03
Palm Springs resort for sale
06
Nonprofits are hurting
Minter’s menagerie grows
ARTS
02
09
Mariah Christmas!
The
www.ebar.com
Serving the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer communities since 1971
Tree of Hope inspires Keith Fong was appointed a judge on the Alameda County Superior Court.
Gay Asian law clerk named to Alameda court by Matthew S. Bajko
A
See page 7 >>
SFPD to pay $150K to trans sergeant in bias case by John Ferrannini
T
Cynthia Laird
gay Asian federal law clerk will be joining the Alameda County Superior Court, bringing the number of out judges on the East Bay bench to eight in early 2021. Governor Gavin Newsom named Oakland resident Keith Kern Fong, 58, to a vacancy on the court December 8. Fong was one of three judicial appointments to the Alameda bench that Newsom announced earlier this month. Fong, a Democrat, will fill the vacancy created by the retirement of Judge Ronni B. MacLauren. He has been a law clerk for Judge Saundra Brown Armstrong at the U.S. District Court, Northern District of California since 2009. He will be the second gay male jurist known to be serving on the Alameda County court, as Judge Tom Reardon has served on the bench for 22 years. As of the end of 2019, there were six LGBTQ judges on the East Bay bench according to the demographic data on the state’s judiciary released in March. Fong, who is of Chinese descent, will be one of at least two gay Asian male judges in the Bay Area. The other, San Francisco Superior Court Judge Roger Chan, reached out to Fong to congratulate him on his appointment and offered his support as Fong transitions onto the bench in either late January or early February. “I am just thrilled. I have so many emotions; I am excited, humbled, all of those things,� Fong told the Bay Area Reporter in a recent phone interview. “It is such an honor to serve. It is especially an honor being a gay man of color joining the bench.� Joining the Alameda bench January 4 will be Elena Condes, a lesbian and longtime criminal defense attorney who won election to a vacant judicial seat in the November 3 election. Condes, who is Latina, will be the first LGBTQ woman of color on the East Bay county court. She and her wife, Danielle Condes, live in Berkeley and have a 20-year-old daughter in college. She will serve alongside the court’s four out female judges: Jenna M. Whitman, Kimberly E. Colwell, Tara M. Flanagan, Karin S. Schwartz, and Victoria S. Kolakowski, the state’s lone out transgender jurist who is married to B.A.R. news editor Cynthia Laird.
Vol. 50 • No. 52 • December 24-30, 2020
Rick Gerharter
T
he Rainbow World Fund’s 15th annual World Tree of Hope sits in the majesty of Grace Cathedral atop Nob Hill. The tree is decorated with origami cranes that contain inspiring messages during these uncertain times. A
virtual lighting ceremony was held December 21. The Rainbow World Fund, which organizes the project, is an LGBTQ humanitarian organization that works to provide aid and advocacy around the world.
he City and County of San Francisco has reached a $150,000 settlement with a transgender police sergeant in his workplace harassment case. After Sergeant Flint Paul received genderDaisy Rose Coby affirming surgery in 2006, he was referred to SFPD Sergeant with female pronouns Flint Paul and colleagues called him by his former name, including on the police department radio, he said. Now, the city has settled with Paul – $50,000 of the money will go toward legal fees – according to court documents, and will also attempt to redress systemic transphobia. Both the San Francisco Police Commission and See page 3 >>
CA follows SF in updating LGBTQ COVID data collection by Matthew S. Bajko
C
alifornia health officials have now updated their tracking system online to include LGBTQ COVID data. It comes several days after San Francisco began asking COVID-19 test takers what their sexual orientation is in addition to their gender identity. Monday, December 21, the California Department of Public Health announced that it had moved forward on starting to track the COVID SOGI data. In an advisory to the media, it noted that “as part of its commitment to reduce health inequities and ensure the best outcomes for all Californians, the state has launched a Health Equity Dashboard on www. covid19.ca.gov that tracks California’s health equity measure and data by race and ethnicity, sexual orientation, and gender identity.� It can be found at https://covid19.ca.gov/ equity/ and the data shown is a cumulative 30-day total, updated on December 17, 2020, according to a note affixed to the charts. It also clarifies that sexual orientation and gender identity are not collected for tests. Based on the information posted, the sexual orientation information is missing from 90% of the state’s COVID cases and is missing from 93.5% of deaths. It is the opposite in terms of gender identity, with the info missing from 1.6% of cases and from 1.3% of deaths. The state website also links to a separate page with information on how health departments can better collect the SOGI data that was compiled by the National LGBTQIA+ Health Education Center at Boston’s Fenway Institute.
Courtesy YouTube
California Health and Human Services Secretary Dr. Mark Ghaly
Two weeks ago San Francisco officials had informed the Bay Area Reporter they were working with their sponsored testing provider, Color, to expand the data requested at the time of testing or during registration to ask a question about sexual orientation. It makes San Francisco one of the few municipalities in the state to be collecting the SOGI data. “SOGI data collection has been added to the city’s testing site registration through Color lab,� Clair Farley, a trans woman who is the director of the Mayor’s Office of Transgender Initiatives, informed the Bay Area Reporter December 18. According to a screen shot Farley sent to the B.A.R., those now signing up to get tested through one of the city’s testing sites will be asked: “How do you best describe your sexual orientation or sexual identity?� Options include straight or heterosexual, lesbian, gay, or homosexual, bisexual, questioning, other, or prefer not to say. A note informs people the CDPH “has requested this information to help understand the
impact the virus has across the state.� It comes prior to the question people were already being asked about what their gender identity is. The choices include “Trans Female,� “Trans Male,� or “Genderqueer/Gender Nonbinary.� “We want to thank the COVID Command Center (CCC) and the Color lab for working with us to update the city’s testing sites to include vital sexual orientation and gender identity data collection,� stated Farley to the B.A.R. “This will help us better track the impact of COVID on our LGBTQ communities and help us to address health inequities.�
Law not fully implemented
As the B.A.R. first reported in November, state and most local health officials have not fully implemented a law Governor Gavin Newsom signed in September or regulations instituted in July by Dr. Mark Ghaly, the secretary of the California Health and Human Services Agency, aimed at asking everyone getting tested for COVID-19 to be asked the SOGI questions. Last month, Farley had told the B.A.R. it was San Francisco officials’ understanding that both the regulations and Senate Bill 932 only mandated reporting SOGI data for positive test results. The city’s health department has been ascertaining the sexual orientation of people who test positive for COVID-19 via contact tracing. A few jurisdictions, such as Monterey County, are asking the SOGI questions of people when they get a COVID-19 test. But most of the state’s major metropolitan areas are not, noted gay state Senator Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco), who authored the bill. See page 7 >>
ENT PRESS SF INDEPEND ION ASSOCIAT