’s bottom line.
A
cccording to at least one rreport, many companies in water-intensive industries w ((such as manufacturing) need to improve their water-management techniques and provide more information for investors about the companies’ water-related risks. Issued by the Ceres investor coalition, the financial services firm UBS and financial-data provider Bloomberg, “Murky Waters: Corporate Reporting on Water Risk” evaluated and scored waterdisclosure practices of 100 publicly traded companies in eight key sectors exposed to water-related risks. “We chose sectors where water security concerns are likely to have a material impact on business, whether through regulatory, legal or reputational constraints that in some
cases can go so far as to threaten a firm’s very ‘license to operate,’” says Julie Hudson, global head of SRI and Sustainability Research at UBS Investment Bank. “It is clear that any threat to water security could have a significant impact on the bottom line of such companies.” Many companies, the report suggests, are not including material water risks and performance data in their financial filings, nor are they providing local-level water data— particularly in the context of facilities in water-stressed regions. The study also found that none of the 100 companies provide comprehensive water data on their supply chains (an important issue, since much of a corporation’s water footprint is in the supply chain).
© IGOR IGOR DUTIN DUTINA—FOTOLIA.COM D UTINA A—FOTOLI FOTOLI T A COM COM
Improved Water-Disclosure Practices Needed ASAP What does all this mean? It’s simple. With better analysis of their water situations, companies can take practical steps to anticipate potential shortages. Ceres notes that the alcoholic beverage company Diageo—which had one of the highest scores on the evaluation—identified 11 of its 52 plants as being in water-stressed areas. As a result, the company targeted a 50% reduction in non-ingredient water consumption at the plants in question and sought ways to reduce consumption at its other facilities by 30%. Ceres also reports that Unilever’s business in India is now harvesting rainwater and recycling processing water at its sites. Such practices, along with new technology, have helped cut those sites’ groundwater consumption levels in half. MT
DOES YOUR COMPANY HAVE A GREEN EDGE? E-mail your product and service news to: gpietras@atpnetwork.com For information on advertising in the Green Edge section, contact JERRY PRESTON at: Phone: (480) 396-9585 / E-mail: jpreston@atpnetwork.com
30 |
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
MAY 2010
TTHE HE G GREEN REEN EEDGE DGE
Energy-Saving Screw Blowers
A
tlas Copco notes that its new ZS screw blowers are, on average, 30% more energyefficient than conventional lobe blowers. According to the company, industries that will benefit the most from this new technology are municipal and industrial wastewater treatment plants, where air blowers typically represent up to 70% of the total electricity costs. With its introduction of this new screw technology, Atlas Copco now offers a complete product line of compressors and blowers for all applications and processes below 4 bar(e)/58 psig.
Compact Central Inverter For Photovoltaic Plants
A
BB’s central inverter, the PVS800, feeds solar power into medium- or low-voltage grids via transformers and switchgear (also available from ABB). Extremely compact, these new products come in power ratings of between 100 and 500 kW, and can be used in industrial-
scale photovoltaic power plants and for medium-sized power plants on the roofs of commercial or industrial buildings. ABB Houston, TX For more info, enter 32 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
Atlas Copco Rock Hill, SC For more info, enter 30 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
Benchmarking Tool On Sustainability Patented
W
orking with the Aberdeen Group, Rockwell Automation is offering a new sustainable manufacturing assessment tool to end users. It utilizes data collected and analyzed from more than 200 manufacturing organizations participating in Aberdeen’s primary research in sustainable production. By completing a short online survey, participants receive a complimentary personalized analysis that will show them how their organization compares to industry peers and help them quickly identify key capabilities and technologies used by top performers. Rockwell Automation Milwaukee, WI
For more info, enter 31 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
• Removes scale from pipe work • Removes scale from heat exchangers and steam boilers • Saves energy by keeping heating elements scale free • Increases life of capital equipment • Reduces cleaning costs, chemicals & labor • Saves 50% on cooling tower make up water • Saves irrigation water • Provides short term payback Applications: Residential • Commercial • Industrial
Dealer territories available. Scalewatcher North America Inc., Oxford PA Call Toll Free (800) 504-8577 or by email: sales@scalewatcher.com
www.scalewatcher.com For more info, enter 75 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
MAY 2010
MT-ONLINE.COM | 31
SUPPLY CHAIN LINKS
Sustainability And Your Facility: It’s All About Choices You’re Y ’ not alone l in i this hi ongoing i journey. j M. Randi Young, LEED AP Grainger
O
ne of the critical emerging issues on customers’ minds (and some of the most common questions they’re asking us) involve how to operate and maintain sustainable facilities. Organizations everywhere are constantly looking for ways to operate in a more environmentally responsible manner than before—and also cut operating expenses. Maintaining and operating a sustainable facility is achieved by looking at the essential areas of the operation. Sustainability industry experts, such as the United States Green Building Council (USGBC), look at the environmental-savings categories of a building’s exterior, water efficiency, energy and atmosphere, materials and resources and indoor environmental quality. Each of these components represents a critical element when it comes to reducing carbon footprint and the use of natural resources. But there’s an additional element to remember when attempting to operate a sustainable facility: behavior. One could argue that buildings don’t use power or water or generate waste—people do. By better understanding the decision process that employees go through as they discard items or use water and energy, you can help identify what steps need to be taken in order to drive toward more sustainable choices. Utilizing efficient lighting within your facility, for example, will provide value in reduced energy costs and better light quality. Couple that with good choices for how the lighting 32 | MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
MAY 2010
SUPPLY CHAIN LINKS
Listening To Customers For 83 years, Grainger has been serving businesses and institutions across a variety of industries by helping them save time and money related to their maintenance, repair and operating supplies needs. Today, the company remains committed to listening to its customers and helping to collaboratively find the most cost-effective solutions for their evolving business needs. With more than 8000 green products across a broad array of categories, Grainger definitely provides the product solutions that organizations need to “go green,” including those that help save energy, reduce water usage, improve indoor air quality and reduce waste. In addition to products, Grainger is educating business professionals on how to embrace energy-efficient solutions in their operations. Through supplier partnerships and its recent acquisition of Alliance Energy Solutions, the company offers training, needs assessments and audits in areas such as energy, water, green cleaning and waste reduction. Grainger also diligently looks for ways to reduce its own environmental impact. From adopting Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) standards for all new construction, to completing certification as an EPA SmartWay shipper partnering with carriers to reduce transportation emissions, the company is helping to preserve the natural resources within the communities where it does business. Currently, Grainger operates 12 LEED-certified facilities, 10 being LEED Gold. For more information about Grainger’s green products and solutions, visit www.grainger.com/greeninfo.
is used and you’re on track for even more savings and less harmful environmental impact. Simply shutting the lights off when the last person leaves a room or leveraging sensors to judge when lighting is required would make an even bigger impact on bottom-line costs. The same is true when looking at the other key areas of a building that use natural resources and energy, or contribute to waste. When responsible actions are coupled with the right equipment, sustainability and cost savings are likely to follow—as will the culture change necessary for lasting impact. Another piece to consider is the relationship between the personal comfort of employees while inside the building and worker productivity. This is an important consideration as you make changes in your facility. Alterations in filtering or outside air intake can affect the indoor air quality. Updated lighting or individual lighting controls can add to comfort. MAY 2010
And the use of natural cleaning materials can reduce the toxins that enter the air, as well as reduce harmful chemicals going into watertreatment systems. All of these factors impact productivity of the employees occupying the affected space in a gainful fashion. Generally, that impact is positive, but it’s important to continuously engage employees for input and feedback with regard to improvements. The path to sustainability does not have a “final destination,” rather it’s an ongoing journey. With a commitment to continued learning, as well as partnership with experts who can help you achieve your sustainability goals, the journey is sure to be an enjoyable and beneficial one. MT M. Randi Young is a solutions development manager with Grainger and a LEED AP. For more info, enter 03 at www.MT-freeinfo.com MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY | 33
SOLUTION SPOTLIGHT
Cool Solution For Hot Problems
Orival’s technology at work in a cigarette-manufacturing operation
Automatic self-cleaning screen-filters provide cooling-system protection and more.
C
ooling towers dissipate both ambient and process heat in most large manufacturing facilities. These structures facilitate the transfer of unwanted energy (heat) from a transport liquid (usually water) to the atmosphere. Problems with efficient heat transfer, equipment protection and pathological risks to employees can most often be traced to an issue with suspended solids. These solids can originate in the process, in the piping, from the atmosphere or from internal biological growth. Common methods of maintaining minimal suspended solids in a cooling system are side-stream filtration, a process that cleans only a portion of system flow; cyclonic devices, which typically treat all water in a system, but are best at removing high-specific-gravity solids; and granular media filtration, which is also used to treat all water, but is best at removing low-specific-gravity organic solids. Orival offers yet another method—automatic selfcleaning screen-filter technology—that can be used for all system water. Trapping both organic and inorganic solids, regardless of specific gravity, this process also requires minimal energy and little or no coolant liquid for the selfcleaning process. Fully automatic self-cleaning screen filters use weave-wire screens as the filtering media. These provide a positive removal system and eliminate all particles larger than the filtration degree of the screen from the cooling system, and many smaller particles as well. This is due to the filtration effect of the filter cake that builds on the screen element surface between cleaning cycles.
34 |
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
The filtration improvement can be loosely quantified as removing particles down to about 1/10 the size of the screenfiltration degree when the filter cake is at its thickest. This 1:10 relationship, as employed in screen-filtration systems, is called the capture ratio. An efficient suction-cleaning principle allows the filter cake to be removed completely from the screen surface within seconds, without touching the cake or screen. During the suction-cleaning cycle, the filtration process is uninterrupted, thereby providing filtered water downstream at all times and eliminating redundant equipment. Water and chemical losses are minimized, and organic and inorganic solids are removed with equal efficiency. Since only a small pressure differential occurs across the screen element, extrusion of soft organic material through the screen is prevented. If a problem should occur with the filter, a controller will open a built-in bypass valve to provide continuous water flow. The controller will then send a signal to notify personnel. Routine maintenance of automatic self-cleaning screen filters is minimal, consisting of a monthly inspection of the rinse valves (to see that they are seating properly) and an annual inspection of the screen and hydraulic piston. An occasional manually induced cleaning cycle is recommended to assure proper operation. Orival, Inc. Englewood, NJ For more info, enter 33 at www.MT-freeinfo.com MAY 2010
CAPACITY ASSURANCE MARKETPLACE
Energy-Saving Cyclone Separator
D
onaldson Company’s DF-C Cyclone Separator, used at the front end of the purification chain within compressedair systems, provides higher efficiency than the company’s previous models at low-pressure drop. Its optimal flow-path design reduces differential-pressure drop, which lowers energy consumption. The air flow generated by the centrifugal forces of the DF-C range greatly enhances separation of liquid and solid contaminants from the compressed air. Donaldson Company, Inc. Minneapolis, MN For more info, enter 34 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
One-Stop Shopping For Your Alignment Needs
Ultrasound With Onboard Database
A
ccording to SDT, its SDT270 is the first portable ultrasound instrument to include both a built-in temperature sensor and a laser tachometer, as well as an onboard SQL database to capture and manage survey data. In addition, the product’s Internet connection allows remote access for support, training and measurement triggering. Other features include the ability to maintain a database of accurate sound files; two channel inputs for faster data collection; and upgradeability and customization options. SDT International SA/NV Cobourg, ON For more info, enter 37 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
M
r. Shims provides state-of-the-art laser tools to measure alignment, and easy-to-use, top-quality alignment materials, including 304 stainless steel, aluminum and color-coded plastic precut shims. Custom shims and shim stock are available. The company also stocks small tools and hardware, such as drillout extractors, dial-indicator hardware, hollow-punch tool kits, balancing weights and undercut bolts. Mr. Shims Villa Park, IL For more info, enter 35 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
Secure Keypad Ignition Systems
K
eytroller’s 215 generation START-SMART keypad ignition system prevents unauthorized operators from accessing equipment such as forklifts, cranes and personnel carriers. It’s available with code- or RFID-card enabling. A dual relay module connects to your ignition switch for easy installation, and the product can be easily retrofitted to any internal combustion or electric vehicle. Keytroller, LLC Tampa, FL For more info, enter 36 at www.MT-freeinfo.com MAY 2010
For more info, enter 76 at www.MT-freeinfo.com MT-ONLINE.COM | 35
CAPACITY ASSURANCE MARKETPLACE
Pump System Optimizes Tank-Cleaning & Spray Nozzles
Industrial Vacuum For Handling Abrasive Materials
A
XAIR’s new Heavy Duty Dry Vac™ is an industrialduty vacuum cleaner engineered to quickly remove high volumes of dry materials. This wear-resistant unit is suitable for clean-up of abrasive materials including steel shot, metal chips and sand, yet it’s also useful with general-purpose tasks. Powered with compressed air, it connects to a user-supplied 55-gal. open-top drum. There are no motors and impellers to clog or wear out, and it comes with a five-year warranty.
utoJet® FDS30100 Fluid Delivery System from Spraying Systems optimizes the performance of a range of tank-cleaning and spray nozzles. All system components (including the pump, motor and control) are integrated in a compact cart for easy mobility. The system’s Variable Frequency Drive (VFD) eliminates the need for control valves to throttle flow, and the discharge pressure is quickly set on the intuitive touch pad. The VFD also automatically adjusts speed to maintain pressure, reducing energy consumption.
Spraying Systems Co. Wheaton, IL For more info, enter 38 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
E
EXAIR Corporation Cincinnati, OH For more info, enter 39 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
Pressure Transmitters For Hazardous Environments
M
onitoring the pressure of combustible substances, including chemicals, gas and oil, requires purposebuilt instruments with specific safety features. Ashcroft’s compact Type A2X (explosion-proof) and Type A4 (intrinsically safe) pressure transmitters are specifically designed for hazardous, non-network applications where costly “smart” transmitters aren’t required. Less than 5” long, with 1” diameters, they’re available in ranges from 0/5 through 0/10,000 psi and are delivered in accuracies of ±0.5% and ±0.25% of full span. Resulting measurement data are communicated through a choice of six different analog voltage or current outputs. Ashcroft Inc. Stratford, CT
For more info, enter 77 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
36 | MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
For more info, enter 40 at www.MT-freeinfo.com MAY 2010
CAPACITY ASSURANCE MARKETPLACE
Drop-In HVAC Replacement Motors
I new series of silicone-insert couplings from Sterling Instrument offers electrical isolation and no backlash. Ranging in length from 26.5 mm to 57 mm, they have aluminum hubs with either set screws or clamps for fastening to shafts. Stocked in five bore sizes, these metric couplings are identified as the S54HSAM (clamp) and S5PSAM (set screw) Series. Well-suited to tight or skewed connections, they operate in temperatures from -50 C to +150 C and at a maximum speed of 5000 rpm.
n a partnership with Proctor Engineering Group, EFI is now distributing Concept 3â&#x201E;˘, an efficient motor for use with your existing HVAC systems. The units are brushless, permanent-magnet designs that can be dropped in as replacements for common Permanent Split Capacitor (PSC) motors found in most furnaces, air conditioners and heat-pump systems using 24v thermostats. Speed-controllable, these motors offer a lowwatt draw per delivered CFM in both heating and cooling, and have fan-control algorithms for dry, wet and mixed climates.
Sterling Instrument New Hyde Park, NY
Energy Federation Inc. (EFI) Westborough, MA
Silicone-Insert Couplings
A
For more info, enter 41 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
For more info, enter 43 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
Clutch/Brake For Those Tough Conveyor Applications
W
arner Electric offers a new heavy-duty Gen2 electromagnetic packaged clutch/brake UniModule for use in tough conveyor applications. A new, larger bearing provides a dynamicload capability increase of 47% over previous modules. A redesigned armature and spline hub result in an effective spline-length increase of 83%. Standard features include internal-component mounting and an external housing fin design that increases heat dissipation and optimizes stop/start frequencies. Integrated custom mounting bolts make installation easy and allow the conduit box to be located directly on top of the unit for consistent orientation. Warner Electric A business unit of Altra Industrial Motion Braintree, MA For more info, enter 42 at www.MT-freeinfo.com
MAY 2010
For more info, enter 78 at www.MT-freeinfo.com MT-ONLINE.COM | 37
INFORMATION HIGHWAY For rate information on advertising in the Information Highway Section Contact your Sales Rep or JERRY PRESTON at: Phone: (480) 396-9585 / E-mail: jpreston@atpnetwork.com Web Spotlight: SIEMENS
PIP is a consortium of process plant owners and engineering construction contractors harmonizing member’s internal standards for design, procurement, construction, and maintenance into industry-wide Practices. PIP has published over 450 Practices. A current listing of published Practices is available on the PIP website at: http://pip.org/practices/index.asp. For more info, enter 80 at www.MT-freeinfo.com www.pip.org
SIEMENS - How can maintenance costs be cut, while increasing availability? With our SPPA-D3000 Diagnostic Suite, “preventive” maintenance can become reality. Whether using the “Machinery Protection”, “Machinery Analysis”, “Plant Monitor” or “Combustion Dynamics Monitoring” solution, you can predict where and you’re your system might fail, allowing you to avoid unscheduled outages. For more info, enter 79 at www.MT-freeinfo.com www.siemens.com/energy/controls
LUDECA, INC. - Preventive, Predictive and Corrective Maintenance Solutions including laser shaft alignment, pulley alignment, bore alignment, straightness and flatness measurement, monitoring of thermal growth, online condition monitoring, vibration analysis and balancing equipment as well as software, services and training. For more info, enter 81 at www.MT-freeinfo.com www.ludeca.com
CLASSIFIED Need Help? Need A Job? Contact Lisa – LISA LINEAL:
ENGTECH
LINEAL
Recruiting Services
TOLL FREE 877-386-1091
lisalineal@lineal.com www.lineal.com Electromechanical • Electronic Electrical Service & Systems Specialists
Se Habla Español
RENEW
In order for us to send
MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY to you FREE, we are required by the US Post Office to have a completed and signed renewal form once a year.
You may renew online at
www.mt-online.com 38 | MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
Industries Inc.
ATP List Services Customized, Targeted Lists For Your Marketing Needs www.atplists.com Contact: Ellen Sandkam 847-382-8100 x110 800-223-3423 x110 info@atplists.com esandkam@atplists.com 1300 S. Grove Ave., Suite 105, Barrington, IL 60010
For rate information on advertising in the Classified Section Contact your Sales Rep or JERRY PRESTON at: Phone: (480) 396-9585 e-mail: jpreston@atpnetwork.com
MAY 2010
M A I N T E N A N C E
Index ADVERTISER
TECHNOLOGY
®
YEARS
Your Source For CAPACITY ASSURANCE SOLUTIONS
May 2010 Volume 23, No. 5 •
WEB
RS #
PAGE #
1300 South Grove Avenue, Suite 105 Barrington, IL 60010 PH 847-382-8100 FX 847-304-8603
Baldor Electric Company...................www.baldor.com.......................................................83..................BC Cadick Corporation............................www.cbm2010.com .................................................76...................35 CRC Industries ....................................www.crcindustries.com/ei ......................................67...................10 Eventure Events - STO........................www.stoconference.com .........................................82................ IBC Exair Corporation ...............................www.exair.com..........................................................65..................... 5 Fluke.......................................................www.fluke.com/machinehealth.............................69...................17 Generac Power Systems, Inc. .............www.generac.com/mt5 ...........................................61.................IFC Grainger ................................................www.grainger.com ...................................................62..................... 1 Herguth Laboratories, Inc..................www.herguth.com....................................................73...................27 Int’l Maintenance Excellence Conf...www.imec.ca .............................................................68...................11 Ludeca Inc.............................................www.ludeca.com ......................................................71,81 ........23,38 Marshall Institute, Inc .........................www.marshallinstitute.com/8-phase-process .....78...................37 Miller-Stephenson Chemical Co. .....www.miller-stephenson.com .................................72...................24 Mobil Industrial Lubricants...............www.mobilindustrial.com......................................63..................... 2 NSK Corporation................................www.nskamericas.com............................................70...................21 PdMA Corp..........................................www.pdma.com .......................................................74...................29
SALES STAFF OH, KY, TN 135 N. Rocky River Road Berea, OH 44017 440-463-0907; Fax 440-891-1254 JOHN DAVIS jdavis@atpnetwork.com
AL, CA, CO, DE, FL, GA, MD, MS, NC, NJ, SC, PA, VA, WV, DC 1750 Holmes Drive West Chester, PA 19382 610-793-3093; Fax 610-793-3094 JIM HANLEY jhanley@atpnetwork.com
AR, AZ, NV, NM, OK, UT 1300 South Grove Avenue, Suite 105 Barrington, IL 60010 847-382-8100 x116; Fax 847-304-8603 BILL KIESEL bkiesel@atpnetwork.com
Process Industries Practices ...............www.pip.org ..............................................................77...................36 Scalewatcher .........................................www.scalewatcher.com............................................75...................31 Siemens AG ..........................................www.siemens.com/energy/controls ......................66,79 ..........7,38
Access MT-freeinfo.com and enter the reader service number of the product in which you are interested, or you can search even deeper and link directly to the advertiser’s Website. Submissions Policy: Maintenance Technology gladly welcomes submissions. By sending us your submission, unless otherwise negotiated in writing with our editor(s), you grant Applied Technology Publications, Inc., permission, by an irrevocable license, to edit, reproduce, distribute, publish, and adapt your submission in any medium, including via Internet, on multiple occasions. You are, of course, free to publish your submission yourself or to allow others to republish your submission. Submissions will not be returned. Reproduction of Materials: Materials produced by Maintenance Technology may not be reproduced in any form for any purpose without permission. For Reprints: Contact the publisher, Bill Kiesel - (847) 382-8100 ext. 116.
M A I N T E N A N C E
TECHNOLOGY
®
YEARS
Your Source For CAPACITY ASSURANCE SOLUTIONS MAY 2010
CT, ME, MA, NH, NY, RI, VT, ON, QC P.O. Box 1059 Osterville, MA 02655 508-428-3331; Fax 508-428-2545 VINCENT LeGENDRE vlegendre@atpnetwork.com
IL, IN, KS, LA, MI, MN, MO, OR, TX, WA,WI, BC 1300 South Grove Avenue, Suite 105 Barrington, IL 60010 847-382-8100 x108; Fax 847-304-8603 TOM MADDING tmadding@atpnetwork.com
IA, MT, NE, ND, SD, WY, AB, MB, SK 1300 South Grove Avenue, Suite 105 Barrington, IL 60010 847-382-8100 x106; Fax 847-304-8603 ARTHUR L. RICE arice@atpnetwork.com
CLASSIFIED ADVERTISING 3629 N.Sonoran Heights Mesa, AZ 85207 480-396-9585 JERRY PRESTON jpreston@atpnetwork.com
MT-ONLINE.COM | 39
VIEWPOINT Randall K. Noon, P.E., Cooper Nuclear Station
Root-Cause Your Successes
M
ost plant personnel understand the value of root-cause analysis (RCA). Properly conducted, an evidence-driven RCA can be a strong performance-improvement tool. It fixes problems that waste time and resources, and it mitigates risk. One of the advantages of the RCA method is that once the causes of one failure or problem are clear, you can look around to see if the same causes are at work elsewhere in the organization. Lessons learned in solving one problem can be used to identify and prevent the same type of problem from occurring in other places. In RCA parlance, this is referred to as “Extent of Condition” or “Extent of Cause.” For example, in a root-cause investigation, a certain machine was found to have failed due to a flawed bearing. With this in mind, the investigator checked to see if the same type of bearing was used anywhere else in the plant, and identified five machines where it was. He then scheduled those machines to have replacement bearings installed. In a sense, that first root-cause investigation “vaccinated” the plant against five more failures. While most organizations have come to understand the value of using RCA techniques to fix and prevent problems, few—if any—recognize the value of using such techniques to determine the root cause of a success. The same way the understanding of one failure can be used to prevent others, the understanding of what causes a success can be used to promote and transfer success to other places. Consider this scenario: A company president chooses a new manager for a failing department. Six months later, the department is handsomely profitable and efficient. The obvious difference is the new manager—and the president congratulates himself on his selection. Now that his handpicked protégé has proven himself so well, the president proceeds to move him around to let other departments benefit from his acumen.
Truth be told, the real reason for the success wasn’t the new manager at all. Analysis of the facts found that the improvement was due to two key employees in the department who took advantage of the management changeover to implement work-procedure changes. They had wanted to do this for years, but were kept from it by the old manager. The new manager was simply a coincidence, not the cause. (The reader may wish to look up the logic term, post hoc ergo propter hoc, which describes this situation.) The improvement would have taken place no matter who was chosen to be manager. Thus, if the new manager credited with the success is transferred to another location, it’s unlikely that success will transfer with him—that is, not unless he also takes along the two employees who jumped on the opportunity to implement some very-needed changes in work procedures.
The understanding of what causes a success can be used to promote and transfer success to other places. In short, the RCA technique with which most companies are already familiar is not only good for determining the cause of a failure, it is also a valuable tool for determining the cause of success. In the same way that knowledge about one failure can be used to prevent others, knowledge about one success can be used to build others. MT Frequent Maintenance Technology contributor Randy Noon has been investigating failures for more than 30 years. E-mail: rknoon@nppd.com.
The opinions expressed in this Viewpoint section are those of the author, and don’t necessarily reflect those of the staff and management of MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY magazine.
40 | MAINTENANCE TECHNOLOGY
MAY 2010
Minimize risk and maximize results during your next
SHUTDOWN TURNAROUND
OUTAGE Best Management Practices Budgeting & Cost Management Scope & Frequency Planning & Scheduling Shutdown Organization Contractor Management & Availability Capital Project & Turnaround Integration Environmental Health & Safety Staff Management STO Strategy Close-out Systems & Technology Work Control & Analysis Work Execution Work Identification Work Management Processes — Lifecycle Organizational Alignment STO Strategies in a Recessionary Market Knowledge Transfer Risk Management
June 6-8, 2010
The Westin Galleria Houston Houston, Texas www.stoconference.com
Attend STO 2010 to get IMMEDIATE PAYBACK!
For more info, enter 82 at www.MT-freeinfo.com ©2010 by Eventure Events LLC. All rights reserved. Eventure and STO 2010 logos are trademarks of Eventure Events LLC.
Produced by:
The First Name in Power Transmission
DODGE® power transmission products offer reliable service and low maintenance to help reduce your total cost of ownership. Our innovative bearings, gearing and power transmission products have solved the toughest applications for over 125 years. Our technical sales team can help you with the most challenging applications, and our worldwide distributor network ensures immediate delivery.
• Unmatched Quality • Superior Reliability • Improved Uptime
When it comes to PT solutions, DODGE is the first name in power transmission. dodge-pt.com
baldor.com
• Quick Delivery
©2008 Baldor Electric Company
For more info, enter 83 at www.MT-freeinfo.com