Towards Urban Data Commons? On The Origins And Significance Of Platform Data Sharing Mandates

Page 27

Understanding the Evolution Data sharing policy mandates did not emerge as a regulatory approach overnight, but evolved from existing trends and conditions, notably including the concept of “corporate data philanthropy” which I argue constitutes a key precursor. This section of the report provides a narrative of that roughly decade long evolution for the field. Intended not as authoritative “history” but rather as a theory of development for platform urbanism data sharing, this account is nonetheless informed by contemporaneous sources illustrating prominent trends and approaches to urban data, by primary and secondary source conversations with city officials, and from meta-analysis of platform data sharing policies. The narrative covered begins with a power shift in urban information processing, with “big data” and mobile technologies leading the private sector to far surpass local government capabilities as an authoritative source of civic information about the city. Calls for “data philanthropy” articulated a vision for data sharing for public benefit but relied on corporate good will. Some platforms did voluntarily offer data under this vision precluding perceived need for formal mandates. This gave cities a first taste of platform data and set the stage for the evolution of limited data sharing polices in “early adopter” agencies with the market leverage to target ride-hail and short-term rental platforms like Uber and Airbnb. Finally, this narrative will bring us to the present explosion of data sharing mandates across US cities and beyond, particularly in the domain of micromobility, and consider the more acute factors that enabled it. Let’s dive in.

Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs | Harvard Kennedy School

17


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook

Articles inside

Individual vs. Collective Conceptions of Urban Platform Data and the Case for Managing City Data as a Commons

10min
pages 142-152

Platform Urbanism Data Sharing Policy Guidelines: Best Practice Recommendations for Practitioners

14min
pages 128-136

New Frameworks Beyond the Binary

5min
pages 138-141

Summary of High-level Insights and Observations

13min
pages 118-127

The Results: the Dataset, the “Platform Urbanism Data Sharing Policy Hub” and Resultant Policy Analysis

1hr
pages 61-117

Where Things Stand in Platform Urbanism: Controversy Over MDS and Possible Futures

2min
pages 48-51

Techlash and the Sharing Economy

2min
pages 40-41

Aggregating a Policy Dataset

5min
pages 54-57

Show Me the Policies: The Access to Information Problem

2min
pages 52-53

Policy Clean Up, Structuring, and Organizing to Create a Research Database

3min
pages 58-60

Dockless Micromobility and Post Tech-Lash Municipalism: Cities Band Together and Demand Data

8min
pages 42-47

Early mandates: Select Cities Seek Data with Public Policy, While Platforms Resist

2min
pages 38-39

Understanding the Evolution

1min
page 27

The Data Philanthropy Vision Goes Local

3min
pages 30-32

Data Sharing on Uber’s Terms

2min
pages 36-37

Urban Platform Data Philanthropy in Action: Strava Metro and Waze CCP

3min
pages 33-35

Digital Platforms, IRL Impacts: The Good, the Bad and the Disruptive

1min
page 20

Big Data and a “Data Philanthropy” Vision for Public Good

2min
pages 28-29

What is Platform Urbanism?

1min
page 17

Challenges to Democratic Rule-Making Authority and Legitimacy

5min
pages 21-24
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.