Disbioética Vol 2

SUMÁRIO

Prefácio | 9 Agradecimentos | 13 +PVTQFW§£Q TGǤGZµGU FKXGTUCU FQ KP­EKQ FC ECTTGKTC | 15 1. DO ATENDIMENTO MÉDICO EM

TEMPOS DE CÓLERA

| 19

2. ERÍSTICA E MEDICINA | 25 3. UMA VIDA INDIGNA DE

SER VIVIDA?

| 31

4. QUANDO A MEDICINA ENLOUQUECEU | 37 5. A

MEDICINA COMUNISTA

6. DISTOPIA

REVISITADA

| 43

| 49

7. LIBERDADE E CONSCIÊNCIA MÉDICA | 57 8. TUDO É BOM MOTIVO PARA MATAR UM BEBEZINHO… | 67 9. UM MERGULHO NAS PRÓPRIAS TREVAS | 75 10. UMA PONTE PARA O FUTURO DIRETO DO PASSADO | 79 11. BIBLIOGRAFIA DE BIBLIOGRAFIA | 95 ÍNDICE REMISSIVO | 101

BIOÉTICA

| 83

PREFÁCIO

0QU ºNVKOQU CPQU Q CWVQT FGUVC QDTC FT *©NKQ #PIQVVK 0GVQ XGO FGUGORGPJCPFQ WO RCRGN HWPFCOGPVCN PQ $TCUKN PC FGPºPEKC FCSWKNQ SWG EJCOC CRTQRTKCFCOGPVG FG disbioética.1 %QOQ P£Q RQFGTKC UGT FKHGTGPVG UGW HQEQ RTKPEKRCN VGO UKFQ Q EQODCVG CQ JQNQECWUVQ FQ U©EWNQ ::+ ƴ Q CDQTVQ 2 o genoE­FKQ UKNGPEKQUQ FG PQUUC GTC 3WCNSWGT O©FKEQ SWG P£Q UG QRQPJC C GUUG VGTT­XGN CVGPVCFQ EQPVTC C FKIPKFCFG JWOCPC e contra essa covardia para com inocentes não é digno do sal

1

2

0Q XQNWOG FG Disbioética (Brasília: Monergismo, 2017), Angotti GZRNKEC ƹDis GO OGFKEKPC TGOGVG C CNIQ GTTCFQ FKH­EKN SWG F³K QW NGUC Q RCEKGPVG .QIQ C RTQRQUVC FQ PGQNQIKUOQ ǣEC DGO ENCTC VTCVCTGK FG CUUWPVQU SWG TQPFCO C DKQ©VKEC Ƶ QW C ©VKEC TGNCEKQPCFC XKFC JWOCPC KPFKXKFWCN G GO UQEKGFCFG Ƶ G SWG C HGTGO EQOQ RGTEGDQ PQ EGP¡TKQ EWNVWTCN G RQN­VKEQ FG PQUUQU FKCUƺ R 1 TGPQOCFQ DKQGVKEKUVC 'FOWPF & 2GNNGITKPQ CRTGUGPVC Q SWG RQFGTKC UGT EJCOCFQ FG WO TGUWOQ FC RQUK§£Q ETKUV£ ƹ1 CDQTVQ © EQPUKFGTCFQ WOC CDQOKPC§£Q RQKU FGUVT³K WOC ETKCVWTC ETKCFC G ƶOQNFCFCƷ PQ XGPVTG 5CNOQ RQT WO &GWU RGUUQCN RCTC UGT COCFC RQT GUVG &GWU 'UUG UGT ETKCFQ © FKIPQ FG TGURGKVQ RQKU © WOC RGUUQC C ECOKPJQ FC RNGPC CVWCNK\C§£Q 1 CDQTVQ RTKXC GUUC RGUUQC FQ UGW FGUVKPQ FG UGT COCFC G COCT 0GPJWO OCTECFQT DKQN³IKEQ CTDKVT¡TKQ QW KPVGTXCNQ FG VGORQ RQFG CNVGTCT Q HCVQ FG SWG Q QXQ HGTVKNK\CFQ © WOC UWDUV¢PEKC KPFKXKFWCN RGTVGPEGPVG C WOC GUR©EKG FG UGTGU EQO WOC PCVWTG\C TCEKQPCN ETKCFC RQT WO &GWU RGUUQCNƺ %H The Christian Virtues in Medical Practice (Washington DC: Georgetown University Press, 1996), p. 147.

Disbioética - Volume II

SWG EQOG SWGO FKT¡ FQ R£Q 3 As atrocidades desse plano (em RNGPC GZGEW§£Q FKCD³NKEQ GUV£Q DGO FQEWOGPVCFCU G FGXKFCOGPVG GZRQUVCU G ETKVKECFCU PQU UGWU GZEGNGPVGU NKXTQU A morte da medicina4 e A tradição da medicina.5 'UVG NKXTQ ϐ UGIWPFQ XQNWOG FC U©TKG Disbioética ϐ VTCVC P£Q CRGPCU FC RGTXGTU£Q FC DKQ©VKEC SWG P£Q GUV¡ TGUVTKVC CIGPFC CDQTVKUVC OCU VCOD©O FG ǣNQUQǣC RQN­VKEC G VGQNQIKC ' P£Q RQFGTKC UGT FKHGTGPVG #ǣPCN C V©EPKEC ǣNQU³ǣEC6 — reV³TKEC FKCN©VKEC G N³IKEC Ƶ © ºVKN GO SWCNSWGT FGDCVG SWCPFQ UG RQFG KPENWUKXG CPVGEKRCT QDLG§µGU HWVWTCU G GZRQT HCN¡EKCU OGKCU XGTFCFGU G UQǣUOCU 1 ECR­VWNQ CRTGUGPVC WO FGUUGU ECUQU G *©NKQ GPUKPC OGFKCPVG Q GZGORNQ EQOQ GZCOKPCT CU HCN¡EKCU GUSWGTFKUVCU SWG PQU TQFGKCO RQT VQFC RCTVG Ƶ PC ITCPFG O­FKC PCU WPKXGTUKFCFGU G PQU UWRQUVQU ƹGURGEKCNKUVCUƺ *©NKQ © WO O©FKEQ ǣN³UQHQ KUVQ © RCTC GNG ǣNQUQǣC P£Q © WOC RTQǣUU£Q OCU UKO PQTOC G UGPVKFQ FC XKFC 7

3

4 5 6

7

%QOQ CUUGXGTC 4 , 4WUJFQQP[ ƹ# KPECRCEKFCFG FCU UQEKGFCFGU O©FKECU FG EQPFGPCT G DCTTCT QU CDQTVKUVCU FGKZC ENCTQ C UWC ECRKVWNC§£Q OQTCNƺ (An Informed Faith Ƶ XQNWOG =8CNNGEKVQ %# %JCNEGFQP (QWPFCVKQP ? R 0C QRKPK£Q FG 4WUJFQQP[ ƹ OGFKFC SWG C RT¡VKEC OGFKEKPCN QEKFGPVCN UG CHCUVQW FQ ETKUVKCPKUOQ GNC UG VQTPC ECFC XG\ OCKU WOC ENCUUG FG V©EPKEQU RTQǣUUKQPCKU GO XG\ FG EWTCFQTGUƺ %CORKPCU 8+&' 'FKVQTKCN Brasília: Monergismo, 2017.

1 RTQHGUUQT 1NCXQ FG %CTXCNJQ FGǣPG CUUKO VCN V©EPKEC ƹ6©EPKEC ǣNQU³ǣEC © UCDGT TCUVTGCT WO VGOC WO RTQDNGOC WOC KF©KC CV© UWCU TC­\GU PC GUVTWVWTC OGUOC FC TGCNKFCFG 6TCVC UG FG RGPUCT PQ CUUWPVQ CV© SWG Q RGPUCOGPVQ GPEQPVTG UGWU NKOKVGU G C RT³RTKC TGCNKFCFG EQOGEG C HCNCTƺ %H # ǣNQUQǣC G UGW KPXGTUQ & outros estudos 5£Q 2CWNQ 8KFG 'FKVQTKCN R 1NCXQ FK\ SWG RCTC QU ƹǣN³UQHQU RTQǣUUKQPCKUƺ CU SWGUVµGU ǣNQU³ǣECU UGTXGO CRGPCU ƹRCTC CNKOGPVCT C RGUSWKUC GTWFKVC G CSWGEGT Q FGDCVG CECFªOKEQƺ 'NGU FGEKFKTCO ƹDWUECT CPVGU C UGIWTCP§C FG WOC KFGPVKFCFG RTQǣUUKQPCN FQ SWG C QTFGO FC XKFC KPVGTKQT conciliando UGO OCKQTGU FTCOCU FG EQPUEKªPEKC Q TKIQT FCU KPXGUVKIC§µGU CECFªOKECU EQO C HTCIOGPVC§£Q FGUCTOQPKC G FGHQTOKFCFG FCU UWCU CNOCUƺ op. cit. R %QO EGTVG\C GUUG © WO FQU OQVKXQU FC UQEKGFCFG XGT EQO

10| Hélio Angotti Neto

Prefácio # FKUEWUU£Q RQN­VKEC RQT UWC XG\ © KORTGUEKPF­XGN RQKU ƹCU EQPVTQX©TUKCU GO VQTPQ FCU RQN­VKECU RºDNKECU G QU FGDCVGU OQTCKU OQUVTCO SWG FKCPVG FC FKXGTUKFCFG FG EQPUKFGTC§µGU OQTCKU VGOQU UGORTG EQPEGR§µGU FKHGTGPVGU CEGTEC FC XKFC OQTCNƺ 8 ' RCTVKEWNCTOGPVG PQ $TCUKN VGOQU WOC GNKVG OKPQTKV¡TKC SWG CPUGKC KORQT UWCU EQPEGR§µGU CVG­UVCU RTQITGUUKUVCU G OCTZKUVCU SWG GO IGTCN U£Q UKP´PKOQU EQPVTC C OCKQTKC FC RQRWNC§£Q CFGRVC EQPUEKGPVGOGPVG QW P£Q FQU XCNQTGU LWFCKEQ ETKUV£QU SWG OQFGNCTCO Q OWPFQ QEKFGPVCN 9 2QT ºNVKOQ Q XCNQT FC VGQNQIKC PQ ECORQ FC DKQ©VKEC © KPGUVKO¡XGN 1 ETKUVKCPKUOQ ϐ RQT OGKQ FG JQOGPU EQOQ #IQUVKPJQ FG *KRQPC G 6QO¡U FG #SWKPQ RQT GZGORNQ ϐ OQNFQW C ©VKEC QEKFGPVCN UGPFQ WO FQU ITCPFGU TGURQPU¡XGKU RGNC GZVKP§£Q FQ DCTDCTKUOQ RCI£Q 10 Assim, como grande FGHGPUQT FC VTCFK§£Q ETKUV£ G JKRQET¡VKEC 11 QU RTGUUWRQUVQU VGQN³IKEQU FG *©NKQ RGTOGKCO VQFQ GUVG NKXTQ #NK¡U UGWU GUETKVQU U£Q WO EQPXKVG EQGTªPEKC RQKU P£Q RQWEQU ETKUV£QU CUUWOGO RQUK§µGU ©VKECU EQPVT¡TKCU EQUOQXKU£Q G TGNKIK£Q SWG RTQHGUUCO CQ OGUOQ VGORQ GO SWG EQPUVKVWGO WO FGUCǣQ CQ ƹKPǣGNƺ RCTC SWG GUVG XGLC C DGNG\C FQ RCFT£Q ©VKEQ legado pelo cristianismo.

8

9

10

11

FGURTG\Q Q GORTGGPFKOGPVQ ǣNQU³ǣEQ RQKU PQ EGP¡TKQ WPKXGTUKV¡TKQ GNG UG TGUWOG C CRCTªPEKC G RCR©KU UQEKCKU UGO EQPGZ£Q EQO C TGCNKFCFG 0£Q GZKUVG NKXTQ OGNJQT UQDTG GUUG RTQDNGOC QW FQGP§C! FQ SWG A ǣNQUQǣC G UGW KPXGTUQ & outros estudos, de Olavo de Carvalho.

ENGELHARDT, H. Tristram. (WPFCOGPVQU FC DKQ©VKEC ETKUV£ QTVQFQZC +PVTQFW§£Q geral e fundamentos 5£Q 2CWNQ 'FK§µGU .Q[QNC R :+: &KXGTUQU NKXTQU FQEWOGPVCO KUUQ 7OC XKU£Q ECV³NKEC UQDTG Q CUUWPVQ pode ser encontrada em Como a Igreja Católica construiu a civilização ocidental FG 6JQOCU ' 9QQFU ,T 7O GZEGNGPVG NKXTQ CRTGUGPVCPFQ C visão protestante é O livro que fez o seu mundo: como a Bíblia criou a alma da civilização ocidental FQ KPFKCPQ 8KUJCN /CPICNYCFK 8GLC Q GZEGNGPVG NKXTGVQ Medicina pós-hipocrática (Brasília: Monergismo, FG *WIJ , (NGOOKPI 8GLC Q UGW NKXTQ Arte médica: De Hipócrates a Cristo (Brasília: Monergismo, 2018).

Hélio Angotti Neto|11

Disbioética - Volume II

#PIQVVK CRTGPFGW C NK§£Q FG SWG ƹQ O©FKEQ SWG U³ UCDG OGFKEKPC PGO OGFKEKPC UCDGƺ .GVCOGPFK #UUKO UGW EQPJGEKOGPVQ ǣNQU³ǣEQ G CRQTVG EWNVWTCN RGTOKVG NJG CP¡NKUGU UWDUVCPEKCKU G RTGEKUCU TGXGNCPFQ CU HCN¡EKCU G QU RTGUUWRQUVQU RQT FGVT¡U FQU KPKOKIQU FG VQFC C VTCFK§£Q QEKFGPVCN ϐ ETKUV£ G JKRQET¡VKEC &GUGLQUQ SWG UGWU NGKVQTGU VCOD©O RQUUCO DGDGT FCU TKSWG\CU FC CORNC EWNVWTC Q FT *©NKQ QHGTGEG PQ ECR­VWNQ FGUVG NKXTQ WO RTGEKQUQ ƹRNCPQ FG NGKVWTCƺ CDTCPIGPFQ JKUV³TKC DKQ©VKEC ǣNQUQǣC G OWKVQ OCKU +UVQ RQUVQ Q NGKVQT VGO GO O£QU WO NKXTQ UKORNGU SWG P£Q UG FGV©O GO NQIQOCSWKCU PGO UG TGUXCNC RCTC Q RGFCPVKUOQ CPVGU RTQENCOC WOC OGPUCIGO HWPFCOGPVCN J¡ WOC NWVC EQPVTC C RT³RTKC JWOCPKFCFG G QU JQOGPU FG DGO FGXGO se preparar para combater este bom combate. Não se trata de WOC EQPXQEC§£Q TGXQNW§£Q OCU WO EJCOCFQ CQ RTGRCTQ KPVGNGEVWCN G EQTCIGO RCTC GZRQTOQU CU QDTCU FCU VTGXCU (WLCOQU RQKU FC QOKUU£Q RQTSWG ƹCSWGNG SWG UCDG SWG FGXG HC\GT Q DGO G P£Q Q HC\ PKUUQ GUV¡ RGECPFQƺ 6KCIQ ϐ (GNKRG 5CDKPQ FG #TCºLQ 0GVQ Brasília, 21 de maio de 2018

12| Hélio Angotti Neto