Estimating ‘Not There Yet’���������������������������

Fully Automated AI Collision Repair Estimating ‘Not There Yet’

A panel discussion at the Collision Industry Conference (CIC) in Las Vegas in November included representatives from a number of technology companies touting the potential benefits—for auto body shops and insurers—of artificial intelligence (AI) estimating, but also acknowledging some of its current limitations. “We’re not there yet, 100%, with straight-through processing,” said Dune Pagaduan of Mitchell International, referring to AI being capable of completing all estimates

procedures for the “So not everythingShop Showcase specific vehicle. is AI. We comwith Ed Attanasiobine it with the OEM procedures and our editorial data to produce that specific accurate estimate.” In discussing what AI estimating offers shops specifically, the panelists noted the wide variance in estimates often seen even when Social Media for Shops with Ed Attanasiodifferent estimators look at the same vehicle. AI can help collision repair businesses increase consistency in their estimating, Pagaduan said. Panelist Jason Verlen of CCC Intelligent Solutions said it also offers shops access to photos and in-SEMA Show Goes On with Ed Attanasioformation even before the customer arrives.

“So there’s huge increases and improvements in cycle time” and the customer experience, Verlen said. “But it’s not like AI solves all the world’s problems.” He noted the panel moderator talked about recently watching an estimating contest at a Texas trade show in which 16 estimators writing for a quarter panel replacement on a mainstream vehicle came up with 16 different estimates, ranging from 130 lines to 400 lines. “So someone may ask me: ‘Is your AI accurate? Does it match what a human would do?’ My answer is: Which one of those [16] guys do you want me to match,” Verlen said. “That’s why I say AI is no magical bullet. That’s why we combine AI with build sheet data, with business rules, with insurer Media and Publicity for Shops with Ed Attanasio guidelines, and that’s how we come up with an estimate that’s reasonable to the situation.” He suggested to “reduce skepticism” among new users, the systems’ thresholds should be set high at first so “virtually everything the AI generates on an estimate a human will agree to.” Then gradually loosen the thresholds to get more complete estimates, he said, after skeptics have “been trained to see that it does work” even if there are at times a “difference in opinion.”

Jimmy Spears of Tractable said his company’s artificial intelligence estimating system has become adept at quickly determining from photos if a vehicle is a total loss. “One of things that AI does a wonderful job on is triage,” Spears said. “We’re in the high 90s of calling balls and strikes: Is this car repairableoristhiscarnotrepairable.”

For insurers, he said, the system

without human interaction. “So is AI real? Sure, it assists us in making and automating decisions, thousands at a time…more quickly so that we shrink cycle time. But you still need experts, humans, to complete the whole process.”

He said AI systems can currently write accurate estimates on “low-severity collisions.” “But when you get to higher severity type collisions—more complex, more parts—then that’s the journey we have to go to get to that 100%,” he said. “I think in the next two to three years, we’ll get there.”

The panelists were asked if any AI system built on historical data can identify substrates, systems and OEM procedures for nearly new vehicles often involved in collisions. “That is the challenge,” Pagaduan said, noting historical data ideally needs to be paired with other information in the system, like OEM build sheet data and OEM repair

Shop StrategiesDune Pagaduan of Mitchell International said AI can help collision repair businesses with Stacey Phillipsincrease consistency in their estimating Jason Verlen of CCC Intelligent Solutions said about 22% of repairable claims are currently processed through AI photo-estimating He noted as recently as three years ago, fewer than 1% of vehicle Body Shops Giving Back with claims involved photo-estimating. Stacey Phillips “As of today, roughly 22% of repairable claims go through the process,” he said. “And we have

Ti some carriers on our system where over 70% of their repairable claims ps for Busy Body Shops with go through CCC Stacey Phillips photo offers AI.” a product, Estimate-STP, which, Verlen said, on low-impact collisions can write a complete estimate with no needed

My SEMA review or changes by a human. Beyond that, he acknowledged, it’s still with “a Stacey Phillipsjoint process between the human and theAI.” But the AI does “make the process much more efficient,” he said, in part by getting a consumer an estimate faster, which in turn speeds their decision-making about choos-Shop Strategies with Vi ing a shop and scheduling repairs.ctoria Antonelli

Toll Free: 800-551-8189

Parts Direct: 318-425-3417 Fax: 318-425-1705

Electronic Catalog Available Online!

Your Best Source for Genuine GM Parts, Powertrain Engines and Transmissions

• Fast, Next-Day Delivery • Millions in Inventory • We also sell tires!

7500 Youree Drive Shreveport, LA 71105 www.chevyland.com

with with