october 2021
NEW RESEARCH ON ART AND ITS HISTORY
OCTOBER 2021
Art in twentieth-century China Empress Cixi’s Japanese screen | History painting under Mao | Chen Yanqiao’s heroic nudes Vermeer and Van Gogh discoveries | Recent acquisitions at Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen
the burlington magazine no. 1423 vol. 163 COVER_OCT21.indd 2
20/09/2021 18:31
From Antiquity to today
At Carrousel du Louvre & Online
70 Galleries
6 - 11
November 2021 Pierre-Auguste Renoir, Sunset, 1879 or 1881, Oil on canvas. The Clark Art Institute, 1955.602.
finear ts-paris.com oct21fineartsparis.indd 1
17/09/2021 14:17
JEAN-BAPTISTE OUDRY
oct21robilant+voena.indd 1 RV-JBOudry_BurlingtonAD-WK.indd 2
17/09/2021 15/09/2021 14:19 13:46
C H A R L E S B E D D I N GT O N L I M I T E D DEALER AND AGENT IN FINE ART
GUIDO RENI (Bologna 1575–1642)
Saint John the Baptist preaching in the Wilderness Oil on canvas 85 x 56⅝ in. (216 x 144 cm.) PROVENANCE:
The Regia Pinacoteca, Turin, by 1635. The Abbé Reynard, Paris, by the late 1760s. Acquired from him by Sir Joshua Reynolds, PRA, in 1768, on behalf of Charles Ingram, 9th Viscount Irwin (1727-1778), and by inheritance at Temple Newsam House, Yorkshire, and elsewhere to the previous owner. SELECTED LITERATURE:
Inventario della regia Pinacoteca di Torino descritta nel 1635, ‘San Giovanni Battista nudo al deserto, con bocca aperta, figura intiera. Di Guido Reni. De’ migliori. A. p[iedi liprandi] 3 ½; L. p. 2 ½.’ A Catalogue of the Pictures at Templenewsam, Ms., 4 March 1808, no. 10 ‘Guido – St. John preaching in the wilderness, size of nature … it has been engraved’ (hanging in the Gallery). G.F. Waagen, Treasures of Art in Great Britain, London, 1854, III, p. 332 ‘Guido Reni – John the Baptist; whole-length figure’. ENGRAVED:
Pascal Pedro Moles (Valencia 1741–1797 Barcelona), dated 1770 (when Moles was studying in Paris). Anon. (Paris, Bibliothèque Nationale, Vol. 28, no. 61).
ACQUIRED BY A PRIVATE COLLECTOR
This painting, which is in exceptional condition, and in which Reni’s distinctive touch is evident throughout, along with very prominent pentimenti, displays many of the qualities for which the art of ‘the divine Guido’ has always been esteemed. The painting was held in exceptional regard during the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, being valued in 1808 at the considerable sum of 600 guineas. Hidden in a private collection since then, it is yet to be fully published. On stylistic grounds it may be dated around 1631/2, which is confirmed by its absence from the Turin inventory of 1631 but presence in that of 1635. It thus anticipates the well-known painting of the same subject, of very different character, in the Dulwich Picture Gallery. Several copies of the painting are known, and the influence of the composition is evident in the work of several later painters. Those include Sir Joshua Reynolds, who acquired it for an ancestor of the previous owner in September/October 1768, and whose more youthful Saint John the Baptist in the Wilderness was underway in in December 1770, though not exhibited until 1776. A red chalk drawing which would appear to be a study for the torso of the Baptist in this painting was sold in an auction in New York in 2011.
1 6 s av i l e r o w, l o n d o n w 1 s 3 p l
tel +44 (0)20 7439 4959 www.charlesbeddington.com
oct21beddingtonDPS.indd 2
fax +44 (0)20 7439 4969 info@charlesbeddington.com
17/09/2021 14:05
oct21beddingtonDPS.indd 3
17/09/2021 14:06
oct21asianartlondonadvert.indd 1
17/09/2021 17:23
FRANCESCO VEZZOLI
THE OEDIPUS COMPLEX
Trinity Fine Art
11 October 1 November
Vezzoli_def.indd 1 oct21trinity.indd 1
15 Old Bond Street, London W1S 4AX United Kingdom
info@trinityfineart.com T: +44 (0) 207 493 4916 www.trinityfineart.com
16/09/21 15:32 17/09/2021 14:14
Indian & Islamic Art: 21 – 30 October East Asian Art: 28 October – 6 November
INDIAN AND ISLAMIC ART – SOME HIGHLIGHTS For the second year running the Asian Art in London programme will be divided into two overlapping phases. This, the 24th iteration of AAL, will begin with a focus on Indian and Islamic art on 21st October, with East Asian art events commencing a week later on the 28th (with some dealers and salerooms inevitably selling in both categories). This celebration of Asian art will embrace ancient and modern works from the Middle East, India, Southeast Asia, the Himalayas, Central Asia, China, Japan, Korea and Vietnam. As always there will be a large geographical spread of participants across London. This will include visitors to the city from the regions and abroad who will occupy temporary spaces. The largest concentration of exhibitions and auctions will be in Mayfair, St James’s and Kensington. For full details and to download the comprehensive AAL guide with maps, relevant museums, collections and Asian societies visit: asianartinlondon.com Illustration from a Markendeya Purana series Kangra or Mandi, India. c.1830–50. Pigments on paper, 13.7 by 20.6 cm. marble, 40.6 by 90.8 by 53.8 cm. ROB DEAN ART, 35 BURY STREET, SW1
An engraved shaffron (horse’s head armour) with the basmala. Ottoman Turkey or Anatolia, 16th century. Steel, 58.5 by 44 cm. CHISWICK AUCTIONS, 1 COLVILLE ROAD, W3
A sword or shamshir with the hilt in the form of a Makra (Hindu sea-creature). India, 19th century. Steel, gold, silver, enamel, diamonds, emeralds, green beryls, rubies and glass, 104 by 40.9 cm. PETER FINER, 38-39 DUKE STREET, SW1
A ‘dakon’ or ‘congklak’ game board. Central Java (probably Surakarta), early 18th century. Wood, lacquer, pigments and gold leaf, 89 by 15 by 17 cm. JONATHAN HOPE, 8 DUKE STREET, SW1
oct21AALround-up.indd 1
Iznik border tile. Ottoman Turkey, c.1570–80. Ceramic, 25.5 by 13 cm. CHRISTIE’S, 8 KING STREET, SW1
17/09/2021 14:09
Special exhibition until January 2, 2022
Kronprinsessegade 30 Copenhagen, Denmark davidmus.dk
oct21davidcollection.indd 1
17/09/2021 14:22
Indian & Islamic Art: 21 – 30 October East Asian Art: 28 October – 6 November
EAST ASIAN WORKS OF ART – SOME HIGHLIGHTS
Geometric panel. China, Ming dynasty, 15th century. Silk brocade, 70 by 65 cm. JACQUELINE SIMCOX, 106 NEW BOND STREET, W1
A carved Yaozhou ware bowl. China, Northern Song Dynasty (960–1127). Ceramic, diameter 9.5 cm. LITTLETON & HENNESSEY ASIAN ART, 1 PRINCES PLACE, SW1
Vase, by Yonezawa Hisashi. c.1960. Ceramic, width 32 cm. JOOST VAN DEN BERGH, 21 CORK STREET W1
oct21AALround-up.indd 2
Head of Buddha Sakyamuni. Thailand, Chang Mai Lan Na kingdom, 15th century. Bronze, height 40 cm. MARCEL NIES ORIENTAL ART, 27 DOVER STREET, W1
A carved treasure box. China, Qianlong (1736–95). Cinnabar lacquer, width 21 cm. SWORDERS, 15 CECIL COURT, SW2
A pair of famille rose fish bowls. China, Qing Dynasty, Yongzheng period (1723–35). Ceramic, diameter 62 cm. DUKE’S, DORCHESTER (check for London location)
17/09/2021 14:10
Jacqueline Simcox Limited
A white silk kesi panel, woven with spotted deer and crested birds on a ground of variously coloured leaves and flower heads. East Central Asia, 12th/13th century 55 x 33 cms PRO V ENA NCE:
Spink & Son Ltd, London, before 1994 The Hollander Collection, USA PU B LIS HED:
Chinese Textiles, Spink & Son exhibition catalogue, no. 4, 1994 S I MILA R EX A M PLES :
The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York Illustrated: When Silk Was Gold, by James C.Y. Watt & Anne E. Wardwell, no. 16, 1997 Musée Guimet, Paris, Illustrated: Asie Extreme, by Jean-Paul Desroches, pl 36, 1993
EX HIB IT ION :
CHINESE TEXTILES 28th October - 6th November at Shapero Rare Books 106 New Bond Street London W1S 1DN
Business address: by appointment only 54 LINTON STREET
•
LONDON
•
N1 7AS
w : jacquelinesimcox.com t : +44 (0)777 5566 388 e : js@jacquelinesimcox.com
oct21simcox.indd 1
17/09/2021 14:09
Collectors’ desire Rare and Elegant Song Ceramics A Superb Junyao Purple-splashed Dish Song Dynasty Diameter: 18.5cm Sotheby’s Hong Kong, 22 April 2021, lot 16 (Sold for £2,552,000/US$3,466,500)
Collecting brings joy! Learning brings knowledge! Song Dynasty Ceramics highlights over 126 objects from the V&A’s magnificent
collection to discuss China’s great age of ceramic production (960-1279). This longawaited survey is illustrated with many of the very finest examples of Song ware in the Western world. The V&A’s collection of Song Dynasty ceramics ranges from rare and precious items to many interesting study pieces.
Rose Kerr is an English art historian specializing in Chinese art, especially Chinese ceramics. She is the author of over 25 books on Chinese art. This is the second and augmented edition of her book Song Dynasty Ceramics which was first published by the Victoria and Albert Museum in 2004. She was the Keeper of the Far Eastern Department at the Victoria & Albert Museum in London until 2003.
£ 80 / US$98
Order a copy to know more about Song ceramics orderbook@cabookpublishing.com.hk
oct21CAPublishing.indd 1 Burlington layout_new.indd 2-3
17/09/2021 14:37
A Bubble Bowl with Blue Glaze and Purple Splashes Northen Song dynasty Diameter: 8.5cm Sotheby’s Hong Kong, ‘Important Chinese Art’, October 13, 2021 (Estimate: HK$18,000,000 – 22,000,000)
In time to place a bid to build your Collection
CA Book Publishing・The Art Publication Specialist that Cares for you and the art culture www.cabookpublishing.hk
oct21CAPublishing2.indd 1
17/09/2021 14:40 16/9/21 下午3:57
Art & Museum Insurance Specialists For over 50 years Blackwall Green has arranged insurance for treasured collections, major exhibitions and leading galleries throughout the world.
Contact: Robert Hepburne-Scott, Executive Director, Blackwall Green T: +44 (0)20 7234 4307 E: Robert_Hepburne-Scott@blackwallgreen.eu www.blackwallgreen.com Blackwall Green Europe is a trading name of Nordic Försäkring & Riskhantering AB which is authorised by the Swedish Financial Supervisory Authority and also subject to limited regulation in the United Kingdom by the Financial Conduct Authority. Details about the extent of our regulation by the Financial Conduct Authority are available from us on request. Incorporated in Sweden under company number 556418-5014 with registered address at Mölndalsvägen 22, 412 63 Göteborg, Sweden. UK branch registered in England and Wales under branch number BR021003, with registered address at The Walbrook Building, 25 Walbrook, London EC4N 8AW
The winner of The Burlington Magazine Contemporary Art Writing Prize 2021 has been announced. This year's Prize was judged by the art historian and curator Lowery Stokes Sims and the artist Elizabeth Price.
WRITING PRIZE 2021
The Prize was awarded to Padraig Regan, who chose to write about Ambera Wellmann’s solo exhibition UnTurning at MAC, Belfast. The judges were particularly impressed by Padraig’s ability to combine art-historical analysis with evocative language. In particular they remarked on their ‘ability to position the act of painting as a physical experience’. You can read their winning entry on Burlington Contemporary. contemporary.burlington.org.uk/reviews/reviews/ ambera-wellmann-unturning
WINNER ANNOUNCED xii
oct21page12.indd 1
the burlington magazine | 163 | october 2021
17/09/2021 14:58
Attributed to Antonio Rodríguez, Portrait of Moctezuma, c. 1680. Florence, Gallerie degli Uffizi. Tesoro dei Granduchi
Exhibitions Fall/Winter 2021-22
september 21, 2021—january 23, 2022
Murillo’s The Prodigal son and the art of narrative in Andalusian Baroque painting september 28, 2021—january 23, 2022
Leonardo and the copy of Mona Lisa. New approaches to the artist’s studio practices october 5, 2021—february 13, 2022
Return Journey Art of the Americas in Spain
Information and advanced booking +34 902 10 70 77 www.museodelprado.es
oct21prado.indd 1
17/09/2021 14:43
Haskell 2021.qxp_Haskell 1/4 13/09/2021 09:36 Page 1
THE JOURNAL OF FINE ART, DESIGN, ARCHITECTURE, PHOTOGRAPHY, SCULPTURE, HERITAGE, DECORATIVE ARTS AND CRAFTS
Francis Haskell Memorial Fund The Burlington Magazine Foundation
AUTUMN (SEP TEMBER - NOVEMBER 2021)
€10 (STG£9)
Scholarships The grants of up to £2000 annually awarded from the Francis Haskell Memorial Fund to enable scholars to spend time in libraries or archives carrying out advanced research in the history of western art, will not be made this year. The additional award given by the Trustees of The Burlington Magazine Foundation in conjunction with the Francis Haskell Trustees, will also be deferred.
Jack Butler
YEATS 150 Year Celebration
SUBSCRIBE TO THE IRISH ARTS REVIEW FROM ONLY £50 AND RECEIVE:
It is hoped to welcome applications in April 2022 and to advertise to that effect both in The Burlington Magazine and on the Francis Haskell Memorial Fund website.
Four editions of the Irish Arts Review plus FREE access to the Online Price Guide to Irish Art Sales! T: +353 1 676 6711 E: subscriptions@irishartsreview.com WWW.IRISHARTSREVIEW.COM
Lapicque Book 2018 Jacket.qxp_Layout 1 07/08/2018 11:15 Page 1
𝜏𝜏𝜏𝜏
TIME { }and
ETERNAL LIFET
his group of work studies the period from Jose Dupon 1864–1935, to Alberic Collin 1886–1962.
ThE ExhIbITIoN CoINCIdEs wITh ThE Dupon’s work was of a less decorative style, which was oPENING oF CRomwELL PLACE IN ThEin contradiction to other work of this period, particularly AuTumN-wINTER oF 2020/2021 French, but which was typically Belgian, somewhat
understated and “smoothed” off. This style relied on the power and volume of the subject to take over from the decoration of detailed representation. He was at the
GALLERIEs 1 ANd 11
start of the 50 year period that sculpture developed into
1-5 CRomwELL PLACE, souTh KENsINGToN, LoNdoN sw7 2JEModern Art.
Bugatti’s style was well developed when he was drawn to Antwerp, where from 1907 until his death in 1916 the changes in his Ouevre can be seen.
association with Dupon. Collin continued to work, apart from the First World War, until the Second World War in 1940, after which his artistic output finished.
Wildlife Sculpture from the ANT WERP ZOO MOVEMENT, 1890 – 1940
1890 – 1940
Collin met Bugatti on his arrival and they shared their
Wildlife Sculpture from the ANT WERP ZOO MOVEMENT,
A Master of Colour
TIME {𝜏𝜏𝜏𝜏 } and ETERNAL LIFE
Lapicque: A Master of Colour
Design and print services for fine art catalogues and books
A volume of work always draws comparisons when the best of Ouevres are assembled. The comparisons take on
One short sleep past, we wake eternally And death shall be no more; Death, thou shalt die.
ART CUÉLLAR-NATHAN
MARJON COLLECTION
With
SLADMORE EDITIONS
a further depth of appreciation.
ART CUÉLLAR-NATHAN, ZURICH www.artcuellarnathan.com
MARJON COLLECTIONAlberto Burri S L A D M O R E E D I T I O N S (1915–1995)
Bianco Cretto, 1969 Acrovinilico su compensato 71.5 x 102 cm
John Donne (1572–1631) Wilkes Collection of French 19th Century Sculpture Cover B.qxp_Layout 1 29/07/2019 16:16 Page 1
John Latham (1921–2006)
Courtesy: Fondazione Palazzo Albizzini Collezione Burri. © Fondazione Palazzo Albizzini Collezione Burri, Città di Castello – by Siae 2020
An exhibition promoted by:
Bachelor Experience Negative, 1962 Books, wire mesh, machine fragments, plaster on canvas on hardboard 190 x 92 x 23 cm
Competitive Prices
In collaboration with:
Robilant+Voena
BOWMAN SCULPTURE
Courtesy: Lisson Gallery
FONDAZIONE PALAZZO ALBIZZINI COLLEZIONE BURRI
RUPERT
Reliable Service
WACE ANCIENT
ART THE HORSE
A SCULPTURAL ICON
Later Chinese Bronzes Littleton & Hennessy Asian Art
OLIVER FORGE & BRENDAN LYNCH
forgelynch.com
the burlington magazine | 163 | october 2021 Forge & Lynch 2020 No.3 FINAL COVER.indd 1
oct21page14.indd 1
2020
xiv
Littleton & Hennessy Asian Art
+44 (0)20-7388 1228
French Sculpture
1
Please contact Christ Hall or Mark Scott for further information or for a free quotation. hall@burlington.org.uk scott@burlington.org.uk
The Wilkes Collection of Nineteenth-Century
COURT ART FROM INDIA, PERSIA AND TURKEY
Later Chinese Bronzes
If you are planning a printed or digital catalogue or have any other publishing project in mind, we welcome the opportunity to discuss how we might work together.
The Wilkes Collection of Nineteenth-Century French Sculpture
High Quality Design and Printing
13/10/2020 13:04
17/09/2021 15:41
SI N CE 1707
Thomas Patch (Exeter 1725–1782 Florence), The River Arno looking towards the Ponte Santa Trinità, Florence oil on canvas, 95.2 x 129.5 cm, €100,000 – 150,000
Francesco Guardi, San Giorgio Maggiore, oil on panel, 21 x 33 cm, auction 10 November 2021
OLD MASTER PAINTINGS 19TH CENTURY PAINTINGS WORKS OF ART Auction Week 4 – 11 November 2021
Palais Dorotheum Vienna tel. +43 1 515 60-570 www.dorotheum.com
Dusseldorf | Munich | Rome | Milan | London | Paris | Brussels | Prague | Geneva
oct21dorotheum.indd 1
17/09/2021 14:45
oct21page16.qxp_Internet and Contacts 17/09/2021 14:53 Page 1
C O N T @ C T S
Download FREE digital content related to published articles:
T R I N I T Y F I N E A RT 15 old bond street london w 1s 4 a x www.trinityfineart.com
info @trinityfineart.com +44 (0)20 7493 4916
Daniel Katz Gallery f r o m a n t i q u i t y t o t h e 2o t h c e n t u ry
• 1669 Inventory of Dirck van der Lisse • P.-J. Mariette’s annotations to 1767 Jullienne sale
w w w. m a s t e rd raw in g s. or g/ c o n t e n t / d i g i t a l - re s o u r c e s
www.katz.art
N E W R A R I T E T G A L L E RY O L D M A S T E R PA I N T I N G S
From Renaissance to the 20th Century www.newraritetgallery.com
day & faber old master drawings (0)7891 765877
m
uk
www.dayfaber.com
m
50% OFF for curators 11 Duke Street | St James’ | London SW1Y 6BN Tel. +44 207 930 1144 | Fax. +44 m 207 976 1596 www.rafaelvalls.co.uk | info@rafaelvalls.co.uk
XVI
THE BURLINGTON MAGAZINE | 163 | OCTOBER 2021
shop.burlington.org.uk/promotion/curators
The Regent’s Park & online at frieze.com/viewingroom Buy tickets now
Explore thousands of years of art history from around the world
FRIEZE MASTERS 13–17 OCTOBER 2021
Global media partner
oct21friezemasters.indd 1
Global lead partner Deutsche Bank
17/09/2021 14:46
New Titles The Drawings of Peter Paul Rubens
A Critical Catalogue, Volume One (1590–1608) By Anne-Marie Logan & Kristin Lohse Belkin 2 vols, 536 p., 250+ col. ills, ISBN 978-2-503-59570-2 Book series: Pictura Nova, vol. 22
This is Volume I of the three-volume catalogue raisonné of all drawings considered by the authors to be by Rubens. It is the first publication that presents the artist’s entire drawn oeuvre in chronological order, previous such publications containing only selections of drawings. By leafing through the illustrations, this arrangement provides the user with a quick visual impression of the variety of techniques, media, subject and functions of Rubens’s drawings at an one time.
Scottish Portraiture 1644-1714
David and John Scougall and Their Contemporaries By Carla van de Puttelaar 2 vols., 754 p., 1265 col. ills, ISBN 978-2-503-59727-0 New Book Series: Irreplaceable Portraits, vol. 1
This book is the first comprehensive publication on Scottish portraiture from the period 1644 to 1714, with an emphasis on the painters David Scougall (1625-1685), and his son John Scougall (1657-1737). Countless paintings have been photographed anew or for the first time, and have been compared in detail, which had hardly been done before, while information is also included on technical aspects and (original) frames.
Many Antwerp Hands
Collaborations in Netherlandish Art Edited by Abigail D. Newman and Lieneke Nijkamp 242 p., 80 col. ills, ISBN 978-1-912554-73-7
A fresh look at the phenomenon of artistic collaboration in the early modern Low Countries. The essays in this book draw upon economic and social history, current interests in immigration and mobility, print studies, and technical analysis, embracing a range of literary and archival sources along the way. Interdisciplinary in their perspectives and methodologically diverse, these essays present both theoretical reflections on artistic collaboration and in-depth studies of particular artistpartnerships and collaboratively made objects.
www.brepols.net - info@brepols.net UK Orders: MARSTON Book Services
direct.orders@marston.co.uk - www.marston.co.uk
sept21brepols.indd 1
Orders North-America: ISD
orders@isdistribution.com - www.isdistribution.com
17/08/2021 11:33
THOMAS GAINSBOROUGH, R.A.
ANDREW CLAYTON-PAYNE
oct21clayton-payne.indd 1
17/09/2021 14:11
Copley and West in England 1775–1815
by Allen Staley This beautifully and thoroughly illustrated book, which constitutes the first serious investigation of the relationship between Benjamin West and John Singleton Copley, will be of considerable interest to both British and American art historians, and appeal to lovers of the
INTRODUCTORY OFFER:
£24.50 + P&P (RRP £35)
30% SAVING
art of both countries. West and Copley have always and properly been viewed as the two pre-eminent eighteenth-century American artists, despite the fact that, at the age of twenty-one, West left his native shores in 1760, never to return. He went on to become immensely successful in England, becoming, among other things, the second president of the Royal Academy of Arts. Copley spent half his working life also in England. For a time, the two expatriate Americans had a close working relationship, that we can see substantially reflected in both the formal language and the subject matter of many of their best works, but it eventually and inevitably turned into rivalry. The book begins with a brief prologue discussing the earliest of West’s depictions of recent historical events and of subjects set in America, painted prior to Copley’s arrival in England. It then follows the year-by-year evolution of Copley’s painting from 1775 to his death in 1815, with an underlying focus upon his ongoing give-andtake with West, and it ends with examination of hitherto little-known and unstudied major late paintings, from after 1800, by both artists. To purchase or for more details please visit:
shop.burlington.org.uk/product/COPLEY/
july21copleyandwest.indd 1
16/06/2021 12:45
Leaf through pages or scroll online, whatever your way, find a subscription to suit you
30% off for new readers Visit our website for more information
shop.burlington.org.uk
Terms and Conditions apply. This offer is applicable for new subscribers and for the first year only. For more information on our full pricing list and range of subscription packages available, please visit: shop.burlington.org.uk/subscriptions
oct21subscriptions.indd 1
17/09/2021 14:07
NORTH ITALIAN, c. 1520–40 Apollo Belvedere After the Antique
Bronze 26 cm (10¼ in.) high PROVENANCE
David Lascelles (b. 1950), 8th Earl of Harewood, United Kingdom, until 2013
info@tomasso.art tomasso.art
sept21tomasso.indd 1
17/09/2021 14:13