november 2016
MACK LOT Prepared for MACC Development by City Form Detroit, MAde Studio & Giffels webster
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS introduction....................................................................................................................................................................... 04 The Neighborhood center in the mack avenue corridor development plan existing conditions......................................................................................................................................................... 06 community engagement & design process.............................................................................................................. 08 Timeline community input event: programming & amenities for the lot & corridor community input Event: DATA community feedback session: configuration of the lot elements & corridor MACK avenue and lot VISION.......................................................................................................................................... 16 mack avenue strategy mack avenue design components mack lot plan and design components STAGE Details PERSPECTIVES ELEVATIONs LANDSCAPE STRATEGY PLANTING PALETTE SUN STUDIES Programmatic opportunities OUTDOOR furniture AND PLAY COMPONENTS BUDGET: MACK LOT acknowledgments............................................................................................................................................................. 45
MACK Lot
3
introduction The Neighborhood center in the mack avenue corridor development plan MACC Development is leading planning efforts for the Mack Lot, an underutilized lot on Mack Avenue between MACC Development/The Commons and D&D Storage in the 48214 community. This effort also addresses improvements to the portion of Mack Avenue anchored by the Mack Lot and The Commons. The objective of the Mack Lot project is to envision a new outdoor community space that brings people together through arts and culture, food, and recreation alongside a pedestrian friendly corridor. A stakeholder-driven, place-based approach informed the project. City Form Detroit, MAde Studio, and Giffels Webster assisted MACC Development with the plan. The Mack Lot leverages multiple public and private initiatives occurring on the corridor such as The Commons, a combination coin laundry and coffee bar that will operate in the storefront space below MACC Development’s office at 7900 Mack Avenue. Private investments include the adaptive reuse of the D&D Storage building adjacent to the Mack Lot as well as visions for the area as a Market Garden District with new residential, grocery, and recreation spaces. Plans for the Mack Lot also build from the Mack Avenue Corridor Development Plan, a community generated plan for the Mack Avenue commercial corridor developed in 2015-16. Anchored by the Neighborhood Center concept, the plan resulted in the following strategies for the corridor:
4
Concept for Mack Avenue in the Mack Avenue Corridor Development Plan
1. NEIGHBORHOOD CENTER Create a neighborhood center at Mack Avenue between Baldwin and Parker Streets that leverages existing assets and emerging opportunities. 2. ALTERNATIVE LAND USES Implement alternative land use strategies including green infrastructure and stormwater management on vacant land. 3. PLACEMAKING Create public spaces for people to come together by programming vacant and underutilized land through placemaking interventions. 4. NON MOTORIZED TRANSPORTATION Implement non-motorized transportation on Mack Avenue between East Grand Boulevard and Fischer Street.
neighborhood center
PA R
KE
Opportunity sites for alternative land uses and placemaking
RS
T
Opportunity zone for non-motorized transportation improvements
1
SE
YB
3
2
UR
N
ST
K AC
VA N
Mack Lot
E AV
4
M
5 BE
AL
6 SE
YB
BA
LD
MACK Lot
WI
N
UR
N
ST
DY
KE
ST
1 2
MT. ZION BAPTIST CHURCH
3
D+D STORAGE Exg. Storage Small Business Start-Ups Co-Working Entrepreneur Resource Center
4
THE COMMONS Coffee Bar + Coin Laundry MACC Development Co-Working Entrepreneur Resource Center
5
FUTURE REDEVELOPMENT Restaurant/Market Fresh Food Options
6
NON-MOTORIZED TRANSPORTATION Bike Lanes Pedestrian Crosswalks TrafďŹ c Calming
SS
T
FUTURE DEVELOPMENT Gathering Space Banquet/Meeting Space Small Business
ST
5
SEYBURN ST
VAN DYKE AVE
existing conditions
The Mack Lot is a 0.19 acre site located at 7906 Mack Avenue between MACC Development/The Commons and D&D Storage. The site is currently used for storage and secured with a fence. The Mack Lot is a natural extension of “The Commons,” the forthcoming space for coin laundry, a coffee shop, and community activities, with the potential to serve as an outdoor gathering space for the community. The Mack Avenue corridor is also a consideration for this project within the neighborhood center area. Here the Mack Avenue right-of-way is typically 66 feet wide including one driving lane in each direction and a parking lane and concrete sidewalk on each side. The corridor is heavily trafficked connecting the economic center of Detroit and suburban areas.
6
2
Mack Avenue
3
4
5
BEALS ST
Mack Lot
SEYBURN ST
Key components in the design development of the project are the need for traffic calming and improved pedestrian crossings on Mack Avenue and a stormwater management strategy on the Mack Lot in light of the stormwater drainage charges recently implemented by the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department (DWSD). These driving forces— along with an analysis of existing site conditions, neighboring investments and initiatives, and stakeholder input— provided a basis for the design of the Mack Lot and Mack Avenue at the neighborhood center between Baldwin and Parker Streets.
1
Mack Lot Site Plan
1
MACK’S VAN DYKE MINI MART
4
MACC DEVELOPMENT/THE COMMONS
2
MT. ZION BAPTIST CHURCH
5
D&D STORAGE
3
Z’S AMAZING SAVINGS
MACK LOt
7
community engagement & design process
SECOND COMMUNITY MEETING 10_11_2016
PROPOSAL TIMELINE
FIRST COMMUNITY MEETING 09_11_2016
TIMELINE
8
AUGUST
SEPTEMBER
Fri, 5
Mon, 29
Wed, 7
Sun, 11
Team Meeting
Team Meeting
Team Meeting
Community Engagement Event at Mack Lot
Wed, 14
Meeting with M1DTW on D&D Storage
Tu, 20
Team Meeting
OCTOBER
NOVEMBER Tu, 11
Feedback Session at GenesisHOPE
MACK Lot
Th, 13
Meeting with Kresge Foundation
Th, 24
Fri, 11
Team Meeting
Internal Draft Submission
Mon, 21
Final Submission Kresge KIP:D
9
community input event: programming & amenities for the lot & corridor The community engagement process gathered critical input from local business owners, residents, and church and community leaders on what they would like to see in the Mack Lot and on Mack Avenue. The Community Input Event was held outdoors on Mack Avenue between D&D Storage and MACC Development in front of the Mack Lot. Over seventy-five people, largely from the 48214 community, participated in conversations addressing the following: “What programs and activities would attract you to the Mack Lot? What amenities and features would attract you to the Mack Lot? Which approach (or attributes) would you prefer to see in the Mack Lot? What amenities and features would make Mack Avenue more comfortable?� Through these conversations, community members expressed a desire for kid-friendly spaces such as recreation and play areas, and food options, with landscaping and bike lanes identified as priorities for Mack Avenue. The follow-up Community Feedback Session held at GenesisHOPE served as an opportunity for community members to provide feedback on the preliminary designs for the Mack Lot and Mack Avenue through facilitated roundtable discussions. Preferences for the stage design and furniture configurations for the Mack Lot as well as a phased traffic calming approach for Mack Avenue were expressed. The input gathered through community engagement strongly informed the resulting vision and design for the Mack Lot and Corridor described subsequently in this document. 9/11/16 Stakeholder Event Demographic Data of Participants
10
MACK Lot
11
community input event: DATA FOOD AND FRIENDS 57 votes
RECREATION & PLAY 42 votes
VISUAL ARTS 38 votes
STORYTELLING 27 votes
Preferred Approaches (or Attributes) for the Mack Lot
9/11/16 Community Event Voting Activity for Approaches to the Lot
12
9/11/16 Community Event Findings
MACK Lot
13
community feedback session: configuration of the lot elements & corridor B A
C
14
Lot Configuration Options - Programmatic Flexibility
MACK Lot
15
mack avenue and lot vision
The Mack Lot is a new outdoor community space that brings people together through arts and culture, food, and recreation anchoring the revitalization of Mack Avenue as a pedestrian friendly corridor.
16
MACK Lot
17
mack avenue strategy
The strategy for Mack Avenue is to revitalize it as a pedestrian friendly corridor through traffic calming and non-motorized transportation improvements from East Grand Boulevard to Fisher Streets which includes the neighborhood center project area. Initial conversations with the community concluded that traffic calming, better pedestrian crossings, bike lanes, landscaping, and improved transit (bus) stops are of priority interest. Upon further discussion with the community and in part because the project area lies with a greater Mack Avenue corridor, a phased implementation plan of traffic calming is being proposed as follows. Existing Conditions: Mack Avenue is one of the major highway and commercial corridors traversing the east side of Detroit. Starting at Woodward Avenue in Midtown, Mack generally parallels the Detroit River moving in a northeast-southwest direction until it reaches the Grosse Pointes where the corridor changes to a more northsouth alignment. The pavement cross-section and rightof-way width changes significantly along the alignment. Within the MACC Development neighborhood center area, more specifically from East Grand Boulevard through Fischer (and extending easterly to St Jean at the Fiat-Chrysler Jefferson Avenue North Plant), the right-ofway is typically 66 feet wide, with a 50 foot face-to-face of curb pavement and approximately 8 foot wide concrete sidewalks on each side. The existing pavement travel way is defined by a single solid yellow centerline marking dividing traffic in both directions. No further delineation
18
of travel and/or parking lanes typically exists. The posted speed limit is 30 mph, but the observed speeds and antidotal evidence shows much higher actual speeds. Short (Near) Term Improvements: With relatively small implementation costs, changes to pavement striping, defining of parking and bus stops, painted curb extensions, and special emphasis crosswalk pavement markings are proposed to improve Mack Avenue in the short term. It is proposed to stripe a three lane section, with one lane in each direction and a center turn lane. The limits of parking (though not individual spaces) and bus stops would also be striped. Painted curb extensions (aka “bump outs�) are proposed at the residential street intersections. Midblock crosswalks at select intersections between signalized intersections are also proposed to reduce the distance between crossings. Along the alignment, painted refuge islands could be added in place of the center turn lane to shorten the pedestrian distances. Long Term Improvements: To improve Mack Avenue in the long term, the center turn lane would be removed, one lane of travel in each direction would remain, and the parking would be moved from along the curb to adjacent to the travel way. Permanent, built curb extensions could replace the painted curb extensions at the residential street intersections to shorten the pedestrian distances and create opportunities for stormwater management. A bike lane with buffer strip would be added along the curb, creating parking protected bike lanes.
existing conditions - 66’ ROW between East Grand Blvd and Fisher St - 50’ road bed with 8’ sidewalks on either side of the street - Solid yellow centerline divides traffic in both directions - Speed limit is 30mph, but observed speeds are actually much higher
The Commons/ MACC Development
Mack Avenue
8’-0” 10’-0”
15’-0”
15’-0”
10’-0”
8’-0”
50’-0”
Short term - Add center turn lane, define parking - Could apply on all 13 blocks - Reduces vehicular weaving - Can include mid-block pedestrian crossings and curb extensions on mainline
The Commons/ MACC Development
Mack Avenue
8’-0” 8’-0”
11’-0”
12’-0”
11’-0”
8’-0” 8’-0”
50’-0”
long term - Buffered bike lane, remove parking in select areas for center turn lane - Could apply where on street parking is in high demand and center turn lane not needed (up to 10 blocks) - Transition area needed where section changes from buffered bike lanes back to parking
The Commons/ MACC Development
Mack Avenue
8’-0” 5’ 2’ 8’-0” 10’-0”
10’-0” 8’-0” 2’ 5’
8’-0”
50’-0”
MACK Lot
19
ummary:
+ can be implemented where on
+ reduce pedestrian crossing distance, traffic calming, and street parking exists increased sidewalk space
Option 1 - crosswalk striping
$1-5k per
Pedestrian Crossin $1-5k +design coordination with future
+ can be implemented where on protected bike lanes needed street parking exists
Summary:
+design coordination with future protected bike lanes needed
mack avenue DESIGN COMPONENTS
conditions are unmarked, worn, or marked Option 1 - crosswalk+Existing striping with only parallel markings
Option 2 - painted curb extension
tion 2 - painted curb CURB extension A PAINTED mmary: EXTENSION
ost:
each +special emphasis marked E$1-5k CROSSWALK STRIPING
$1-5k
Cost:
crosswalk are an inexpensive opportunity for improvement along the corridor
each - Low cost $1-5k or temporary + low cost or temporary alternative to standard curb extension alternative to standard curb + low cost or temporary alternative extension to standard curb extension + maintain flexibility within roadway - Maintain flexibility for future improvements + maintain flexibility roadway within roadway forwithin future for future improvements improvements
$1-5k
ReducedPedestrian Road Width Crossings Reduced Road Width Applications: Option 1 - crosswalk striping
1 - standard curb extension st:Option extent except intersections Option 1 +Full - standard curb extension B
STANDARD CURB EXTENSION
and East Grand, pplications:ofVanKercheval Dyke, and McClellen where left turn pockets are provided.
+Existing conditio unmarked, worn, o with only parallel m
per walk
+special emphasi crosswalk are an i - Existing are per walk conditions opportunity for imp unmarked, worn, or marked along the corridor with only parallel markings
$1-5k
- Special +Existing conditions are emphasis marked crosswalk unmarked, worn, or marked are an inexpensive opportunity with only parallel markings
for improvement along the
Option 2 - pavement treatment
$10-20k$1-5k per walk - Reduce+Existing pedestrian crossing $10-20k each conditions are
F
PAVEMENT TREATMENT
$10-20k
each
Full extent except intersections + Traffic Impact Study would be educed Road Width f Kerchevalneeded and East Grand, to confirm traffic volumes can be accommodated Road Width Reduced plications: an and McClellen where management 3 - Dyke, curb extension with stormwater without center turn lane. Reduced Road Width Reduced Road Width ft turn pockets are provided.
+special emphasiscorridor marked crosswalk are an inexpensive opportunity for improvement along the corridor
Option 3 - pedestrian sig
$10-20k $10-20k
per walk
Option 2 - pavement treatment
distance, traffic calming, unmarked, worn, or marked + reduce pedestrian crossing pedestrian crossing with only parallel markings + reduce and increased sidewalk distance, traffic calming, and distance, traffic calming, and space +special emphasis increased sidewalk space marked are an inexpensive increased sidewalk space - Can becrosswalk implemented where opportunity for improvement + can be implemented where on alongparking the corridorexists onstreet street parking exists + can be implemented where on - Design coordination with street parking exists +design coordination with future future protected bike lanes protected bike lanes needed needed +design coordination with future $20-50k each protected bike lanes needed
- Tactile and + tactile andvisual visual cue cue toto watch forpedestrians pedestrians watch for - Implemented within +implementedcorridors within commercial and/ corridors and/or orcommercial downtowns downtowns
Option 2 - pavement treatment
ull extent except Option 3intersections - curb extensionWITH with stormwater management CURB EXTENSION + provides stormwater management G pedestrian Cand signals Option 3 - pedestrian signals Option -East curbextension extension with stormwater management Option 3 -3 curb with stormwater management Option 2 - pavement treatment STORMWATER MANAGEMENT $20-50k Kercheval Grand, and curb extension together tersections Option 2 painted curb extension $20-50k each Impact Studywhere would be $10-20k per walk - Provides stormwater $25-75k Grand, + use where$20-50k curb extensions conflict ntTraffic Dyke, and McClellen $20-50k each $1-5k each per walk $25-75k per signal with existing catch basins $10-20k management + curb ellen where - Signalization should be + provides stormwater management eeded to confirm traffic turn pockets are provided. extension rovided. and curb extension together ++provides stormwater management lowgrant cost ortogether temporary alternative + and visual cue to as tactile one of the + tactile and visual cue to + implemented signalization should be + may trigger additional
CTO
and curb extension together - Use where curb extensions toextensions standard curb extension watch for pedestrians opportunities + use where curb conflict
+ use where curb extensions conflict conflict w/ existing catch
with existing catch basins
++use where curb extensions conflict +implemented maintain flexibility within roadway withwithin existing catch basins +design coordination with future + may trigger additional grant basins commercial with existing catch corridors basins and/or for future improvements protected bike lanes needed
*images from NYC Street Design Manual
eded to confirm traffic Summary: ne. umes can be accommodated *image from NACTO 4 midblock hout center turncurb lane.extension
TO
Traffic Calming
each
+ provides stormwater management and curb extension together
Option 2 - painted curb extension olumes can be accommodated y would be Traffic Study ffic ithoutImpact center turnwould lane.be mmodated
$1-5k each
implemented as one of the last design tools last design tools
watch for pedestrians
*images from NYC Street Design Manual
$20-50k - Traffic$25-50k calming and per pair
Option 4 - midblock curb extension Option 4 - midblock curb extension Cost:
*image from NACTO
20 *image from NACTO
*image from NACTO
Applications:
*images from NYC Street Design Manual
*images from NYC Street Design Manual
+Full extent except intersections of Kercheval and East Grand, *images from NYC Street Design Manual Van Dyke, and McClellen where
pedestrian amenity $25-50k per pair + traffic calming and pedestrian - Could be prioritized amenity + traffic calming and pedestrian amenitythere are mid-block where + Could be prioritized where there attractors suchwhere assuch schools + Could be prioritized there per pair areare mid-block attractors $25-50k as $25-50k per pair mid-block attractors such as - Design coordination with schools schools + traffic calming and pedestrian future protected bike lanes+ traffic calming and pedestrian amenity +design coordination with +design coordination withfuture future amenity needed protectedbike bikelanes lanes needed protected needed + Could be prioritized where there *image from NYC Street Design Manual
*images from NYC Street Design Manual
$10-20k
Option 3 -
+ tactile and visua watch for pedestria
+implemented with commercial corrido downtowns
Option - center median / refuge islands +implemented within
opportunities
downtowns + may triggergrant additional - May trigger additional grant + maywith trigger additional grant + low cost or temporary alternative +design coordination future opportunities opportunities protected bikeopportunities lanes needed curb extension - Design coordination with to standard with future *images from NYC Street Design Manual +design coordination *image from NACTO *images from NYC Street Design Manual +design coordination with future future protected bike lanes protected bike lanes needed protected bike lanes needed + maintain flexibility within roadway Option - midblock curbCURB extension D 4 MIDBLOCK for futureHimprovements EXTENSION painted CENTER *image from NACTO
+ Could are mid-block attractors such be as prioritized where there schools are mid-block attractors such as schools
+design coordination with future protected bike lanes+design needed coordination with future
protected bike lanes needed
commercial corridors and/or downtowns
$10-25k per 100 sq-ftISLAND MEDIAN/REFUGE + allows for pedestrian refuge $10-25k - Allows forapply pedestrian refuge + could in many locations, however, too in many center medians - Could apply many can become restrictive to turning locations, however, too movements many center medians can become restrictive + area for landscapingto turning movements - Area for landscaping Source of Images: NACTO and NYC Street Design Manual
existing conditions
Mack Lot
Short term Add center turn lane, paint curb extensions, define parking
G H
A
A
A
A
E
Mack Lot
long term Add buffered bike lane and curb extensions, remove parking in select areas for center turn lane
G B
C
D
B
C
E
B
C
B
C
Mack Lot
MACK Lot
21
mack LOT PLAN AND DESIGN COMPONENTS
The participants in the first public input session expressed a desired to create a place for the community to come together and share food, music, art, and to provide safe areas for play and other special events. There was also strong support for flexible arrangements of furniture and to invest in a central element, a stage that would provide a place for the communities’ youth to host poetry slams or music events while also being a desirable space for church gatherings, oral history events or other special gatherings. Finally, nearly everyone agreed that food went hand in hand with any celebration and a long community table is the material expression of this priority. In the second public engagement session, we requested direct feedback on design options for the stage, and advanced the design of the gardens and the permeable fence. We talked about materials, and colors, and the need to allow the design to be participated by the members of the community, to address issues of character and identity.
22
MULTIPURPOSE STAGE CAFE/ PLAY AREAS
600 SQ FT
17%
1438 SQ FT
16%
GARDENS
The design outcome shown is a manifestation of the tremendous time, commitment and open dialogue feedback that community members offered during two different community engagement sessions. These moments of conversation played a key role in identifying and refining the kinds of activities many individuals desired and, the kinds of design elements that would best foster this vision.
7%
1332 SQ FT
53% OPEN AREAS FLEXIBLE PROGRAMMING
The Mack Lot outdoor community space design incorporates a mix of arts and culture, food, and recreational opportunities to serve a diverse and inclusive community along the Mack Avenue Corridor. The design of the lot is organized to sustain many different types of activities that cater to a multigenerational public. Some of the important features include a central stage for performances, an outdoor seating space for an adjacent cafĂŠ (in The Commons), a long table for community gatherings, and a safe play area for children. The design also includes a series of gardens with colorful plantings that contribute to the onsite management of storm-water and provide seasonal, visual interest. The design also includes easily accessible bike racks at the Mack Avenue entry, and a visually permeable fence that provides access along Mack Avenue, as well as from the back alley (anticipating the organization of food truck parking in the alley in the future.)
4490 SQ FT
Garden 3
LONG TABLE
BIKE RACKS
Garden 2 OPEN AREAS FLEXIBLE PROGRAMMING MAIN ACCESS
Garden 1
ALLEY
MACK AVENUE
SECONDARY ACCESS
PLAY AREA
CAFE AREA
Garden 4 MULTIPURPOSE STAGE
FOOD TRUCKS
FUTURE BUILDING ACCESS
MACC COMMONS 0
MACK Lot
10ft
23
Stage details
1
24
1.
Stage Transversal Section
2.
Stage Longitudinal Elevation
3.
Stage Plan
4.
Detail Canopy
5.
Detail Deck in Cafe area
6.
Detail Stage Platform
2
3
4
6
5
MACK Lot
25
PERSPECTIVES
View from Entry at Mack Avenue
26
View from Alley Entry
MACK Lot
27
28 WEST ELEVATION view toward D&D STORAGE
Back fence and play area
Door to alley
Door to alley
Long table with Garden 3 in the back
Garden 2
Bike racks
ELEVATIONS
NORTH ELEVATION VIEW TOWARD ALLEY
MOVIE PROJECTION
EAST ELEVATION view toward MACC development & THE COMMONS
On street parking
Bike Lane
Sidewalk
Garden 1
Future Door
Deck on seating cafe area
Stage
Garden 4 and play area
MACK AVENUE
Elevation View (left to right shows West Elevation toward D&D Storage, North Elevation toward the alley, and East Elevation toward MACC Development and The Commons)
MACK Lot
29
LANDSCAPE STRATEGY STORMWATER MANAGEMENT The design includes four different gardens in the Mack Lot, all of them addressing different perimeter conditions and access to sunlight and the lack of mechanical irrigation. Across all three gardens, plant species have been selected to provide visual interest (color, texture, seasonal bloom cycles and/or berries) and low maintenance once established. The entry garden, Garden 1, is texturally rich with a continuous, soft border of Japanese forest grass set against a backdrop of colorful ligularia, whose leaves provide a purplish hue and tall bloom spikes of golden yellow. Additionally, Garden 2 defines the corner of the lot with a moderately tall (15-18’ mature height) serviceberry tree and a cluster of sweetfern shrubs and ligularia, which makes a visual connection to the entry. Garden 3 continues along the length of the D&D Storage and provides a visual “green wall” with a mixture of sweetfern and winterberry shrubs. Both shrubs grow into soft forms with a mature height of 4-5’, which will sit below the level of new openings (as a result of the current design work undertaken by the owner) along the D&D Storage building. The winterberry shrubs grow vibrant, red berries that provide color and visual interest throughout the entire winter. Finally, Garden 4 is a rain garden that captures the rain from the stage canopy and provides color and interest for the play area. This is achieved with a line of dwarf blue arctic willows and a mix of other water loving species including ferns, solomon’s seal, and astilbe.
30
Following the new regulatory framework around stormwater management, the City of Detroit will charge a stormwater fee based on the acreage of impervious ground surface that a given site has, at a rate of $750/month for each 1 acre of impervious surface. The Mack Lot measures 0 .19 acres, and if the entire lot were impervious, the charge would be (.19*750) = $142.50 per month. The regulations allow property owners to gain credits, which are based on two forms of measurement: volume and flow, allowing up to an 80% reduction, which in the Mack Lot would result in a monthly fee of $28.50. Additionally, by reducing the amount of impervious surface under 0.02 acres, the lot would be considered exempt from the stormwater fee. In response to these options, the design strategy for the Mack Lot maximizes the pervious ground treatment, keeping only less than 0.02 acres of impervious surface on it (fee exempt). Four ground surface treatments are: pervious gravel, stage (below the .02 acre area), wood deck situated over a pervious surface, and mulch. This way the entire site (except for the planting beds and play area which would be mulch) would be gravel (stabilized with underlay) with a wood deck in the stage and cafe outdoors area.
GARDEN 1
GARDEN 2
A
Japanese forest grass
B
Ligularia
C
Autumn Brilliance Serviceberry
D
Sweetfern
View Garden 1
D
GARDEN 3
View Garden 2
D
E
Winterberry
F
Starry Solomon’s Seal
G
Astilbe chocolate shogun
H
Dwarf Blue Arctic Willow
I
Ostrich Ferm
D
GARDEN 4
MACK Lot
View Garden 3
View Garden 4
31
PLANTING PALETTE 1 2
Garden Zone Code
3 1
A
Botanical Name
Hakonechloa macra ‘all gold’
Common Name
Japanese forestgrass
Plant Typical Typical quantity Persis. Nativity Hardiness height ft width ft
24
5-9
1.5
1.5
Light Type
PSh-Sh
4 1
32
B
Ligularia stenocephala
2
A
Ligularia stenocephala
2
B
2
Ligularia
Ligularia
8
1
0
4-8
4
3
PSh
prefers light afternoon shade prefers light afternoon shade
12
1
0
4-8
4
3
PSh
Amelanchier x grandiflora Autumn Brilliance ‘Autumn Brilliance’ Serviceberry
1
1
1
3-7
20
15
F-PSh
C
Comptonia peregrina
Sweetfern
3
1
2
2-6
3
6
F-PSh
3
A
Comptonia peregrina
Sweetfern
7
1
2
2-6
3
6
F-PSh
3
B
Ilex verticillata
Winterberry
8
1
2
3-9
5
5
F-PSh
4
A
Smilacina stellata
Starry Solomon’s Seal
3
1.5
PSh
4
B
Astilbe ‘chocolate shogun’ Astilbe chocolate shogun
4-8
2
1.5
S-PSh
4
D
Salix purpurea ‘Nana’
4
E
Matteuccia pennsylvanica Ostrich Ferm
Dwarf Blue Arctic Willow
40 24
Details on Light needs
7
1
0
4-8
4
4
F-PSh
4
1
2
3-7
3
5
PSh-Sh
Soil Type
L
L
Soil Soil pH Moisture
N
N
Drought Salt Heat Tolerance Tolerance Tolerance
Plant Form
Plant Texture
Foliage Color
Fall Color
Bloom Time
Bloom Color
YG
Jl-Aug
YG
MW
Prefers consistent moisture; poor drainage OK
E
M
DG
Jl
Y
MW
Prefers consistent moisture; poor drainage OK
E
M
DG
Jl
Y
Tolerant of a somewhat wide range of conditions
A
W
L,S,C
AC
M
S,L,C
AC
S,L,C L,S,C
Fruit Color
F
Pr
Winter Wildlife Form Value
ST
V
M
MG
D
4
ST
R
C
MG,DG
Ap-My
Y-G
Bf
AC
D
4
ST
R
C
MG,DG
Ap-My
Y-G
Bf
AC
MW
Tolerant of poorly drained soils
R
M
DG
Jn
W
DMW
Likes moist conditions
2
R
F
BG
A-My
Y
M
soils should never dry out
0
E,I
F
MG
N
MACK Lot
ST
R,Y,O
Fruit Type
2
L,S,C AC-ALK L
Details on Soil Moisture needs
Y
My-Jn
F
R
A,S
Bd
F
Bd
B
B, Bf
A,S
33
sun studies
JANUARY
FEBRUARY
MARCH
APRIL
MAY
JUNE
JULY
AUGUST
SEPTEMBER
OCTOBER
NOVEMBER
DECEMBER
0
34
Kilowatt hours per meter2 , per month
175
MACK Lot
35
Programmatic opportunities THE SOCIAL LANDSCAPE OF LOCAL ORGANIZATIONS
The Mack Lot can be activated with a mix of anchoring and flexible elements that support different activities over the course of the year. Whether it is a summer movie screening or performance, or fall culinary events, the lot’s urban furniture can be configured as needed. This flexibility also allows for a variety of uses (play, rest, study, entertainment) and for users to coexist. The MACC Outdoor Commons can be a place for many types of events, performances, and gatherings of friends and family. The types of events and regular activities of the lot must come from what neighbors would like to see and support. This lot can serve as a node in the creative network of Detroit, one that supports freedom of expression as well as conversation about the future. The next page illustrates some of the events and activities discussed with members of the community during the public input sessions. The suggested activities reflect the desire to connect to already well-established, city-wide events, and offer ideas for new programs to better serve the surrounding neighborhood members.
STORYTELLING/ ORAL HISTORY DETROIT 1967 ORAL HISTORY PROJECT DETROIT STORYTELLING
DETROIT SOUND CONSERVANCY
MICHIGAN STORYTELLING
DETROIT ASSOCIATION OF BLACK STORYTELLERS MACC LITERACY PROJECT
INSIDE OUT DETROIT
MUSIC AND PERFORMANCE DETROIT MUSIC HISTORY
MOVEMENT
DETROIT DANCE CITY SUMMER STAGE DALLY IN THE ALLEY(S) FREEP FILM FEST
THE commons PROGRAMMING
FOOD FIELD DETROIT
as a way to help imagine the
CITY COMMON CSA
and the activities you’d like to
DILLA DAY
PARADISE VALLEY FESTIVAL
FOOD AND FAMILY
We invite you to use this board Lot over the course of a year,
CULINARY ARTS EVENT OPEN STREETS DETROIT
DETROIT AGRICULTURE
BETTER BLOCK DETROIT
GREENING OF DETROIT
participate in. Add community events or Detroit area events to build the number of potential host or co-sponsor. Complete
DETROIT JAZZ FESTIVAL
URBAN ORGANIC FEST
DETROIT MUSIC MAGAZINE
opportunities for the Lot to
36
TRANS ORAL HISTORY PROJECT
VISUAL ARTS MACK ART ALIVE HEIDELBERG one313 WORKSHOP
a weekly activities sheet to
PEWABIC CERAMICS
illustrate the weekly events you
MURALS IN THE MARKET
would enjoy attending.
ART FAIR
CITY SCULPTURE
COMMUNITY SPECIFIC AND CITY WIDE EVENT CALENDAR MACC BASKETBALL
ON GOAL
MACC VOLLEYBALL
MACC LITERACY PROJECT
MACC LITERACY PROJECT
MONDAY
TUESDAY
KWANZAA HANUKKAH
52
51
50
49
CHRISTMAS 48
47
THANKSGIVING 46
45
44
43
42
41
40
39
Detroit wide event
PARADE
BIONEERS CONFERENCE HALLOWEEN
national festivity
december
november
october
FALL september
august
july
DxD
DETROIT BIKES
LABOR DAY 38
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
DALLY IN THE ALLY
37
SIDEWALK FEST REDFORD
JULY 4th 27
DxD
ANGELS’ NIGHT
DETROIT JAZZ FESTIVAL
Weekly activities IN THE COMMONS... SUNDAY
DxD
SUMMER june
may
april
AFRICAN WORLD FESTIVAL
36
SOLSTICE 22
19
18
17
16
15
RAMADAN
DETROIT DESIGN FESTIVAL
OPEN STREETS DETROIT
ARAB & CHALDEAN WORLD FESTIVAL
SPRING march
february
14
13
12
11
10
09
08
07
06
05
04
03
DxD
CONCERT OF COLORS
DETROIT RIVER DAYS
MEMORIAL DAY
DxD
PARADISE VALLEY MUSIC FESTIVAL
ALLIED MEDIA CONFERENCE
FLOWER DAY EASTERN MARKET
MOTHERS DAY
DxD
26
JACKIE ROBINSON DAY
WINTER january
BELLE ISLE KITE FESTIVAL
MLK
02
01
WEEK
DxD
25
TIGERS OPENING DAY
PACZKI DAY
MLK
NEW YEAR’S
DxD
24
DxD
21
DxD
20
DxD
DRINKS X DESIGN
MOVEMENT ELECTRONIC MUSIC FESTIVAL
23
DILLA DAY
community / neighborhood wide
WHAT would you like TO do HERE? WEDNESDAY
THURSDAY
FRIDAY
SATURDAY
12:00 2:00 4:00
YOGA CLASSES
YOGA CLASSES
READING CLUB CULINARY EVENT
CHURCH COMMUNITY MEETING
DANCE CLASSES
DANCE CLASSES
YOGA CLASSES
READING CLUB YOGA CLASSES
DANCE CLASSES CHILDREN’S ACTIVITIES
CHILDREN’S ACTIVITIES
MORNING
CHILDREN’S ACTIVITIES
READING CLUB YOGA CLASSES
DANCE CLASSES
LOCAL FESTIVAL: MUSIC AND FOOD
DANCE CLASSES
AFTERNOON
10:00
6:00
AFTERNOON
8:00
MORNING
6:00
10:00
MOVIE NIGHT !
MACK Lot
CONCERT
EVENING
8:00
10:00 12:00 2:00 4:00 6:00
EVENING
6:00
8:00
8:00 10:00
37
OUTDOOR furniture AND PLAY COMPONENTS
The furniture selection for the Mack Lot balances custom fabrication with commercially available products. This is done to provide a mixture of materials and colors as well as allowing for a flexible rearrangement of some of the furniture elements. The customized bench and table utilize cedar for their construction which will turn into a silver tone as it weathers in place over time. The tables and benches will be arranged on the site in a long line to allow for anything from a large communal meal to individual sitting space. These components will be heavy enough to discourage everyday movement but can be relocated for special events. Commercial chairs were selected that can stack and be moved in and out of the site each day, as well as provide color. Commercially available tables were also chosen to provide some flexibility of daily organization; they can be paired with benches or chairs in many combinations. The bike racks are simple “U” loops and will be located on the Mack Avenue side of the entry fence. The bike racks shown are fabricated by a Michigan-based business, Cycle Safe. Finally, the play area is tucked in a quiet corner of the lot. The ground surface will be 12” of wood chip playground mulch and will site a two-seat swing set and a sandbox.
FRAME COVER
Customized Bench / Table - Cedar Wood Sections
Bench Material only 8’ x 17” x 17” Piece dimension sides 1” x 4” x 1’5” top 1”’x 4” x 1’5” frame 2” x 8” x 8’ frame 2” x 8” x 1’1” legs 2” x 8” x 10” Total Cost
Table Material only 8’ x 3’ x 3’ Qty -10 -24 -02 -03 -04
$120 - $130.00
Piece dimension sides 1” x 4” x 3’ top 1”’x 4” x 3’ frame 2” x 8” x 8’ frame 2” x 8” x 2’6” legs 2” x 8” x 2’4” Total Cost
Qty -18 -24 -02 -03 -04 $207.00
Cover
Framing
ONLINE PRICES
38
Primary Bipod Swing Set 8’ H Top Rail Two Seats, one bay www.school outfitters.com $645.99 + shipping
MACK Lot
Table+2 benches, gray, Table (length 63”, width 39 3/8”, height 29 1/2”) $325.00
OUTDOOR CHAIRS
OUTDOOR BENCH/ TABLES
http://cyclesafe.com
SAND BOX
BIKE RACKS SWING SET
CycleSafe, Inc. 5211 Cascade Rd. SE, Suite 210 Grand Rapids, Michigan 49546 Phone: 616-954-9977
Hop Side Chair $ 78.99
Primary Bipod Swing Set 8’ H Top Rail Two Seats, one bay www.school outfitters.com $645.99 + shipping
39
budget: MACK LOT Qty
U/M
Description
Per Unit Cost
0.19 24.00 22.22 8175 305
acre cuyd cuyd sqft lin.ft
Regrade site slope and compact top layer to prepare for COREgravel installation per mfg specifications$14,418.53 Soil amendment - Plant mix $85.00 Hardwood Bark Mulch 6" Thick $70.00 COREgravel 50-35HDÂŽ * price on website includes estimate for gravel $2.90 Aluminum edging $6.00
Total
Cost reference
$2,739.52 $2,040.00 $1,555.56 $23,707.50 $1,830.00
14 1 1 2 1
Site work
subtotal
$31,872.58
Planting Materials 24 20 1 10 8 40 24 7 4 32
#1 size 2 gallon 10' clump 3 gallon 1-2' #1 size #1 size 3 gallon #1 size hr
Hakonechloa macra 'all gold' (Japanese forestgrass) Ligularia stenocephala (Ligularia 'Little Rocket') Amelanchier x grandiflora 'Autumn Brilliance' (10' Serviceberry, 3 stakes) Comptonia peregrina (Sweetfern) Ilex verticillata (Winterberry) Smilacina stellata (Solomon's Seal) Astilbe 'chocolate shogun' Salix purpurea 'Nana' (Dwarf blue arctic willow) Matteuccia pennsylvanica (Ostrich fern) Landscape Labor (planting and mulch spreading)
$8.00 $15.00 $484.00 $30.00 $5.75 $8.00 $5.00 $30.00 $7.00 $24.76
subtotal
$192.00 $300.00 $484.00 $300.00 $46.00 $320.00 $120.00 $210.00 $28.00 $792.32
3 5 1 5 4 3 3 5 3 11
$2,792.32
Deck (16'-4" x 40' dimension) 8 38 224 20.7 6 152 2 32
footing board board cuyd sqft 5 lb unit 5 gallon hr
8" diameter, concrete pier footings, 48" deep 2" x 10"x16' pressure treated lumber 1"x 4" x 10' Tacoma cedar boards Removal of soil Corten Steel retaining edge (1/4" x 12") Stainless stl deck nails Deck joist tie Sealer Carpentry Labor
$220.00 $20.11 $5.48 $95.00 $39.95 $2.60 $149.00 $45.29
subtotal
$1,760.00 $764.18 $1,227.52 $1,966.50 $500.00 $239.70 $395.20 $298.00 $1,449.28
$8,600.38
Outdoor Furniture 16
40
chair
Hop Side Chair
$79.00
$1,264.00
9 6 6 1 15
11
4 8 8
unit unit unit
Ikea Falster (702.405.77) Table Bike racks Custom Cedar Long Tables + Benches
$175.00 $70.00 $500.00
subtotal
$700.00 $560.00 $4,000.00
$6,524.00
Stage 2 5 30 30 50 29 8 5 116 504 168 8 10 120 24
column column lin.ft lin.ft board board 5 lb 5 lb unit board board
Stainless steel 3" OD x 2.5" ID x .250" Wall Tube @ 11' length Stainless steel 2" OD x 1.5" ID x .250" Wall Tube @ 11' length Architectural grade Laminated Beam 5-1/8" x 21 Architectural grade Laminated Beam 5-1/8" x 21 2" x 10"x 20' SPF lumber 2" x 10" x 16' pressure treated lumber Stainless stl trim nails Stainless stl deck nails Deck joist tie 1" x 4" x 10' Tacoma Rough Cedar Tongue & Groove siding 1"x 4" x 10' Tacoma cedar boards Welded cross bracing, stainless steel rod unit Footings 5 gallon Sealer hr Carpentry Labor hr Metals Labor
$800.00 $500.00 $32.33 $7.56 $23.10 $20.11 $39.95 $39.95 $2.60 $14.91 $5.48 $200.00 $149.00 $45.29 $49.44
subtotal
$1,600.00 $2,500.00 $969.90 $226.80 $1,155.00 $583.19 $319.60 $199.75 $301.60 $7,514.64 $920.64 $3,000.00 $1,600.00 $1,490.00 $5,434.80 $1,186.56
7 7 6 6 6
6
11 11
$29,002.48
Play Area 24.9 24.9 4 1 1 16 8 8 subtotal
cuyd cuyd unit unit unit hr hr hr
Removal of soil 12" Depth Play mulch Footings Swing Set- Primary Bipod Swing Set - 8' H Top Rail, Two Seats, One Bay Sand Box Swing Set and Sandbox Installation Labor Landscape Labor (mulch spreading) Landscape Labor (site excavation)
$95.00 $70.00 $200.00 $850.00 $300.00 $24.76 $24.76 $28.98
$2,365.50 $1,743.00 $800.00 $850.00 $300.00 $396.16 $198.08 $231.84
1 1 9 8 11 11 11
$6,884.58
Fence
MACK Lot
41
Play Area 24.9 24.9 4 1 1 16 8 8
cuyd cuyd unit unit unit hr hr hr
Removal of soil 12" Depth Play mulch Footings Swing Set- Primary Bipod Swing Set - 8' H Top Rail, Two Seats, One Bay Sand Box Swing Set and Sandbox Installation Labor Landscape Labor (mulch spreading) Landscape Labor (site excavation)
$95.00 $70.00 $200.00 $850.00 $300.00 $24.76 $24.76 $28.98
$2,365.50 $1,743.00 $800.00 $850.00 $300.00 $396.16 $198.08 $231.84
1 1 9 8 11 11 11
$6,884.58
subtotal
Fence 330 240 48
6' board 1x6 S4S Select Western Red Cedar Boards lin.ft 3" Galv x 11 gauge Square Tubing (Fence Posts) Hardware and Fasteners (for Gate and Connections) hr Ironworker Labor (75% Level)
$22.46 $5.23 $29.05
$7,411.80 $1,255.20 $800.00 $1,394.40
6 10 11
$10,861.40
subtotal
Mural Commission and Installation fee for Mural Artist
$5,000.00
$5,000.00
subtotal
Outdoor Infrastructure installation of outdoor hose bib installation of outdoor outlet for stage
$500.00 $500.00
$1,000.00
subtotal
Construction Documentation + Administration 8
%
Fee set at 8% of overall project budget ($120,000) Structural Engineering Consultation re: Stage Fees and Permits for Construction
$9,600.00 $1,000.00 $380.00
12
$10,980.00
subtotal
Inflation Costs Time and Materials 4.85
%
Estimated inflation of price of labor and materials of $120,000 project
$5,820.00
$5,820.00 Contingency 10 subtotal
%
10% Contingency of overall project budget ($120,000) based on US General Services Admin Rates
$12,000.00
$12,000.00
TOTAL
$131,337.74
42
13
1
2
Superior Scape, Inc 51989 Schoenherr Road Shelby Township, MI 586-739-9630 CoreGravel.CA http://www.coregravel.ca/site/assets/files/1016/core_gravel_design_install_guide.pdf COREgravel
3
Twixwood Wholesale Nursery http://www.twixwood.com/ http://avail.sbinursery.com/LiveInventory.aspx
4
Cold Stream Farm Free Soil, MI www.coldstreamfarm.net
5
Lodi Farms Ann Arbor, MI lodifarms.com
6
Fingerle Lumber Summer 2016 Price Catalog Ann Arbor, MI
7
Speedy Metals www.speedymetals.com Livonia MI
8
School Outfitters www.schooloutfitters.com includes shipping estimate
9
Regional Concrete www.regionalconcretellc.com Battle Creek, MI
10
MACK 11
American Fence & Supply Co https://afence.com/store/Galvanized-Square-Tubing/ Lot
State of Michigan 2016 Prevailing Wage Rates for State Funded Projects
5
Lodi Farms Ann Arbor, MI lodifarms.com
6
Fingerle Lumber Summer 2016 Price Catalog Ann Arbor, MI
7
Speedy Metals www.speedymetals.com Livonia MI
8
School Outfitters www.schooloutfitters.com includes shipping estimate
9
Regional Concrete www.regionalconcretellc.com Battle Creek, MI
10
American Fence & Supply Co https://afence.com/store/Galvanized-Square-Tubing/
11
State of Michigan 2016 Prevailing Wage Rates for State Funded Projects Wayne County http://www.michigan.gov/documents/lara/Wayne_536398_7.pdf
12
City of Detroit Buildings and Safety Engineering Department Fee Schedule http://www.detroitmi.gov/Portals/0/docs/Permits/BSEED/Construction/FEE%20SCHEDULE%20%20REVISED%204-1-13.pdf
13
U.S. General Services Administration Office of the Chief Architect Project Estimating Requirements for the Public Buildings Service https://www.gsa.gov/portal/mediaId/170507/fileName/P_120.action
14
County of Fairfax, Virginia Department of Public Works and Services 2016 Comprehensive Unit Price Schedule, Land Development Services http://www.fairfaxcounty.gov/dpwes/publications/unit-price-schedule.pdf
15
Corten.com http://www.corten.com/request-quote-sent.html?conv=1
43
44
acknowledgments Annie Duerr Anthony K. Moore Ashly Psalms Bernadine Martin Bethany Martin Brandy Chirco Bryon Rossi Carlton Davis Carolyn Davis Carrie Hartz Cathy Minter Charles Johns Chester S. Mylenek Chris Cain Christopher Williams Cle Sims Colette Eby Colleen Donaldson D’Hasson Taylor Damon Mattison Sr. Danell Wilson Danna Reyes Deacon Chris Rabaut Dearie Smith De’borah Joaces Derrell White Dominique Peacock Donald Marchese Jr. Donna Givens E.A. Guice Elizabeth Royal Erika Linenfelser
Ezra Stevenson Geneva Guice Ginny Hui Grace Johns Greg Montgomery Hunter Moore Ian McCain Jacob Wesorick James Martin James Savage Jaylin Harris Jazzimine O’neal Jeanine Hatcher Jeffrey Nolish Joel Stahl Johnny Hui Jonathan Demers Jonathan Royal Jonathan Starks Joseph Brennan Joshua Eby Justin Mast Kahlilia Davis Kaitlyn Meister Kevin King Kiearra D. Scruggs Kimberly Buffington Larry Hill Laura Demers Lawrence Robinson Ldelle Stevenson Leon Stevenson
Marceanna Bell Marie Thompson Marlena Williamson Mattie Goshea Michael Feng Michael Swafford Michelle Smith Milana King Nate Egger Nicole Justian Peter Deucher Ron Norwood Ron Omilian Sandra Stahl Scott Munekawa Shaina Davidson Shayla Shuck Sheena Gowens Shiloh Stevenson Sneha Wesorick Thomas Ronds Tiffany Orr Toyia Watts Tristan Ragins Tyler Ford Tynae Ishmael Tyress Taylor Tyrone Morton Tyronne Harris Victoria Coleman Z’Aaliyah White Zandra Richardson
Thank you to all who participated in the development of the Mack Lot! MACK Lot
45