February 1, 2024 edition of the Bay Area Reporter, America's LGBTQ newspaper

Page 1

Hate crime case dismissed

Bi women seek office

11

'My Home on the Moon'

ARTS

05

ARTS

03

11

The Old Gays

The

www.ebar.com

Serving the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer communities since 1971

Vol. 54 • No. 5 • February 1-7, 2024

Senator Butler meets with SF youth by Matthew S. Bajko

L Courtesy Governor Newsom’s office

Bentrish Satarzadeh was appointed a Superior Court judge.

Newsom names out Assyrian Satarzadeh to Alameda bench by Matthew S. Bajko

T

he call Bentrish Satarzadeh had been waiting five years to receive came last Tuesday when she heard from Governor Gavin Newsom’s office that he was appointing her to a vacancy on the Alameda County Superior Court. In doing so, Newsom is believed to have doubled the number of Assyrians serving on the California state bench. “In Persian, there is a saying that even an old fish is a new fish when taken out of the water. It is the same as saying better late than never,” Satarzadeh, 46, told the Bay Area Reporter during a phone interview January 30 to discuss her judicial appointment. A year after becoming a court commissioner in Alameda County in 2018, where she has presided over small claims, traffic, and child support cases, Satarzadeh had applied with Newsom’s judicial appointments office to be considered for a judicial vacancy on the bench. She learned January 23 that she would be filling the seat left empty by the retirement of Judge Jacob Blea, whose sixyear term ends on January 8, 2029. “It was so thrilling to finally get this appointment,” she said. “I never felt entitled to it. So I very much had prepared myself to not ever having the position, and I was in an assignment doing child support, which I loved, and could have spent the rest of my career helping families in Alameda County.” A lesbian married mom of a 19-month-old toddler, the only person she could tell the news to until it was officially announced late Monday night was her wife, Maggie Marano, a children’s book author and executive at mental health firm Headspace. The couple, together 11 years and married since 2016, reside in Alameda. “Luckily, my daughter can’t speak very much,” joked Satarzadeh about needing to keep her appointment a secret until now. She will take her judicial oath of office Friday, February 2. Based on the court’s demographic data released last March, Satarzadeh will bring the number of LGBTQ judges on the Alameda County bench to 11. “I feel like I am floating on cloud nine. It is a surreal feeling,” said Satarzadeh, a former cochair in the early 2010s of the Alice B. Toklas LGBTQ Democratic Club based in San Francisco. With their daughter, Emma, now preschool age, Satarzadeh said her judicial appointment comes at a time that works for her family. She told the B.A.R. she is excited to bring the perspective of a parent, and the patience and humility the role requires, to the bench as a judge. “As a judge I know that it is going to be a lot more responsibility and a lot more work. Luckily my daughter is old enough to be in preschool,” she said. “We are able to leave her at preschool, and my wife is my greatest support. The timing of this judgeship couldn’t come at a better time because my family life is now organized in a way I can devote myself to this new role.” See page 9 >>

esbian U.S. Senator Laphonza Butler, during her first official community event in San Francisco as California’s junior senator, met with youth leaders January 27 at the Boys & Girls Club of San Francisco’s Don Fisher Clubhouse near City Hall. It was part of a Northern California barnstorm that also had her in Fresno on Friday. “I have a responsibility in this moment to make sure I am in service of those generations coming after me,” said Butler. “There are those who believe the biggest threat to our democracy is happening in November. I think the biggest threat is happening in high schools and colleges. That threat is their cynicism about the effectiveness of government.” Her visit to the youth services organization’s building on Fulton Street bordering San Francisco’s Hayes Valley and Fillmore districts included a private 90-minute roundtable discussion with young people from the boy’s and girl club and University of San Francisco on topics including reproductive rights, jobs, and the economy. “It was a great discussion,” said Krisabelle Zhao, 18, the Excelsior Clubhouse 2023 Youth of the Year, of the time spent with Butler. Talking about reproductive rights was particularly relevant, she added, since she wants to be an OB-GYN. The San Francisco native is currently enrolled at City College and plans to transfer to a four-year college as she pursues a career in the medical field. “I felt very privileged and honored to be given this opportunity,” said Zhao, who told the Bay Area

Rick Gerharter

U.S. Senator Laphonza Butler spoke to an audience of youth and community leaders Saturday at the Boys & Girls Club of San Francisco’s Don Fisher Clubhouse.

Reporter it was her first time meeting face to face with a U.S. senator. Afterward Butler addressed a crowd of youth and local community leaders, including San Francisco District Attorney Brooke Jenkins, followed by a brief press gaggle with local media. She noted it was her fourth such event, having also met with youth at open houses in Los Angeles and San Diego. “What I am truly trying to accomplish is to make sure that whoever is our elected official knows that your voice is heard,” said Butler. “In opening the house the intention is truly to open the house of government and invite you into the center.”

Butler explained she wanted to hold such events with youth to counter the cynicism younger people may feel about their government, leading them to vote less frequently than older Americans and feel elected leaders are not concerned about their futures. Her staff used the event to inform the youth what services they can access via the senator’s office. “Unless we open the house and truly give you the information you need to make it work for you, we are not really building that participatory government,” said Butler. In the audience was gay Oakland resident Sean Sullivan, who owns several LGBTQ nighttime venues in the East Bay city. He attended Butler’s event due to his involvement with the youth services and housing provider Covenant House, where he once worked and continues to support. With 40% of homeless youth LGBTQ, Sullivan told the B.A.R. it is important to highlight that fact for the senator as she works to address the state’s housing crisis. “I think it is awesome the senator is making it a hallmark of her short tenure to reach out and talk to young people,” said Sullivan, adding that her making herself accessible to them and emphasizing that “no one has it figured out is really important.” Boys & Girls Club of San Francisco President Rob Connolly welcomed Butler at the start of the public portion of her open house. He thanked her for taking the time to meet with and hear directly from youth about what concerns they have. See page 8 >>

SF’s battle for the gavel becomes a referendum on safety issues by John Ferrannini

S

an Franciscans will be voting on who will occupy two Superior Court judgeships on March 5 in what is becoming the city’s latest referendum on public safety issues. Attorney Chip Zecher, a gay man who was appointed by Governor Gavin Newsom to the board of directors of UC Law San Francisco (formerly Hastings) in 2019 and is its vice chair, is challenging sitting Judge Michael Isaku Begert for Superior Court Seat No. 1. Zecher is being joined in running against an incumbent by San Francisco Assistant District Attorney Jean Myungjin Roland, who is challenging sitting Judge Patrick Thompson for Superior Court Seat No. 13. At a debate on December 7, the Bay Area Reporter reported that unlike previous elections where sitting San Francisco judges were challenged from the left, in this case they are being challenged from the right. Due to ethics rules the judges and challengers couldn’t discuss how they’d rule on cases, but the two aspirants charged the incumbents with being out of touch with what ordinary San Franciscans are experiencing. They are being supported by Stop Crime Action, the political arm of Stop Crime SF. The challenges come as citizen concern over crime and public safety have boiled over. The San Francisco Chronicle endorsed keeping Begert and Thompson in a January 27 editorial. For their parts, the San Francisco Democratic County Central Committee and the Harvey Milk LGBTQ Democratic Club endorsed the incumbents as well, while the Alice B. Toklas LGBTQ Democratic Club endorsed the challengers. No endorsement in the two races is listed on the website of the San Francisco Republican Party. Several other San Francisco Superior Court judges were up for election this year, but because they’re not being challenged, their names won’t appear on the ballot.

Courtesy the candidates

San Francisco Superior Court Judge Michael Isaku Begert, left, is being challenged by attorney Chip Zecher.

Zecher

Zecher told the B.A.R. he decided to run because of the street conditions in the Tenderloin neighborhood, where UC Law is located. “It was a slow process but really it started in 2019 when I was appointed by the governor to the board of UC Law – formerly UC Hastings – and I became well acquainted with the challenges businesses face and public institutions face from the public safety concerns on our streets,” he said. “UC Law is right in the middle of open-air drug markets and gun violence – shootings around the college are a weekly or biweekly event.” Zecher said he decided to run ultimately after District Attorney Brooke Jenkins made the remark that she “has trouble with some judges,” he said. Jenkins was appointed by Mayor London Breed two years ago after the successful recall of District Attorney Chesa Boudin, a self-styled progressive prosecutor and former public defender.

“I’ve become an activist at 60,” Zecher said. “I haven’t been involved before, except as a donor and as a volunteer on different campaigns.” Jenkins, through a spokesperson, declined to comment. In his B.A.R. candidate questionnaire, Zecher stated that he has empathy for people who are addicted. “I do believe in a compassionate approach to those severely afflicted and addicted on our streets and do not think that permitting fentanyl drug dealers to continue to ply their trade unfettered on our streets is a compassionate way forward,” he stated. During the December debate, Zecher took exception to San Francisco Board of Supervisors President Aaron Peskin’s criticism of him and Roland for putting their hats in the ring. See page 3 >>


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.