NOVEMBER 2013
VOLUME 127
NUMBER1
'~HARVARD LAW
REVIEW
THE SUPREME COURT, 2012 TERM FOREWORD:
Reva B. Siegel
EQUALITY DIVIDED COMMENTS: BEYOND THE DISCRIMINATION MODEL ON VOTING
SamuelIssacharoff
WINDSOR AND BROWN: MARRIAGE
Michael J. Klarman
EQUALITY AND RACIAL EQUALITY LICENSE, REGISTRA TION, CHEEK SWAB: DNA
TESTINGAND
ErinMurphy
THE DIVIDED COURT LEADING CASES THE STATISTICS
ESSAYS IN HONOR OF JUSTICE RUTII BADER GINSBURG Deborah E. Anker Susan H. Farbstein Judge Nancy Gertner Lani Guinier Vicki C. J ackson Richard J. Lazarus
J ohn F. Manning M artha M inow Carol S. Steiker Julie C. Suk Laurence H. Tribe Mark Tushnet
RECENT PUBLICATIONS
Copyright ©
THE
HARVARD
LAW
REVIEW
ASSOCIATION
2013
by
VOLUME 127
NOVEMBER 2013
HARVARD
LAW ©
NUMBER 1
REVIEW 2013
by The Haruard Law Review Association
CONTENTS THE SUPREME COURT 2012 TERM FOREWORD
Equality Divided
Reva B. Siegel..
I
COMMENTS
Beyond the Discrimination Model on Voting
Samuel I ssacharoff
Windsor and Brown: Marriage Equality and Racial Equality
Michaell.
License, Registration, Cheek Swab: DNA Testing and the Divided Court
Erin Murphy
95
Klarman
I27
I61
LEADING CASES
1.
Constitutional Law A. Elections Clause Federal Preemption of State Law Federal Voter Registration Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc B. Article IV Privileges and Immunities Clause State Freedom of Information Laws McBurney v. Young
c.
,; ,y
I98 DIRf
Q'i.
$'"
•
~ ~
"o ~
.. .'~08
~ CJ.:j '"
lQ
AS')r"
First Amendment q'8L/Q"\'i."~· • '. h. Freedom of Speech ~ Unconstitutional Conditions .2 COTA "~_ J. r& ;;>. Ag~ncy for I nternatio~al Developni.erit v. N? C' . Allzancefor Open Society International, Ind-. __ ... r •.•.•.•.• ~
I
e
n
_
~u
COMPRA
iJ 14
CONTENTS
D. Fourth Amendment Trespass Test Florida v. Jardines
228
E. Sixth Amendment I.
Assistance of Counsel Retroactivity Chaidez v. United States
238
2.
Righ t to J ury Trial Mandatory Minimum Sentences Alleyne v. United States
248
F. Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection Clause Public-University Affirmative Action Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin
258
H. Federal Jurisdiction and Procedure A. Class Actions L Certification Requirements Under SEC Rule IOb-5 Amgen Inc. v. Connecticut Retirement Plans & Trust Funds 2.
Class Arbitration Waivers American Express COov. ltalian Colors Restaurant
268
278
B. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Plain Error Review Henderson v. United States
288
C. Standing Challenges to Government Surveillance Clapper v. Amnesty International USA
298
lH. Federal Statutes and Regulations A. Alien Tort Statute Extraterritoriality Kiobel v. Royal Dutch Petroleum Coo B. Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of Actual lnnocence Gateway McQuiggin V. Perkins C. Clean Water Act Auer Deference Decker v. Northwest
Environmental
ii
308 1996
Defense Center
318
328
CONTENTS
D. Communications Act of 1934 Chevron Deference City of Arlington v. FCC
338
E. Copyright Act of 1976 First Sale Doctrine Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons, Inc
348
F. Hatch-Waxman Act Reverse- Payment Settlements FTC v. Actavis, Inc
358
G. lndian Child Welfare Act Termination of Parental Rights Adoptive Couple v. Baby Girl
368
H. Patent Act of 1952 I. Patent Exhaustion Doctrine Bowman v. Monsanto COo 2. Patentable Subject Matter Ass'nfor Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics, Inc I.
378
388
Title VII Employer Liability for Supervisor Harassment Vance v. Ball State University
THE STATISTICS
398 ~
408
ESSAYS IN HONOR OF ]USTICE RUTH BADER GINSBURG
423
~;-.,,'"t
Introduction
423
Deborah E. Anker
425
Susan H. Farbstein Judge Nancy Gertner
~~ ~:
429
:
433
Lani Guinier
437
Vicki C. Jackson
445
Richard J. Lazarus
45 I
John F Manning
455
Martha Minow
461
III
CONTENTS
Carol S. Steiker
468
Julie C. Suk
···································4 73
Laurence H. Tribe
478
Mark Tushnet
481
RECENT PUBLICATIONS
486
IV