DRAFT_SP21ARCH 988_DR BOOK

BACK TO EARTH ABSARI SHASHI SHAWAL

BACK TO EARTH MSARCH 2020-2021 ABSARI SHASHI SHAWAL

BACK TO EARTH by Absari Shashi Shawal

© September 2021 Absari Shashi Shawal

A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science, Architecture School of Architecture Pratt Institute September 2021

I

II

Program Introduction

IV - XII

Ariane Lourie Harrison THE STORY complexProgression

10 - 19

onEarth

20 - 21

createsApproaches

22 - 27

toDeployment

28 - 29

THE BLUEPRINT theResearch

32 - 33

suggestsUnlocking

34 - 41

newSensibilities

42 - 47

followingRemediation

48 - 49

THE MOVE soilFormation

52 - 57

linkMachines

58 - 67

THE NEW STORY

68 - 87

Bibliography

88 - 89

References & Image Citations

90 - 91

III

IV

Introduction Xereroetomniseaquivoluptatiisalitas et aute volores pores nissit id erumAt porum fugitior solum nonseribus dem consedoloremporatibusavolenihitam, quis nonem aceste mos susandit rem voluptatiasduciatiosmoluptionsecullenda id ulpa dest, site volum ius, cupis

V 9

BACK TO EARTH

10

THE STORY This Chapter talks about the historical roots dating back to the earliest days of the Governors Island.

In addition to a vision of a new Skyline underground called soil-o-line. ... .... .... .... ..................................

BACK TO EARTH

12

complexProgression

On the Concept of ‘a’ History.

In New York Harbor, Governors Island is situated approximately 800 yards south of Manhattan Island, and the 400-yard-wide Buttermilk Channel divides it from Brooklyn to the east. There are 72 acres of bedrock on the north side, a national historic district. Fort Jay (1798), Castle Williams (1811), churches, barracks and a number of stately residences are all situated here, and the oldest structure is the House of Governor (1708). 103 acres of landfill containing material excavated during the building of the Brooklyn Battery Tunnel is on the south side of the island (1940-50). On this southern side, there are a variety of transitional buildings and operational facilities.

Although usually imperceptible to the human eye, the land is constantly changing engaging different events over the period of time.

Governors Island refers to an environment with a land area of 172 acres that has been changed for a drive by human, and also by the land itself. Walking through this land, one can find history, memories and can also seizure some amazing interpretations of New York city. The island shadows its past events and at the same time, the infrastructures of the past also leave an opportunity to welcome new possibilities here.

There are countless sections where this island has increased or decrease in scope, which in turn has significant consequences in the timeline.

13

BACK TO EARTH

14

Year 2020: Governors Island is open to the public on a seasonal basis, rejuvenating its own history by becoming a site for solutions to the present challenges. In September 2020, Mayor Bill de Blasio and the Trust for Governors Island introduce plans to make this land a dwelling for climate crisis solutions. Arts and culture, open space, and recreation form the three key pillars of Governors Island; together they advance the mission of the Island to be an extraordinary public place that supports expanded, year-round public access, and they create a path towards the Island’s financial self-sufficiency. The Island brings together a crossdisciplinary network of researchers, educators, advocates, innovators and policymakers to create, take a look at and put into consequences.

Year 2017: In October, New Yorkers consider Governors Island a public space for the first time. The Lower Manhattan Cultural Council (LMCC) plans to be the first permanent home for artists and a home to a diverse range of arts, cultural and educational programming. With this future focus, Governors Island will be a gathering spot for international specialists, supporters, pioneers, and understudies working on environmental change arrangements while offering important freedoms for public commitment, welcoming involved training, programming, and backing activities around environment and ecological issues.

Year 2001: In January, President Bill Clinton designates 22 acres of the Island, including Fort Jay and Castle Williams and the area that surrounds the structures, as the Governors Island National Monument, to be owned and managed by the National Park Service.

15

BACK TO EARTH

16

complexProgression

Year 1965: Governors Island is still an army post and quiet neighborhood for military families. In response to changing military technology and budget constraints, the U.S. Department of Defense announces the pending closure of Governors Island and the Brooklyn Navy Yard.

Ownership of the Island is soon to be transferred to the United States Coast Guard.

Year 1941: Between the two World Wars, the Island becomes the center of an important Army headquarters for ground and air forces. By World War II, the U.S. First Army uses Governors Island as its headquarters.

Formerly established in Europe in 1919, the First Army also initiates their planning efforts for the D-Day invasion on this fairy-tale island.

Year 1917: Every morning, newspapers report that soldiers from the Twenty-Second Infantry Regiment have arrived to be garrisoned on Fort Jay. The War has already been raging for more than two years when, in April, Congress declares war on Germany and the Central Powers.

Year 1878: Governors Island has evolved from a small military outpost to an army headquarters and garrison. The Army moves both offices and officers to the Island, building six new generals' houses, now known as Colonels Row, and enclosing Nolan Park.

Year 1783: At the end of the Revolutionary War, British troops withdraw from the city. On December 4th, the British Royal Navy departs the Island and the Royal Navy surrenders to the Continental Army.

Year 1664: Once and for all, the English capture New Amsterdam, which they rename New York, and Nutten Island from the Dutch. The city and the Island choose to switch hands between the British and the Dutch over the following decades until the British recaptured elite control of the Island for his majesty’s fortification and garrison.

17

BACK TO EARTH

18

complexProgression

Sketch 01: What is not mentioned in the mentioned timeline is a series of rolling hills on the Island’s southern tip. Today, these hills provide beautiful views of the New York City skyline while protecting the Island from future storm surges.

Monologue : “When we came here the first time, we saw the Island flat as a pancake, not more than three and a half feet above sea level… I know, people would build a park here and the park would be lost in the first storm,” says Adriaan Geuze of West 8 on the television channel HBO.

Sketch 02 : What if, elevating the land is considered one additional time to save Governors Island from storms and other anticipated disasters?

Constructions built on this Island, however permanent, whether for shelter, storage, parks, exhibitions, sport, industry, will always be temporary.

But adding a ground level or elevating the old one is the fluidity that complements the firmness and fixity of bedrock.

Field of Vison : The challenges of protecting the world’s coastlines will only get harder as climate change continues. This Island has the potential to become a landmark establishment by promoting climate resilience renovations. This Island needs a more resistant design rather than another city skyline.

19

BACK TO EARTH

20

onEarth

21

BACK TO EARTH

22

23

BACK TO EARTH

24

createsApproaches

25

BACK TO EARTH

26

createsApproaches

27

BACK TO EARTH

Year 2021, Building 14 Basement minus fifteen, Climate watch: Sunny at Plus zero, CO2 can fluctuate up as high as 500 parts per million, far above the global average of about 413.

28

createsApproaches

Year 2091, Building 14 Basement minus fifteen, Climate watch: Sunny at Plus zero, CO2 can fluctuate up as high as 2000 parts per million, far above the global average of about 500.

29

BACK TO EARTH

30

toDeployment

31

BACK TO EARTH

32

THE BLUEPRINT This Chapter talks about the compaction, loss of soil structure, nutrient degradation, and soil salinity. With a test of driving heavy machinery on soil that will also be known as soil’s new friend. ... .... .... .... ..................................

33

BACK TO EARTH

34

theResearch

Architecture—its crucial form and functions—has also undergone a transformation since the age of mechanization with the pervasive integration of various technologies.

My curiosity suggests that the passage underground can unlock new sensibilities and understandings of our relationship with the ground: as a historically loaded context and as a space of potential remediation and reclamation.

No aspect of our present life occurs without technological interfaces. Machines continually reshape human needs and wants. Cross breeding building, technology and material for more optimal social and environmental outcomes, allows us to imagine new ways that architecture and environment interact.

Figure X: Description.

In contrast, Governors Island is a constructed environment, from its layers of landfill to the more recent landscape interventions addressing sea-level rise. Much climate-change works of here celebrate strategies for wind, sun and green surfaces but overlooks the ground, where pollutants and extractive industries are lodged.

Therefore, with an anticipation that perhaps does not provision in the architectural world yet, more a concept of portraying the soil as a movement in itself and sometimes, where all of the mechanical and structural systems were pushed to nature, “not only so that they could be understood but can be a part of the earth without interruptions”is the pursuit I am looking forward to prepare.

35

BACK TO EARTH

36

suggestsUnlocking

Back to Earth The world needs mediating between the earth and the growth. If there was the equivalent of carbon trading in, could one modernizing nation “pay” another change? Could backwardness become a resource? Can Earth save the earth?

There is little awareness in this growth of mechanization, how different cultures have interpreted permanence, or of the variations in material, climate, and environment, which in themselves.

From a largely cultural concern, preservation has become a political issue, and heritage a right - and like all rights, susceptible to political correctness.

Bestowing an aura of authenticity and loving care, preservation can trigger massive surges in development.

In modernism, the concept of “house-as-machine” is reflected in a set of variations. Initially, it is identified as plain support of the domestic activities by technological means; then, it is extended to the ergonomic design of the house, in response to every possible design issue. Rooms with mechanical requirements favor a more integrated implementation of the machine, whereas rooms such as the living room and the bedroom are more flexible, as these may change in the house’s lifetime. Studies on the house of that era would focus on a special kind of variableness permitting transformations through standardization. The machine offered itself as the main reference to a radical revision of the design principles and a new philosophy about architecture. Compound structural models may offer more complex properties and may better respond to space’s total behavior; in that case, machine’s qualities such as efficiency and performance may be combined with other ones such as openness, flexibility, and adaptability.

37

BACK TO EARTH

Reyner Banham starts with a description of environmental management before we had modern systems. Most of the architecture was massive.

Thick and weighty structures had thermal advantages; the mass of masonry stores the heat of the fire during the day and keeps one warmer at night. By providing almost total control of the atmospheric variables of temperature, humidity, and purity, it has demolished almost all of the environmental constraints on a design that has survived that other great breakthrough, electric lighting.

38

suggestsUnlocking

The Centre Pompidou, designed by Renzo Piano and Richard Rogers, is a 20th-century architectural marvel, immediately recognizable by its exterior escalators and enormous colored tubing. According to Francesco Dal Co, author of Centre Pompidou: Renzo Piano, Richard Rogers, “...the building has many things, including inspiration to numerous cultural centers. But most importantly, it’s a paradox. The architects thought the huge public building was a gesture against power,” he says.

On the other hand, in Lydia Kallipoliti’s ‘The Architecture of Closed Worlds’, prototypes are presented through unique discursive narratives with historical images. Each includes new analysis in the form of a feedback drawing that problematizes the language of environmental representation by illustrating loss, derailment, and the production of new substances and atmospheres.

What do outer space capsules, submarines, and office buildings have in common? Each is conceived as a closed system: a self-sustaining physical environment demarcated from its surroundings by a boundary that does not allow for the transfer of matter or energy.

The Architecture of Closed Worlds is a genealogy of self-reliant environments.

From the space program to countercultural architectural groups experimenting with autonomous living, this publication documents a disciplinary transformation and the rise of a new environmental consensus in the form of synthetic naturalism.

No geology is neutral, writes Kathryn Yusoff. Tracing the color line of the Anthropocene, A Billion Black Anthropocenes or None examines how the grammar of geology is foundational to establishing the extractive economies of subjective life and the earth under colonialism and slavery.

39

BACK TO EARTH

40

suggestsUnlocking

Yusoff argues that “the Anthropocene is not reducible to anthropogenic climate change or to a carbon or capitalist imaginary” (p. 40). Rather it is merely the latest in a long history of traumatized worlds, beginning most recently with that attendant to the exploitation of (overwhelmingly) black and brown peoples associated with the resource extractions that enriched western European colonizers. State-sponsored geological inquiry originated as a means to discover, describe, and designate Earth materials for extraction. U.S Army expeditions to begin mapping the U.S. commenced in the 19th century, with the topographical engineers accompanied at times by the Cavalry to “pacify” the native Indians (Thomas and Warren, 2008). The Geological Exploration of the Fortieth Parallel (1867) was the first to specifically target natural resources across the newly expanded US, and led ultimately to the creation of the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS & Rabbitt, 1975).

Yusoff’s book challenged the idealized vision of geology as a purely scientific quest— an effort, at its most basic level, to read the planet’s history— because in Yusoff’s words “No geology is neutral.” She argues that, as a science that emerged from the need for resources, geology lies entangled inextricably with notions of conquest. Geology identifies and enables resource extraction, but does so without acknowledging the impacts of this activity on human subjects. “Geology is a hinge that joins indigenous genocide, slavery, and settler colonialism through an indifferent structure of extraction” (p. 107).

We are abandoning the reductionist approach of isolating a commodity to study, and instead considering the context of the commodity within the larger system of Earth and its inhabitants. It’s high time, we recognize geology’s insights to Earth as a system, an approach long embraced in the indigenous community and using that power to save—save new species, save new breeds, save new races and, save the earth itself.

41

BACK TO EARTH

42

newSensibilities

43

BACK TO EARTH

44

newSensibilities

45

BACK TO EARTH

46

newSensibilities

47

BACK TO EARTH

48

followingRemediation

49

BACK TO EARTH

50

THE MOVE

This Chapter talks about reinventing relation with earth using multiple interfaces. ... .... .... .... ..................................

51

BACK TO EARTH

Chakrabarti, Vishaan. A Country of Cities: A Manifesto for an Urban America, 2013. Print Clog. Data Space, 2012. Print Gorman, Michael J. Buckminster Fuller: Designing for Mobility.

Milan: Skira, 2005.Print.

52

soilFormation

Every day, architecture surprises the earth gifting a new relative of humans and non-human.?? The earth is undoubtedly more than an organism. It survives its own way and encounters new possibilities.

Sometimes, it opens the door to solve complex progressions, and sometimes, it creates new approaches for functional fabrication.

Someday, practicing architecture can serve as an example of how we can recreate our relationships with the environment. How we can delicately and respectfully, interact with creatures. Creatures, that are old and rare. Creatures, that our current methods of studying and living endanger.

53

BACK TO EARTH

54

soilFormation

55

BACK TO EARTH

56

soilFormation

57

BACK TO EARTH

58

linkingMachines

59

BACK TO EARTH

60

linkingMachines

61

BACK TO EARTH

62

linkingMachines

63

BACK TO EARTH

64

linkingMachines

65

BACK TO EARTH

66

linkingMachines

67

BACK TO EARTH

68

THE NEW STORY

This Chapter offers a radical new approach to Earth history in this intertwined tale of the planet’s human and nonhuman beings. ... .... .... .... ..................................

69

BACK TO EARTH

70

thenewStory

Today, if you completely want to study a living creature, you need to adapt to the creature’s natural state. Even then, your understanding of its ecosystem can be partial. Every particle on/in the earth is more complex than all the carbon in the ecology and the atmosphere combined. What’s more complex, is the relationship between the particles. What’s more dangerous, is to suggest another relationship called architecture.

Let’s save the earth with earth.

71

BACK TO EARTH

72

thenewStory

73

BACK TO EARTH

74

thenewStory

75

BACK TO EARTH

76

thenewStory

77

BACK TO EARTH

78

thenewStory

79

BACK TO EARTH

80

thenewStory

81

BACK TO EARTH

82

thenewStory

83

BACK TO EARTH

84

thenewStory

85

BACK TO EARTH

86

thenewStory

‘‘

Governors Island is a constructed environment, from its layers of landfill to the more recent landscape interventions addressing sea-level Much climate-change works of here celebrate strategies for wind, sun and green surfaces, but overlooks the ground...

87

BACK TO EARTH

[1]. Mathur, Anuradha, and Dilip Da Cunha. “Soil That New York Rejected and Re-Collects.” Landscape Journal, vol. 17, no. Special Issue, 1998, pp. 31–34., doi:10.3368/lj.17.special_issue.31.

[2]. ECOVOLT Romania - LP ELECTRIC Systems. (2010) Diagramă turbină eoliană. Retrieved February 22, 2013, from http://www.lpelectric.ro/ro/support/wind_diag_ro.html [3]. Sisson, Patrick. “Centre Pompidou, a Monument to Modernity: 8 Things You Didn’t Know.” Curbed, 24 Jan. 2017, archive.curbed. com/2017/1/23/14365014/centre-pompidou-paris-museum-renzo-pianorichard-rogers.

[4]. Hazen, Robert. “The Story of Earth by Robert M. Hazen: 9780143123644 | PenguinRandomHouse.Com: Books.” PenguinRandomhouse.Com, 2017, www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/308348/the-story-of-earth-byrobert-m-hazen.

[5]. “Talks.” ReSITE, 2005, www.resite.org/talks?gclid=Cj0KCQjwp86EBhD7ARIsAFkgakjE56diOvIjJsf9Fz1Wnvq4TxXeKiOyRKE11HwtWt9Zb32mOVZE6zwaAj7MEALw_wcB. [6]. Perez, Adelyn. “AD Classics: AD Classics: Centre Georges Pompidou / Renzo Piano Building Workshop + Richard Rogers.” ArchDaily, 2 Feb. 2021, www.archdaily.com/64028/ad-classics-centre-georges-pompidou-renzopiano-richard-rogers.

[7]. Aguilar, Cristian. “Soil Centre Copenhagen / Christensen & Co.” ArchDaily, 24 Oct. 2019, www.archdaily.com/469885/soil-centre-copenhagen-christensen-and-co.

88

References

[8]. “The History Of.” Governors Island, 2000, www.govisland.com/history.

[9]. “Contemplating and Commemorating Rapid Transit in New York City.”

Museum of the City of New York, 1999, www.mcny.org/story/contemplatingand-commemorating-rapid-transit-new-york-city?gclid=Cj0KCQjwp86EBhD7 ARIsAFkgakh0OeVwTTA7yv2fnOMBU1dDO5LnpjjasJ7XSuZ-7LHIPL2M3FI9afkaAm38EALw_wcB. [10] Harvard University Graduate School of Design. “Kathryn Yusoff, ‘Geo-Logics: Natural Resources as Necropolitics.’” Harvard Graduate School of Design, 2 Dec. 2020, www.gsd.harvard.edu/event/kathryn-yusoff-natural-resources-asgeologic-necropolitics.

[11] Soreghan, Lynn. “‘A Billion Black Anthropocenes or None.’” Inhabiting the Anthropocene, 16 Dec. 2020, inhabitingtheanthropocene.com/2020/12/02/abillion-black-anthropocenes-or-none.

[12] Yusoff, Kathryn. A Billion Black Anthropocenes or None (Forerunners: Ideas First). Univ Of Minnesota Press, 2018.

89

BACK TO EARTH Page II | Racial Justice | Fall 2020 | ARCH 901 | Instructor: Ariane Lourie Harrison Page III | Conjectural GI | Fall 2020 | ARCH 901 | Instructor: Ariane Lourie Harrison Page IV | Weather Underground | Fall 2020 | ARCH 981 | Instructor: Cynthia Davidson Page10 | Soil Boring Sample | Spring 2021 | ARCH 902 | Instructor: Dorothy Tang Shine Fall 2020 | ARCH 813 | Instructor: Jeffrey Page IV | The Sunflower Shine| Anderson Page14 | Mapping Geo in GI | Fall 2020 | ARCH 901 | Instructor: Ariane Lourie Harrison Page16 | The New Shoe Polish | Fall 2020 | ARCH 813 | Instructor: Jeffrey Anderson Machine Fall 2020 | ARCH 813 | Instructor: Jeffrey Page18 | The Shoe Machine| Anderson Post Human| Human Fall 2020 | ARCH 901 | Instructor: Ariane Lourie Page20 |Post Harrison Physical Modelling| Modelling Fall 2020 | ARCH 901 | Instructor: Ariane Lourie Page22-23 |Physical Harrison The Weather Underground| Fall 2020 | ARCH 901 | Instructor: Ariane Page26-28 |The Harrison Page30 | Soil Boring | Spring 2021 | ARCH 902 | Instructor: Dorothy Tang Speculative Section| Section Fall 2020 | ARCH 901 | Instructor: Ariane LouriePage32|Speculative Harrison Weather Underground| Underground Fall 2020 | ARCH 901 | Instructor: Ariane Page40-45|Weather Harrison 90

Image Citations Page 36-40 | Racial Justice | Fall 2020 | ARCH 901 | Instructor: Ariane Lourie Harrison Artificial Secretive| Secretive Fall 2020 | ARCH 901 | Instructor: Ariane Lourie Page46|Artificial Harrison Page48| Soil Boring | Spring 2021 | ARCH 902 | Instructor: Dorothy Tang, in collaboration with Humna Naveed.

The Weather Alternative| Alternative Fall 2020 | ARCH 901 | Instructor: Ariane Page50|The Harrison Mechanization Territory| Territory Spring 2021| ARCH 902 | Instructor: Ferda Page50|Mechanization Kolatan Mechanization Territory| Territory Spring 2021| ARCH 902 | Instructor: Ferda Page56-62|Mechanization Kolatan Streamlining Land| Land Spring 2021| ARCH 902 | Instructor: Ferda Page64|Streamlining Kolatan Page66| Soil Boring | Spring 2021 | ARCH 902 | Instructor: Dorothy Tang Page68| Soil Boring | Spring 2021 | ARCH 902 | Instructor: Dorothy Tang Page68| Soil Fabrication | Spring 2021 | ARCH 902 | Instructor: Alina Gorokhova Streamlining Land| Land Spring 2021| ARCH 902 | Instructor: Angela Page72-76|Streamlining Huang Back to Earth| Earth Spring 2021| ARCH 902 | Instructor: Ferda Page78|Back Kolatan Back to Earth| Earth Spring 2021| ARCH 902 | Instructor: Ferda Page80|Back Kolatan Back to Earth| Earth Spring 2021| ARCH 902 | Instructor: Ferda Page84|Back Kolatan 91