GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia THE
DESIGN REALISATION ERIK BEAN STUDIO 3A RELOCATION: THE MAKING OF UTOPIA CJ LIM, EVA ROSBORG AAGAARD & SIMON DICKENS AARHUS SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE SPRING 2017
1.1 INTRODUCTION
GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia THE
Relocating across memory to critique the contemporary European Union. The Grand Tour of EUtopia is a modern pilgrimage critiquing the role of the European Union in modern Europe. Exploring protective nationalism and promoting transnational empathy by evoking compassion through the exploration of climate, community, culture, development, and geography. The final destination of the tour develops a dialog between the European Union and Thyborøn. A town rich in history and part of Denmark’s extensive habitat protection area. Pilgrim’s bring the ingredients to confront their own past and future within the EU, becoming a part of a landscape that connects them to each other and the environment. The final stop of the tour is manifested in a series of archives collecting the diplomatic, intellectual, cultural, political, economic, and social history of the individuals of the EU. Pilgrims are encouraged to connect over food and drink, and release ‘gifts’ of their memories back to the Union.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
4
FEATURED ILLUSTRATIONS
65 R PROTECTING THE IMF KWATE ER PROTECTING THE L LIMFJJORD BREA AKWAT ORD THE BRE THE
FEATURED ILLUSTRATIONS
R PROTECTING THE LIMF KWATE JORD BREA THE
R PROTECTING THE LIMF KWATE JORD BREA THE ING THE BREWERY AND BAKER NECT Y CON
LMINATION OF TH THE CU G ATIN G THE BREWERY AND BAKEETOUR IVIN RY ARCRONNECT
RAGE CATHEDRA E THE STO INSID THE CULMINATION OF T L HE TO G AT UR IVIN ARR
RAGE CATHEDRA E THE STO L INSID
FEATURED ILLUSTRATIONS
67 PROTECTING THE IM WATER R PROTECTING THE L LIMF REAK FJJO KWATE OR RD D HE B BREA TH T E
ING THE BREWERY AND B KER NECT NG THE BREWERY AND BA AKERY CONNECTI Y CON
FEATURED ILLUSTRATIONS
68 R PROTECTING THE LIMF KWATE JORD BREA THE
R PROTECTING THE LIMF KWATE JORD BREA THE ING THE BREWERY AND BAKER NECT Y N O C
RIENWAETRIO YN ELBM AN CU TH OD FB HE TG TA HKEET GCATTIN RO YUR NE IVNIN O ARCR
CIAOTN HO ED NE AT MAIG LR E SCTUO FR HE TH TA HLE TO TT AE NSGID UR IVIIN ARR
RAGE CATHEDRA E THE STO L INSID
CONTENTS
1
BUILDING FORM, SYSTEMS, PLANNING AND CONTEXT
INTRODUCTION 1.1 Project Brief 4 Masterplan Isometric 5 Building Isometric 6 1.2 Project Definitions Utopia 7 Relocation 8 Undesirable 9 1.3 Articles: Contemporary Europe 10 1.4
The Grand Tour of EUtopia Stops of the Grand Tour
SITE ANALYSIS
11
3
BUILDING PERFORMANCE
ENVIRONMENTAL OVERVIEW
3.1 3.2 3.3
Environmental Principles Overview Environmental Project Overview Environmental Design Overview
ENERGY SYSTEMS
3.4 Energy Strategy 50 3.5 Energy Production 51
WASTE SYSTEMS
3.6 Waste Management 52
WATER SYSTEMS
3.7
Rainwater Collection Strategy
1.5 Site Location 12 1.6 Environmental Context: Habitat 13 1.7 Environmental Context: Coastal Protection 14
PASSIVE HEATING AND VENTILATION
3.8
Solar and Ventilation Strategy
INSULATION
FORMAL DEVELOPMENT
1.8 Masterplan Development 15 Building Development 16 1.9 Building Program 17 1.10 How Pilgrims Navigate the Space 18
47 48 49
3.9
Calculating Thermal Performance
OCCUPANT COMFORT
3.10
Occupant Comfort Chart
53
54
55
56
LIGHTING 3.11
Atmospheric Lighting Strategy
1.11 General Arrangement 19-21 1.12 Building Section 22-23 1.13 Fire Escape Strategy 24 1.14 Accessibility 25
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
2
BUILDING CONSTRUCTION
4
STRUCTURAL OVERVIEW
GENERAL ARRANGEMENT
57
3.12 Wisteria maintenance 58
BUILDING PROCUREMENT
2.1 Key Structural Principles To Be Explored 27 2.2 Key Section 28 2.3 Structural Grid 29
4.1 Clients and Contracts 60 4.2
Building Cost Estimation
61
BREAKWATER
4.3
Project Schedule: Gantt Chart
62
2.4 2.5 2.6
Breakwater Typology Study Breakwater Setting Out and Construction Breakwater Step Module Detail
FLOATING WALKWAY
2.7
Floating Planter Detail
STORAGE CATHEDRAL
2.8 Storage Cathedral Structure Systems 2.9 Oil Rig Recovery Process 2.10 Storage Cathedral Connection Details Connection at Oast House Floor Detail Connection at Breakwater Wall Detail
30 31 32
4.4 Health and Safety 63
33
34 35 36
5
APPENDIX
5.1 Final Drawings 65 5.2 Model Photos 69
BANQUET BRIDGE
2.12 Banquet Bridge Operating Mechanism 2.13 Banquet Bridge Details Pulley System Detail Water Filled Counter Weight Detail Bearing Detail
TASTING ROOMS
2.14
Tasting Rooms: Marine Timber Structure
OAST HOUSE
37 38
5.3 Supporting Information 70-88 5.4 Bibliography 89
39
2.15 Oast House Details 40 Oast Press Detail Oast Oven Roof Penetration Detail Floor Edge Detail
2.16 Wisteria Trellis Truss System 2.18 Wisteria Trellis Planter Details Planter Detail Roof Light Upstand Detail
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT FROM:
WISTERIA TRELLIS 41 42
Matthew Wells, Techniker Engineers Markus Krauss, Transsolar Jette Birkeskov Mogensen, Schmidt Hammer Lassen
TYPICAL WALL SECTION
2.17 Kitchen Wall Section 43 Rainwater Collector Roof Parapet Detail
CONSTRUCTION SEQUENCE
2.18 Construction Sequence 44
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
2
BUILDING FORM, SYSTEMS, PLANNING AND CONTEXT
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
01
3
1.1 INTRODUCTION: MASTERPLAN ISOMETRIC
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
5
1.1 INTRODUCTION: BUILDING ISOMETRIC
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
6
1.2 PROJECT DEFINITION: UTOPIA ERNEST MILLER HEMINGWAY Born July 21, 1899 Ernest Hemingway lived a vigorous life of conflict and anguish eventually leading to his suicide in July 2, 1961. Fighting in the First World War, volunteering in the Spanish Civil war, and reporting on the Second World war he was exposed to the worst of suffering. At home the deterioration of several marriages and a multitude of injuries left him battered and eventually contributed to his suicide. His writing served as a moment of Relocation and Utopia. His words were a foil to transport his consciousness across time and find momentary bliss in the making of peace with his inner demons. To the public eye Hemingway lived a storied and exciting life, cavorting with the lost generation and developing a unique writing style which eventually garnered him the Nobel Prize. However, his outward image and inner self were always at odds.
WALLED EUROPE 70 years after the end of the Second World War and 25 years after the fall of the Berlin wall we live in a new age of barrier construction. Across continents, walls, fences and high-tech border surveillance are under construction. The Schengen Agreement ratified only six years after the Berlin wall fell marked the erection of a new barrier less than 100km to the East.
CURRENT WALLS ATLANTIC WALL
PILGRIMAGE EUROPE The pilgrimage began as a form of penance or coming to terms with ones own actions or past. Many pilgrimages exist in Europe today, religious, secular, educational, and recreational. The pilgrimage becomes the tool of utopia to confront the status of contemporary Europe.
START FINISH PILEGRIMSLEDEN
BIG TWO-HEARTED RIVER “Big Two Hearted River” is a short story from the collection “In Our Time” published 1924. The story is written in a terse descriptive manner and follows a semi-autobiographical Hemingway as a young man who arrives by train in a Michigan town from his childhood. Only now the town and the surrounding landscape has been ravaged by fire. The young man hikes out into the landscape to find the perfect fishing spot on a stream. He travels from the blackened and scorched earth into the richly wooded forest. Exhausted he makes a camp for the night. In the morning he collects grasshoppers for bait and goes fishing for trout in the creek. He battles the fish. After catching two fish he decides he is finished for the day. Upstream there is a swamp, here he tells himself he will not ever go. The story concludes with the young man stating that there are plenty of days left to fish the swamp.
CREATING UTOPIA
PILGRIMS WAY CANTERBURY CAMINO DE SANTIAGO MODERN GRAND TOUR WILLIAM BECKFORD’S GRAND TOUR THE ORIENT EXPRESS
CREATING DIALOG
UTOPIA FOR HEMINGWAY
UTOPIA FOR PILGRIMS
A EUROPEAN CONVERSATION
The act of writing Big Two-Hearted River was cathartic action for Hemingway, reconciling his actions of the past with the present. By using a character other than himself he is able to transport himself across time and space to deal with the demons of his past. His greatest tool was his writing so logically this is how he would confront his problems. His story becomes an avenue for him to discuss the pain and loss he suffered during his time in the war. By fictionalizing the story he is able to insulate himself from his own anguish, however, it is in the confrontation of his inner pain that he reaches Utopia. The story is able to reconcile the terror and pain of the war with his childhood of innocence fishing in the creek. Furthermore, the story helps him understand who he has become after the war. Including the fear that it has changed him for ever, and that he will constantly be searching out the danger of “the swamp” for the rest of his life.
Utopia for the pilgrim is the experience of traveling to understand and confront the nature of European history and reconcile it with the present. The act of traveling creates empathy and builds an understanding of the nature of contemporary Europe. A continent that has a long and tumultuous history. Over the last several decades Europe has seen a period of unprecedented peace and prosperity. Cooperation, cohesion, and unity have brought the continent together, however, contemporary Europe is also seeing a crisis of self. Thousands of kilometres of walls have been erected, the continent has seen an influx of immigrants, refugees, and migrants fleeing persecution. The nature of European cohesion has also been rocked by “Brexit,” rising protectionism, nationalism, and right wing politics.
The Grand Tour catalyzes the catharsis of confronting the pilgrim’s experience of Europe through conversation. Similarly the Grand Tour creates a stage for the voice of Thyborøn to be heard by the EU. Thyborøn optimizes the small European town feeling rejected or overlooked by the European Union. The Grand Tour helps the town reconcile its own place in the union, in history, and its future in the European Union.
PROJECT DEFINITION: UTOPIA Utopia is the cathartic confrontation of our history, reconciling our actions of the past with the present.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
7
1.2 PROJECT DEFINITION: RELOCATION
HEMINGWAY’S MEMORY COLLAGE
HEMINGWAY’S MEMORY COLLAGE The collage explores the fractured nature of Hemingway and his cathartic confrontation of the past in Big Two Hearted River. Movement through time and space is central to the understanding of the collage. As the viewer moves around and closer to the collage what appeared to be a portrait is really an assembly of objects. On the surface elements from the story, below, elements of Hemingway’s troubled and violent past.
PROJECT DEFINITION: RELOCATION
PROJECT DEFINITION: RELOCATION Relocating across memory. In order to reach Utopia one must make a pilgrimage of the mind, from the present to the past.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
8
1.2 PROJECT DEFINITION: UNDESIRABLE PHOTOS OF THYBORØN’S BUNKERS
BUNKER LANDSCAPE
BUNKERS IN THYBORØN
ATLANTIC WALL HISTORY
ATLANTIC WALL EUROPE
ATLANTIC WALL DENMARK
Hitler's Atlantic Wall stretched along the coasts of Norway, Denmark, Germany, Holland, Belgium and France. 5000km of shoreline depicted as endless and impenetrable. In reality strong fortifications existed, but the "wall" was mainly a number of strongholds with relatively unprotected beach in between. What is left of the Atlantic Wall in Denmark is an impressive reminder of the past and monument of the consequences of blind submission. ATLANTIC WALL THYBORØN The Limfjord was an important waterway and a potential weak spot in the Atlantic Wall. German occupation forces tried to seal off the western entrance to the fjord with two coastal batteries and a large array of bunkers. Many of these bunkers today have sunk into the sand, but the remains of an entire coastal battery is strung out along the shore.
PROJECT DEFINITION: UNDESIRABLE The site of Thyborøn Denmark is undesirable because of the presence of Hitler’s World War Two defensive military bunkers and the negative historical connotations associated with them.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
9
1.3 ARTICLES: CONTEMPORARY EUROPE
PROTECTIONISM AND NATIONALISM INTERNATIONALLY
THE ECONOMIST: LEAGUE OF NATIONALISTS “It is troubling, then, how many countries are shifting from the universal, civic nationalism towards the blood-and-soil, ethnic sort. As positive patriotism warps into negative nationalism, solidarity is mutating into distrust of minorities... A benign love of one’s country.. is being replaced by an urge to look on the world with mistrust.”
BBC: PROTECTIONISM: IS IT ON THE WAY BACK “It seems that free-trade and protectionist tendencies are fairly evenly balanced among the great powers, with every nationalist impulse countered by a liberalising one... The German Chancellor, Angela Merkel, has long maintained that a return to protectionism would be a grave danger for the global economy.”
http://www.economist.com/news/international/21710276-all-around-world-nationalists-are-gainingground-why-league-nationalists
http://www.bbc.com/news/business-18104024
THE RISE OF THE FAR RIGHT AND XENOPHOBIA IN EUROPE
THE NEW YORK TIMES: EUROPE’S RISING FAR RIGHT “Amid a migrant crisis, sluggish economic growth and growing disillusionment with the European Union, far-right parties — some longstanding, others newly formed — have been achieving electoral success in a number of European nations.”
THE GUARDIAN: REFUGEES AREN’T THE PROBLEM “If there was a crisis in 2015, it had less to do with the refugees and much more to do more with European governments and societies who did not all step up to the plate. In fact, Europe isn’t confronted with a refugee and migrant crisis. It’s the refugees and migrants who are confronted with a crisis of Europe.”
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/world/europe/europe-far-right-political-parties-listy.html? _r=0
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/oct/31/refugees-problem-europe-identity-crisis-m igration
BREXIT
THE GUARDIAN: BREXIT DIARIES “The Guardian’s three-month Brexit diaries project has revealed a nation deeply divided, between those texting their friends this week to say “happy Brexit day” – and others for whom the news brought only anxiety and fear.”
BANKSY: BOVER, UNITED KINGDOM “The mural has appeared at a difficult time, when Brexit and the increasingly frosty relationship between Theresa May’s government and the EU over negotiations on Britain’s departure have become central to the general election on 8 June.” - The Guardian
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/apr/01/brexit-diaries-article-50-uk-theresa-may-britaineu
http://www.banksy.co.uk/ https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2017/may/07/banksy-brexit-mural-dover-eu-flag
INVESTIGATION In a contemporary Europe issues of division and conflict are prevalent. Can architecture critique the current nature of the continent and strike up a dialogue with its inhabitants?
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
10
1.4 THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
1.4 GRAND TOUR STOPS
1 LES L AR
LESVOS, GREECE
MANIFESTATION ON SITE
Europe’s entry way for migrants and refugees. 95,093 refugees arrived in 2016.
The development of an on site migratory seasonal ecology.
CRITERIA: RISING INDUSTRY
MANIFESTATION ON SITE
A rising industiral center representative of the role new EU members can play. Cheap labour, a stable currency and a flat tax rate, the city is now a leading European industrial hub of manufacturing, mining, and the production of raw materials.
The utilization of prefabricated elements on site that are manufactured within the EU.
CRITERIA: POST RESOURCE EXTRACTION
MANIFESTATION ON SITE
The site of post resource extraction. The process of change as the natural landscape transforms the industrial sites. These spaces have been irrevocably shaped by humans. Left behind are traces of exploitation but also the creation of haunting beauty combining industrial and natural.
The materiality of roof. Roof water collectors are lined with small marble tiles transported by pilgrims.
CRITERIA: CLIMATE CHANGE
MANIFESTATION ON SITE
The Alps are refered to as the water towers of Europe underpining the wellbeing of surrounding areas. Temperatures in the Alps have risen almost twice as much as the global average and continuing to rise. The Alps consume around 10% more energy per capita than the European average.
The Storage Cathedral creation of specific views on site highlighting objects of importance around the site
CRITERIA: GRAIN PRODUCTION
MANIFESTATION ON SITE
The Largest grain producer, France has the biggest utilized agricultural acreageof Europe and is the biggest producer of agricultural goods. The International Grains Council (IGC) puts total French grain production for 2012-13 at 67.8 million tonnes.
Grain as material. On the site different grains are used in for the creation of a variety of breads, and beers.
CRITERIA: CLIMATE CHANGE, SEA LEVEL
MANIFESTATION ON SITE
Zuiderzee Works Flevoland is approximately 3m below sea level. A man-made system of dams and dikes, land reclamation and water drainage works, the largest hydraulic engineering project in the Netherlands. The project involved the damming of the Zuiderzee, a large, shallow inlet of the North Sea.
Construction expertise from the Netherlands is used to develop the large breakwater wall protecting the mouth of Limfjord.
CRITERIA: NEW LAND
MANIFESTATION ON SITE
The new landmass composed of sandbanks emerged from the violent waters of the North Sea. It lies 15 miles off the coast of Germany’s Wattenmeer. Winds blew seeds from across Europe, and 49 species of plants have been detected on it.
Habitat and new land. New land is created by the mass of the breakwater creating new habitats for birds and sea life. It becomes a gathering point for pilgrims blown across Europe.
CRITERIA: ENRGY PRODUCTION
MANIFESTATION ON SITE
Ekofisk is an oil field in the North Sea. It is one of the most important oil fields in the North Sea. The first discovery after the Groningen gas field discovery.
Recycled materials. The storage cathedral frame is constructed from a decomissioned North Sea oil rig jacket
CRITERIA: CONFRONTING HISTORY
MANIFESTATION ON SITE
A history of conflict is found at Thyborøn. The remains of Hitler’s World War Two Atlantic wall, World War One’s naval Battle of Jutland, and the entrance to Denmark for returning Vikings.
The confrontation of the history of modern Europe is manifested on site by the materials, skills, and stratagies represented by the eight stops of the Grand Tour of EUtopia.
E SE B OS , G R E E CINCREA
GES T
IO N REFUGEE POPULAT
BULGARI DIV, A OV ACTURING CENTER PLMANUF NE
CRITERIA: MIGRATION
W
2
PLOVDIV, BULGARIA
PO
TALY IA, I XTRACTION GLSOURCE E PUST RE
3 AN NCSIN, GFTR EMPER CE LA ATU CREA - IN TB RE GE ONHAN M ATE C
4
CL I
M
5 VA L LA
ZU
ID CL
ERZ
IM
A TE
DE L
RGE S
T AG
E E WO
MONT BLANC, FRANCE
VAL DE LOIRE, FRANCE
E N C ER OIRE, FRAPRODUC
RICULTURAL GRAI
E TH NE RKS , RISE
CH AN G E - SE A
PUGLIA, ITALY
LE V
N
RL
DS AN
EL
6
ZUIDERZEE, NETHERLANDS
NE W
AND, GERMAN Y ISL D ECOLOGY RD RY AN BIERRITO T
7
BIRD ISLAND, GERMANY
LA R
O ISK, N RWAY OF ROPEAN OIL FIELD EKEST EU G
8
T H YBO CAT H
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
11
R Ø N, D E
RK
A N MISTORY
ARTIC CONFRONTATION
OF H
9
EKOFISK, NORWAY
THYBORØN, DENMARK
1.5 SITE LOCATION EUROPE
DENMARK
LEMVIG KOMMUNE
AERIAL VIEWS OF THYBORØN
THYBORØN AND THE ENTRANCE TO THE LIMFJORD
PROTECTED BIRD HABITAT
WORLD WAR TWO ATLANTIC WALL BUNKERS
PROJECT SITE
ROUTE OF ARRIVING PILGIRM FERRIES
CONNECTING WITH THYBORØN REPURPOSING FISHING BOATS Thyborøn arose as a fishing town however depleted North Sea fish stocks have affected the industry. The fishing boats would be repurposed to ferry pilgrims from the stop in Ekofisk to Thyborøn. EMPLOYING THYBORØN The project also creates other employment oppotunities for residents of Thyborøn. Creating jobs for bakers, brewers, gardners, and other staff.
EXISTING ROCKY GROINS WORLD WAR TWO ATLANTIC WALL BUNKERS THYBORØN
PROTECTED BIRD HABITAT
PROTECTED BIRD HABITAT
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
12
INVESTIGATION Can the architecture engage with local environment? Can it help protect special habitats in the Limfjord?
MARINE PROTECTED AREAS
1.6 ENVIRONMENTAL CONTEXT: HABITAT
MAJOR BIRD SPECIES IN THYBORØN
DARK-BELLIED BRENT GOOSE
EURASIAN OYSTERCATCHER
COMMON SHELDUCK
EURASIAN WIGEON
DUNLIN
DENMARK Natura 2000 is a network of protected areas designed to protect European animal species and habitats. Natura 2000 is based on the 1979 Birds Directive and the 1992 Habitats Directive. The ecological infrastructure provided protects ecosystem services and ensures that Europe’s natural systems remain healthy and resilient.
GREY PLOVER
BAR-TAILED GODWIT
HABITATS DIRECTIVE SITES (SCI) BIRD DIRECTIVE SITES (SPA)
RED KNOT
SANDERLING PROJECT SITE THYBORØN LIGHT-BELLIED BRENT GOOSE CHEMINOVA
NISSUM BREDNING
NISSUM BREDNING The Natura 2000 network has marked a large area of the Nissum Bredning, the most westerly section of the Limfjord, for protection. The to peninsulas flanking Thyborøn are important bird habitats. Protection came into the spotlight after the dumping of chemical waste by Cheminova in the 1980’s.
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
DEC
BIRD REST STOP The wetlands at Agger Tange and Harboøre Tange are staging areas for waterfowl, specifically the lagoons, flooded meadows and shallow areas of the Nissum Broads. The species occuring in the greatest numbers are mallard, teal, widgeon, and in the autumn the pochard and goldeneye. There are also flocks of coot, mute swan, whooper and Bewick’s swan. In spring Harboøre Tange an important stopover location for pink-footed goose, an arctic breeding goose species only seen in western Jutland during migration. The area also host a variety of waders including the golden plover, lapwing, oystercatcher, dunlin, curlew and snipe.
CONCLUSION The form of masterplan prevents destructive flooding of the wet lands and bird habitat. Collecting sand also creates new habitat for the birds. European protected sites. European Environment Agency (EEA). http://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/ explore-interactive-maps/european-protected-areas. Accessed 13 November, 2016 THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
13
1.7 ENVIRONMENTAL CONTEXT: COASTAL PROTECTION YEARLY COASTAL EROSION RATES
HISTORICAL EROSION AT THYBORØN
PROJECT SITE
THYBORØN
TORSMINDE
{
SITE AREA
{
1695
1791-1826
SITE AREA
SITE AREA
FOCUS AREA
{ HVIDE SANDS
SITE AREA
1849
{
1855
SITE AREA
SITE AREA
APPLYING COASTAL DEFENCE The project masterplan becomes a part of Denmark’s coastal defence system. The shape of the masterplan restricts erosion and longshore drift protecting the coastal landscape. AREAS BELOW +2.5m
10 8
6
4
2
0
-2
-4
{
m / YEAR
1867
HIGH FLOOD THREAT AREA
1874
DEVELOPMENT OF COASTAL DEFENSE BEACH NOURISHMENT
NOURISHMENT IN MILLION M³
COST IN MILLIONS DKK REVETMENT
BREAKWATERS
NOURISHMENT
100 3 80
60
2
40
THYBORØN NURISHMENT
1
20
0 0
1985
75
77
79
81
83
85
87
89
91
93
95
1987
1989
1991
1993
1995
1997
97
NUMBER OF BREAKWATERS BUILT
MEASURED WAVE HEIGHTS AT THE HARBOUR AND OFFSHORE 2.0 m
OCTOBER 2008
NOVEMBER 2008
1.8 m
30
1.6 m 1.4 m 1.2 m
20
1.0 m 0.8 m 0.6 m
10
0.4 m 0.2 m
0 75
77
79
81
83
85
87
89
91
93
95
97
0.0 m
INVESTIGATION Can architecture protect the local environment? Current coastal protection methods are expensive can the Grand Tour provide an alternative?
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
14
1.8 FORMAL DEVELOPMENT: MASTERPLAN MASTERPLAN FORMAL DEVELOPMENT
LONG SHORE SAND DRIFT
CONNECTION TO AGGER NARROWS CREATED FOR TIDAL ENERGY GENERATION
WISTERIA TRELLIS AND PILGRIM HOTELS
SAND COLLECTION
BREAKWATER LINKING PONTOON PATH SAND COLLECTION NARROWS CREATED FOR TIDAL ENERGY GENERATION
DEVELOPING THE FORM The shape of the scalloped breakwater was developed through an understanding of the linear rhythm of the coastal landscape. A series of existing rocky groins leads into to pointed breakwaters where the project links the two forms echoing the language of the existing coast. The form is also driven by the function of collecting sand before it enters the fjord damaging the ecology. Appended to the breakwater is a series of programmes for the pilgrims. A floating path links the structures further calming the water and creating a physical link between the two divided sections of land.
WISTERIA TRELLIS AND PILGRIM HOTELS
BREAKWATER SAND COLLECTION
EARLY BUILDING FORMAL DEVELOPMENT SHELTERED HARBOUR FOR ARRIVING PILGRIM FERRIES
CALMED WATER FOR HABITAT PROTECTION
BREAKWATER SAND COLLECTION
WISTERIA TRELLIS AND PILGRIM HOTELS NARROWS CREATED FOR TIDAL ENERGY GENERATION
DEVELOPING THE FORM The curving masterplan form was adapted into initial building forms. These curving volumes were later simplified into the rainwater collector roofs of the final design.
CONNECTION TO THYBORØN
CONNECTION TO BUNKERS SITE PLAN 1:5000
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
15
1.8 FORMAL DEVELOPMENT: BUILDING BUILDING TECTONIC DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPING FORM The structures formal development arose out of a series of tectonic collages and sketch developments. These became the foundation for the original layout of the building and the relationship between spaces inside.
TECTONIC COLLAGE: STORAGE CATHEDRAL Early collage of storage elements for items brought by pilgrims
TECTONIC COLLAGE: ADAPTING CURVES Early collage of curving elements adapted into structure.
SKETCH DEVELOPMENT: BUILDING FORM The curves of the master plan are explored.
SKETCH DEVELOPMENT: STORAGE CATHEDRAL The collage is directly translated into a section
SKETCH DEVELOPMENT: BUILDING FORM The curves of the master plan are adapted into a building form.
SKETCH DEVELOPMENT: STORAGE CATHEDRAL The section is adapted, the form of an enclosure wrapping around the storage elements is introduced.
SKETCH DEVELOPMENT: BUILDING FORM The curves are reconstructed and adapted into room forms. The building is imagined as a linkage between the path and the breakwater.
SKETCH DEVELOPMENT: STORAGE CATHEDRAL The two forms have a relationship across from one another on opposing breakwaters. These would develop into the storage cathedral and the bakery chimneys.
SKETCH DEVELOPMENT: BUILDING FORM The moving bridge is introduced. The two buildings have separate programs joined during special events.
BUILDING FORMAL ARRANGEMENT
CREATING OVERLAPPING VIEWS The volumes both stagger and align to create relationships between the different programs
CREATING A NEW AXIS OF LINKAGES The building creates physical links between the arriving pilgrims and the breakwater and between the two breakwaters with the banquet bridge.
IMPORTANT PROGRAMS AT FRONT COMPRESSED SPACE OPENING TO CATHEDRAL OPEN SPACE FOR ARRIVING PILGRIMS
CREATING A SPACE OF ARRIVAL The two buildings frame the view into the Limfjord for arriving pilgrims as they arrive from the wide open ocean creating a sense of arrival.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
CREATING A PROGRAMMATIC ARRANGEMENT The spaces within the building are arranged in specific way.
16
1.9 BUILDING PROGRAM 7 OAST HOUSE
6 TASTING ROOMS
TRAVELING PILGRIM ARCHITECTS
CELEBRATING THE GRAND TOUR AT THE CULMINATION IN THYBORØN The main elements of the Thyborøn Grand Tour stop are a brewery and bakery. This is where the pilgrims share a beer and literally break bread with one another. The food evokes memories of home trading stories with one another, developing transnational empathy, and building understanding.
7
6
EXPERIENCE THYBORØN 1
ARRIVAL DOCK
2
RECEPTION HALL
3
MEETING ROOMS
4
RESTAURANT
5
STORAGE CATHEDRAL
6
TASTING ROOMS
7
OAST HOUSE
8
BANQUET BRIDGE
9
BREWERY
10
BANQUET KITCHEN
11
RECIPE BOOK LIBRARY
12
BAKERY
1
6
8
17
TASTING ROOMS At the tasting room pilgrims can meditate over a beer looking at the bunkers. The pilgrims bring their own memories and perspectives to the view.
9 THE BREWERY
OTHER FEATURES 13
ROOF TOP WATER COLLECTORS
14
BIO DIGESTER
15
WATER REMEDIATION TERRACE
16
ROOF LIGHTS
17
WISTERIA TRELLIS GARDEN
16
14
THE OAST HOUSE The hops pilgrims bring from the Grand Tour of EUtopia are processed and used beer production at the Oast House. Raw hops are roasted, dried for brewing, and suspended in the storage cathedral for storage.
INGREDIENTS FROM ACROSS EUROPE Pilgrims bring the ingredients for the final destination in Thyborøn from their homes and across the route of the Grand Tour. These ingredients are transformed into different experiences on the sight and then offered back to the pilgrims. This process links the pilgrims to the tour and creates an archive of ingredients, taste, and experience.
12 THE BAKERY
THE BREWERY The brewery is where hops, yeast, and grain brought by pilgrims and roasted in the oast house is transformed into beer for the pilgrims to enjoy, drink, and share a story over.
THE BAKERY At the bakery grains and other baking ingredients are made into bread to feed visiting pilgrims. At the recipe book library historical recipes from across Europe are stored and referenced to make different baked breads. Pilgrims can literally break giant loaves of Grand Tour bread with one another.
FUEL
GRAIN
MARBLE
HOPS
WATER
SEEDS
13
15
17 WISTERIA TRELLIS GARDEN
13 WISTERIA TRELLIS CANOPY THE WATER COLLECTORS The rooftop rain water collectors are lined with marble tiles brought by pilgrims. The water is used by the Grand Tour brewery to make a special tasting beer.
9 5 12 11 4 2
3
10
KEY PLAN
1 ISOMETRIC VIEW
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
TOUR OF EUt D N A R G o pia E H T
THE WISTERIA TRELLIS Draped across the culmination of the final stop of the Grand Tour is a trellis of wisteria. The winding vines are exotic and symbolize acceptance across the Grand Tour.
17
1.10 HOW PILGRIMS NAVIGATE THE SPACE
1
4
PILGRIM ARRIVAL Pilgrims arrive to Thyborøn from Ekofisk by re-purposed fishing boat ferry.
TASTING ROOM MEDITATION Pilgrims ascend the Storage Cathedral to the Tasting Rooms where they try the beer and have a quiet moment pondering the bunkers framed by the windows.
2
5
6
PILGRIM BANQUET Once enough pilgrims are present the banquet bridge is lowered and a feast is prepared. The pilgrims dine on bread and beer made on site and trade stories
ADDITIONAL SPACES Pilgrims are of course free to visit other places in the building such as the bakery, brewery, recipe library, meeting halls, and restaurant.
DEPOSIT PILGRIM GIFTS Pilgrims move through the building to the Storage Cathedral where they deposit the items they have brought with them
EXPLORE THE BREAKWATER Pilgrims explore the breakwater and the floating walkway admiring the flora and fauna and the contrast between the open sea and the calm fjord.
6
6
1
5
4
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
3
RECEPTION Arriving pilgrims are given keys to their simple rest house lodgings located along the back side of the breakwater.
3
2
18
1.11 GENERAL ARRANGEMENT: LEVEL 1 - ENTRY LEVEL
EXPERIENCE THYBORØN
14
13
11
10
9
8
1
7 5
4
15 6
13
12
14
1:500 @ A2 0m
5m
10m
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
20m
40m
19
3
2
1
ARRIVAL DOCK
2
RECEPTION HALL
3
MEETING ROOMS
4
RESTAURANT
5
STORAGE CATHEDRAL
6
PILGRIM GIFT RECEPTION
7
BANQUET BRIDGE
8
BREWERY
9
BANQUET KITCHEN
10
RECIPE BOOK LIBRARY
11
BAKERY
12
PONTOON WALKWAY
13
SHEET PILE BREAKWATER
14
BREAKWATER MODULE
15
LIVING MACHINE TERRACES
1.11 GENERAL ARRANGEMENT: LEVEL 2 - TASTING ROOM
EXPERIENCE THYBORØN
7
5
7
5
5
8
5
5
5
5
4 2 7 7 3
7
1
1:500 @ A2 0m
5m
10m
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
20m
40m
20
1
TASTING ROOM: BUNKER VIEW
2
TASTING ROOM: LIMFJORD VIEW
3
BEER STORAGE SILOS
4
BANQUET BRIDGE COUNTER WEIGHT
5
WATER COLLECTOR ROOFS
6
BANQUET BRIDGE (UPRIGHT)
7
ROOF LIGHTS
8
BANQUET BRIDGE UPRIGHT
1.11 GENERAL ARRANGEMENT: LEVEL 3 - OAST HOUSE
EXPERIENCE THYBORØN
7
5
7
5
5
6
5
3
4
2
3
5
5
5
7 1
7 7
1:500 @ A2 0m
5m
10m
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
20m
40m
21
1
OAST ROASTER
2
METHANE STORAGE
3
ESCAPE CHUTE SYSTEM
4
LOADING HATCH
5
RAIN WATER COLLECTOR ROOFS
6
BANQUET BRIDGE (UPRIGHT)
7
ROOF LIGHTS
1.12 GA SECTIONS PLAN REFERENCE
50m - STRUCTURE ROOF
40m - OAST HOUSE ROOF OAST ROASTER OAST HOUSE
34m - OAST HOUSE LEVEL
BAKERY SMOKE STACKS STORAGE CATHEDRAL LOUVRE SCREEN BEER STORAGE SILOS
24m - TASTING ROOM LEVEL
DRYING HOPS BANQUET BRIDGE
WISTERIA TRELLIS
ROOF LIGHTS 14m - BANQUET KITCHEN ROOF BRIDGE COUNTER WEIGHT PONTOON WALKWAY BANQUET KITCHEN BREAKWATER MODULES
6m - ENTRY LEVEL
WATER FILTRATION UNIT
0m - SEA LEVEL
SHEETPILE WALL
RAINWATER STORAGE -6m - BASEMENT LEVEL RAINWATER STORAGE TANKS
1:300 @ A2 0m
5m
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
10m
20m
22
1.12 GA SECTIONS PLAN REFERENCE
50m - STRUCTURE ROOF
40m - OAST HOUSE ROOF
34m - OAST HOUSE LEVEL
LIM FJORD VIEW TASTING ROOM
24m - TASTING ROOM LEVEL BEER STORAGE SILO ARRIVAL DOCK RESTAURANT MEETING HALL ARRIVAL HALL
6m - ENTRY LEVEL
PILGRIM GIFT DEPOSIT 0m - SEA LEVEL
GIFT SORTING ROOM
GIFT STORAGE
-6m - BASEMENT LEVEL
1:300 @ A2 0m
5m
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
10m
20m
23
INVESTIGATION
1.13 FIRE SAFETY STRATEGY
What kind of fire exit strategy is appropriate for a marine structure?
MARINE FIRE EXITING STRATEGIES
AREAS OF USE AND RATIONALE
A: MARINE EVACUATION SYSTEM Inflatable ramp fixed to the side of the structure is inflated when needed, raft inflates with ramp
AREA OF USE Projecting Volumes
B: FIRE RATED EXIT STAIR Fire resistant exit stair with emergency lighting.
AREA OF USE Traditional exit routes
C: MARINE FIRE SHOOT Specially designed for fixed and floating offshore installations and comes with a fire retardant chute and integrated life rafts stored inside the blast proof container.
AREA OF USE High elevation areas
D: FREE FALL LIFE BOAT Free fall life boats are mounted on the side of a structure and can be launched up to 50m in the air containing 70 people.
AREA OF USE Not in use
DANISH FIRE CODE REQUIREMENTS
RATIONALE These systems are compact and deliver occupants safely to the ocean. They are utilized in areas projecting into open water. The compact nature of their storage system means that they can be deployed under the structure with minimal visible impact. Unfortunately they are single use and have limitations to egress drills.
RATIONALE Inexpensive and easy to maintain fire exit stairs are utilized throughout the building where a means of egress to the main breakwater or floating path is possible
OCCUPANCY CLASSIFICATIONS
RATIONALE The fire shoot is deployed at the oast house a structure occupied only by workers and with flammable materials and processes. These are added in addition to regular fire stair.
RATIONALE Initially considered as part of fire safety the free fall boat was not utilized due to danger of collision with floating ships or people. Also once deployed the means of egress has then been closed so no others can use it.
MEANS OF EGRESS AND SPRINKLERS 1:1000 LEGEND HIGH FIRE RISK AREA
25m RADIUS FROM EXIT
25m
FIRE SHOOT MARINE EXIT RAMP ADDED EXIT STAIR HIGH RISK AREA AT BAKERY
SPRINKLER
BREAKAWAY PANELS IN CURTAIN WALL LEAD TO MARINE EXIT RAMPS
EXIT STAIRS WITH 1HR FIRE RATING
HIGH RISK AREA AT OAST HOUSE ABOVE
INFLATABLE RAFTS AND FIRE PUMPS AND EXTINGUISHERS PLACE AT 50m INTERVALS ALONG FLOATING PATH
CONCLUSION Norsafe Lifeboats: Free Fall Lifeboats. http://norsafe.com/lifesaving-systems/freefall-lifeboats/. Accessed 16 May 2017 Danish Building Research Institute. Instructions For Building Regulations 2015. Denmark http://sbi.dk/anvisninger/Pages/258Anvisning-om-Bygningsreglement-2015-2.aspx#/5-Brandforhold Viking Life-Saving Equipment. https://www.viking-life.com. Accessed 16 May 2017 THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
By utilizing marine safety strategies means of egress can be achieved without excessive changes to the formal arrangement.
24
1.14 ACCESSIBILITY CODE DOCUMENTS
BUILDING ACCESS
WASHROOM ACCESSIBILITY
RELEVANT DOCUMENTS Several documents outline accessibility standards in Denmark. The Dansk Standard, Accessibility for All, and several additional documents from the Danish Association of Persons with Disabilities.
IMPLEMENTING ACCESSIBILITY STANDARDS
RAMPS Throughout the project ramps are utilized in place of stairs to increase accessibility for disabled persons.
ELEVATORS Where multiple levels exist where ramps cannot be implemented elevators are installed.
ACCESSIBLE WASHROOMS Washrooms on the site are designed to accessible design standards.
VISUALLY IMPAIRED AIDES Throughout the project aides for the visually impaired including braille, and tactile paving along the breakwater and floating walkway.
RAMPS AND ELEVATORS
ACCESSIBLE WC ACCESSIBLE WC
ELEVATOR ACCESSIBLE WC RAMP
RAMP
ELEVATOR RAMP
ACCESSIBLE WC
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
25
BUILDING CONSTRUCTION
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
02
26
2.1 KEY STRUCTURAL PRINCIPLES TO BE EXPLORED REFERENCE IMAGES
INVESTIGATION NOTE A number of pages have this note, look here to see what principles, ideas, or questions that page is investigating.
CAN LOCAL SHIP BUILDING EXPERTISE BE INCORPORATED INTO THE DESIGN OF TIMBER STRUCTURES?
VIKING SHIP HULL Traditional viking boat building methods are used to construct the tasting rooms.
WHAT KIND OF MOVING BRIDGE IS BEST SUITED FOR THE BANQUET BRIDGE?
WHAT KIND OF TRUSS IS CAPABLE OF BOTH SPANNING THE NECESSARY DISTANCE AND SATISFYING THE TRELLIS’S DESIGN VISION?
OIL RIG JACKET A salvaged oil rig structure is used as the structural frame of a space of pilgrim celebration.
TOWER BRIDGE A moving bridge connects the two sides of the building. Linking together the brewery and bakery for pilgrim banquets. WHAT KIND OF STRUCTURE IS BEST SUITED FOR THE SPACES WITH RAINWATER COLLECTORS ABOVE?
UNITE D'HABITATION POOL Tiled rooftop pools are used to collect rainwater and provide drinking water, and unique flavor to the beer made on site.
WHAT KIND OF FIRE EXIT STRATEGY IS APPROPRIATE FOR A MARINE STRUCTURE?
HOW CAN THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE BREAKWATER BE STREAMLINED?
THERE ARE A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT TYPES OF BREAKWATER TYPES. WHICH TYPE BEST SUITS THE SPECIFIC CRITERIA OF THE GRAND TOUR OF EUTOPIA? AN ANALYSIS OF THE FOUR MAJOR TYPES.
SHEETPILE COFFERDAM This method of double walled sheetpiling makes up the structure of the breakwater.
CONCLUSION NOTE This is the counter part to the investigation note above. Here is where each page’s conclusions and decisions are summarized.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
27
2.2 REFERENCE SECTION PLAN REFERENCE
BRIDGE SECTION SECTION 2.13 50m - STRUCTURE ROOF
HOP ROASTER SECTION 2.15
40m - OAST HOUSE ROOF
OAST PRESS DETAIL SECTION 2.15 34m - OAST HOUSE LEVEL
OAST HOUSE FLOOR EDGE DETAIL SECTION 2.15
PULLEY SYSTEM DETAIL SECTION 2.13
WALL SECTION
24m - TASTING ROOM LEVEL
SECTION 2.17
WATER FILLED COUNTER WEIGHT DETAIL SECTION 2.13 14m - BANQUET KITCHEN ROOF
BEARING DETAIL SECTION 2.13
ROOF LIGHT DETAIL SECTION 2.16
RAIN COLLECTOR PARAPET DETAIL SECTION 2.17
BREAKWATER MODULE SECTION 2.6
FLOATING WALKWAY SECTION 2.7 6m - ENTRY LEVEL
FLOATING PLANTER DETAIL SECTION 2.7
CONNECTION AT BREAKWATER DETAIL SECTION 2.10
BREAKWATER MODULE DETAIL SECTION 2.6
0m - SEA LEVEL
-6m - BASEMENT LEVEL
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
28
2.3 STRUCTURAL GRID
INVESTIGATION What kind of structure is best suited for the spaces with rainwater collectors above?
STRUCTURAL COLUMN ISOMETRIC
CHOOSING A STRUCTURAL SYSTEM FOR ABOVE GROUND STRUCTURES REINFORCED CONCRETE ADVANTAGES High Compressive Strength Lower skilled construction Easy maintenance Fire resistance
ROOF LIGHT APERTURES
ROOF WATER COLLECTOR
DISADVANTAGES Lower Tensile Strength Large space requirement Heavy
ROOF WATER COLLECTOR
STEEL FRAME ADVANTAGES Ductile so good under wind loads Highest strength to weight ratio Prefabrication flexibility
STEEL COLUMN SYSTEM
DISADVANTAGES
STEEL FRAME
Expensive Poor fire resistance
TIMBER ADVANTAGES Light weight Aesthetic Renewable
COMPOSITE DECK ON STEEL STRUCTURE COMPOSITE DECK ON STEEL STRUCTURE
DISADVANTAGES Susceptible to rot and other infestation Swelling and contraction with moisture Poor fire resistance
STRUCTURAL COLUMN GRID 1:1000
A B C
3.5m 3.5m 4.5m
D 5.5m
E F G
3.5m 4.0m
23.5m
H 8.0m
I J
3.7m 3.7m
K 7.3m
L
4.5m
M 7.0m
N
3.1m
8.7m
1
2
3.6m 6.0m
3
4
6.0m
5
6.0m
6
6.0m
7
11.0m
8
11.4m
9
5.7m
10
5.7m
11
12
5.7m
7.0m
13
4.0m
14
15
8.6m
4.0m
16 17
10.6m
6.0m
18
19
CONCLUSION http://www.buildings.com/article-details/articleid/2511/title/concrete-vs-steel/viewall/true
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Steel frame construction allows for high strength and low weight. Steel structure is also chosen because of the ease of prefabrication. Many steel elements are constructed off site to ease construction and avoid poor weather which may obstruct construction on site and delay the construction programme.
29
INVESTIGATION DIFFERENT TYPES OF BREAKWATERS
2.4 BREAKWATER TYPOLOGY STUDY
There are a number of different types of breakwater types. Which type best suits the specific criteria of the Grand Tour of EUtopia? An analysis of the four major types.
CALULATING WAVE PRESSURE
OPTION A: SLOPING OR RUBBLE MOUND BREAKWATER
WAVE TYPE AT THYBORØN The waves arriving on the site are non breaking as the water depth is approximately 9m deep. However, over time sand will accumulate in the breakwater and decrease the water depth.
DESCRIPTION Rubble mounds arranged in sloping hills. They are the most common method to protect harbors from waves. The seaward slop of the mound can wasily absorb wave energy.
WAVE ACTION
NON BREAKING WAVES FORCES ON VERTICAL WALLS Typically hydrostatic forces from non breaking waves can be expected when the depth of the structure (9m) is 1.5 times the wave height (4.5m). The Sainflou method of wave pressure theory describes the forces acting on the wall.
ADVANTAGES Flexibility Low transmission and reflection DISADVANTAGES Large volume of material needed Large area of seabed ocupation
p 1 = (p 2 + w0 h)
OPTION B: VERTICAL BREAKWATER DESCRIPTION
p1
Traditionally constructed from interlocking stone blocks, the technology has since improved. Now concrete caissons are used.
WAVE ACTION
H + h0 H + h + h0 SEA p1
H +h 0
H h0
SWL
h
ADVANTAGES Inexpensive
pz p2
DISADVANTAGES Wave reflection and transmission Undermining and erosion
BREAKING WAVES FORCES ON VERTICAL WALLS It is expected that breaking waves will also act on the structure. As some areas are below 1.5 times deeper than the wave height. In addition sediment collecting in the breakwater will lower the depth over time. The force of these waves are calculated with the Minikin formula.
OPTION C: COMPOSITE BREAKWATER DESCRIPTION WAVE ACTION
Rubblemounds are placed infront of the upright sections of breakwater. These blocks dissipate energy before reaching the upright wall.
p d = 101w pd Hb LD D,d d D
ADVANTAGES Increased strength over vertical breakwater DISADVANTAGES Large seabed area Less suitable for deep water conditions
Hb
hd
LD
D
(D + d d )
= maximum dynamic pressure = breaker height = wave length = depth at the toe of the wall = depth one wave length infornt of the wall
AREA OF BREAKWATER
OPTION D: PILED BREAKWATER DESCRIPTION WAVE ACTION
Piled breakwaters are constructed in the form of sheet piles anchored to each other with the space between them filled with infill. ADVANTAGES Good in poor soil conditions Work carried out above sea level Cost effective DISADVANTAGES Must use multiple walls for extra strength
SELECTION CRITERIA
OPTION 1
EASE OF LAYOUT
2
SENSITIVE TO ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS
3
HABITATABLE UTILIZATION CONDITIONS
4
EASE OF AVAILABILITY OF MATERIALS/EQUIPMENT
5
LOW COST OF CONSTRUCTION
6
LOW COST OF MAINTANCE
A
B
C
D
CONCLUSION Tsinker, Gregory P. Port Engineering: Planning, Construction, Maintenance, and Security. John Wiley & Sons. New Jersey. 2004.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
The sheet pile breakwater provides the ideal breakwater typology for the masterplan. Its low environmental impact, strength, and ease of installation suit the site’s environmental sensitivity, and the short window of installation between inclement weather.
30
2.5 BREAKWATER - SETTING OUT AND CONSTRUCTION
INVESTIGATION HOW CAN INSTALLATION BE SIMPLIFIED?
How can the construction of the breakwater be streamlined?
CHOOSING AN INSTALLATION METHOD
PREVIOUS LAYOUT
VIBRATION METHOD A vibratory hammer uses vibration to transfer up and down vibratory forces to the pile. The head is not damaged and a high level of efficiency is achieved. This method is also useful for removing piles.
R4 =
450m
R3 = 400m
CREATING SIMPLIFIED RADIUS BREAKWATER In order to simplify the construction of the breakwater they are made up of only four different radius circles and straight arms. By modifying this radius the floating breakwater modules can be prefabricated with only five different sections.
PERCUSSION METHOD A hydraulic or diesel hammer is used to ram the pile down into the ground. In order to avoid weakening or buckling the pile a pile cap is added. This method achieves a high force useful in areas of joint resistance or ground resistance.
R2 = 600m
R1 =
800m
PRESS IN METHOD A hydraulic mechanism grasps the sheet pile driving it downward. The machine is small and does not require a crane. This method is useful in sensitive areas as it is low noise and low vibration. WHY PRESS IN? By utilizing a driving mechanism that is mounted to existing sheetpiles work can continue even when wave action would make cranes and barges dangerous and inoperable. This will also minimize the number of floating vehicles required for the construction of the breakwater keeping the channel clear and reducing pollution.
SIMPLIFIED FLOATING MODULES By maintaining a single radius at each bend of the breakwater each of the 16 floating dock elements at the curve can be fabricated to the same specifications.
0m
50m
200m
SHEET PILE INSTALLATION 1
2
STEEL TIE ROD STEEL H-SHAPE SHEET PILE STEEL I-PROFILE REINFORCING CONCRETE INFILL
ENCLOSURE OF THE COFFERDAM AND INSTALLATION OF BRACING
SHEET PILE PLACEMENT
3
4
WATER REMOVAL
POURED REENFORCEMENT AND CAPPING
Tsinker, Gregory P. Port Engineering: Planning, Construction, Maintenance, and Security. John Wiley & Sons. New Jersey. 2004.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
CONCLUSION Choosing the right installation method and simplifying the construction means that construction is easier, faster, and more cost effective.
31
2.6 BREAKWATER STEP MODULES 1:5 DETAIL MODULAR BREAKWATER DECK AREA MODULAR BREAKWATER DECKING Fixed to the front of the sheetpile breakwater is a series of stepped breakwater decks. They absorb wave energy and convert it to energy. This modular ‘beach’ hosts different programs. Programmed modules can be exchanged or added as necessary.
DECKING AREA
DECKING AREA
BREAKWATER DECK SECTION 1:100
DECKING AREA
MODULAR BREAKWATER DECK
EDGE DETAIL 1:10
300x300x25mm L-SHAPED STEEL TRAY IPE 180 STEEL BEAM M8mm BOLTS THROUGH SHEAR PLATE M20mm REMOVABLE BOAT
BLANK MODULE
RADIENT HEAT PIT
AMPHITHEATRE
SWIMMING HOLE
WASHROOMS
CHANGING ROOMS
30mm DEEP VERTICAL WOOD SLATS
STEEL ANGLE FIXED WITH M8mm bolts
30mm DEEP WOOD DECKING WITH ANTI-SLIP NOTCHING FILLED W/ HIGH GRIP STRIPS 40mm DEEP WOOD BLOCKING
GLAMPING
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
ARCHIVE TOWER
32
2.7 FLOATING PATH PLANTER 1:8 DETAIL FLOATING WALKWAY AREA
PONTOON WALKWAY SECTION 1:100
PONTOON WALKWAY
FLOATING BRIDGE - KUMBH MEL, INDIA
WHY THE FLOATING BRIDGE? The floating bridge or walkway was selected because of its cost effectiveness, ease of prefabrication and modular nature. Its low profile also means that pilgrims are brought closer to the water and the nature of the Limfjord. The walkway is located behind the breakwater so there is little to no wave action.
THE WALKWAY ALSO CALMS THE WAVES PROTECTING THE ECOLOGY AND ENCOURAGING BIO-DIVERSITY
COMMON GLASSWORT (SAMPHIRE) SALICORNIA EUROPAEA Glasswort is a 5-20 cm high. The leaves are fleshy and grow together in pairs. Grasswort blooms in July-September. There is great variation in the colours of the plants, which may have distinct green, pink, red or violet colours. Grasswort grows at the water’s edge. It is also edible and considered a specialty.
SALTMARSH RUSH JUNCUS GERARDI Saltmarsh rush grows to a height of 40 cm belonging to the rush family. Saltmarsh rush grows in the outer part of the salt marshes. It has wide-creeping rhizome forms which shoot with upright, grassy-green leaves and brown flowers.
GREATER SEA-SPURREY SPERGULARIA MEDIA Greater sea-spurrey belongs to the pink family. It is a low-lying herb with a flattened stem and succulent, linear leaves. The opposite leaves are surrounded by two fused membranous shaft leaves at the base. The flower petals are white or pink.
STRAWBERRY CLOVER TRIFOLIUM FRAGIFERUM Strawberry clover is a low growing plant with up to 30 cm long, rooting shoots. Strawberry clover belongs to the pea family. The leaflets are narrowly ovoid, smooth to slightly hairy and green-dark green. The flower head is ball shaped and the corolla is white to pink. It grows in the inner drier area of the marsh.
BEACH PEA LATHYRUS JAPONICUS Beach pea is a perennial and belongs to the pea family. It grows in an ascending and climbing manner and the stems are edged, green, and usually hairless. The leaves are scattered, with 3-5 leaflets. The blade tip is transformed into a tendril when flowering occurs in July-August.
2 LAYERS 60mm DEEP WOOD BLOCKING 60mm DEEP WOOD DECKING WITH ANTI-SLIP STRIPES WATER PROOF LED DOWNLIGHT STRIPS INTEGRATED SPRINKLER SYSTEM MOLDED FIBERGLASS PLANTER M20mm BOLTS W/ BRACKET ATTACHMENT IPE 770mm STEEL BEAM M30mm BOLTS
IRRIGATION PIPING ELECTRICAL PIPING 25mm STEEL PLATE FIXED IPE WITH M8mm BOLTS AND WELDED L-BRACKET
HOW DO YOU RECREATE A SALT MARSH FOR LOCAL PLANTS? The planters are designed for native Danish coastal plants and recreate the specific growing conditions they need. This is achieved by combining sandy soils with a hydro gel a super absorbent polymer. This replaces the underlying mud layer found in marsh conditions and prevents roots from getting too dry. In addition salt water is added via the irrigation system, acting as a herbicide and introducing nutrients, minerals and salt water creatures.
MULCH TOP LAYER SANDY LOAM AND ORGANIC COMPOST SUBSTRATE WATER RETAINING LAYER OF HYDROGEL SANDY BOTTOM LAYER
STEEL PIVOT FOAM FILLED METAL PONTOON
Robinson, Alexander, Margolis, Liat. Living Systems: Innovative Materials and Technologies for Landscape Architecture. Springer Science & Business Media, 2008
Robinson, Alexander, Margolis, Liat. Living Systems: Innovative Materials and Technologies for Landscape Architecture. Springer Science & Business Media, 2008. Plants of the Agger. http://agger.nationalparkthy.eu/ THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
33
2.8 STORAGE CATHEDRAL STRUCTURAL BREAKDOWN OAST HOUSE STEEL FRAME STRUCTURE
S2
S1 KIT OF PARTS The oast house structure is an active truss made up of wide flange beams, columns and bracing. Connections are welded and bolted. The primary structure is composed of wide-flange steel sections (S1). The primary structure is fastened to the main structural frame by a cold-formed circular hollow section (S2) sandwiched between to circular steel plates welded together and bolted to the two assemblies.
TASTING ROOM TIMBER STRUCTURE
W1
W2
KIT OF PARTS The tasting room’s primary structure is a glue lam continuous frame (W2) 400mm deep and 150mm wide. Additional blocking and framing is carried out with 50mm deep and 100mm wide boards (W2). Setions are bolted together with structural steel brackets.
STORAGE CATHEDRAL RECYCLED STRUCTURE
S4
KIT OF PARTS The bridge structure is composed of square hollow steel sections welded and bolted together. The square HSS allows for simplified welded connections and additional bracing at the junction to the swing arm and counter balance. The primary vertical and horizontal elements are both composed of 500mmx300mmx20mm RHS HSS (S4).
STORAGE CATHEDRAL RECYCLED STRUCTURE
B1
STORAGE CATHEDRAL STRUCTURE The Storage Cathedral is composed of three major structural elements. The main structural frame is made up of a salvaged and recycled north sea oil rig jacket. The circular HSS frame is craned into place with two barge cranes, and then bolted to the sheetpile breakwater. The Oast House and Bridge are pre-assembled into larger components at a nearby staging area. The elements are then craned into place and fastened by workers operating from scaffolding platforms attached to the main structural frame. This methodology allows for increased flexibility as a reduced number of cranes and barges are needed and the time spent in the potentially high seas is limited.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
C1
B2
S3 KIT OF PARTS The primary structural frame is composed of circular hollow steel sections welded together. The circular HSS primary columns (C1)are 1000mm diameter with 20mm wall thickness. The circular HSS beams (B1) are 711mm diameter with 14.2 mm wall thickness The circular HSS diagonal bracing elements (B2) are 508mm diameter with 12.5mm wall thickness The primary columns are fastened to the breakwater structure with an assembly of 2x30mm thick circular steel plates welded to the columns and braced by 30mm thick steel fins (S3)
34
2.9 STORAGE CATHEDRAL : OIL RIG FRAME RECOVERY PROCESS WHY RECYCLED OIL RIG STRUCTURE? SPATIAL REQUIREMENTS
JACKET RECOVERY
1
ROBUST STRUCTURE
2
COST EFFECTIVE
3
LINK TO GRAND TOUR
4
WITHSTAND MARINE CONDITIONS
5
GLASS FACADE
STEEL STRUCTURE
TRANSPORTATION AND INSTALLATION
CONCRETE STRUCTURE
The process of removing the used oil rig jacket from the North Sea provides insight as to what is required to move such mega structures. The Jacket will be removed, cut, and refurbished on land, after which it will be returned to a smaller barge and craned into place on sight.
RECYCLED OIL RIG JACKET STRUCTURE
LIFTING JACKET STRUCTURE BY CRANE
1 2 3 4 5
TRANSPORT OF JACKET FROM REFURBISHMENT
JACKET RECOVERY PROCESS PHASE 1
The recovery barge is brought alongside the oil rig jacket. The upper jacket is cleaned as necessary, the barge ballast is readied and blocks are placed upon the barge deck.
PHASE 3
The jacket is lifted to the selected pivot point which is maintained by the B-system and the downturn is initiated.
PHASE 5
The jacket’s centre of gravity is sufficiently far beyond the turning point to ensure undisturbed re-immersion.
PHASE 2
The top of the jacket is linked to the barge by the winch. Tension is placed on the line and the rig’s support piles are cut.
PHASE 4
Wire forces, jacket and barge movements are continuously maintained for secure controlled lowering.
PHASE 6
The jacket is pulled as far as the winch bump. The jacket is secured to barge for shipment to land where the jacket is removed via skid or trolley system
A Danish Field, Platforms and Pipelines, Decommissioning Programmes. Fornyelsesfondon https://allseas.com/activities/heavy-lifting/installation/
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
35
2.10 STORAGE CATHEDRAL CONNECTION 1:20 DETAILS STORAGE CATHEDRAL CONNECTION AT OAST HOUSE 1:20
POLISHED CONCRETE FLOOR 400mm STEEL WIDE FLANGE BEAM 200mm THICK DENIM INSULATION
M16mm BOLTS THROUGH 20mm THICK CIRCULAR STEEL BOTTOM PLATE WELDED TO 159x6.3mm HSS CHS STEEL TUBE 10mm METAL CEILING PANEL FIXED WITH STAINLESS STEEL CLIPS CIRCULAR STEEL PLATE MOUNTED TO GLASS FOR BRIDGE CABLE THROUGH WAY 700mm SALVAGED, RESTORED, AND REFINISHED OIL RIG JACKET STRUCTURE
TRIPLE PANE BOLT ON GLASS SYSTEM
INTERIOR
EXTERIOR
HSS CHS 219.1x8mm STEEL STAND OFF BOLT ON GLASS SYSTEM
STORAGE CATHEDRAL BASE 1:20 1000mm STEEL OIL RIG JACKET COLUMN
PLINTH STRUCTURE
30mm STEEL PLATE FINS WELDED TO PRIMARY STRUCTURE AND 30mm DEEP CIRCULAR STEEL BASE PLATE M30mm BOLTS 100mm COMPOSITE CONCRETE DECK 240mm STEEL BEAM
HE 650mm STEEL SUPPORT RUNNING PARALEL TO FOOTING
POURED IN-SITU SHEET PILE CAP
H-CAP STEEL SHEETPILE WALL H-SHAPE STEEL REINFORCING POURED IN-SITU CONCRETE INFILL
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
36
INVESTIGATION What kind of moving bridge is best suited for the banquet bridge?
BANQUET BRIDGE LOWERING SEQUENCE
2.12 BANQUET BRIDGE: OPERATING MECHANISM
WHAT TYPE OF MOVING BRIDGE TO USE? CHOOSING AN INSTALLATION METHOD BANQUET BRIDGE SELECTION A number of criteria were considered in the selection of an approriate type of moving bridge for the banquet hall. The movement of the banquet hall is important to the design because of the ceremony attached to lowering the bridge for pilgrim banquets, the symbolic connection between the two structures, and the necessity of lifting the space for arriving pilgrim ferries.
SPATIAL REQUIREMENTS
A number of moving bridge typologies exist including the drawbridge, bascule, folding, curling, vertical-ift, table, retractable, rolling bascule, submersible, tilt, swing, and transporter. Several types were compared in more detail.
DRAWBRIDGE
1
FREE SPANNING
2
LIFTING CLEAR FOR BOAT TRAFFIC
3
ACCOMODATE AN ENCLOSED BANQUET ROOM
4
COMPACT MECHANISM
5
COST EFFECTIVE
REQUIREMENTS FULFILLED
The bridge deck is hinged on one side ADVANTAGES Upward swinging deck Design opportunity with counter weight DISADVANTAGES Heavy counter weight required
BASCULE BRIDGE
1
2
3
4
5
BANQUET BRIDGE SELECTION The drawbridge is selected because of its compact and vertical folding, ability to enclose the deck easily, and design opportunities to have a water filled counter weight using the adjacent sea water.
FINKENWERDER DRAWBRIDGE
REQUIREMENTS FULFILLED
A drawbridge hinged on pins with a counterweight to facilitate raising. ADVANTAGES
1
2
3
Upward swinging deck Easily enclosed deck DISADVANTAGES Large awkward counter weight BASCULE BRIDGE CHICAGO
FOLDING BRIDGE
REQUIREMENTS FULFILLED
A drawbridge with multiple sections that collapse together horizontally. ADVANTAGES
1
2
4
Compact DISADVANTAGES Difficult to enclose deck FOLDING BRIDGE KIELER HÖRN, SBP
ROLLING BRIDGE
REQUIREMENTS FULFILLED
The bridge deck is hinged on one side ADVANTAGES Unique mechanism
PLAN DIAGRAM OF PULLEY SYSTEM
1
2
4
DISADVANTAGES Expensive Difficult to enclose deck
BRIDGE
HINGE BEARING
THOMAS HEATHERWICK, LONDON
LIFT BRIDGE
REQUIREMENTS FULFILLED
The bridge deck is hinged on one side VERTICAL PULLY
ADVANTAGES Easily enclosed deck Room consistantly horizontal
1
3
4
DISADVANTAGES HORIZONTAL PULLY VERTICAL PULLY COUNTER WEIGHT
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Deck is always joining sides Both ends require tall towers
PONT JAQUES CHABAN-DELMAS, FRANCE
37
2.14 BANQUET BRIDGE : HOIST SYSTEM
100mm DIA. BRAIDED CABLE STEEL CABLE ATTACHMENT BOLTED TO PLEXIGLAS TANK WITH M30mm BOLTS SANDWICHED BETWEEN 50mm STEEL PLATES
M30mm BOLTS THROUGH 50mm STEEL PLATE FIXING PULLEY TO ROOF STRUCTURE 100mm STEEL MOUNTING PLATE STEEL PULLEY WHEEL GUIDE 100mm DIA. BRAIDED STEEL CABLE
100mm CAST CYLINDRICAL PLEXIGLAS TANK RUBBER GASKET AND SILICONE SEALED CONNECTION INTERFACE FLEXIBLE TUBING TO COUNTER BALANCE WATER PUMP AND BALLAST TANK
1400mm STEEL BEARING MOUNTED TO 1000mm ROUND HSS STRUCTURE ROTATING STRUCTURE WELDED TO BEARING
Reynolds Polymer. http://www.reynoldspolymer.com/. Accessed 16 April 2017
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
38
2.15 TASTING ROOMS : MARINE TIMBER STRUCTURE
INVESTIGATION Can local ship building expertise be incorporated into the design of timber structures?
VIKING SHIP INSPIRED STRUCTURE
CHAPEL SANAKSENAHO ARCHITECTS
TRADITIONAL VIKING SHIP CONSTRUCTION
WOOD MODEL SHIP BUILDING KIT
PLANK ON FRAME CONSTRUCTION
SELECTING A CLADDING TYPE CARVEL
COLD MOLDED
Individual tapered planks edge to edge and fastened to a framework.
Several layers of thin veneers of wood glued to each other over a jig or framework.
ADVANTAGES / DISADVANTAGES Requires high skills, additional caulking between planks or glued splines and heavy framework.
ADVANTAGES / DISADVANTAGES Fairly high skills and maybe the production of a jig that becomes redundant. Also uses expensive materials, produces a very strong monocoque hull shell. Difficult to repair.
LAPSTRAKE / CLINKER
STITCH & TAPE
PLANK ON FRAME
Individual tapered planks with over lapping edges fastened to transverse timbers.
Pre-shaped panels of plywood stitched edge to edge giving a multi-line shape with ply frames added.
The form of the tasting rooms lends itself to a combination of methods. Prefabrication of the elements and the ability for pieces to be machined digitally means a high degree of precision can be achieved. The structure also requires a heavy framework already so this is not considered a disadvantage.
ADVANTAGES / DISADVANTAGES Requires high skills, expensive materials. Requires regular maintenance and is difficult to repair. Can suffer from leaks as the hull gets older.
ADVANTAGES / DISADVANTAGES Can use low cost materials, requires low skills and only basic tools. The quickest, cheapest and easiest form of construction. Requires use of messy epoxy joints.
TASTING ROOM WALL ASSEMBLY TASTING ROOM By utilizing traditional boat building techniques the tasting rooms can be built light weight and connect with the local marine construction industry.
LEGEND 1
50mm HSS FRAME
2
200mm CEDAR CLADDING
3
WATERPROOF BREATHER MEMBRANE
4
50mm BLOCKING
5
300mm DENIM BATT INSULATION
6
VAPOR BARRIER
7
200mm CEDAR INTERIOR CLADDING
8
400x150mm GLUE-LAM TIMBER FRAME
8 7
5
6
I was a part of Thyborøn’s boat building industry, I’ve got the skills for this job!
4
3
2
1
2
Selway Fisher Design. Yacht & Boat Designs, Plans & Manuals For The Home & Professional Boat Builder http:// www.selway-fisher.com/ THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
39
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
WIND COWL ROTATES WITH DIRECTION OF WIND TO VENT SMOKE
FLORESCENT CHANNEL LIGHTING
DIFFUSED ACID ETCHED TWO-PLY LAMINATED INTERIOR GLAZING
COLOUR FREE PEBBLED TEXTURE AND LIGHT SANDBLASTING EXTERIOR GLAZING
OAST HOUSE WALL DETAIL 1:10
THE OAST HOUSE The Oast House roaster is where raw hops are roasted and dried for brewing. Raw hops are hoisted up to the Oast House where they are placed in the ovens the temperature is raised drying the hops. They are placed in a packing machine and suspended in the storage cathedral. The hops pilgrims bring from the Grand Tour of EUtopia are processed and used beer production.
TRADITIONAL OAST HOUSE
PREFABRICATED OAST ROASTER SEGMENT BOLTED TOGETHER
400mm IPE STEEL ROOF STRUCTURE
M20mm BOLTED SHEAR PLATE
100mm CONCRETE DECK
2 LAYERS 50mm RIDGED INSULATION
SPRAY FOAM CAVITY
50mm RIDGED INSULATION
2 LAYERS WATERPROOF MEBRANE
STAINLESS STEEL FLASHING
WATERPROOF TAPE
HOP ROASTER INTERFACE AT ROOF DETAIL 1:10
HOP DRYING TRACK SYSTEM
RECIEVING HOP SACK
FLOOR ASSEMBLY 100mm CONCRETE DECK 300mm IPE STEEL BEAM DENIM INSULATION FILLED CAVITY METAL CEILING PANEL
HOP PRESS
OPERATION WHEEL
HANGING STEEL SQUARE SECTION STRUCTURE
MOBILE GANTRY WHEEL SYSTEM
HOP PRESS DETAIL 1:10
2.16 STORAGE CATHEDRAL : OAST HOUSE DETAILS
40
INVESTIGATION
2.17 TRELLIS TRUSS SYSTEM
What kind of truss is capable of both spanning the necessary distance and satisfying the trellis’s design vision?
NO DIAGONAL
The spanning structure must be able to span 50m, support the trellis, wisteria, and support structure. It is also important that vertical elements are free to curve and maintain the visual impact of the arching trellis.
SPAN 50m
SELECTION CRITERIA
HIGH STRENGTH
TRELLIS ELEVATIONS MATERIAL EFFICIENCY
CHOOSING A TRUSS SYSTEM
1
2
WARREN TRUSS In this type of truss, diagonal members are alternatively in tension and in compression. The Warren truss has equal length compression and tension web members. Warren trusses are commonly used in long spans.
6
3
PRATT TRUSS In a Pratt truss diagonal members are in tension for gravity loads. This type of truss is used where gravity loads are predominant
4 7
5
8
TRELLIS ELEVATIONS VIERENDEEL TRUSS Vierendeel trusses are rigidly-jointed trusses having only vertical members between the top and bottom chords. The chords are normally parallel or near parallel. Elements in Vierendeel trusses are subjected to bending, axial force and shear, unlike conventional trusses with diagonal web members where the members are primarily designed for axial loads. They are usually more expensive than conventional trusses and their use limited to instances where diagonal web members are either obtrusive or undesirable. Vertical members near the supports are subject to the highest moments and therefore require larger sections to be used.
WIDE SUPPORT STRUCTURE TO RESIST SHEAR BENDING AT ENDS
REMOVAL OF WIDE SPANS WITH NO VERTICAL CONNECTION
VERTICAL CONNECTIONS AT LARGE ARCH
VIERENDEEL TRUSS Identifying structural truss elements
TRELLIS SYSTEM TRELLIS CONNECTION DETAIL
CAST FIBERGLASS REINFORCED PLANTER
CAST RECTANGULAR HSS CONNECTION
400mm STEEL UPE CHANNEL
M30mm BOLTS
CAST RECTANGULAR HSS CONNECTION
TRELLIS RADIANT SYSTEM JOINT
STEEL HSS PLANTER STRUCTURE
CONCLUSION SteelConstruction: The Free Encyclopedia For Uk Steel Construction Information. http://www.steelconstruction. info/Trusses. Accessed 10 May 2017
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
The vierendeel truss is able to span the distance between the two breakwaters with out compromising the trellis design language due to the absence of diagonal members.
41
2.18 TRELLIS DETAILS TRELLIS ROOF LIGHT UPSTAND DETAIL 1:20
TRELLIS PLANTER SECTION DETAIL 1:20
SQUARE HSS STEEL TRELLIS CIRCULAR STEEL SUPPORT FOR BOLT ON GLASS SYSTEM GLASS ROOF LIGHT STEEL CAP FLASHING
UPSTAND ASSEMBLY
100X100MM MARBLE TILE 2 LAYERS WATERPROOF MEMBRANE AFFIXED TO CONCRETE POURED IN PLACE CONCRETE RIDGED INSULATION ALUMINIUM FRAMING FIBRE BOARD BACKING MARBLE TILE
60mm CIRCULAR HSS CONTAINING RADIENT HEAT PIPING IRRIGATION PIPING 250X150mm STEEL SQUARE HSS TRELLIS STRUCTURE WISTERIA TREE STEEL BAND FIBREGLASS MOLDED TRELLIS
360mm DENIM BATT INSULATION FILLED CAVITY COMPOST, PEAT MOSS AND PERLITE GROWING MEDIUM
DRAINAGE LAYER
GRAVEL DRAINAGE BED
400x300mm STEEL BASE BEAM STEEL CAP FLASHING M30mm STEEL BOLTS THROUGH 20mm STEEL BASE PLATE WELDED TO STRUCTURE
TRELLIS SECTION AT ROOF WATER COLLECTOR 1:50
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
42
2.19 WATER COLLECTOR ROOF PARAPET DETAIL
DEBRIS FILTER LED CONTINUOUS STRIP LIGHTING
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
ROOF ASSEMBLY
100X100x10mm MARBLE TILE 2 LAYERS WATERPROOF MEMBRANE 200mm DEEP CONCRETE COMPOSITE DECKING 400mm STEEL WIDE FLANGE BEAM 360mm DENIM BATT INSULATION FILLED CAVITY 20mm STEEL PLATE 40MM RIDGED INSULATION WATERPROOF MEMBRANE 50mm ALUMINIUM FRAMING 10mm WATER RESISTANT BOARD BACKING 100x100x10mm MARBLE TILE
1 2 3
PILGRIM TILES Marble tiles are carried by pilrgims from the stop in the abandoned marble mines in Italy. The irregular and patchwork nature of the different tiles represent the diversity of Europe.
4
5
6 7 8 9 10 11
INTERIOR
EXTERIOR
COPPER RAINWATER DOWNSPOUT TRIPPLE PANE GLASS MOUNTED ON BRUSHED STAINLESS STEEL CURTAIN WALL SYSTEM
COPPER DOWNSPOUT OFF STAND MOUNTED TO VERTICAL MULLION
100mm COMPOSITE CONCRETE DECKING IPE 240mm STEEL BEAM HE 650mm STEEL SUPPORT
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
43
2.20 CONSTRUCTION SEQUENCE
1
1: SITE PREPARATION SITE OFFICE
A: SITE OFFICE SET OUT STAGING AREA AT ADJACENT VACANT PORT AREA
B: ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION MEASURES SET UP C: STAGING AREA ESTABLISHED
FUTURE BREAKWATER
LAYING OUT OIL BOOM
2
2: BREAKWATER CONSTRUCTED A: GUIDE PILES DRIVEN BEGINNING WITH AREA AT BAKERY / BREWERY B: INITIAL PILES DRIVEN BY BARGE THEN SWITCHED TO MOUNTED PUSH IN SYSTEM III
I
II
INSTALLATION OF STORAGE CATHEDRAL AFTER STAGE I. BREAKWATER COMPLETION FOR ADDITIONAL CRANE MANEUVERING AREA
C: BREAKWATER CONSTRUCTION ORDER I. BREWERY SECTION COMPLETED FIRST SO CONSTRUCTION CAN BEGIN. II. BAKERY SECTION III. ADDITIONAL BREAKWATER SECTIONS D: CAVITY FILLED WITH CONCRETE E: INTERNAL VOID PUMPED OUT
III
3
3: FLOATING MODULES AND PILGRIM REST HOUSES DELIVERED A: PREFABRICATED MODULES DELIVERED TO STAGING AREA B: SEGMENTS ASSEMBLED AT STAGING AREA
FOCUS AREA
C: COMPLETED SEGMENTS FLOATED TO BREAKWATER D: SEGMENTS CRANED INTO PLACE BREAKWATER MODULES
E: SEGMENTS JOINED, CONSTRUCTION, AND FIT OUT COMPLETED ON SITE
PILGRIM REST HOUSES
4
4: INSTALLATION OF PREFABRICATED STEEL FRAMES A: STEEL FRAME ELEMENTS ARRIVE BY BARGE B: ARRIVAL DOCK FLOATED TO SITE C: COMPOSITE CONCRETE FLOORS POURED IN-SITU B: PARTIALLY COMPLETED FRAMES IS CRANED INTO PLACE C: WELDING, BOLTING, AND COMPLETION ON-SITE
COMPLETED STEEL FRAME
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
44
2.20 CONSTRUCTION SEQUENCE
5
5: BANQUET BRIDGE, OAST HOUSE, AND LIVING MACHINE CONSTRUCTION A: STORAGE CATHEDRAL INTERIOR ELEMENTS CRANED INTO TOWER B: BANQUET BRIDGE ARRIVES BY BARGE, CRANED INTO POSITION C: OAST HOUSE STEEL FRAME CONSTRUCTION BEGINS SEGMENTS ASSEMBLED AT STAGING AREA, CRANED INTO POSITION, AND WELDED ON SITE D: LIVING MACHINE CONSTRUCTED, TERRACES BUILT AND PRE-FRABRICATED BIO-DIGESTERS INSTALLED
6
6: WISTERIA TRELLIS AND ROOF LIGHTS INSTALLED A: SUPPORT COLUMN PILES DRIVEN WHERE NECESSARY B: COLUMNS FIXED TO STRUCTURE C: STEEL TRELLIS ELEMENTS CRANED AND BOLTED INTO POSITION D: ROOF LIGHT GLAZING INSTALLED E: PLANTER BOXES INSERTED INTO STRUCTURE, FILLED, AND WISTERIA SAPLINGS PLANTED
7
7: FLOATING WALKWAY INSTALLED A: FLOATING WALKWAY SEGMENTS ASSEMBLED AT STAGING AREA B: SEGMENTS FLOATED INTO PLACE
8
8: PROJECT COMPLETION AND FINISHING A: PAINTING B: SMALL EQUIPMENT DELIVERED C: SITE CLEAN UP D: DISMANTLEMENT OF STAGING AREA AND SITE OFFICE E: CELEBRATING BANQUET
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
45
BUILDING PERFORMANCE
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
03
46
3.1 ENVIRONMENTAL PRINCIPLES OVERVIEW ENVIRONMENTAL FOCUS
WATER
1
RAINWATER COLLECTION SYSTEM
REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN 2012 www.rup2012.rm.dk
Summary
the energy strategy 2050
The diagrams below outline the different environmental strategies on the site of The Grand Tour of EUtopia. Several of these elements will be explored in more detail.
– from coal, oil and gas to green energy
&OFSHZ 4USBUFHZ o GSPN DPBM PJM BOE HBT UP HSFFO FOFSHZ 4VNNBSZ February 2011:8
Invitation to contribute to the vision:
For information about this publication, please contact: The Danish Ministry of Climate and Energy Stormgade 2-6 1470 Copenhagen K Denmark Telephone: +45 3392 2800 Email: kemin@kemin.dk www.kemin.dk
RAIN WATER COLLECTION
2
By 2030, the Central Denmark Region will be an international growth region in a cohesive Denmark
ISBN printed publication 978-87-92727-15-2
WASTE WATER AND SEWAGE REMEDIATION
ISBN electronic publication 978-87-92727-16-9 Cover: BGRAPHIC Layout/illustrations: Solid Media Solutions Print: Litotryk København A/S Number printed: 500 copies This publication can be downloaded and ordered on www.ens.dk and via www.kemin.dk
THE DANISH GOVERNMENT February 2011
3
Adopted by the Regional Council Date: 20 June 2012
RENEWABLE ENERGY GENERATION
DANISH DEVELOPMENT DOCUMENTS
Development planning documents at Denmark’s national and regional level mandate shifts to renewable energy sources away from fossil fuels. They also outline the necessity of waste management.
CARBON FILTRATION
WASTE
DRINKING WATER
BIO FILTRATION
FERTILIZER
PRODUCTION
BIO-DIGESTER
ORGANIC WASTE & WASTE WATER
PRODUCTS
BEER
BALLOON FOREST
BREWERY
HEAT EXCHANGE
ENERGY
CHP UNIT
BAKERY
PIEZOELECTRIC TRELLIS GARDEN WIND ENERGY
BREAD
ELECTRICITY
WISTERIA GARDEN
HEATED BREAKWATER BATTERY STORAGE
HEAT PUMP
TIDAL STREAM ENERGY
WAVE ENERGY
HEAT PUMP
SUSTAINABLE PILGRIMAGE The diagram shows how energy, waste, and water make a pilgrimage around the site leading to self sustainability. THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
47
3.2 ENVIRONMENTAL PROJECT OVERVIEW ENVIRONMENTAL OVERVIEW An overall view of the systems and flows of waste, and energy on the site. How do environmental stratagies work together to create a holistic approach.
NATURAL VENTILATION AND STACK EFFECT
BIO MASS PRODUCTION
PASSIVE SOLAR GAIN
LIVING MACHINE
RAIN WATER COLLECTION
HEAT AND ELECTRICITY PRODUCTION
GREY WATER REMEDIATION
RADIENT FLOOR SYSTEM
WATER FILTRATION AND COLLECTION
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
48
3.3 ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN OVERVIEW N
SOLAR GAIN
10° 20°
BAKERY
30°
Each of the spaces in the building has southern exposure for solar gain. The wisteria trellis shades these facades during the summer months while letting light penetrate the spaces in winter. The storage cathedral has large glazed facades that allow for solar gain but are equipped with louvers to mitigate the intense summer sun.
40° 50° 60° 70° 80° 90°
W
RAINWATER COLLECTOR ROOFS
E
WISTERIA TRELLIS
STORAGE CATHEDRAL OAST HOUSE BREWERY
SOUTH FACING FACADES
LIVING MACHINE
S
SHEETPILE BREAKWATER
SUN PATH DIAGRAM
BREAKWATER MODULES
N
WIND SHELTER
NW
NE
W
E
The wall of the breakwater acts as wind break against the very strong wind arriving primarily from the West. The buildings are also arranged with the shortest length but tallest height facades facing the wind. This means the rest of the building is largely sheltered from the wind. The entrance is located on the East side of the building sheltered from the wind.
WIND BREAKING FACADE SW
SE
BREAKWATER WALL
S
WIND ROSE
WAVE PROTECTION The breakwater’s primary function is to mitigate the large waves from the North West. The energy of these waves is harnessed by the breakwater wave energy collectors. The building itself is sheltered from the waves by the breakwater protecting it from large swells.
N
m 0.
0
m
BREAKWATER BOARDWALK ENERGY COLLECTORS
Be lo w
.0
m
-1
.5 -1
0.
1. 0
5
m .5
m
-2 2. 0
m
-3 .0 2. 5
-3 .5
m 3. 0
-4 .0 3. 5
4. 0
-4
.5
m
CALM 13.81 %
WAVE HEIGHT AND DIRECTION
RAIN WATER COLLECTION The large roofscapes act as rain water collection basins to make use of the high levels of precipitation found on the West Coast of Denmark. The rain water is collected on the roofs and directed down pipes where it is filtered through a gravity assisted carbon filtration system and stored in large tanks in the breakwater wall.
TOTAL PRECIPITATION 872MM
120
100
80
60
ROOF TOP RAIN COLLECTORS 40
20
0 JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
DEC
MONTHLY PRECIPITATION THYBORØN
CONCLUSION The environmental context of the surrounding site is a primary driver of the masterplan’s formal development. Most influential are the high waves, strong winds, ample rain fall, and scarce winter sun.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
49
INVESTIGATION
3.4 ENERGY STRATEGY
How can the project site be energy self sufficient in order to align with Danish Energy policies for the future and contribute to the local community?
CONSUMPTION OF FOSSIL FUEL 1990-2050 600
SITE ENERGY SOURCES The four sources of energy produced on site align with Denmark’s strategy 2050.
500
900
SITE LOCATION Located on the wild west coast of Denmark.
800 700 600 500 400
400
300
WAVE ENERGY
200 100 0
300
200
2000
1990
TIDAL ENERGY
2010
2020
Historical Without new initiatives
2030
2040
2050
With new initiatives
WIND ENERGY RENEWABLE ENERGY 2000-2020
100
250
PJ
BIOGAS 0
200
2009 Oil Gas Coal Other RE Wind Biogas
2020 Biofuel
Biomass
150
100
DENMARK ENERGY STRATEGY 2050 The Danish Energy Agency has outlined a strategy that indicates a desire to move away from nonrenewable energy.
SOLAR POWER Solar power is not used as the winter months see the structure used most and coincide with the lowest sun levels
NATURAL COASTAL ENERGY SOURCES The coastal site has plentyful and energetic weather systems making it a site where weather based renewable energy sources are previlant and viable.
50
0 2000
Other
ENERGY PRECEDENTS
COMBINING SOURCES
2005
Wind
2010
Biogas
Biofuel
2015
2020
Biomass
ENERGY DISTRIBUTION
WAVE ENERGY Wave energy is collected along the moving breakwater boardwalk.
WAVE STAR ENERGY PLANT, DENMARK
WIND ENERGY Bladeless wind energy systems are built-in to the trellis ends on site. The integrated design does not use traditional blade based turbines because of their visual impact and potential noise production.
VORTEX BLADELESS ENERGY GENERATOR
EXCESS ENERGY TRANSPORTED TO THYBORØN
TIDAL ENERGY Tidal energy is used to take advantage of the tidal increases caused by the narrowing of the Thyborøn Limfjord channel.
ENERGY STORAGE & DISTRIBUTION Energy generation and consumption is distributed across the project site. Smaller substations collect and channel energy for local use, sending excess to the central system. Extra energy is fed back to the local Thyborøn power grid.
OPEN CENTER TURBINE, UNITED KINGDOM
CONCLUSION Wave Star Energy Systems. http://wavestarenergy.com/ Vortex Bladeless Energy. http://www.vortexbladeless.com/ European Commission. SETIS. https://setis.ec.europa.eu/setis-reports/setis-magazine/ocean-energy/open-centre-turbines-%E2%80%93invisibly-harnessing-power-of. Accessed 5 May 2017 THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Drawing energy from local renewable environmental sources utilizes the West Coast of Denmark’s natural environmental conditions and reduces Thyborøn’s nonrenewable energy requirements.
50
INVESTIGATION
3.5 ENERGY GENERATION
How can the harnessing of environmental energy processes including wave, wind, and tidal energy be integrated with the project design?
BREAKWATER BOARDWALK WAVE GENERATOR WAVE HEIGHT AT THE HARBOUR
POWER GENERATION
HYDRAULIC MOTOR AND GENERATOR When compressed fluid is released the energy turns a motor and electric generator.
WAVE HEIGHT AT THE HARBOUR
2.0
ACCUMULATOR Accumulator stores compressed fluid
1.8 1.6
N
1.4 1.2 1.0
HYDRAULIC FLUID
FLOATER Floater moves with motion of the waves
CALM 13.81 %
0.8 0.6 0.4
200
220
240
260
280
300
320
340
m
m
0 0.
m
lo Be
-1 5 0.
w
.0
m
.5 -1 0 1.
m
.5 -2 0 2.
m
.0 -3 5 2.
m
.5 -3 0 3.
.0 -4 5
4. 0
0.0
3.
-4 .5
m
0.2
200
SECTION OF MOVING BREAKWATER WAVE GENERATOR HYDRAULIC FLUID
HYDRAULIC FLUID TANK Hydraulic fluid returns to a tank where it is stored until the next wave
WAVE ENERGY GENERATOR The moving breakwater modules move up and down with the incoming waves. Thyborøn is an area with waves of high frequency and height making it an ideal place to collect wave energy year round.
WATE
R FLO
W IN
TAPERED WALL INCREASES WATER FLOW
OPEN CENTER TIDAL STREAM GENERATOR
R TE
OW
IN
FL
WA
LIGHTING
BATTERIES
W
AT
ER
FL
OW
OU
T
THYBORØN POWER
TIDAL CHANNELS ON SITE There are three tidal channels with generators on site.
TIDAL CHANNEL Tidal flow is concentrated into narrow troughs to increase flow
PIEZOELECTRIC TRELLIS WIND GENERATOR
OPEN CENTER TIDAL GENERATOR Open center tidal generators have an open center to allow marine life through. They are also very quiet.
FLEXIBLE SHAFT
WHAT IS PIEZOELECTRIC POWER GENERATION? Piezoelectric means literally ‘pressing electricity’. The technology is not new and essentially intales the compression and expansion of crystals to generate current. Arrays of these crystal panels can be used to create energy. Large scale energy harvesting is not yet commercially available but by project completion it is expected to be ready.
EXPANSION COMPRESSION
+
POWER USES Power generated is sent to uses on site and extra power is directed to Thyborøn.
ELECTRICITY
ELECTRICITY
-
WATER PUMP
POWER CREATION N
NW
NE
HEAT SOURCE
PIEZOELECTRIC MATERIAL
W
E
LIGHT WEIGHT CARBON FIBRE AND FIBRE GLASS TRELLIS END VIBRATION
SW
SE
S
European Commission. SETIS. https://setis.ec.europa.eu/setis-reports/setis-magazine/ocean-energy/opencentre-turbines-%E2%80%93-invisibly-harnessing-power-of. Accessed 5 May 2017 American Piezo Energy. https://www.americanpiezo.com. Accessed 20 April 2017
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
HEAT EXCHANGE
TRELLIS RADIANT HEAT SYSTEM The energy generated by the trellis piezoelectric generators run the pumps for the trellis radiant heat system which is connected to a heat exchange linked to heat producing elements such as the bio digesters, bakery, and brewery.
TRELLIS IRRIGATION & LIGHTING The energy generated by the trellis piezoelectric generators run the pumps for the intigrated irrigation and lighting system.
CONCLUSION The three energy sources drive the building and masterplan form. Wave energy is harnessed by the scallop shaped moving breakwater generator, tidal energy is focused through narrow channels, and wind energy vibrates the trellis. 51
3.6 WASTE MANAGEMENT
INVESTIGATION Can the project mitigate its waste production and harness its energy? ANAEROBIC DIGESTER
HEAT
WASTE STRATEGY
Waste on site is treated in several areas making use of the volume of the breakwater and increasing waste capacity for peak pilgrimage times and allowing waste from Thyborøn to be accepted as well.
BIOGAS LIVING MACHINE
IS ODOUR AN ISSUE?
BIOGAS
LIVING MACHINE
Decomposing biomass will of course have a smell however a properly maintained anaerobic digester will not smell. The ample wind on site will disperse an odour produced. By the time the fluids reach the wet land they will no longer smell
COMPLEX SUSTRATES
LIVING MACHINE PRIMARY LIVING MACHINE MEMORY BALLOON LIFTING AGENT
ACTIVE SOLIDS
LIVING MACHINE
WASTE FROM THYBORØN IS TREATED
BIOMETHANE
ELECTRICITY CHP UNIT
RØN TINY THYBO IT H S O N TAKES FROM EU! FUEL AIR
WASTE GAS
WASTE GAS FUEL EXCHANGER WARM WATER
COLD WATER
DIGESTATE STORAGE LAGOON
ELECTRICITY
ENGINE
GENERATOR
BIOFERTILIZER
LIVING MACHINE ANAEROBIC REACTOR
ANOXIC REACTOR
CLOSED AEROBIC REACTOR
OPEN AEROBIC REACTOR 1
OPEN AEROBIC REACTORS II-IV
CLARIFIER
CONSTRUCTED WETLAND
The pretreatment of high strength wastewater or for biological phosphorus removal in tertiary treatment.
For pretreatment and nitrogen removal via denitrification in tertiary treatment.
The first phase of aerobic treatment for high strength waste with a built-in biofilter for odor removal.
Aerated open tanks contain plants that are adapted to a high strength wastewater environment. During the process, the organic contaminants are converted into bacterial biomass
As the wastewater flows through each stage, its strength is reduced and organisms take part in the treatment process. In addition to plants, animals including fish can be found in the tanks.
Bacterial biomass is separated from water and recycled to the front to continue to digest the soluble organic content of the wastewater. A small fraction is removed as excess sludge.
These ecosystems can be located indoors and outside. They are used to provide a high level of polishing removal of colloids and further denitrification.
TOILET WATER
IRRIGATION
GRAVITY ASSISTED LIVING MACHINE The open air stages of the living machine are contained in a series of terraced ponds. This way gravity does the work and the system uses less energy GREY WATER GREY WATER
HEAT EXCHANGE SYSTEM
HEAT
LOCATION OF PRIMARY LIVING MACHINE
WAS TE
WAT ER
HUMAN WASTE
BAKERY / FOOD WASTE
BREWERY WASTE
RADIANT SYSTEM
CONCLUSION The living machine including the anaerobic bio-digesters will manage the site’s waste without burdening Thyborøn’s sewage system or polluting the local water. It also connects to a heat exchange warming the buildings!
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
52
INVESTIGATION
3.7 WATER: RAIN COLLECTION AND FILTRATION
The project will see large influxes of people. Can rain water serve the drinking water needs of the site and avoid overloading the poor quality local aquifers?
ROOFTOP RAIN WATER COLLECTORS
DAYS OF RAIN THYBORØN
COLLECTED RAINWATER WILL BE OF A BETTER QUALITY THAN SURROUNDING GROUND WATER DUE TO FEWER CONTAMINANTS
30 28 26 24 22 20 18 16 14 12 12 10 8 6 4 2 0
16 13 10
9
14
11 9 7
7
7
7
RAINWATER COLLECTORS AT ROOFTOPS
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
DEC
MONTHLY PRECIPITATION THYBORØN TOTAL PRECIPITATION 872
MM
120
100
80
60
40
CARBON FILTERS INSIDE BREAKWATER
20
0 JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
DEC
STORAGE TANKS INSIDE BREAKWATER
PARTICULARLY VALUABLE VALUABLE LESS VALUABLE
KEEPING WATER CLEAN The filters and tanks are seperated in order to mitigate potential contamination. GROUND WATER VALUE The ground water around Thyborøn is considered less valuable than other parts of Denmark. This is because of its low quality due to its low elevation, high salt content, and agricultural polutant levels. The rain water collected will be of a higher quality than the typical ground water available.
N
CALCULATING RAIN WATER COLLECTION
ROOFTOP RAINWATER BASIN
ANNUAL PRECIPITATION (mm) x effective collection area (m²) x drainage coefficient (%)x filter efficiency (%) x 0.05
Hey! This beer’s got that ANNUAL PRECIPITAION (mm) = 872 unique Grand Tour flavour. Must be the EFFECTIVE COLLECTION AREA (m²) = 3,423 water! DRAINAGE COEFFICIENT (%) = 0.8
GRAVITY FED SYSTEM
FILTER EFFICIENCY (%) = 0.9
FILTER LAYERS
872 x 3423 x 0.8 x 0.9 x 0.05 = 104,743.8 LITERS
GRAVEL PALM FIBER SAND CHLORINE GRAVEL GRAPHENE OXIDE ALUM PALM FIBER PEBBLE
104,743.8 LITERS 104.74 M³ PER YEAR
GRAVITY AIDED GRAPHENE OXIDE MEMBRANE The University of Manchester has developed a graphene membrane capable of seperating organic solvents from water including salt and other particles. This technology is currently being tested for mass production, by completion the filter will be available. The graphene layer can be used in layered filtration assembly.
FILTERED WATER STORAGE
FRESH WATER OUTPUT
BREWERY
SHOWERS
BAKERY
DRINKING WATER
CONCLUSION Climate Data.org. Climate Thyborøn. Https://en.climate-data.org/location/861222/. Accessed 21 Mar 2017 Harvesting rainwater for domestic uses: an information guide. Environment Agency. https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/environment-agency The University of Manchester. Graphene: Manchester’s Revolutionary 2D Material. http://www.graphene.manchester.ac.uk/ Accessed 10 May 2017 BBC News. Graphene-Based Sieve Turns Seawater Into Drinking Water. http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-39482342 THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Large roof planes are designed to collect rain water. The large volume of the breakwater wall is used to contain storage tanks.
53
INVESTIGATION
3.8 SOLAR AND VENTILATION STRATEGY
How can passive environmental strategies be harnessed to daylight and ventilate the building?
ROOF LIGHTS AND SOUTHERN EXPOSURE
STORAGE CATHEDRAL VENTILATION N
STORAGE CATHEDRAL
OAST HOUSE LIGHTING ANALYSIS
STORAGE CATHEDRAL LOUVRES ON SOUTH FACADE
2
1
LOUVERS
2
WISTERIA TRELLIS
1
SUMMER SOLSTICE 21 JUNE 53.08˚
HORIZONTAL LOUVRES AT SOUTH FACADE
LOUVER SUPPORT
EQUINOX 20 MARCH 30.25˚
REFLECTIVE LOUVER INDIRECT LIGHT
WINTER SOLSTICE 21 DECEMBER 7.91˚
INTAKE VENTS ON BREAKWATER WALL
GLASS WINDOW
EXHAUST VENTS AT CEILING OF STORAGE CATHEDRAL
UTILIZING PASSIVE VENTILATION PRINCIPLES
CROSS VENTILATION, STACK EFFECT, AND GROUND COUPLED HEAT EXCHANGE The building regulates its interior temperature through cross ventilation and the stack effect. Cold air is directed into the building low on the breakwater where its temperature is regulated by the ocean water. From there it is drawn through the mass of the subterranean breakwater operating as a ground coupled heat exchange venting into the buildings and exhausted through the storage cathedral. The temperature difference and pressure difference draw the air continuously through the building.
WINTER WISTERIA
SUMMER WISTERIA
The cut back and bare wisteria allows light through the trellis
Flowering wisteria provides shade to the areas below.
DAYLIGHT ANALYSIS: OAST HOUSE DIVA TEST 1
ADJUSTING THE DESIGN
DAYLIGHT AUTONOMY (300 lux) Mean daylight Autonomy = 53.46
CHANNEL GLAZING INSULATION 80mm Okapane translucent acrylic insulation between surface 2 and 3
Daylit area = 62 % of floor area. Daylight Factor Analysis 15% of all sensors have a daylight factor of 2% or higher Continuous Daylight Autonomy The mean continuous daylight autonomy is 69%
The work carried out in the Oast House is not precision work so 300 lux should be sufficient, however, should more light be required interior lighting can be activated.
Useful Daylight Illuminance The % of space with UDI 100-2000lux larger than 50% is 100%
Solemma LLC. DIVA-for-Rhino. http://www.solemma.net/ THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Daylit area = 100 % of floor area. Daylight Factor Analysis 96% of all sensors have a daylight factor of 2% or higher Continuous Daylight Autonomy The mean continuous daylight autonomy is 84% Useful Daylight Illuminance The % of space with UDI 100-2000lux larger than 50% is 82%
100%
50%
N
0%
N INTERIOR GLAZING Diffusing, acid-etched two-ply laminated with PVB UV interlayer
DAYLIGHT AUTONOMY (300 lux) Mean daylight Autonomy = 76
Areas coloured below 50% daylit are not sufficiently illuminated.
100%
EXTERIOR GLAZING Colour free, low iron double plank channel glass. Pebbled texture and light sandblasting on surface 1 and 2.
INTERIOR GLAZING In order to achieve a higher level of daylight in the Oast house the interior glazing was changed. Originally it was a translucent glazing with only 20% transmittance of light, this was changed to a 50% transmittance glazing to allow light to penetrate into the middle of the room.
TEST 2
50%
WALL ASSEMBLY
0%
OAST HOUSE CAVITY WALL
CONCLUSION The form of the building can be used to passively light and ventilate effectively. By using passive strategies the building will consume less energy while maintaining air quality and comfort.
54
3.9 INSULATION: CALCULATING THERMAL PERFORMANCE
INVESTIGATION Can innovative insulation types achieve necessary thermal resistance in the water collector roof assembly?
WATER COLLECTOR ROOF SECTION
DETAIL OF ROOF ASSEMBLY 1:10 DOES WATER HAVE AN R VALUE? Water essentially has an R value of 0. With one side against the warm building and one side against the cool air a convection loop is established transferring heat efficiently. Water does have excellent thermal mass but must be insulated from the outdoors.
1
2 3
4
ROOF SECTION LOCATION 5
6 7 8 9
ROOF ASSEMBLY 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
WHAT TYPE OF INSULATION TO USE? Different types of insulation have different advantages and disadvantages. What kind of insulation balances cost, effectiveness, and project narrative? TYPE
ADVANTAGES
DISADVANTAGES
BATTS AND BLANKETS EX: FIBERGLASS
NON-FLAMMABLE RESISTANT TO MOISTURE
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES, IRRITANT
LOOSE FILL EX: CELLULOSE
ENVIRONMENTALLY FRIENDLY PAPER/CARDBOARD
RISK OF MOISTURE AND PEST INFESTATION
DENIM
RECYCLED MATERIAL, MAKES USE OF PILGRIM’S OLD CLOTHES
POTENTIALLY MORE EXPENSIVE AND DIFFICULT TO INSTALL
INSULATED PANELS
HANDLES HIGH TEMPERATURES
MORE DIFFICULT INSTALLATION
SPRAY FOAM
EXCELLENT AIR BARRIER, FITS ODD SHAPES
EXPENSIVE, NOT VERY THICK
0-300mm VARIABLE WATER LEVEL 10mm MARBLE TILE 2 LAYERS WATERPROOF MEMBRANE 200mm COMPOSITE CONCRETE DECK 360mm INSULATION FILLED CAVITY 40mm RIGID INSULATION 40mm STEEL STUD FRAMING 10mm RIGID BACKBOARD 10mm MARBLE TILE
CALCULATING ASSEMBLY INSULATION VALUES
WHY DENIM?
MATERIAL
THICKNESS
R VALUE
R VALUES ROOF
MARBLE TILE
10mm
0.00483
RSI inside surface = 0.10
WATERPROOF MEMBRANE
2mm
0.05
CONCRETE DECKING
200mm
0.1
DENIM INSULATION
360mm
7
RIGID INSULATION
40mm
1.4
PLYWOOD
10mm
0.09
MARBLE TILE
10mm
0.00483
U=
Denim insulation allows pilgrims to contribute to the materials used on site. Denim insulation is an existing product available from several manufacturers with excellent thermal properties.
1 RSI + RSO + RA + R1 + R2 + R3 ...
U = 0.11377
1
OLD DENIM IS COLLECTED AND SORTED
DENIM PULP IS PRESSED INTO SHEETS AND ROLLED FOR TRANSPORT
DENIM IS SHREDDED UNTIL CONSISTENT PULP AND METAL BUTTONS REMOVED
DENIM SHEETS ARE CUT ON SITE AND INSTALLED LIKE REGULAR BATT STYLE INSULATION
Baden-Powell, Charlotte. Architect’s Pocket Handbook. Elsevier, Oxford, 2002 Inno Therm Cotton And Denim Thermal Insulation. http://www.inno-therm.com/. Accessed 10 May 2017
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
2
RS0 outside surface = 0.04
PASSIVHAUS The standard U value for passivhaus certification is 0.15. The extremely thick denim insulation layer in the beam cavity helps this assembly reach U=0.11. There is risk of thermal bridging at the beams.
DEFINITIONS
EQUATIONS
THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY (k-value) The heat (W) transmitted through unit area (m²) of material of unit thickness (m) for unit temperature difference (K) between inside and outside environments, expressed as W/mK
U=
THERMAL RESISTANCE (r-value) A measure of how well a material resists the flow of heat by conduction. The reciprocal of thermal conductivity, mK/W
R=
3
THERMAL RESISTANCE (R-value) This means how well a particular thickness of material resists the passage of heat by conduction, calculated from the r-value in units of m²K/W.
4
THERMAL TRANSMITTANCE (U-value) The reciprocal of thermal resistance W/m²K. This measures the amount of heat transmitted per unit area of the fabric per unit temperature difference between inside and outside
1 RSI + RSO + RA + R1 + R2 ...
K-value Material thickness
CONCLUSION The use of denim insulation is both effective and allows the pilgrims to take part in the supply of construction materials.
55
3.10 OCCUPANT COMFORT
FUNCTION
RECEPTION
LOCATION
RATIONALE
Issue:reception The reception The area willarea see will seedifferences large changes in large in the occupants. Those arriving number of occupants. With will beat times dressedof arrival. much influxes warmerjust thanarriving those working Those will be in the space. dressed warmly. It will be Response: to Area behinda difficult maintain reception temperature desk fitted comfortable for with the radiant both guestsfloor andsystem. those Installation vestibule. working in ofthe reception area.
TEMPERATURE
LIGHT LEVEL
NATURALY VENTILATED FULLY ENCLOSED ACCOUSTIC CONTROL 16-20 ˚C
200 lux
Issue: Workrooms and must have sufficient daylight and Workrooms, occupiable acoustic control rooms in institutions, Response: rooms, Operabledining sun teaching screensmust control sun. areas have the sufficient daylight for the roomspanels to be Suspended ceiling well lit. acoustic effects. mitigate
MEETING ROOMS
KITCHEN
NATURALY VENTILATED FULLY ENCLOSED ACCOUSTIC CONTROL 18 ˚C
Issue: High levels of ventilation necessary High levels of are ventilation are in this space to keep necessary in this space.it comfortable with hot Keeping the temperature kitchen equipment comfortable is challenging Response: with hot kitchen Mechanical equipment ventilation is added to the working. space to increase air floor and temperature control
300 lux
ARTIFICIALLY VENTILATED FULLY ENCLOSED ACCOUSTIC CONTROL 18 ˚C
500 lux
Issue: The storage cathedral’s The storage cathedral a temperature only has tois be large space. Interior lightly controlled however temperature herebe islowless humidity should for regulated however the storage of hops.humidity must be mitigated to insureis Response: The space that dried with hops a are not ventilated passive subject moisture. system,torelying on the low
STORAGE CATHEDRAL
local humidity for storage climate.
BAKERY
Issue: Similar to the kitchen Similar to isthe kitchento the the bakery adjacent hot bakery is adjacent to hot ovens. Working temperature equipment. Making bread must be controlled. by hand can Mechanical be labour Response: intensive hot work. ventilation assists passive systems. For moderate conditions operable windows mitigate temperature.
BREWERY
BANQUET BRIDGE
The brewery a factory type Issue: The is brewery is a environment workers factory type with environment not preforming highly with workers performing low physical physicaltasks. exertion tasks. Response: The space is warmed by internal brewing equipment and ventilated passively through stack effect.
Issue: The banquet room The banqueton room located is located theis moving on the moving bridge. bridge. Environmental Environmental controls only controls are only needed need available when whentothebebridge is down. the bridge isWhen down. lowered When Response: down bridgelinks links into the the bridge into passive systems in thesystems rest of adjacent passive the building. which can be supplemented by operable windows.
REQUIREMENTS
NATURALY VENTILATED FULLY ENCLOSED
16 ˚C
300 lux
ACCOUSTIC CONTROL
ARTIFICIALLY VENTILATED FULLY ENCLOSED 16 ˚C
500 lux
ACCOUSTIC CONTROL
NATURALLY VENTILATED FULLY ENCLOSED
16 ˚C
300 lux
ACCOUSTIC CONTROL
NATURALLY VENTILATED FULLY ENCLOSED
20 ˚C
200 lux
ACCOUSTIC CONTROL
Baden-Powell, Charlotte. Architect’s Pocket Handbook. Elsevier, Oxford, 2002 Autodesk. Measuring Light Levels. Sustainabilityworkshop.autodesk.com/buildings/measuring-light-levels Accessed 8 May 2017 THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
56
3.11 ATMOSPHERIC LIGHTING DESIGN LIGHTING DESIGN PRECEDENTS
OAST HOUSE TRANSLUCENT CAVITY WALL
ATMOSPHERE VIEW
OAST HOUSE LIGHTING EFFECT The oast house has a cavity wall lined with translucent glass. Inside the channel lighting is reflected against the interior wall and further diffused through the sandblasted channel glass facade.
REFLECTING FIXTURE
CHANNEL GLAZING INSULATION 80mm Okapane translucent acrylic insulation between surface 2 and 3
RUDJERG KNUDE LIGHT HOUSE, JUTLAND
EXTERIOR GLAZING Colour free, low iron double plank channel glass. Pebbled texture and light sandblasting on surface 1 and 2.
INTERIOR GLAZING Diffusing, acid-etched two-ply laminated with PVB UV interlayer CHANNEL LIGHTING 3500K Florescent lighting tubes with reflective housing
ATMOSPHERE: CREATING A BEACON FOR ARRIVING PILGRIMS The Oast House is lit up in order to become a signal of arrival for pilgrims coming to the site by sea.
NELSON-ATKINS MUSEUM OF ART, STEVEN HOLL
STORAGE CATHEDRAL PENDANTS JUNCTION BOX
TRANSFORMER
PILGRIM PROVIDED LIGHTING The different vessels brought by pilgrims are reused and turned into lighting. The storage cathedral requires minimal activity lighting and the jar and bottle lights provide atmosphere at night.
BRAIDED COAXIAL CABLE OMER ARBEL LIGHTS LONDON DESIGN FESTIVAL, VICTORIA AND ALBERT MUSEUM
FIXTURE LID LED LIGHT
PILGRIM JAR
ATMOSPHERE: CREATING A REFLECTIVE SPACE The Storage Cathedral is lit by bottle lamps to remind pilgrims of what was brought to the site by others.
CHANDELIER 2009, KATHERINE HARVEY
WISTERIA TRELLIS ATMOSPHERIC LIGHTING
SPOT UPLIGHTING ASHIKAGA PARK WISTERIA LIGHTING, JAPAN
ASHIKAGA PARK WISTERIA LIGHTING, JAPAN
ATMOSPHERE: MAKING AN ACCEPTING SPACE The intimate and accommodating lighting of the wisteria reminds the pilgrims of the flower’s symbolism of acceptance.
CONCLUSION The appearance of the project is highlighted from different perspectives. To an arriving pilgrim the Oast house is a beacon. The cathedral lighting is meditative, and the trellis lighting highlights the accommodating nature of the wisteria. THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
57
3.12 ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT: WISTERIA MAINTENANCE ATMOSPHERIC PRECEDENTS
SUMMER WISTERIA SECTION
FALL PROTECTION
TRACK SYSTEM LATERAL WINCH SYSTEM
WINTER MOBILE COVER
TOSHI YOSHIDA, WISTERIA AT USHIJIMA
INTEGRATED SCISSOR LIFT
WINCH SYSTEM MOTOR WINTER SUSPENDED STAGE SCAFFOLD
20m
DIRECTION OF MOVEMENT
10m
WISTERIA SIZE The largest Wisteria in the world is in Sierra Madre, California and covers over 0.40 hectares.
SUMMER
HOW DO YOU MAINTAIN A WISTERIA?
THE GARDENER SUMMER YEAR 1
BIOMASS COMPOSTING AND FERTILIZING WISTERIA
CLIPPINGS
PRUNE SIDE SHOOTS 3-5 BUDS
I live in Thyborøn, gardening was a hobby of mine until the Grand Tour of EUtopia arrived, now I get paid to do what I love!
TIE STRONGEST BRANCHES TO TRELLIS
TIE MAIN STEM FOR SUPPORT
WINTER YEAR 1 TRIM MAIN STEM TO 75mm ABOVE SIDE BRANCHES
TIE SELECTED BRANCHES TO TRELLIS. CUT BACK BY 1/3
SUMMER YEAR 3 CONTINUE TO TIE IN STRONGEST BRANCHES
FERTILIZER
BIODIGESTER
WISTERIA MAINTENANCE Wisteria needs to be pruned twice a year once in late winter to prepare the flowering spurs for the forthcoming season, and again in mid-summer. Summer pruning controls long, whippy shoots that are heading off into the distance, and encourages them to become flowering spurs instead.
AFTER FLOWERING CUT SIDESHOOTS BACK 3-5 BUDS FROM MAIN BRANCHES
WINTER YEAR 3 CUT BACK THE SIDESHOOTS PRUNED IN SUMMER TO 2-3 BUDS. THESE WILL BE THE FLOWERING SHOOTS NEXT SEASON
CUT BACK MAIN BRANCHES TO FIT TRELLIS
HAND SHEARS
HEDGE SHEARS
LOPPER
LONG REACH LOPPER AND SAW
CONCLUSION Royal Horticultural Society. www.rhs.org.uk Accessed 8 May 2017 How to grow wisteria. http://www.thompson-morgan.com/ Accessed 8 May 2017 THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
The Wisteria Acceptance Trellis is more than just an aesthetic addition to the project. It is important for its solar shading, employment opportunities, and integration into the bio-digester fertilizer cycle. 58
BUILDING PROCUREMENT
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
04
59
4.1 CLIENTS AND CONTRACTS CLIENT: EUROPEAN UNION AND THE EUROPE 2020 STRATEGY
CONTRACT ANALYSIS APPLICABLE DANISH AUTHORITIES
Description of Services
Building and Planning
KEY POLICIES
Danish Association of Consulting Engineers
DESCRIPTION OF SERVICES
To raise the employment rate of the population aged 20–64 from the current 69% to at least 75%. To achieve the target of investing 3% of GDP in R&D in particular by improving the conditions for R&D investment by the private sector, and develop a new indicator to track innovation. To reduce greenhouse gas emissions by at least 20% compared to 1990 levels or by 30% if the conditions are right, increase the share of renewable energy in final energy consumption to 20%, and achieve a 20% increase in energy efficiency. To reduce the share of early school leavers to 10% from the current 15% and increase the share of the population aged 30–34 having completed tertiary from 31% to at least 40%. To reduce the number of Europeans living below national poverty lines by 25%, lifting 20 million people out of poverty.
STANDARD CONTRACT AB92
UNDERSTANDING CONSULTANCY ROLES INITIAL CONSULTANCY 1.1 Appraisal 1.2 Design Specification
DESIGN MANAGEMENT CONSULTANCY 2.1 Design Management 2.2 Ict Management
FLAGSHIP INITIATIVES DESIGN PHASE CONSULTANCY 3.1 Outline Proposal 3.2 Project Proposal 3.3 Preliminary Project Regulatory
Innovation Union: to improve framework conditions and access to finance for research and innovation. Youth on the move: to enhance the performance of education systems. A digital agenda for Europe: to speed up the roll-out of high-speed internet and reap the benefits of a Digital Single Market. Resource efficient Europe: to help decouple economic growth from the use of resources, by decarbonising the economy, increasing the use of renewable sources, modernising the transport sector and promoting energy efficiency. An industrial policy for the globalisation era: to improve the business environment, especially for SMEs, and to support the development of a strong and sustainable industrial base able to compete globally. An agenda for new skills and jobs: to modernise labour markets by facilitating labour mobility and the development of skills. European platform against poverty: to ensure social and territorial cohesion such that the benefits of growth and jobs are widely shared.
CONSTRUCTION PHASE CONSULTANCY 4.1 Construction Management 4.2 Site Supervision
OPERATIONAL PHASE CONSULTANCY 5.1 Preparation Of An Operation And Maintenance Plan 5.2 Implementation Of The Plan
IDENTIFYING POSSIBLE FUNDING INITIATIVES THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia KEY FUNDING CRITERIA 1 REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
4
SOCIAL INCLUSION
2 TERRITORIAL CO-OPERATION
5
PARTNERSHIP IN EMPLOYMENT
3 ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
6
DIVERSIFYING COASTAL ECONOMIES
THE EUROPEAN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT FUND (ERDF)
THE COHESION FUND
PLANNING CONSULTANCY 7.1 Planning Tasks 7.2 Brief And Work Programme 7.3 Preparatory Work
THE EUROPEAN SOCIAL FUND (ESF)
7.4 Problem Description 7.5 Forecasts 7.6 Objectives 7.7 Alternative Plans
7.8 Impact Assessment 7.9 Public Comment Procedures
CONTRACT CRITERIA TIME
The ESF focuses on increasing the adaptability of workers and enterprises, enhancing access to employment and participation in the labour market, reinforcing social inclusion by combating discrimination and facilitating access to the labour market for disadvantaged people, and promoting partnership for reform in the fields of employment and inclusion.
European Maritime and Fisheries Fund (EMFF)
€ 63.4 BILLION
€ 6.4 BILLION
The Cohesion Fund contributes to interventions in the field of the environment and trans-European transport networks. It applies to member states with a Gross National Income (GNI) of less than 90% of the EU average.
Helps fishermen in the transition to sustainable fishing, as well as supports coastal communities in diversifying their economies and finances projects that create new jobs and improve quality of life along European coasts makes it easier for applicants to access financing.
The Danish Association of Consulting Engineers (FRI) and the Danish Association of Architectural Firms (DANSKE ARK) . Description of Services Building and Planning 2012 General Conditions for Consulting Services. ABR 89 RIBA Plan of Work. https://www.ribaplanofwork.com/ THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
5.3 Assistance With Property Operation
FITTINGS, FIXTURES AND EQUIPMENT CONSULTANCY 6.1 Standard Fittings, Fixtures And Equipment 6.2 Design Of Fittings, Fixtures And Equipment
€ 256 BILLION The ERDF supports programs addressing regional development, economic change, enhanced competitiveness and territorial co-operation throughout the EU. Funding priorities include modernizing economic structures, creating sustainable jobs and economic growth, research and innovation, environmental protection and risk prevention.
3.4 Main Project 3.5 Project Follow-up
COST
QUALITY
MANAGEMENT CONTRACT In identifying the relationship between time, cost, and quality the Grand Tour of EUtopia construction in Thyborøn is most concerned over time scale and quality. In order to minimize the environmental impact of construction a short construction period is important. Quality is also key to representing the strength of the Union and ensuring that maintenance costs are low on such a major piece of infrastructure. Contracts can be broken down into smaller segments and distributed for prefabrication contracts in order to speed up construction.
EARLIEST START DATE GUARANTEE OVER DELAYS EARLIEST COMPLETION DATE
LOWEST COST BEST VALUE MOST EFFICIENT
HIGHEST QUALITY LOW MAINTENANCE DETAIL CONTROL
CONCLUSION Selecting the right contract is important to the satisfaction of all parties involved. In this case quality and time are of highest importance to the project.
60
4.2 BUILDING COST ESTIMATION RECEPTION HALL
BREWERY AND BAKERY
629m²
1041m²
TYPE: Factory: Owner Occupation For Light Industrial Use COST PER/m²: €1165
TYPE: Hotel Accommodation Facilities: Restaurant Areas COST PER/m²: €1836
TOTAL: €990,675
TOTAL: €1,212,765
TOTAL: €3,488,400
STORAGE CATHEDRAL
MEETING ROOMS AND ADMINISTRATION
OAST HOUSE
TYPE: Hotel Accommodation Facilities: Front Of House And Reception COST PER/m²: €1575
800m²
RESTAURANT, BANQUET BRIDGE, AND KITCHEN
1900m²
TYPE: Factory: Owner Occupation For Light Industrial Use COST PER/m²: €1575
TYPE: Hotel Accommodation Facilities: Function Rooms/conference Facilities TYPE: Factory: Owner Occupation For Light Industrial Use COST PER/m²: €1575 COST PER/m²: €1575
334m²
825m²
TOTAL: €932,000
TOTAL: €526,050
TOTAL: €1,299,375
TASTING ROOMS
RECIPE BOOK LIBRARY
ENGINEERING WORKS: SHEETPILE, CONCRETE
160m²
212m²
33,975m² SHEETPILE + 11,112m³ CONCRETE CAP
TYPE: Hotel Accommodation Facilities: Bar Areas COST PER/m²: €1661
TYPE: Library COST PER/m²: €3265
TYPE: Sheetpile wall and concrete poured in-situ COST PER/m²: €178 (sheetpile) + €87 (concrete in-situ)
TOTAL: €185,760
TOTAL: €692,180
TOTAL: €7,014,294
REFERENCE
ESTIMATED BUILDING COST COSTING REFERENCE Spon’s Architects and builders Price book was used a source for cost estimation.
990,675 1,212,765 3,488,400 932,000 526,050 1,299,375 185,760 692,180 7,014,294
}
NOTES This cost total is reflective only of the areas directly related to the building itself and not the overall masterplan area.
€16,341,499
This cost estimate is also conservative. It can be assumed that costs of construction would be considerable more expensive due to the location of project in a marine area. Costing does not include potential weather delays, and transportation costs of prefabricated elements. For instance the estimated cost of decommissioning and transporting a north sea oil rig is €60,470,856 according to the Danish Sustainable Offshore Decommissioning Project.
Aecom. Spon’sArchitects’ and Builders’ Price Book. CRC Press. 2015
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
61
4.3 PROJECT SCHEDULE: GANTT CHART CONSTRUCTION PROGRAMME
2020
2021
2022
JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC
JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC
JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC
PRE-CONSTRUCTION PHASES PRE-CONSTRUCTION
Set Up Site Office Environmental Protection Set Up Staging Area Construction 2016
OFFSITE CONSTRUCTION
Oil Rig Salvage And Retrofit Prefabrication: Steel Frames Prefabrication: Pilgrim Rest House Frames Prefabrication: Storage tanks, Brewing Equipment Prefabrication: Breakwater Modules Prefabrication: Trellis Frames
ONSITE CONSTRUCTION
CHAPTER 2.0
MAIN BUILDING CONSTRUCTION Primary Structural Element Sheetpile driving Primary Structural Element Sheetpile concrete fill and cap Primary Structural Element Storage Cathedral Frame Installation Secondary Structural Element Banquet Bridge Installation Secondary Structural Element Delivery and Installation of Steel Frames Secondary Structural Element Tasting Room Installation Secondary Structural Element Oast House Construction Roof Construction Living Machine Construction Trellis Frames craned and fixed in place Roof Light Installation Soil Delivery and Wisteria Planting Equipment Installation Interior Furnishings And Millwork Fit-Out Removal of Equipment Equipment Testing and Completion
COMPLETION
CONCLUSION The construction sequence identifies the various time lines of completion for different fabrication and construction elements. The gantt chart illustrates how schedules can be completed in parallel for efficient delivery. THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
62
4.4 HEALTH AND SAFETY PREPARING HEALTH AND SAFETY RISK ASSESSMENT
HEALTH AND SAFETY REFERENCES
Every company with employees must prepare a health and safety (H&S) risk assessment. This is an EU rule that applies all over Europe. The H&S risk assessment process helps determine whether you have any problems relating to health and safety and helps you draw up a plan for addressing any problems before someone gets injured. The H&S risk assessment can therefore contribute to a good working environment. Important requirements for the H&S risk assessment: The risk assessment must be prepared jointly by the employer and the health and safety organization or the employees. The risk assessment must be written down either on paper or electronically. The risk assessment must be available at the workplace such that management, the employees and the Danish Working Environment Authority (WEA) can read it. The risk assessment must contain a survey of the company’s health and safety initiatives and a description of any problems. You must also include the company’s sick absence statistics. If there are health and safety-related problems, the risk assessment must also include an action plan for addressing any problems that cannot be solved immediately. The risk assessment must be revised at least every three years
IDENTIFYING CONSTRUCTION HAZARDS
ACCIDENTS DUE TO FALLING
ACCIDENTS WITH TOOLS
ACCIDENTS DUE LIFTING OR MOVING HEAVY OBJECTS
ACCIDENTS DUE TO MACHINERY
HEALTH AND SAFETY ROLES AND INFORMATION EXCHANGE
DESIGNER ROLES This diagram shows how information relates to each other and the responsibilities of the key stakeholders in the project. Designers should consider the information they provide about how their designs reduce and control foreseeable risks.
ACTIONS TO MITIGATE HEALTH AND SAFETY RISK PREPARE A HEALTH AND SAFETY PLAN The risk of a project can be mitigated with a well thought out plan and the communication of that plan with the contractor.
START OF PROJECT CLIENT: Client to check what documents are already in their possession that will be relevant to the project. Including an existing health and safety file.
PREFABRICATION A large portion of the project is prefabricated. By working in a closed, consistent, and supervised environment the work can be conducted more safely.
PRE-CONSTRUCTION INFORMATION (PCI) CLIENT AND PRINCIPAL DESIGNER: Assess adequacy of existing information Agree arrangements to fill gaps in existing information Provide sufficient information to designers and contractors
PROCESS OF DESIGN PRINCIPAL DESIGNER: Must take account of PCI to: Eliminate, reduce or control foreseeable risks in their designs Provide Information about measures taken in designs to reduce or control risks not eliminated Principle Designer must take information into account in the PCI and the health and safety file Provide it to the principal contractor towards the construction phase plan.
CONSTRUCTION PHASE PLAN PRINCIPAL DESIGNER: CLIENT: Ensure the plan is drawn up before construction phase begins PRINCIPLE CONTRACTOR Draw up the plan on the basis of pre-constrcution information, information provided with designs PRINCIPLE DESIGNER Help the PC prepare the plan PRINCIPLE CONTRACTOR Ensure the plan is appropriately reviewed updated and revised Address any significant changes to risks involved and controls put in place
ACCIDENTS DUE TO OBJECTS MOVING OR SLIDING
PREFABRICATION: STAGING AREA Prefabricated elements are first brought to the staging area where they are preassembled so they just have to be craned into place. This limits on site work which may be dangerous due to weather, low light, heights, etc.
HEALTH AND SAFETY FILE CLIENT: Ensure the PD prepares the file PRINCIPLE DESIGNER to prepare the file in cooperation with the PC To ensure the file is appropriately updated reviewed and revised PRINCIPLE CONTRACTOR To provide PD with relevant information for inclusion in the file PRINCIPLE DESIGNER To pass the file to the client at the end of the project PRINCIPLE DESIGNER To pass the file to the PC if the PD’s appointment ends before the project finishes
PROPER TRAINING Ensuring workers are properly trained means that they are aware of the risks and the content of the health and safety plan. PROPER EQUIPMENT Having strict rules about equipment ensures worker safety. Work cannot be conducted without proper hard hats, work boots, ear plugs, eye protection, high visibility vests, gloves, and fall protection.
END OF PROJECT CLIENT: To retain the health and safety file and ensure it is available for any subsequent construction work on the building If the client disposes of the their interest in the building they must provide the file to anyone who takes on the client duties.
Managing health and safety in construction: Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015. http://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/priced/l153.pdf https://osha.europa.eu/en Arbejdstilsynet. Don’t Gamble with your saftey on the construction site. www.arbejdstilsynet.dk
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
63
APPENDIX
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
05
64
5.2 MODEL PHOTOS STORAGE CATHEDRAL ITERATIONS
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
69
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
1 2 3
9
4 5
7
8
10 6 13 12
11
14
15
16 17
18
CONTEXT: SITE PHOTOGRAPH KEY Locations of photographs taken of Thyborøn Denmark.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
70
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
1
2
3
4
5
6
CONTEXT: SITE PHOTOGRAPHS Photographs of site Thyborøn Denmark.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
71
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
CONTEXT: SITE PHOTOGRAPHS Photographs of site Thyborøn Denmark.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
72
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
BUNKERS IN THYBORØN Photographs of Atlantic Wall bunkers in the town of Thyborøn Denmark.
Agger-Thyboron Coastal Batteries. krigsturist.dk http://www.wartourist.eu/. Accessed 1 November 2016 THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
73
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
SOCIO-ECONOMIC STATUS 2013
LANDSDEL VESTJYLLAND
DENMARK -0,4%
-2,2%
REGION MIDTJYLLAND
LANSDEL ØSTJYLLAND 0,1%
-0,7%
STRUER
RINGKØBING-SKJERN
NORDDJURS
SAMSØ
LEMVIG
SYDDJURS
RANDERS -1,8%
-2,6%
SKIVE
VIBORG -1,6%
-1,7%
HEDENSTED
FAVRSKOV
-1,6%
HOLSTEBRO
-0,8%
HERNING
-0,6%
ODDER 0,1%
0,7%
-0,5%
0,8% AARHUS
RETREAT IN EDUCATION TEMP OUTSIDE LABOR FORCE UNEMPLOYED EMPLOYED
IKAST-BRANDE
4% 5% 4%
1,3%
2% 5% 3%
HORSENS 1,2%
OUTSIDE THE LABOR FORCE
9%
SILKEBORG
4%
12%
SKANDERBORG
3%
3,2%
EMPLOYMENT CREATION
73%
-8,7%
DENMARK
-6,8%
LEMVIG
-6,3%
-5,9%
-4,9%
76%
LABOR FORCE AND EMPLOYMENT FROM 2003-2013
EMPLOYMENT DEVELOPMENT 2013-2023
LEMVIG WORKFORCE
LEMVIG EMPLOYMENT
DENMARK’S WORKFORCE
DENMARK’S EMPLOYMENT
OVERALL 85%
120
UNSKILLED WORKERS, STUDENTS ETC.
SHORT HIGHER EDUCATION
74
124
MEDIUM FURTHER EDUCATION
SHARE OF 20-64 YEAR OLDS
UFAGLÆRTE, STUDENTER MV.
-494
80% 75% 70% -
-61
65% 60% 55%
115
LONG FURTHER EDUCATION 50% 2003
JOBS BY KOMMUNE 2013
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
JOBS PER 100 INHABITANTS
THYBORØN
HARBOØRE
NØRRE NISSUM LEMVIG
BÆKMARKSBRO
13 - 500
41 - 60
501 - 1,000
61 - 80
1,001 - 1,500
81 - 100
1,501 - 8,350
101 - 161
STATISTICS: EMPLOYMENT Employment trends for the municipality of Lemvig. Lemvig Kommune has the fifth lowest employment in the Midtjylland Region.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Lemvig Kommune Statistics. regionmidtjylland. https://www.rm.dk/regional-udvikling/statistik-og-analyse/ midt-i-statistikken/. Accessed 24 November, 2016
74
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
DROP OUT RATES FOR SECONDARY EDUCATION 2014
DROPOUT RATE OF VOCATIONAL EDUCATION IN 2014
Skive
Skive
Randers
Lemvig
Norddjurs
Randers
Lemvig
Viborg
Struer Holstebro
Holstebro
Syddjurs
Favrskov
Silkeborg
Herning Aarhus
Aarhus
Skanderborg
Ringkøbing-
Syddjurs
Favrskov
Silkeborg
Herning
Norddjurs
Viborg
Struer
Skanderborg
Ringkøbing-
Skjern
Skjern 0-8%
Ikast-Brande Horsens
0 - 15 %
Ikast-Brande
Odder
Horsens
9 - 12 % 13 - 16 %
Samsø Hedensted
Odder 16 -30 %
Samsø Hedensted
17 - 20 %
POPULATION'S HIGHEST LEVEL OF EDUCATION IN 2015
31 -45 % 46 -68 %
LEMVIG
PRIMARY SCHOOL
PRIMARY SCHOOL
SECONDARY SCHOOL
VOCATIONAL SHORT HIGHER EDUCATION
POLYTECHNIC EDUCATION
HIGHER EDUCATION
PREPARATORY EDUCATION
LEMVIG
28%
4%
46%
3%
15%
4%
SECONDARY SCHOOL
MIDTJYLLAND
23%
5%
37%
6%
19%
9%
VOCATIONAL TRAINING
DENMARK
25%
6%
35%
5%
19%
10%
SHORT HIGHER EDUCATION
2.771
16
628
550
65
MEDIUM-CYCLE HIGHER EDUCATION
LONG HIGHER EDUCATION
THE FIGURE SHOWS THE NUMBER OF STUDENTS CALCULATED BY MUNICIPALITY OF RESIDENCE IN 2014 THE ONGOING TRAINING ACTIVITY.
525
18
69%
70%
REGION MIDTJYLLAND
DENMARK
77%
75%
HERNING
75%
74% AARHUS
SILKEBORG
73% IKAST-BRANDE
NORDDJURS
72%
69%
71%
69% ODDER
SKANDERBORG
HORSENS
69% HEDENSTED
HOLSTEBRO
69% FAVRSKOV
71%
69%
RINGKØBING-SKJERN
69%
69% VIBORG
LEMVIG
68%
SYDDJURS
68%
STRUER
66% SAMSØ
RANDERS
SKIVE
65%
POPULATION WITH A PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION 2015
STATISTICS: EDUCATION Education trends for the municipality of Lemvig. Lemvig Kommune’s population with a professional education is just below the national average in the Midtjylland Region.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Lemvig Kommune Statistics. regionmidtjylland. https://www.rm.dk/regional-udvikling/statistik-og-analyse/ midt-i-statistikken/. Accessed 24 November, 2016
75
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
PERCENT OF POPULATION LOW INCOME 2014
INCOME PER. CAPITA IN 2014
Skive
Skive Randers
Lemvig
Norddjurs
Randers
Lemvig
Viborg
Struer Holstebro
Syddjurs
Favrskov
Holstebro
Silkeborg
Herning Aarhus
Aarhus
Skanderborg
Ringkøbing-
Skanderborg
RingkøbingSkjern
Skjern Ikast-Brande
Ikast-Brande
3 - 3,5 %
Odder
Horsens
Horsens
3,6 - 4,5 %
AVERAGE INCOME 2014
LANDSDEL VESTJYLLAND
LANDSDEL ØSTJYLLAND
100.000199.999 KR.
300.000399.999 KR.
400.000499.999 KR.
14%
13%
11%
12%
15%
14%
16% 200.000299.999 KR.
14%
28%
24%
26%
25%
26%
23%
27% 16%
16%
14%
23% 099.999 KR.
13%
9%
9%
7%
6% DENMARK
LANSDEL ØSTJYLLAND
LANDSDEL VESTJYLLAND
DENMARK
298.785
289.283
282.114
325.329
304.315
297.536
295.804
289.764
287.782
287.123
286.313
285.995
284.946
284.540
REGION MIDTJYLLAND
SKANDERBORG
FAVRSKOV
ODDER
HEDENSTED
AARHUS
HORSENS
VIBORG
SYDDJURS
HERNING
HOLSTEBRO
SILKEBORG
RINGKØBING-SKJERN
LEMVIG
IKAST-BRANDE
RANDERS
315,001 - 326,000 kr
INCOME DISTRIBUTION 2014
284.450
283.769
279.009
278.626
273.721
270.404
262.651
269.446
STRUER
SKIVE
295,001 - 315,000 kr
Hedensted
LEMVIG
259.279
275,001 - 295,000 kr
Samsø
5,6 - 6 %
Hedensted
SAMSØ
259,000 - 275,000 kr
Odder
4,6 - 5,5 %
Samsø
NORDDJURS
Syddjurs
Favrskov
Silkeborg
Herning
Norddjurs
Viborg
Struer
500.000+ KR.
AVERAGE INCOME 2014
PRIMARY SCHOOL
SECONDARY SCHOOL
VOCATIONAL
SHORT HIGHER EDUCATION
MEDIUM HIGHER EDUCATION
576.275
538.584
504.531
378.683
367.489
364.669
373.883
370.334
HELE LANDET
370.960
312.847
314.139
334.080
230.081
208.199
REGION MIDTJYLLAND
223.864
185.673
198.113
183.683
LEMVIG
HIGHER EDUCATION
STATISTICS: INCOME Income trends for the municipality of Lemvig. Lemvig Kommune has the seventh lowest average income in the Midtjylland Region.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Lemvig Kommune Statistics. regionmidtjylland. https://www.rm.dk/regional-udvikling/statistik-og-analyse/ midt-i-statistikken/. Accessed 24 November, 2016
76
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
NET MIGRATION 2014
382
MIGRATION 2007-2015
306
1.200 EMIGRATION
196
1.000
RINGKØBING-SKJERN
FAVRSKOV
LEMVIG
SKIVE
HEDENSTED
HOLSTEBRO
STRUER
IKAST-BRANDE
VIBORG
SYDDJURS
600
IMIGRATION
-86
-50
400 -70
SAMSØ -11
29
16
200
-239
0
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
-373
-333
-296
-231
-228
-140
HERNING
ODDER
SILKEBORG
NORDDJURS
RANDERS
SKANDERBORG
HORSENS
AARHUS
40
59
83
800
INEQUALITY 2000-2014 GINI COEFFICIENT
MOVEMENT BY AGE 2015 NET RELOCATION
33
IMMIGRATION
EMIGRATION
60
32
40
31 30
AVERAGE ALL KOMMUNES
29 28
20 0 -20
27
-40
26
-60
25 LEMVIG
24 23
-80
95 YEARS
100 YEARS
90 YEARS
85 YEARS
80 YEARS
75 YEARS
70 YEARS
65 YEARS
60 YEARS
55 YEARS
50 YEARS
45 YEARS
40 YEARS
2014
35 YEARS
2012 2011
30 YEARS
2010 2009
25 YEARS
2008 2007
20 YEARS
2006 2005
15 YEARS
2004 2003
10 YEARS
2002 2001
5 YEARS
2000
0 YEARS
-100
22
RELOCATION FROM LEMVIG OVER 25 YEAR OLDS 2015
RELOCATION FROM LEMVIG 16-24 YEAR OLDS 2015
[-568] - [-420]
[-6,519] - [-350]
[-419] - [-190]
[-349] - [-0]
[-189] - [-0]
[-1] - [350]
[-1] - [-10,524]
[351] - [706]
STATISTICS: MIGRATION Migration trends for the municipality of Lemvig. Lemvig Kommune has the third highest net migration with a large proportion of youth leaving the municipality for Denmark’s urban centres.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Lemvig Kommune Statistics. regionmidtjylland. https://www.rm.dk/regional-udvikling/statistik-og-analyse/ midt-i-statistikken/. Accessed 24 November, 2016
77
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
POPULATION TRENDS BY KOMMUNE 2010-2016
SAMSØ LEMVIG STRUER SKIVE RINGKØBING-SKJERN NORDDJURS HEDENSTED HOLSTEBRO SYDDJURS IKAST-BRANDE ODDER HERNING FAVRSKOV SILKEBORG VIBORG RANDERS SKANDERBORG HORSENS AARHUS REGION MIDTJYLLAND DENMARK
POPULATION PROJECTION LEMVIG KOMMUNE 2015-2035
120
-7% -6%
REGION MIDTJYLLAND
-4% -3% -2%
100
0% 0%
LEMVIG
1% 1% 1%
80
2% 2% 2% 3% 3%
40
3% 4% 7% 8%
-
3% 3%
2015
PROPORTION 20-64 YEAR OLDS IN 2016
2017
2019
2021
2023
2026
2027
2029
2031
2033
2035
POPULATION BY AGE GROUP 2015-2025
SAMSØ STRUER SYDDJURS LEMVIG RINGKØBING-SKJERN ODDER SKANDERBORG FAVRSKOV HEDENSTED SKIVE IKAST-BRANDE NORDDJURS SILKEBORG VIBORG HOLSTEBRO HERNING RANDERS HORSENS AARHUS REGION MIDTJYLLAND DENMARK
51% 53%
POPULATION BY NUMBER
53%
POPULATION BY PERCENT
53% 54% 54%
LEMVIG
LEMVIG
-768 -488 -1.187 504 489 -1.450
-22% -23% -10% 24% 44% -7%
REGION MIDTJYLLAND
HELE LANDET
55%
0-15 YEARS 16-24 YEARS 25-69 YEARS 70-79 YEARS 80+ YEARS TOTAL
55% 55% 55% 55% 56% 56% 56%
-1% -3% 1% 35% 46% 5%
-1% -4% 1% 28% 45% 4%
56% 57% 57% 58% 65% 58% 58%
POPULATION PYRAMID
80+ YEARS
1.103
70-79 YEARS 60-69 YEARS
1.592
2.121
2.625
3.072
3.107
50-59 YEARS 3.233 40-49 YEARS
2.854 2.791
30-39 YEARS
1.838
20-29 YEARS 10-19 YEARS 0-9 YEARS
1.938 1.856
1.701
1.505
2.888
2.081 1.910
1.649 2015
2025
STATISTICS: POPULATION Population statistics for the municipality of Lemvig. Lemvig Kommune’s population is falling and a low proportion of the population is made up of 20-29 year olds.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Lemvig Kommune Statistics. regionmidtjylland. https://www.rm.dk/regional-udvikling/statistik-og-analyse/ midt-i-statistikken/. Accessed 24 November, 2016
78
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
ELECTIONS TO MUNICIPALITY COUNCILS IN LEMVIG KOMMUNE 2005
2009
2013
8,000
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
LETTERS NOT RESERVED
UNITY LIST
LIBERAL DEMOCRATIC PARTY
THE SLESVIG PARTY
DANISH PEOPLES PARTY
LIBERAL ALLIANCE
SOCIALIST PEOPLES PARTY
CONSERVATIVE PEOPLES PARTY
SOCIAL LIBERAL PARTY
SOCIAL DEMOCRATIC PARTY
0
ELECTION TO PARLIAMENT IN LEMVIG KOMMUNE 2007
2011
2015
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
THE ALTERNATIVE
THE RED-GREEN ALLIANCE
VENSTRE, DENMARKS LIBERAL PARTY
DANISH PEOPLES PARTY
CHRISTIAN DEMOCRATS
LIBERAL ALLIANCE
SOCIALIST PEOPLES PARTY
CONSERVATIVE PEOPLES PARTY
SOCIAL LIBERAL PARTY
SOCIAL DEMOCRATIC PARTY
0
STATISTICS: POLITICS Political trends for the municipality of Lemvig. Lemvig Kommune is a strong supporter of the Venstre, Denmark’s Liberal Party.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Election to the Parliament by Result of the Election and Municipalities. Statistics Denmark. http://www.dst.dk/ en/. Accessed 24 November, 2016
79
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
THROUGHPUT OF GOODS AT THYBORØN HAVN 2015 1 QRT
2 QRT
3 QRT
4 QRT
220
200 180
160
QUANTITY (1,000 TON)
140 120
100
80
60 40
OTHER MIXED CARGO
WOOD
GOODS IN RORO UNITS
VEHICLES
CONTAINER GOODS
OTHER SOLID BULK
LIME, CEMENT, PLASTER
BOULDERS, SAND AND GRAVEL
FERTILIZERS
SOLID CHEMICALS
FEEDING GOODS
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION
COAL
ORES AND METAL WASTE
OTHER LIQUID BULK
LIQUID CHEMICALS
MINERAL OIL PRODUCTS
CRUDE OIL
LIQUID GAS
0
IRON AND STEEL PRODUCTS
20
THROUGHPUT OF GOODS AT THYBORØN HAVN 2008-2016
550
500
450
QUANTITY (1,000 TON)
400
350
300
250
200
2016
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
100
2008
150
STATISTICS: THYBORØN PORT Statistics for the port of Thyborøn. Through put has declined since 2008 but the port remains a large importer of sand, gravel, and boulders for local port construction.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Throughput of Goods in Major Danish Seaports by Seaport Direction and Type. Statistics Denmark. http:// www.dst.dk/en/. Accessed 24 November, 2016
80
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
PILGRIM HOSTEL BUNKER GUEST HOUSE LOCATION
The pilgrim hostel is the primary lodging typology. Embedded into the breakwater wall facing the Lim Fjord these hostels are equipped with bunk style dorm rooms, common areas and kitchens. FORM
NUMBER OF GUESTS PER UNIT
X 40
PILGRIM CABIN BREAKWATER CABIN LOCATION
50
TOTAL
2000
The pilgrim cabin is a summer time lodging facing the sea. The three of the four volumes are double rooms while the fourth contains washroom facilities. Pilgrim cabins make up approximately a quarter of the breakwater’s programmable blocks. Should the need arise in the future more blocks can be reprogrammed as pilgrim cabins. FORM
NUMBER OF GUESTS PER UNIT
X6
PILGRIM TENT
NUMBER OF UNITS
NUMBER OF UNITS
260
TOTAL
1,560
The pilgrims may also bring their own accommodation. This is at their preference or as a necessity at peak pilgrimage times.
BREAKWATER CABIN LOCATION
FORM
NUMBER OF GUESTS PER UNIT
X1-4
NUMBER OF UNITS
200
TOTAL
200-800
PILGRIM ACCOMMODATION The culmination of the Grand Tour of EUtopia has ample housing facilities for a variety of different pilgrims. From families crossing Europe, to the lone traveller, to the Dane just visiting for the weekend.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
81
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
YEARLY ATTENDANCE AT PILGRIMAGES DIFFERENT PILGRIMAGE TYPOLOGIES SELECTED
GRAND TOUR TYPOLOGY
NAME
GLASTONBURY
CAMINO DE SANTIAGO
MECCA
RUTA DE PELEGRINO
DISNEYLAND
TYPOLOGY
MUSIC FESTIVAL
PILGRIMAGE ROUTE
RELIGOUS SITE
PILGRIMAGE ROUTE
THEME PARK
YEAR
2016
2016
2016
2016
2015
ATTENDANCE
150,000
277,915
1,500,000
2,000,000
18,280,000
HISTORICAL
2,500 IN 1986
1,000,000 IN 1955
MONTHLY ATTENDANCE CAMINO DE SANTIAGO 2015 TOTAL: 262,458 54796
44799
37433 35925
31078
25574
17722
5229
5080 1217
JAN
2062
1544
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
DEC
ANNUAL ATTENDANCE PILGRIMAGES The annual number of pilgrims attending different religious and secular pilgrimages. Data collection to inform the prediction of potential numbers of pilgrims on the Grand Tour of EUtopia.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
http://caminoways.com/media/number-of-compostelas-2015-caminoways.png
82
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
ANNUAL ACCUMULATED PRECIPITATION DENMARK 1874-2015
MONTHLY PRECIPITATION THYBORØN TOTAL PRECIPITATION 872
120 950 900
100
850 80
800 750 MM
60
MM
700 650
40
600 550
20
500 450
0
1880
1900
1920
1940
1960
1980
2000
JAN
2020
DAYS OF RAIN THYBORØN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
DEC
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
DEC
MONTHLY TEMPERATURE THYBORØN AVERAGE TEMPERATURE 8.3 ºC
30 28 26 24 22 20 18 16 14 12 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 JAN
22 20 18 16 14 12 14
13 9
ºC
11
10
6
9 7
7
7
10 8
13
4
7
2 0 -2
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
DEC
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
CLIMATE DATA JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
MM
73
47
54
43
51
53
68
86
98
ºC
1.1
0.7
2.6
6.0
10.7
14.1
15.7
16.2
ºC MIN
-0.9
-1.4
0.2
3.3
7.6
11.3
13.2
ºC MAX
3.1
2.9
5.0
8.7
13.8
17.0
18.3
OCT
NOV
DEC
107
106
86
13.6
99
5.8
3.0
13.6
11.2
7.7
3.8
1.0
18.9
16.0
12.2
7.9
5.0
CLIMATE DATA THYBORØN Research into the climate of Thyborøn to explore the potential of precipitation and solar collection.
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Climate Data.org. Climate Thyborøn. https://en.climate-data.org/location/861222/. Accessed 21 Mar 2017
83
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
THYBORØN Tid 0522 1112 S 1746 2317
1 2
Januar m 0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
Tid 0602 1202 M 1831 2356
m 0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
0655 1524 Ti 1924
0.5 0.1 0.4
16
0601 1154 M 1828
0.5 0.1 0.4
17
3
0000 0645 Ti 1244 1915
0.1 0.5 0.1 0.4
18
0050 0736 O 1342 2006
0.1 0.5 0.1 0.4
4
5 0145 0831 To 1648 B 2105 6
0.0 0.5 0.1 0.4
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
2 0606 1200 To 1832
0352 0939 L 1645 D 2204
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
3
0448 1045 S 1724 2307
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.4
4
0539 1144 M 1806
0.0 0.4 0.1
5
0003 0630 Ti 1236 1849
0.4 0.0 0.4 0.1
6
0054 0719 O 1325 1931
0.4 0.0 0.4 0.1
7
0140 0809 To 1409 2009
0.4 0.0 0.4 0.1
0221 0857 F 1448 2037
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0256 0948 L 1522 2057
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0328 1048 S 1554 A 2121
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
0402 1012 M 1627 2154
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
0439 1039 Ti 1705 2233
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.0
0.1 0.5 0.1 0.4
4
0223 0912 L 1719 B 2142
0419 1019 F 1727 2245
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
5
0.0 0.5 0.1 0.4
0339 1024 S 1807 2251
0515 1125 L 1809 2345
22
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.4
6
0.0 0.5 0.1 0.4
0519 1137 M 1853 2357
0606 1222 S 1850
0.0 0.4 0.1
7
0.0 0.5 0.1 0.4
0633 1242 Ti 1924
0.0 0.4 0.1
22
0040 0656 M 1313 1931
0.4 0.0 0.4 0.1
8
0.4 0.0 0.4 0.1
23
0130 0745 Ti 1400 2012
0.4 0.0 0.4 0.1
0214 0834 O 1441 2046
0.4 0.0 0.4 0.1
0253 0921 To 1517 2109
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0325 1001 F 1548 2124
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0354 1007 L 1617 A 2145
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0424 1024 S 1648 2215
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
0500 1054 M 1725 2253
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
0539 1135 Ti 1806 2337
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.0
20 21
0.0 0.5 0.1
23
9
0019 0617 M 1256 1941
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
24
0114 0709 Ti 1351 1943
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
0204 0756 O 1439 2015
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
0252 0842 To 1526 C 2054
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0339 0928 F 1611 2134
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0425 1015 L 1656 2218
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
0512 1106 S 1742 2305
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
15
0141 0828 F 1609 2056
17
0211 0904 To 1648 D 2136
19
0515 1155 S 1913
14
0.0 0.5 0.1 0.4
m 0.1 0.5 0.1 0.4
0.0 0.5 0.1 0.4
8
13
2 0026 0714 To 1315 1942
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
0056 0728 O 1339 1923
9 0148 0815 To 1428 1956
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0238 0851 F 1514 2034
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0325 0929 L 1557 C 2115
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
0411 1010 S 1640 2159
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
0457 1055 M 1724 2245
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
0544 1146 Ti 1809 2334
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
0633 1459 O 1858
0.5 0.1 0.4
10 11 12 13 14 15
Tid 0520 1116 O 1746 2317
Tid 0030 0727 To 1535 1952
16
0121 0809 F 1421 2039
0.0 0.5 0.1 0.4
12
m 0.5 0.1 0.4
3
0400 1045 L 1827 2318
11
Februar
0.1 0.5 0.1 0.4
0.0 0.5 0.1 0.4
10
Tid 0624 1221 O 1852
0054 0754 O 1606 2025
0247 0934 F 1738 2210
7
2017
1
18 19 20 21
24 25 26 27 28
THYBORØN
DMI
Dansk Normaltid (UT+1 time)
1
Marts
m 0.5 0.1 0.4 0.0
Tid 0612 1220 To 1833
16
0.5 0.1 0.4
17
0006 0655 F 1251 1921
0.0 0.5 0.1 0.4
18
0101 0750 L 1350 2017
0.0 0.5 0.1 0.4
0205 0853 S 1700 B 2119
0.0 0.5 0.1 0.4
0346 1006 M 1748 2230
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.4
0606 1124 Ti 1833 2340
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0709 1232 O 1912
0.0 0.4 0.1
23
9 0042 0819 To 1330 1913
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
24
0138 0933 F 1421 1943
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0229 1040 L 1506 2021
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0316 1138 S 1547 C 2101
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0401 1229 M 1627 2143
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0444 1315 Ti 1706 2228
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
0527 1133 O 1748 2315
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
8
10 11 12 13 14 15
m 0.4 0.1 0.4
m 0.5 0.1 0.5
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
2
0045 0733 S 1321 1957
0114 0751 L 1530 2016
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
3
0.0 0.5 0.1 0.5
0154 0836 M 1430 B 2059
0332 0852 S 1603 2119
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
4
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0507 0951 Ti 1726 2212
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0424 1000 M 1645 D 2224
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0604 1114 O 1812 2327
0515 1102 Ti 1728 2323
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.4
6 0705 1223 To 1857
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0604 1158 O 1812
0.0 0.4 0.1
7
0016 0654 To 1249 1856
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
8
0104 0743 F 1336 1934
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0147 0833 L 1418 2006
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0226 0925 S 1455 2030
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0302 1025 M 1530 2058
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0339 1002 Ti 1606 A 2133
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.0
0419 1021 O 1645 2214
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.0
0502 1056 To 1727 2300
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.0
0548 1139 F 1812 2349
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.0
20 21 22
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
5
THYBORØN Oktober
Tid 1 0123 0714 O 1339 2037
November
Tid 16 0211 0745 To 1443 2234
m 0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
Tid 1 0127 0710 F 1348 2036
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
0255 0821 F 1528 2327
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
2
0334 0900 L 1606 A
0.4 0.1 0.4
3
0014 0410 S 0938 1639
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
4
0445 1017 M 1711 2243
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
5
0521 1057 Ti 1744 2315
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0557 1141 O 1820 2352
23
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
7 0549 1137 To 1822 2351
0636 1229 To 1859
0.4 0.1 0.4
8
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0640 1236 F 1915
0.5 0.1 0.4
23
24
0036 0718 F 1514 1944
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
9
0044 0737 L 1613 2016
0.1 0.5 0.0 0.4
24
0126 0806 L 1600 2036
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0144 0843 S 1706 D 2129
0.1 0.5 0.0 0.4
0230 0901 S 1648 B 2139
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0304 1003 M 1800 2249
0.1 0.5 0.0 0.4
0410 1006 M 1737 2248
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0536 1126 Ti 1857 2358
0.1 0.5 0.0 0.4
0509 1112 Ti 1825 2348
0.1 0.4 0.0 0.4
0626 1234 O 1956
0.1 0.5 0.0
28
0554 1210 O 1913
0.1 0.5 0.0
14
0057 0717 To 1334 2058
29
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.0
15
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
0149 0821 F 1427 2158
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
m 0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
0121 0722 M 1341 2024
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0139 0707 Ti 1400 2201
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
2 0204 0742 To 1419 2130
0204 0756 Ti 1420 2120
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
0228 0744 O 1451 2300
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
3
0242 0812 F 1458 2130
0242 0818 O 1454 2223
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
0310 0824 To 1536 A 2354
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
4
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
0318 0848 L 1538 C 2135
0349 0904 F 1616
0.4 0.1 0.5
5
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
0357 0928 S 1619 2206
0042 0427 L 0946 1654
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
6
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
0438 1012 M 1703 2245
0124 0505 S 1030 1733
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
7
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
0521 1100 Ti 1751 2328
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
0545 1116 M 1812 2353
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0609 1151 O 1841
0.5 0.0 0.5
0627 1206 Ti 1854
0.4 0.1 0.4
9 0016 0700 To 1249 1936
0.1 0.5 0.1 0.4
0109 0757 F 1405 D 2038
0.1 0.5 0.1 0.4
0212 0903 L 1725 2154
0.1 0.5 0.0 0.4
0336 1023 S 1823 2316
13
0.1 0.5 0.0 0.4
0606 1143 M 1924
0.1 0.5 0.0
28
14
0024 0646 Ti 1251 2030
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
29
0121 0713 O 1351 2135
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
2 3 4
5 0315 0841 To 1527 C 2327 6
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
17 18 19 20 21
0347 0911 F 1601 2205
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
0421 0948 L 1640 2233
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
0500 1030 S 1723 2310
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
0543 1116 M 1809 2354
10
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
0630 1208 Ti 1900
0.4 0.0 0.5
25
11
0044 0721 O 1305 1956
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
26
0139 0818 To 1415 D 2100
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0247 0925 F 1739 2218
0.1 0.4 0.0 0.4
0552 1042 L 1840 2339
0.1 0.4 0.0 0.4
0636 1158 S 1945
0.1 0.5 0.0
7 8 9
12 13 14 15
22 23 24
0039 0713 O 1310 1941
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0144 0804 To 1545 2036
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0345 0905 F 1632 B 2141
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0430 1012 L 1720 2247
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0515 1115 S 1809 2345
30
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0600 1209 M 1858
0.1 0.4 0.0
31
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
27 28 29
0037 0640 Ti 1257 1947
8
10 11 12
15
December
m 0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
Tid 16 0044 0702 M 1303 2054
17 18 19 20 21 22
25 26 27
30
0040 0633 To 1301 2000
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.0
0414 1153 F 1626 C
0.4 0.1 0.4
24
0258 0915 To 1521 A 2057
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.0
10
0012 0442 L 1228 1654
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
25
0342 0934 F 1603 2141
0.5 0.1 0.5 0.0
0053 0509 S 1044 1723
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0427 1009 L 1647 2229
0.5 0.1 0.5 0.0
0129 0537 M 1106 1752
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0515 1049 S 1733 2321
0.5 0.1 0.5 0.0
0609 1139 Ti 1827
0.4 0.1 0.4
28
0603 1135 M 1823
0.4 0.1 0.5
14
0243 0648 O 1219 1906
29
0021 0657 Ti 1226 1918
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
15
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0326 0733 To 1306 1952
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
0350 0758 O 1324 2021
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0155 0902 M 1427 2003
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.0
0309 1053 Ti 1530 2258
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0237 1001 Ti 1506 2036
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.0
0351 1142 O 1607 C 2139
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0318 0947 O 1544 A 2114
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.0
0427 1226 To 1640 2214
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0400 1000 To 1624 2157
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.0
0459 1303 F 1712 2252
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0445 1033 F 1706 2243
0.5 0.1 0.5 0.0
0530 1113 L 1746 2333
0531 1115 L 1752 2334
0.5 0.1 0.5 0.0
14
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0604 1142 S 1822
0.4 0.1 0.4
29
0621 1201 S 1842
0.5 0.1 0.5
15
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
30
0355 1208 Ti 1616 C 2134
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0435 1252 O 1652 2216
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.1
0512 1331 To 1730 2300
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0551 1144 F 1809 2348
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0631 1224 L 1851
0.4 0.1 0.4
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
9
10 11 12 13
0022 0641 M 1220 1900
17 18 19
23 24 25 26 27 28
31
1
11 12 13
Tid 0411 0825 F 1402 2046
m 0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
0457 0928 L 1511 D 2149
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0546 1040 S 1649 2258
19
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0636 1145 M 1748
0.0 0.4 0.1
20
0003 0725 Ti 1240 1834
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0100 0816 O 1330 1917
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.0
0151 0912 To 1415 1959
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.0
0239 0841 F 1459 2042
0.5 0.1 0.5 0.0
0325 0906 L 1542 A 2128
0.5 0.1 0.5 0.0
0410 0942 S 1627 2216
0.5 0.1 0.5 0.0
0457 1024 M 1715 2308
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
0545 1109 Ti 1804
0.4 0.1 0.5
16 17
21 22 23
26 27
0013 0636 O 1159 1858
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
0333 0734 To 1256 2000
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0423 0844 F 1412 2117
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
30
THYBORØN
DMI
Dansk Normaltid (UT+1 time) Juli
2017 August
m 0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
Tid 1 0027 0647 F 1251 1918
0642 1134 To 1842
0.1 0.4 0.1
2
0117 0727 L 1339 2012
0015 0730 F 1236 1954
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.0
3
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0203 0806 S 1422 2109
0115 0816 L 1331 2120
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.0
4
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0243 0839 M 1459 2210
0207 0741 S 1421 2234
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
5
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0318 0857 Ti 1530 2310
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0254 0815 M 1509 A 2336
0347 0912 O 1557 C
22
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
0338 0854 Ti 1554
0.4 0.1 0.5
0.4 0.1 0.4
23
0032 0421 O 0936 1641
8
0036 0443 O 1004 1654
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
24
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0122 0504 To 1021 1727
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0514 1036 To 1727 2327
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
0209 0550 F 1109 1817
0550 1115 F 1807
0.4 0.1 0.5
26
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0254 0639 L 1202 1910
0007 0632 L 1200 1852
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
27
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
0336 0734 S 1306 2012
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0056 0719 S 1251 1943
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
0415 0839 M 1602 2125
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0200 0812 M 1348 2041
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
0451 0954 Ti 1649 B 2234
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0507 0913 Ti 1457 D 2148
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
0528 1100 O 1738 2333
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0606 1159 To 1827
0.1 0.4 0.1
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
0353 0943 M 1621 A 2157
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0653 1217 M 1839
0.0 0.4 0.1
18
0014 0657 O 1238 1902
0251 0828 S 1516 C 2106
3
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
3 0107 0739 To 1330 1957
0426 1012 Ti 1649 2216
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0046 0745 Ti 1312 1935
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.0
0704 1206 O 1818
0.0 0.4 0.1
4
0.4 0.0 0.4 0.1
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
19
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0333 0911 M 1600 2140
4
0615 1103 Ti 1710 2332
0157 0823 F 1418 2058
0416 0957 Ti 1645 2220
0.5 0.0 0.5 0.1
0457 1044 O 1718 2244
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0141 0839 O 1403 2040
0036 0754 To 1302 1909
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.0
0241 0903 L 1500 2203
0.5 0.0 0.5 0.1
0530 1118 To 1750 2318
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0131 0846 F 1351 1953
0.5 0.1 0.4 0.0
0319 0935 S 1535 2301
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0314 1024 F 1530 2252
0222 0809 L 1439 2036
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
0351 0937 M 1603 C 2351
0.4 0.1 0.4
0351 1106 L 1604 2342
0309 0839 S 1524 A 2121
0042 0725 S 1347 1953
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0420 1142 S 1632 C
0.4 0.1 0.4
24
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
0418 0943 Ti 1627
9
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
8
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0642 1244 L 1906
8
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
7
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0603 1157 F 1825 2357
7
0.4 0.0 0.4 0.1
6
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0501 1045 O 1732 2303
6 0230 0933 To 1450 2152
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
5
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0133 0815 M 1620 2048
0.1 0.5 0.1 0.4
0025 0445 M 1014 1657
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
25
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
9
10
0354 0917 M 1610 2207
0439 0959 Ti 1657 2258
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
0233 0912 Ti 1708 B 2150
0.1 0.5 0.1 0.4
0105 0510 Ti 1034 1723
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0524 1044 O 1745
0.4 0.1 0.5
11
0346 1018 O 1756 2257
0.1 0.5 0.1 0.4
0144 0541 O 1105 1755
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0227 0613 To 1133 1838
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
12
0502 1127 To 1842 2358
0.1 0.5 0.0 0.4
0000 0617 To 1144 1834
0315 0707 F 1228 1937
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0558 1227 F 1924
0.0 0.5 0.1
14
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
0044 0700 F 1229 1919
0400 0809 L 1337 2048
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0051 0645 L 1321 1949
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
15
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
0352 0749 L 1321 2011
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
0445 0925 S 1630 B 2208
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0140 0729 S 1410 2007
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
0529 1039 M 1719 2315
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.4
5
11 12 13
Datum of Predictions = Chart Datum Tidspunkterne er givet i dansk normaltid (UT+1 time). Ved sommertid, skal tidspunkterne øges med 1 time.
17
20 21 22 23
26 27 28 29 30 31
September
Tid 16 0554 1023 O 1736 2305
0527 0951 M 1534 2220
31
0213 0936 O 1440 2015
9
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
0219 0957 M 1448 2154
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
30
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.0
8
0602 1116 S 1747 2346
13
0127 0839 Ti 1358 1938
8 0339 1110 To 1553 2326
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
2
27
0255 1021 O 1515 2231
0112 0809 S 1347 1933
23
0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
12
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0.5 -0.0 0.4 0.1
0316 1101 S 1550 2339
26
0036 0747 M 1314 1902
7
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0124 0856 S 1400 2030
0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
11
22
0205 0925 Ti 1430 2122
7
0209 0748 L 1433 2042
25
0.0 0.4 0.1
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
Tid 1 0612 1142 Ti 1809
10
0657 1225 S 1825
6
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
0024 0719 L 1302 1900
m 0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
22
0109 0825 M 1340 2006
0.5 -0.0 0.4 0.1
Tid 16 0439 0845 S 1421 D 2110
21
21
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0023 0751 L 1307 1927
m 0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
6
0607 1130 L 1744 2342
5
0.5 -0.0 0.4 0.1
6
Tid 1 0512 1006 L 1657 B 2239
20
0009 0726 S 1245 1906
0.0 0.4 0.1
m 0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
19
4
0630 1212 F 1821
Tid 16 0236 0958 L 1513 2252
18
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
20
m 0.4 0.0 0.5 0.1
17
0518 1025 F 1658 D 2241
-0.0 0.4 0.1
3
16
Datum of Predictions = Chart Datum Tidspunkterne er givet i dansk normaltid (UT+1 time). Ved sommertid, skal tidspunkterne øges med 1 time.
2017
m 0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
18
0650 1208 F 1836
DMI
Dansk Normaltid (UT+1 time)
-0.0 0.4 0.1
5
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
15
0629 1146 L 1813
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0312 1118 M 1539 2054
14
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
0540 1116 To 1737 2333
0.5 0.0 0.4 0.1
13
0430 0914 To 1606 2135
3
-0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
-0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0224 1021 S 1459 2016
12
0535 1038 F 1724 2300
4 0552 1100 To 1748 2315
0.5 -0.0 0.4 0.1
11
2
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.4
0131 0918 L 1413 1943
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0451 1013 O 1651 D 2235
22
0457 0936 O 1703 B 2156
0343 0813 O 1404 2035
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0.5 -0.0 0.4 0.1
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
m 0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0403 0906 Ti 1605 2131
20
0403 0818 Ti 1356 2040
1
Juni
Tid 0442 0914 To 1637 B 2139
2
19
m 0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
m 0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
18
Tid 0033 0716 M 1254 1937
Tid 0300 0723 Ti 1306 1945
0315 0806 M 1520 2030
17
0033 0810 F 1321 1930
10
Maj
m 0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
21
9
2017
Tid 0048 0715 S 1321 1938
16
-0.0 0.4 0.1
Datum of Predictions = Chart Datum Tidspunkterne er givet i dansk normaltid (UT+1 time). Ved sommertid, skal tidspunkterne øges med 1 time.
Tid 1 0034 0643 S 1257 1933
April
Tid 0638 1227 L 1901
1
0008 0659 F 1502 1921
19
DMI
Dansk Normaltid (UT+1 time)
2
10
13 14 15
m 0.0 0.4 0.1
0.4 0.0 0.4 0.0
17 18 19 20 21
25
28 29 30 31
m 0.4 0.1 0.4 0.1
Tid 0705 1215 L 1957
16 17
m 0.1 0.4 0.0
0100 0716 S 1315 2112
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
0154 0719 M 1409 2221
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
0241 0756 Ti 1457 2321
20
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.0
0324 0836 O 1543 A
0.4 0.1 0.5
0.4 0.1 0.5
21
7 0003 0415 To 0936 1627
0015 0404 To 0918 1627
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
22
0.0 0.4 0.1 0.5
0103 0445 F 1001 1710
0.1 0.3 0.1 0.5
0448 1010 F 1703 2300
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
0148 0527 L 1048 1755
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0524 1051 L 1744 2337
10
0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1
0230 0612 S 1138 1842
0606 1136 S 1830
0.4 0.0 0.5
25
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
11
0306 0700 M 1235 1933
0023 0654 M 1227 1920
0.1 0.4 0.0 0.5
26
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0339 0754 Ti 1533 2032
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0115 0745 Ti 1324 2017
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.5
0408 0900 O 1618 2140
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0218 0843 O 1432 D 2123
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0441 1010 To 1705 B 2245
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0532 0951 To 1747 2241
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0520 1112 F 1754 2342
0.1 0.4 0.1 0.4
0619 1106 F 1849 2357
0.1 0.4 0.0 0.4
0601 1208 L 1842
0.1 0.4 0.1
6
9
12 13 14 15
18 19
23 24
27 28 29 30
Datum of Predictions = Chart Datum Tidspunkterne er givet i dansk normaltid (UT+1 time). Ved sommertid, skal tidspunkterne øges med 1 time.
TIDAL CHARTS THYBORØN
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
https://www.dmi.dk/en/hav/maalinger/tidal-tables/
84
6
COASTAL ENGINEERING 2010 6 COASTAL ENGINEERING 2010
6 Example: Inflow Example: Inflow
COASTAL ENGINEERING 20
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
Example: Outflow Example: Example: Outflow Inflow
Ex
INFLOW CONDITION CONDITION Figure 7. Examples of simulated instantaneous flow fields for anOUTFLOW inflow situation (left) and an outflow Figure (right), 7. Examples of simulated instantaneous flow fields for anFigure inflow7.situation Examples (left) of and simulated an outflow instantaneous flow fields for an inflow situation respectively. situation (right), respectively. situation (right), respectively.
Figure 8. Measured and calculated current speed and direction in front of the southern breakwater, Nov. FLOW VELOCITIES Figure 8. Measuredby and current speed and direction in Figure front 8. ofMeasured the southern andbreakwater, calculated current Nov. speed and direction in front 2008. Measurements thecalculated Danish Coastal Authority. 2008. Measurements by the Danish Coastal Authority. 2008. Measurements by the Danish Coastal Authority.
TIDAL STREAM ENERGY POTENTIAL The project site is located at the western entrance to the Lim Fjord with large potential for tidal energy generation do to both tidal changes and flow generated by wave action. Specific areas in at the channel entrance have larger flow velocities
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Sistermans, Paul and Nieuwenhuis. EROSION Case Study: Western Coast of Jutland (Denmark) DVH Group.
85
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
IMPLEMENTATION FOR EU OVERVIEW
EU BUDGET BY FUND CF
YEI
ESF
ERDF
EAFRD
IMPLEMENTATION PROGRESS
EMFF
SPENT
DECIDED
0%
PLANNED
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
13.9%
IMPLEMENTATION BY FUND FOR EU OVERVIEW
43.2%
BUDGET BY FUND
18.3%
TOTAL COST % OF PLANNED SPENT
DECIDED
0%
PLANNED
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
CF EAFRD EMFF
21.9%
ERDF ESF YEI
IMPLEMENTATION BY MEMBER STATE
EU BUDGET BY THEME CF
YEI
ESF
ERDF
EAFRD
TOTAL COST % OF PLANNED
EMFF
SPENT
0 COMPETITIVESNESS OF SME
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
DECIDED
0%
PLANNED
10%
20%
30%
AUSTRIA BELGIUM
ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION & RESOURCE EFFICIENCY NETWORK INFRASTRUCTURES IN TRANSPORT AND ENERGY
LOW-CARBON ECONOMY
BULGARIA CROATIA CYPRUS CZECH REPUBLIC DENMARK ESTONIA
DENMARK €2 253 056 430 (100.0%) €772 682 071 (34.3%) €41 730 225 (1.9%)
FINLAND FRANCE
SOCIAL INCLUSION
GERMANY GREECE
RESEARCH & INNOVATION
HUNGARY IRELAND ITALY
SUSTAINABLE & QUALITY EMPLOYMENT
LATVIA LITHUANIA
EDUCATIONAL & VOCATIONAL TRAINING
LUXEMBOURG MALTA NTHERLANDS
CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION & RISK PREVENTION INFORMATION & COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES
POLAND PORTUGAL ROMANIA SLOVAK REPUBLIC SLOVENIA
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
EFFICIENT PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
SPAIN SWEDEN TERRITORIAL CO-OPERATION UNITED KINGDOM
TERRITORIAL CO-OPERATION €12 429 740 981 (100.0%) €4 275 091 245 (34.4%) €89 374 839 (0.7%)
OUTERMOST & SPARSELY POPULATED
DISCONTINUED MEASURES
EU FUNDING AND IMPLEMENTATION BREAKDOWN Analysis of current European Union budgeting and funding allocation. Locating opportunities for funding the Grand Tour of EUtopia nationally and at the EU level.
EUROPEAN STRUCTURAL AND INVESTMENT FUNDS. Data. https://cohesiondata.ec.europa.eu/overview THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
86
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
DECOMMISSIONING OPTIONS FOR THE PLATFORM TOPSIDES & PLATFORM JACKETS LEAVE IN SITU This is not a legally or environmentally acceptable option. REUSE IN SITU All these options are opportunity driven and can only be considered if the opportunity arises within the right time frame. There would be significant issues that would have to be resolved about ownership and responsibility of removal at the ultimate end of their useful life. REUSE IN ANOTHER LOCATION This option requires the topsides to first be to shore removed, cleaned and revamped. Based on the cost implications, the option was rejected. REMOVE AND RECYCLE This is one of the most likely futures for the topsides because of the low probability of finding a suitable reuse opportunity. RIGS TO REEFS DISPOSAL This might have been a practical option for the jackets. However, the permits necessary for this method of disposal are not likely to be forthcoming foreseeable. DEEP SEA DISPOSAL This method of disposal is not legally acceptable in North East Atlantic waters. DELAY DECOMMISSIONING AWAITING NOVEL NEW TECHNOLOGY Initial research indicates that the equipment, if developed, is not likely to be available within a suitable time frame.
IDENTIFYING MATERIAL OPPORTUNITIES INVENTORY OF MATERIALS PLATFORM TOPSIDES ITEM
DESCRIPTION
WEIGHT IN TONNES
MATERIAL
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
STRUCTURAL STEEL PIPING VESSELS MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT ELECTRICAL & INSTRUMENT CABLES CABLE TRAYS ELECTRICAL CABINETS & EQUIPMENT HVAC/ARCHITECTURAL SAFETY (INCLUDES WATER PIPING) DECKING
712 460 237 156 5 24 14 1 61 24
CARBON STEEL CARBON STEEL CARBON STEEL CARBON STEEL PLASTIC COATED COPPER GALVANIZED STEEL MISCELLANEOUS MISCELLANEOUS CARBON STEEL TIMBER
TOTAL 1694 PLATFORM JACKETS 1 2 3 4 5
JACKET STRUCTURE PILES RISERS RISERS ANODES
945 190 0 0 15
CARBON STEEL CARBON STEEL CARBON STEEL SS DUPLEX ALUMINIUM ALLOY
TOTAL 1150
IDENTIFYING MATERIAL AVAILABILITY
FIELD DECOMMISSIONING SCHEDULE 2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Cessation of production Clean & make safe Well decommissioning Module segregation and pre-lifting Pipeline clearing Platform removal (window) Pipeline decommissioning (window) Onshore disposal (window) Debris clearance & final survey
RECYCLING DECOMMISSIONED NORTH SEA OIL RIGS FOR CONSTRUCTION MATERIAL The North Sea currently hosts more than 600 offshore oil and gas installations, many of which have been standing since the 1960s and 1970s. Many have exceeded their operational lifetime of 25 years. Many of the steel and concrete structures have also become obsolete. As a result they have become redundant and need to be removed.
The Guardian. Can North Sea Installations be recycled, or Decommissioned Sustainably. https://www.theguardian. com/sustainable-business/2014/dec/01/north-sea-installation-recycle-sustainable-reuse-oil-gas A Danish Field Platforms and Pipelines Decommissioning Programmes. http://www.offshoreenergy.dk/ June 2013 THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
Danish Sustainable Offshore Decommissioning Project. Offshore Center Denmark. http://www.offshorecenter.dk/
87
5.3 SUPPORTING INFORMATION
1. Brewhouse: 1.1 Brewhouse: Mash tun / kettle, 1.2 Brewhouse: Combi tank – lauter tun / whirlpool, 1.3 Hot water tank (boiler), 2. Fermentation: 2.1 Fermentation tuns, 2.2 Fermentation tanks, 2.3 Maturation tanks, 2.4 Serving tanks, 4. Cooling: 4.1 Glycol Cooling Unit, 4.2 Plate heat exchanger for cooling the wort / hot water production, 5. Raw preparation : 5.1 Malt mill, 6. Sanitation: 6.1 Mobile CIP pump, 6.2 * CIP station, 7. Production of industrial gases: 7.1 Compressor, 7.2 Generator N2 / bottles with CO2, 8. Yeast management: 8.1 Yeast tank, 9. Beer filtration: 9.1 * Primary and secondary filter, 10. Bottling and salling of beer: 10.1 * KEG Washing and Filling maschine, 10.2 * Distribution and sales of beer * 10.3 Tapping of beer.
BREWERY SCHEMATIC Understanding and procurement of necessary brewing equipment. Volumes to be scaled appropriately for consumption and distribution on the Grand Tour of EUtopia.
http://www.czechminibreweries.com/production/container-breweries/mobbeer-pubmaster-250/
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
88
5.4 BIBLIOGRAPHY CHAPTER 1 European protected sites. European Environment Agency (EEA). http://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/explore-interactive-maps/european-protected-areas. Accessed 13 November, 2016
CHAPTER 2 http://www.buildings.com/article-details/articleid/2511/title/concrete-vs-steel/viewall/true Tsinker, Gregory P. Port Engineering: Planning, Construction, Maintenance, and Security. John Wiley & Sons. New Jersey. 2004. Tsinker, Gregory P. Port Engineering: Planning, Construction, Maintenance, and Security. John Wiley & Sons. New Jersey. 2004. Robinson, Alexander, Margolis, Liat. Living Systems: Innovative Materials and Technologies for Landscape Architecture. Springer Science & Business Media, 2008. Plants of the Agger. http://agger.nationalparkthy.eu/ A Danish Field, Platforms and Pipelines, Decommissioning Programmes. Fornyelsesfondon https://allseas.com/activities/heavy-lifting/installation/ Reynolds Polymer Technology. http://www.reynoldspolymer.com/. Accessed 16 April 2017 Selway Fisher Design. Yacht & Boat Designs, Plans & ManualsFor The Home & Professional Boat Builder http://www.selway-fisher.com/ SteelConstruction: The Free Encyclopedia For Uk Steel Construction Information. http://www.steelconstruction.info/Trusses. Accessed 10 May 2017 Norsafe Lifeboats: Free Fall Lifeboats. http://norsafe.com/lifesaving-systems/freefall-lifeboats/. Accessed 16 May 2017 Danish Building Research Institute. Instructions For Building Regulations 2015. Denmark http://sbi.dk/anvisninger/Pages/258-Anvisning-omBygningsreglement-2015-2.aspx#/5-Brandforhold Viking Life-Saving Equipment. https://www.viking-life.com. Accessed 16 May 2017
CHAPTER 3 Wave Star Energy Systems. http://wavestarenergy.com/ Vortex Bladeless Energy. http://www.vortexbladeless.com/ European Commission. SETIS. https://setis.ec.europa.eu/setis-reports/setis-magazine/ocean-energy/open-centre-turbines-%E2%80%93-invisibly-harnessing-power-of. Accessed 5 May 2017 American Piezo Energy. https://www.americanpiezo.com. Accessed 20 April 2017 Climate Data.org. Climate Thyborøn. Https://en.climate-data.org/location/861222/. Accessed 21 Mar 2017 Harvesting rainwater for domestic uses: an information guide. Environment Agency. https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/environment-agency The University of Manchester. Graphene: Mancheste’s Revolutionary 2D Material. http://www.graphene.manchester.ac.uk/ Accessed 10 May 2017 BBC News. Graphene-Based Sieve Turns Seawater Into Drinking Water. http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-39482342 Solemma LLC. DIVA-for-Rhino. http://www.solemma.net/ Baden-Powell, Charlotte. Architect’s Pocket Handbook. Elsevier, Oxford, 2002 Inno Therm Cotton And Denim Thermal Insulation. http://www.inno-therm.com/. Accessed 10 May 2017 Autodesk. Measuring Light Levels. Sustainabilityworkshop.autodesk.com/buildings/measuring-light-levels Accessed 8 May 2017 Royal Horticultural Society. www.rhs.org.uk Accessed 8 May 2017 How to grow wisteria. http://www.thompson-morgan.com/ Accessed 8 May 2017
CHAPTER 4 The Danish Association of Consulting Engineers (FRI) and the Danish Association of Architectural Firms (DANSKE ARK) . Description of Services Building and Planning 2012 General Conditions for Consulting Services. ABR 89 RIBA Plan of Work. https://www.ribaplanofwork.com/ Accessed 17 May 2017 Aecom. Spon’sArchitects’ and Builders’ Price Book. CRC Press. 2015 Managing health and safety in construction: Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015. http://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/priced/l153.pdf European Agency for Health and Saftey at Work. https://osha.europa.eu/en. Accessed 16 May 2017 https://arbejdstilsynet.dk
CHAPTER 5 Agger-Thyboron Coastal Batteries. krigsturist.dk http://www.wartourist.eu/. Accessed 1 November 2016 Lemvig Kommune Statistics. regionmidtjylland. https://www.rm.dk/regional-udvikling/statistik-og-analyse/midt-i-statistikken/. Accessed 24 November, 2016 http://caminoways.com/media/number-of-compostelas-2015-caminoways.png https://www.dmi.dk/en/hav/maalinger/tidal-tables/
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia
89
ND OF THE TOUR THE E
THE GRAND TOUR OF EUtopia