Additive Manufacturing (3-D Printers)
ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING (3-D PRINTERS)
10/5/2015
FDM or PolyJet 3-D Printer? Comparing Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) or PolyJet 3-D Printers is right for Red
Tim McDougald CAD Engineer tmcdougald@redvalve.com
Valve/Tideflex速 to reduce the overhead cost and improve productivity.
Additive Manufacturing (3-D Printers)
Table of Contents
I.
Definitions and Terminology
1
II.
Purpose of Proposal
3
III.
Industry Background Information Related to 3-D Printing
4
IV.
Solutions and Cost Scenarios
5
1. Stratasy’s Objet, Fortus, and Dimension series
5-7
2. 3D Systems’ ProJet x60 and ProJet HD 3000/3000 Plus
7-8
V.
Conclusion and Wrap-up
9
VI.
Sources
10
VII.
Quotes
11
Tim McDougald | Page 1
Additive Manufacturing (3-D Printers)
Additive Manufacturing (3-D Printers) FDM OR POLYJET 3-D PRINTER?
I.
DEFINITIONS AND TERMINOLOGY 3-D printing is a process for making a physical object from a threedimensional (3-D) digital model, typically by laying down many successive thin layers of a material called slicing. Additive
manufacturing
Rapid
prototyping)
official
industry
is
(or the
standard
term (ASTM F2792) for all applications
of
the
technology. It is defined as the
process
of
joining
materials to make an object from 3-D data (CAD, STL, etc.), usually layer upon layer, as opposed to subtractive manufacturing methods. Compression molding is a method of molding in which the material, generally preheated, is first placed in an open, heated mold cavity to form the part. CNC (Computer Numerical Control) is a computer program that converts numerical coordinates of a graph and controls the movements of the cutter shaping the metal material. FDM
technology
(Fused
Deposition
Modeling)
is
an
additive
manufacturing technology commonly used for modeling, prototyping, and production applications. It is one of the techniques used for 3-D printing. Nylon 12 is a polymer made from aminolauric acid or laurolactam monomers that each has 12 carbons, hence the name ‘Nylon 12’. It is one of several nylon polymers. Photopolymer is a polymer that changes its properties when exposed to light, often in the ultraviolet or visible region of the electromagnetic
Additive Manufacturing (3-D Printers)
spectrum. These changes are often manifested structurally, for example hardening of the material occurs as a result of cross-linking when exposed to UV light. Polycarbonate is a synthetic resin in which the polymer units are linked through carbonate groups, including many molding materials and films. Polymer is a large molecule that is made up of repeating subunits connected to each other by chemical bonds.
Polymer, are basically,
anything that has a plastic or rubber material. * Non-polymers include: elements, metals, ionic compounds, and some organic matter. Prototype is a first, typical or preliminary model of something, especially a machine, from which other forms are developed or copied. Reverse engineering is the reproduction of another manufacturer’s product
following
detailed
examination
of
its
construction
of
composition. Subtractive manufacturing is achieved by using a block of material usually metal, and then removing the excess through CNC milling or turning technology. Tango family offers a variety of elastomer characteristics including Shore scale A hardness, elongation at break, tear resistance, and tensile strength.
Rubber-like material is useful for many applications including:
Exhibition and communication models
Rubber surround and over-molding
Soft-touch coatings/nonslip surfaces
Knobs, grips, pulls, handles, gaskets, seals, hoses, and footwear.
Rubber-like materials include:
Rubber-like gray (TangoGray FLX950)
Rubber-like black (TangoBlack FLX973)
Rubber-like translucent (TangoPlus FLX930)
Tim McDougald | Page 3
Additive Manufacturing (3-D Printers)
Rubber-like advanced black (TangoBlackPlus FLX980)
Ultem 9085 is a FDM thermoplastic ideal for aerospace, automotive, and military applications because of its FST rating, high strength-to-weight ratio, and existing certifications. It empowers design and manufacturing engineers to 3-D print advanced functional prototype and production parts. II.
PURPOSE OF PROPOSAL Does Red Valve/Tideflex® have a competitive edge against our competitors? For decades, our company has been one of the leading producers of handfabricated parts for valves, gadgets, gussets, and compression molds. However, it may be time for us to explore the possibilities of reducing the high volume of waste in order to save the company from financial stress, so the company has more potential profits from our inventory. Moreover, this positive momentum to become a sustainable company would allow Red Valve/Tideflex® to establish an Additive Manufacturing Division to our repertoire. Being able to utilize this division would allow the Engineering Department to verify each part’s precision before it is produced and developed by an extremely exorbitant metal fabricator. The value of adding an additive manufacturing (AM) system
to
our
engineering
department would pay dividends well after it was completely paid off in four to five years. For instance, if one 3-D printer
was
purchased
today
at
$250,000, it would be paid off in as little as eight (8) business quarters (two (2) calendar years). Also, AM will allow
us
materials
to
add
before
presentational our
clients
purchased our products. Red Valve/Tideflex® could be on the breakthrough of achieving an enormous amount of productivity while decreasing its overhead and labor costs. This new proposal will allow Red Valve/Tideflex® to prototyping designs with AM methods.
This
proposal
covers
the
definitions,
industry
background
Additive Manufacturing (3-D Printers)
information, gives valuable solutions, and concludes with information on how AM is a reliable source for managing time and budgets in the industry. III.
INDUSTRY BACKGROUND INFORMATION RELATED TO 3-D PRINTING This year Red Valve/Tideflex® has recently purchased an automatic cutting machine called Autometrix Radium® to help control rubber waste, and shield overhead costs. This cutting program will be a definite improvement and mark a cornerstone for the company in the future. However, it should not be the only scenario to achieve lower cost-saving benefits when dealing with compression molds. Therefore, one of the best practices is to do ‘test runs’ with lower-priced materials such as polymers, photopolymers, and other plastics when making 3D model of our products. These ‘test runs’ will save engineers, technicians, and designers lots of time when trying to see if the product will fit in the valve by having experiments with inexpensive materials like polymers and plastics. Creating an opportunity to add an AM system to the daily operations will establish a strong method where we can examine a prototype’s design before purchasing costly materials.
This would prove to be a solid investment for our
company. Any manufacturing process could be improved with AM to improve efficiency capacity and unit cost of materials and labor. For instance, companies like Joe Gibbs Racing in Huntersville, NC utilize 3-D printing to build gadgets for their race cars at impressive speeds to keep up in the racing industry. Also, they have used several CNC machines to develop engine parts for their racing vehicles. Other companies such as Danko Arlington, Inc. in Baltimore, MD and Champion Motorsport in Pompano, FL utilize FDM manufacturing in their businesses. Danko Arlington (Danko) has found a niche for the using AM for their pattern tooling operation. Using the FDM process, their products have been successful with rapid prototyping. Danko has earned recognition for its design with aerospace casting which required 100% radiographic inspection on its military parts. smooth
interior
Similarly, Champion Motorsport (CM) wanted to achieve a and
exterior
surface
finish
on
its
tubular
composite
Tim McDougald | Page 5
Additive Manufacturing (3-D Printers)
components. They used the Fortus 3-D Production System to make conceptual and functional model prototypes that were soluble cores for their high performance turbo inlet ducts. Now, its ducts are made in a single piece by laying up carbon fibers on the FDM printed soluble core. IV.
SOLUTIONS AND COST SCENARIOS This proposal includes price quotes from two very reputable 3-D printing companies:
Stratasys and 3-D Systems.
Stratasys has an established
reputation in the 3-D community by building
its
AM
systems
to
help
engineering deparments make realistic prototype designs. Also, 3-D Systems has transformed its classic printing company to become a 3-D printing industry giant. quite
unique
Both, however, have products
that
would
enable Red Valve/Tideflex速 to choose which system is more valuable and well-balance to meet our needs.
Stratasys: Objet, Fortus, and Dimension Series Stratasys has three potential choices in their additive manufacturer line: Objet, Fortus, and Dimension series. All three are capable of serving our company but come with different speeds, abilities, and costs. Objet Series (24, 30 Pro, and 30 Prime) This series builds prototypes in a photopolymer material and cures it with a UV (ultraviolent) light. The size of the build chamber or build plate where the model is prepared varies among series types. All of these Objet series use a process called PolyJet 3-D printing and is much like an inkjet printer.
The
material is jetted out onto layers of a curable liquid photopolymer where the build preparation software has calculated each placement of photopolymer and support constituents used.
Basically, this process accumulates fine layers to
Additive Manufacturing (3-D Printers)
make a 3-D part and any support material can be removed by hand or with water-based solutions. A prototype can be used immediately without any chemicals or powder added at the end. F o r F o Fortus (250mc, 350mc, and 450mc) The Fortus machines use FDM plastic and have the capabilities of using multiple materials if you choose the 350mc and 450mc models. The build plates on these models are rather larger than the Objet series. They are more expensive with price tags above $150,000. The 350mc and 450mc additive machines have the ability to run real ABS, Nylon 12, Ultem 9085, and polycarbonate.
All of these products use FDM technology which enable
production grade builds while having extremely durable characteristics. Fortus 3-D printers use thermoplastics that have advanced mechanical properties such as high heat, caustic chemicals, sterilization, and high-impact applications. These properties make finished products have fine details, and smooth surfaces, accurate strengths. Also, no special venting is required with the Fortus production systems.
Dimension (1200es and Elite) Other FDM technologies, the Dimension 1200es and Elite, are special in their own distinctive ways. The build plates are roughly 10�x10�x12� and only ABS plastics are available with limited colors. These products print from the bottom
Tim McDougald | Page 7
Additive Manufacturing (3-D Printers)
up on deposited layers with supports material. No curing is required with these models; simply wash them with water-based solutions. Also, the models can be drilled, tapped, sanded, and painted to match the designer’s requirements. This model is a good match for modeling compression molds, patterns, and customized tools and fixtures. Overall, the Dimension 1200es includes many beneficial aspects of what Red Valve/Tideflex® would be looking to accomplish with an AM system.
3D Systems: ProJet x60 and ProJet HD 3000/3000 Plus 3D Systems of Rock Hill, SC, has several powdered and plastic filament 3D printers which can generate models of about 12” by 7.7” with the height of 8”. All of these printers have a different build volume.
The powdered 3D printers
utilize monochrome or color printer and start from the top of the machine working its way to the bottom. The printing machine fills the microscopic holes or gaps in the model, seals the surface, enhance the color saturations, and thus, improve mechanical properties of the part.
Essentially, this process
solidifies the materials use to create the component model leaving the rest of the powder for to be recycle for the next part to be printed. 3D Systems has different approaches to achieving AM. The first 3-D Printer model is called the ProJet x60 (160, 260C, 360, 460 Plus, 660 Pro, and 860 Pro) utilizes a powder-print format.
The second models
are called ProJet HD 3000 and HD 3000 Plus, which use an ABS filament plastic for its tasks.
ProJet x60 Series
Additive Manufacturing (3-D Printers)
The ProJet x60 series has the ability to use either mono or color depending on the model. They can be print 3-D models which provide extremely good tensile and flexible strengths for the finish prototypes. However, they do have one setback being the parts are formed using a powder substance that has to be air-brush, cleaned, and soaked in cleaning solution after printing is complete. Moreover, the ProJet x60 requires a toxic solution, not water-based, to help remove any debris or powder particles. This process is very timeconsuming and the chemicals used are not safe for everyday use.
P
P r ProJet HD 3000/3000 Plus ProJet HD 3000 and HD 3000 Plus are professional 3-D printers with highdefinition and high-volume. These do not use a powder for their builds, but rather an ABS material plastic. These parts still need to get cleaned with a toxic chemical solution once they are printed.
Basically, this AM system needs to
remove the bulk wax by soaking the prototype in a wax bath. In 2010, the machine cost about $16,000 per unit.
Tim McDougald | Page 9
Additive Manufacturing (3-D Printers)
V.
CONCLUSION AND WRAP-UP Engineers, designers, and shop builders at Red Valve/Tideflex® could be able to manage their waste content, add productivity to the workload, and produce scaled graphical prototypes with either of these AM systems in this article. Many questions remain to be unanswered still about 3-D printing, but this report should clarify several topics. One problem is which product is the right choice for our capacity? Do we want a powdered or ABS 3-D modeling systems? Several enquiries such as these are all very reasonable to ask if we want to manage our materials better to become more financially stable and improve our profit margins. All of these models in this article have different abilities, characteristics, and processes that they use to create a 3-D prototype. Some use ABS filaments, while other types of 3-D printer may use a recycled powder component. Other types of filaments such as Nylon 12, ABS, HDPE, polycarbonate, and Tango (rubber-like properties) can be utilized to make a design. Stratasy’s supports a blending formula for filaments to create unique color, but only their Connex 2 and Connex 3 models which range from $120,000 to $250,000.
Thus, the
Connex models have be excluded from this report. Whether we choose Stratasy or 3D Systems to select from, however, we will begin a thorough transformation of improving our company’s reputation and output performance to our customers. Our clients will be able to see if the parts fit before detailed and costly metal fabrications begin. This is literally what we are after with pursuing our requirement for a quality 3-D printer. Simply having an AM system produce flexible and extremely robust sample parts would make Red Valve/Tideflex® a choice that perspective clients will trust for years to come.
VI.
SOURCES
Additive Manufacturing (3-D Printers)
Mishek, Dan. “How and When to Choose Between Additive and Subtractive Prototyping?” Moldmaking Technology.
2009. 1-2. Internet. 24 Aug
2015 http://www.3dsystems.com/3d-printers/professional/overview http://www.stratasys.com/3d-printers/design-series “D3VU 2015: Digitial Manufacturing and Prototyping.” D3 Technologies. Webinar. 01 September 2015. VII.
QUOTES
See next pages for three (3) price quotes for Stratasys’ Objet 24, Objet 30 Pro, and Objet 30 Prime from Prototyping Solutions.
Tim McDougald | Page 11