HOW SHOULD WE THINK OF ·ATTACK”? Krassimir KANEV The ·Attack” coalition’s penetration of the parliament was, for Bulgarian political life, like a foul-smelling skeleton falling out of the closet, where it had remained hidden for years. It came as a shock not only to politicians, but also to political pundits; a shock which quite understandably shook the approved interpretations of the Bulgarian political process. But even before the elections, some of them made an attempt to force the advance made by ·Attack” into the channel of speculative patterns regarding the Bulgarian transition, which look a lot like the schemes of a ·transition from capitalism to socialism”, only turned inside-out. According to them this group is, in the words of Ahmed Dogan, ·a normal tumour”; something which, as Andrey Raychev and Kuncho Stoychev are trying to convince themselves, exists in ·normal” democratic countries and is the Bulgarian equivalent of the parties of Le Pen in France, Haider in Austria, Pim Fortuyn in the Netherlands or Umberto Bossi in Italy. In other words - we’ve become ·normal” and now we’ve got a ·normal” far-right party. It seems to me that this way of regarding ·Attack” just as appropriate as if we were to think of Bulgaria as being France or Austria; it is as far from reality as Bulgarian political and social life are far from the standards of such advanced democratic societies. In those societies, it would not be possible for a group using such forms and degrees of expression of racism and xenophobia to achieve parliamentary representation, nor even to be present in the public sphere. It would be impossible for such an aggressive Holocaust denier as Volen Siderov to find any place for himself there, other than in the dock in a court of justice. In this sense, if we are determined to find a political equivalent for him, we should look towards Adolf Hitler and Radovan Karadzic, rather than the European far right. LET’S MAKE A FEW COMPARISONS And let’s make them with regard the points on which they are possible and appropriate. In an interview in September 1987, the leader of the French National Front, Jean-Marie Le Pen, made the following statement regarding the existence of the Nazi gas chambers: ·I am saying that there are historians who debate these issues. I am not saying that the gas chambers did not exist. I myself have not seen them. I have not studied the matter specially. But I do think that this is a minor detail from the history of the Second World War.” For this ·minor detail” (and please note, without having said that the Holocaust had not existed!), Le Pen was ordered by a French court to pay a fine of about 200,000 dollars for disputing those crimes against humanity. While on a visit to Munich some years later, in December 1997, he commented on his 1987 ·minor detail” about the gas cham-
bers as follows: ·If you take a book of a thousand pages about the Second World War, in which 50 million people died, the concentration camps would take up two pages and the gas chambers 10 or 15 lines, and that is what is called a detail.” Jean-Marie Le Pen was fined a second time for these comments, and this time had to pay about 50,000 dollars, in order for the court’s decision to be published in several French newspapers, as well as a significant amount to compensate the organisations that had filed the lawsuit. After this ruling against him, he stopped making any public statements on the matter. I am not sure that there is a Bulgarian politician from any political power, much less a prosecutor, who would, if he didn’t know that those statements had been made by Le Pen, find them at all problematic, much less deserving of such harsh penalties. Let’s turn now to the book of the leader of ·Attack” Volen Siderov, The Boomerang of Evil, whose first edition was published in 2002. It is a third-rate piece of antiSemitic propaganda, which seeks to uncover the Jewish ·worldwide conspiracy” using a collection of references to proven falsehoods, simple-minded ideological constructs and ·facts” pulled out of thin air. In it he calls