www.browncountypress.com
CMYK
CMYK
THE BROWN COUNTY PRESS Serving Brown County, Ohio since 1973
Vol. 38 No. 21
Sunday, January 2, 2011
Tincher murder trial begins BY Wayne Gates The Brown County Press The murder trial of Dallas Tincher is underway. Jury selection began at 9 a..m. on Monday, Dec. 27,and was completed by 1:30 p.m. Nine women and three men will decide Tincher’s guilt or innocence. Two women and one man were picked as alternate jurors. After receiving instructions not to discuss the case with each other or any friends or family members,
the jurors were dismissed for the day. Following the dismissal of the jury, Tincher attorney Gary Rosenhoffer said that the defense was willing to stipulate to the fact that Carpenter was murdered and that they objected to the admission of photographs of Carpenter’s body and of the crime scene. “Those can only serve to the jury”, inflame Rosenhoffer told visiting Judge Thomas Nurre. Nurre said that the state was not bound by the stipulation of the defense and
ruled in favor of Prosecuting Attorney Jessica Little. This means that Little can introduce the photographs as well as testimony from medical experts regarding Carpenter’s death. The jury returned Tuesday morning for a tour of the crime scene off Stringtown Road in Aberdeen where Carpenter was shot, allegedly by Joseph Hensley at Tincher’s direction. The jurors were taken to other locations involved in the crime and investigation as well. At press time, opening
arguments were scheduled to begin on Wednesday. The first witnesses in the trial would be called after opening arguments are complete. Hensley and his girlfriend, Sarah Clemens, are both listed as possible witnesses in the Tincher trial. If Hensley testifies, it will fulfill his part of a plea bargain discussed with Little that will lead to a sentence of 15 years to life in prison. Clemens is also expected to testify in exchange for a lighter sentence for her involvement in the case.
The Brown County Press/FILE PHOTO
Dallas Tincher (right) and attorney Gary Rosenhoffer.
Murder for hire case is top story for 2010 BY Wayne Gates The Brown County Press
The Brown County Press/WAYNE GATES
Rick Eagan takes the oath of office from Rep. Jean Schmidt. From left are Fr. Dohrman Byers, Tiffany Eagan, Eagan, Margaret Eagan (partially hidden) Schmidt and Common Please Judge Scott Gusweiler. Son Scott Eagan was not able to attend because of work commitments as a paramedic.
Rick Eagan sworn in for county commission BY Wayne Gates The Brown County Press Newly elected Brown County Commissioner Rick Eagan was sworn into office on Sunday, Dec. 26. The oath was administered by 2nd District Congressional Representative Jean Schmidt. About 40 people witnessed the ceremony, including members of Eagan’s family, Common Pleas Judge Scott Gusweiler and State Representative Danny Bubp. For many at the ceremony the swearing in represented achieving a goal that Eagan said began four years ago, but was nearly derailed by Eagan’s
horrific accident in November of 2009. Eagan suffered severe injuries, including an eventual leg amputation below the knee and was intensive care for months after being struck by a car while he was outside his vehicle after hitting a deer. Eagan drew a sympathetic laugh from the crowd as the swearing in began, saying “I can’t raise my right hand because it’s full of metal”. He then went on to repeat the oath of office. After the swearing in, Eagan told those assembled “Thank you for coming and thank you for your support, I couldn’t have done it without you.”
He added later that “I feel very special to have the friends and family that I have.” Others at the ceremony echoed the theme of recovery over adversity. A visibly emotional Margaret Eagan, Rick’s wife, said “It’s impossible to put into words” when asked to describe how she felt. “God is on our side and I always knew he could do it”, she added. Schmidt echoed those sentiments in remarks to the crowd. “Nobody has fought harder than Rick to be here today”, she said. “Without faith in the Lord, CONTINUED ON PAGE 9
2010 was a big year for news in Brown County. Here is a look back at the top ten stories of the year. 1. Dallas Tincher and Joseph Hensley murder cases. This story is still in the news as Tincher’s trial is currently underway. Tincher is charged with hiring Hensley to kill John Carpenter of Aberdeen for 900 dollars and a four wheeler. The twists and turns of the case have included a fight over the testimony of an elderly witness, both defendants facing the death penalty and later having it dropped, and a plea deal for Hensley that included some controversial conditions for his testimony against Tincher. The latest twist was Brown County Prosecutor Jessica Little filing a motion before the Ohio Supreme Count to have Common Pleas Judge Scott Gusweiler removed from the case for alleged bias against the prosecution. Gusweiler filed a response
simultaneously denying the bias and voluntarily withdrawing from the case. Hensley is expected to testify against Tincher in exchange for a plea deal. If he does not testify, his trial is set for next March. 2. An attacker attempts to kill two Mt. Orab Police Officers. On the morning of Jan. 3,
2010, 61 year old George Ruby shot Mt. Orab Police Officer Justin Conley in the back as he left the police station about 4 a.m.. Conley was saved by the bullet resistant vest he was wearing. Conley ran for cover and the attack set off a gun battle between Ruby, Conley and Mt. CONTINUED ON PAGE 9
Merchants Bank in Higginsport robbed again BY Wayne Gates The Brown County Press Merchant’s National Bank in Higginsport was robbed for the second time in two months on Tuesday, Dec. 28. Brown County The Sheriff’s Office said a man walked into the bank shortly before 9 a.m., implied he had a gun and demanded money. Investigators did not release the amount of cash taken. The following was released
by the Brown County Sheriff’s Office in a press release: “Sheriff Wenninger reports that on December 28, 2010, at 8:40AM, the merchant’s Bank in Higginsport was robbed. A lone male suspect produced a note demanding money, and implied he had a weapon. The suspect was described as a white male 5 feet to 5feet 6 inches tall, with a skinny build. He was wearing a dark CONTINUED ON PAGE 9
B R O A D S H E E T O D D
RULH board questions decision to accept ‘Race to the Top’ grant money BY Martha Jacob The Brown County Press The Ripley-Union-LewisHuntington Local School District Board of Education spent a lot of time discussing its decision to apply for ‘Race to the Top’ grant funds during its Dec. 21 meeting. Superintendent Charles Birkholtz told the board that he
still had a lot of questions about strings that may be attached to the funds that keep showing up. “There are things about this 4-year, $204,000 ‘Race to the Top’ grant that I didn’t realize at the time when we applied for it,” Birkholtz said. “One of the major things I’ve been trying to figure out are all these new requirements for our district. It’s always interesting
when you’re dealing with the federal government. They sort of drop things on you in bits and pieces.” Birkholtz said he is especially concerned over the labor intensive teacher and principal evaluations, required every year of the program. “I’ve been having some serious discussions with Wesley CONTINUED ON PAGE 9
BY Martha Jacob The Brown County Press With her usual grace and a smile on her face, Brown County Commission President
CMYK
Index Classifieds..........Page 16 Court News......Page 13 Death Notices.........Page 7 Education ..........Page 6 Opinion ..............Page 4 Social..................Page 6 Sports .......Pages 11, 12
Where to find us www.browncountypress.com Phone (937) 444-3441 Fax (937) 444-2652 219 South High St. Mt. Orab, OH 45154 bcpress@frognet.net
Sun Group NEWSPAPERS
Margery Paeltz was the guest of honor at a recent send off to say goodbye after serving the county for the past four years. “It has been my privilege to serve Brown County these last four years,” Paeltz said. “I remember when I first began my term, in 2007, I did a lot of listening and felt like I had a lot to learn. “But one thing I am very proud of is when we saw that revenues were not really going up, we planned for the future and were able to put back over $720,000 which we put in the capital improvement fund.” “We were able to leave those funds this year when we really needed them and they had climbed to over $1.2 million. We were able to help Brown County General Hospital as well as balance the budget.” Paeltz said that throughout her term she and her fellow commissioners have had to make many tough decisions, CONTINUED ON PAGE 9
CMYK
Community says good-bye to commissioner Margery Paeltz
The Brown County Press/RITCHIE BUTLER
Lady G-Men crowned 2010 BCT champions The Georgetown Lady G-Men defeated Western and Fayetteville to capture the 2010 Brown County Holiday Tournament title. For full story, see Sports on page 11.