Success Story
Joe Castle, CEO Castle Auto Group
The No. 1 Retention Dealer in the North Central Region
Jessica Germain, Esq.
Director of Customer Experience and Employee Engagement Germain Auto Group
Castle Auto Group
Goodbye Traditional Media. Hello Top 100! How GM’s No. 1 Retention Dealer is Growing Market Share at Just $90 PVR
At 28 years old, second-generation dealer Joe Castle negotiated a deal with his father that would allow him to purchase two of his under-performing dealerships — provided he could turn them around in six months. The stores Castle were eyeing were selling less than 50 total cars per month and were, in fact, losing a combined total of $96,000 a month. Castle managed to get them turned around. In three months, the stores were selling 150 vehicles per month and generating $100,000 per month in gross profits. And he wasn’t done. From 2008 to 2014, Castle increased sales at these dealerships to more than 300 units a month.
Castle’s dealerships are located in Villa Park, Illinois, and to say that it’s a competitive market is an understatement. His stores compete with eight stores within a 10-mile radius — to put that in perspective, there are fewer Walgreens stores than Chevy dealerships within that area. There are, in fact, 87 Chevy dealerships within a onehour drive of Villa Park. Despite the heavy competition, and despite his stores starting deep within the hole, Castle’s Chevy store currently is a member of GM’s Top 100 dealerships nationwide — out of a field of more than 3,000 stores. The turnaround at Castle’s Buick GMC dealership was equally impressive, pulling into the Top 15 nationwide. In 2014, Castle Auto Group was given an award by GM for having the highest customer retention for sales to service for the North Central Region. So, how has Castle and his team managed to take these dealerships from the edge of total failure to the top of GM’s national rankings?
å Continued inSide
Success Story ä Continued froM the Cover
He reinvented his sales and marketing strategy from the ground up. Instead of relying on the old methods (that weren’t working), Castle did what many thought was impossible. He eliminated traditional media and commissioned salespeople and created a 100 percent targeted media strategy that leveraged social media to attract and convert a new generation of customers.
low-volume group, but we still had an established customer base. I knew there were lessons to be learned, so we cleaned up our database and jumped in with both feet.”
allowed us to clearly understand which ZIP codes generate the most revenue with the lowest cost per sale.
CONNECTING “THE VIRTUAL” WITH “THE pHYSICAL”
“To be successful in the future, we knew we needed to learn from our historical successes as well as our previous failures,” Castle said. “In other words, starting over did not mean starting from scratch. When I took over, we were a
The first step was to look at their geographic area and make plans for their specific situation. “We took a close look at every customer who had ever purchased or serviced at one of our stores and compared that with the historical performance of every ZIP code in our market area,” Castle said. “The next thing we did was to identify the ZIP codes within our market area that had the highest statistical probability of generating longterm, repeat customers. This process removed all the guess work because it
“Identifying our ‘perfect market’ was a big deal for us, but we still had to figure out how to reach our customers more effectively,” Castle said. “All the traditional media sources we were using — TV, newspaper, radio, etc. — were all expensive. Although they covered many of the areas we wanted to target, they also forced us to pay for a lot of areas we didn’t. We had to be more effective and we had to cut costs, so we started looking hard at digital media.”
Castle said that it was at this point, when they started asking different questions, they had the “ah ha” moment they had been looking for. “We all know that customers now shop online, but we were completely ignoring the reality that every online shopper goes home to a physical address — the “virtual” and the “physical” are connected — and we use that to our advantage.”
Castle explained that, while customers shop online, the decisions they make — where they want to buy and service their cars, for example — are strongly influenced by where they live and work. “Connecting the dots completely changed the way we were thinking and led us to our current three-part strategy,” Castle said. “First, we target based on where customers live and where they are most likely to spend
their money. Then, we connect with them using targeted and digital media. Finally, we treat our in-dealership sales and service processes as an extension of the overall customer experience.”
FINDING THE RIGHT CUSTOMERS
In order to turn dealerships that were bleeding money into profitable businesses, Castle knew that drastic action was necessary — the “old ways” wouldn’t cut
Castle auto Group
“By connecting with customers where they spend their time online, we’ve found that we can become part of their lives.” - Joe Castle, CEO Castle Auto Group
it. “Making this change was one of the scariest decisions of my life, but I did it,” he said. “We eliminated all of our traditional advertising and focused 100 percent of our efforts on targeted media”
DIALING IN DIGITAL MEDIA
Although Castle’s overall strategy uses many targeted media channels, his use of social media is especially impressive. His dealerships’ innovative approach has cultivated an amazing 46,000 Facebook fans, and his targeted social media advertising is so effective that Facebook actually outperforms Google for generating traffic to his dealership Website — which gets over 10,000 unique visitors a month. “It’s simple,” Castle said. “We have a three-part strategy that is designed to target, connect and convert.” target: “We do four types of Facebook campaigns every month,” Castle said. “Two for sales and two for service. For each, we do one branding campaign that promotes the virtues of doing business at Castle Auto Group and one set of targeted offers based on what we are promoting that month.” Castle said he found Facebook advertising has been extremely effective for his dealerships for two reasons. First, it is extremely targeted. It allows the dealerships to target by specific criteria, such as income level, gender and personal interests, while also allowing them to
focus on their targeted ZIP codes — those that have the highest income potential with the lowest cost per sale. The other reason Castle found is that Facebook advertising is exceptionally responsive. His team can start getting feedback from their campaigns within minutes. “The dashboard we use compiles all of the interactions that customers are having with our ads and puts them in one place,” Castle said. “This allows us to make edits to campaigns that are not performing up to our standards and reallocate funds to fuel to the things that are performing especially well.” Connect: “We use our Facebook page to maintain our connection with our current customers and to reinforce our social media branding campaigns,” Castle said. “The dashboard that our social media agency gives us allows us to see what customers are talking about online. We use this information to tailor the content that gets posted to our site. This helps us stay relevant and create a personal connection between new customers and our dealership.” Convert: “We use all of our social media tools to drive traffic back to our dealership Websites,” Castle said. “The results have been amazing. Facebook is our No. 1 source of Website traffic. Like many dealerships, we get a lot of traffic from Google, but Facebook has consistently generated more traffic for well over a year.” “These dealerships are living proof that social media can help a dealership not only find a customer base, but keep that base engaged and coming back in the future,” said Sean Seltzer, the CEO of SOCIALDEALER.com, the company that helped Castle shape his dealerships’ marketing strategies. “Castle Auto Group proves that new ways of thinking and marketing can provide big rewards.”
pULLING IT ALL TOGETHER
To maximize conversion on his new 100 percent digital marketing strategy, Castle completely reinvented his sales and service engagement processes, which included: •Consistently branding across all mediums, making sure that, from start to finish, everything customers see online (display ads, Facebook
ads, Website images, etc.) must match what they see when they enter the dealership. •Creating a “Super BDC” with multiple departments, which include phone, Internet and a dedicated social media team. •Changing the sales process so that customers can pre-negotiate key elements of their deals before ever setting foot in the dealership. •Replacing commissioned salespersons with “customer care advocates,” who are responsible for demoing the car, answering any questions the customer may have and doing limited negotiation. It wasn’t easy turning struggling dealerships into national showcases of success, but Castle knew that, to change what his dealerships were getting, he had to change what they were doing. Castle knows that a key to success is not only bringing new customers into the dealerships, but in retaining his existing customer base. This process begins with the opportunities he generates every month, and many of these come from social media. Having all his data in one dashboard and having a full service social media agency that does all the work makes his vision possible. “Without social media and the technology to take full advantage of it, our turnaround wouldn’t have been possible,” Castle said. “By connecting with customers where they spend their time online, we’ve found that we can become part of their lives.”
Facebook Case study To get a free copy of Facebook’s whitepaper on Castle Auto Group email: successstories@autosuccessonline.com
See video.
Success Story
Success Story MONTHLY SALES
310
ADVERTISING PVR
$672
33%
7X
DECREASE
200%
5X
20%
DECREASE
$90
48
-$96k
150
INCREASE
BEFORE
UNIQUE WEBSITE VISITORS
90 DAYS
“
BEFORE
90 DAYS
TODAY
BEFORE
90 DAYS
2,800
10,200
BEFORE
90 DAYS
Without social media and the technology to take full advantage of it, our turnaround wouldn’t have been possible.
Joe Castle, CEO Castle Auto Group
“
GROSS PROFIT
Castle auto Group
In A nutshell
Goodbye Traditional Media. Hello Top 100!
How GM’s No. 1 Retention Dealer is Growing Market Share at Just $90 PVR • Tripled overall sales in 90 days by revamping sales process and exclusively marketing to ZIP codes with highest profit potential and lowest cost per sale. • Eliminated all non-targeted advertising and implemented a 100 percent digital marketing strategy that reduced advertising per vehicle retailed from $672 to $90. • Leveraged social media platforms to increase Website traffic by 500 percent, from less than 2,000 to more than 10,000 unique visitors per month. • Increased conversion by standardizing messaging and branding across all advertising mediums • Simplified execution by using a full-service social media agency to manage all of his social media marketing and reputation management activities å read fuLL Story