FDA Update 20-21
|
Active Surveillance in Prostate Cancer 22
|
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 2
Spotlight on Research: Lung Cancer 74
JANUARY 15, 2012
ASCOPost.com
Editor-in-Chief, James O. Armitage, MD
53rd ASH Annual Meeting
Improved Survival with Chemotherapy Alone in Limited-stage Hodgkin Lymphoma
Sentinel Lymph Node Biopsy for Thin Melanomas?
But current radiation techniques less toxic By Alice Goodman
By Michael S. Sabel, MD
A
n important study suggests that radiotherapy may not be a necessary addition to chemotherapy in previously untreated patients with limited-stage Hodgkin lymphoma, sparing patients the risks of late radiation-induced cardiac Ralph M. Meyer, MD effects and second cancers. These data were based on 12 years of follow-up of the Hodgkin’s Disease 6 trial (HD.6), which was presented at the 53rd Annual Meeting of the American Society of Hematology in San Diego1 and published online simultaneously in The New England Journal of Medicine.2 (See added perspective on page 7.) The study showed that ABVD (doxorubicin, bleomycin, vinblastine, and dacarbazine) chemotherapy
alone achieved improved overall survival compared with radiation alone or radiation combined with ABVD. The 12-year overall survival rate was 94% for ABVD vs 87% SEE PAGE 83 for those who received radiation (P = .04). The rate of freedom from disease progression was lower in the ABVD arm vs radiation therapy at 12 years—87% vs 92% (P = .05)—demonstrating that in this trial, at least, progression-free survival was not predictive of overall survival.
Controversial Strategy “The strategy of treating limited-stage Hodgkin lymphoma with chemotherapy alone is controversial. Our results alter this debate. The 12-year rates of 87% for freedom from disease progression and 94% for overall survival in the ABVD arm suggest
Bevacizumab Breast Cancer Indication Rescinded: What Are the Downstream Implications? By Ronald Piana
L
hen sentinel lymph node biopsy for the regional staging of melanoma was first introduced, it was recommended for any patient with a melanoma 1.0 mm in Breslow thickness or greater. Patients with thin melanomas were not thought to have a sufficiently high risk to warrant the additional cost and morbidity of the procedure. As experience grew, several retrospective series identified risk factors beyond Breslow thickness that were associated with an increased risk of regional metastases, and should therefore prompt consideration of sentinel lymph node biopsy for patients with melanomas shy of 1.0 mm (in a range generally considered to be 0.76 to 0.99 mm). These risk factors were continued on page 2
continued on page 6
Expert’s Corner
eading up to FDA’s resolution to revoke the breast cancer indication for bevacizumab (Avastin), the debate over the drug’s clinical value was imbued with contentious ideologic overtones, which culminated in a 2-day public hearing that exposed deep divisions not only in the scientific community, but also among breast cancer advocacy groups and
W
individual patients and survivors. In the face of the recent FDA decision, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services will continue coverage for bevacizumab in metastatic breast cancer, further complicating the issue for providers and payers. To clarify this ongoing debate, The ASCO Post spoke with nationally regarded health-care expert Lee N. Newcomer, MD, Senior Vice President of Oncology for UnitedHealthcare.
Drug manufacturers need to develop drugs that make a significant difference for the patient. — Lee N. Newcomer, MD
Coverage Decisions FDA Commissioner Margaret A. Hamburg, MD, said she revoked bevacizumab’s approval in breast cancer after concluding that the drug was not effective or safe. As an oncologist and payer, how do you determine whether a cancer therapy warrants coverage?
Dr. Sabel is Associate Professor of Surgery at the University of Michigan Health System and Director of the University of Michigan Comprehensive Cancer Center Breast Cancer Clinical Outcomes Project, Ann Arbor.
MORE IN THIS ISSUE Oncology Meetings Coverage San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium ���� 3 53rd ASH Annual Meeting ���������������� 6, 7 97th Annual American College of Surgeons Clinical Congress ������ 15, 16 NIH State-of-the-Science Conference ������������������������������������� 22, 25 Eighth Annual Society for Integrative Oncology Conference ������������������� 32, 33 2011 Health IT/EHR Symposium �������� 60 Direct from ASCO ��������������������������������������� 38
continued on page 14
A Harborside Press® Publication