AA: Project 1 - Case Study Paper

Asian Architecture [ARC 60403/2234] PROJECT 1: CASE STUDY

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

NAME:

AIDA JUNITA BINTI ZULKIFLEE AMOS TAN CHI YI BENJAMIN CHENG JIA YEOW BRIDGET TAN SU TING KHOR YEN MIN NGE JIA CHEN

STUDENT ID:

0317766 0318330 0323336 0318370 0318149 0317738

LECTURER:

MS SHAHRIANNE

SUBMISSION DATE:

29 NOVEMBER 2016

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper Table of Contents

Page

Abstract………………………………………………………………………………………………..3 1.0

Introduction…………………………………………………………………………………...5

2.0

Critical Regionalism………………………………………………………………………….7

3.0

2.1

Introduction to Critical Regionalism……………………………………………….7

2.2

Influence of Critical Regionalism in Malaysia…………………………………..10

Application of Critical Regionalism in Vertical Developments including the skyscraper typology………………………………………………………………………..12

4.0

5.0

Similarities & Differences between Menara Mesiniaga and Generic Skyscraper…...17 4.1

Menara Mesiniaga As Compared to the International Style…………………..18

4.2

Menara Mesiniaga Similarities to the International Style……………………...18

4.3

Menara Mesiniaga Differences As Compared to the International Style…….19

Vernacular and Malay Architecture……………………………………………………….22 5.1

Introduction to Vernacular Architecture………………………………………….22

5.2

Characteristics and Adaptation of Vernacular Malay Architecture in a Tropical Climate……………………………………………………………………………...23

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

1

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

5.3

Adaptation of Malay Architecture’s Bioclimatic Strategies in Menara Mesiniaga…………………………………………………………………………..28

6.0

Conclusion…………………………………………………………………………………..32

7.0

References………………………………………………………………………………….33

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

2

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

Abstract In the current age of globalization, architecture seeks to resuscitate local identities and instil a psychological sense of place and belonging. However, the last thing we need today is another simple-minded attempt to revive the hypothetical forms of a lost vernacular or the employment of the International Style in architecture which would only result in buildings struggling to adapt to the changed environmental or sociocultural context. Hence, Critical Regionalism; an approach to architecture that strives to adopt Modern Architecture, critically, for its universal progressive qualities in addition to using geographical contextual forces to add value and meaning to the architecture, as the former lack sense of place and significance alone. This research paper aims to discuss Critical Regionalism and its approach adopted into Ken Yeang’s Menara Mesiniaga. The intention of carrying out this study is to identify the qualities of Critical Regionalism found in skyscrapers that sets them apart from the generic skyscraper. It is anticipated that the adaptation of vernacular Malay architecture form technologies into the building are being discovered through this case study. Literature reviews from various reliable sources regarding vernacular Malay architecture and critical regionalism were conducted to further assist in the validation of this research. In order to provide a wider variation of research, it is important to deliberate on Critical Regionalist architecture found within the Asian context, in which the Bedok Court Condominium in Singapore and the Rokko Housing I, II and III in Japan are taken to understand how the building design and its contextual response exemplifies critical regionalism. Comparisons between Menara Mesiniaga and the vernacular Malay architecture were also made to prove that there is a solid relationship between the two designs. It is understood that vernacular Malay architecture is heavily influenced by climate, where effective design steps were taken to accommodate the warm and humid climate found in Malaysia. Moreover, its flexibility in design through an addition system has allowed it to cater to the widely different needs of users. These qualities could be found in Menara Mesiniaga, therefore strengthening the fact that there are vernacular Malay

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

3

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

architecture influences on the building design such as the building layout, ventilation strategies, shading and natural lighting. The vernacular influence is further enhanced through the application of bioclimatic design in the building, where passive design strategies were implemented in order to achieve thermal and visual comfort as a whole. Hence, this concludes that Menara Mesiniaga is a critical regionalist architecture, where the building design has not only taken the vernacular into consideration but has also included the environmental context, ultimately giving meaning and sense of place to the building.

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

4

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

1.0 Introduction Malaysia, being an equatorial country, experiences a hot and humid climate all year long, with frequent rains and high temperatures being the norm. The town in which Menara Mesiniaga is located in, Subang Jaya, is located in the Greater Kuala Lumpur region, known as the Klang Valley. Subang Jaya is also known to have an abnormally high amount of lightning strikes in the region, and as such also has a high frequency of rain.

In general, the local architecture typically reflects the need for thermal comfort of its occupants. While Subang Jaya itself does not have any vernacular or historical architecture per se, its buildings do have considerations in the form of the 5-foot way (which is a public shaded road), north facing solar orientation, small windows and clerestories for stack ventilation. However, the Menara Mesiniaga takes its sustainable practices from more than these modern practices.

The vernacular architecture of Malaysia could be found in the villages and kampungs in the form of the Rumah Melayu. While the Rumah Melayu itself is a building topology and thus many variants exist thereof, there exist general design axioms. The Rumah Melayu exhibits a multitude of passive design solutions that result in a thermally comfortable internal environment for its occupants.

For Ken Yeang, three main forces influence his design methodology.

1. The climate. Buildings have to be designed in response to the ambient conditions of the site, and the design solution ultimately have to be specific to the location. With equatorial climate of Malaysia, Ken Yeang had to account for heavy rainfall, searing temperatures and relentless sun in its design. The local conditions of Subang Jaya also had to be considered, with its winds and other climatic elements influencing the Menara Mesiniaga’s design.

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

5

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

2. The culture. Buildings have to be designed according to the local attitude and way of life. The Malaysian work ethic, views and priorities have to be accounted for, and thus will influence the spatial planning as well as facilities and systems.

3. The aspirations of countries to join the developed world.

These forces can be summed up by the fact that there will never be a standard “onesize fits all” solution in architecture. This is directly contradictory to the “International Style” philosophy, of which assumes there exists a “universal truth” in architecture, and thus justifying the existence of the same approach, form and programme regardless if the building is in New York or in Kuala Lumpur.

The Menara Mesiniaga can be seen as the physical manifestation of this methodology.

Everything from its form, to its spatial planning, to its internal systems proves that this methodology is clearly influential on the building’s design. Most importantly, it has a relatively high success in achieving those thermal comfort goals for its occupants.

This paper will investigate the adaptation of vernacular Malay architecture form and technologies in a modern skyscraper by responding to the following research questions: Question 1:

What is critical regionalism and how does it influence architecture in Malaysia?

Question 2:

How is critical regionalism applied in the skyscraper typology?

Question 3:

What are the similarities/differences of critical regionalism used in Menara Mesiniaga compared to the generic skyscraper?

Question 4:

How does the Malay vernacular architecture influence the design of Menara Mesiniaga?

Question 5:

How does the bioclimatic design applied in Menara Mesiniaga parallels the strategies used in Malay vernacular architecture?

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

6

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

2.0

Critical Regionalism 2.1

Introduction to Critical Regionalism

Critical Regionalism is an approach to architecture that strives to counter the inauthentic and lack of meaning in Modern Architecture by using contextual means to give a sense of place and identity. The term was first used by Alexander Tzonis and Liane Lefaivre and later more famously and pretentiously by Kenneth Frampton in “Towards a Critical Regionalism: Six points of an architecture of resistance.� As per said by Kenneth Frampton, Critical Regionalism should take up modern architecture critically for its universal progressive qualities but at the same time should value the responses specifically to the context. Emphasis should be placed on topography, climate, light, tectonic form rather than scenography and the tactile sense rather than the visual.

Critical Regionalism vs. Regionalism

Figure 2.1.1 Menara Mesiniaga

Figure 2.1.2 Malay Kampung House (Source: Master thesis "One Straight Story", 2015)

(Source: AKDN,n.d)

As put forth by Tzonis and Lefaivre, critical regionalism need not be directly drawn from the context, rather elements can be stripped of their context and used in strange rather than familiar ways. Critical regionalism is distinct from regionalism which attempts to achieve a one-

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

7

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

to-one correspondence with vernacular architecture in conscious way without consciously partaking in the universal.

Critical regionalism is considered as a particular form of post-modern (not to be confused with post-modernism as architectural style) response in developing countries. The following architects have used such an approach in some of their works: Alvar Aalto, Jorn Utzon, Studio Granda, Mario Botta, B.V.Doshi, Charles Correa, Alvaro Siza, Rafael Moneo, Geoffrey Bawa, Raj Rewal, Tadao Ando, Mack Scogin / Merrill Elam, Ken Yeang, William S.W Lim, Tay Kheag Soon, Juhani Pallasma and Tan Hock Beng.

Figure 2.1.3 International Critical Regionalism (Source: WorldMuseum, n.d)

The architects have to mediate the impact of universal civilization with elements derived from the peculiarities of a particular space. There are preference to how the architect

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

8

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

deals with the irregularities of the physical landscape rather than how he or she employs local culture. The architects should enter “a dialectical relation with nature�, taking clues from topography and avoiding bulldozing in order to flatten space. Using top-lighting and exposing the elements of construction is a way to express critical regionalism, and it must be speaking more of the relationship of the building to its space.

Sometimes Regionalism goes back to just conservation and resorts to blind use of vernacular but critical regionalism seeks architectural traditions that are deeply rooted in the local conditions. This results in a highly intelligent and appropriate relevant architecture. In its broadest sense, then, the Critical Regionalist sensibility looks to the uniqueness of site and location when deriving the formal aspects of any given project.

All point to a design method that is assuredly modern but relies on the organic unity of local material, climatic and cultural characteristics to lend coherence to the finished work. The result is an architecture suited light and touch. Through a studied and careful appreciation of provincial traditions, regionalism in the post-war years resulted in designs permeate with sensitivity to the specifics of local climates and materials, topographies and building methods.

In a global aspect, its influence can be felt in the work of the Tichino School in Switzerland, the sophisticated urban infusions of many contemporary Spanish architects (including Rafael Moneo), or the austere concrete forms of the Japanese master Tadao Ando.

Figure 2.1.4 National Museum of Roman Art, Rafael Moneo

Figure 2.1.5 ISM Apartment Block 1951

(Source: Archdaily, 2015)

(Source: Hilary French: Key Urban Housing of the Twentieth Century, Lawrence King Publishing, London, 2008)

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

9

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

The Southern California work of Richard Neutra in the 1930s, for example, or the brilliant projects designed by the Barcelona architect J.A Coderch, demonstrate a variety of innovative alterations of local forms and methods to the requirements of modern functionality.

The results are formally and conceptually divorced from received notions of style, as in the case of Coderch’s celebrated ISM apartment block (1951), which represents a modern brick veneer mediated by carefully realized interpolations of traditional elements such as full-height wood shutters and thin overhanging cornices.

2.2

Influence of Critical Regionalism in Malaysia

The influence of critical regionalism is blatantly displayed in Malaysian context, as there are plenty of skyscrapers imbued with our very vernacular qualities. The architects Ken Yeang with Menara Mesiniaga, Nik Mohammed with Menara Dayabumi, and Cesar Pelli with our proud Petronas Twin Tower have appropriately expressed our culture into the internationally influenced building to create our very own identity.

Figure 2.2.1 Menara Mesiniaga

Figure 2.2.2 Menara Dayabumi

(Source: AKDN, n.d.)

(Source: Panaromio, 2013)

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

10

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

Figure 2.2.3 Petronas Twin Tower (Source: Momoc, 2009)

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

11

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

3.0

Application of Critical Regionalism in Vertical Developments including the skyscraper typology

According to Collins English Dictionary (2000), a skyscraper is defined as a tall building of multiple stories, especially one for office or commercial use. In the modern context, the term was coined when Chicago had one building to first employ the use of steel structure, which was the Home Insurance Building, built in 1885. It was a major stepping-stone toward modern skyscraper construction in the years to come (History.com, 2010).

Today, most skyscrapers are merely designed to be the tallest and outstanding structure, thus devoid of sense of contextual identity.

Figure 3.1: Home Insurance Building (Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/com mons/3/38/Home_Insurance_Building.JPG)

Applying Critical Regionalism in vertical developments especially skyscrapers can be a tedious process. It involves understanding the context to which the skyscraper would be built upon, ultimately reflecting locality and contributing to place identity. This is extremely important as skyscrapers stands as a monumental structure and the intention of applying critical regionalism approach in skyscraper design will be outstanding as it will definitely differ from other modernist skyscrapers. Failure to design a skyscraper to respond to both context and culture will result in the conformation of skyscraper that shows placelessness and lack of identity, similar to skyscrapers that have adopted the International Style or Modernism approach.

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

12

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

Two case studies were made to identify how critical regionalism is applied to the skyscraper typology. The case studies chosen are located in London and Singapore respectively. This is to show the various approaches these skyscraper designs were made across different context and climate, displaying critical regionalism.

Case Study 1: London - 1 Undershaft

By Avery Associates

Figure 3.2: 1 Undershaft (Source: http://www.architectsjournal.co.uk/pic tures/606x422fitpad[0]/5/5/4/1406554 _14-12-16-1-Undershaft-AAA-5.jpg)

Figure 3.3: St. Helen’s building (Source: http://www.earchitect.co.uk/images/jpgs/london/l ondon_building_aw050507_204.jpg)

1 Undershaft (Figure 3.2) is a proposed skyscraper to be built in the financial district of London, replacing the currently standing St Helen’s building. It is set to be the world’s exemplary skyscraper in applying Critical Regionalism in its design.

St. Helen’s building as shown in Figure 3.3, is a skyscraper that has applied the International Style in its design. Due to the site being bought by a different owner, plans were made to demolish the building and to build a brand new skyscraper (Skyscrapernews.com,

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

13

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

2015). In result, the proposed design for the new building was made and has actually succeeded in its design due to its sensitive response to its context.

1 Undershaft 30 St Mary Axe

Leadenhall building 20 Fenchurch

Leadenhall building

1 Undershaft 30 St Mary Axe

Figure 3.4: 1 Undershaft among London skyscrapers (Source: https://acdn.architizer.com/thumbnailsPRODUCTION/68/fc/68fc7df057869e2a2b04776a73111855.jpg)

1 Undershaft is set to be built among the London skyline, standing along notable skyscrapers such as 30 St Mary Axe (the Gherkin), the Leadenhall building (the Cheesegrater), The Scalpel and 20 Fenchurch Street (the Walkie-Talkie). Its design is intended to correlate closely with its surroundings, especially having the lowest possible visual impact on the skyline (The Angry Architect, 2015).

Note, in Figure 3.4, how the building has its massing responding directly to the adjacent Leadenhall building and has taken into consideration of not obscuring the view of the Gherkin (Weston, 2015). The building’s design also pays attention to its climatic response as shown in Figure 3.5.

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

14

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

Figure 3.5: Section and diagram of 1 Undershaft (http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=1791935)

In short, the prospect of a context-sensitive architecture in the heart of a commercial business centre has shown that 1 Undershaft design has successfully applied Critical Regionalism. The building has brought in principles of modernism and has responded to surrounding formal and cultural factors, allowing it to compete with its surrounding skyscrapers yet maintaining the sense of place within the London skyline. Although the proposal fell through in the last minute due to new ownership, it undoubtedly would have been the first skyscraper in the world to attempt Critical Regionalism in this scale and context.

Case Study 2: Singapore – Oasia Hotel Downtown

By WOHA

Figure 3.6: (L-R) Oasia Hotel Downtown among Singapore’s Central Business District, View of Hotel from Gopeng Street, Carved-in skygarden viewed up close.

(Source: http://www.woha.net/#Oasia-Hotel-Downtown)

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

15

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

Oasia Hotel Downtown is one of the few skyscrapers that eschew the International Style of a sealed glass box. The building design has taken into consideration its tropical climate based on its context. The double-skin façade system functions as an environmental buffer, shading against harsh tropical sun from warming up the hotel rooms and sky terraces (Figure 3.6). It also visually blurs out the transition between the air-conditioned interior from the naturally ventilated public space and the building exterior (Furuto, 2012).

WOHA has adopted the club sandwich approach by splitting the building into 3 different strata, each with its own sky garden. This creates generous public areas for recreation and social interaction within the hotel. The open sky terraces also allows good cross-ventilation apart from allowing visual transparency, ultimately ensuring thermal comfort (WOHA, 2016).

This way, the hotel has successfully incorporated open, functional and comfortable public space in contrast with the typical hotel design typology which is enclosed air conditioned spaces.

In short, Oasia Hotel Downtown was designed to combat the generic, InternationalStyle skyscraper by creating open spaces throughout the high-rise. The design also caters to its tropical climate where ventilation is prioritized in order to achieve thermal comfort. Its unique façade has also stood out among neighbouring skyscrapers in Singapore’s Central Business District, providing a fresh look to the area.

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

16

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

4.0

Similarities & Differences between Menara Mesiniaga and Generic Skyscraper The “generic skyscraper” is a misnomer, as it implies there exists a “standard template”

of which all skyscrapers around the world follow. While effectively this may be true, we first have to understand that the modern stereotype of a skyscraper being a tall, narrow, glass covered box did have its roots influenced by cultural and climatic situation in the place where it was first designed.

The problem arises when this climatic and cultural response is assumed to be the same the world over, and thus the design is exported all over the globe (thus the term, International Style, a term which was not coined by any of the Modernist architects) with this very assumption, resulting in the general population assuming that there exists a “generic skyscraper”.

Thus, we can now define the “generic skyscraper” as a tall, office building built according to the International Style of architecture, and would then exhibit characteristics common to it.

Figure 4.1: Typical characteristics of an International Style skyscraper (Source: Bill Zbaren, 2015)

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

17

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

4.1

Menara Mesiniaga As Compared to the International Style

In general, Menara Mesiniaga exhibits the Structural Expressionism style of architecture, a contemporary approach during its construction period that, as its name suggests, exhibits its structural systems and expresses it as a part of the building’s form. This style can be traced back to the Modernist style of architecture, where buildings have a certain degree of expressing its structure, although it was largely hidden away in the building’s walls.

However, though Menara Mesiniaga does seem to tick all of the boxes for being an International Style building, the beauty of the Critical Regionalism approach is that, while it may have the physical characteristics of an International Style structure, the method and deployment of these characteristics define the Menara Mesiniaga as a contemporary example of Asian architecture.

4.2

Menara Mesiniaga Similarities to the International Style

At first glance, the Menara Mesiniaga does seem to have large International Style influences (unsurprisingly considering its origins). While it may not have a rectilinear form, it does have a central, cylindrical massing. It has no ornamentations, and has a lot of planar surfaces. Interior spaces are relatively open, with very little structure obstructing circulation or views. There is a heavy usage of glass and steel, and cantilever construction could be found on the ground floor’s foyer.

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

18

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

Figure 4.2.1: Similarities to the International Style of skyscraper (Source: Aga Khan Development Network, 1995)

4.3

Menara Mesiniaga Differences As Compared to the International Style

As discussed in the previous Section (4), the employment of the Critical Regionalist approach to architecture has resulted in the adoption of vernacular architectural tectonics, technologies and approaches in the Menara Mesiniaga. This has resulted in the Menara Mesiniaga displaying the following principle differences:

Figure 4.3.1: Principle differences between Menara Mesiniaga and International Style skyscrapers (Source: Aga Khan Development Network, 1995)

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

19

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

Broken Up Massing Description: In stark contrast to the smooth homogenous surfaces of the International Style skyscraper,

the

Menara

Mesiniaga’s

smooth

cylindrical form is highly punctuated by apertures that appear to have “penetrated” into the building in an upward, spiralling pattern.

Rationale: This broken-up massing is done for principally for the usage of greenery as well as introducing permeable interior spaces. Similar to a vernacular Malay house.

Figure 4.3.2: Instead of a smooth, homogenous massing, Menara Mesiniaga has created voids in its cylindrical form, allowing for the use of passive design elements.

Usage Of Greenery Description: The usage of vegetation in any building as a thermal control strategy is concept employed by the vernacular Malay house. While International Style skyscrapers seem to be extremely reluctant in the employment of any vegetation, the Menara Mesiniaga uses it liberally to cool and shade the interior from the sun.

Rationale: It can be argued that it is a necessary approach given its climatic context.

Figure 4.3.3: Use of vegetation in Menara Mesiniaga highlighted

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

20

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

Permeable Spaces Description: International Style skyscrapers are known to have relatively airtight environments. In fact, the rise of sick building syndrome cases can be directly linked to the increasing use of HVAC in office buildings. Menara Mesiniaga, in contrast, employs the use of permeable spaces (i.e. allowing outside air to flow inward).

Rationale: This is a form of cross ventilation that is also used by the Malay house, an effective form of passive design for the climatic situation.

Figure 4.3.4: Wind enters through permeable façade and into the interior, ventilating and cooling the internal environment.

Emphasis On Sunshading Description: Menara Mesiniaga is renowned for its expressed use of large, sun shading louvres that are hung. This creates a visual depth compared to the relatively flat surfaces of International Style skyscrapers, and proves the local context’s importance on the usage of sunshading devices due to the existing climatic condition.

Rationale: The local climatic situation requires extensive sunshading devices to minimize solar gain.

Figure 4.3.5: Large sunshading louvres are expressed

While Menara Mesiniaga already bears a rather obvious difference to the “generic skyscraper”, it is worth bearing in mind the reasons, rationale and justifications for this. Ken Yeang did not design Menara Mesiniaga just so he could put Malaysia on a map with its radical form; rather, it is an exercise in necessity – a design specifically for the given site conditions.

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

21

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

5.0

Vernacular and Malay Architecture 5.1

Introduction to Vernacular Architecture

According to an analysis by Connor Janzen (2015), in terms of architecture, vernacular defines the built environment as structures created by untrained individuals, suited for particular needs of the individual who built the structure. For example, macro climate of an area is a significant influence on vernacular architecture. In Malaysia, the hot and humid climate affect the use of low thermal mass materials and application of cross-ventilation.

Characteristics of vernacular architecture is also governed by local environment and construction materials. For instance, Malaysia – being covered in rainforest and abundant in trees and timber as building materials, developed a wooden vernacular. In other words, vernacular architecture can be seen as designing based on local needs, availability of construction materials and reflecting local traditions.

Apart from that, the way of life of users and the use of the building heavily influence the building’s form. Interaction between users and cultural aspects also affect the layout and size of buildings in vernacular architecture.

Vernacular is meant to be sustainable – thus not exhausting the local resources available. Unsustainability of the local resources makes it unsuitable for local context, hence it is not considered as vernacular.

Vernacular architecture in any region creates a connection between both culture and architecture, and people in the region. Vernacular architecture is not stringently limited to any specific region, but it is becoming more popular as a design strategy in modern day urban planning and building.

Vernacular architecture is inclined to develop in order to reflect the environmental, cultural, technological, economic and historical context. Specifically to Malaysia, some of the

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

22

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

ideals in vernacular architecture include sustainability, cultural significance and adaptability.

Through understanding and analyzing these ideals, they can be utilized to further improve schemes and design regarding architecture.

Figure 5.1.1 Example of a Malay House (Yuan, 1987)

5.2

Characteristics and Adaptation of Vernacular Malay Architecture in a Tropical Climate

Among the characteristics of vernacular Malay architecture is that there is an extensive comprehension and consideration of nature. As villagers were highly dependent on nature to provide for their needs, a deep understanding of the study of ecology was widespread. Their daily necessities including building materials were acquired directly from nature. The traditional Malay house is designed directly with nature in its approach through its climatic design. In order to grasp the adaptation of the traditional Malay house, the environmental conditions of the tropical climate must be understood.

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

23

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

Set up wholly by the villagers themselves, the traditional Malay house is an outstanding house form which takes the local climatic conditions as well as the social life of the inhabitants into consideration. It is designed to adapt to the warm and humid climate of Malaysia as well as for functional purposes. Its flexible design meets the various needs of the users.

Design for Climatic Control

Figure 5.2.1 Climatic Design and Considerations in a Traditional Malay House

The design and form of the traditional Malay house illustrates several characteristics that equips its house form with the suitability to adapt to the hot and humid climatic conditions in Malaysia. (a) Ventilation for passive cooling and humidity control; (b) Direct solar radiation control; (c) Control of glare from the surroundings and open sky; (d) Protection from rain; (e) Natural vegetation in the surroundings for a cooler environment; (f) Building materials of low thermal capacity (for minimal heat transmission into the house

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

24

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

The traditional Malay house is mainly focused on the ventilation and solar radiation control for the climatic comfort for the inhabitants in the house as these are the effective criteria for climatic comfort in a hot and humid environment.

Design Approach for Ventilation

Figure 5.2.2: Design Approach for Ventilation in a Traditional Malay House

Ventilation in a traditional Malay house consists of three strategies: top, bottom and cross ventilation at an appropriate body height. With these approaches, appropriate design features and adaptive devices are practised.

1. Planning Layout/ Site Planning

Figure 5.2.3: Random Arrangement of Malay Houses

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

25

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

a) Random arrangement of houses This is to ensure that the wind has a comparatively unrestricted passage through the community. b) Orientation Due to religious purposes, traditional Malay houses are oriented to face Mecca (in an eastwest orientation). This minimises exposure to heat from solar radiation. The direction is also appropriate for the wind direction in Malaysia (north-east and south-west).

Figure 5.2.4: Ventilation Aided by Raised Floor in a Traditional Malay House

c) Raised Floor The traditional Malay houses are raised on timber stilts or pile to elevate the building for natural ventilation as well as a form of protection from floods. d) Vegetation The compound of the Malay house is often heavily shaded with trees and covered with vegetation. This sets the house in a cooler environment as well as reduces glare from the surrounding environment with the less reflective natural ground covers.

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

26

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

2. Building Layout

Figure 5.2.5: Floor Layout of a Traditional Malay House

a) Elongated open plans to allow easy passage of air and good cross ventilation. b) Minimal partitions for natural lighting and air circulation within the whole interior space.

3. Openings

Figure 5.2.6: Ventilation Openings of a Traditional Malay House

a) Full-length fully openable windows and doors (due to the body level being the most vital area for ventilation) to achieve cross ventilation. Exterior winds are also encouraged to ventilate the spaces in the house.

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

27

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

b) Decorative elements (intricate carved wooden ventilation grilles and panels – tebar layar) for air passage through roof area.

4. Roof Elements a) Ventilation joints and panels in the roof construction (tebar layar) to trap and direct air for roof ventilation. b) No ceiling panel to assure no air blockage. c) Ventilated roof space for cooling of the house. d) Large overhangs for provision of good protection against heavy rainfall, solar radiation and to allow for windows to be left open most of the time for ventilation. e) Construction materials with low thermal capacity for minimal heat retention.

5.3

Adaptation of Malay Architecture’s Bioclimatic Strategies in Menara Mesiniaga

Bioclimatic high-rise is a skyscraper with designs and spaces which provide passive low energy benefits. Connections with Malay architecture are evident in the case of the design of the Menara Mesiniaga. The architect’s intention in taking the Malay sensitivity to comfort, climate and nature is encapsulated in the building. The principles and technologies of shading, openness, permeability to air movement, linkages to water and the garden are abstracted and applied to high-rise office towers. Besides that, an extensive use of natural ventilation and natural light reflected of open and permeable Malay house forms are prominent in the building.

Menara Mesiniaga has adapted a few of the traditional Malay house features which have created excellent bioclimatic designs with both internal and external features to produce a low energy building ideal for the tropical climate.

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

28

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

The traditional Malay house is raised up by silts. The space between the ground and the house is well shaded with minimum blockage by structures. Besides to protect the building from flash flood, this allows cross ventilation (Figure 5.3.1) to occur in between the space, creating a cooling effect at the bottom of the house.

The exoskeleton of Menara Mesiniaga has exposed steel and reinforced concrete structure (Figure 5.3.2) that wraps around the curtain wall to block the sunlight off. It is useful as a heat sink component and to minimize heat absorption. The sloped berm and open mezzanine floors (Figure 5.3.3) which circles the circumference of the building allows air movement underneath the building. This has created a well-shaded and ventilated lobby entrance without mechanical systems.

Figure 5.3.1

Figure 5.3.2

Figure 5.3.3

The random arrangement of tall trees in the kampong provides shade and also does not block the flow of winds into the house. With adequate natural vegetation in the surroundings, this can create a cooler environment of external and internal of the house.

(Figure 5.3.4) Menara Mesiniaga has stepped terraces (Figure 5.3.5) which can be seen spiralling up and away from the berm, generating an atrium which not only provides transitional spaces and natural ventilation but also the planting enhances the shade and increases the oxygen supply into the building.

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

29

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

Figure 5.3.4

Figure 5.3.5

Besides that, the traditional Malay house has minimum amount of partitions used to create open interior spaces. This promotes good ventilation throughout the interior spaces.

Body level is the most important area for ventilation, thus full-length fully openable windows are important in the house. (Figure 5.3.6) In Menara Mesiniaga, besides reflecting the sun rays, the exposed columns and beams are open to encourage air circulation within the building. (Figure 5.3.7) Also, all office floors terraces are provided with full-height sliding glass doors that allow fresh air in.

Internal enclosed rooms are placed as a central core which provides natural lighting and a good view of the surrounding context around the building.

Figure 5.3.6

Figure 5.3.7

In traditional Malay house, attap roof is used as thermal insulator and to provide shade.

It has low thermal capacity which holds less heat and cools down at night. (Figure 5.3.8) In Menara Mesiniaga, a cantilevering rooftop pool is designed to ‘green’ the rooftop by insulating and reflecting the overhead sun. Ken Yeang has also adopted and implemented

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

30

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

the idea by making the central core as extensive passive heating and cooling strategies (Figure 5.3.9) of the building. The concrete core of the building is situated on exterior of the east side of the tower. This creates sun shading for the building and its material construction allows it to become a heat sink that will reradiate absorbed heat into the interiors at night.

Figure 5.3.9

Figure 5.3.8

Furthermore, large roof overhang and the low exposed vertical areas (windows and walls) are essential to traditional Malay Houses to provide protection against driving rain, good shading and allow the windows to be left open most of the time for ventilation.

In Menara Mesiniaga, the curvilinear overhang roof (Figure 5.3.11) minimises the south faรงade from exposing to solar radiation from the high angled sun. On north and south faรงade, double-glazed curtain walls are used to control solar gain whereas on the east and west faรงade, aluminium fins and louvers (Figure 5.3.12) are installed to provide sun shading for the interior spaces.

Figure 5.3.10

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

Figure 5.3.11

Figure 5.3.12

31

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

6.0

Conclusion Critical regionalism is an approach to architecture that seeks to mediate between the

global and the local languages of architecture, in addition to regionalism in vernacular architecture. The term typically denotes an architecture that is derived from its local setting, ultimately becoming inherently site specific, while responding to the local climate and culture.

It places emphasis on the reflection of local tradition and culture of a building’s site through its design and material to prevent the lack of identity and placelessness in the building.

The influence of critical regionalism in skyscraper typology and in the Malaysian context has significantly affected the design of Menara Mesiniaga, as did the adaptation of vernacular Malay architecture.

These design approaches and bioclimatic principles implemented were not only quintessential to make a mark in the world of architecture, but also vital in order to create a sustainable built form which responds fittingly to the site context.

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

32

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

7.0

References

A HISTORY OF ARCHITECTURE - CRITICAL REGIONALISM. (n.d.). Retrieved November 25, 2016, from http://www.historiasztuki.com.pl/kodowane/003-02-05-ARCHWSPREGIONALIZM-eng.php Ahmad, A. MALAY VERNACULAR ARCHITECTURE. Hbp.usm.my. Retrieved 28 October 2016, from http://www.hbp.usm.my/conservation/malayvernacular.htm An Architecture of Resistance – Kenneth Frampton (1983). (2011). Retrieved November 27, 2016, from https://criticalregionalismdotcom.wordpress.com/2011/03/03/anarchitecture-of-resistance-kenneth-frampton-1983/ Bromberek, Z. (2004). Contexts of architecture: Proceedings of the 38th Annual Conference of the Architectural Science Association ANZAScA and the International Building Performance Simulation Association - Australasia, Launceston, 10-12 November, 2004. Retrieved November 20, 2016, from http://anzasca.net/.../uploads/2014/08/ANZAScA2004_Kamal.pdf Critical regionalism. (n.d.). Retrieved November 21, 2016, from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_regionalism Critical Regionalism. Retrieved November 23, 2016, from http://www.slideshare.net/ar_suryas/critical-regionalism Furuto, A. (2012). Oasia Downtown / WOHA. ArchDaily. Retrieved 18 November 2016, from http://www.archdaily.com/215376/oasia-downtown-woha History.com (2010). Home Insurance Building - Facts & Summary - HISTORY.com.

HISTORY.com. Retrieved 14 November 2016, from http://www.history.com/topics/home-insurance-building Janzen, C. (2015). Vernacular Architecture in Malaysia – Connor Janzen. Retrieved November 15, 2016 from http://connorjanzen.com/vernacular-malaysia/

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

33

Menara Mesiniaga and Critical Regionalism: Adapting Vernacular Malay Architecture Form and Technologies in a Modern Skyscraper

Menara Mesiniaga. (n.d.). Retrieved November 15, 2016, from http://www.mesiniaga.com.my/about-us/menara-mesiniaga.aspx Nasir, A. & Teh, H. (1996). The traditional Malay house (1st ed.). Shah Alam: Fajar Bakti. skyscraper. (2000). Collins English Dictionary - Complete & Unabridged 10th Edition.

Retrieved 13 November 2016, from Dictionary.com website http://www.dictionary.com/browse/skyscraper Skyscrapernews.com (2015). Avery Associates Aviva Proposals - Article #3508.

Skyscrapernews.com. Retrieved 26 November 2016, from http://www.skyscrapernews.com/news.php?ref=3508 Surya Ramesh, Architect at Government Engineering College, Thrissur Follow. (2008).

The Angry Architect (2015). Hidden in Plain View: Is This the World’s First Contextual Skyscraper?. Architizer. Retrieved 16 November 2016, from http://architizer.com/blog/hidden-in-plain-view/ Weston, R. (2015). The Contextual Tower: Avery Associates' No 1 Undershaft. Architects Journal. Retrieved 16 November 2016, from https://www.architectsjournal.co.uk/buildings/the-contextual-tower-avery-associatesno1-undershaft/8674823.article Wijnen, B. Malay Houses. Malaysiasite.nl. Retrieved 20 October 2016, from http://www.malaysiasite.nl/malayhouse.htm WOHA (2016). WOHA. Woha.net. Retrieved 18 November 2016, from http://www.woha.net/#Oasia-Hotel-Downtown

ARC 2213/2234 Asian Architecture

34