Southwest Edition Texas Oklahoma Louisiana New Mexico
28
YEARS
www.autobodynews.com
Threat of Lawsuit Leads to Postponement of Latest CIC Parts Presentation by John Yoswick Special to Autobody News
Just hours before industry trainer Toby Chess was to make another presentation about non-OEM bumper and structural parts at the Collision Industry Conference (CIC) in Atlanta on April 15, Chess said he was threatened with a lawsuit if he did so. He declined to reveal who threatened the legal action but said, because he had not had a chance to consult with an attorney, he chose to forego making his presentation at the meeting. In presentations at the previous two CIC meetings in November and January, Chess showed potential problems with a number of non-OEM bumper parts, including apparent significant differences in the material and structure of the parts. That has
led at least four insurers to pull back from the use of such parts; it has also led parts suppliers to develop improved tracking and recall programs for the parts, and to the launch of several testing and certification programs for such parts. Chess was clearly frustrated by the threat of legal action against him, saying he never portrayed the demonstrations as scientific research but merely as a way to “bring light” to a potential problem. “I was asked last month why I did this,” Chess said. “I said that I don’t work for insurance companies, I don’t work for parts companies, I don’t work for body shops. I work for the consumer. I’m a trainer. I teach. So I have no vested stake in this. I thought it was necessary to say these things. I think we’ve demonstrated to the See Threat of Lawsuit, Page 4
SCRS Forum Brings State Shop Associations Together to Discuss Efforts and Share Ideas by John Yoswick Special to Autobody News
Collision repair associations leaders from around the country met in Secaucus, New Jersey, in March to share ideas and discuss state legislative or regulatory successes and efforts. The 2010 East Coast Resolution Forum, an event sponsored by the Society of Collision Repair Specialists (SCRS) and the Alliance of Janet Chaney
Automotive Service Providers (AASP) of New Jersey, was held in conjunction with AASP-New Jersey’s NORTHEAST 2010 trade show. Here’s a round-up of some of the news and discussion from the meeting: Iowa: Janet Chaney, of the Iowa Collision Repair Association, reported on the progress of a proposed state law the group supports that would in essence allow Iowa shops to transfer the expense of sales tax on paint materials they purchase to insurers or customers. Chaney said currently shops pay the sales tax on such purchases but are not reimbursed for it by insurers.
See SCRS Forum, Page 6
VOL. 28 ISSUE 5 MAY 2010
GM Pays Back Gov’t Loans Years Early; Chrysler Posts Operating Profit in Q1
In what can only be called a remarkable turnaround since last year’s bankruptcy procedings, both GM and Chrylser have rewarded the faith of “bailout” proponents with strong first quarter results reflecting better vehicle sales buoyed by a thawing economy and improved consumer spending. General Motors announced it has repaid loans from the U.S. government, five years ahead of schedule. GM completed the repayment of its loans from the U.S. and Canadian governments by paying the outstanding balances of $4.7 billion and $1.1 billion respectively. In addition, Chrysler announced an operating profit for the first quarter of 2010, so may soon be in a position to start to repay its government loans as well. Chrysler posted a $143-million operating profit in the first quarter and was on track to at least break even this
year on an operating basis with a stronger cash position. Chrysler owes the U.S. government nearly $7 billion in loans. Payments on principal are not due until 2011 and full repayment is not expected until 2014. The administration wasted no time in taking credit where it is due, saying that not only did the $85 billion auto industry bailout work, it saved millions of jobs. President Barack Obama “took a lot of heat” to keep GM alive, said Vice President Joe Biden. “And this has even exceeded our expectations.” White House press secretary Robert Gibbs led off his press briefing with the GM and Chrysler news, saying it justifies President Obama's “very difficult and unpopular decision” to loan them money last year. The loans were designed to assist “a structured See Bailout Bonus, Page 3
CONTENT HIGHLIGHTS
• CIC Presentation Postponed
• Plano’s Ray Huffines Chevrolet Wins on Margins • Houston Auto Body Association • It’s a Safety Marketplace • Dallas Forcing Body Shop Owners Out • TIAA Fishing Tournament and Meeting
Toyota Fined, Awaits Class Action Still A Mustang, in name only, part 2 Gonzo’s Toolbox: “Slick Talkin’ Mechanic”
Change Service Requested
See Page 19
Service, Service, Diagnostic Diiagnostic D and an d Mechanical M e ch aniccal al NEWS nd Mec echanical Mech ech ec hanical ca
www.autobodynews.com
P.O. BOX 1400, OCEANSIDE, CA 92051-1400
Presorted Standard US Postage PAID Ontario, Ca. Permit No. 1
DAVID McDAVID T H I S B R A N D S TA N D S F O R S AV I N G S
ACURA OF AUSTIN • Over $400,000 Parts Inventory • 15,000 Parts in Stock • Trained Experienced Crew
• In State Next Day Shipping w/Quick Local Delivery • Great Discounts
Hour: Monday - Friday 7 AM - 7 PM • Saturday 8 AM - 5 PM • Sunday Closed
Wholesale Parts Specialist: John Raygo 512-401-5976 Watts 800-575-3553 Parts 512-401-5976 Fax 512-401-5988 jraygo@mcdavid.com
ACURA OF PLANO • Over $500,000 Parts Inventory • 15,000 Parts in Stock • Trained Experienced Crew
• In State Next Day Shipping w/Quick Local Delivery • Great Discounts
Hour: Monday - Friday 7 AM - 6 PM • Saturday 8 AM - 5 PM • Sunday Closed
Wholesale Parts Specialist: Danny Waide Phone 972-964-6000 972-964-6044 Fax 972-964-6070 dwaide@mcdavid.com
LINCOLN MERCURY OF PLANO • Over $400,000 Parts Inventory • 8,000 Parts in Stock • Trained Experienced Crew
• In State Next Day Shipping w/Quick Local Delivery • Great Discounts
Hour: Monday - Friday 7 AM - 6 PM • Saturday 7:30 AM - 4 PM • Sunday Closed
Parts Manager: John Keith Phone 972-964-5000 Fax 972-985-3114 jkeith@mcdavid.com
HONDA OF FRISCO • Over $600,000 Parts Inventory • 11,000 Parts in Stock • Trained Wholesale Crew: Mario, Phillip
• In State Next Day Shipping w/Quick Local Delivery • Great Discounts
Hour: Monday - Friday 7 AM - 7 PM • Saturday 7:30 AM - 5:30 PM • Sunday 11 AM - 4 PM
Parts Manager: Dan Zieber Phone 972-731-3175 Toll Free 1-866-442-2711 Fax 972-731-3179 dzieber@mcdavid.com
HONDA OF IRVING • Over $900,000 Parts Inventory • 17,000 Parts in Stock • Trained Wholesale Crew: Gary, Marie, Jim
• In State Next Day Shipping w/Quick Local Delivery • Great Discounts
Hour: Monday - Friday 7 AM - 9 PM • Saturday 8 AM - 5 PM • Sunday 11 AM - 6 PM
Parts Manager: Dan Zieber Phone 972-790-6008 Toll Free 1-800-492-4464 Fax 972-790-6066 hondaparts@mcdavid.com
HONDA OF HOUSTON • Over $1,000,000 Parts Inventory • In State Next Day Shipping w/Quick Local Delivery • 100,000 Parts in Stock • Great Discounts • Trained Experienced Crew Hour: Monday - Friday 7 AM - 9 PM • Saturday 8 AM - 5 PM • Sunday Closed
Parts Manager: Scott Bentley Phone 800-444-1263 Fax 713-948-1949 wwood@mcdavid.com
NISSAN OF HOUSTON • Over 1.3 Million Parts Inventory • 28,000 Parts • Trained Experienced Crew
• Texas & Louisiana Next Day Shipping • Great Discounts
WELCOME TO THE
DAVID McDAVID M MccDAVID AUTO GROUP
Hour: Monday - Friday 7 AM - 6 PM • Saturday 8 AM - 5 PM • Sunday Closed
Parts Manager: Dick Graham Phone 800-231-9657 Fax 713-948-1949 nissanparts@mcdavid.com 2 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
www.davidmcdavid.com
Contents
‘R2R Act’ Bipartisan Co-sponsor List Grows . . . . . . . . 18 80 Percent of Tested Cars Fail Inspection Checks. . . . 21 AAA Oklahoma Gave Consumers Crash Prevention Course . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 Administration Continues Push for Accident Prevention . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 Aluminum Roof Replacement On The Mitsubishi Lancer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36 Arizona Auto Glass Fraud Bill Passes State Senate 28-0 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 ASAA Opposing Ohio OEM Parts Legislation . . . . . . . . 21 Attanasio - Car West Elite Hits its Numbers . . . . . . . . 28 Attanasio - Marina Auto Body Melds Dealership Relationships & DRPs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38 BMW Group has Sales Growth of 13.8% In First Quarter 20 CA Auto Recycler Meets with Rep. Thompson in DC on R2R . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 CA Insurance Commissioner Says Mercury Illegally Overcharged . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 CAPA 501 Standard for Bumper System Parts . . . . . . . 10 Car Car Council Wants Consumers to Remember Their Three “R’s”. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 CARSTAR Collision Centers Promotes Green Initiatives . 7 Causey - Games Insurers Play . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 CAWA Battery Core Bill Now Law in Arizona . . . . . . . . . 21 City of Dallas Forcing Body Shop Owners Out . . . . . . 18 CRA Aftermarket Parts Demonstration Gets Major Media Attention . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 El Paso, TX, Body Shop is Target of Attorney General Lawsuit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 Evans - Working On a ‘57 Thunderbird With Old School Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 Falling Average Vehicle Product Use. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 First Responders Get Vehicle Extrication Training Courtesy of GCIA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 Franklin - Concentrate Your Marketing Firepower . . . . 13 GM Pays Back Gov’t Loans Years Early; Chrysler Posts Operating Profit in Q1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 GM, Carfax Unite to Push Out Recall News . . . . . . . . 18 Gonzo's Toolbox - “You’re Just One of Those Slick
Talkin’ Mechanics” . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 Houston Auto Body Association Joins Existing Texas Associations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Houston Auto Body Association Joins Existing Texas Associations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34 Maaco Positions Itself As Customer Pay Provider. . . . 10 Maryland Salvage Bill Now Awaits Governor Signature. 18 McGee and Webster - It’s Still a Mustang®; But in Name Only – PART 2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 Minnesota Body Shop Gets 30% of Power From Solar Arrays . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Mitchell Inc. Gives CAA Members Open-House Tour of Facilities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 Mitchell Releases Industry's Total Loss Vehicle Configuration Solution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 National Performance Buys Speed Warehouse of Hayward, CA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 New Revolution® Lift Line Offers Quality & Value at the Right Price . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 Parts for Profit, Part 2—Profitable Management . . . . 16 Plano’s Ray Huffines Chevrolet Wins on Margins in Wholesale Parts. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 PPG Chairman Charles Bunch Reports on New Strategy 32 SCRS Forum Brings State Shop Associations Together . . 1 State Farm Prevails in Gunder Slander Suit. . . . . . . . . 33 Suppliers Partnership Adds Five New Corporate Members . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 Texas Companies Leave Millions in Tax Credits Unclaimed. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Threat of Lawsuit Leads to Postponement . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 TIAA 2010 Scholarship Fishing Tournament. . . . . . . . . . 11 TIAA Annual Meeting Includes Leadership Training, Hotel Stay. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 TIAA Has Free PCI Terminal Perk from Bancard Group. . . 11 Toyota Fined $16.4M, Will Face Single Sudden Acceleration Lawsuit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 Transmission Anti-Rollaway Shift Interlocks Now Required 21 U.S. Chemical Introduces Two New 2.1 VOC Primers . . . 37 Yoswick - Insurers And Shops Don’t Speak Same Language . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30
Serving Texas, Oklahoma, Louisiana, New Mexico and adjacent metro areas, Autobody News is a monthly publication for the autobody industry. Permission to reproduce in any form the material published in Autobody News must be obtained in writing from the publisher. ©2010 Adamantine Media LLC.
Autobody News
Box 1400, Oceanside, CA 92051 (800) 699-8251 (214) 371-6626 Fax www.autobodynews.com Email: news@autobodynews.com Aegis Tools . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
LKQ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
BMW Wholesale Parts Dealers . . . . . . . 23
Mercedes-Benz of Oklahoma . . . . . . . . 35
Chassis Liner. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
Mitsubishi Wholesale Parts Dealers . . . 36
Autoland Scientech. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 Chacon Suzuki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
Chevyland . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30
Classifieds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39
David McDavid . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Ford Wholesale Parts Dealers
TX, OK, LA, NM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
Fredy Kia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
Gladwin Paint . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
Goodson Honda West . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
Honda/Acura Wholesale Parts Dealers 37
Huffines Hyundai McKinney . . . . . . . . . 15
Huffines Hyundai Plano . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 Hyundai Wholesale Parts Dealers . . . . 26 Kia Motors Wholesale Parts Dealers . . . . 9
Continued from Page 1
Bailout bonus
Southwest
Indexof Advertisers
Publisher & Editor: Jeremy Hayhurst General Manager: Barbara Davies Contributing Writers: Tom Franklin, John Yoswick, Lee Amaradio, Dan Espersen Janet Chaney, Toby Chess, Mike Causey, Tom McGee, Stefan Gesterkamp, Rich Evans Advertising Sales: Joe Momber, Christina Shubert (800) 699-8251 Advertising Sales Assistant: Stephanie Bowling Art Director: Rodolfo Garcia
Mazda Wholesale Parts Dealers . . . . . . 34
Mike Calvert Toyota. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 MOPAR Wholesale Parts Dealers . . . . . 11
Nissan/Infiniti Wholesale Parts Dealers . . . 33
Park Place Lexus. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
Ray Huffines Chevrolet . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
Replica Plastics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29
SCA Appraisal Company . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
Suzuki Wholesale Parts Dealers . . . . . . 31
Soft-Sanders from Style-Line, Corp . . . 25
Toyota Wholesale Parts Dealers . . . . . . 38
VIM Tools. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 Volkswagen Wholesale Parts Dealers . . . 32
Volvo Wholesale Parts Dealers . . . . . . . 33
Young Chevrolet . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
bankruptcy, and save 1 million to 3 million jobs.” While the Obama administration still expects a loss on the taxpayer bailout of the industry, it will be smaller than initially forecast. The White House budget office once projected the loss on the GM package alone to be some $30B, but now says it will likely not exceed $8B. GM didn't need to be making this payment now. The company had already paid back $2 billion of what it owes under the terms of the Troubled Asset Relief Program that began in December of 2008. The company had until 2015 to repay the rest but chose to do so now for reasons of business psychology in an attempt to reduce the “Government Motors” taint. “We’ve developed a healthy, clean balance sheet and we’ve developed a cost structure that allows us to be competitive,” CEO Ed Whitacre, said of GM’s performance. Much of GM’s improvement comes from slashing its debt load and workforce as part of its bankruptcy reorganization last year. It has stated it wants to be a public company again as soon as practical, but CEO Whitacre's team has backed off of that commitment somewhat. GM is still a long way from regaining its blue-chip status. It remains
more than 60 per cent government-owned and lost $3.4 billion in last year's fourth quarter alone. Chrysler, now run by Italy's Fiat Group, posted an operating profit of $143 million in the first quarter that was attributed to cost cuts and sales of its new Ram Heavy Duty pickup. The company is building up cash but had a net loss of $197 million in the quarter and has shed $3.78 billion after it emerged from bankruptcy on June 10. That loss included $2.1 billion in payments to the healthcare trust fund of the United Auto Workers. Chrysler-Fiat CEO Sergio Marchionne has said Chrysler will break even this year (Fiat also lost significant money last year) saying, “This positive operating result in the first quarter is a concrete indication to our customers, dealers and suppliers that the 2010 targets we have set for ourselves are achievable. We are also generating cash to finance the investments being made in our product portfolio and brand repositioning,” Larry Summers, presidential economic adviser and co-architect of the bailout, wrote: In 2008, the American auto industry lost over 400,000 jobs and analysts estimated that at least 1 million more jobs could have been lost had GM and Chrysler liquidated. That didn't happen. Instead, over the past nine months since GM and Chrysler emerged from bankruptcy, the industry has actually added 45,000 jobs— the strongest pace of job growth in the auto industry in nearly a decade.
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 3
CRA Aftermarket Parts Demonstration Gets Major Media Attention
In a media-oriented demonstration organized by the Collision Repair Association of California (CRA), Autobody News’ columnists CRA President Lee Amaradio (left in photo) and Industry Trainer Toby Chess (using saw) were featured on ABC TV news replicating Chess’ earlier demonstration of softer steel in certain aftermarket parts vs higher-strength steel in OEM bumper reinforcements.
Attending the April 8 demonstration in Sacramento was California State Assemblyman Dave Jones, (flanked by Amaradio (l) and Chess (r) in the photo adjacent) who said he wants claimants notified if they had their vehicles repaired with any aftermarket bumper bar. Jones said he wants insurers to stop requiring the use of aftermarket rebars. Jones released the following statement on April 9: “Unbeknownst to most Californians, for many years inferior aftermarket parts have been installed in their cars when they are repaired as part of an insurance claim after a collision. These substandard parts can affect the safety and performance of the vehicle in a future collision and pose a serious risk to anyone on California roads and highways. Lee Amaradio steadies an aftermarket reinforcement bar for Toby Chess California law rewho saws through it in a press demonstration of apparent differences quires that aftermarket between OEM and aftermarket reinforcement bars. replacement crash parts only be used in the reIn the photo Lee Amaradio steadies an pair of an automobile if “the parts are at aftermarket reinforcement bar for Toby least equal to the original equipment manChess who saws through it in a press ufacturer parts in terms of kind, quality, demonstration of the apparent difference safety, fit, and performance,” and that inbetween OEM and an unspecified type of surers warrant that these parts are in fact aftermarket reinforcement bar. The saw as good or better than the manufacturer hardly scratched the OEM part (see video parts. at www.autobodynews.com) yet cut this Today, I am calling on the Insurance particular aftermarket part with apparent Commissioner and the Insurance Industry ease. to:
Continued from Page 1
Threat of Lawsuit
industry that there has to be more than just selling these parts. I hope that after I get some legal counsel on this, I can come back to you and show you more of what I did find. Some (of the non-OEM parts) are very good. And I was prepared to tell you about that.” What may have provoked alarm in the market was that Chess was preparing to present his results on a series of tests on OEM and aftermarket hoods. In part, Chess had intended to point out that a particular replacement hood for an ‘09 Corolla, which was CAPA-certified, had tested very close to the OEM control in his analysis. Of course, this information was not relayed to the attendees. Without confirming or denying it was the source of threatened legal action against
Chess, LKQ Corporation, following the CIC meeting issued a written statement about Chess’ presentations (see sidebar above), including the one last November in which he used a firefighter’s extrication saw to show it was easier to cut through the metal used to make a particular non-OEM bumper bar being sold as a replacement for an OEM part made from ultra-high-strength steel. In its statement, LKQ Corporation said it tried to replicate such a test and found “the saw [also] cut through the OE rebar with relative ease, “raising concerns that “there is a lot of misinformation being spread.” The company pointed to crash testing it did that it says showed both an OEM and non-OEM bumper passed federal safety standards for passenger protection. A number of CIC participants in Atlanta after Chess’ announcement expressed outrage that legal threats would be used to
4 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
inforcement bars; * Notify the owners of the vehicles of the existence of these substandard parts and the risk they pose; and, * Develop a program to replace all of the defective bumper reinforcement bars on California roads and highways. If the Insurance InState Assemblyman Dave Jones flanked by CRA president Lee Amaradio dustry is not able to take (left) and ICAR trainer Toby Chess (right) announces his plan to take legthese simple steps to islative action if Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner fails to address comply with California the issue of damaged vehicles repaired with aftermarket reinforcement law and protect our resibars. Jones said he wants claimants notified if they had their vehicles repaired with an aftermarket bumper bar and said he wants insurers to stop dents, legislation should requiring the use of aftermarket bars. be introduced that orders insurance companies to * Identify all of the vehicles that con- do so, and provides strict penalties for failtain these inferior aftermarket bumper re- ing to do so.”
LKQ Issues Statement Following CIC Meeting “LKQ believes the collision industry needs accurate and relevant information. In an effort to determine the veracity of Mr. Chess’ “sawzall” test at NACE in November 2009, we attempted to replicate his test of the OE rebar. Our results were significantly different! The saw cut through the OE rebar with relative ease.
“Questioning the relevance of a sawzall test, we chose to conduct crash tests of the aftermarket part. The results of the tests, which more accurately replicate actual accident condi-
prevent a presentation and open discussion at the meeting. Speaking as a past CIC Chairman, Chuck Sulkala said this was the first such incident he was aware of in CIC’s nearly 30-year history. He said Chess was merely raising awareness of issues that had been discussed for decades, and commended parts suppliers for finally taking action in the months since Chess’ previous presentations to address traceability of the parts. “To have something stopped because of a potential lawsuit is shooting the messenger,” Sulkala said. “The day of stopping discussions at CIC because of a legal issue has got to come to an end. It should never have come to be in the first place.” Industry consultant John Bosin, who chairs the CIC Parts Committee, also called such a threat of legal action “reprehensible” and told Chess he would help start a legal defense fund if necessary.
tions, showed the aftermarket rebar met FMVSS208, the federal standard for occupant safety. “That both the OE and aftermarket rebars performed well in the crash test was not surprising. But, by performing the sawzall test ourselves, it is very clear to us that there is a lot of misinformation being spread. LKQ believes that it is important for the consumer and the industry to receive relevant and accurate information, so we have communicated that message to the parties involved.”
“Whomever has initiated this (threat of) legal action passed up the opportunity to use this as the forum it is, to express their views,” Bosin said. “We would have been open. We may not have liked what we heard, but they could have come here. They were welcome. Whoever it is, why aren’t they here talking about the issue and telling us what their concerns are and explaining their actions.” CIC Chairman and Collision Week publisher Russ Thrall assured CIC attendees he would “figure a way through this to make sure the things that need to be said get said.” Like Bosin, he said CIC’s mission is to serve as an open forum for the industry. “If there’s a presentation up here that you find uncomfortable or you feel is wrong, that’s why the microphones (throughout the room) exist,” Thrall said.
Hit awiwith HOME RUN! ith our G Genuine enuiine eF Ford ord rd dP Parts art a ts When it comes to Ford Genuine Parts, go with a winning team. Use Genuine Ford Parts for your customers’ late model Ford, Lincoln and Mercury vehicles. You're always guaranteed that they will fit right the first time, every time.
Hit One Out of the Park! Call your local Authorizedd Ford Wholesaler today! These dealers are Genuine Ford Parts wholesale specialists. Bob Tomes Ford, Lincoln, Mercury M cK I N N E Y
800-792-1155 214-544-5081 214-544-5194 Fax
Casa Ford, Lincoln, Mercury E L PA SO
915-490-8437 915-775-8259 Fax gilbert@casaford.com www.casaford.com
Champion Ford Gulf Freeway H O U S TO N
Wholesale Direct
800-388-4005 713-371-4111 713-371-4101 Fax
Five Star Ford
N O RT H R I C H L A ND HILLS Wholesale Direct
800-895-7827 817-577-2781 817-577-0558 Fax www.5starford.com
Gene Messer Ford, Mazda, Lincoln, Mercury AMARILLO
Wholesale Direct
806-355-7417 806-352-9604 Fax
ribarra@genemesser.com
Fordparts.com/genemesser
Helfman Ford STAF FORD
800-634-8008 281-240-0642 Fax
parts@helfmanford.com
www.fordparts.com/helfman
Kinsel Ford BEAUMONT
Wholesale Direct
800-468-4550 866-339-7711 Fax
Lone Star Ford HOUS TON
800-756-2293 281-931-3300 281-931-3378 Fax
ronnie.yates@lonestarford.com
TEX A S
Mac Haik Ford, Lincoln, Mercury GEORGETOWN/AUSTIN
800-804-4423 512-930-6260 512-930-6345 Fax parts@machaikflm.com
www.machaikflm.com/orderparts
North Park Lincoln, Mercury SAN ANTONIO
800-880-8846 Toll 210-341-8846 Direct 210-341-3904 Fax
www.fordparts.com/northparklm
Park Cities Ford DALL AS
214-504-1626 214-358-4186 Fax parts@pcford.com
www.parkcitiesford.com
Russell & Smith Ford
OKLA HOMA
Tommie Vaughn Motors
Bob Moore Ford O K L A HO M A C I T Y
405-246-2393 405-246-2348 Fax
HOUSTO N
800-944-4415 713-293-4309 Fax
gburns@bobmoore.com
Town East Ford
United Ford PDC
972-682-1293 972-682-1290 Fax
800-800-9001 800-676-8509 Fax
TULSA
MESQUI TE
Wholesale Direct
Wholesale Direct
tglover@vtaig.com
mberger@penskeautomotive.com
Waxahachie Ford
N EW MEXICO
www.towneastford.com
WAXAHACHIE
888-325-4947 972-825-4577 Direct 972-825-4576 Direct lyanez@landerscorp.com
www.waxahachieford.com
www.fordparts.com/unitedford
Bob Turner Ford Country A L B U QU E R Q U E
Wholesale Direct
800-432-8321 505-449-1250 505-449-1209 Fax
HOUS TON
800-392-1983 713-664-0965 Fax
www.lonestarford.com
Make us your one-stop shop today! www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 5
Continued from Page 1
SCRS Forum
The bill (HF 2530) would exempt shops from sales tax for wholesale materials purchases if sales tax is billed and collected as a line item to the shops’ customers. “That’s money right in our members’ pockets,” Chaney said. “If it’s a $1 million shop, that’s $10,000.” An Iowa House committee had approved the bill, though it failed to make further legislative progress before lawmakers adjourned the session. Montana: Chaney, who also represents the Montana Collision Repair Specialists, said a past president of the association, Max Yates of Yates Body Shop in Butte, Mont., has registered to run as a Republican for an open House seat in the Montana legislature. “He said, ‘I’m tired of complaining about it. I’m going to see if I can make a difference,” Chaney said. SCRS Executive Director Aaron Schulenburg said such efforts are important for the industry. “Because that gives us somebody inside that body, being able to speak our voice to their peers, instead of just us speaking to them as a legislative body,” Schulenburg said. New Jersey: Charlie Bryant of AASP-New Jersey said state regulators have told the association that companies conducting mobile repairs—such as those doing lot repairs at dealerships—are not covered under the state’s shop licensing law. He said the association is working to change that, in part by pointing ouot that even photos on some of those companies’ websites show them doing more than just minor damage repairs. Representatives from other states at the meeting told Bryant they have successfully addressed mobile repair operations by speaking with environmental regulators, the fire marshal, and even land zoning agencies (when a dealership was not zoned to have a body shop at its location). Pennsylvania: Steve Behrndt, of the Pennsylvania Collision Trade Guild, expressed concern about a towing-related legislation in his state that he believes could have profound impact on collision repairs. Behrndt said the bill (HB 2041), which has been passed by the Pennsylvania House and has been introduced in the Senate, prohibits a tower from obtaining a signature authorizing repairs, or from refusing to release a vehicle to an insurer when paid for towing and storage, seemingly overriding current state law requiring permission from the vehicle-owner. It also requires a tower to notify the insurer of a vehicle, if known, the whereabouts of the vehicle within 24 hours of the tow. Behrndt said all these provisions will make it easier for an insurer to get a vehicle into a shop of its choice.
“We call this legalized wreck-chasing on behalf of the insurance industry,” Behrndt said. He cautioned those from other states to watch for similar legislation in their state being promoted as s pro-consumer towing-related bill. Massachusetts: Two of the three associations serving Massachusetts collision repair shops spoke at the meeting in New Jersey and both said the three groups are working more closely together than ever before. “I can almost guarantee you within Janet Chaney anthe next six months nounces Butte shop that we will merge,” owner Max Yates will Peter Hendrix, presirun as Republican dent of the Massachucandidate for Monsetts Autobody tana Legislature. Association, said of his group, the Central Massachusetts Auto Rebuilders Association, and the AASP of Massachusetts/Rhode Island. “We’ve been fighting each other and fighting the insurance industry, we’ve been hiring separate lobbyist and dealing with often the same issues but on our own. It hasn’t worked. It’s not going to change unless we group together.” Peter Abdelmaseh, executive director of AASP of Massachusetts and Rhode Island, said proposed state legislation related to shop rates is among the projects on which the three groups have been working together. The bill would establish three levels of shop classification, opening the door for higher rates for shops with better levels of equipment and training. “We believe in Massachusetts that the standards need to be attached to some economic benefit,” he said. “Otherwise, our people will be out making investments with no return” Connecticut: Although there was not any discussion at the meeting about any merger of the two associations serving Connecticut shops, there was talk about improved relationships among the approximately 600 shops in the state. “We stopped calling each other competitors,” shop owner Bob Skrip of the Auto Body Association of Connecticut said. “We’re all colleagues. Start using that word. In every other profession in this world, they all stick together. You’d talk to a colleague every day, but everyone’s afraid to talk to their competitors. No more competitors. We’re all colleagues.” Skrip said his group is conducting a membership drive, getting board members and others from the group to meet one-onone with other shop owners to offer a money-back guarantee that new members will more than make back their first-year dues to the association.
6 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
As he reported a year earlier, Skrip said rather than legislative efforts, the association is focused on consumer education efforts. “A smart consumer is very dangerous to insurers,” Skrip said. He said he had no news to share with regard to the association’s successful class action lawsuit against The Hartford, saying the insurer is preparing its appeal of the $15 million judgment shops won against it. “We all knew going in from 2003 that it’s a long process,” Skrip said of the litigation. Meanwhile, Lisa Siembab of the Connecticut Collision Repair Specialists said that in addition to industry education and community service, that association may also focus this year on what it sees as a consumer disclosure issue related to some dealerships taking in collision repair work even if they don’t operate a body shop. “The consumer is being led to believe that they indeed have a body shop when in fact they do not,” Siembab said. “We have a problem with that. We think the consumer needs to be fully informed that their vehicle will be leaving the premises to go to a body shop to be repaired. Consumers aren’t being told this.” She said some dealers have gone so far as to have doors labeled “Body Shop” within the dealership. At least one member of the Auto Body Association of Connecticut at the meeting said that was an issue on which the two groups might work together.
Maryland and Virginia: Jordan Hendler, executive director of the Washington Metropolitan Auto Body Association, discussed several legislative proposals her group recently helped defeat. The association opposed a bill in Maryland, for example, that it felt would legitimize the use of salvaged airbags, and a bill in Virginia that would have raised the threshold of damage requiring a flood-damaged vehicle to receive a branded title from $1,000 to $5,000. Peter Hendrix, presi“Legisladent of the Massachutively, it’s important setts Autobody to remember that this Association, saying type of block is as “it’s not going to good as a win,” Ed change unless we group together.” Kizenberger, executive director of the Long Island Auto Body Repairmen's Association (LIABRA), said association leaders should remind their members. “Here is an example where something that is proposed that is detrimental to the industry. Being able to block that is important. It takes just as much work, and sometimes more, to stop something that has momentum than it is to try to start something legislatively on your own.”
Your B W deserves the BEST PARTS at the BEST PRICE!
CHACON SUZUKI Dallas • New Braunfels
LOOK FOR US US IN IN: Dallas
New Braunfels
39490 LBJ Freeway South Dallas, TX 75232
3566 IH 35 South New Braunfels, TX 78132
csdparts@chaconsuzuki.com csnbparts@chaconsuzuki.com
972-572-7007
830-624-7000
Main
Main
DIRECT: 469-567-1220 FAX: 972-346-6575
FAX: 210-587-2440
Suzuki Kizashi 2010
Texas Companies Leave Millions in Tax Credits Unclaimed
Texas employers are leaving millions in federal tax credits unclaimed and the opportunity for tax savings is now greater for those who choose to participate in the Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC) program. Employers who hire unemployed veterans or eligible 16- to 24-year-olds are now entitled to receive up to $2,400 in tax savings for each member of those groups added to their payrolls in 2009 and 2010. As part of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, these groups are now included with the existing 10 targeted populations eligible for WOTC. Administered by the U.S. Department of Labor and the Texas Workforce Commission (TWC), WOTC is a federal income tax benefit for private employers who hire from certain groups. Tax credits range from $1,200 to $9,000. WOTC reduces a business’ tax liability, serving as an incentive to select job candidates who face barriers in their efforts to find employment. “We want Texas employers to earn valuable tax credits while benefitting from the skills of these often untapped groups of qualified workers,” said TWC Chairman Tom Pauken. “It’s particularly encouraging to me that unemployed veterans now are included in this program.” TWC certifies which newly-hired employees make an employer eligible for the tax credit based on applications re-
ceived from the new employer. Although TWC was able to identify more than $200 million in tax credits for Texas employers in FY 2009, there were many more credits available that went unclaimed because applications were not submitted. WOTC offers employers a way to address workforce shortages while reducing hiring costs and gives job seekers a way to overcome some employment barriers. For the newly added groups to qualify their employers for WOTC, new hires who are unemployed veterans must have been receiving unemployment benefits for at least four weeks and youth must not have been regularly employed or regularly attending school for six months prior to being hired. “Our company saved $114,000 on our federal income taxes last year by hiring 85 qualifying employees to work in our restaurants,” said Joseph Hicks, Certified Public Accountant for Wright Foods, which owns several restaurant franchises in the McAllen area. Within each employee group, specific eligibility requirements apply. All forms and WOTC information are available online at: www.twc.state.tx.us/svcs/wotc/ wotc.html, or by calling the TWC WOTC unit at 1-800-695-6879.
(Source: Texas Business Today, Winter Issue)
CARSTAR Collision Centers Promotes Green Initiatives
When most car owners think about going green, they think of hybrid vehicles or alternative fuels. But now, car owners can go greener when they have their accident damage repaired. CARSTAR Collision centers are adopting green repair practices—from new painting technology to energy saving techniques to environmental improvements—designed to improve the car repair process and reducing the shops’ carbon footprint. CARSTAR has created a Certified Green program with partners such as the EPA’s Collision Repair Campaign, Energy Star and Certified Green Investment to guide collision centers through enacting smart environmental management practices and delivering continual improvements on a yearly basis. “We want to do our part to help improve the environment and enhance how the thousands of collision repairs that happen in CARSTAR locations impact their local communities,” says Dick Cross, CEO of CARSTAR Collision Centers, the nation’s largest chain of collision repair experts. “There have been tremendous improvements in repair technology, new methods for decreasing energy use, and better ways to reduce waste that, collectively, help the collision centers deliver a more
‘green’ car repair. We’re proud of the many CARSTAR stores who have achieved Certified Green status and look forward to having all of the CARSTAR stores embrace this important effort.” The CARSTAR Certified Green program will help deliver projected annual savings of $5,300 to each CARSTAR Collision Center, along with an annual Eco Savings of 26.7%, which reflects a reduction in environmental pollution and contribution toward global greenhouse gas reduction. Certified Green stores also qualify for tax credits, utility service rebates, government grants and other benefits such as reduced insurance premiums, workers comp discounts and compliance concessions. The first CARSTAR stores to achieve Certified Green status are CARSTAR Metcalf in Stillwell, Kan., and Scuderi Auto Body CARSTAR in Rockville, Md. CARSTAR stores are modernizing their equipment, changing to waterborne paint systems, adding energy efficient light fixtures, updating heating, ventilation and air conditioning controls, improving pollution prevention measures and employing smart waste management practices.
Houston’s Largest
Volume Honda Parts Department!
IT’S YOUR FUTURE... PUT IT IN HIGH GEAR WITH AN SCA APPRAISAL If you’re an experienced Auto Body Estimator or Insurance Claims Estimator and want to be in business for yourself, but not by yourself, then an SCA Appraisal Franchise just might be right for you. With 30 years experience in the Independent Auto, Truck, Motorcycle, Marine, RV and Heavy Equipment Appraisal business, SCA has painstakingly perfected its franchise model in order to provide our franchisees with a blueprint for proven results.
FRANCHISE
Jon Gironda, Vice President SCA Franchising, Inc.
With a Franchise Licensing Fee of only $10,000.00, *plus applicable business setup and working capital costs, you can be running your own SCA Appraisal Franchise within a matter of *6-10 weeks.
10250 Old Katy Rd., Houston, TX 77043
(*Franchise signing and training sessions occur every 60 days at our Los Angeles, CA headquarters) (*Business Setup and Working Capital costs can range from $3,850.00 to $28,200.00).
• Cutting Edge Web-Based Dispatch Management System. • 130+ Corporate Support Employees. • 2 National Service Centers (Los Angeles & New York). • National Marketing Division.
• Centralized Business Model. • Weekly Direct Deposits. • Established Territories Available Throughout the U.S. & Puerto Rico.
> For more information please visit our website at www.sca-appraisal.com or e-mail: jgironda@sca-appraisal.com
ghwparts@goodsonauto.com
866
769
40 - 80
Wholesale Parts Line
866.769.8040
713.464.2549 Fax
Se Habla Español
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 7
Houston Auto Body Association Joins Existing Texas Associations by David M. Brown Special to Autobody News
A trio of auto association groups is now serving the Lone Star State: San Antoniobased Texas Independent Auto Association; Austin’s Automotive Parts & Services Association; and, as of 2009, the Houston Auto Body Association, which became an affiliate of the national Society of Collision Repair Specialists in February. Established in 2009 to serve the greater Houston area, HABA comprises approximately 35 owners and managers of collision centers (Active Members), businesses associated with the collision industry (Associate Members) and like-minded associations that abide by the group’s code of ethics (Group Affiliate Members). The group was formed to put the collision industry in Houston on a straightercourse. “Many of us felt we weren’t getting fair and reasonable compensation for our work,” says the group’s president, James Brown, owner of Rapid Body Works in Houston. He notes that different areas and insurers were using unique procedures, creating confusion and misinterpretation. Brown explains that Andy Holder, owner of Metropolitan Collision, also in Houston, began contacting body shops the first part of 2009, and by that September HABA became a registered nonprofit association. Holder is now vice president of the group. “Together, we could strategize and agree on standards and procedures to improve business for all of us, so that consumers could be ensured their vehicles were being restored to their safe pre-loss condition,” says Brown, whose nine-year-old company is ICAR Platinum and ASE certified. HABA’s membership requirements include proof of liability insurance and technical certification for technicians, the use of a computerized estimating system, a lifetime warranty against defects and an approved spray booth meeting current federal and local requirements. Brown says that the organization is dedicated to setting just and equitable standards and providing a forum for working out differences between shops and shops and insurers. HABA is establishing itself as a consumer advocacy agency in providing both information and a presence at the Texas Legislature to protect the public’s rights, as well as those in the collision industry. “One of our members has already had meetings with the Texas Insurance Commissioner and presented questions as well as signed petitions to add to the Consumer Bill of Rights,” Brown reports. Assisting Brown and Holder as board of directors officers are Phillip Hahn, Treasurer (Mossy Nissan Collision Center); Jennifer Barbee, Secretary (Metropolitan Collision); and Ronnie Brush,
Chairman of the board (Westside Lexus Collision Center). SCRS is welcoming of HABA, which adds to its portfolio of 38 affiliate associations comprising 6,000 collision repair businesses and 58,500 specialized professionals in the United States. “It is always exciting for SCRS to partner with new, emerging industry leaders,” says Aaron Schulenburg, executive director of SCRS.
David Abrahams (l) of PPG distributor TASCO presenting a substantial donation to HABA President James Brown.
“The HABA has exhibited tremendous drive and determination in the formation of their association, and their commitment to the implementation of recognized and practiced repair standards is laudable.” The oldest organization of the Texas three is the Texas Automotive Parts & Services Association, founded Oct. 11, 1932, as the Automotive Wholesalers of Texas. As a trade association designed to serve the automotive aftermarket industry, APSA serves a 10-state membership of 800 members representing approximately 2,000 locations. Besides Texas, representative states are Kansas, Oklahoma, Nebraska, Iowa, Missouri, Arkansas, Colorado, New Mexico, and Wyoming. The members own or represent auto parts and paint stores, machine shops, engine rebuilders and service repair shops, both mechanical and collision. In the last few years, through a series of mergers, APSA has grown from a single state association to a regional association which, because of the increase in the number of members, has enabled APSA to provide quality programs and benefits, says the organization’s president, Jim Quinten. For instance, the group offers its members an insurance package through the member-owned AP&S Insurance Agency. Still, the most important work APSA does is legislative advocacy — lobbying in the various states and in Washington, Quinten explains. He is assisted by the APSA vice president, Melanie Norman, and a 25-member board of directors representing all 10 states. “The members own the association, and it only exists for their benefit,” he says. “The APSA staff works for the members and are dedicated to that effort.” Formed in 1980, TIAA comprises mechanical and body shops throughout Texas. The organization began with chapters in Odessa, Waco, Austin, Houston, San An-
8 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
tonio and the Rio Grande Valley, but membership grew to approximately 850 members statewide. Between 30–40 collision shops now belong. “Our members are mostly familyowned and -operated independent business that put the focus on customer service on a personal level,” says Gary Pundt, TIAA president and owner of Alamo Heights Garage in San Antonio. Joining him on the board are Hank Amor, vice president and owner of Oak Hill Automotive in Austin; David Bippert Secretary, owner of Lone Star Radiator in San Antonio; and Roy Baird, Treasurer, owner, Car Pro of San Antonio. In May, the group will choose new officers at its annual meting, Pundt explains. “We formed so that our members would have more control over the state and local chapters and be able to monitor the Legislature and act on our own behalf at the state level and not get lost in the national association shuffle,” he explains. The group actively monitors legislation affecting the mechanical and the collision industry: “We have members in Austin that will at a moment’s notice rally support to testify at the state capitol on behalf of our membership.” He adds: “We’re also a great platform for our members to network across the state
and be able to stay in touch and discuss industry issues that come up.” He notes that these include “insurance-steering problems and the repair process that the insurance companies force upon the collision shops.” Education is also an important TIAA component. Members serve on various education boards, offering feedback on new training programs and guidance for future technicians. The group also fund raises for scholarships to give financial aid to those deserving and in need. For the last for years, TIAA members have also donated services and parts to repair vehicles at no charge for residents of battered women’s shelters in Austin and San Antonio. Says Pundt: “This is a public service that we are proud to do, and we feel it is a great way to give back to our local communities.”
James Brown, President, HABA jbrown2000@charterinternet.com www.habaonline.org (832)-515-9609 Jim Quinten, APSA 8000 Centre Park Drive, Suite 150 Austin, Texas 78754 Phone: 512-339-0044 Fax: 512-339-4477 jim.quinten@apsassociation.com Gary Pundt, State President T.I.A.A. 210-445-7625 gary@ahgarage.com
Central Kia Irving
(972) 257-7602
(972) 257-7650 Fax
M-F 7:30-7:00, Sat 8:00-5:00
Central Kia Plano
(972) 422-9320
(972) 633-5761 Fax M-F 7:30am - 7:00pm Sat 8:00am - 5:00pm
De Montrond Kia Houston
Wats 1-800-392-6704 (281) 872-3909 (281) 872-3914 Fax
Fredy Kia Houston
Toll Free 800-883-1933 Direct (713) 941-3600 (713) 947-8053 Fax 7:00am - 6:00pm M-F 7:00am - 12:00 Noon Sat Free local delivery Free DSI shipping
Huffines Kia Denton Denton
940-321-2504
(940) 497-2920 Fax
M-F 7:00-7:00, Sat 8:00-5:00 Local Delivery Available www.Huffines.net
OKLAHOMA Bob Moore Kia Oklahoma City
800-654-3987
(405) 749-6011 (405) 749-6069 Fax
M-F 7:30-6:00, Sat 8:00-4:00 trichardson@bobmoore.com
Cable Kia Oklahoma City
Wats (866) 751-1055 (405) 787-6582 (405) 789-8500 Fax
Ferguson Advantage Imports
Kia of Baton Rouge
(918) 317-6280 Fax
(225) 490-8014 Fax
Broken Arrow
800-880-8815
Open M-F 7:00am - 6:00pm
LOUISIANA All-Star Kia
Alexandria Hours: M-F 7:30-5:30 Sat 8:00-2:00 CST
(318) 445-1486
(318) 448-1828 Fax
Baton Rouge 5740 Siegen Lane
Huffines Kia McKinney McKinney
469-525-4450
(469) 525-4459 Fax
(225) 490-8000
M-F 7:00-7:00, Sat 8:00-5:00 Local Delivery Available www.Huffines.net
TEXAS
Hurst
Archer Kia Houston
1-888-983-1425
(281) 983-1437 Fax
Capitol Kia
13573 North US Hwy 183 Austin
(512) 583-1900
(512) 583-1899 Fax 7:30am - 6:00pm M-F
Moritz Kia
(877) 651-4542
(817) 595-8325 Fax
Southwest Kia
39650 LBJ Freeway South Dallas
Toll Free 888-544-9249 Direct (972) 616-0069 (972) 421-0294 Fax
M-F 7:30-6:00, Sat 8:30-5:00
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 9
Maaco Positions Itself As Customer Pay Provider
The typical vehicle is 10.2 years old, the highest average in 14 years, according to a late-March report from R.L. Polk & Co. Old or new, most will eventually require some form of bodywork and painting. The cost should reflect conditions including a car's age and projected longevity, say consumer-oriented statements by Maaco. A collision repair on a one to threeyear-old car usually calls for state-ofthe-art options. The owner of a four to 10-year-old car could often benefit from a shop that knows how to provide a superior looking job and still find ways to lower the estimate, especially when the driver is paying out of pocket. “It's important to bring a vehicle back to a condition that maintains the resale value if the car would be going into the resale arena,” said David Lapps, president of Maaco Collision Repair & Auto Painting, “such as a lease turn back or a car that's going to be sold in the next year or so. “However, with an older car, or one the customer... may be paying herself, Maaco will find ways to save her money without affecting the quality, so that only the expert commercial buyers of newer used cars could pick it up.”
Minnesota Body Shop Gets 30% of Power From Solar Arrays
Minnesota’s Southwest Journal, a regional business publication, has reported that Mulroy’s Body Shop at the corner of 39th Street and Nicollet Avenue in Twin Cities Minnesota, has installed the largest array of solar panels in the Twin Cities area, generating 30 percent of the building’s power. “Once you have grandchildren, you start thinking about how we’ve got to do our part to leave this world in better shape than we’ve got it,” said shop owner Pat Mulroy. “Body shops, we’re not known as a real green thing, but we want to change that.” The installation of the shop’s 174panel, 40-kilowatt system was completed in early April as part of a project run by South Minneapolis-based Solarflow Energy, which offers solar electricity leasing. The company is under contract with Xcel Energy for the project, which involves installing solar panels on 20 residential and five commercial properties in the metro. It is also partially funded through an Xcel Energy Renewable Development Fund grant. “We’re trying to prove the model of solar service in Xcel territory,” said Solarflow CEO Gerardo Ruiz during a March interview about the project. Ruiz said the panels are leased at a cost that is less than the value of the electricity being delivered, which Mulroy will receive at no additional expense. Mulroy
said he expects to break even financially this year, but because the lease rate is locked, he foresees significant savings in years to come. U.S. Sen. Al Franken (D-Minn.) swung by Mulroy’s on April 7, along with City Council Member Elizabeth Glidden
helped create a new energy future,” he said. “So to me, this is just a perfect example of what we should be doing and what we are doing.” Ruiz declined to specify how much stimulus funding he was getting, but he did say the purchase price of the system installed at Mulroys is about $300,000. Glidden, who leads the city’s Regulatory, Energy and Environment Committee, said Minneapolis is pushing to find more ways to go solar and Mulroy’s is standing out as an example for the rest of the community of how to do it. “I live a block away from here and Mulroy’s is one of the best community partners you can have,” she said. The shop is also leasing space U.S. Sen. Al Franken and Minneapolis City Council Member Elizabeth Glidden (8th Ward) stopped by Mulroy’s to a company that converts gasBody Shop earlier this month to see its new solar panels, powered vehicles to electric. The talk to installers and promote clean energy. official launch of that business is planned later this spring. Mulroy (8th Ward) to see the panels, talk to in- said his shop’s other green efforts include stallers and emphasize the role of federal the use of eco-friendly water-based stimulus dollars in the project. Stimulus paints. funds provide a grant to Solarflow based Mulroy’s solar array is the largest in on the value of the installation, Franken the Twin Cities for now, but the Minsaid. neapolis Convention Center will pass it “This is an example of where the this summer with a project that involves stimulus package has created jobs and thousands of panels.
CAPA 501 Standard for Bumper System Parts
CAPA announced Feb 1 that it is developing a new bumper certification standard. The CAPA Bumper Systems Standard will cover steel bumpers (front and rear), steel reinforcements (rebars), bumper brackets and absorbers. The CAPA program is a direct response to the importance of truly independent certification and testing as a mechanism for fostering market competition. “We are pleased to respond to the cross-industry demand for CAPA certification. The bottom line is that insurers, repairers, and part distributors cannot simply look at competitive parts and make an informed decision on the true comparability of that part to a car company brand part,” said Gillis. To ensure comparability, the car company service part undergoes a comprehensive testing regimen with the results becoming the “standard” to which the aftermarket part is compared. The aftermarket part undergoes the same comprehensive testing regimen. If the test results show the aftermarket part is comparable to the car company brand part, then, and only then, it can bear the CAPA Quality Seal. “The CAPA Quality Seal is crucial because as the various “tests results” being released demonstrate, it is impossible to determine if an aftermarket part will perform comparably to a car company brand part, unless all critical as-
pects of the part have been tested and reviewed,” said Gillis. The CAPA program requires comprehensive continuous post approval inspection and marketplace monitoring. After the dynamic bumper testing process has been completed, the proposed standard will be presented to CAPA’s Technical Committee for review and approval. The CAPA Technical Committee includes representatives of key collision industry segments including repairers, distributors, manufacturers and insurers. CAPA’s new Bumper Systems Standard (CAPA 501) will benefit from CAPA’s history in quality, safety assurance, and compliance. For over six years CAPA has been certifying automotive lighting. It was CAPA who discovered and reported FMVSS 108 compliance issues to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) in 2004. We learned that marketplace and package claims about safety compliance may be suspect when we discovered that 80% of the aftermarket lights we tested did not meet all the requirements of FMVSS 108 even though FMVSS 108 was printed on the boxes delivered to shops by part distributors. Today, the best way insurers, shops, and distributors can ensure that aftermarket lights are truly comparable to car company brand lights and fully comply with FMVSS 108 is to look for the CAPA seal.
10 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
YOUR ULTIMATE SOURCE for LEXUS PARTS At Park Place Lexus, our wholesale parts operation has an inventory exceeding $1.5 million and a helpful, knowledgeable sales team that includes a Spanish-speaking member. For orders, we have four convenient options: phone, fax, email and OPS Trax. We even offer free shipping on OPS, and free shipping on Noble Logistics for prepaid orders over $500. In most cases, you can count on next-day delivery. For more information, contact either one of our Dallas-area locations:
PARK PLACE LEXUS PLANO • 888.815.0402 PlanoPartsWholesale@parkplacetexas.com PARK PLACE LEXUS GRAPEVINE • 888.826.1268 GVwholesale@parkplacetexas.com
TIAA 2010 Scholarship Fishing Tournament, May 21, Port Aransas
The 2010 Texas Independent Automotive Association Scholarship Fishing Tournament is Friday, May 21 in Port Aransas. Proceeds from the TIAA event support the scholarships for Texas youth who attend college-level automotive repair programs within the state of Texas. To register for the fishing tournament and to pay for meal at the event, you can download a form (www.tiaa.net) and mail with check payable to TIAA to 639 W. Rhapsody, San Antonio, TX 78216. There will be double the payouts this year for award winners in both Redfish and Speckled trout. In addition, this year there will be two competitive divisions: guided and unguided anglers. Participants are encouraged to register as soon as possible to ensure enough
fishing guides can be contracted for the event ahead of the event as possible. If you wait to register right before the event,
Mike Riordan (Left) and son Christian, 12, hold up two large King Fish they caught during the 2009 TIAA Scholarship Fishing Tournament. Although the fish didn't qualify for the awards, the two benefited from time spent together. Photo by Lee Roberts
it may be possible you won't be able to fish because there may not be enough boats for everyone to fish from. For more information or to ask about sponsorship opportunities, call Luke Harms, the event organizer, at (210) 413-2428 The Annual meeting, management session and lunch will be held on Saturday, May 22 at Virginias on the Bay from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. All members in good standing who attend will receive reimbursement for one nights stay up to $100 and a FREE lunch for two. There are currently rooms being held at the Plantation Suites 1-877-836-FUNN for $89 per night and Best Western Ocean Villas 1-361-3311749. Reservations through the state office must be made by April 9th to qualify for the FREE night. Contact the office via E-mail at tiaastateoffice@tiaa.net.
TIAA Annual Meeting Includes Leadership Training, Hotel Stay
In conjunction with the fishing tournament in Port Aransas, there is a brief annual meeting, lunch and management session from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. Saturday, May 22, 2010 at Virginia’s On The Bay. The leadership training is being presented by Automotive Speaker and Author David Eschbach. All members in good standing who attend will receive reimbursement for one nights stay up to $100 and a FREE lunch for two. There are currently rooms being held at the Plantation Suites 1 (877) 836-FUNN for $89 per night as well as The Best Western Ocean Villa 1-361-331-1749. Reservations through the state office needed to be made by April 9th to qualify for the FREE night. Contact the office via E-mail at tiaastateoffice@tiaa.net. Eschbach will present leadership training titled, “The Challenge.” To excel in tomorrow’s marketplace we must challenge ourselves to identify our true partners by discovering and utilizing the right organizations, vendors and employees. Your independence relies on the partners you choose. Challenge yourself to choose the right partners. Challenge them to support you while you achieve your goals. Challenge yourself to create a winning team and remain strong, independent and proud. Management companies nationwide have charged hundreds of dollars for this information, but thanks to cooperative efforts with TIAA, it's yours free. Not only that, but TIAA will pay for a FREE night’s stay (per membership) at the hotel we will be holding the conference at and complementary lunch for up to two people. The only requirement is that you are a member in good standing, register by April 9th, and attend the luncheon and leadership session. TIAA will finish the day with the installation of officers and plan to be done by no later than 1 p.m.
TIAA Has Free PCI Terminal Perk from Bancard Group
“What is PCI Compliant?” or “How do I become PCI Compliant?” are common questions these days. Did you know that Visa & Mastercard can fine you up to $500.00 per transaction if you are not in compliance? The BankCard Group announced that they will provide any existing TIAA member in good standing (excluding current members with The BCG) a Free Pci Compliant Terminal in the month of April. Call Jayme Mathis @ 866.412.0717 or 210.639.1497. You can also reach him at: jmathis@thebankcardgroup.com www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 11
Plano’s Ray Huffines Chevrolet Wins on Margins in Wholesale Parts
The wholesale parts game isn’t a slam dunk, nor is it a no-brainer. If a dealership makes a commitment to wholesale and works it hard and smart, they might be able to eke out a meager profit at the end of the year. But, if a parts department deviates from its plan, their already paper-thin margins can disappear in a millisecond. Robert Jones has been the parts director at Ray Huffines Chevrolet in Plano, Texas, for 12 years and possesses four decades of total industry experience. He knows that wholesale is a tough game, but if you do it right, it will reward you in many ways, he explained. “Wholesale is a different game than selling parts retail or selling them to your own service department,” Jones said. “If you set up a system and can stick with it, you can make money in a recession. We grew in ’09 and business has drastically improved already in ’10, so if you continually push and stress customer service and sell a good product, you can succeed in wholesale.” Jones runs a highly successful parts department that maintains an inventory of $2.2 million in parts. Last year, his department sold more than $9 million in both mechanical and collision parts for the entire General Motors lineup, including GMC, Buick, Pontiac and Cadillac and now Saturn, a nameplate they added earlier this year when a local Saturn dealership closed its doors. The parts department at Ray Huffines Chevrolet operates from a 35,000 squarefoot facility and employs 18 people, including 10 countermen, Jones said. The Huffines family has been in the automotive business since 1924 and owns a total of eight dealerships. Jones, 58, knows this business is tough in any economy and admits that today price is more important than ever. “It’s a grind and volume is king—and volume is dictated by price. That’s why we’re always trying to take advantage of the price programs offered by the manufacturer. It all works together. You need to buy right so that we can sell right. In the end, it’s all about offering our customers the best deals out there. Everyone is focusing on price. Sure, service is paramount, but in this tough economy, we lead with price and that’s the reality.” His attitude about maintaining exceptional customer service in his department is unwavering, Jones said. “We literally treat every one of our customers like family, like our fathers or mothers. The Huffines family has always stressed customer service over profit. Sure, we want to make a profit, but the customer always comes first. The company employs 600 people and each one of them shares the Huffines approach 100%, Jones explained.
From left to right, Parts Director Robert Jones, Administrative Coordinator Kathy Fondry and Assistant Parts Manager Paul Cruson run the parts department’s front office at Ray Huffines Chevrolet.
“This is a very different work environment here,” he said. “The Huffines family makes every employee in their organization feel wanted, respected and valued. Mr. Huffines insists on singing happy
birthday for each employee on their big day—from every manager and technician to each driver and in between. You won’t find something like this at many other companies.” Jones is right out there on the front lines every day when it comes to the neverending battle of OEM vs. the aftermarket. The insurance companies he works with want to save money by using the aftermarket, so Jones needs to be flexible, he admitted. “It’s a dance between the shops, the insurance companies and us. It’s a twoedged sword, because we need the insurance companies to provide us with revenue. But, they have the checkbook and they call the shots. If they insist on using aftermarket or re-manufactured parts on a
repair, that’s the way it will go. That’s why we try to do whatever we can to get our parts on as many of their estimates as we can.” By offering price flexibility to his wholesale body shops, Ray Huffines Chevrolet positions itself in a more competitive situation when matched up against the aftermarket, Jones said. “Our ‘Bump the Competition’ program has been working well for us for the past several years. It’s a simple process. The shop faxes a copy of the estimate, and if particular parts fit into the program, we’re able to adjust the price and then capture more of the estimate.” But in the end, Jones knows that his parts are superior to their aftermarket alSee Ray Huffines, Page 15
WATS:
800-955-6282 Parts Direct:
972-202-2300 • 9 Salesmen • Over $2 Million Inventory • 7 Delivery Trucks • Extensive Collision Parts Inventory • Free Delivery within Texas (call for details) • Engines and Transmissions at truck load pricing (call for details)
Hours: Monday - Friday 7 to 7 Saturday from 8 to 5
Collision Centers & Body Shops
Ray Huffines Chevrolet • Plano, TX
12 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
• We “Meet or Beat” aftermarket pricing. Ask your salesman about “Bump the Competition” and “GM Outlet Shop”. • Cycle time costs you money. Let our huge collision inventory work to your advantage.
On Creative Marketing
Tom Franklin has been a sales and marketing consultant for forty years. He has written numerous books and provides marketing solutions and services for many businesses. He can be reached at (323) 871-6862 or at tbfranklin@aol.com.
Concentrate Your Marketing Firepower with Thomas Franklin
Insurance companies are up to their old tricks again. Apparently none learned the lesson of the M-2 fiasco a few years ago. Because insurance executives are often graduates of business schools and thoroughly educated in corporate culture, they have a natural tendency to believe the myth of “economy of scale.” This leads them to believe that a monolithic mess like M-2—a consolidator that bought up a huge number of shops only to collapse under a pile of debt, loss and inefficiency—could repair vehicles for much less than independent shops. Around that time, the nations largest insurance company dropped dozens of small shops in favor of large shops and consolidators they believed could deliver repaired vehicles for less because of “economy of scale.” Management guru Peter Drucker observed many years ago that so-called “economy of scale”—by which shops would be expected to purchase parts and outsource some services more cheaply—are generally lost because of bloated bureaucracies that arise in large
corporations so that tracking real costs are often lost in the shuffle. At the end, M-2 could no longer pay for parts or stall on payments. Inconsistent payment of employees resulted in continual turnover of employees. The idea that “economy of scale” is really that important in a laborintensive business like collision repair is corporate think nonsense. So now another large insurance company (see last month’s column) is dropping dozens of small shops—not because they failed to do quality repairs or to treat customers fairly—but because the company’s corporate-minded executives believe the myth that shifting to large consolidators and multi-shop enterprises will result in lower repair costs. The irony of their move is their inconsistency in reasoning. This is a company that still works through agents because agents provide personalized care. They ignore the fact that large corporate shops tend, like M-2, to have revolving door employees who thus pay far less personal attention to customers. So what does this have to do with the
dozens of independent shops that suddenly find a major insurance source of jobs and revenue disappear? The usual response is to scramble to find other sources of business. Unfortunately this often means trying many multiple marketing efforts at once. By dividing their resources into relatively unfocused advertising, promotion and sales efforts, they lose the power that could be gained from one highly concentrated marketing effort at a time. It’s not that a shop should only go after a dealership, a DRP, a fleet account or any other specific source. It’s just that it’s more effective to choose a single target and put all available resources behind that one big push. Otherwise they’re like a military bombing operation that scatters a few bombs over a large area without hitting the most important target. An example of concentrated firepower would be going after a new insurance DRP by addressing the agents, the adjusters, the local coordinator and also executives at the state and national level. Records of prior jobs performed for that insurer’s customers
and letters from satisfied customers plus any other relevant documentation may take some time to assemble, but that is the kind of ammunition needed to press this marketing initiative. One shop manager who succeeded in gaining new DRP business for her shop traveled to several CIC meetings to meet the top-level insurance executives who represented their companies at the periodical meetings. Rather than the usual approach, contacting the local DRP coordinator and sending a comprehensive package of information about the shop, she used a top-down approach, using her CIC contacts to influence the local coordinators, and then using the references from customers and agents to reinforce her proposal. A concentrated effort to get a dealership’s business would involve getting the buy-in from every level of management, including the used car sales manager, the parts manager, the service manager, and of course the general manager and owner. Shop records of jobs performed on those makes and models of vehicles would reinSee Franklin, next page
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 13
The Right Cause
Games Insurers Play with Mike Causey
It has been said that one does not realize the value of a good insurance company until one files a claim. Insurers that have local agents that the policyholder can meet with “face to face” generally fare better than the “internet based” insurance policies, according to numerous autobody association surveys. When it comes to insurance coverage for physical property damage, cheaper premiums are not always the best way to go. Remember that old adage: You get what you pay for! As for the claims process for auto body repair, most claimants can use all the help they can get. The truth is that most claimants are simply not familiar with the process and all the pitfalls that many insurers place in their path. The investment in a motor vehicle is significant for most people. Making sure the value of that investment is not diminished through poor quality visible repairs is important to most vehicle owners. While not all insurance companies are guilty of “steering” customers to certain “preferred body shops” or demanding body shops cut corners to save a dime, most insurers do just that. The goal is to squeeze every penny they can to pay out as little as possible on each claim. Most insurance companies play a game—a game that makes sure that the
Mike Causey is a consumer advocate and lobbyist for the Independent Auto Body Association (IABA), in addition to Non-profits such as alternative healthcare groups (Citizens for Healthcare Freedom, NC Reflexology Association), Organic farming and Healthy Eating. Mike is a writer and speaker on numerous consumer issues and legislation. Mailing address: Causey & Associates, P.O. Box 16725, Greensboro, NC 27416 Email: gocausey@aol.com Phone: (336) 210-1947
cost of repairing an insured damaged vehicle is held down to the lowest level possible without incurring the wrath of the masses. Insurers bank on one important fact. The fact that most vehicle owners won’t keep their vehicle very long. Therefore, the insurers are not too worried about using imitation crash parts or sub-standard parts. Suppose an insurance company saves $40 or $50 on a part by demanding the body shop use the “Made in Taiwan” or “Made in China” imitation crash parts. How much does this “savings” cost the unsuspecting customer? Could it be hundreds or maybe thousands of dollars at trade-in time? When an insurance company chooses to use the cheaper types of parts, a “diminished value” claim (DV) is a possible consideration in many states. A DV claim could compensate you for the “imitation crash parts” replacing your factory “original equipment” or “OEM” parts.
The art of steering Here are a few of the word tracks used to manipulate the customer into using a specific “preferred” repair facility: > “Oh, sorry, we can’t guarantee the repairs at [your shop] because ‘they’ are not one of our network shops and they’re not on our list;”
> “If you use them, we can’t get an adjuster out for two weeks; if you take it to our network shop we will have someone start on it right away;” > “Claims take longer to settle if you use them;” > “Oh no, they charge more than the prevailing rate for this area and you will have to ‘pay the difference’ in repair cost;” > “If you use that shop you will have to pay for your rental out of pocket.”
Insurance company control of the collision repair industry has grown significantly in recent years. Many shop owners now struggle everyday to get paid fairly. They’re pressured to use aftermarket crash parts on the jobs they do get and watch insurers steer away customers right and left. Shop owners are routinely “secondguessed” regarding their estimates. They generally feel “under the thumb” of the insurer (or insurer representative). All this daily pressure from insurers has caused many body shop owners to be resentful toward the insurance industry. This resentment is apparent from comments on internet blogs as well as surveys conducted by industry associations and publications. Body Shop owners who say they have lost business because of steering had these comments:
Mitchell Releases Industry's ‘Most Comprehensive Total Loss Vehicle Configuration Solution’
Mitchell International, Inc., a leading provider of information, workflow and performance management solutions to the Property & Casualty claims and Collision Repair industries, announced the release of WorkCenter™ Total Loss 4.0, the latest version of the industry's most accurate, trusted and verifiable total loss vehicle valuation solution developed in conjunction with customer satisfaction and vehicle pricing expert J.D. Power and Associates. As a part of its advanced feature set, WorkCenter Total Loss 4.0 presents detailed vehicle equipment data much like that contained in a build sheet and in the same “window sticker” terminology used by the manufacturers themselves. Sourced through R. L. Polk & Co., the premier provider of automotive information and marketing solutions, the detailed descriptions of options and packages are displayed on the Mitchell comparable vehicle and N.A.D.A.® vehicle valuation reports. Supplying an easily understood, readily
accepted description of vehicle equipment allows carriers to assure policyholders that all the equipment on their total loss vehicle was taken into account for the valuation. This results in increased customer satisfaction along with improved first call settlement rates for insurance carriers. Jesse Herrera, Senior Vice President, Product Management and Marketing for Mitchell International, said, “With the addition of vehicle equipment option package data, we believe WorkCenter Total Loss 4.0 is now the industry's most comprehensive vehicle configuration offering, underscoring Mitchell's commitment to vastly improving often hotly contested and opaque claims settlements involving vehicle equipment and option packages. This advancement also further streamlines the total loss valuation process by making the most up to date, accurate and trusted vehicle valuation data instantly available to consumers, estimators and insurers.” In addition, WorkCenter Total
14 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
Loss 4.0 will ease the job of the estimator because all of the manufacturer standard equipment will display automatically via Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) decode. The estimator will only need to review and select vehicle packages and optional equipment, improving accuracy and reducing cycle time. WorkCenter Total Loss is a statistically-driven, fully automated single solution that can optimize the total loss claims settlement process and fully support the highest customer satisfaction initiatives. The solution combines Mitchell's superior claims processing solutions with J.D. Power and Associates' data analysis and superior pricing capabilities, resulting in an intuitive and powerful methodology for insurance carriers. It is available via the web or as a stand-alone, desktop application. For more information, please visit www.mitchell.com.
● “We’ve been in business for 19 years and 99 percent of the time, the customers are very happy. Yet insurers steer business away from us constantly.” ● “I’ve had old customers tell me they were told to go to another shop.” ● “Insurers make the customers feel as though they won’t pay unless they take the vehicle to one of their shops.” ● “Vehicles have been removed from our shop because of insurers.” “The companies tell appraisers what they can and can’t pay for,” says another shop owner. “We continually hear, ‘I know you need to do it, but I can’t pay for it.’” Tell your customers to call their insurance company and tell them where they would like to have their vehicle repaired. Customers should be told: “If you need any help deciding on which insurance carrier to buy your policy from, ask or call your local body shop. We can tell you which insurance companies are customer service friendly and will help with your insurance claim needs every step of the way. Some insurance companies make you feel that they have your best interest in mind. when in reality they are just managing their bottom line.” Suggested slogan for your office: REMEMBER, IT’S YOUR CAR, YOUR CHOICE.
Franklin
Continued from Page 13
force this shop’s ability to focus on this dealership’s products. While a DRP arrangement either exists or it doesn’t, it is possible with many dealerships to propose a “toe-in-thedoor” approach, such as a dealership that already had an “authorized collision repair facility.” You could take on any overload and any problem jobs the other shop preferred not to do. Dealership relationships can be a lot like marriages, often ending in divorce. By providing exemplary service, the “toe-in-thedoor” shop, became the new authorized shop when the other shop failed to deliver one too many times. Losing a major source of business—especially in a tough economy like this— can be a devastating experience, but it’s essential for a shop owner or manager to resist scattering resources all around. Using a concentrated firepower approach may not guarantee a result, but it can form a basis for a second and third concentrated effort if needed and provide a feeling of certainty that all that could be done has been done on that one target. That certainty will make the next concentrated effort that much more effective.
Continued from Page 12
Ray Huffines
ternative, saying “An OE part is the original part made by the manufacturer and that’s the bottom line. In some cases, the re-manufactured part is fine for a specific job. In other instances, the OEM is the best way to go, because it fits correctly and lines up perfectly every time. In the end, there’s enough business out there that we can all make a living, I believe.” Parts availability and reliable delivery is just as important to quality and price, Jones said. “We have a 91.5% fill-rate, which means we have pretty much anything our customers need right here onsite. We deliver roughly within 10 miles south of our location and 100 miles to the North and to portions of southeast Oklahoma. We have two deliveries per day and everything is pretty much guaranteed next day at the latest. GM’s distribution center is in Fort Worth, so it’s conveniently located for us.” Jones cites his staff’s overall knowledge about the brands they sell as a key ingredient to their formula for success. “We’re real fortunate to have a ton of experience on our front line staff,” Jones said. “We’ve got well over 100 years combined total experience in this group. Dean, one of my top people, is 70 and he’s been with me
The delivery team at Ray Huffines Chevrolet includes, from left, Byron Rodriguez, Art Littlefield, Brinca Roberts, Ryan Ekstrom and Juan Costilla.
for almost 20 years. These guys know how to handle our wholesale and retail efforts from top to bottom. We need to know more about these cars than our customers do, and that’s where their value is apparent. Sure, quality parts delivered on-time are important, but our knowledge is something that can differentiate us from the rest of the parts suppliers out there in the market.” Ongoing training is a major component within the entire customer service dynamic, Jones explained. “GM has a training system that is very effective. All of my counter guys have to train on all their new products every year. It comes out to about 8–10 hours of training per year and it’s all done online. That way they can do it at their convenience, so they don’t have to travel and they won’t miss work.”
Jones identified the value of his department’s outside sales efforts through his sole man on the street, Jesse Dominguez. “We’re getting a lot additional business from Jesse. He calls on 10–15 shops per day, which adds another layer of customer service. By getting him out in the field, he’s also available to any and all of our wholesale accounts. If a customer has delivery or pricing issues, Jesse can address them before they become a problem. We’re currently in the process of adding another salesman, because we can see the results of our efforts in this regard and want to strengthen that aspect of our whole marketing mix.” Other marketing efforts directed by Jones include targeted direct mail programs and promotional flyers that Dominguez hands out to his contacts while visiting shops, Jones said. Ray Huffines Chevrolet also advertises in trade publications to reach his accounts and prospective ones on a regular basis, he said. “We want the shops to know that we value their patronage,” Jones said.
The wholesale parts crew at Ray Huffines in Chevrolet is a highly-skilled and seasoned group, including from left, Kelly Kendrick, Chris Smith, John Limbocker and J.D. Webster.
“We’re willing to go out of our way to give them quality parts priced reasonably and delivered promptly. Those are the basic things they want and we want to be there to give it to them—consistently and reliably. Ray Huffines Chevrolet Plano 1001 Coit Road Plano, Texas 75075 (866) 687-8647
Register Your Email for Our
Free Monthly Newsletter at www.autobodynews.com
Young Chevrolet
Parts for Buick, Cadillac, Chevrolet, GMC, Oldsmobile, Pontiac
HYUNDAI
• Same day shipping until 5:30 EST • 60,000 part numbers • Next-day air until 4:30 EST • 13 parts pros eager to serve you • 4.2 million inventory • 15 radio-dispatched trucks • 97,000 square-foot warehouse
WE HAVE YOUR GENUINE HYUNDAI PARTS.
Camaro 2010
We want your business!
Huffines Hyundai Plano
Huffines Hyundai McKinney
909 Coit Rd • Plano, TX 75075 Hours: Mon-Fri 7-7, Sat 8-5, Sun closed
1301 N. Central Expressway McKinney, TX 75071 Hours: Mon-Fri 7-7, Sat 8-5, Sun closed
(800) 955-5388 (972)-202-2200 Local (972)-202-2195 Fax
(800) 679-6705 (562)-683-0380 Local (469)-525-4365 Fax
Genuine GM Parts at Genuine GM Prices Toll Free: 800-451-0108 Main: 214-328-9111, Opt. 5
parts@youngchevrolet.com
www.youngchevrolet.com 9301 E. R.L. Thornton Fwy, Dallas, TX
214-328-8381 Fax (main): 214-328-6675 Fax (wholesale): 214-328-0716 Direct:
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 15
Parts for Profit, Part 2—Profitable Management of Inventory & Personnel by Larry Williams
This is Part 2 of last month’s article directed to dealership parts managers directly managing employees handling both mechanical and collision parts, however, Larry Williams the same principles apply to parts management in a body shop. To read Part 1, see Autobody News, April 2010 edition or look online at www.autobodynews.com. Larry Williams is a former parts manager and consultant who has received national awards during his 40 years of creating profitable departments. He can be reached at ljoew2@gmail.com.
Making the most profit out of your inventory is easy, and once set up properly, needs minimum maintenance. Making the best profit out of your personnel is the hard part. This is why I spend most of my effort on my people. The hardest part of any profession is learning the language. The various terminologies used to communicate needs. Auto parts is one of the hardest, a language of multiple words for the same item. Controller, solenoid, actuator, module, ECU, etc. can all used to describe the same object. Only a few years ago Ford started a program to unify parts terminology. Now all departments, design, engineering, manufacturing, service and parts would all refer to a part by one name. Manufacturers have been in business almost a hundred years, and only now are addressing the problem. Same thing with new models…all kinds of information for sales and service, nothing for parts education. Everyone must learn on the job. Qualified personnel are difficult to find, so your best results will be if you train your people yourself. Promote from within on a scale of needed expertise, driver, stockman, back counter, front counter, phones. Always start new counter personnel at the back counter. They can get the most help, information, and actually see the vehicle if necessary. Technicians will educate a new counterperson better and faster than any other method. Every person has an area they are happiest working in, find the best fit for your personnel. A person is most productive when working in the area that they like. They make fewer mistakes, enjoy their work, have less attendance problem, etc. Every person must know exactly what their job and their responsibilities are. Not just verbal, WRITTEN DOWN! You must create your own policy and procedure manual, with every position defined, and all duties outlined. Only with a permanent “bible” for your department can you cope
with ongoing personnel issues. A few examples:
Driver Duties: 1) Maintain a professional appearance 2) Keep my vehicle clean and maintained daily. 3) Maintain a professional attitude with all my customers. 4) Organize my deliveries in the best way for time and distance. 5) Maintain contact at all times. 6) When not delivering, assist with receiving-shipping, and housekeeping. 7) Obtain training toward further advancement.
Receiving Clerk Duties 1) Maintain my area in a neat and clean, organized manner. 2) Complete all receipts every day. 3) Complete all paperwork every day. 4) Complete all stocking duties every day. 5) Report all errors, mistakes, problems immediately.
Shop Counter Duties 1) Fill all part requests as quickly as possible. 2) Record all transactions at time of sale. 3) Attempt to fill all missed sales with local sources. 4) Verify all unfilled orders with both technician and service advisor. 5) Handle all “car down” orders as quickly as possible. 6) Process all core and warranty part returns daily. 7) Keep my area as neat as possible. Analyze and define every position and discuss with each employee exactly what you believe their job duties are. The result creates secure feelings between you and your people about their work. Here are a few thoughts concerning each position.
Parts Driver: One of the most important, yet lowest-paid and least-trained position. Many times, this is the only representative of the dealer to actually meet the customer face-to-face. Your driver is the symbol of your professionalism, pride, and sincerity in all transactions with your most frequent customers. These customers have the option of purchasing parts elsewhere, and if offended by a driver surely will. Let your drivers know how important they are to the image of the dealership, and that the customers are theirs as well as the dealers. Their uniforms must be clean and well kept, their appearance a credit to your business. Delivery trucks must be clean, with easily read signs, not cluttered, but with name and phone numbers clearly stated. Make each driver responsible for their vehicle. Check all fluids, tires, gasoline, etc.
16 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
each night, in order to have them completely ready for the next morning’s business. Remember, your customers appreciate early deliveries rather than late ones. It is better to have several runs each day to different areas rather than one run that will take all day. Short runs allow you to make an emergency run for that “special” customer. If you have a central location in town, divide your deliveries by area, east/west, or north/south, and set a schedule. Make sure all your customers are aware of your schedule. Always have some way to keep in touch with your driver—radio, pager, cell phone, etc. Give your driver some discretion in the field. Allow him to make minor adjustments for damaged goods, returns, wrong parts, etc. Your customers will appreciate the quick handling of their problems. Drivers are responsible for obtaining all information when wrong parts are sent, since the second trip must be correct. I make a note here about an unfortunate bias in our industry. I have found it unwise to use a female driver in a situation that calls for speedy deliveries. The typical garage or body shop customer is male, and when meeting a female driver, usually wants to talk longer than he would with a male driver. This creates a no-win situation for the female driver. If she stops to be friendly, she is delaying deliveries to the rest of her customers. If she is efficient, the man will sometimes interpret this action as curt or unfriendly, and may hesitate on placing his next order. None of this is her fault; it’s just the situation. I therefore have used only male delivery drivers, although I have absolutely no hesitation in placing women in any other parts department position. Indeed, some of my best parts salespeople have been women.
Receiving-Shipping: Stated in that order because receiving is the most common and the most important duty. All incoming freight must be checked pieceby-piece. Quantity ordered, billed, and received must match. All packing slips must be checked and turned in to the manager for final accounting. Mark all exceptions on packing slips, also a separate exception report to the manager. For extra parts, make packing slips for posting; then make all claims after checking with the factory invoice. All part number changes must be posted, any bin locations changed daily, after all the receiving is done. Remember, you must have accuracy in three places: physical on-hand stock, computer inventory information, and your accounting dollars. All three have to agree at all times. Parts received are generally in two classifications, stocking and special orders. Stock orders are easier to handle. Every part has a location, and no pressure to deliver. Orders are received in the morning and parts
are on your shelves in the afternoon. Special orders are a completely different situation. All special orders are to be considered high priority. A $2.00 part can be holding up a $1,000 job. After checking all the parts on the packing slip, separate pieces by order type. Priority is your shop, then wholesale, and finally retail. With shop orders, speed is your first concern, followed by communication. Take all shop orders to a designated area near your back counter. Give written notification to your back counter personnel and also to the responsible service consultant. Parts should also be visible to the technicians when they are at the back counter. Wholesale customers are next. Notify the counterperson responsible; then place the part in either the will-call or delivery area for your driver. Retail customers are last, but they require the most handling. A copy of the special order is attached to the part; the part is placed in a special order section in alphabetical order. A copy of the order is placed in an alphabetical file, and another copy is used to contact the customer. A phone call is best, but a post card can also be mailed. Special orders will always accumulate. For reasons unknown, even when parts have been pre-paid, customers will not come back for them. You must clean out special order shelves on a regular basis. This is just a part of normal business. The most important thing about shipping is keeping records. Duplicates of packing slips, carrier name and shipping number, all necessary information to track shipments must be kept in an organized file, preferably kept by carrier and date. Remember, if you cannot prove liability on lost shipments, you will have to assume the loss. As you can see, the receiving, shipping, housekeeping portion of the department’s business is critical to all sales areas. This is a good position for an assistant manager. You need someone with good organizational skills, who is good with paperwork, neat, and supportive of all the other personnel. This position is truly the foundation of a good parts department.
Shop Counter Personel As I have said before, the back counter is the best place to train a future counterperson. The technician cannot be lost or driven off by unfortunate delays or errors. The car, the technician, all of the necessary information, is here. Advice and help are available at all times. Your regular back counter personnel can always use the extra hands and feet, and the heavy volume of orders provides the greatest experience in the least amount of time. Your back counter (service sales) is the best profit center and the backbone of all parts department sales. A good parts opera-
tion contributes to increased service and sales. Customers who have their car repaired in a timely manner return for more service, and continue to purchase vehicles at your dealership. The most important thing for service sales is the proper inventory of expected parts. You must never be out of parts for regularly scheduled service. Set minimum amounts (two services) for all part numbers. Not having simple items such as spark plugs, filters, etc. will give your customer the worst possible impression of your department and dealership. A separate fast-moving stock area must be next to your back counter. Not only for filters and fluids, your service special order section must also be here. A separate shelf, in view of your technicians, is used for all “car down� orders. The part is a constant reminder to get the car into the shop and finished. The back counter is also the center for phasing in new numbers and adjusting onhand quantities. Here is where you purchase parts from other dealers or more importantly, other parts suppliers, like NAPA and AUTO ZONE. If you have a regular monthly bill of over $1000 for your own car line, you are not managing your inventory properly. Independent part stores only carry the most popular parts, the same ones you should never be out of. Every purchase of a part that has a factory number needs to be entered in your sys-
tem. Instruct all of your countermen to use only factory numbers on purchase orders. When you do your daily review, enter all these numbers as lost sales. You should only have to do this two times before the number comes up on your suggested stock order. If you do not catch these missed sales, you will continue giving away profits that rightfully belong to you. If your dealership includes a body shop, assign one person to handle all these orders. This position is mandatory training for a future wholesale counterperson. They must know how your best customer operates in order to work with him. Six months of dedicated involvement with a functioning body shop will give them the experience necessary to understand this customer’s point of view. Remember, you are not just a parts warehouse. You are a partner in the auto repair business. Your people should know how their parts will be used. They should be aware of a technician’s primary needs, and which parts need to be available first. This attitude creates a bond between you and your customer that will benefit you both. Retail Counter Personel After learning on the back counter; transfer your trainees to the front counter. By now they should be able to find the most common parts, and understand the repair procedures used in mechanical and body
!%')3¸ 7).$3()%,$ 2%0!)2 !$$3 4/ 9/52 "/44/- ,).%
s !%')3¸ 7INDSHIELD 2EPAIR 3YSTEMS s !%')3¸ 2EPAIR !DHESIVES s !%')3¸ 'LASS (ANDLERS s 3/,/ 7INDSHIELD 3ETTING 4OOLS s !%')3¸ 3CRATCH 2EMOVAL 3YSTEMS s !LL -AJOR "RANDS OF 0OWER AND -ANUAL #UT OUT 4OOLS "LADES AND !DHESIVE 'UNS s 'REAT SERVICE AND TECHNICAL SUPPORT 6IEW PRODUCT DEMOS AT WWW AEGISTOOLS COM
&OUFS DPEF "#/ GPS PĂľ BOZ XJOETIJFME SFQBJS TZTUFN BU XXX BFHJTUPPMT DPN
4HE #HOICE OF 0ROFESSIONALS 7ORLDWIDE FOR OVER YEARS
TOLL FREE IN 5 3 AND #ANADA % MAIL INFO AEGISTOOLS COM s 0HONE s &AX 0 / "OX -ADISON 7) 53!
repair. At the front counter they will learn how to take care of a new kind of customer‌ the kind that can be extremely frustrating to serve. The typical front counter (walk-in) customer is an amateur mechanic, who may or may not know the correct terminology of the part, or parts, that he needs. A trainee will learn to use illustrations, locations, and descriptions to determine the required parts. These customers need more time per sale than any other. Patience is the primary requirement for this position. Other walk-in customers will be your local wholesale accounts; picking up orders. This position, along with your parts driver, is the “faceâ€? of your dealership. The first few seconds of your customer’s experience determines all of his future purchases. A smile, with a pleasant greeting, helps set the stage for future sales. An attitude of being “interruptedâ€? however is unfortunately a common occurrence in many businesses. If you happen to notice this attitude, shift your employee to the back counter, where his frustration will do less harm. Technicians know how to deal with this, and may help you save the employee. At the front counter the manager will also learn if the trainee is a salesman or an “order taker.â€? Most of your employees will simply take orders. There are very few “naturalâ€? salesmen found in parts departments. Cultivate these people when you find them. This is the type of personality you want on the front counter, and later, on wholesale telephones. Special traits to look for are friendliness, extra consideration, eagerness, keen sense of enthusiasm, and the desire to help. All of these characteristics are required to understand difficult customers, and again, patience! You are looking for someone who likes to solve other people’s problems. This employee will have ideas that encourage sales—by changing displays, promoting accessories, and looking for extra opportunities which promote growth. In other words, this is an “Atypeâ€? personality. This employee responds best to positive feedback, self-management, and performance rewards, and is one of your best profit-producing assets. Let this person be the one who takes the overflow of your telephone business. He takes the calls from your main telephone number—not your direct wholesale lines. This process allows gradual entry into telephone sales. Some time must be spent in this capacity in order to gain the experience necessary for the most difficult position; the voice of your dealership. Retail Counter Duties 1) Keep work area neat and clean. 2) Maintain a professional image. 3) Maintain a professional attitude. 4) Greet every customer as soon as possible. 5) Maintain the sale. When parts are out of stock, check nearby sources, then special order.
6) Call customers when special orders arrive.
Wholesale Telephone Sales This position calls for your most experienced personnel. It is the voice of your department, and the hallmark of your competence. Many of your important customers will never see anyone except your driver. Their perception of you will be the person they talk to when they place their order. That perception must be the best one possible. Your employee will have to recognize exactly what the customer wants, without delay, and complete the transaction quickly. Here is the perfect spot for your “Atype� individual. This person loves to hear the phone ring, has a smile in their voice, and makes friends easily. This employee enjoys getting ahead, reaching goals, and responds to rewards. This individual will have every tool they need at their disposal. Telephone, computer, paper, order forms, pens, and stapler—everything should be at their station. Time management is the key to wholesale success. Every call needs to be handled as efficiently as possible, to keep your lines open for the next call. If any call is for more than two parts, train your personnel to always call back. Never keep a customer on hold. The hold button is your worst enemy. Your next enemy is doubt. Time spent going to the bin to check on a part is time wasted. Your telephone wholesaler must always be able to trust the inventory information available to them. If the inventory states that there is one part in stock, they must be able to sell it, without checking. The accuracy of your inventory is key. The parts manager is the one who should accept all responsibility for the accuracy of the inventory. You can allow your people to make inventory adjustments, but make sure they notify you of any and all changes that have been made. You need to know if your inventory errors are excessive, and why. If you do your job right, an increase will be the natural result of your efficiency. With proper training, you will always have personnel available to move up into sales positions. Simply add personnel as your demand increases. Increasing business can bring on a new set of problems—a breakdown in communication being the most common one. Watch your telephone traffic, and be prepared to add additional direct phone lines when necessary. With a large wholesale operation, a separate line just for your drivers is also a good idea. Some dealers employ outside sales personnel to promote their business. I have never done this myself, but you may find it that works for you. Comments? Contact Larry Williams at ljoew2@gmail.com.
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 17
GM, Carfax Unite to Push Out Recall News
General Motors and Carfax have entered into an agreement to aid dealers, owners and potential buyers about rectifying unrepaired safety, non-compliance and emission recalls. GM executives explained that they’re providing millions of vehicle identification numbers to Carfax for units with open recalls. Brands include Chevrolet, Buick, GMC and Cadillac as well as ones the automaker no longer sells, Hummer, Saab, Pontiac and Saturn. Buyers and sellers can access this information through Carfax Vehicle History Reports and at www.carfax.com/recall by May 1. Carfax research indicated that consumers utilizing these resources can help significantly increase completion rates on open recalls. The data also revealed that about four out of five GM owners complete recall repairs within 18 months of being notified of a recall. “We know some people do not take their vehicles in for recall repairs when they get their letters. Carfax makes it easy for consumers to find out whether a vehicle they are considering has an open recall and increases the chances of that repair being made,” stressed Jamie Hresko, GM’s vice president of global quality.
Maryland Salvage Bill Now Awaits Governor Signature
The Washington Metropolitan Auto Body Association (WMABA) is taking credit for successfully moving HB 1199 through both the House and the Senate during the recent 2010 legislative session. This bill (HB 1199), which adds an exclusion to the threshold for “cosmetic damage” and “the cost of towing, storage or vehicle rental,” was successfully passed with majority support by stakeholders, as well as legislators. The bill’s provisions create an additional salvage application statement that an insurer must provide in certain circumstances; prohibit anyone from using specified costs to determine the cost to repair a vehicle for highway operation under the motor vehicle salvage program; and ensure that a specified cost of repair calculation may not affect specified rights. The legislation would add an exclusion for non-structural items to the state’s total-loss calculation. The bill also creates a specific exclusion for costs arising from towing, storage and vehicle rental, and would require a salvage certificate application for any vehicle acquired by an insurance company as a result of a claim settlement.
‘R2R Act’ Bipartisan Co-sponsor List Grows
The Motor Vehicle Owners’ Right to Repair Act (HR 2057) has gained more bipartisan support with the addition of nine members of Congress to the growing cosponsor list. Reps. Michael Arcuri (DNY), Anh “Joseph” Cao (R-LA), Barney Frank (D-MA), Loretta Sanchez (D-CA), James Sensenbrenner, Jr. (R-WI), Bennie Thompson (D-MS), Glenn Thompson (R-PA), Paul Tonko (D-NY) and Charles Wilson (D-OH) have declared their support of the Right to Repair Act. The bill now has 60 co-sponsors in the House of Representatives. “We thank these nine members of Congress for backing this critical piece of pro-consumer and pro-small business legislation,” said Ray Pohlman, president of the Coalition for Auto Repair Equality (CARE). “The Right to Repair Act does not cost tax payers money, does not create a new agency and, more importantly, does not ask taxpayers for a bailout. It simply requires that vehicle manufacturers provide car owners and their trusted neighborhood repair shops with the same access to the same safety alerts, technical service bulletins, diagnostic tools and repair information they provide to their dealer network – nothing more, nothing less. The top priority of the Right to Repair Act is motoring consumer safety, ensuring that motorists know what is happening with their vehicles.” Be-
cause vehicles are becoming increasingly sophisticated with virtually every system either monitored or controlled by computers, servicing these vehicle systems to keep them in safe working order requires ready access to complete and accurate information, tools and software from the car companies. The Right to Repair Act protects motorists by allowing them to have access to the repair information for the vehicle they purchased, thus ensuring that they can choose where, how and by whom they have their vehicles repaired. “Allowing independent repair shops to compete on a level playing field promotes fair competition and ensures that car owners throughout the country continue to have access to affordable and convenient automotive repair,” said Kathleen Schmatz, president and CEO of the Automotive Aftermarket Industry Association (AAIA). The Senate version of the Motor Vehicle Owners’ Right to Repair Act (S 3181) was recently introduced with bipartisan support by Sens. Barbara Boxer (D-CA) and Sam Brownback (R-KS). The House version of the bill (HR 2057) was introduced by Reps. Edolphus Towns (D-NY), Anna Eshoo (D-CA) and George Miller (D-CA). The legislation is said to provide car companies with strong protections for their trade secrets.
18 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
City of Dallas Forcing Body Shop Owners Out A Dallas business operating for 31 years is being forced to close its doors. But it’s not because of the economy or lack of customers. It’s because the city of Dallas is forcing it to, according to a story broadcast by FOXdfw.com Jerry Moreno, 61, owns Downtown Auto Upholstery and Body Shop at 1623 N. Hall St., in the shadow of downtown Dallas on Ross Avenue at Hall Street. He’s been in business more than two dozen years and he says it’s all he’s ever known. He does auto glass and convertible tops as well “This place is my life,” he said. But now he has to close and move out. “We don’t have any choice. I have to leave,” he said. He’s no longer allowed to operate an auto related business on the property. Otherwise, he faces a $2,000 per day fine. “They’re taking it away from me. I feel they’re taking part of my life; part of my body, you know?” he said. Moreno is worried about his half dozen employees, too. “I will try to find another job because this one is going away,” said Juan Hernandez. “And I have two kids. I don’t know what I’ll do.” The city said it’s looking for high end development on Ross Avenue
heading downtown into the arts district from the east. The city approved a plan five years ago to rezone the area and is now enforcing its eminent domain. Local businesses, mostly car dealers and another body shop, Rick’s Auto Body and Repairs, were given two to five years advanced notice to relocate. “Clearly there’s Jerry Moreno is being a lot of sympathy forced out of his N. for businesses,” Hall St. location. said David Cossum, assistant director of Current Planning. “The way it was addressed that was to provide some adequate time period for business owners to seek, relocate and market their property. You can’t argue it’s not a hardship on an owner. Clearly it is. But as with a lot of things with the city, you’re looking at the bigger picture in how you’re trying to make the entire city benefit.” Jerry, 61, says that all may be true but he can’t reinvent himself now, and more importantly, he feels he shouldn’t have to.
? rtts? parts Kia pa for Kia itin ing for wait of wa Tiredd of k. quicck. you qui em’’ too you git’ em We We’ll git r ts! partts! your par alll you foor all firsst for Cal Call uss firs LESALE PARTS WHOLESALE PARTS WHOLESALE PARTSWHOLESALE Free next day delivery to over 400 cities in Texas and Louisiana. (certain restrictions apply for Oklahoma) Price matching program for aftermarket and recon parts. One of the bbiggest inventories in the nation. O Over 30 years combined experience. Ov No restocking fees. Competitive discounts. Co
Hours: Mon - Fri 7 - 8 Ho Sat 7 - 6 If you are an Automotive Repair Shop, Body Shop or Fleet for Wholesale Parts.
800-883-1933 or
CALL 713-947-8053 Fax parts@fredykia.com
Service, Service, Diagnostic Diiagnostic D gnostic and an d Mechanical M e chanical ch aniccal al NEWS nd Mec echanical Mech ech ec hanical ca
www.autobodynews.com
Toyota Fined $16.4M, Will Face Single Sudden Acceleration Lawsuit Autobody News
May 2010
Toyota agreed April 19 to pay a $16.4 million fine imposed by the Transportation Department—the largest ever government penalty against an automaker, and the maximum amount allowed under U.S. law. The fine was imposed on Toyota for concealing and delaying the release of information related to recent recalls to fix sticking pedals. Toyota failed to tell the agency about the ‘sticky pedal’ problem for at least four months.” The Houston Chronicle reported, “The government has linked 52 deaths to crashes allegedly caused by accelerator problems in Toyotas. The recalls have led to congressional hearings, a criminal investigation by federal prosecutors, dozens of lawsuits and an intense review by the Transportation Department.” A separate investigation by the Los Angeles Times has indicated that more than 100 deaths may ultimately be blamed on the defect. The federal fine “is only narrowly tailored for one of the many defects,” confirms Susan Schroeder, the Orange County (California) DA's chief of staff, “and it in no way effects our case.” It does not release Toyota from civil or criminal actions, including the recently filed lawsuit. The federal court system has consolidated more than 200 separate lawsuits against Toyota
into one single class-action suit, which will be heard in a California courtroom. The Los Angeles Times reports, “In a ruling handed down [April 16], the U.S. Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation allowed more than 100 suits seeking classaction status, as well as at least 50 personal injury cases, to be adjudicated in a single federal courtroom.” The Detroit Free Press notes, “lawsuits began appearing last fall as Toyota initiated recalls eventually involving about 8 million vehicles,” all triggered by claims that some Toyota vehicles can accelerate suddenly, without input from the driver. The Times put the number at about 150 lawsuits, but an AP report on April 21 claims the decision “affects more than 200 lawsuits against Toyota around the country.” Claims have been filed by owners seeking “damages from Toyota for injuries or deaths attributed to instances of sudden acceleration,” as well as some who don’t claim their Toyotas have been involved in accidents, but who are suing because their vehicles have lost value due to the recalls. Toyota had pushed the courts to consolidate all of the claims into a single case, according to the Times. The company argued that “the legal process would be best
served if the cases were argued in one courtroom.” However, there are risks for Toyota in this approach. Reuters notes, “Some lawyers estimate Toyota faces potential civil liability of more than $10 billion as it struggles to contain an auto-safety crisis that has tarnished its public image.” Such a massive claim will be covered heavily by the media, and a loss in the lawsuit could be devastating to the Japanese automaker. The major players in the courtoom will be used to high stakes. The legal team opposing Toyota, Reuters reports, include “firms with experience ranging from big tobacco litigation to the Enron Corp bankruptcy and claims arising from the Exxon Valdez oil spill.” The first hearing in the matter has been set for May 13. Lexus GX 460 recall Toyota said the factors contributing to the Lexus GX 460 rollover risk include components such as 18-inch wheels, as well as heavy components, such as the fuel tank, which is located on the left side. Plus “the left side is made even heavier because of the presence of the driver.” Toyota also said the activation of the vehicle stability control “may not be suffi-
Sienna Recall Toyota has issued a recall order for about 600,000 Sienna minivans from model years 1998 through 2010, in order to correct a defect that could cause the spare tire to fall from beneath the van. In light of bad publicity from a series of high-profile recalls, the company has released details of this recall to the media unusually quickly—before The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration had time to issues a formal recall order. The New York Times reports, “Toyota said its latest recall covered the 1998–2010 model year Siennas with two-wheel-drive that have been sold or registered in 20 cold-climate states and the District of Columbia. Toyota said rust from road salt could cause the carrier cable that holds the spare tire to rust and break, allowing the tire to tumble into the road.”
by Jim Lang, President, Lang Marketing
across the overall light vehicle market were generated by the expanding number of vehicles on U.S. roads during these ten years.
This reflects the increasing average age of cars in the U.S. and the growing number of domestic cars twelve years and older. Generally, consumers perform only necessary repairs on older vehicles. Consumers are also inclined to purchase economy rather than premium aftermarket components when having repairs done by mechanics or performing DIY work on older vehicles.
Growth Versus Decline Aftermarket product use by the average light truck climbed over $12 between 1999 and 2009, while product consumption by the typical car slipped nearly $55 at userprice. At the same time, total light vehicle aftermarket product sales climbed nearly 16%, a direct result of the increasing number of light vehicles on U.S. roads and light truck population growth.
Falling Average Vehicle Product Use
The number of cars and light trucks on U.S. roads increased slightly during 2009; while light vehicle aftermarket product sales receded. As a result, average light vehicle product volume continued its downward trend during 2009, at user-price.
Ten Year Aftermarket View Product use by the average car and light truck decreased $13 at user-price between 1999 and 2009, with 2009 product volume totaling just over $360 for the typical light vehicle on U.S. roads.
Rate Of Decline Aftermarket product consumption per light vehicle declined at a 0.4% average annual pace between 1999 and 2009, underscoring that all aftermarket product gains
Cars Versus Light Trucks Aftermarket product consumption by the typical car is falling faster than is light vehicle truck product volume. While annual product use per passenger car in the U.S. declined 16% between 1999 and 2009, light truck product use for the average vehicle climbed nearly 3% over this ten-year span.
Passenger Car Product Use Aftermarket product volume by the average passenger car slipped below $275 at user-price during 2009, much less than the nearly $325 in 1999 product volume per car.
Light Trucks Also Decline in 2009 Light trucks averaged $4 less in 2009 products per vehicle than during the previous year. This annual product decline among light trucks is the result of two factors: an aging truck population and a drop in accessory volume, which average much more per light truck than for the typical passenger car.
cient in certain circumstances due to the setting of the VSC program. Toyota will update the VSC program to enhance the effectiveness of the VSC so that the risk of the vehicle sliding, even to the point that it is almost sideways, will be reduced.
More Analysis In-depth analysis of the changing use of aftermarket products for cars and light trucks as well as for all light vehicles is provided in the soon-to-be-released 2011 AAIA Factbook & Lang Aftermarket Annual. From Aftermarket Insight™ by Jim Lang, President of Lang Marketing Resources, Inc., www.langmarketing.com.
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 19
Gonzo’s Toolbox
Excerpted from Scott “Gonzo” Weaver's Book, “Hey Look! I Found The Loose Nut”, which provides a Good Laugh for Mechanics of Any Age. The book is available at amazon.com. Contact Scott Weaver at Gonzosae@aol.com and see his website at www.gonzostoolbox.com.
“You’re Just One of Those Slick Talkin’ Mechanics” with Gonzo Weaver
A referral came in from and old customer. It was an early 90’s Ford pickup that could have passed for a clown car. This thing had every color of the rainbow on it. Windshield was cracked, and the driver side window was hanging sideways. Even the bed of the truck was loaded down with all kind of debris from roofing shingles to old busted up lawn furniture. Not to mention the interior could use some house cleaning. These are the type of vehicles I hate to get stuck behind when I’m riding my motorcycle. You just never know when something is going to fly out of the bed of the truck and smack into you. The only reason I even took this pile of junk into the shop was because it was a referral from a regular customer. Normally, if you pull up to the shop in this bad of shape you better have one hell of a heart bleeding story, or I’ll tell you to get it on down the road. Anyway, this beat up old Ford had so many problems. I had to do my best to sort though what I could. It was hard to start, and when it did start it had a terrible miss. If you tried to drive it even few feet it would buck and backfire, and eventually start to move, but not without a great effort on the motor’s part. I called our junk collector and told him what I had found right off the bat, and that it needed taken care before we went any further. The old distributor had such a wobble in the shaft that half the time it couldn’t find the contact points. I thought this was why it was so hard to start, and for that matter the big backfire. Of course a lot of other things could cause the same problem. But this was so obvious any first year tech could have spotted the problem. “So that’s all there is wrong with it?” he asked. “I seriously doubt that. I haven’t checked it for codes. I haven’t looked at
the transmission or fuel pressure, but this distributor has got to go,” I said. Now it’s a money thing. He told me to go ahead with it, and keep him informed of the results. After installing the distributor it started right up, even sounded pretty good. Before pulling it out onto the road, I thought I better check those codes. There were 2 codes; One for a TPS, and another for the transmission. I called him and told him what I found. Now it’s back to money thing again. “OK, go ahead with the TPS. I don’t think there is anything wrong with the transmission,” he told me. This was like putting the curse of Murphy on the truck. Something has to go wrong now. I put the TPS in, and cleared the codes. The engine started great, ran terrific, and sounded surprisingly solid. All the codes cleared, and no more really obvious problems (I could have spent days straightening things under the hood). It was time to hit the road. Oh, oh. The truck’s transmission was trash. It had all the gears, well, sort of. It would lumber along, drop in and out of gear, and find a new neutral position when it had a chance. For the most part the transmission was in about as good of shape as the rest of the truck. Just plain overworked. You might as well put a fork in this one, because it’s done. Time to make the call. It seems every time you get this far into one of these never ending repairs it will reach a point where you’re not solving one problem at a time, but creating an even bigger one, the financial one. Almost every time this type of customer will go along with what needs done until he thinks you don’t know what you’re doing, and are just out to take their money. Not so! The whole thing comes down to maintenance. It’s not like every-
thing broke at once. They let it go, then expect a one-fix repair with a discount!. Like I said, the outcome is a little different each time, but the common factor is usually the same. I’m not getting paid for all the work I have completed….only some sort of agreed upon amount of the repair. This guy took it the extreme. When I called him and told him about the transmission he didn’t have the money. I expected this. Oh, he didn’t have the money for the repairs we had already done. What he was going to try to do was talk me into giving the truck back to him, and he would pay so much each week, because he needed that truck to get back and forth to work. If he didn’t have a way to get to work he couldn’t pay me. I told him that he should have thought of that before he agreed to the work that was done, because the car doesn’t leave until the bill is paid. That’s when he started in on me. “You’re just one of those slick-ass talking mechanics,” he shouted through the phone. “Well that might be the case, and I have called worse, but we did have an agreed upon bill.” I said. “Oh come on man, I know it didn’t need any of that work you did. All it needed was a transmission. So I’m not going to pay for any of it, and I’m picking up my truck today,” he screamed into the phone. Now there are two things to keep in mind on this story. One, he originally agreed to all the repairs as they were getting done. And two, he didn’t think there was anything wrong with the transmission. Or did I miss something in the conversation? The screaming on the phone went on for what seemed like hours. There was no getting through to him about the agreed upon work, or the conversations we had about the additional work to the truck. Or the fact that I had originally told him about
the amount of items I found wrong with the truck. I could tell I might as well be talking to the wall. “OK fella, I can see we’re not going to get anywhere. You know me being a slick-ass talking mechanic and all; tell me how much you have and be honest now. If I agree to accept the amount I’ll put your truck out front, and you bring in what cash you have and I’ll give you the keys. Here I am trying to help you out, and now all you want to do is change things after the fact. I didn’t want to do this job in the first place because of the horrible condition it was in, but another customer said you were an upstanding guy. So I did the work. Take your truck home and do whatever you want with it, because I don’t need to make a living off someone who doesn’t trust me. Even if the guy who referred you does. He agreed to this strange arrangement, but he was still mouthing off when he got to the shop. He walked out to his truck and started right up. He came back in the office still mad as hell, and wanted me to show him which parts I changed, so he wouldn’t change the same ones again. I did, and then he wanted a receipt for the parts. You can figure out the rest, he left the same way he came in. Unfortunately for him, there was no way to show his manhood with a tire squealing peel out in the parking lot. The transmission doesn’t work that well! Oh by the way, I do feel sorry for the guy, and wish I could have done more for him since he was a referral from a good friend and customer. The money is very important, but I do need to have some assurance that I’m appreciated for what I do. The old customer and I talked about it later. He said he thought the guy was a kind and conscientious guy. He’d never heard a cuss word out of him, since he was the janitor at his local church and all. Go figure.
The BMW Group increased sales by 13.8% percent in the first quarter: A total of 315,614 (prev. yr. 277,264) BMW, MINI and Rolls-Royce brand automobiles were delivered to customers worldwide. The company’s sales volumes rose 12.1% in March to reach a total of 141,701 (prev. yr. 126,381) vehicles. All three brands made strong gains: Sales of BMW brand vehicles climbed 12.7% to 117,696 (prev. yr. 104,423) units in the month under review. MINI delivered 23,880 vehicles in March (+9.1%), while Rolls-Royce automobiles were presented to 125 customers (+78.6%) last month. Ian Robertson, member of the
Board of Management of BMW AG, responsible for Sales and Marketing: “We are back on our growth track in nearly all the automobile markets. We had a good first quarter with a sales increase of 13.8%. We intend to continue improving on last year’s figures throughout the second quarter, thanks not least to the new BMW 5 Series Sedan and new models such as the 3 Series Coupé and Convertible.” Robertson added: “For 2010 as a whole, we are aiming for healthy growth in the single-digit percent range to reach more than 1.3 million vehicles.” In the United States, the company
posted a 7.4% increase in volumes, with sales of 55,051 (prev. yr. 51,244) vehicles between January and March. Substantial increases were also seen in other key markets: For instance, in the United Kingdom sales climbed 13.8% to 34,327 (prev. yr. 30,165) units; in France sales were up 5.2% to 14,462 (prev. yr. 13,745) units; and in Spain sales were 37.4% higher at 10,374 (prev. yr. 7,549) units. The BMW Group made gains in almost all automobile markets in the first quarter. The company achieved new quarterly records not only in the emerging BRIC countries of Brazil (+131.2%), Russia (+11.6%), India (+32.5%) and China
(+106.1%), but also in Austria (+23.1%), South Korea (+65.8%) and Malaysia (967 / +14.0%), as well as in the Latin American markets (4,173 / +71.0% - including Brazil) and the Middle East (3,908 / +13.1%). Despite the overall downward market trend, the BMW Group was the only German manufacturer to also make gains in its largest single market, Germany, where it expanded its market share. With a total of 56,617 (prev. yr. 55,837) vehicles sold in the country in the first three months of the year, there were 1.4% more new BMW and MINI registrations than in the same period last year.
BMW Group has Sales Growth of 13.8% In First Quarter
20 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
Transmission Anti-Rollaway Shift Interlocks Now Required
New cars with automatic transmissions must be equipped with an interlock device that requires the brake pedal be pressed before the driver can shift the transmission out of “park,” as of Sept. 1, 2010. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration took the action in response to a law passed in 2008 designed to protect children from vehicle rollaways in which a car is inadvertently shifted into neutral or another gear. The new requirement applies to all passenger cars and light trucks weighing 10,000 lbs. or less.
National Performance Buys Speed Warehouse of Hayward, CA
Larry Pacey, president and CEO of National Performance Warehouse (NPW), has announced that the company is acquiring the wholesale operations of Speed Warehouse. The transaction will be completed on April 26th. Speed Warehouse has been in business for more than 60 years. The business was started by Jerry Light in 1949, selling high-performance parts after World War II. Speed operates out of three distribution points in Hayward, San Jose, and Tustin, CA.
80 Percent of Tested Cars Fail Inspection Checks
Last year, eight out of 10 cars failed at least one component of a national vehicle-inspection process, according to the Car Care Council (carcare.org)
Problems were: ● Low, overly full, or dirty engine oil was found in 27% of cars ● Low, leaky, or dirty coolant in the radiator or surge tank was identified in 26% of cars. ● One out of every two belts was unsatisfactory in 51% of cars ● 10% of cars required at least one new hose.
Car Car Council Wants Consumers to Remember Their Three “R’s” In recognition of Earth Day, the Car Care Council is encouraging vehicle owners to consider the new 3 R’s to do their part to protect the environment: Reuse, reduce and repower. Consumers could make a huge environmental contribution and a wise investment by reusing or hanging onto their current vehicles rather than buying a new one, by reducing emissions and fuel consumption through vehicle maintenance and by repowering a failed engine. This year marks the 40th anniversary of Earth Day.
ASAA Opposing Ohio OEM Parts Legislation
The Automotive Aftermarket Suppliers Association (AASA) is working to oppose provisions in Ohio legislation that would bar OEM part sales to non-franchised dealers or reimbursements to nonfranchised dealers for warranty or recall work. The two provisions are part of House and Senate bills revising Ohio’s motor vehicle franchise laws. Rep. Matt Lundy (D-Ohio 57th District) is the sponsor of HB 364 and Sen. Mark Wagoner (R-Ohio 2nd District) introduced a companion bill in the Ohio Senate. In its March 22 letter to Rep. Lundy, AASA noted, “Aftermarket manufacturers are deeply concerned with language contained in HB 364 ... We believe this provision eliminates consumer choice by requiring individuals to obtain replacement parts only at automobile dealerships.” The letter notes that the provision would affect both independent repair shops and the DIY market. “The language restricts the access to original equipment parts only to auto dealers. Vehicle owners would no longer perform their own maintenance with the parts of their choice. Moreover, independent repair shops would no longer have access to the full range of parts that consumers may need for vehicle repair,” the AASA letter noted. AASA appealed to Lundy to amend the provisions.
CAWA Battery Core Bill Now Law in Arizona
The California/Nevada/Arizona Automotive Wholesalers' Association (CAWA) says that Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer has signed into law HB 2130 to address a discrepancy in battery core sales and deposits. HB 2130, authored by Rep. Michele Reagan and sponsored on behalf of CAWA, will update the amount of the recycling deposit that retailers can charge consumers who purchase automotive batteries to an amount that is not greater than the recycling deposit charged by battery manufacturers. The bill increases from $5 to not more than $15, the recycling deposit that a retailer can charge a consumer for the purchase of a new battery. The deposit is returned to the consumer upon the return of the used battery core. The bill also increases from 30 days to 45 days the amount of time a consumer has to return a used battery core for recycling, in order to have the recycling deposit returned in full. “CAWA is elated with this victory on behalf of Arizona automotive parts stores and retailers. Last year we heard from our retailer members how important this issue was for them, and as a result, we acted quickly and proactively to address this monetary discrepancy related to the sale and deposit of automotive batteries,” said Rodney Pierini, CAWA president and CEO. In 1990, legislation was enacted that prohibits the disposal of automotive batteries in landfills or by incineration. In
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 21
ALL OEM Information with Tom McGee and Jeffrey Webster
Tom McGee is National Account Manager for ALLDATA Collision. He has had a long career with I-CAR, including as President & CEO. Tom is an ASE certified Master Collision Repair/Refinish Technician. He has also run his own collision facility and been a career and technical school instructor. He can be reached at Tom.McGee@alldata.com. For other Tom McGee articles in Autobody News, go to: http://www.autobodynews.com/tom-mcgee/index.php — JEFF WEBSTER is an ALLDATA Technical Writer.
It’s Still a Mustang®; But in Name Only – PART 2 of 2
In my April column, I wrote that, as I visit shops, I sometimes hear the same comments regarding the need for OE repair information. Among the most common are: “I’ve been fixing cars since 1960something and we know how to fix them.” “They are still cars and nothing is really changing on them.” “My technicians are great and they know how to fix cars.” So, last month, I started comparing a 1965 Ford® Mustang® with the 2008 version. The point being that fixing today’s complex cars requires more than experience. New metals and plastics, electronic systems and reset procedures, hybrid systems and more have changed the way we do business. Let’s continue looking at the Mustang to see what has changed over the years and how those changes affect the collision repair process.
Sectioning – Lower Frame Rail While I looked everywhere I could, I was not able to find any sectioning procedures for the front lower frame rail on the ’65. Here is a portion of the 2008 sectioning procedure: Always refer to ALLDATA® ColliSM sion for safety procedures, identification of material types, recommended refinish materials, and removal and installation procedures. Always refer to the vehicle manufacturer for questions relating to applicable or non-applicable warranty repair information.
Item 1
Part Number
16055 LH / 16054 RH
Material Front Frame Rail WARNING: Frame rail crush zones absorb crash energy during a collision and must be replaced if damaged. Straighten damaged frame rails to correct frame dimensions prior to frame member section-
ing. Failure to follow these instructions may adversely affect frame rail performance and may result in serious personal injury to vehicle occupant(s). NOTE: Right side shown (Figure 1), Left side similar.
NOTE: Cut line shown in illustration is approximate, refer to the following procedure for specific cut locations.
WARNING: Never install used or reconditioned parts (as specified below) from pre-owned, salvaged or damaged vehicles. The use of such parts could lead to serious injury. Never use non-Ford parts or accessories for completing repairs. Ford Motor Company does not approve or recognize body and structural repair procedures, tools, parts or anything but new genuine Ford equipment. Ford cannot attest to the safety, quality, durability or legality of non-Ford parts or accessories. Use of such parts could lead to serious personal injury as they may contain damage which is not visible. Ford does not approve use of the following: • Salvaged or used parts • Major body clips or assemblies from salvage vehicles • Aftermarket structural or body components • Salvaged or reconditioned wheels • Used supplemental restraint system (SRS) components - air bags - restraint sysDescription tem modules Frame rail sectioning kit - safety belts, buckles or retractors - crash sensors Returning a vehicle to pre-accident condition can only be assured if repair procedures are carried out by skilled technicians using new genuine Ford parts and Ford-approved methods. Structural component repair procedures approved by Ford, using genuine Ford parts, have been validated by Ford Motor Company engineers. Ford Motor Company does not endorse, cannot attest to, and makes no representations re-
22 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
garding structural repairs (frames, rails, aprons and body panels) carried out using non-genuine Ford Motor Company parts or non-Ford-approved methods. In particular, Ford makes no representations that the vehicle will meet any crash safety or anti-corrosion performance requirement. Such parts and methods have not been tested by Ford, and may not meet Ford's requirements for safety, performance, strength, quality, durability and corrosion protection. Ford Motor Company bears no responsibility or liability of any kind if repairs are performed using alternative structural component repair procedures and/or parts.
WARNING: Invisible ultraviolet and infrared rays emitted in welding can injure unprotected eyes and skin. Always use protection such as a welder's helmet with dark-colored filter lenses of the correct density. Electric welding will produce intense radiation, therefore, filter plate lenses of the deepest shade providing adequate visibility are recommended. It is strongly recommended that persons working in the weld area wear flash safety goggles. Also, always wear protective clothing. Failure to follow these instructions may result in serious personal injury. WARNING: Always wear protective equipment including eye protection with side shields, and a dust mask when sanding or grinding. Failure to follow these instructions may result in serious personal injury.
NOTICE: This sectioning procedure is only recommended when collision damage does not extend into the front shock tower area. For more severe collision damage, repairs must be made at the original factory seam and joint locations. Failure to follow these instructions may compromise the structural integrity of the vehicle.
NOTE: The following repair procedure illustrates the sectioning of the front side member and fender reinforcement components In situations where collision damage is less severe, the sectioning procedure to repair only those damaged components may be determined from these procedures.
1. Position the vehicle on a frame repair rack following the manufacturer's recommendations. Measure the vehicle to determine if the body requires straightening and alignment. • Remove the front bumper For additional information, refer to Bumpers. 2. Remove the engine For additional information, refer to Engine System - General Information. 3. Remove the suspension components For additional information, refer to Front Suspension.
NOTICE: The frame rail sectioning instruction kit provides the specific service procedure instructions for replacement of the frame rail sectioning kit. It is mandatory that the replacement section be installed per the installation guidelines. The frame rail service component must be located to maintain the original factory dimensions. For additional information, refer to Body in this section for correct underbody dimensional information. 4. Remove the radiator support assembly. 5. Cut off the front apron from the main part of the apron, 80.5 mm (3.16 in) for-
ward of the 14 mm (0.55 in) x 20 mm (0.78 in) slot, and remove the remainder of the apron (Figure 2). 6. NOTE: Factory spot welds may be substituted with either resistance spot welds or Metal Inert Gas (MIG) plug welds. Spot/plug welds should equal factory welds in both location and quantity. Do not place a new spot weld directly over an original weld location. Plug weld hole should equal 8 mm (0.31 in) diameter.
NOTE: Refer to welding equipment manufacturer's instructions for correct machine set up. Drill out the spot welds in the front fender apron reinforcement. See Still a Mustang, Page 27
Mitchell Inc. Gives CAA Members Open-House Tour of Facilities
Mitchell International hosted an Open House for CAA members at their Mitchell Technology Campus in the Scripps Ranch area of San Diego on March 23rd. The CAA San Diego Chapter joined with Mitchell International to host the Open House so that CAA members could get a unique insider’s view of Mitchell’s collision information software and development facility. The event was well attended with approximately 100 participants. Mitchell provided small group tours of their editorial and software development areas and explained how tremendous amounts of information is turned into state-of-the art
tools for collision repair professionals. Mitchell also hosted a casual dinner at the end of the tour. Hosting the Mitchell tour was Mike Milliken, VP Content Management. The tour coordinator was Gil Silva, Director of Editorial Operations/Data Acquisition. The Mitchell tour was comprised of 4 stops (see photos).
3rd stop: Vehicle Dimension Database – Tom Beres, Supervisor, Vehicle Dimension Department.
each have over 10-15 years of collision repair hands-on experience and the Esti-
mating Team is made up of staff with estimating backgrounds. Many in the CAA group were impressed to hear that Mitchell measures each car independently from what the OEM’s provide as measurements. According to Tom: “It takes about 6 hours to measure a vehicle. If it’s in Mitchell, it’s been measured by us.” For additional information about the CAA and membership benefits, contact Hop Sanchez at SanchezH@Finishmaster.com For additional information about Mitchell International and their products and services contact Amanda Smith at 858371-1523 or Amanda.Smith@mitchell.com
2nd stop: Collision Estimating Database – Jerry Gastineau, Manager, Labor Department.
1st stop: TechAdvisor-Repair Standards Database - Serge Pirino, Manager Procedural Department.
Jerry explained how the Mitchell Collision Estimating Database team was made up of 3 key process teams. The Parts Team is comprised of staff with many years of dealership Parts Department experience, the Labor Team staff
4th stop: Mitchell Data Center – Larry Grimes, Manager, IS Services. Larry gave a tour through the Mitchell high-security IT Data Centers.
When you repair a BMW, use the parts that are identical to those used in Se-
Original BMW Parts
ries production – and just as reliable.
Choose Original BMW Parts. Because you can’t repair your reputation.
bmwusa.com
You only get one chance at the first repair. Original Thought #78
X6 M 2010
Texas
BMW of Dallas
BMW of San Antonio
BMW of Houston North
Classic BMW
Dallas (800) 245-7269 (972) 241-3953 Fax Houston (888) 215-7431 (281) 875-4021 Fax
San Antonio (210) 732-7121 (800) 880-1430
Plano (214) 778-2673 Direct Wholesale (214) 778-2674 Direct Wholesale (214) 778-2814 Fax
Oklahoma
BMW of Tulsa
Tulsa (800) 331-3996 (918) 665-1360 Fax
New Mexico Sandia BMW
Albuquerque (800) 642-2697 (505) 217-0289 Fax
Original BMW Parts
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 23
Custom Corner
Rich Evans is the owner of Huntington Beach Bodyworks and an award winning painter and fabricator. He offers workshops in repair and customization at his facility to share his unique talents. For contacts and design samples visit www.huntingtonbeachbodyworks.com
Working On a ‘57 Thunderbird With Old School Tools & Techniques with Rich Evans
We are going to switch it up this month and go back to the old school way of fixing things on a `57 Thunderbird. A friend from New York shipped me out his Thunderbird, and there’s a good story behind it. His Dad had it in the family for awhile and took it for its last drive before turning it over to his son. We know what happened from there. It got in a car accident and took a heavy hit to the front. My buddy knows my work and was prepared to ship me the
Hood.
car from New York, so I told him ‘no problem, I could fix it.’ Now it would probably be faster and easier to go to a wrecker and buy a front clip to repair this Thunderbird. But with my experience buying parts for older cars, I always seem to come across problems with those parts when I buy them. They’re also expensive. Here I decided we are going to repair as much as possible and see what’s available in new parts, which are easily reproduced from jigs made to reproduce the original parts. The nose panel was available; a couple of the fiberglass pieces were available, but that would take away from its original feel. Then I happened to get a call from a buddy in New Zealand, Willie Newman, a friend who is probably one of the best metal finishers on the planet. Not a lot of guys I know here are doing much metal finishing, but in New Zealand it’s a valued trade. They will fix or fabricate what they don’t have or can’t get easily, and they get very good at it. Willie stopped off in California on his way to Germany and I figured it would be a good time for me to take on a different challenge and repair, rather than just buying, by making a few panels. It’s good to hone your inner craftsman. There’s always 100 ways to fix a car but I’m always willing to try something new and approach it in a different way. I got the car on the frame rack and tied the car down securely. It looks like it got hit above the frame. So what I want to do is hang my gauges on the four points of the chassis so I can see if the chassis is bent or not. The chassis looks good so we
are one step ahead. Looking at the unistructure bolted on the chassis and from there we need to start with our left fender which is pretty much wasted. In most people’s eyes that fender is gone. They’d cut it off and put a new one on. This time I’m going to take a more difficult route and repair that. It’ll take probably about 160 hours of actual labor versus spending the money on “gold parts” from the wrecking yard. When you have a customer that is budget conscious, it pays to have to have an A, B and C plan. What is left over is profit. I’m going to repair as much as I can and reach out to companies that will supply me with the available parts needed. I send the bumper out for repair. I am going to get a left headlight bezel, a left headlight assembly, a new grill and there’s a nose piece and a reinforcement for a nose piece, a new harmonic balance drum. I’m also going to need a new radiator. What I can’t repair I’ll get used. I am going to have to repair the left and right core support, the lower balance, repair the left fender, left inner fender, the hood, left hood hinge. I’ll get the harmonic balancer used. Other than that we are going to have to repair everything else. Starting with the fender we take a half-inch piece of metal and make a template because the right and left side are basically the same but flip-flopped. We will make a template, flip-flop it to the right. Then put this piece of metal behind it, drill a hole in the middle of it and use it as a pulling device, so we’re not tearing the fender. We want to put tension on it and massage this fender out and walk it back out to give it shape.
Hood Reinforcement.
There’s a lot of hammering and dollying involved. Willie and guys like him use more gas acetylene torches versus the TIG or MIG. It’s just great old-school craftsmanship. They use a low flame and the type of rod you use when you’re piecing things together you can hammer and dolly and flatten out the weld from behind, as long as you make access when you’re doing that. We pull on the fender and get it
24 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
pretty true, and at a certain point remove some of the paint so we can see what’s underneath and guess what? We run into a lot of shoddy craftsmanship. We then decided not to put another fender on it because we might run across it in the other fenders or rust or extra work so we were geared up for it. We had to cut a few pieces out on the top of the fender. After getting it pulled we got the new parts in and had to make some alterations with those parts. The header panel was really flimsily done and the inner reinforcement I just had to pack it back up and send it back to the place I got from. I ended up ordering the left and right baffle, at 300 bucks each, and they weren’t even close to being a fit. So we just took the old ones; hammered and dollied them out, getting the reference lines from the factory stamping and just spent a lot of time hammering and dollying these parts. Each part that we took, we dressed up, got it back to as close as we could. When we go for a mockup, things are getting closer. You’re screwing and fitting them in, cross meas-
uring, using your grills and other pieces for reference. We expect some obstacles. The next big part was straightening out that hood. We didn’t want to pay an arm and a leg for a hood. We figured we would remove the skin from the frame and that will give us the access to straighten that frame. Before doing that we hammer and dolly the frame.
Hood Repaired.
We used a flat bench where we could really get on it and push it back to get the major buckle out of it. Then we depicked it and fixed the frame. The metal has memory so you can hammer and dolly areas that are obvious
ly damaged. You don’t want to look at the whole picture at this point. You want to have a plan, go in, hammer and dolly, get things straightened out, it will start taking its shape back. Then we’ll go to the hood and hammer and dolly that. We
had to do a lot of shrinking to give it its shape because the metal was really stretched. Take your time and bring back some real craftsmanship. I know that’s a dying art. Nowdays, working on the modern cars, we’re really just changing panels that are already made available. A lot of body techs out there aren’t really learning the craftsmanship. I try to learn something new everyday and the biggest thing is a staying active. “If you don’t use, you lose it.” I make an effort to work alongside other people who’s work I admire and try to learn their ways of doing things. If I
don’t like what I learn, I just won’t use it or apply it. Even if you are only picking up 20% of what’s being done, you are learning. That’s the key. Learning something new every day will make you better at what you do at the end of the day. So getting our left and right baffles banged and hammered out. We get the hood where we need it so all the pieces are coming into place. On the front of the fender we needed to cut the front flange off and make a flange, taking a piece of metal, putting it in the brake and take it over to the shrinkers. Woodward supplies me with a lot shrinkers, English wheel and brakes and shears. Go to their web site. They’ve got a great set of equipment choices that if your just working in your garage or you have a body shop and you want to start messing with metal of more and fabbing your own pieces. These are affordable products, and if you do it more and more everyday, you might get a heavier duty product that is a little bit more expensive. Those are available through Woodward as well. Use what you have. A lot of jigs you have to make up for putting these hoods on, or clamping things. When you’re making parts, you have to make jigs and templates. It’s more man hours, but it’s less money out of your pocket and more profit in your pocket.
So getting back to that flange on the front fender, we create that. We’ll fit it over, mark it, and cut the old piece it has too many cracks and too many welds. Too many people have worked on it, and the metal is too thin. We’ll add a new piece there. So taking measurements and making sure everything is in its right place. We take the torch and gas it, hammer and dolly it, and tack it in place. Just like a TIG you are going to work your way around and hammer and dolly it. Make sure the metal is not moving. Keep checking it. Check your references and use what templates and what pieces you have. We’ve got the
new hinge in and we’re putting the hinge on just to check our gaps. We ran into a few problems on the hood, but eventually, if you keep checking it, you’re going to get it right. You are dealing with a unistructure so with everything screwed in place you can move things around and adjust it. You want to have the integrity of everything moving smoothly. You want your gaps to be even. Again, it’s a lot of hammering and dollying. Make sure you wear earplugs because it does get loud. A lot of body shops aren’t used to just hammering and dollying any more. If you walk into a body shop and you hear hammering and dollying, you know the real thing’s going on. It’s a kind of music to my ears. It’s amazing what you can do with a hammer and a dolly. We had to make some adjustments that to the front nose panel we bought. We had to cut and move it in because it was way off. Sometimes the parts that you are buying have to be modified to fit. They are going to be close but not really accurate. Any time you are buying aftermarket parts you can guarantee you have to modify them somewhat to fit. Make sure you do your mockup and check things as you go. Don’t weld things into place and put your hood on without checking your gaps because you are going to run into some problems. Working with Willie, who has maybe 35 years of experience with this kind of craftsmanship, is a great experience. All he does is build, so coming into a collision job he might not understand it in the same way guys who do it everyday. But he does this kind of fabrication every day, so he knows that when he comes across obsta-
cles, he can actually take a flat piece of metal and just make it, versus purchasing a replacement. So think about that if you’re building a hot rod or an old-school vehicle and you can’t find the part. Don’t think you’re at a dead end because there are ways. There are videos out there that can show you how. Gene Winfield has a line of videos out. So does Ron Covell. Visit their Web sites. I thought this would be a good project to cover in the column because it was fun and satisfying doing it. It’s good to stand back and see what you can fix versus replace. Everything that you learn from this kind of project you are going to be able to take to the next one. You are going to be able to depend on yourself to create and make something cool. Using that approach with hammering and dollying so you are not using so much filler. Anytime you are taking out a dent or something make sure you are getting it as metal finished as possible by using slapsticks or metal files. You want to file everything down. Guys like Willie file everything. Hit and pick and find your lows and highs and hammer and dolly it until it comes out true. You don’t want to take too much metal away because it takes away from the strength and integrity of the vehicle. Next time I’ll be able to show you a 57’ Thunderbird completed with using every part you’ve seen damaged, repaired versus the grill and the nose panel. I had to alter those. The grill was chrome, so I used that as reference point. I think of it like the old blacksmiths who have inspired me. Especially the guys that used to make the suits of armor. That took thousands and thousands of hours but they did what
they did without a welder. They did with what they had: fire, hammers, wood, whatever they needed, even leather to put things together and they riveted everything. Imagine what you can do today if you applied that kind of creativity with the types of tools you have available now. Anyway that’s the story for this month. Take a look. I think you guys will be impressed with what was done. Thanks as usual to my sponsor companies. I’ll go over them next column.
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 25
First Responders Get Vehicle Extrication Training Courtesy of GCIA
On Friday April 16th, the Georgia Collision Industry Association conducted a free seminar for First Responders so they could learn the latest and safest techniques and procedures for accidents involving late model vehicles with new technologies. The course was attended by Metro Atlanta first responders and 135 firefighters and first responders from over 20
different departments showed up to learn the latest in vehicle construction, hybrid technology, air bag safety, and extrication techniques using the latest equipment. The program was held at Sports & Imports Duluth at 3400 McDaniel Road, Duluth, GA 30096.
The course covered Hybrids, Air Bags, Vehicle Safety, Vehicle Construction, and the latest Extrication Techniques in hands-on exercises. The course was taught by collision industry professionals who have taught this class all over the United States. It is designed for any First Responder, Firefighters,
Police and EMTs. Turnout gear was required for training on late model vehicles. The GCIA would like to thank Gene and Michelle Hamilton of Sports & Imports, FinishMaster, Weaver Automotive, LKQ Corp, Progressive Insurance, Holmatro Rescue Equipment, Georgia Fire and Rescue Supply, Jason’s Deli-Duluth, All Event Rentals, Atlanta Toyota, and Toby Chess for sponsoring this program.
See these Hyundai dealers below for all your collision parts needs! TEXAS
OKLAHOMA
Allen Samuels Hyundai
James Wood Hyundai
NO RTH RICHL AND HILLS
DECATUR
NORMAN
800-888-2079
940-627-4607
866-619-6406 405-364-3307
817-589-7882 Fax
940-627-4653 Fax
Mon-Fri 7am - 7pm Sat 7am - 4pm sgressley@asag.net
Mon-Fri 7:30am - 5:30pm hyundaiparts@jameswood.com
Hub Hyundai
Vandergriff Hyundai
Automax Hyundai
405-364-6504 Fax Mon-Fri 8am - 6pm Sat 8am - 1pm
NEW MEXICO
The Hyundai Genesis— 2009 North American Car of the Year. Think About It
DO THE RIGHT THING ENOUGH TIMES, AND PEOPLE BEGIN TO NOTICE. Hyundai Sales Up More than 14% (year on year). In 2008 Hyundai became the world's fifth-largest automaker, with 7% market share in the United States. 26 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
HOUSTON
ARLINGTON
800-856-2212
866-643-7320
281-955-2311 Fax
817-557-6778 Fax
Mon-Fri 7:30am - 6pm Sat 8am - 3pm hubparts290@hubhouston.com www.hubhouston.com
Mon-Fri 7am - 6pm Sat 8am - 5pm ddavison@vtaig.com www.vandergriffhyundai.com
Larry H. Miller Hyundai ALBUQUERQUE
505-792-7050 505-792-7016 Fax Mon-Fri 7:30am - 6pm Sat 8am - 4pm lleon@lhm.com www.Larrymillerhyundai.com
Continued from Page 22
Still a Mustang
7. Drill out the spot welds attaching the shock tower to the apron panel, and the apron to the lower rail. • Dress all spot weld surfaces. 8. Chamfer inner and outer side member cutline surfaces to improve butt weld surfaces. 9. Measure 12.5 mm (0.49 in) rearward
from the lower rail cutline. Drill seven 8 mm (0.31 in) holes in the insert overlap area flange (Figure 3). 10. Transcribe the inner front side member cutline to the new lower side member, cut to length and chamfer the bull end to improve the weld surface. 11. Construct an insert from the unused inner side member material (Figure 4). 12. Measure 12.5 mm (0.49 in) forward from the lower rail cutline. Drill nine 8 mm (0.31 in) holes in the new lower side member for attachment of the insert (Figure 5). 13. Apply corrosion protection to the repair areas on the vehicle and service parts (Figure 6). 14. Position the insert to the new lower side member, clamp and check fit and alignment MIG plug weld 9 holes. 15. Measure underbody to verify correct dimensions. For additional information, refer to Body for dimensional information. 16. Position the new radiator support assembly, apron panel, rail assembly, front fender lower reinforcement and front fender upper reinforcement (Figure 7). • MIG plug weld all holes. 17. Fusion weld the front fender upper and lower reinforcements to the front fender apron, front fender apron to the radiator support and the seam between the old and the new side members. • Dress all welds. 18. Install the engine. For additional information, refer to Engine System-General Information. 19. Install the suspension components. For additional information, refer to Front Suspension.
Tire Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS) As near as I can tell, the ’65 Mustang came equipped with bias-ply tires. You had to provide your own pressure gauge to determine the air pressure in the tires. Today we have tire pressure monitoring systems. Here is the procedure to reset the TPMS on the 2008 Mustang: NOTE: If the vehicle has been stationary for more than 30 minutes the sensors will go into a “sleep mode” to conserve battery power. It will be necessary to wake them up so they will transmit the latest tire pressure information to the Smart Junction Box (SJB). NOTE: The tire pressure sensor training procedure must be done on a single vehicle in an area without radio frequency noise and at least 1 m (3 ft) away from other vehicles equipped with a Tire Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS). Radio frequency noise is generated by electrical motors and appliance operation cellular telephones remote transmitters,
power inverters and portable entertainment equipment.
NOTE: If a sensor does not respond to the Tire Pressure Monitor Activation Tool attempt to activate the same sensor with the Tire Pressure Monitor Activation Tool. If the sensor still does not respond move the vehicle to rotate the wheels at least onefourth of a turn and attempt to activate the same sensor again. NOTE: The SJB has a 2-minute time limit between sensor responses. If the SJB does not recognize any 1 of the 4 tire pressure sensors during this time limit, the horn will sound twice and the message center (if equipped) will display TIRE NOT TRAINED REPEAT and the entire procedure must be repeated.
NOTE: For vehicles with different front and rear tire pressures (such as the E-Series and certain F-Series), the tire pressure sen-
sors must be trained following a tire rotation. Failure to train the sensors will cause the TPMS indicator to illuminate. For ve-
hicles with the same tire pressure for front and rear tires, tire rotation will not affect the system. 1. Turn the ignition switch to the OFF position, then press and release the brake pedal. 2. Cycle the ignition switch from the OFF position to the RUN position 3 times, ending in the RUN position. 3. Press and release the brake pedal. 4. Turn the ignition switch to the OFF position. 5. Turn the ignition switch from the OFF position to the RUN position 3 times, ending in the RUN position. The horn will sound once and the TPMS indicator will flash if the training mode has been entered successfully. If equipped, the message center will display TRAIN LF TIRE. 6. NOTE: It may take up to 6 seconds to activate a tire pressure sensor. During this time, the Tire Pressure Monitor Activation Tool must remain in place at the valve stem. Place the Tire Pressure Monitor Activation Tool on the LF tire sidewall at the valve stem. Press and release the test button on the Tire Pressure Monitor Activation Tool. The horn will sound briefly to indicate that the tire pressure sensor has been recognized by the SJB. 7. Within 2 minutes of the horn sounding, place the Tire Pressure Monitor Activation Tool on the RF tire sidewall at the valve stem and press and release the test button to train the RF tire pressure sensor. 8. NOTE: Do not wait more than 2 minutes between training each sensor or the SJB will time out and the entire procedure must
be repeated. Repeat Step 7 for the RR and LR tires. The procedure is completed after the last tire has been trained. When the training procedure is complete the message center (if equipped) will display TIRE TRAINING COMPLETE. For vehicles not equipped with a message center successful completion of the training procedure will be verified by turning the ignition switch to the OFF position without the horn sounding. If the horn sounds twice when the switch is turned to the OFF position the training procedure was not successful. 9. Using the scan tool locate the updated TPMS sensor identifiers trained to the SJB and document them. 10. NOTE: This step is required to clear DTC C2780 cause the SJB to exit the manufacturing mode and to make sure there are no other concerns with a newly programmed SJB. If the sensors are being trained due to the installation of a new SJB clear any DTCs and carry out the SJB On-Demand Self Test. It’s still a Mustang, but it has definitely changed since the 60’s There have definitely been changes in this vehicle since the ‘60’s. And we haven’t
even touched the diagnostic trouble codes, changes in the drivetrain, or even the number of exterior colors available. We might have been able to set the points and timing on the ’65 without OE technical information, but you cannot work by memory on today’s version of the Mustang, or any other vehicle for that matter. You definitely need the proper OE technical information.
©2010 ALLDATA LLC. All rights reserved. All technical information, images and specifications are from ALLDATA Collision. ALLDATA is a registered trademark and ALLDATA Collision is a mark of ALLDATA LLC. All other brand names and marks are the property of their respective holders.
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 27
Ed Attanasio is an automotive journalist based in San Francisco, California. He can be reached at era39@aol.com.
Shop Showcase
Car West Elite Hits its Numbers After One Year in Business with Ed Attanasio
Car West Auto Body has six locations in Northern California fixing approximately 1,200 cars monthly combined, but the company’s prize gem is its 52,000-square foot shop in Fremont, CA. The facility employs 35 people and contains approximately $1.8 million in equipment alone, making it one of the largest body shops in the entire Bay Area.
Car West Elite Auto Body operates from a huge facility in Fremont, Calif.
They call it Car West Elite Auto Body, and tout it as a premium auto body shop— and when people see it for the very first time, it’s hard to disagree. It’s an enormous undertaking with thousands of moving parts, but Craig Moe, the president of Car West Auto Body, is reporting respectable numbers from his Fremont location after just one year in existence. Many people said Moe was crazy for opening a big shop in April ’09 in the midst of a deep recession, but it now looks like a sage move, because the Fremont facility is fixing 175 cars per month and adding more all the time. “We figured it would take us at least a year to get ramped up to where we we’re making money and we’ve done that,” Moe told Autobody News. “For the first couple of months, we were doing 35–50 vehicles per month and now we’re just under 200. We’ve already reached its minimum capacity to make money, so it’s worked out very well. It’s not like we came here thinking we’d have to start all over. We knew we were going to get a fair amount of business at the start, because we had been doing all the collision work for Magnusssen’s Lexus of Fremont out of our Dublin location. We were running the Dublin shop 24/7, so it was logical to move that work to Fremont when we opened.” Shop Manager Brian Hobaugh brought his key employees from Dublin to work at their Fremont shop so that they could hit the ground running when it opened. “We took most of the top people from our Dublin facility so that we could immediately start servicing the Mag-
nussen’s Lexus located in the Fremont Auto Mall. The entire purpose of building this shop was to be closer to the dealership. The transition has worked well and we’re pleased with the results. The service to Magnussen’s was uninterrupted and fairly seamless, which was our goal.” In the meantime, Car West’s Dublin facility has re-ramped up their volume quickly through targeted marketing and by reaching out to the area. “We’ve extended our market reach in Dublin now by adding more and insurance DRPs and we’re also getting a lot of referral business from the dealerships in the area. We have Dublin back to where it was before we opened the facility in Fremont.” Hobaugh is enthused about the results he’s seen within just one year of operation at the company’s Fremont mega-shop, he explained. “Craig essentially said, ‘we’ll build it and they’ll come’ and it’s worked out that way. Once people see this shop, they want to work with us. It speaks for itself.”
thing without everybody’s input. We made sure that everyone contributed feedback, from the technicians, mechanics, painters and management. And I believe we did everything right. I think we nailed it.” By implementing a production system where techs work in teams and help each other when needed, Car West Elite is operating smoothly, hitting their cycle times and putting out the type of quality they’re always thriving for, Moe said. “The shop is very efficient. We wanted to create a facility where our customers would always want to bring their cars here. We wanted to carry the same high-end look and approach throughout the entire shop. I’ve seen some impressive shops where the front end of the facility is really nice, but when you get into the actual shop itself, that’s where they try to save money. We didn’t cut back in any aspect of this shop and it’s paid off.” To get their name out there, Car West Auto Body showcases their Fremont shop
mont area to their list of customers. “We’re adding DRPs and we have several more in the works. We’re very close to the Fremont Auto Mall and we’ve always been working with Magnussen’s Lexus, but we’ve now also added Fremont Chevrolet and are now working Jaguar, Volvo, Nissan, and Land Rover—all from the Auto Mall,” Moe said. Being a multi-shop operation (MSO) has helped Car West Auto Body in acquiring insurance business, Moe said. “It’s a model that many insurance companies prefer, I believe,” he said. “They want one point of contact with a company like ours, so that if there are any changes to their program or administrative procedures they need to deal with, they don’t have to call six different people. It’s convenient and the insurance companies are leaning toward that model more and more.”
Car West Elite prides itself on a high profile reception area that impresses customers and vendors alike.
Body techs work in teams and support each other within the production system implemented at Car West Elite Auto Body.
Car West Elite is Moe’s dream shop, containing all of the bells and whistles he began to envision many years ago. “This is my first opportunity to build a shop from the ground up, so to speak. We had a shell, but when it came to the complete layout— the overall design, the equipment we put into it and exactly how it was going to be set up—including the lean processes and everything—we did it all from scratch. We basically started with a blank piece of paper and we didn’t want to make any mistakes. Moe traveled throughout the state to look at other cutting-edge shops before designing his own, he said. “We looked closely at some of the top body shops in California and researched all of the best equipment. Then, we had many, many meetings with employees and vendors. The worst thing you can do is build some-
28 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
whenever they can. “Part of our marketing involves using the shop for meetings, luncheons and training sessions for insurance companies, I-CAR classes, and for equipment vendors to promote the facility and the industry as a whole. We’ll do whatever it takes to get exposure for this shop and to get people to see what we’ve done,” Moe said. What will the immediate future look like for Car West? “Things will get better,” Moe said. “From what I’ve seen, we’ve already hit the bottom of this recession, so we’re excited about growing and pushing to capacity. We’re doing only 25% of what this shop can produce. Our goal is 700 cars per month and I believe we can get there.” To feed their plus-sized shop, Car West Elite has added several insurance DRPs and local car dealerships in the Fre-
Moe also thinks the number of body shops in the Bay Area will shrink considerably more within the next year, he said. “We’ve seen a lot of car dealerships close within the last 18 months, so it logically means that more body shops could close their doors as well. There are shops out there right now that are probably out of business, but they just don’t know it or haven’t admitted it yet. The problem in this business is that you have to keep investing in newest equipment and adapting to servicing the insurance companies the best way you can. We decided a long time ago to gear our key performance indicators (KPIs) toward dealing with the insurance companies. They’re always looking at our cycle times, days and hours touch time and customer satisfaction numbers, so we’re specifically gearing ourselves to what the insurance companies are looking for.” Car West Elite Auto Body 4311 Solar Way Fremont, California 94538 (510) 657-3300 Shop Manager Brian Hobaugh 52,000-sqaure-foot facility
CA Insurance Commissioner Says Mercury Illegally Overcharged Consumers
Inquiry also finds insurer failed to cease illegal acts despite previous agreements to do so
California Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner announced today that an examination found that Mercury Insurance has violated the state insurance statutes and as a result, Mercury Insurance may have illegally overcharged thousands of Californians for auto and homeowners insurance. “As the head of the state’s largest consumer protection agency, I must ensure that insurance companies fulfill their obligations and follow state law,” said Commissioner Poizner. “However, an examination done by the Department of Insurance appears to show that Mercury Insurance has disregarded California’s consumer protection statutes and overcharged consumers. In addition, the Department’s examination finds that Mercury Insurance has apparently continued to violate the law despite agreements with the state to terminate its illegal behavior.” The California Department of Insurance (CDI) conducted a Market Conduct Exam covering the period of March 1, 2007 to May 31, 2007. During that timeframe, CDI found that Mercury Insurance Group, comprising Mercury Insurance Company, Mercury Casualty Company and California Automobile Insurance
Company, violated the insurance code, resulting in consumers being overcharged or denied coverage. The 35 categories of alleged violations include: Mercury Insurance failed to correct violations of state law indentified by the Department of Insurance from exams conducted in 1998 and 2002. Mercury did not collect the right information about a driver’s prior accidents during its auto insurance application and underwriting process to make sure that surcharges are only applied for those accidents where the insured is at fault, and to make sure people are not charged for bodily injury accidents when no injuries had occurred. The auto insurance applicant is required by Mercury Insurance to provide “lifetime” experience regarding certain major convictions, while the law only allows insurers to charge for such convictions for “10 years” for specific alcohol-related offenses and “three years” for the others. Homeowners’ insurance premium credits were not being consistently applied when they were due, resulting in insureds being overcharged. Mercury’s auto insurance non-renewal notices and procedures required the Good Driver to take additional steps, beyond what is provided for in the law, to obtain cover-
age when another person on the policy no longer qualified for coverage. Mercury’s auto insurance underwriting guidelines required individuals with certain medical impairments to undergo additional underwriting scrutiny before a policy could be issued. Mercury barred from coverage people in certain occupations -- Bartender, Liquor Store Owner, Painter, Cocktail Waitress/Waiter and Artists – who didn’t meet additional underwriting standards that were not applied to people in other occupations. Mercury Insurance Group has 10 days to correct each violation found in the latest exam. Should the violations not be corrected, Mercury Insurance Group faces a $5,000 fine for each violation and an additional $5,000 fine for each violation if it is found to be willful. The insurer also faces additional penalties for the past violations, and its failure to implement corrections following the previous exam. In an unrelated incident, protesters showed up at a booksigning by Poizner for his new book, “Mount Pleasant.” They objected to passage in which Poizner says he knew he shouldn't expect “Silicon Valley-caliber ambition and smarts from East San Jose schoolkids.”
Mercury Says Poizner’s Interests are Only Political
Mercury was quick to point out that Commissioner Poizner is seeking the Republican nomination for California governor. The company stated that “political interests” were at play in the department’s announcement. Poizner's own spokesman acknowledged that making such a big announcement about such violations was unusual, but Poizner's office argues that the company has repeated violations it had previously agreed to fix. Mercury is the $3.5 million main backer of Prop. 17, a November ballot initiative that would allow transferable “loyalty discounts” for drivers who change carriers, but the rates would not apply to those who let their insurance lapse. Prop 17 would create an insurance surcharge on drivers, including soldiers and seniors, who have had a lapse in car insurance coverage for virtually any reason during the past five years, or who missed a single payment. Under the measure, people who stopped driving and didn't need insurance for a time would be required to pay up to a $1000 more for car insurance when they sought to restart coverage. Currently, insurance companies are prohibited from imposing such a surcharge in California (see p. 18).
A Work Of Art.
MIKE CALVERT TOYOTA www.mikecalverttoyota.com • Overnight Delivery ry in Most Areas of TX & LA • Volume Discountss ng • One-Stop Shopping Local
(713) 558-8272 Fax
(713) 558-8131
Isn’t it time others see her the way you see her?
Toll Free
Fiberglass Quarterpanel Extensions. Replica Plastics of Dothan designs, tests and manufactures over 400 quality parts for GM cars including Buick, Cadillac, Oldsmobile, Pontiac and Chevrolet. Our affordable quarter panels install in minutes, without having to remove the rear bumper, and come with a full lifetime warranty. Contact us today for a complete listing of parts and prices.
1-800-527-5368 Download at www.CollisionLink.com
2333 S. Loop West • Houston, TX 77054
P.O. Box 1147 • Dothan, Alabama 36302 P: 800-873-5871 F: 334-792-1175 W: replica-plastics.com E: stone@ala.net www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 29
Industry Insight
John Yoswick is a freelance writer based in Portland, Oregon, who has been writing about the automotive industry since 1988. He is the editor of the weekly CRASH Network (for a free 4-week trial subscription, visit www.CrashNetwork.com). He can be contacted by email at jyoswick@SpiritOne.com.
Insurers And Shops Don’t Always Speak The Same Language with John Yoswick
On its surface, the proposal seems fairly straight-forward. “Word-tracks used to offer repair shop referrals to consumers should not include comments, remarks or statements that disparage any collision repair business,” the proposal, crafted last year by the Collision Industry Conference (CIC) Trade Practices Committee, reads. “When a consumer voices their shop selection, their decision should be honored without further comment. Repairers should also refrain from making any comments that disparage an insurer, direct repair program or other repair facilities.” But during a recent panel discussion at CIC about how this and other trade practice proposals might get implemented, it became clear that shops and insurers aren’t always speaking the exact same language. One man’s “steering” is another man’s “consumer education.” “I’m not sure what this statement is intending to provide,” Allstate’s Randy Hanson said, a statement echoed by some other insurance company representatives on the panel. “If you’re trying to say,’ Follow the law and play nice,’ we do that. But I suspect there are other issues this is trying to get at, and this statement doesn’t do a lot for me in terms of what that is exactly.” Industry consultant Lou DiLisio spoke for many collision repairers when at CIC he voiced frustration with insurers’ view of the issue. “It’s the implementation and execution of those word tracks, and it’s what gets done when there’s something identified that’s out of place,” DiLisio said. “Whet gets done when I call up and say, ‘Your word track was deviated from…’ What gets done? Unfortunately, nothing.”
Steering vs. education The panel discussion organized by the “Insurer-Repairer Relations Committee” at the latest CIC meeting focused on just two of the first five proposals developed by the “Trade Practices Committee.” Hanson wasn’t alone in portraying the word tracks and other information used to describe a direct repair program as “consumer education.” “We should have the right to inform the consumer about the process,” Michael Lloyd of California Casualty said. “In some states, once the customer voices a choice of shop, that’s where it stops, and I’m good with that. But there are other states, like California, which recently passed a regulation that says we have the
right to explain our program to our customers. We’re going to honor their choice of shop, but I agree with that law that we should have the ability to make sure the consumer is informed.” Joe Laurentino of Esurance told DiLisio that he doesn’t think his company’s employees stray from the company’s word tracks when talking to consumers about shop choice. “I won’t say it doesn’t ever happen,” Laurentino said. “But the vehicles we fix today are highly complex. We need to make sure they get to the repairers who can fix the car properly and by the OE specifications.” If there are concerns about the wording used by an Esurance employee, Laurentino told DiLisio, “I would personally address that if you call me with the claim number.” Hanson said as more and more claims calls are handled by call centers, there is “strict adherence to the script,” scripts that Allstate has made available to the Automotive Service Association for feedback (and to which Allstate responded with some changes, he said). In response to a question, he said there is no financial incentive for call center employees to get a certain percentage of customers to use a Allstate direct repair program shop. Hanson argued against state laws that limit an insurer’s right to discuss the program even with a consumer who has a shop in mind. “What about the customer who comes back and says, ‘How come you didn’t tell me you had this program?’” he said. “I entertain a lot of those calls. That’s a difficult conversation too because I have to tell them I can’t tell them. They don’t understand that. They don’t understand that there’s a law that says I can’t inform them.” But Aaron Schulenburg, executive director of the Society of Collision Repair Specialists (SCRS), challenged the idea that insurers are consistently adhering to scripts and honoring customers’ shop choice. “Otherwise, I and the other association leaders in the room wouldn’t get calls on a regular basis from shops who say, ‘I had a customer. I had their keys. I had their car. I had a signed authorization, and the car got towed out because of what they were told,’ “ Schulenburg said. “That happens. Often. And there’s a lot of customers who quite frankly aren’t willing to fight. If the customer doesn’t have the time or energy in invest in fighting it and moving up the ladder and meeting the (insurance)
30 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
manager and going to their department of insurance, at the end of the day they’ll throw their hands up and say, ‘Fine, tow it out and take it where you need it.’”
Dispute resolution The panel also discussed another of the “Trade Practices Committee” proposals, which calls for insurers to make available their DRP agreement guidelines and key performance metrics, and to “publish the intended field application of the program’s policies, guidelines and metrics, along with a process for handling potential misunderstandings or deviations from company policy.” As with the word track proposal, this idea got a mixed reception from insurers on the panel. Hanson said Allstate includes a copy of its direct repair program contract on its website. Lloyd said California Casualty already makes standard operating procedures available to its direct repair shops through its website. “But as far as posting that (DRP) agreement to everyone, that’s not going to
happen,” Lloyd said. “Hopefully our agreements give us some kind of competitive advantage. I guess that would be the main reason I just don’t see it happening.” Laurentino said his company’s legal department won’t allow Esurance direct repair agreements to be openly published. But several shop representatives on the panel said the actual terms of the DRP contracts are not as much the issue as inthe-field policies and procedures being interpreted or implemented differently by staff even within the same insurance company. “When we believe there’s a deviation in the field, when a policy is being applied differently than, as I understand, corporate intended it, where do we go to bring that to somebody’s attention, to have some resolution of the issue,” Bill Lawrence of LC Automotive Group asked the insurers on the panel. Joe Lacy of GEICO said in those instances a shop should contact a supervisor for a clarification. Lloyd said his company See Insurers and Shops, next page
Chevyland NEED GM PARTS? YYou’re in good hands hands. Gift Cetrraitin fipucrcahatese. with power details. Call for
LLargest argest Larg arge est st Inventory Inventory in in Tri-State Tri-State Area! Area! We deliver to TX, OK and LA.
51,855 Part Numbers Order in by 5pm, Arrives Next Day 7:00am - 6:00pm M-F
800-551-8189
Online Parts Look-ups Jeral Lawler, Parts Mgr. We price match! Call for quote.
(318) 425-3417 - (318) 425-1705 Fax
Bud Nelson — Customer Relations Representative Ron Gleason — Customer Relations Representative 7500 Youree Dr., Shreveport, LA 71037
www.chevyland.com
El Paso, TX, Body Shop is Target of Attorney General Lawsuit
An east El Paso body shop is facing serious allegations of lying to customers, according to a lawsuit filed by the Texas state attorney general and the El Paso County Attorney’s Office. The suit alleges Jacob’s Body Shop, previously known as Gemini’s Body Shop, and its owner Veronica Quiroz took money for repairs promising new parts had been installed. According to the suit, subsequent inspections revealed that on various occasions the parts actually were used and second-hand.”If you're driving with parts that already have 200,000 miles on them or have been used extensively, sure, it could be a safety issues,” said Ralph Girvin, an assistant El Paso county attorney.In at least one case, an inspection revealed the car in question was not deemed unsafe to drive. The suit is requesting up to $20,000 per incident from Quiroz. “Gemini’s Body Shop would charge the consumer a fee of $500. If the consumer could not pay the price of this exorbitant fee, Gemini's Body Shop would refuse to release the vehicle,” said an affidavit of Ray Niblett, an agent with the National Insurance Crime Bureau.
AAA Oklahoma Gave Consumers Crash Prevention Course
AAA Oklahoma offered Enid, OK, its first vehicle crash prevention course on April 24. The seven-hour classroom course qualified motorists for an auto insurance discount from most insurance carriers, including AAA Insurance Co. The class was open to all licensed drivers. The course was held 9:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. April 24 at the Public Library of Enid and Garfield County, 120 W. Maine. Cost was $20 for AAA members and $30 for non-members. Mark “Safety Guy” Sprayberry, from Tinker Air Force Base, taught the course, using AAA’s newly revised “Managing Visibility, Time and Space” curriculum. Drivers learned how to simplify driving situations, improve skills behind the wheel, and reduce risk on the road. For information on future courses contact Sheryl Williams in Tulsa at (800) 222-2582 or go to www.AAA.com and click on “AAA News & Safety.” Pre-registration is required. AAA is a not-for-profit organization serving 344,000 members in Oklahoma. The club’s Enid office is at 215 W. Garriott. Call 242-7100 for information.
Genuine Parts And Accessories Making the cheap parts work takes R&R — and they don't pay you for that. So insist on using genuine Suzuki parts in the first place. It's good for both your customer and your business. Get your parts from the crash parts specialists.
Texas
Oklahoma
SAN ANTONIO
Ferguson Advantage Imports
800-985-7275
BROKEN ARROW
Cavender Suzuki
(210) 490-7160 Fax Hours: 7:30-6:00 stevemorris@cavenderauto.com www.cavenderbuick.com
800-880-8815 (918) 317-6280 Fax
Arizona Auto Glass Fraud Bill Passes State Senate 28-0 An Arizona House bill addressing auto glass businesses and insurance fraud passed the state’s Senate April 19 with a unanimous vote of 28-0. The legislation adds a section to the state’s laws addressing auto glass shops and details a number of items that are “unlawful” for those “who sell or repair auto glass.” It had previously passed the state’s House, where it originated, but one small technical amendment was made in the Senate (changing the word “advising” to “advise”), so it now returns to the House for Rep. McLain’s acceptance of the amendment and a final vote. The Senate calendar defines the bill’s purpose as follows: “Outlines unlawful practices for a person who sells or repairs auto glass and institutes a penalty of a class 6 felony for persons who violate the auto glass laws with the intent to injure, defraud or deceive an insurer.” The legislation identifies the following items as illegal: * To submit a false claim to an insurer for auto glass repair or replacement or for related services if the services were not provided, if the work appears on the invoice as being completed in an incorrect geographical area, resulting in a higher payment, if the work wasn’t authorized by the owner or lessee of the vehicle, or if the invoice was mislabeled with such a date that insurance coverage might not have applied; * To advise a policyholder to “falsify the date of damage to the auto glass that results in a change of insurance coverage for repair or replacement of the glass;” * To misrepresent the price of the repairs or replacement being billed to an insurer, or that the insurer has approved the repairs “unless the auto glass repair or replacement facility has verified coverage or obtained authorization directly
Insurers and Shops
Continued from Page 30
could be willing to put together some “generic guidelines of how we do business” but would want more input from the committee as to what topics should be covered. Hanson said he understand shops are sometimes hesitant to move up the chain of command because of possible reprisals. But he balked at the idea of some way to submit concerns anonymously or through a thirdparty or “hotline,” saying it “complicates the resolution” and often lacks enough detailed information to be “actionable.” If a problem involves some sort of fraud—such as an insurance company employee seeking some of pay-off—repairers should contact the corporate security department at that company, several of the panelists said.
from the insurance company or any other third party administrator contracted with the insurance company and the evidence has been confirmed by fax, e-mail or other written and recorded communication;” * To advise a customer that the work will be paid entirely by his/her insurer “unless the insurance coverage has been verified by a person who is employed by or is a producer contracted with the policyholder’s insurer or is a third party administrator contracted with the insurer;” * To add to the damage of the auto glass prior to the work being done, or to encourage a customer to do the same “to increase the scope of repair or replacement;” and * To perform work “clearly and substantially beyond the level of work necessary to repair or replace the auto glass to put the vehicle back into a safe predamaged condition in accordance with accepted or approved reasonable and customery glass repair or replacement techniques.” In addition, the legislation includes a section making it illegal for an auto glass business representative to “misrepresent the relationship of the glass repair facility to the policyholder’s insurer.” The bill originally was introduced by Arizona Rep. Nancy McLain, who advised at a recent hearing that she introduced the bill “to try to get rid of some outright fraud that’s going on in the windshield repair business.” Representatives of the Arizona Glass Association, including Rex Altree of New Image Auto Glass and Kerry Soat of FasBreak, both of which are based in Arizona, worked closely with legislators to reach an agreed-upon wording in the bill. To read background on the bill and its journey to passage, see www.glassbytes.com and www.autobodynews.com
But panelist Mike Condon, one of the consultants that conducted a study last year to examine the viewpoints of top auto claims personnel, offered perhaps the most optimistic viewpoint on hopes for at least one aspect of the trade practice proposal. “It was clear that most insurers wanted, or were interested in, some sort of dispute resolution process, but none of them really had any idea of how to do it,” Condon said of the interviews in the study with top claims personnel at nine major insurers. He said the fact that no such mechanism exists could provide a good opportunity for the industry to work together to develop one, rather than having a number of different ones pop up. “What we need to start is probably to develop requirements from insurers as to what it might look like,” Condon said.
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 31
Suppliers Partnership Adds Five New Corporate Members
SP is a partnership between automobile original equipment manufacturers and their suppliers and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). SP Work Groups address issues that improve the environment while providing value throughout the automobile supply chain. SP provides a forum for small, mid-sized and large automotive and vehicle suppliers to work together, learn from each other, and share technologies and environmental best practices. The Suppliers Partnership for the Environment (SP) announced April 19 that five companies have joined the organization: AGS Technology Inc., Arcalis Scientific, LLC, Green Tree Products & Technologies LLC, Lear Corporation and TestAmerica Laboratories, Inc. In addition, the State Government of Victoria, Australia, will be joining SP as a liaison member. SP Chair Randy Leslie, Vice President and General Manager, Johnson Controls, Inc., Automotive Experience, stated, “These company additions to SP will enhance the organization as a whole, and provide more opportunities for the organization to improve environmental and economic excellence, while sharing best practices to improve individual company performance.”
Adam Westerdale, COO of General Oil Company and Chair of SP's Membership Development Committee added, “We are excited to have these companies working with us and a new liaison member to SP. In addition, we are particularly pleased to welcome back one of our founding members, Lear Corporation.” The new member companies' representative to the SP Board of Directors will be: * AGS Technology Inc.: George Staniulis, Vice President * Arcalis Scientific LLC: Pat Beattie, President * Green Tree Products & Technologies LLC: Sam Cremin, Managing Director * Lear Corporation: Barbara Boroughf, Vice President, Global Environmental, Health & Safety * TestAmerica Laboratories, Inc.: Dave Lanzola, National Account Manager Steve Hellem, Executive Director of SP states, “We look forward to working with these new companies, and continuing our pursuit of environmental excellence and the economic viability of the automobile supply chain.” More information about SP can be found at www.supplierspartnership.org.
PPG Chairman Charles Bunch Reports on New Strategy
At the company's recent annual meeting, PPG Industries’ Chairman and CEO Charles Bunch reviewed steps the company took in 2009 to respond to the global financial crisis that began at the in 2008 and continued through 2009. “The strategic vision we have established is to continue to be the world’s leading coatings and specialty products company,” Bunch said. “We have continued to make progress toward achieving that vision. Yet, in 2009, we were clearly challenged with an uncertain and difficult global economy. At PPG, we responded quickly and decisively.” Bunch said that during 2009, PPG shifted its priorities to respond to the difficult economic conditions. “We placed greater emphasis on operating discipline. We worked on restoring margin leadership, especially in the coatings industry. We focused more on profitability than pure growth. We took steps to improve our cost structure, and we worked to leverage our global technological and manufacturing capabilities to the most efficient use of the entire company. We keyed in on costs, margins, working capital and cash flow,” he said. Bunch also noted two restructuring initiatives—one announced in September 2008 and one in March 2009 – that are
expected to result in approximately $250 million in annual cost savings once completed. “In addition to our cost-cutting measures,” Bunch said, “PPG benefited from actions it has taken over the past several years to grow the coatings and optical and specialty material components of our portfolio.” He said that the proportion of PPG’s sales in these businesses has grown substantially over the past few years. “These businesses saw continuously improving positive momentum throughout the year, and by the end of 2009 were delivering higher year-overyear earnings,” he said. Bunch commented that the company also benefited from efforts to broaden the geographic reach of its business, and specifically its expanding footprint in the Asia/Pacific region, which posted record earnings for the year and now represents about 15 percent of the company. “Overall, our efforts to transform PPG have served us well in this downturn,” Bunch said. In 2009, PPG posted sales of $12.2 billion, a decrease of about 23 percent versus the prior year. This was largely attributable to the contraction of demand in many of PPG’s key end-use markets, which in turn was driven by the global recession.
32 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
Administration Continues Push for Accident Prevention
The U.S. Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works held a hearing April 14 titled, “Opportunities to Improve Transportation Safety.” U.S. Sen. Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., is the chairwoman of the committee. She and Sen. James Inhofe, ROkla., ranking member, gave opening remarks. Discussed at the hearing were options that could further reduce fatalities on America's highways by improving safety for all modes of surface transportation. Witnesses at the hearing included: * The Hon. John D. Porcari, deputy secretary of transportation, U.S. Department of Transportation * Kirk T. Steudle, director, Michigan Department of Transportation * Laura Dean-Mooney, national president, Mothers Against Drunk Driving * Jackie Gillan, vice president, Advocates for Highway & Auto Safety * Deb Hubsmith, director, Safe Routes to School National Partnership * Gregory M. Cohen, president and CEO, American Highway Users Alliance * Ted Miller, Ph.D., principal research scientist, Center for Public Health Improvement and Innovation In his statement about reducing accidents, Porcari told the committee,
“Innovation and technology will be critical to improving vehicle, operator and infrastructure safety. Infrastructure improvements reduce the number of crashes and the severity of crashes. They are designed to work in concert with vehicle and behavioral measures to improve driver performance and diminish severity through tools such as signage, pavement friction, rumble strips, the Safety Edge and cable median barriers. We must also explore innovative ways to reduce deaths and serious injuries caused by impaired driving, speeding, failure to wear seatbelts and motorcycle helmets, and other high risk behaviors, including distracted driving.” Porcari also noted an issue that has grown in its significance for causing accidents, “[Transportation] Secretary [Ray] LaHood is personally committed to reducing the number of injuries and fatalities caused by distracted driving - a dangerous practice that has become a deadly epidemic. Our latest research shows that nearly 6,000 people died in 2008 in crashes involving a distracted driver, and more than half a million people were injured.” The DOT will continue research emphasis on IntelliDrive technologies that help prevent accidents.
Want every job to be a bang-up job? We want to be your source for Real Volkswagen Parts. With your skill and our parts, every collision repair will be a bang-up job. And that will add up to more repeat business for both of us. Call your order in today.
TEXAS
OKLAHOMA
Boardwalk Volkswagen
Metro Volkswagen Inc.
1-800-777-9047
1-800-527-7287
RICHARDSON
FAX: 214-453-5055 www.vwoncentral.com
IRVING
FAX: 972-570-5260 parts@metrovwtx.com Brian Ellis
These dealers are Genuine VW Parts wholesale specialists.
Cable Volkswagen
O KLAHOMA CITY
1-800-522-6793
FAX: 405-789-3317
State Farm Prevails in Gunder Slander Suit; Gunder Says He Will Appeal State Farm won a summary judgement against Ray Gunder (see Autobody News, April edition) on March 26. The U.S. District judge, Steven D. Merryday, ruled that although State Farm may have made defamatory statements about Gunder’s Auto Center of Lakeland, Fla., the shop failed to prove that the insurer’s primary motive in making such statements was to harm the shop rather than further its own cause. Gunder had alleged that State Farm “intentionally and unjustifiably interfered with [Gunder’s] relationships with its customers” by falsely stating to insureds that the shop overcharged for repairs and completed repairs in an untimely, inefficient and substandard manner. The judge noted that Gunder’s Auto Center was terminated from State Farm’s DRP program in 2004, and case records also showed that Gunder’s objected to State Farm’s method of compensating repair shops for paint and materials. To recover for slander, the plaintiff must show 1) that the defendant published a false statement; 2) about the plaintiff; 3) to a third-party and 4) the plaintiff suffered damages as a result of the publication of the statement. State Farm argued that even if State
Farm agents uttered false statements about the plaintiff, the statements are privileged. “State Farm was acting as an insurer and was communicating with the party seeking benefits under the insurance contract about an issue in which they have a common interest, the prompt and full repayment of repairs,” the court decision stated. Although the judge agreed that the communications between State Farm and claimants were privileged, he noted that they could still be Ray Gunder considered slanderous if Gunder’s could prove State Farm acted with “express malice,” meaning, “ill will, hostility or evil intention to defame and injure.” However, the court ruled that “The plaintiff fails to provide extrinsic evidence of express malice.” The Florida Supreme Court defined “express malice” as follows: Where a person speaks upon a privileged occasion, but the speaker is mostly motivated more by a desire to harm the person defamed than by a purpose to protect the personal or social interest giving rise to the privilege, then it can be said that there was
express malice and the privilege is destroyed. Strong, angry or intemperate words do not alone show express malice; rather, there must be a showing that the speaker used his privileged position to “gratify his malevolence.” Ray Gunder openly discussed with the other repair shops State Farm’s method for determining the “prevailing competitive market rate” for repairing vehicles insured by State Farm. The judge said “in essence, the plaintiff alleges that State Farm began falsely accusing the plaintiff of “overcharging” customers promptly after State Farm admonished the plaintiff for attempting to set prices in the area. Although State Farm statements (if false) might be defamatory, the plaintiff offers no evidence (other than the alleged falsity of the statements) from which a juror could infer malice. The statements “do not inherently demonstrate express malice.” Gunder submitted additional affidavits from several potential and former customers who said they would have used Gunder’s for repairs had it not been for statements about the shop made by State Farm. Regarding State Farm’s claims that Gunder’s overcharges for repairs, the shop submitted proof that State Farm routinely paid for repairs at
other shops that charged rates similar to or higher than Gunder’s. When the judge ruled for summary judgement the additional affidavits were declared moot. “State Farm neither attacked the plaintiff's moral character nor accuse the plaintiff or its proprietors of violent crime; each allegedly slanderous statement concerns only the matter of common interest between State Farm and the insured—the quality and value of the plaintiff's work,” said the judge. Merryday ruled that the evidence provided by Gunder’s was insufficient and failed to show “express malice” on the part of State Farm: “The plaintiff fails to present evidence showing that State Farm’s ‘primary motive’ was to harm the plaintiff rather than to further State Farm and the insured’s mutual interest in securing timely, quality repairs to the insured’s automobile,” the decision stated. Ray Gunder has said he will appeal.
www.autobodynews.com CHECK IT OUT!
Shift into Genuine Nissan and Infiniti OEM Parts To advertise call Advertising Sales at:
800-699-8251 e-mail:
advertising@autobodynews.com
www.autobodynews.com
S80 ‘10
Your Source for Wholesale Volvo Parts Right Part. Right Price. Right Now. Trust your order to the collision parts specialists at these fine Dealers:
Texas
2010 Altima Coup
Genuine Nissan and Infiniti OEM Wholesale Parts are superbly crafted to strict quality See the standards. Use of genuine OEM Wholesale Parts is a shift in the right direction toward trouble-free repairs and quicker turnaround. The following dealers proudly stock genuine parts. Call your local distributor today!
Autobody News
OKLAHOMA
Volvo of Dallas DALLAS
800-498-7402 972-963-9750 972-963-9749 Fax
NEW
Bob Moore Infiniti OKLAHOMA CITY
800-999-1447 405-748-6091 Fax
Mon. - Fri. 7:30 - 6 ipaparts@bobmoore.com www.bobmoore.com
MISSISSIPPI
www.autobodynew
Gray Daniels Nissan South BRANDON
800-530-7989 601-948-3050 601-985-3753 Fax Mon. - Fri. 7:30 - 5:30 Sat. 8 - 2
volvo Genuine parts www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 33
It’s a Safety Marketplace and Consumers Are Buying
Car safety ratings often grab the media spotlight. Sometimes they’re published by the Institute, while other ratings are from the government or Consumer Reports. Bigger news than these periodic media splashes is the growth of the safety marketplace around the world, spurred by the availability of vehicle ratings from multiple sources. “These crashworthiness ratings aren’t in competition. One isn’t better than another,”
ed demand that was “considerably higher than originally anticipated,” A.L. Haynes of Ford told Congress in 1957. Other early indicators of car buyers’ interest in safety involve their rejection of vehicles perceived to be unsafe. Sales of Chevrolet Corvairs plummeted after 1965, for example, when Ralph Nader focused public attention on suspension problems that could lead to loss of control and rollover. Likewise, negative publicity about the easyto-damage fuel tanks on Ford Pintos led to declining sales in the 1970s.
says Institute president Adrian Lund. “The key is to look at every available source of safety information and choose a car, pickup, or SUV with top ratings across the board. These vehicles are on the market, and buyers are finding them. A new poll confirms the attention that consumers are paying to safety, factoring it into their vehicle choices. In turn, this demand puts pressure on auto manufacturers to compete in the safety marketplace. Consumer interest isn’t new: More than a half century ago, Ford officials estimated that installing optional lap belts and other safety features in 1956 models pushed sales up about 200,000. The safety belts generat-
By the 1980s, automakers were tuning in to safety and beginning to compete in the worldwide safety marketplace. A sign of this involves airbags. After waging in earlier years what the US Supreme Court dubbed “the regulatory equivalent of war” against frontal airbags (see Status Report, July 7, 1983; on the web at iihs.org), automakers began competing in the mid-1980s to put air-bags in cars ahead of federal requirements (see Status Report, Dec. 7, 1985; on the web at iihs.org). Side airbags followed at a much faster pace, beginning in the 1990s. This also is when automakers began a concerted effort to redesign vehicle seats and head restraints to provide better occu-
Reprinted from the Insurance Institute of Highway Safety, Status Report, V. 45, No. 4.
The safety ratings published by the institute, consumer reports, and the federal government aren’t in competition. One isn’t better than another. The key for any car buyer is to look at every available source of safety information and choose a vehicle with good ratings across the board. These vehicles are on the market, and buyers are finding them.
Consumers are paying attention to vehicle safety A new institute poll shows safety is a high priority among drivers
“You need all the safety you can get.” This is what a respondent to a 1992 Institute survey said when asked about factors that are important when buying a new car (see Status Report, May 23, 1992; on the web at iihs.org). The responses haven’t changed much since then. Safety still is impor tant. It’s the second most important factor, behind only quality/reliability, in both the 1992 survey and a new one conducted for the Institute earlier this year. Eighty-six percent of respondents to the 2010 survey said safety is a very important consideration. Only 2 percent said it’s not important. What’s new this year is the proportion of respondents who know about vehicle crash tests and safety ratings. Back in 1992, only the federal government was supplying such ratings, but since then the Institute and others have begun rating vehicle safety and attracting extensive media attention to the comparative results. So it’s not surprising that more than 3 of every 4 respondents to the 2010 survey said they’ve seen vehicle safety ratings. The source of such ratings isn’t uppermost in consumers’ minds. Only 30 percent of respondents could name an organization that provides ratings (Consumer Reports was mentioned the most). Only 14 percent could name the rating of their present vehicle. Yet 78 percent said they’d seen safety ratings, mostly on the internet, in magazines, or on television. Sixty-seven percent said such ratings would be very useful in purchasing a vehicle or considering what vehicle to own. These findings are in line with a 2005 survey conducted for Euro-NCAP in the Czech Republic, France, Germany, Great Britain, Italy, Poland, and Portugal. Safety and reliability were cited as the top factors in buying a car. Each was deemed important by 94 percent of EU respondents. Only 2 percent said these aren’t important. Almost half of the EU respondents overall, including more than 70 percent in Germany, said they had used or looked for information about the crash protection provided by various vehicle makes. The source of this information was fairly evenly distributed among car magazines, friends or acquaintances, and newspaper or television. The Institute’s telephone survey of 928 licensed drivers 18 and older was conducted in February 2010 by International Communications Research in Pennsylvania. The 2005 survey for EuroNCAP was conducted by Market & Opinion Research International. It involved face-to-face interviews as well as telephone polling of more than 900 adults in each of the 7 EU countries. 34 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
pant protection in rear-end crashes. Among the most important safety advancements since the 1990s are the redesigned structures of passenger vehicles. Now the fronts and sides themselves, not just the safety features inside, provide important protection in crashes. Initially pushing automakers toward this emphasis on safety was the popularity of The Car Book, a National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) brochure that compiled safety information vehicle model by vehicle model. Launched in 1980, it became the most frequently requested government publication of its time. Raising consumer interest in safety to much higher levels are the crash tests and crashworthiness ratings published not only by NHTSA but also by private organizations in the United States and worldwide. Consumers use the comparative ratings to make informed choices among cars to buy. US government was first: The 1972 Motor Vehicle Information and Cost Savings Act required NHTSA to establish a program of car crashworthiness ratings. The resultant New Car Assessment Program (NCAP), launched in 1978, isn’t part of any government regulatory program. It exists to provide consumer information, initially assigning pass or fail scores to cars based on performance in front and rear crash tests. Since then the pass/fail ratings have given way to stars, 1 to 5 depending on how well
Give your customers what they deserve... The Best. with genuine mazda parts.
a vehicle performs in front, side, and rollover tests. Now more than 30 years old, NCAP is due for some changes (see Status Report, July 24, 2008; on the web at iihs.org). The high NCAP scores most vehicles earn limit the usefulness of the ratings in distinguishing safety differences among vehicles. “We do favor changes,” Lund says, “but at the same time it’s important to recognize NCAP’s success over decades. Auto manufacturers have improved the designs of their vehicles. In particular, they’ve improved the restraint systems in modern cars to earn high NCAP ratings.” Besides NCAP, both the Institute and Consumers Union rate vehicle safety, and the ratings attract more media attention than NCAP’s. Institute crash tests routinely are covered on national news, attracting tens of millions of viewers. About 8 million people subscribe to Consumers Union publications, making the flagship Consumer Reports a top 10 magazine. Ratings expand worldwide: Comparative safety ratings aren’t confined to the US market. NHTSA’s pioneering NCAP has spawned similar programs in other countries. These include: 1. EuroNCAP, launched in 1997, is backed by 7 governments, the European Commission, and by consumer groups in every EU country. Ratings are based on occupant protection in front, side, and pole
Genuine Mazda parts are specifically designed, engineered and tested for Mazda vehicles. Customers and repair professionals prefer the quality and satisfaction that only comes from genuine Mazda parts.
Mazda 3 2010 Order your Genuine Mazda Parts from one of these trained trai tr aine ai nedd crash ne cras cr ashh parts as part pa rtss specialists rt spec sp ecia ec ialililist ia stss in your st yyou ourr area: ou area ar ea:: ea
TEXAS
Ingram Park Mazda
Kinsel Mazda
Russell & Smith Mazda
6980 NW Loop 410 San Antonio, TX
Beaumont, TX
Houston, TX
800-454-6735
800-392-1983
Fax 409-923-5856
Fax 713-664-0965
800-580-7278 Direct 210-681-6018 Fax 210-543-0739
Mon - Sat 7:30-6 fieyna@russellsmith.com www.russellsmithmazda.com
tests. There’s also a test for whiplash injury in rear impacts and a set of measures to compare the damage vehicles inflict on pedestrians in crashes. EuroNCAP boosts the ratings of vehicles with safety belt reminders, speed limiters, and electronic stability control. 2. Japan’s NCAP, established in 1996 and revised in 2001, is a government program based on front and side tests adopted from both US government and Institute tests. Japan’s side test is conducted at a
thorized by the government. A common characteristic of these NCAPs and the crash-worthiness evaluation programs run by the Institute and Consumers Union is that the tests aren’t part of any regulatory program. In fact, the idea of these tests conducted primarily for consumer information is to see which vehicles go beyond minimum governmental requirements to do a better job of protecting their occupants in crashes. For this reason, the tests generally are more demanding than
faster speed than EuroNCAP’s (35 versus 30 mph). 3. Launched in 1992, ANCAP in Australia and New Zealand is sponsored by national and state governments together with insurers and other private groups. Current tests are based on the front and side impacts conducted by EuroNCAP. 4. Also launched in 1999 is Korea’s NCAP, sponsored by the Ministry of Construction and Transportation. Tests include not only front, side, and rear configurations but also brake and rollover tests. 5. The world’s newest NCAP is in China, where the basis of the ratings is a regimen of front and side tests. This program is run by the China Automotive Technology & Research Center, an independent group au-
those required to comply with safety regulations established by governments in the United States and elsewhere. Ratings influence automakers: Providing consumer information is the primary, but not the sole, purpose of rating vehicles for safety. The ratings also pressure automakers to manufacture safer cars. As a former Ford executive put it, the ratings “provide information we have to address. Our customers are paying attention.” The hard evidence that automakers heed the ratings is the overall improvement in scores. NCAP was first, compelling manufacturers to improve vehicle restraints. Another example involves the Institute’s frontal offset crash tests. When the first set of results of this program became public in the
Knowing that consumers factor safety into their decisions about which vehicles to buy, auto manufacturers rush to advertise any safety honor associated with their products.
WHOLESALE COLLISION PARTS
Pictured:
2006 SL600 Roadster
Qualified Mercedes-Benz Parts Pros are available now. OKLAHOMA
Mercedes-Benz of Oklahoma City Nationwide Toll Free
1-800-657-2582 (405) 272-1737 FAX Drop Ship Available
mid-1990s, poor performers outnumbered huge (see Status Report, April 17, 2008; on good ones (see Status Report, Dec. 2, 1995; the web at iihs.org), but the features are relon the web at iihs.org). But this has turned atively new. They aren’t on most models yet, around, and it’s the rare new car design that so their effectiveness hasn’t been quantified. doesn’t earn a good rating based on the same The Institute is working on this. test. So successful is this program that the “If our evaluations find that some of Institute has looked for ways to get out of the newer features are reducing crashes, the business of frontal offset crash testing al- we’ll report this and look to factor it into our together (see Status Report, March 29, 2006; vehicle safety ratings,” Lund promises. on the web at iihs.org). Other organizations are headed in the same “Everybody who has been rating vehi- direction, seeking to expand the amount and cle safety for years has a similar success quality of safety information available to story,” Lund says. “The scores improve over consumers worldwide. time, and sometimes very quickly. This wouldn’t happen over and over again if con- Defects Versus Safety Ratings sumers weren’t paying enough attention to Safety ratings indicate how well a car prothe ratings to make automakers take notice.” tects its occupants in a crash, compared with Real-world data complement tests: other models. The tests on which the ratings Besides vehicle ratings based on controlled are based sometimes reveal safety defects tests, information is available about the on- but aren’t designed to do so. Ferreting out the-road safety experience of hundreds of vehicle design defects that jeopardize safety passenger vehicles. For example, the Insti- and deciding what to do about them are the tute publishes death rates by vehicle make work of the National Highway Traffic and model (see Status Report, April 19, Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) Office of 2007; on the web at iihs.org). The affiliated Defects Investigation. Highway Loss Data Institute compares ve- “If one of our crash tests finds a defect, we hicle loss experience under 6 insurance cov- report it to NHTSA. We also tell the autoerages, including 3 related to injuries. Both maker, who might elect to fix the problem the insurance statistics and the death rates voluntarily and initiate a recall. If we believe are adjusted for driver age and other factors a proposed fix will solve the problem, we rethat could influence the results. port the findings to consumers and let them “This real-world information comple- know that our published ratings apply only ments the crash test results. Each kind of to vehicles that have been fixed. This has information has its strengths,” Lund ex- happened a number of times,” says Institute plains. “The tests take the driver factor president Adrian Lund. completely out of the comparisons among By the same token, the Institute would vehicles, focusing on design differences downgrade the crashworthiness rating of a that influence safety. The real-world re- vehicle that isn’t fixed. This virtually never sults are useful, too, because they indicate happens, though, because disclosure is such what’s going on out on the road. The idea a powerful incentive. Automakers usually is to pick vehicles with good test results hurry to fix any problems the Institute unand good real-world experience, too.” covers in its tests. Future of vehicle safety ratings: So Most safety defects aren’t uncovered in far ratings worldwide indicate primarily ve- crash tests conducted by the Institute or hicle crashworthiness — that is, how well a any other group. Most such problems are vehicle protects its occupants in collisions. A revealed by consumers who report probcouple of years ago the Institute added the lems to NHTSA. The agency monitors availability of electronic stability control to complaints, looking for trends indicating the criteria to earn its highest award, TOP that a serious defect might exist, and then SAFETY PICK, and the following year Eu- opens an investigation when a trend indiroNCAP began factoring this feature into its cates this step is warranted. NHTSA is ausafetyPictured: ratings. thorized to order automakers to recall The 2006 addition marks a new direction be- vehicles and make repairs, based on invesSL600 stability control isn’t about tigations indicating serious safety probcause electronic Roadster It’s designed to help driv- lems in a vehicle’s design, construction, crashworthiness. Qualified or ers maintain control in emergencies and performance. Mercedes-Benz avoid crashing in the first place. Thus, more “Think of crashworthiness ratings as Parts Pros recent ratings of vehicle safety reflect not general information about car safety, and are available now. only crashworthiness but also how well a then consult NHTSA about specific safety vehicle can help a driver avoid a crash. recalls,” Lund concludes. “Make sure a veO K hicle L Ayou’re H Othinking M A of buying hasn’t been This may be the direction of the future, as more crash avoidance features are added recalled or, if it has, the problem has been to cars. Their potential to reduce crashes is fixed. Then it should be okay.”
WHOLESALE COLLISION PARTS
Mercedes-Benz of Oklahoma City Nationwide Toll Free
1-800-657-2582
These days automakers mostly advertise the crash test ratings of their safest ve(405) 272-1737 FAX hicles, but before such ratings became ubiquitous some automakers advertised Drop Ship Available the real-world experience of their cars. For example, General Motors ran an annual ad toutIng the better-than-average insurance loss experience of its product line. The 1981 ad shown above ran in more than 330 newspapers and magazines as part of what GM described as “a continuing effort to emphasize the quality” of its products. www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 35
This article first appeared in the I-CAR Advantage Online, which is published and distributed free of charge. I-CAR, the Inter-Industry Conference on Auto Collision Repair, is a not-for-profit international training organization that researches and develops quality technical education programs related to collision repair. To learn more about I-CAR, and to subscribe to the free publication, visit http://www.i-car.com.
I-CAR Tech
Aluminum Roof Replacement On The Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution And Outlander
The use of dissimilar metals together in roof panel is ready to be separated from one area of the vehicle structure, and the the body at the bonded locations. To asattachment methods used with those mate- sist in the removal process, heat can be rials, can affect damage analysis and repair used in the bonded area of the damaged versus replace decisions. Two models from panel with a flameless heat source up to Mitsubishi that require these considera- 204°C (400°F). As the adhesive gets tions are the Lancer Evolution and Out- warmer, its strength and bond will lander. weaken. Heating above 204°C (400°F) The Lancer Evolution and Outlander may weaken high-strength steels and aluare equipped with an aluminum roof, on minum. The lower center roof bow on the models without a sunroof (see Figures 1 Lancer Evolution, and the inner side roof with Amaradio Jr.on both the Lancer Evolution and and 2). On models withLee a sunroof, the rails roof panel is made from steel. On vehi- the Outlander are high-strength steel cles with an aluminum roof, the roof parts. panel is attached to steel roof rails and roof bows. Installing a Replacement Roof Panel Blind rivets and adhesives are used for the replacement roof panel attachment. The recommended rivet diameter is 4.8 mm. The adhesive used for the rivet-bonding is different from that used for the attachment areas with just adhesive. The Lancer Evolution and Outlander body repair manuals state to use Figure 1 - (Mitsubishi media photo) This 2008 Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution an epoxyayresin struchas a rivet-bonded aluminum roof panel. tural adhesive for the rivet-bonding attachAccording to the 2008–2010 Lancer Evo- ment, specifically 3M AAD Part No. 8115 lution and 2007–2010 Outlander Body Re- or equivalent. For the adhesive bonding atpair Manuals, the aluminum roof panel is tachment, a urethane body sealer, specifimade from a type of aluminum containing cally 3M AAD Part No. 08360 or magnesium, copper, and silicon. man- equivalent is recommended. with Dan The Espersen uals state that this type of aluminum has The recommended adhesives are apthe equivalent strength of cold-rolled steel plied to the appropriate locations, noted in sheets. the repair manual. The adhesive maker’s recommendations should be followed for part preparation. Roof Panel Attachment The aluminum roof panel is rivet-bonded For specific instructions, refer to the to the front, side, and rear roof rails, and vehicle maker’s technical information at bonded with adhesive alone to the inner http://www.mitsubishitechinfo.com. This sides of the front and rear roof rails and to is a subscription-based web site. Subthe center roof bow. Self-piercing rivets scriptions are available for one day, (SPRs) are used for the factory rivet-bond- seven days, 30 days, six months, or one ing attachment. year.
Amaradio Explains CRA
Consumer Callout
and Outlander models.
This aluminum roof panel replacement procedure is just one example of this type of construction technology. The I-CAR Advanced Material Damage Analysis (DAM08) course Figure 2 - (Mitsubishi media photo) This 2008 Mitsubishi Outlander has a presents additional rivet-bonded aluminum roof panel. information regarding the use of dissimpraisers and collision repair technicians ilar metals in new vehicle construction. must provide complete and accurate di- Watch for it in your area. agnosis and repairs to maintain the reliability of a vehicle structure. Damage analysis and repair versus replace deci- For comments or suggestions on the Adsions have become more challenging be- vantage Online, please contact I-CAR at cause of the increased use of dissimilar advantage@i-car.com. materials in vehicle construction, such as the rivet-bonded aluminum roof panel Photos courtesy of Mitsubishi Motors on some Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution North America, Inc.
Parts Parts you you Need. Need. People People you you Trust. Trust. Genuine Genu Ge nuin nu inee Mitsubishi in Mits Mi tsub ts ubis ub ishi is hi replacement rrep epla ep lace la ceme ce ment me nt Crash CCra rash ra sh Parts PPar arts ar ts are are close cclo lose lo se at at hand hand through tthr hrou hr ough ou gh the the following quality dealerships. They offer exceptional customer service, follllllow fo owin ow ingg qu in qual alit al ityy de it deal aler al ersh er ship sh ips. ip s. TThe heyy offer eexc he xcep xc epti ep tion ti onal on al ccus usto us tome to merr se me serv rvic rv ice, ic e, wide wid w idee id selection sele se lect le ctio ct ionn of in-stock io iinn-st nstoc st ockk parts oc part pa rtss and rt and the the experience expe ex peri pe rien ri ence en ce necessary nnec eces ec essa es sary sa ry to to ensure ensu en sure su re your yyou ourr ou repairs repa re pair pa irss proceed ir proc pr ocee oc eedd smoothly. ee smoo sm ooth oo thly th ly.. ly
ALL OEM Information
The Right Cause with Mike Causey
Roof Panel Removal Following the removal of the SPRs, the
2010 Outlander
Order your Collision Repair Parts from one of these Crash Parts Specialists near you:
Conclusion Estimators, auto physical damage ap-
Want to Contribute to this Southwest Edition?
write us! publisher@autobodynews.com
Don Herring Mitsubishi - North PLANO
800-548-3197 (972) 490-0730 Fax
#3 Volume Parts Dept. in the Nation. $600,000 Inventory.
Automaker Actions and Announcements
36 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
with your Janet Chaney Promote business with
Promote your business with
T E XA S
West Loop Mitsubishi SAN ANTONIO
800-224-1968 (210) 681-4583 Fax
M-F 7:30 am - 6:00 pm #1 Volume Dealer in All of Texas. wlparts@lonestar-auto.com
U.S. Chemical Introduces Two New 2.1 VOC Primers
U.S. Chemical & Plastics, a division of Alco Industries and a leader in repair, refinish, appearance and maintenance products for the automotive aftermarket, has added two new low 2.1 VOC primers to its line-up of refinishing products, including 2520™ DTM Primer and 2720™ 2K Urethane Primer.
DTM Primer.
Urethane Primer.
“Our 2520 is a fast drying, high build, direct-to-metal primer,” said Sharon Nixdorf, product manager. “It's ideal for use on properly-prepared bare substrates, body filler and sanded original equipment (OE) finishes. It also features outstanding filling, leveling and sanding properties and offers excellent adhesion to bare metal.” USC 2520 is available now along with 2515-4 Activator, which is specif-
ically formulated for use with the DTM Primer. The company's 2720 2K Urethane Primer is a high quality, two-component acrylic urethane that is easy to sand and can be applied to a variety of substrates. It provides outstanding fill, build and color holdout and is ideal for repairs requiring the use of low-VOC primers. USC 2720 should be used with 2715-4 Activator, which is specifically formulated for use with the 2K Urethane Primer. USC's new 2520 and 2720 2.1 VOC primers join an already extensive family of premium primers, including USC 1K Acrylic, Easywork Epoxy, Easywork 2K Urethane, Morton Eliminator HB Polyester and Morton Impact Flexible Primer/Surfacer. This diverse offering gives auto body repair professionals several options for selecting the right primer for each unique project. Founded in 1950, U.S. Chemical & Plastics is internationally recognized for formulating and manufacturing premium body filler and refinishing products. Its products are sold in more than 60 countries. U.S. Chemical & Plastics, an ISO 9001:2008 Certified company, is a privately owned corporation headquartered in Massillon, Ohio.
The Collision Parts that Fit the Best rts Order Genuine Honda and Acura Parts from the following dealersh dealerships.
‘09 Honda Acc ord
‘09 Acura TSX
They’re here to serve your collision parts needs! TEXAS David McDavid Acura Austin
800-575-3553 512-401-5976 512-401-5988 Fax
M-F 7-7 • Sat 8-5 JRayGo@mcdavid.com
ARIZONA San Tan Honda Superstore Chandler
800-765-1353
480-289-2377 Fax
M-F 7-6 • Sat 7-5 partsdistro@santanhonda.com Daily delivery to most of New Mexico and El Paso, TX.
New Revolution® Lift Line Offers Quality & Value at the Right Price
Revolution® Lift brand has a new line of vehicle lifts, from the world’s leading lift manufacturer and available throughout North America from local Rotary Lift distributors. The Revolution Lift line offers quality, safety and overall value at a competitive price. With the many economic challenges facing shops today, it’s more important than ever to buy the right equipment at the right price. In the past, shop owners have been willing to sacrifice value for low price when choosing which vehicle lifts to install, says John Rylee, director of marketing. Now they don’t have to. The Revolution line currently includes the lift models most commonly found in North American independent repair shops: two-post, four-post and specialty. The two-post lifts range in capacity from 9,000 lbs. to 12,000 lbs. Four-post lifts are available in 9,000 lb. or 14,000 lb. models. Also available are a 6,000 lb. mid-rise lift and a motorcycle lift. Technician productivity and wellbeing are paramount at Revolution Lift. All Revolution two-post and four-post lifts wear the gold label that demonstrates they have been third-party tested by ETL, and ALI certified to meet ANSI/ALI ALCTV2006 safety standards. They are manu-
factured in an ISO 9001 certified facility owned by Revolution’s parent company, Vehicle Service Group (VSG). Revolution lifts are backed by more than 85 years of lift design and manufacturing experience, plus an unmatched network of factory-trained distributors and installers who can provide convenient installation, parts and service. For added convenience, all Revolution lifts can be ordered online at www.revolutionlift.com. To learn more about Revolution Lift, contact your local Rotary Lift distributor, log on to www.revolutionlift.com or call (800) 604-3359.
About Revolution Lift Revolution Lift manufactures commercial-grade two-post, four-post and specialty lifts for use in professional automotive service facilities and at home. Revolution is the low-cost lift line you can trust. All Revolution Lift products are manufactured to the highest quality standards in ISO 9001 certified factories and feature reliable safety features as part of their design.
www.autobodynews.com
CHECK IT OUT! CA Auto Recycler Meets with Rep. Thompson in DC on R2R
F. John Azevedo and his wife Shirley Azevedo, owners of Pacific Auto Salvage Inc. in Napa County, CA, met with Rep. Mike Thompson (D-S.Helena) on March 18. The meeting was in conjunction with the (ARA) Automotive Recyclers Association Legislation Days meeting held in Washington, DC, March 17–19 2010. During the visit, ARA members presented issues that affect the Automotive Recycling Industry. The Azevedos said they were lucky to have Mr. Thompson and Jonathan Birdsong, his Legislative Director, speak with them in person; many of the members do not get to see their Representatives, only staff. During the visit, Anthony Livingston, Director of Government Affairs with ARA, addressed three major issues: 1) National Motor Vehicle Title Information System (NMVTIS); 2) National Vehicle Mercury Switch Recovery Program (NVMSRP); 3) Motor Vehicle Owners Right to Repair (HR 2057) “HR2057 is probably the biggest issue for me and my son at Pacific Auto Salvage. My son Willie Azevedo is a licensed ASE Master Automotive Technician. In order for us to provide a quality part and the solution to our customer’s transportation needs, we need to be able to accurately test the parts we
To advertise call Advertising Sales at:
800-699-8251
Left to right, Pacifice-mail: Auto Salvage owner, F. John Azevedo, Rep. Mike Thompson (D-S.Helena), advertising@autobodynews.com Shirley Azevedo and Jonathan Birdsong last month in Washington D.C. www.autobodynews.com
provide to our customers. We also need the vehicle repair information so that we can help our customers properly diagnose their automobile problems,” said Azevedo. See the NEW Small auto repair businesses say that if HR2057 does not pass the independent auto repair and auto part supply businesses like Pacific Auto Salvage will not have www.autobodynew access to the information needed to test and repair customers’ cars. There will not be any choice for the consumer, but to take their cars back to the dealer. That is not a good solution for the auto industry and the consumers. “If you can’t afford $5,000 for a new Dodge transmission and buy a rebuilt one from me for $800, you still have to have your car towed to the dealer before it will work,” Azevedo said.
Autobody News
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 37
Ed Attanasio is an automotive journalist based in San Francisco, California. He can be reached at era39@aol.com.
Shop Showcase
Marina Auto Body Melds Dealership Relationships & Selected DRPs with Ed Attanasio
Tom Williamson has owned and operated Williamson’s method of sharing emmultiple body shops over many years. He’s ployees between his two locations has discovered a formula for Ed success that in- proven to run his shops more efficiently. with Attanasio cludes a team of people whom he trusts to “We have to find economies of scale. do a great job; by building referral rela- There is not enough margin in this business tionships with new car dealerships, and by to ignore savings where we can take adcarefully choosing insurance Direct Repair vantage of them. By utilizing key employPrograms (DRPs). ees in both locations we’re able to take Williamson, 57, owns Marina Auto advantage of those resources,” he said. One of the reasons Marina Auto Body Body, with two locations in Southern California. Both shops are flourishing despite has held its own is its tenacity in improving tough economic times by building solid production processes and techniques. In partnerships, riding a strong reputation and early 2008, Marina Auto Body began using stressing customer service above every- a tracking and analysis system developed thing else. by The Fix Auto Group. This allowed the company to change the way the shops were performing, based on the information they received from their customers. “We joined Fix Auto in ’08 and they helped us open our eyes. From the data and customer feedback they made available to us, we found out who we really were as a company. We were able to determine what was missing to, not only, become better, but also compare ourselves against our peers. We found out that we were doing a good Between their two locations in Southern California, job, but not a great job each time. As a team, Marina Auto Body repairs an average of nearly 400 we made diligent and appropriate changes cars per month. and have seen better results overall.” Williamson’s Marina Del Rey locaWilliamson said the majority of Mation operates out of a 25,000 square-foot rina Auto Body’s revenue is evenly split facility, employing 39 people and repair- between working with dealerships and ining 275–300 cars per month. The other lo- surance companies. “It’s a good mix. I cation in Huntington Beach is in a 10,000 have several DRP’s and referral relationsquare-foot facility, employing ten people ships with three key dealerships (Toyota of and repairing 75 cars per month. Huntington Beach, Toyota of Marina Del “They’re two very different sizes and Rey, and W.I. Simonson Mercedes-Benz). types of businesses, but we run both of They’re our referral source in each case. them using the same principles. In the end, While these dealerships don’t have their it comes down to satisfying our customers, own collision facilities, we’re proud to act which are in three key groups—car owners, insurance companies, and the dealerships we work with. You can have the right equipment, best people, and use top techniques to fix these vehicles, but the basics all apply. It comes down to CSIs (customer service indexes) in this industry. And, it can either make you or break you.” Marina Auto Body has done remarkably well during the recession and Williamson credits that success to building A clean, comfortable customer waiting room at a strong reputation in the past decades. He Marina Auto Body in Huntington Beach keeps understands that a company is only as great clients content. as the employees who help run it and maintain credible relationships with their clients. as their preferred repair facility. They send “We’re down a little because of the us their clients and in return we purchase economy, but we are still keeping our car all of our parts for each Toyota and Mercounts high. We’re fortunate, because many cedes-Benz from them. We’re satellite opshops are having a difficult time in this area. erations for these three accounts, and it I believe one of the main reasons we’re works very well for our mutual customers.” doing well is because our team is constantly It’s a comfortable situation because, working towards improvements.” by working with a wide range of clients,
Shop Showcase
Say What?!
Say What?!
38 MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS | www.autobodynews.com
Williamson never puts too many of his eggs in one basket. “I’ve always felt like we need a blend of DRP’s and dealership work. When the dealerships are recommending us, it’s a win-win, because the customer in most cases is going to say, ‘this must be a pretty good shop and let’s take our vehicle there.’ Then, when they come to one of our shops, they see a professional operation. Immediately they notice that we all have the appropriate training, the latest equipment, and that we provide great service. After the job is completed, we follow it up with CSIs. “These dealership relationships enhance our credibility and our reputation, but then we have to deliver every time to maintain those levels. If we didn’t perform, we wouldn’t still have these great relationships with both the insurance companies and the dealerships. You’re only as good as your last job in this industry, and we know it,” said Williamson. Williamson needs to keep all of his clients happy, but he knows the car owner is the most important cog in the wheel.
“Everything is driven by customer service, bottom line. The person who brings their car into our shops has to leave here feeling beyond satisfied every time. Sure, we want our insurance partners and our dealerships happy, but what we focus on is the final user. Without their respect and positive feedback, we wouldn’t succeed. “We work with the DRP’s we’ve selected and we believe that the insurance companies we’re working with today are very pro-customer. They want their customer’s vehicles to be repaired to pre-accident condition. They’re not looking for the cheapest, but want customer satisfaction. You hear it over and over again from all of the really good carriers. It’s about policy retention and not about doing a cheap repair.” Williamson admitted that there are never easy solutions or simple answers to the questions surrounding what type of part to put on a particular car. “At times it’s an issue, because in many instances customers are bewildered when we have to call them and tell them that their insurance
Verso ‘10
TEXAS
Freeman Toyota Scion
Sterling McCall Toyota
HURST
HOUSTON
888-628-7626 817-287-5349 Fax
Mon. - Fri. 7am - 7pm; Sat. 8am - 3pm parts@toyotatime.com www.freemantoyota.com
800-231-1440 713-270-3942 Fax
Monday - Friday 7am - 7pm Saturday 7am - 4pm
These Dealers are Genuine Wholesale Parts Specialists.
Body Tech Jorge Jimenez sets up a 2010 Mercedes-Benz GLK on a Celette bench at Marina Auto Body.
company requested that they put an aftermarket or used part on a car. “I have no problem with a used part. If it’s an OE part, I have no issues selling it and we communicate that fact to the customer.
If their insurance company wants to put an aftermarket part on the customer’s car and they agree to it and it doesn’t fit, we won’t put it on their vehicle. When that happens, we’ll get the insurance company to come out and inspect. In most cases, after someone from the insurance company has seen in for themselves, they’ll then allow us to put an OE part on that car. The parts are getting better, but we still experience fit problems.” What does Williamson expect from a quality parts vendor? “The two most valuable things a vendor can bring to the table are knowledge and value. Our MercedesBenz and Toyota dealerships do an outstanding job and our relationship with them is great. Sure, quality and price are
important, but in the end there is no substitute for a vendor’s product knowledge.” Marina Auto Body has had great experiences with their parts vendors, because they shop around and find the ones that fit into their system most effectively. “If they don’t have everything you’re looking for, find a vendor that does. Our dealerships started listening to their customers loud and clear long ago, so they have the right people in their wholesale parts departments which make everything easier. They do a great job.” Continually refining and improving your business in this industry is Williamson’s final piece of advice to his fellow shop owners. “If we don’t strive to be better, we’re going to be extinct pretty
AUTOBODY MARKETPLACE
quickly. We need to do it by embracing new technology, instituting employee training to insure proper repair techniques and emphasizing customer service while keeping it a priority.”
Marina Auto Body (Orange County) 17911 Georgetown Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92647 (714) 848-3178 www.marinaautobodyhb.com
Marina Auto Body (Los Angeles) 4095 Redwood Avenue Los Angeles, CA 90066 (310) 822-6615 www.marinaautobody.com
WHEELS AMERICA
Nine Locations in the USA!
• Thousands of OEM Remanufactured Wheels in Stock • Lifetime Guarantee • CNC Quality • Powder Coated
102
888-4-FIX-RIM $109 to repair with this ad w ww .f i x ri m . co m
8’ x 8’ x 20’ Powder Oven
$18,995 Order Now At 888-770-0021
» Reduce Cycle Times » Repair More Cars » Improved Repair Technique * Ram & Pump Not Included
(916) 316.3672 www.therailsaver.com
If you’re using Waterborne Paint...
9’ x 14’ x 26’ Paint Booth $5,975
To advertise, call
800-699-8251
WHAT YOU’RE Give us yourDOING opinion on matters a Go to www.magna-trac.com
Free Crating On All Orders! Distributors Wanted
Patent Pend.
write u
- Click on Product Demo
www.autobodynews.com - Scroll Down & Click on View Video publisher@autobodyn FREE Air Drier Gun CHECK IT OUT! with Purchase!
Magna-Trac PATENT PENDING
Advertise in our CLASSIFIED SECTION for $50 per column inch! Place an ad in our Autobody Marketplace section of Autobody News. Call or e-mail now for rates:
800-699-8251 sbowling@autobodynews.com
To advertise call Advertising Sales at:
800-699-8251 e-mail:
advertising@autobodynews.com
www.autobodynews.com
The source for timely information that every body shop needs!
CALL 800-699-8251 Start Your FREE Mail Subscription.
www.autobodynews.com | MAY 2010 AUTOBODY NEWS 39
See the NEW