Director Javier Fuentes-Leon on his ghost-story film.
m co
Terms used by same-sex couples often depend on legal recognition of relationship.
. AR eB
Feeling the ‘Undertow’
– ut e s. in al ko nl on ec r o ers Ch rte p po nd Re , a a s re fied y A ssi Ba cla he ts, s t ar It’ s, w ne
Husband or wife?
see Arts
page 8
BAYAREAREPORTER
Vol. 40
. No. 37 . 16 September 2010
Serving the gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender communities since 1971
M
Trans SF Pride has $99,000 deficit services excluded in T Healthy SF
page 3
M
San Francisco Pride Executive Director Amy Andre and board President Mikayla Connell defended the organization’s finances at last weekend’s annual membership meeting.
net calculation that should have been included in accord with the contract. As a result, our beverage partners received a higher percentage of the gross, while San Francisco Pride paid for all
page 16
M
Andre wrote that Pride had been overpaying beverage partners from 2006 through 2009. One of the partners provided a copy of the letter to the B.A.R. “During those years, we did not include certain categories of expenses in determining the
Castro adjusts to quieter Halloween by Matthew S. Bajko our years after San Francisco officials shut down the annual street party that occurred Halloween night in the Castro, the city’s gayborhood has slowly adjusted to the change. The focus of the neighborhood’s holiday celebration has returned to being more residential in nature and LGBT-centric. Many more Castro residents are hosting house parties, while visitors now come to go to the area’s many gay bars rather than mingle on the street. “All of my friends are having parties or small gatherings; that just seems to be what is the trend now,” said Mission Station LGBT liaison Sergeant Chuck Limbert, who is working on the police department’s plans for this year’s holiday. “People should be able to go to their friend’s house and celebrate Halloween in a way that is safe.” Predicated on curbing the violence and gaybashings that had increasingly become as signature a feature at the Halloween street bash as costumed revelers, the cancellation of the outdoor bacchanalia in 2007 was, nonetheless, controversial. While many Castro residents cheered the decision, others lambasted city leaders for killing the cherished tradition. Following the first year of the shutdown, when the majority of Castro businesses and bars shut their doors at 10 p.m., the shock of seeing what some described as a police state soured many on what had been considered a high holy day for the gay community. Even those who agreed that the city needed to take control of the situation were pained to lose the party. “I was depressed. No one was more sad to see Halloween go away than me,” said Castro resident David Perry, a gay public relations professional who oversees the city’s Home for Halloween campaign. “I went every year and was always dressed up. It is one day before my birthday. But about seven years or eight years ago it stopped being fun for me. I don’t want to be yelled at and I don’t want to see people abusing people.” Ever since 2008, when the bars and restaurants were allowed to remain open for business, Halloween has remained relatively calm and peaceful
The sidewalks of the Castro District were full of revelers for Halloween last year. The atmosphere was peaceful and fun, and the police were easygoing, but kept people on the sidewalks.
F
•••FIRST
OF
Rick Gerharter
Rick Gerharter
T
in the Castro. Perry said people have accepted the situation and are beginning to create their own new traditions for celebrating the holiday. “I would say it is true that there is a new normal about Halloween in the Castro,” said Perry. “My neighbor upstairs now has a party every year. He started due to our campaign.” Castro residents Billy Clift and Carl Dickinson, partners who have lived in the Castro for seven years, used to invite friends over prior to hitting the street party each year. As the event became less safe, they would avoid the unruly crowds and head straight for the Edge bar on 18th Street. Now, after handing out candy to trick-ortreaters, the couple hosts a Halloween party at their home. “We used to not have a Halloween night party,” said Clift, an independent filmmaker. “Two years ago we decided not to go anywhere at all, stay here and have a typical house party instead. Everyone was happy to do that because they didn’t want to go into the Castro as well.” Event producer Marc Huestis also stopped attending the Castro Halloween parties because of the negative vibe among the crowds. “I always enjoyed Halloween until it got
TWO
creepy and crazy. I didn’t even go the last few years because I was scared to death and not in a good way,” recalled Huestis. Longing to feel Halloween be fun again, Huestis this year is hosting a screening of the classic horror film Poltergeist at the Castro Theatre Saturday, October 30. On stage will be one of the movie’s stars, JoBeth Williams, who played the mom, as well as a Carol Ann look-alike contest. “I am hoping to be able to create the spirit that once existed the night of Halloween in the Castro District the night before Halloween,” said Huestis. “We will see murder on the screen but not in real life.” With Halloween falling on a Sunday this year, Castro leaders expect a lighter than normal turnout on October 31. There may be bigger crowds descending on the neighborhood the night before, though many bars and clubs across the city will be hosting Halloween-themed parties that night, such as Gus Bean’s annual Colossus Halloween Monster Ball. “Everybody is expecting it to be the same as last year. I hate to be a bore but that is how I feel
SECTIONS•••
page 16
M
ransgender leaders say that Healthy San Francisco, the city’s health insurance program for uninsured residents, is discriminatory because it excludes sexual reassignment services, treatment, and surgery. At least one person has filed a complaint with the city’s Human Rights Commission due to the exclusionary policy, the Bay Area Reporter has learned, and the city’s health deDr. Mitch Katz partment is in talks with the agency about how to remedy the situation. “This is clearly discrimination against a protected class that we do not discriminate against in our own health policy,” said Theresa Sparks, a transgender woman who heads the Human Rights Commission, referring to the fact that sexual reassignment surgery is covered under the city’s health insurance for employees. “If we cover it for our own employees, why don’t we cover it for the residents at large?” Neither Sparks nor Dr. Mitch Katz, director of the health department, would discuss the specifics of the complaint due to confidentiality policies. It was filed three months ago, said Sparks, and the agency has been meeting with health department officials to find a suitable resolution. “Our authority is to enforce all nondiscrimination ordinances in the city and county of San Francisco. We believe it does apply to” the city’s health insurance program, said Sparks. The commission’s public oversight body has yet to take an official stance on the policy. Its chair, transgender activist Cecilia Chung, said she is confident the policy will be changed. “I think if we just look at the surface of it, it definitely sends mixed messages from the city and county of San Francisco and I don’t think it is intentional. We are not intentionally trying to tell the community that we are trying to discriminate against them,” said Chung. “Of course the actions seem to speak otherwise, that is why the community is working very closely with the HRC and we are reaching out to the public health.” Katz said he is amenable to seeing the city offer sexual reassignment procedures to transgender people but is unsure, at this point, of the best way to do so. “We want to work with the Human Rights Commission on making it possible for people to have sexual reassignment surgery. We don’t yet know what the right vehicle will be for that,” said Katz. Healthy San Francisco provides accessible and affordable health care services
Rick Gerharter
by Matthew S. Bajko
he San Francisco LGBT Pride Celebration Committee will be closing its fiscal year with a deficit of about $99,000, as payments to community partners are delayed due to cash flow issues. Despite the troubling budget figures, which Mikayla Connell, president of Pride’s board, discussed last weekend, Amy Andre, the Pride Committee’s executive director, expressed confidence things will turn around next year. “The budget for the coming fiscal year has us poised to eliminate the deficit for this fiscal year and end with a surplus,” Andre told the Bay Area Reporter. She said Pride should end next year with a surplus of about $40,000 on its budget of $1.5 million. Both she and Connell were at Pride’s annual general membership meeting Sunday, September 12. Andre didn’t provide a copy of the budget for next year, and at least one of the organization’s recent budget projections appeared wildly optimistic. Regarding the checks to Pride’s beverage partners, several of them received less money than they had expected due to what Pride officials say was an accounting error. In a September 2 letter to beverage partners, who staff Pride drink booths at the festival,
Rick Gerharter
by Seth Hemmelgarn