COURSE WORK 2:
SOUTHWARK
URBAN DEVELOPMENT PROCESS CARL STJERNSTRÖM W1449866
Contents 1. DESIGN STATEMENT 6
2. RESPONSE TO CONTEXT 10-11 3. SITE LAYOUT & INDICATIVE BUILDING LAYOUTS
14-24
4. SCALE OF DEVELOPMENT 28-31 5. APPEARANCE OF DEVELOPMENT
34
6. LANDSCAPE & PUBLIC REALM
38-39
7. DENSITY & FINANCIAL APPRAISAL
42-47
1.0 Design Statement
DESIGN STATEMENT The proposal for the redevelopment of the site is underpinned by thorough market research and an in-depth analysis. The findings revealed what would be acceptable to the market and this formed the backbone of the scheme. High rates of rental growth and the continued migration east in London, are the dominant themes for office tenants in the city. Demand currently exceeds supply; the market research also highlighted the preference for high density, single use office space. Therefore, supplying single use, high grade office space in the northern part of the site, where the potential value of commercial office space was identified as being the highest, was prioritised. The premiss of the scheme was to prioritise the supply of office space and residential flats in order to meet demand. The market research revealed a preference for smaller residential flats, with one to three person dwelling units being the most profitable. Through the proposed scheme, the number of smaller residential flats has been carefully considered and limited in order to cater to families’ needs for affordable housing within central London. The supposition is that, if this consideration is not factored in, the redevelopment of the site will fall short of the goals of the The Southwark Plan (Part 1) - SP 17 Housing: All developments should, where appropriate, provide more high quality housing of all kinds, particularly affordable housing. The need for a range of housing opportunities is reiterated throughout The 6
Southwark Plan. The proposed ratio of market housing to affordable housing is in the wider community’s best interest whilst allowing the developer to make a healthy profit through a sufficient supply of smaller residential units to help meet current demand. The Mayor’s design guidance sets out a number of benchmarks, including 10 square metres of open space per child. This benchmark will be exceeded through 3745 square metres of public open space, which will be accessible to all residents within the site, as well as the general public (in addition to the communal outdoor space provided within the residential blocks). Within each residential building, lifts enable access to the fourth floor and above. In addition, there are no more than eight dwellings on a single corridor. Secure cycle storage is provided on the ground floor, located at the corners of the building. The flat sizes satisfy Southwark Council’s Residential design standards: Minimum dwelling size standards. The benchmark of providing 10% wheelchair accessible dwellings is also successfully satisfied. A minimum of five square metres of private open space will be provided. The back to back distances between dwellings are at least 18 metres and the front to front distances are at least 12 metres, where necessary. All new routes within the site have been designed to be overlooked. Multiple tiers of balconies will ensure a sense of safety
through eyes on the street, which is broadly accepted to be one of the most influential design considerations in preventing crime. The scheme may be further earmarked as being of an exceptionally high standard of design through consultation with a licensed SBD (Secured By Design) consultant. Entrances are from public space and clearly identified. The public realm will be of an exceptionally high standard thanks to a lush park and leafy streets that enhance the quality of place. The streets within the site will be shared spaces, ideally with a uniform, durable, high quality ground surface that is free of raised pavements and wide enough to allow the safe, simultaneous movement of pedestrians, cyclists and vehicles alike. Vehicular traffic will be limited within the site, in part thanks to the location of the proposed underground parking at the south of the site, the entrance and exit located just off the moderately heavily trafficked Marshalsea Road. The heights of the new buildings proposed for the site do not exceed eight storeys (the total height of eight storeys will only be realised at the perimeter of the site - Block I). The building heights will be kept under nine storeys within the site so as to respect the height of the perimeter of the site and several key listed buildings within the site. RedCross Cottages are buildings of note and have a historic value that must be respected; the appearance of proposed new buildings within the immediate vicinity of the cottages have been carefully
considered in the design process. Similarly, there are other key historic buildings located outside the perimeter of the site, such as St. George the Martyr. Southwark Council has made its desire to retain its cap on the height of new buildings within the site clear by refusing to accept proposals for high rise buildings in the recent past. If conditions change and, or it is agreed by all parties that higher densities and increased building heights should be realised, the northern part of the site would be best suited to exceeding the height of six to eight storeys suggested by Southwark Council (the high grade office block suggested is six storeys).
2.0 Response to Context
DEFINING THE SITE WHERE IS IT? WIDER CONTEXT The study study area is in the Southwark borough The of London, London, south of the river Thames. It is of surrounded by Union Street to the north, by surrounded Borough High Street to the east, by Marshalsea Borough Road to the south and Southwark Bridge Road Road to the the west. to
For the purposes of the study it will be critical to understand the site both in isolation as well as in the context of the wider borough (where appropriate). For the purpose of clarity, ‘The Site’ boundary is shown in Figure 1.
4
10
FIGURE 1: Site location in context FIGURE 1: Site Location in Context
LOCAL CONTEXT The heights of the new buildings proposed for the site do not exceed eight storeys (the total height of eight storeys will only be realised at the perimeter of the site - Block I). The building heights will be kept under nine storeys within the site so as to respect the height of the perimeter of the site and several key listed buildings within the site. RedCross Cottages are buildings of note and have a historic value that must be respected; the appearance of proposed new buildings within the immediate vicinity of the cottages have been carefully considered in the design process. Similarly, there are other key historic buildings located outside the perimeter of the site, such as St. George the Martyr. Southwark Council has made its desire to retain its cap on the height of new buildings within the site clear by refusing to accept proposals for high rise buildings in the recent past. For example, LDS’ Southwark tower scheme was rejected at inquiry. Lifschutz Davidson Sandiland’s 17 storey student tower project was vetoed following a public inquiry.
The planning inspector rejected developer Helical Bar’s appeal against the local authority’s refusal, which was deemed to cause harm to the Grade II listed St. George the Martyr Church. If conditions change and, or it is agreed by all parties that higher densities and increased building heights should be realised, the northern part of the site would be best suited to exceeding the height of six to eight storeys suggested by Southwark Council (the high grade office block suggested is six storeys).
11
11
3.0 Site Layout and Indicative Building Layouts
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
UNDERGROUND PARKING 1:1000
6m
10m
6m
5m
107m
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
m
7.8
7.4m
6.7m
2850 SQ.M 228 car spaces
LEGEND
high grade office leisure/secondary retail light industrial workshop other commercial use park residential school underground parking
14
BASEMENT 1:2500
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
71m
9.1m
5m
6.5m
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
A
B C
D
F G
E
H PARK
LEGEND
high grade office
3
1 I
leisure/secondary retail light industrial workshop
2
other commercial use park residential school underground parking
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
GROUND FLOOR 1:2500
15
LEGEND
high grade office leisure/secondary retail light industrial workshop other commercial use park residential school underground parking
16
1ST FLOOR 1:2500
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
LEGEND
high grade office leisure/secondary retail light industrial workshop other commercial use park residential school underground parking
2ND FLOOR 1:2500
17
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
LEGEND
high grade office leisure/secondary retail light industrial workshop other commercial use park residential school underground parking
18
3RD FLOOR 1:2500
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
LEGEND
high grade office leisure/secondary retail light industrial workshop other commercial use park residential school underground parking
4TH FLOOR 1:2500
19
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
LEGEND
high grade office leisure/secondary retail light industrial workshop other commercial use park residential school underground parking
20
5TH FLOOR 1:2500
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
LEGEND
high grade office leisure/secondary retail light industrial workshop other commercial use park residential school underground parking
6TH FLOOR 1:2500
21
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
LEGEND
high grade office leisure/secondary retail light industrial workshop other commercial use park residential school underground parking
22
7TH FLOOR 1:2500
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
RESIDENTIAL BLOCKS 1:1000
BLOCK F
BLOCK G
51m
BLOCK I
31m 13m
BLOCK E
51m
36m
30m 92m
52m 32m 21m
15m
42m
TYPICAL FLOOR
TYPICAL FLOOR
TYPICAL FLOOR
TYPICAL FLOOR
GROUND FLOOR
GROUND FLOOR
GROUND FLOOR
GROUND FLOOR
RESIDENTIAL
DISTRIBUTION
VERTICAL CIRCULATION TECHNICAL SPACE ACCESS TO BUILDING ACCESS TO UNIT
23
RESIDENTIAL DWELLING TYPES 1:1000
BLOCK F
BLOCK G
BLOCK I
TYPICAL FLOOR
TYPICAL FLOOR
TYPICAL FLOOR
TYPICAL FLOOR
GROUND FLOOR
GROUND FLOOR
GROUND FLOOR
GROUND FLOOR
BLOCK E-G FLAT SIZES (SQ.M)
1b2p: 50 or 53 or 57 or 60
BLOCK E
2b3p: 62 or 64 or 67 2b4p: 70 3b4p: 74 or 82 - 85 4b5p: 92 4b6p: 102 or 111 or 120 *satisfies Southwark Council's Residential design standards: Minimum dwelling size standards
BLOCK I FLAT SIZES (SQ.M)
1b2p: 42 or 50 - 55 2b3p: 63 or 67 2b4p: 70 3b4p: 74 or 80 or 83 4b5p: 4b6p: 112 - 113 *satisfies Southwark Council's Residential design standards: Minimum dwelling size standards
BLOCK I HOUSE SIZES (SQ.M)
3b4p: 128 - 167 *satisfies Southwark Council's Residential design standards: Minimum dwelling size standards
DISTRIBUTION
VERTICAL CIRCULATION TECHNICAL SPACE
24
ACCESS TO BUILDING ACCESS TO UNIT
4.0 Scale of Development
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
A
B C
D
F G
E
H PARK
LEGEND
high grade office
3
1 I
leisure/secondary retail light industrial workshop
2
other commercial use park residential school underground parking
28
GROUND FLOOR 1:2500
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
3D MASSING
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
RESIDENTIAL BLOCKS SECTIONS 1:500
A
47m
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
BLOCK E SECTION A-A
92m
24m
B
B
BLOCK F SECTION B-B
24m
31m
BLOCK G 29
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
18m
A
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
DISTANCE BETWEEN BUILDINGS
A
19m
16m
18m
17m
31m
A
high grade office
BUILDING HEIGHTS
leisure/secondary retail light industrial workshop other commercial use
residential
15m
24m
18m
12m
park
school underground parking
SOUTHWARK BRIDGE RD
BLOCK E
BLOCK F
BLOCK G
BOROUGH HIGH ST
SITE SECTION A-A 1:1250
30
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
LEGEND
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
DISTANCE BETWEEN BUILDINGS
B
17m
12m
17m
67m
B
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
high grade office
BUILDING HEIGHTS
leisure/secondary retail light industrial workshop other commercial use
24m
9m
6m
18m
park residential school underground parking
SITE SECTION SOUTHWARK ST
UNION ST
BLOCK F
MARSHALSEA RD
SITE SECTION B-B 1:1250 PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
LEGEND
31
5.0 Appearance of Development
1
2
3
4
5
6
PROPOSED CHARACTER
34
1 Interior: Devas Street, Bromley-By-Bow - Allies & Morrison 4 Balconies: Devas Street, Bromley-By-Bow - Allies & Morrison
2 Balconies providing views and overlooking public spaces 5 Balconies: Brentford Lock West - Duggan Morris Architects
3 Balconies: Devas Street, Bromley-By-Bow - Allies & Morrison 6 Unique, modest brick facades to add character
6.0 Landscape and Public Realm
2500
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
250 1500
2000
250 1800
700 1800
125
1600 125
2000 450
4000 12500
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK EDUCATIONAL PRODUCT
38
SHARED STREET SECTION 1:50
7
8
9
10
11
12
PROPOSED CHARACTER
7 Devas Street, Bromley-By-Bow - Allies & Morrison 6 Shared space, Brighton - Gehl Architects
8 Brandon House - Allies & Morrison 11 Public park to promote health
9 Liverpool Street East urban realm design - Mott MacDonald 12 Promoting safe cycling
39
7.0 Density and Financial Appraisal
SITE AREAS AND VARIATIONS Site areas up to road centre lines: Main site bounded by Borough High Street, Union St, Marshalsea Road Ayres St Site (petrol station and 11-29 Ayres Street) Union St to Southwark Street assuming all cleared
See map for locations 1 2 3 4 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Bldg footprin Storeys t Groups of buildings: (approx) (ave'd) Uses 27-41 Union Street (31-37 Listed) 1 210 office 3 Union St Club 280 office 3 57-59 Union St (59 Listed) 300 office 2 61-65 Union St & Ayres St (61 Ltd) 1 200 office and pub 3 Redcross Cottages Listed 400 resi 12 houses 2 Church Hall 200 community 2 Quilp-Dorrit Street 680 resi and retail 3 Monarch Flats triangle 190 resi 8 flats 5 Disney Street 1 020 office and resi 5 Disney Place 800 office and resi 4 155-168 Borough High St 375 office and retail 5 134-154 Borough High St 670 office and retail 5 106-132 Borough High St 1 650 office and retail 5 100 Borough High St 405 office 6 Union St bldg 680 office 2
5,2 hectares 0,24 0,97 6,41 hectares
Floor Yield Total area Floor Value Value where Value of Value of Total lost floor non area non resi resi £/ applicabl non area resi resi £/ sqm sqm e residential residential value £ 3630 3630 £380 6,50% £21 221 538 £21 221 538 840 840 £380 6,50% £4 910 769 £4 910 769 600 600 £380 6,50% £3 507 692 £3 507 692 3600 1200 £300 7,00% £5 142 857 £5 142 857 800 800 £8 000 £0 £6 400 000 £6 400 000 400 400 £0 £0 estimate £1 000 000 2040 200 2520 £300 £8 000 6,50% £923 077 £20 160 000 £21 083 077 950 950 £8 000 £0 £7 600 000 £7 600 000 5100 1000 4100 £380 6,50% £5 846 154 £0 £5 846 154 3200 800 2400 £380 £8 000 6,50% £4 676 923 £19 200 000 £23 876 923 1875 1875 £380 6,50% £10 961 538 £10 961 538 3350 3350 £380 6,50% £19 584 615 £19 584 615 8250 8250 £380 6,50% £48 230 769 £48 230 769 2430 2430 £380 6,00% £15 390 000 £15 390 000 1360 1360 £380 6,00% £8 613 333 £8 613 333 38425 sqm Current Value of buildings in the site area £203 369 267 Current Site Value
£31 726 875 per hectare Current Plot Ratio 1: 0,60
42
Building areas and uses BLOCK A B C D E F G H I
EXISTING BUILDINGS RETAINED
27-41 Union Street Union Street Club 57-59 Union Street 61-65 Union Street & Ayres Street Redcross Cottages (listed) Church Hall Quilp-Dorrit Street
BLDG 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 3
Monarch Flats triangle Disney Street Disney Place
4 5 5 5 6 2
Block:
A B C D E F G H I K
Unit types:
GROSS 0 0 0 0 8 560 19410 9 702 0 11 632 0
Net area (-15%) 0 0 0 0 7 276 16 499 8 247 0 9 887 0 41 908
USE
TOTALS sqm
OFFICE LEISURE/SECONDARY RETAIL LEISURE/SECONDARY RETAIL OFFICE SCHOOL RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL LIGHT INDUSTRIAL WORKSHOP OTHER COMMERCIAL USE RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL LEISURE/SECONDARY RETAIL OFFICE RESIDENTIAL OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE & PUB RESIDENTIAL COMMUNITY RESIDENTIAL RETAIL RESIDENTIAL OFFICE RESIDENTIAL OFFICE RESIDENTIAL OFFICE & RETAIL OFFICE & RETAIL OFFICE & RETAIL OFFICE OFFICE
Net block area:
Use totals
18 942 SITE: 897 SITE: 864 SITE: 2 592 SITE: 2 996 SITE: 8 560 SITE: 19 410 SITE: 9 702 SITE: 609 SITE: 1 827 SITE: 888 SITE: 9 736 underground parking 1 481 3 121 1 008 3 630 SITE: 840 SITE: 600 SITE: 3 600 SITE: 800 SITE: 400 SITE: 2 520 SITE: 200 950 SITE: 1 000 SITE: 4 100 800 SITE: 2 400 1 875 SITE: 3 350 SITE: 8 250 SITE: 2 430 SITE: 1 360 SITE: 121 738
HIGH GRADE
HIGH GRADE FLATS FLATS FLATS E.G. LOW GRADE OFFICE HOUSE – MEWS HOUSE FLATS HIGH GRADE HOUSE – MEWS HOUSE
12 HOUSES
8 FLATS
28 335
Total area of retained non-residential bldgs Existing retained residential total area
as drawn
49 304
49 304
5 5
155-168 Borough High Street 134-154 Borough High Street 106-132 Borough High Street 100 Borough High Street Union Street bldg
Residential mix breakdown for new development:
sqm FLOORSPACE 18 942 897 864 2 592 2 996 8 560 19 410 9 702 609 1 827 888 9 736 1 481 3 121 1 008 3 630 840 600 3 600 800 400 2 520 200 950 1 000 4 100 800 2 400 1 875 3 350 8 250 2 430 1 360 121 738 sqm
STOREYS 6 3 1 3 4 5 6 6 1 3 4 6 1 7 4 3 3 2 3 2 2 3
3 157 299 863 863 748 1 712 3 235 1 617 609 609 3 704 5 852
1 210 280 300 1 200 400 200 680
NEW BUILDINGS 3 242 2 996 609 49 304 24 655 5 852 1 827
LEISURE/SECONDARY RETAIL SCHOOL LIGHT INDUSTRIAL WORKSHOP RESIDENTIAL OFFICE (HIGH GRADE) UNDERGROUND PARKING OTHER COMMERCIAL USE
88 485 incl u/grnd pkg area too
EXISTING RETAINED BLDGS OFFICE (INCL OTHER USE) RESIDENTIAL COMMUNITY RETAIL
27 735 10 770 400 200
190 1 020 800 375 670 1 650 405 680 33 328 sqm
39 105 sq m
10770
sqm
as drawn
sqm Studio
sqm
1 bed
sqm
2 bed
sqm
3 bed
sqm
4 bed
sqm
Mews House
sqm
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 flats 0 afforable
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 44 80 39 0 43 0 206 flats 61,8 afforable
0 0 0 0 2451 4510 2223 0 2188 0
0 0 0 0 24 28 23 0 17 0 92 flats 27,6 afforable
0 0 0 0 1547 1796 1471 0 1144 0
0
0 0 0 0 1252 4687 1585 0 1336 0
0 0 0 0 17 41 20 0 13 0 91
0 0 0 0 1800 4627 2265 0 1462 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1530 0
0 16 59 20 0 17 0
112 flats 33,6 afforable
flats
27,3
Houses
9
Totals
Net area - cross check with Col D 0 *floor areas are totally precise (i.e. Net areas, not gross like above) 0 0 0 7 050 15 620 7 544 0 7 660 gross figure incl mews houses too 0 510 units 37 874 sqm with current mix
afforable
43
PG Urban Design
Spreadsheet B: Detailed Development Appraisal
2015-03-23
Spreadsheet B
Floorspace/units for valuation Non-residential uses
Total value:
Floorspace by use: Retail Leisure or secondary retail Hi grade Office/Commercial Light industrial workshop Other commercial use (low grade office) School Refurbished buildings Total area of retained non-residential bldgs.
Gross: 0 3242 24655 609 1827 2996 0 28335
New gross commercial floor area Residential: all dwellings (add rows for additional dwelling types)
61664
Flats for sale Studios 1-bed flats 2-bed flats 3-bed flats 4-bed+ flats Sub-total
rental value/ sq.m: Net: 0 £ 250,0 2755,7 £ 180,0 20956,75 £ 600,0 517,65 £ 150,0 1552,95 £ 450,0 n/a n/a 0 £ 200,0
Net floor area/unit 0 51 66 80 106
sales value/unit: £ 550 000 £ 600 000 £ 850 000 £ 1 100 000 £ 2 225 000
Gross floor area total: 0 8640 4969 7341 7981 28932
Gross floor area/unit
sales value/unit:
Gross floor area total:
£0 £ 1 475 000 £ 2 000 000 £0
0 1305 0 0 1305 Gross floor area total: 0 3720 2174 3200 3367 12671 25132
sales value/sq.m: £ 4 250 £ 4 250 £ 4 250 £ 4 250
Total no. units: 0 144 64 78 64 350
Houses for sale 2-bed 3-bed 4-bed town house 5-bed+ Sub-total
Total units:
Flats for rent (affordable) Studios 1-bed flats 2-bed flats 3-bed flats 4-bed flats Existing retained residential total area Sub-total
Total units: 0 62 28 34 27 1 152
0 145 0 0 145 Net floor area/unit 0 51 66 80 106 10770 11073
Houses for rent (affordable) 2-bed 3-bed 4-bed Live work units subsidised Sub-total
Total units: 0 0 0 0 0
Gross floor area/unit 0 0 0 0 0
Extras Flats for sale with park view U'ground/sub-basement/garage parking spaces total U'ground/sub-basement/garage parking spaces for sale Total (new dwelling units only)
yield: 6,00% 6,50% 5,00% 9,00% 6,00% n/a 10,0%
0 9 0 0 9
Gross area/parkin units g space 155 228
12,5
228 511
12,5
Affordable housing as proportion of total (by gross floor area)
sales value/sq.m: £ 4 250 £ 4 250 £ 4 250 £ 4 250 £ 4 250 £ 6 375
Gross floor area total: 0 0 0 0 0
Add'l sales value/iunit £ 25 000
£0 £ 7 631 169 £ 251 481 000 £ 862 750 £ 11 647 125 £0 £0
£0 £ 86 400 000 £ 54 400 000 £ 85 800 000 £ 142 400 000 *value based on average from comparitive prices exercise (resi - high)
£0 £ 13 275 000 *value based on average from comparitive prices exercise (resi - high) £0 £0
£0 £ 13 438 500 £ 7 854 000 £ 11 560 000 £ 12 163 500 £ 68 658 750
£0 £0 £0 £0
£ 3 875 000 2850
£ 10 000
55369
£ 2 280 000 £ 773 726 794 45%
44 University of Westminster
2015-03-23
Postfraduate Urban Design
Spreadsheet B: Detailed Development Appraisal
PG Urban Design
Floorspace/units building costs Gross floorspace by use.: Retail Leisure or secondary retail Hi grade Office/Commercial Light industrial workshop Other commercial use (low grade office) Existing non-res buidings retained School Refurb buildings Residential for sale: flats Residential for sale: houses Residential for sale: live-work Affordable housing: flats Affordable houses: houses Existing Residential
Community Facilities: Park Underground/garage parking Total building area and cost
sq.m 0 3242 24655 609 1827 28335 2996 0 28932 1305 0 25132 0 10770
3745 2850 134398
building cost/sq.m
£ 800 £ 1 000 £ 1 900 £ 950 £ 1 450
Total building cost £0 £ 3 242 000 £ 46 844 500 £ 578 550 £ 2 649 150
£ 1 100 £ 500 £ 1 800 £ 1 600 £ 1 300 £ 1 500 £ 1 400
£ 3 295 600 £0 £ 52 077 176 £ 2 088 000 £0 £ 37 697 647 £0
£ 53 £ 750
£ 196 613 *assumes cost of £12.50 psm for turfing + £40 psm for other e.g. Decking/new plants/flower beds in addition to basic landscaping costs for the site £ 2 137 500 £ 150 806 736
45
Residual site value calculation Total value of development
£ 773 726 794
Building costs Infratructure costs and basic landscaping @ 10% Basic landscaping costs @ 5% Additional site treatement Total construction cost anyy additional costs Professional fees @ 12.5%
£ 150 806 736 £ 15 080 674 £ 7 540 337 £0 £ 173 427 746 £ 21 678 468
Contingencies @ 5%
£ 8 671 387
Sub total
£ 203 777 602
Short-term finance @ 8% p.a. (Assumes 2-year development programme) Sub-total Developer's profit (Level of profit depends on perceived risk) Sub-total CIL at £35 psm Agents and selling fees @ 3%
£ 16 302 208 £ 220 079 810 20%
Total development cost Southwark CIL Residual value = total value - total cost Site Area Ha Value/Ha Plot ratio Residential density Residential density (excluding Ayres St and Union St - Southwark St sites)
Density Calculations Residential: Number of habitable rooms / site area in HA thus D = HR/HA Mixed Use: Add to the no of habiatble rooms the non - residential floorspace divided by 27.5 thus density equivalnce is D = (NonR sqm/27.5) + (HR/HA)
46
£ 44 015 962 £ 264 095 772 £ 2 158 240 £ 7 922 873 £ 274 176 885 £ 19 030 746 £ 480 519 163 6,2 *excludes Ayres St site (not part of proposed development) £ 77 879 929 2,18 Gross floor area including those excluded from CIL calc. + existing bdgs, community facilities and residential / Site area X10000 328 *Residential density for new develop only 391 *Residential density for new develop only - Brandon House inspired block not treated as mixed-use *Number of existing dwellings on site not known
Total no. Of HRs within dwelling type (no. Of bedrooms + 1 additional HR)
Dwelling type (no. of bedrooms) 1 2 3 4 Total no. Of HRs - new resi
2 3 4 5
Sum total no. Of bedrooms in dwelling type 206 92 121 91
Approx no. Of HRs - retained resi (est. approx 1/4 of total of new resi floor area) Total no. Of habitable rooms within site
Sum total no. Of HRs 412 276 484 455 1627 406,75 2033,75
*assumes that each dwelling has 1 HR in addition to bedrooms *Kitchens, bathrooms, WCs and circulation space not regarded as HRs
47