CANSO Global ATM Safety Conference Transforming ATM Performance 25 - 30 January 2015 Bangkok, Thailand
Organised by
Hosted by
CANSO Global l bATM l ATM Safety f Conference f CANSO Global Safety y Conference Bangkok, Thailand || 25-30 January 2015 Loch h Lomond, d Scotland, l d 4 - 8 November b 2013
Organised by CANSO CANSO – the Civil Air Navigation Services Organisation – is the global voice of air navigation service providers (ANSPs) worldwide. CANSO Members support over 85% of world air traffic. Members share information and develop new policies, with the ultimate aim of improving air navigation services (ANS) on the ground and in the air. CANSO represents its Members’ views in major regulatory and industry forums, including at ICAO, where it has official Observer status. CANSO has an extensive network of Associate Members drawn from across the aviation industry. Full membership is open to all ANSPs regardless of their legal status. This includes ANSPs that are integrated within government structures and departments. Members that are not separated from their governments are able to sign an article of membership which explicitly recognises that CANSO does not represent the national government of the ANSP’s home state in any way. The Associate Membership of CANSO is drawn from a wide range of companies involved with the delivery of air traffic services. Membership offers them the chance to network both formally and informally with clients, and key decision-makers across the aviation industry. Associate Members are also encouraged to lend their expertise to our work programmes and help us to continue to improve the delivery of ANS.
Hosted by AEROTHAI Aeronautical Radio of Thailand Limited (AEROTHAI) is a state enterprise under the Ministry of Transport and Communications. It was founded in 1948 by airlines with the consent of the Royal Thai Government to provide air traffic control and aeronautical communication services for airline operations. Later in 1963, the Government acquired the majority of the Company’s share capital from the founding airlines thereby altering the Company’s status to that of a State Enterprise.
Event Contact Information Conference Contact:
Mark DeNicuolo Safety Programme Manager CANSO Phone: +1 (609) 457 0872 Email: mark.denicuolo@canso.org
Conference Venue:
W Hotel Bangkok 106 North Sathorn Road Silom, Bangrak, Bangkok 10500 Thailand Tel: +66 (0) 2 344 4000 www.whotelbangkok.com
Dear CANSO SSC Members and Associates, On behalf of CANSO and our generous host AEROTHAI, welcome to Bangkok for the January 2015 CANSO Global ATM Safety Conference. We, the safety champions representing air navigation service provision, must continually strive to improve the way we do business, that is, identifying and effectively mitigating risk in order to meet and exceed the demands and expectations of the aviation industry and our flying public. As always, the CANSO Global ATM Safety Conference aims to provide our Members with the safety strategy, tools and ideas to accomplish this task. At this year’s conference, we will focus on the safety-related initiatives of CANSO’s Vision 2020 and our progress to date in accomplishing those goals. Additionally, we will look deeper into the four key safety strategy themes that were agreed upon at last year’s conference: A tailored and proportionate SMS structure People create safety Safety intelligence A challenging and learning environment You will see in this agenda that many of the sessions are linked to one of these four themes to inform our discussion. What are the key objectives of the conference? First, as stated above, we need to remind ourselves of the CANSO Vision 2020 key safety priorities and review our progress towards those goals. Second, we will review the SSC work plans in support of Vision 2020. You will see that there has been an enormous amount of work done this year by our workgroups, as evidenced by the number of excellent discussion papers that have been developed for this year’s conference. We strongly encourage you to read these papers, which were provided to you ahead of the conference, so that you will be prepared to actively participate in the discussions we have planned on these important topics. Third, we will identify challenges and opportunities related to attaining our Vision 2020 goals. The desired outcome of many of the agenda items is to agree upon and modify our existing CANSO safety work plans, as well as to identify new initiatives necessary to improve our ability to manage safety (both now and in the future) and to ensure our success by effectively measuring our performance locally, regionally and globally. Fourth, we need to ensure that our CANSO safety message is strong, consistent and representative of our Member’s positions. Therefore, we will discuss and agree upon the key reports and messages for the CANSO CEO and AGM meetings, as well as ICAO conferences. Finally, we would like to give particular thanks to our colleagues from AEROTHAI and the FAA who have provided outstanding support in the co-ordination and organisation of this event in addition to their usual responsibilities. As you can see, we have a busy and challenging week planned, but we have also tried to allow sufficient time for you to network with your colleagues. We encourage you to take full advantage of the unique opportunities afforded you by this conference, and look forward to your active participation in all the sessions throughout the week. Yours sincerely,
Dr. David Harrison Safety Director, UK NATS Chair, Safety Standing Committee, CANSO
Mark DeNicuolo Safety Programme Manager, CANSO
CANSO Global ATM Safety Conference W Hotel, Bangkok, Thailand 25-30 January 2015 SUNDAY, 25 January 2015 12.00 - 17.00 Venue: Strategy Room, 3rd Floor Safety Standing Committee (SSC) Steering Committee Meeting* *Steering Committee members only
18.00 - 20.00 Venue: Great Room Foyer, 3rd Floor Conference Registration 19.00 - 22.00 Venue: Great Room Foyer, 3rd Floor Welcome Reception Hosted by AEROTHAI
MONDAY, 26 January 2015 08.00 - 13.00 Venue: Great Room Foyer, 3rd Floor Conference Registration 09.00 - 09.15 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor Opening Address & Welcome to Thailand
Mr. Anucha Kammong, Executive Vice President, AEROTHAI
09.15 - 09.30 A Message from the CANSO ExCom Safety Champion
Ed Sims, Safety Champion, CANSO ExCom / CEO, Airways New Zealand
09.30 - 09.45 Keynote Address
Jeff Poole, Director General, CANSO
09.45 - 10.15 Conference Objectives & Agenda
David Harrison, Chair, SSC, CANSO Joseph Teixeira, Vice Chair, SSC, CANSO Mark DeNicuolo, Safety Programme Manager, CANSO
10.15 - 10.45 Venue: Great Room Foyer, 3rd Floor Morning Refreshments
1
MONDAY, 26 January 2015 (continued) 10.45 - 12.30 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor Ice Breaker: The Trial & the Need for a Global Safety Strategy
Obtain continuing SSC approval of the Global Safety Strategy; agree to further develop strategy and work plans, with support from the regions; agree on next steps for implementing the Global Safety Strategy
David Harrison, Chair, SSC, CANSO Mark DeNicuolo, Safety Programme Manager, CANSO
Read: Paper 1, Paper 21 12.30 - 13.30 Venue: The Kitchen Table, 2nd Floor Lunch & Networking 13.30 - 13.45 Asia-Pacific Regional Report2
Tailored & Proportionate2
Report on the top regional safety issues/challenges; report on past and current regional activities to address issues/challenges; discuss how to determine if activities are having a positive impact on safety; discuss future regional strategies to address safety issues/challenges
Hai Eng Chang, Director, Asia-Pacific Affairs, CANSO
13.45 - 14.45 Safety Culture Network
People Create Safety
Report on the status of the Safety Culture Network; propose decisions for the SSC
Job Brüggen, Safety Manager, LVNL
14.45 - 15.15 Afternoon Refreshments 15.15 - 16.45 Top 5 Safety Priorities
Safety Intelligence
Best practices for identifying and addressing top issues and risks Session Facilitator: David Harrison, Chair, SSC, CANSO Presenters: Tony Licu, Head of Safety Unit, Directorate Network Management, EUROCONTROL Claire Marrison, Manager, Strategy Systems & Analysis, Airservices Australia Joseph Teixeira, Vice President, Safety and Technical Training, FAA ATO
Read: Paper 3
1 2
See Read-ahead Papers, page 10 Associated CANSO Global Safety Strategy theme 2
CANSO Global ATM Safety Conference Bangkok, Thailand || 25-30 January 2015
MONDAY, 26 January 2015 (continued) 16.45 - 17.00 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor Day 1 Wrap-up
David Harrison, Chair, SSC, CANSO Mark DeNicuolo, Safety Programme Manager, CANSO
17.15 - 17.30 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor Tuesday Speakers Meeting
TUESDAY, 27 January 2015 09.00 - 10.30 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor Safety Performance Measurement Workgroup Report & Data Analysis Discussion (SSC Full Members only)
Safety Intelligence
Present progress on the Safety Performance Measurement work plan; discuss the 2013 Safety Benchmarking Report and associated metrics analysis; compare data from two ANSPs and discuss challenges to meaningful analysis; discuss the Roadmap to Vision 2020
Heather Henderson, Lead, Safety Performance Measurement Workgroup, CANSO Job Brüggen, Safety Manager, LVNL Sam Espig, Head of Safety Strategy Development, UK NATS Tony Licu, Head of Safety Unit, Directorate Network Management, EUROCONTROL
Read: Paper 4, Paper 2, Paper 3 10.30 - 11.00 Venue: Great Room Foyer, 3rd Floor Morning Refreshments 11.00 - 12.30 Safety Performance Measurement Workgroup Report & Safety Intelligence Data Analysis Discussion (SSC Full Members only) – continued
Heather Henderson, Lead, Safety Performance Measurement Workgroup, CANSO Tony Licu, Head of Safety Unit, Directorate Network Management, EUROCONTROL
Read: Paper 4, Paper 2, Paper 3 12.30 - 13.30 Venue: The Kitchen Table, 2nd Floor Lunch & Networking 13.30 - 13.45 Middle East Regional Report
Tailored & Proportionate
Report on the top regional safety issues/challenges; report on past and current regional activities to address issues/challenges; discuss how to determine if activities are having a positive impact on safety; discuss future regional strategies to address safety issues/challenges
Khaled Arabiyat, Chief QSMS ATM, CARC
3
TUESDAY, 27 January 2015 (continued) 13.45 - 14.15 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor ATO Risk Analysis Processes (RAPs)
Safety Intelligence
Present an overview of enhancements made to the ATO Airborne and Surface RAPs; introduce the Service Integrity RAP; discuss how to get the most out of your data
Pradip Som, Risk Assessment Manager, FAA ATO
14.15 - 15.15 Risk Analysis Tool/Process (RAT/RAP) Implementation & Use
Safety Intelligence
Demonstrate real-life RAT/RAP usage examples from several ANSPs; discuss risk analysis statistics and targets
Roger Dillon, Head of External Safety, UK NATS Hervé Forestier, Head of Safety Performance Division, DSNA Gwyneth Howell, ATM Investigation & Standards Specialist, ATNS Osman Saafan, Director, Safety and Security Management and Military Affairs, DFS
15.15 - 15.45 Afternoon Refreshments 15.45 - 17.15 Transforming Risk Measurement Discussion Panel
Challenging & Learning
Discuss advances in digital data and risk assessment; agree to next steps for how to evolve risk measurement Panel Facilitator: Mark DeNicuolo, Safety Programme Manager, CANSO Panel: David Harrison, Safety Director, UK NATS Gwyneth Howell, Investigation & Standards Specialist, Safety & Regulation Oversight, ATM, ATNS Tony Licu, Head of Safety Unit, Directorate Network Management, EUROCONTROL Joseph Teixeira, Vice President, Safety and Technical Training, FAA ATO
Read: Paper 5, Paper 2 17.15 - 17.30 Day 2 Wrap-up
David Harrison, Chair, SSC, CANSO Mark DeNicuolo, Safety Programme Manager, CANSO
17.45 - 18.00 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor Wednesday Speakers Meeting
4
CANSO Global ATM Safety Conference Bangkok, Thailand || 25-30 January 2015
WEDNESDAY, 28 January 2015 09.00 - 09.15 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor Future SMS Development Introduction
Tailored & Proportionate
Discuss key components the aviation industry should consider as enhancements to the SMS
Roger Dillon, Co-lead, Future SMS Development Workgroup, CANSO Claire Marrison, Co-lead, Future SMS Development Workgroup, CANSO
Read: Paper 6 09.15 - 10.15 Common Safety Methodology Codes of Practice
Tailored & Proportionate
Determine the level of desire for developing Codes of Practice; discuss the practicality of industry involvement; discuss the status and development of CANSO Codes of Practice; decide if CANSO Codes of Practice standards will be formalised
Roger Dillon, Co-lead, Future SMS Development Workgroup, CANSO Claire Marrison, Co-lead, Future SMS Development Workgroup, CANSO Sam Espig, Head of Safety Strategy Development, UK NATS
Read: Paper 7 10.15 - 10.30 Latin America & Caribbean Regional Report Tailored & Proportionate
Report on the top regional safety issues/challenges; report on past and current regional activities to address issues/challenges; discuss how to determine if activities are having a positive impact on safety; discuss future regional strategies to address safety issues/challenges
Mark DeNicuolo, Safety Programme Manager, CANSO
10.30 - 11.00 Venue: Great Room Foyer, 3rd Floor Morning Refreshments 11.00 - 12.30 Barrier-based Risk
Tailored & Proportionate
Present an overview of the barrier-based risk discussion paper; discuss SSC views regarding the development of a CANSO barrier-based risk policy
Roger Dillon, Co-lead, Future SMS Development Workgroup, CANSO Claire Marrison, Co-lead, Future SMS Development Workgroup, CANSO Sam Espig, Head of Safety Strategy Development, UK NATS Glen Smith, Senior Consultant, Helios
Read: Paper 8
5
WEDNESDAY, 28 January 2015 (continued) 12.30 - 13.00 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor ICAO FRMS & Annex 19 Updates
Tailored & Proportionate
Report progress on the development of a Fatigue Risk Management System; discuss a proposal for including an attachment on safety culture in Annex 19
Roger Dillon, Co-lead, Future SMS Development Workgroup, CANSO Claire Marrison, Co-lead, Future SMS Development Workgroup, CANSO
13.00 - 14.00 Venue: The Kitchen Table, 2nd Floor Lunch & Networking 14.00 - 15.00 Use of Reference System Arguments
Tailored & Proportionate
Present an overview of reference system arguments; discuss SSC views regarding the development of a CANSO reference systems policy
Roger Dillon, Co-lead, Future SMS Development Workgroup, CANSO Claire Marrison, Co-lead, Future SMS Development Workgroup, CANSO Sam Espig, Head of Safety Strategy Development, UK NATS Jelmer Scholte, Senior Consultant, NLR Glen Smith, Senior Consultant, Helios
Read: Paper 9 15.00 - 15.30 Afternoon Refreshments 15.30 - 16.00 Safety by Design
Tailored & Proportionate
Discuss what benefits can be realised by designing safety into systems; discuss how safety by design can be incorporated into SMSs; determine the next steps for progressing the safety by design approach
Claire Marrison, Co-lead, Future SMS Development Workgroup, CANSO
Read: Paper 10 16.00 - 16.15 Day 3 Wrap-up
David Harrison, Chair, SSC, CANSO Mark DeNicuolo, Safety Programme Manager, CANSO
16.30 - 16.45 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor Thursday Speakers Meeting 17.45 - 21.00 Departure Venue: W Hotel Lobby Awards Dinner Cruise Hosted by AEROTHAI
6
CANSO Global ATM Safety Conference Bangkok, Thailand || 25-30 January 2015
THURSDAY, 29 January 2015 09.00 - 10.00 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor Human Factors Standard of Excellence
Challenging & Learning
Review AP-15 results and conclusions; determine whether CANSO should develop a Human Factors SoE
Tony Licu, Head of Safety Unit, Directorate Network Management, EUROCONTROL
10.00 - 10.30 Human Performance in Safety Investigations
Challenging & Learning
Discuss the role of human performance analysis in investigations; explore the views of industry partners; explore the impact of fatigue on human performance; determine the next steps for progressing the human performance in investigations approach
Mihaly Kurucz, Head of Safety Division, HungaroControl Alfred Vlasek, Safety Manager, Austro Control
Read: Paper 11 10.30 - 10.45 Africa Regional Report
Tailored & Proportionate
Report on the top regional safety issues/challenges; report on past and current regional activities to address issues/challenges; discuss how to determine if activities are having a positive impact on safety; discuss future regional strategies to address safety issues/challenges
Gwyneth Howell, Investigation & Standards Specialist, Safety & Regulation Oversight, ATM, ATNS
10.45 - 11.15 Venue: Great Room Foyer, 3rd Floor Morning Refreshments 11.15 - 12.15 CANSO Authorised Consultants: A Feasibility Study
Tailored & Proportionate
Explore thoughts on CANSO authorisation of SMS consultants; determine options for next steps
Job Brüggen, Safety Manager, LVNL
Read: Paper 12 12.15 - 13.15 Space-based Surveillance
Challenging & Learning
A discussion of the status, challenges and safety considerations associated with satellite navigation technology integration
Mary MacMillan, Vice President, Safety and Operational Services, Inmarsat Aviation & Stephen Angus, Senior Director of Global Policy, Safety and Operational Services John David, Vice President, Safety and Quality, NAV CANADA
7
THURSDAY, 29 January 2015 (continued) 13.15 - 14.15 Venue: The Kitchen Table, 2nd Floor Lunch & Networking 14.15 - 15.45 Practical Implementation of New Safety Concepts
Challenging & Learning
Discuss the challenges associated with realising the benefits of analysing what went right in the operation; discuss the steps associated with making the transitions from Safety I to Safety II
Tony Licu, Head of Safety Unit, Directorate Network Management, EUROCONTROL Roger Dillon, Head of External Safety, UK NATS Claire Marrison, Manager, Strategy Systems & Analysis, Airservices Australia
15.45 - 16.15 Afternoon Refreshments 16.15 - 17.15 Safely Managing New Entrant Integration
Challenging & Learning
Discuss safety priorities and strategies regarding new entrant integration; explore ANSP and industry perspectives on the safety impact of the influx of UAVs
Randy Willis, Manager, Emerging Technologies, FAA ATO
17.15 - 17.30 Day 4 Wrap-up
David Harrison, Chair, SSC, CANSO Mark DeNicuolo, Safety Programme Manager, CANSO
17.45 - 18.00 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor Friday Speakers Meeting
FRIDAY, 30 January 2015 09.00 - 09.30 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor Safety Management: Balloon Operations
Challenging & Learning
Discuss the safety case principals, management and lessons learned for balloons given their increasing presence internationally
Lew Jenkins, Head of Safety/Operations, Airways New Zealand
09.30 - 10.00 ICAO High-level Safety Conference
People Create Safety
Mark DeNicuolo, Safety Programme Manager, CANSO
Read: Paper 13, Paper 14, Paper 15
8
CANSO Global ATM Safety Conference Bangkok, Thailand || 25-30 January 2015
FRIDAY, 30 January 2015 (continued) 10.00 - 11.00 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor SSC & Steering Committee Terms of Reference
Mark DeNicuolo, Safety Programme Manager, CANSO David Harrison, Chair, SSC, CANSO Joseph Teixeira, Vice Chair, SSC CANSO
Read: Paper 16, Paper 17 11.00 - 11.15 Europe Regional Report
Tailored & Proportionate
Report on the top regional safety issues/challenges; report on past and current regional activities to address issues/challenges; discuss how to determine if activities are having a positive impact on safety; discuss future regional strategies to address safety issues/challenges
Roger Dillon, Head of External Safety, UK NATS
11.15 - 11.45 Venue: Great Room Foyer, 3rd Floor Morning Refreshments 11.45 - 12.45 Digital Data Case Studies
Safety Intelligence
Discuss how digital data can be effectively collected and analysed to identify and mitigate risk in operations Case Study 1: Converging Runway Operations Case Study 2: Opposite Direction Operations
Chris Devlin, Portfolio Manager, Aviation Safety and Training, MITRE
Read: Paper 5 12.45 - 13.15 Conference Wrap-up, Decisions & Plans for Action
David Harrison, Chair, SSC, CANSO Joseph Teixeira, Vice Chair, SSC, CANSO Mark DeNicuolo, Safety Programme Manager, CANSO
13.15 - 13.30 November 2015 Global ATM Safety Conference
Mark DeNicuolo, Safety Programme Manager, CANSO
13.30 - 13.45 SSC Chair Remarks
David Harrison, Chair, SSC, CANSO
13.45 - 14.00 Host Closing Remarks
Sarinee Sangprasit, President, AEROTHAI
9
FRIDAY, 30 January 2015 (continued) 14.00 - 15.00 Venue: The Kitchen Table, 2nd Floor Lunch & Networking 15.30 - 17.00 Venue: Great Room, 3rd Floor SSC Steering Committee Meeting* *Steering Committee members only
Read-ahead Papers #
Title
Author(s)
Agenda Session
1
CANSO Global Safety Strategy
Roger Dillon
Ice Breaker: The Trial & the Need for a Global Safety Strategy
2
Moving Safety Performance Measurement Forward: Achieving Vision 2020
Safety Performance Measurement Workgroup
Ice Breaker: The Trial & the Need for a Global Safety Strategy Safety Performance Measurement Workgroup Report-back & Data Analysis Discussion (SSC Members only) Transforming Risk Measurement Discussion Panel
3
Top 5 Operational Safety Priorities and Mitigations & Identification of the Top 5 Five Contributing Factors, Mitigations and Best Practices related to IFR-IFR LOS and RIs Analysis Report
Safety Performance Measurement Workgroup
Top 5 Safety Priorities
4
2013 CANSO Safety Performance Measurement Benchmarking Report (available to contributing SSC members only)
Safety Performance Measurement Workgroup
Safety Performance Measurement Workgroup Report-back & Data Analysis Discussion (SSC Members only)
Transforming Risk Measurement Discussion Panel Digital Data Case Studies: Converging Runway Operations & Opposite Direction Operations
5
Transforming Risk Measurement Joseph Teixeira
6
Future SMS Development Workgroup Overview of 2014 Work Programme & Proposals for 2015
Future SMS Development Introduction
Future SMS Development Workgroup
10
CANSO Global ATM Safety Conference Bangkok, Thailand || 25-30 January 2015
Read-ahead Papers #
Title
Author(s)
Agenda Session
7
The Development of Codes of Future SMS Practice to Support the Common Development Safety Methodology – A Workgroup Proposal
Common Safety Methodology Codes of Practice
8
The Development of a BarrierFuture SMS Based Risk Model to Support the Development Common Safety Methodology Workgroup
Barrier-based Risk
9
Future SMS Use of Reference Systems in the Development Common Safety Methodology Workgroup
Use of Reference System Arguments
Future SMS Development Workgroup
Safety by Design
Human Performance Aspects in Safety Investigations
Future SMS Development Workgroup
Human Performance in Safety Investigations
Feasibility Study on Creating Authorised Consultants for the 12 CANSO Standard of Excellence in Safety Management Systems
Job Brüggen
CANSO Authorised Consultants: A Feasibility Study
10 Safety by Design
11
ICAO HSLC Item 2.1: Requirements and Challenges of 13 Mark DeNicuolo Harmonized Global Safety Performance Indicators
ICAO High-level Safety Conference
ICAO HSLC Item 2.2: Nonpunitive Reporting Processes 14 and Protection of Safety Information
Mark DeNicuolo
ICAO High-level Safety Conference
ICAO HSLC Item 2.4: Proposed GASP Enhancements to Achieve 15 Global Aviation Safety Objectives
Mark DeNicuolo
ICAO High-level Safety Conference
16 CANSO SSC Terms of Reference
Mark DeNicuolo
SSC & Steering Committee Terms of Reference
CANSO SSC Steering Committee Mark DeNicuolo Terms of Reference
SSC & Steering Committee Terms of Reference
17
11
CANSO Global ATM Safety Conference Loch Lomond, Scotland, 4 - 8 November 2013 Notes