SEAN PATRICK MALONEY

Out of moves

Sean Patrick Maloney’s gambit to push out Mondaire Jones and take a “safe” seat for himself has failed.

By Shantel Destra

AS REPUBLICANS GET close to winning control of Congress in the midterm elections, Democrats suffered a major loss when GOP Assembly Member Mike Lawler eked out a victory over Rep. Sean Patrick Maloney in the 17th Congressional District. The loss was especially heavy for Democrats because the five-term member of Congress was also chair of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee.

Maloney, who currently represents the 18th Congressional District, decided to run in the 17th Congressional District after a chaotic redistricting process. The controversial decision earned him major backlash because it forced first-term Rep. Mondaire Jones out of the 17th District. Jones then unsuccessfully ran in the June Democratic primary in New York City’s crowded 10th Congressional District. Despite the popularity among progressives of Maloney’s primary opponent state Sen. Alessandra Biaggi, he went on to win easily – only to be met with a fierce challenge by a firstterm Assembly member and lobbyist.

Hank Sheinkopf, a veteran Democratic political consultant, suspected Maloney did not think he had any chance of losing the election. “He probably thought he could not have been beaten, and this race was

“He probably thought he could not have been beaten, and this race was an easier win. Nobody saw this coming.”

– Hank Sheinkopf, a veteran Democratic political consultant

an easier win,” Sheinkopf said. “Nobody saw this coming.” But the race tightened, and several political pundits identified it as increasingly competitive, including The Cook Political Report, which shifted its rating from “Lean Democratic” to “TossUp” just two weeks before Election Day.

Maloney, who did not attend his election night party in New York on Nov. 8, conceded to Lawler on Nov. 9 in Washington, D.C.

“I don’t like to lose, but my opponent won this race, and he won it fair and square. And that means something,” Maloney told reporters. “So I’m going to step aside, and I had a good run.”

Lawler responded on Twitter thanking Maloney for his time serving the Hudson Valley. “Humble in victory, gracious in defeat,” Lawler wrote. “Campaigns are tough and he was a tough, and worthy opponent.”

Lawler centered much of his platform around crime, and recent polls highlighted the issue as a top concern for voters this election season. The Assembly member also vowed to address the economy while criticizing his opponent for “wasteful spending in Washington’’ – which he said has contributed to rising inflation. In addition, Lawler focused on the fentanyl crisis. While experts debunked the Assembly member’s theory that the Biden administration’s southern border policy was driving the opioid crisis, addressing the crisis has been extremely important to Hudson Valley voters as the number of overdose deaths continued to rise at alarming rates.

On the other hand, Maloney prioritized abortion rights and gun safety. Sheinkopf said Maloney’s “tremendous loss” was because the member of Congress was late when it came to focusing on crime. “It was very clear a year ago that crime would be an issue this election cycle. (Maloney) was more concerned about (his) national standing than he was about local issues,” Sheinkopf said. “Running in a new district requires a sole commitment to that district.”

Maloney attempted to pivot his messaging to crime in the days leading up to the election by releasing an ad featuring a police officer vouching for him. “Becoming a tough-on-crime guy would not have fit Sean Patrick Maloney’s profile. It just wasn’t him. It was not believable,” Sheinkopf said.

Maloney wasn’t the only Democratic candidate to fall short. Democrats in the state Senate also suffered losses. In Rockland County, Republican challenger Bill Weber bested first-term state Sen. Elijah Reichlin-Melnick with his campaign focused on “keeping communities safe” and repealing bail reform. In the 39th state Senate District, Democrat Julie Shiroishi lost decisively to Poughkeepsie Mayor Rob Rolison. Like Lawler, Rolison vowed to prioritize the economy, crime and public safety if elected.

Jack O’Donnell, a veteran Democratic strategist and managing partner at the political consulting firm O’Donnell & Associates, said Maloney relied heavily on his accomplishments throughout his time in Congress, including his work on addressing climate change and drinking water infrastructure, as his campaign strategy, but it ultimately was not enough to convince his new constituents to vote for him on Election Day. O’Donnell also pointed to Maloney’s senior position within the House Democrats as a possible reason for his struggles to win the race.

“As chair of the DCCC, Maloney was viewed by a lot of folks as a total embodiment of the Democratic Party – including the Democratic left, which is somewhat ironic considering his centrist background – and I think that was also a time commitment away from his district,” O’Donnell said. “He ultimately paid the price for it.”

With Maloney gone, House Democrats will have to find a new chair of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee. Sheinkopf thought there will be life after politics for Maloney. “The great thing about political campaigns and politics is that after you lose, you wake up the next morning and you go to work,” Sheinkopf said. ■

Assembly Member Mike Lawler, left, defeated Rep. Sean Patrick Maloney, right, in the 17th District.

14 New York City Council Member Julie Won gave birth to her son in March.

The City Council’s New Moms By Annie McDonough

Julie Won, Jennifer Gutiérrez and Pierina Sanchez all had their first kids in the past year, and it’s given them clear policy priorities to aid city parents.

WHEN NEW YORK CITY Council Member Jennifer Gutiérrez cast her vote for Speaker Adrienne Adams – the first Black woman and mother to hold the position – the first-term lawmaker participated in the vote virtually, while breastfeeding her newborn daughter. “I was really happy that I got to share that with my daughter, to vote for the first Black speaker,” Gutiérrez recalled recently. “I got some nasty comments,” she said of a tweet celebrating the moment, “But mostly positive.”

Gutiérrez is one of three new mothers to join the City Council this year. She was pregnant during the campaign last year and gave birth shortly after the election. Council Member Julie Won, who represents Western Queens, gave birth to her son in March, and Bronx Council Member Pierina Sanchez had her son in August. Council Member Kevin Riley also welcomed a son over the summer.

In conversations with City & State, the three Democrats spoke passionately about the challenges of giving birth and raising newborns in New York City, from accessing safe maternal health care to finding affordable child care. “The thing that I find myself saying over and over is that it is impossible, and there’s no way to do it, and we do it anyway,” Sanchez said.

But the council’s new parents, along with the rest of this body, may be well-positioned to tackle – or at the very least draw attention to – issues that affect mothers. Already, the first majority-female City Council has passed legislative packages addressing maternal health care needs, child care and abortion access. Gutiérrez sponsored two bills that passed as part of the maternal health and child care packages, while Won and Sanchez co-sponsored several of the bills in these packages. “As the first mother and grandmother to be speaker and leading the first women-majority Council in New York City history, I

am proud that we have advanced a legislative agenda that prioritizes addressing the longstanding challenges and issues facing women and families in our city,” Speaker Adrienne Adams said in an emailed comment. “This Council is uniquely qualified and positioned to ensure progress on child care that supports working families and mothers, that confronts racial disparities in maternal health, and safeguards reproductive health care.”

Gutiérrez, Won and Sanchez are set on drawing attention to additional issues, including postpartum depression, recovery from the major operation that is a Cesarean section, securing flexible work arrangements for parents, and ensuring workplaces provide lactation rooms, which they’re required to do. “The sight of a boob or a woman breastfeeding, the talk of how much these things cost, the ups and downs and the need for postpartum care for women,” Won said, “All these things that people don’t seem to discuss, we need to start to talk about.”

“I HAD THE CHOICE”

Won, a former technology professional who immigrated from South Korea as a child, didn’t know that she was already pregnant on June 22, 2021, when she defeated a crowded field to win the Democratic primary. She and her husband found out in August and took a month or so to discuss whether it was the right time for them to have their first child. “Looking back now as a new mother – one, I’m extremely grateful to have had the baby because he brings me so much joy after a long day, but two, this year it means even more that I had the choice,” Won said.

Asked about what the City Council has done for women and mothers in the past year, Won pointed first to its work on abortion access following the U.S. Supreme Court’s overturning of Roe v. Wade in June. Though the right to an abortion is codified in state law, both the state Legislature and City Council passed additional measures this summer, including to support people traveling to New York to receive an abortion. The City Council allocated $1 million to expanding access to abortion, with half of the money going to fund abortions for those who cannot afford them, and the rest going to support accommodations for those who need to travel to New York to receive an abortion.

The City Council has also shined a light on maternal health care – in particular, the higher rates of maternal mortality and morbidity among Black, Latino and Indigenous people. A package of bills passed in August includes legislation sponsored by Gutiérrez that requires the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene to create a program to train doulas and provide free doula services in marginalized neighborhoods. Gutiérrez said that she was lucky to have a sister-in-law who was a midwife and a doula, and to have found a midwife at Woodhull Hospital. “It just really felt like my exception should be the standard for pregnant people,” Gutiérrez said.

Gutiérrez also sponsored a “Marshall Plan for Moms” that passed as part of a package of bills aiming to expand access to affordable child care. Gutiérrez’s bill requires the creation of a task force to report recommendations for supporting working mothers and caregivers.

“The sight of a boob or a woman breastfeeding, how much these things cost, the need for postpartum care for women: All these things that people don’t seem to discuss, we need to start to talk about.”

– New York City Council Member Julie Won

THE CHILD CARE CHALLENGE

Gutiérrez, Won and Sanchez all said that finding accessible and affordable child care is a challenge. The three council members said they took a few months – Sanchez took six weeks – of maternity leave before returning to work in some fashion, though they still held meetings and calls remotely during some of that time.

Gutiérrez and Won said they benefited from being able to more freely attend hearings and meetings virtually earlier this year, when many of the council’s hearings were held over videoconference, and before the state’s Open Meetings Law was amended this spring to clarify that members of public bodies can attend meetings remotely only under extraordinary circumstances. The two said they hope to have a more flexible hybrid option in the future.

According to the state’s Open Meetings Law and a resolution passed by the council, council members can still attend meetings virtually, but they have to submit a request to the speaker’s office to do so “explaining in detail the extraordinary circumstances which preclude their in-person attendance, including disability, illness, caregiving responsibilities, or any other significant or unexpected factor or event.” Sanchez said

From left, Pierina Sanchez and Jennifer Gutiérrez are juggling being new moms with the demands of elected office.

that she has not had issues so far when she has requested to attend a hearing virtually, but said it’s not something she can automatically do without submitting that request. “We have also sought to ensure the Council is an accommodating employer to new mothers, which many of our members have played an important role in shaping,” Adams said in an emailed comment.

Gutiérrez, Won and Sanchez are frank about the challenges of going back to work after having children. “It was absolutely horrible. I wasn’t there psychologically,” Sanchez said of her return to work soon after giving birth. “I would go through my day and ensure that on the outside looking in, it looked fine. ‘Oh, look, she chaired a hearing. Oh look, she went to this thing,’” Sanchez recalled. “But I kid you not, I would go home and I would be in tears because it’s so overwhelming to have this little one who is just completely amazing and 100% dependent on you, and then have just all of these other pressures.” Sanchez said that her office and team played a crucial role in backing her up and helping to serve constituents during that time.

The constraints of working with newborns – chief among them finding affordable child care – are issues often raised by constituents, but the three council members said they can better appreciate them having experienced it themselves. Sanchez said that she still takes her son with her most places she goes, including to City Hall, while Gutiérrez said she was initially stuck on a neighborhood day care waitlist for months. “Now I’m an even greater supporter of 3K, pre-K and after-school programming as well because I am constantly making sure that my husband and I are juggling both of our busy work schedules to make sure that somebody is taking care of this baby,” Won added. “And I’m lucky enough that my parents are helping me right now between their schedules.”

“A NEW DAY”

In addition to disparities in maternal health and the overall challenge of affordability – of child care, of formula, of diapers – the three council members hope to draw attention to additional barriers mothers and other parents face in having and raising children in the city. Sanchez is working with Bronx Borough President Vanessa Gibson to bring a birthing center to the borough, while Gutiérrez said that she wants to tackle child care deserts and ensure that child care providers – many of them women of color – who contract with the city are paid on time. “It’s been so overlooked because it’s an industry that impacts and serves primarily women and women of color, and no one’s really cared about it,” Gutiérrez said of the child care industry. “I really hope that it’s a new day, and I believe that it is with this new council.”

With children ranging from 3 months to going on a year old, Gutiérrez, Won and Sanchez are consumed with the extraordinary daily developments of their young kids. Sanchez’s son has just started babbling, while Gutiérrez just celebrated her first Halloween with her daughter. (She went as a as a player from the Rockford Peaches in “A League of Their Own” – the Geena Davis version, Gutiérrez is quick to note.) Won is introducing her son to new Korean foods, ensuring “a spice tolerance that is acceptable.” “As a new mother, just coming home after a very stressful day at City Hall, giving him a big hug and seeing his face light up and smiling – it sounds cliche, but it really does make all of your worries melt away,” Won said. ■