PENTICTON WESTERN
NEWS www.pentictonwesternnews.com
5
news ne
New program aims to match gardeners with available land
VOL.46 ISSUE 20
9
FRIDAY, MARCH 9, 2012
entertainment Performers take the stage en for 86th Kiwanis festival
17 7
Don’t forget to set your clocks ahead one hour on Sunday
CJHL JHLL JH sports orts Penticton Vees set new C record with 41 straight wins
COSTLY LAST CALL
City reviews 400 per cent increase for fees to extend bar closure times Simone Blais
Western News Staff
How much does hosting a late night on the town cost? For The Mule’s general manager Steven Parker, he hopes the answer won’t be 400 per cent more than what they paid in 2011. Parker made a presentation to council Monday inviting the City of Penticton, RCMP and liquor licensing of¿cials who are reviewing costs associated with policing late-night closures to consider the rami¿cations of boosting application fees to $24,000 a year from $4,500. “It’s a 400 per cent increase in what we’ve been used to paying for,” he said, adding The Mule would simply have to abandon the application with such a fee. “We’ve never had any communication that it’s an issue. So it’s a surprise to us.” For 2012, the Mule requested 16 dates for extended hours from 7 p.m. to 4 a.m., primarily on holiday weekends or those with special events in town: April 7, 13 and 14; May 19; June 29 and 30; Aug. 3, 4, 10, 11 and 31; Sept. 1; Oct. 27; Dec. 22 and 26. According to building and permitting manager Ken Kunka’s report to council, the Penticton RCMP detachment uses a formula of $100 per hour to calculate the costs associated with late-night openings. Those are billed back to licensed establishments that apply, and work out to $300 per latenight evening. But the RCMP contend there is an uptick in caseloads during those “special event” weekends, and the later
Mark Brett/Western News
GENERAL MANAGER Steven Parker behind the bar at The Mule night club this week. The downtown business could be facing huge increases in costs related to policing for its proposed late-night openings this year.
hours conÀict with predetermined weekend shifts from 7 p.m. to 7 a.m. In a Penticton RCMP report tracking 2010 data, weekends with 2 a.m. bar closure times result in an average of 25 ¿les throughout the city, but those with 4 a.m. closures have seen a 44 per cent increase to 36 ¿les. The report also found that ¿les increase in the downtown core and north beach areas on Fridays with 167 per cent increases (the average of six ¿les going up to 16 ¿les). Providing additional of¿cers to handle the additional caseloads was projected to be in the range of $1,600 an evening — which would cost an establishment like The Mule $24,000 per year. But Barb Haynes, Downtown Penticton Association executive director,
told council Monday that they have been closely tracking police incidents in the area to gauge the problem. When they looked at calls in the downtown area between 2 and 4 a.m. — the hours in question allegedly posing a problem — they found only seven could be directly attributed to The Mule for the entire year. “Not all the calls can be attributed to a late-night opening,” she said, adding the 4 a.m. closures are also offered on long weekends, which generate more parties and liquor consumption by tourists and residents alike. The city’s review was triggered earlier this year by a letter from Lakeside Resort and Casino management, which called on Penticton to abandon the 4 a.m. openings because the hotel found its patrons were damaging
suites and creating too much noise during those late nights. Haynes said the association also polled the Ramada and Coast Penticton Hotel for their sentiments. Both preferred 4 a.m. closures, she said, because their patrons were more likely to go directly to sleep, rather than return to their rooms at 2 a.m. and continue to party as they disturb neighbouring guests. Parker said The Mule outlined for council the numerous measures they’ve taken over the years to boost security. He said bar and security staff co-operate with the police, offering up indoor or outdoor video surveillance footage from the eight cameras on site, and learning how to identify patrons who have had enough is a key part of training.
“In these trying times, or any time for that matter, it never makes sense for The Mule to over-serve our customers,” he said, noting the Liquor Licensing Board’s ¿nes and penalties are stiffer than any pro¿t to be derived from another round of drinks. The later openings, he added, help The Mule expand to not only 40 seasonal staff in the summer, but maintain the 25 staff members throughout the slow winter months. Haynes said boosting fees is a “double-edged sword,” adding that council needs to recognize The Mule is the last business of its kind in Penticton. “Part of this discussion needs to include the business. At the very least, it needs to be a two-way discussion.” Saying the presentation “is quite at odds with the information we’ve been given,” Coun. Garry Litke suggested council permit the ¿rst April opening to 3 a.m. for $300, with a review to come on the fees after a consultation meeting is held with RCMP. Coun. Andrew Jakubeit said it was a “philosophical discussion” between the need for safety, the costs associated with policing and developing an environment in which business can Àourish. “To me, it’s a cost of doing business in a tourist town,” he said, “of course, $1,600 is also unrealistic.” Coun. John Vassilaki defended the 4 a.m. closures, noting how critical that industry is to Penticton. “Tourists, they come to Penticton to enjoy their stay while on holidays,” he said, noting the fees were too high. “Sixteen hundred dollars for two hours? It’s unethical.” Vassilaki moved they allow a 4 a.m. opening for the initial weekend at the $300 fee level, to be adjusted after a consultation meeting and set at “a reasonable price.” Council approved that motion, with only Litke opposed.