Aug. 29, 2012

the butler

Arts, Etc.: Flowers are blooming all over campus. Meet Butler’s green thumbs.

Page 8

VOL. 127 ISSUE 2 ESTABLISHED 1886 INDIANAPOLIS

COLLEGIAN

Sports: How does BU stack up academically in the A-10?

Page 5

BUTLER UNIVERSITY | WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 29, 2012 | WWW.THEBUTLERCOLLEGIAN.COM

Core budget gap filled

Multiple arrests, excise police, policy changes—are administrators trying to

CAP A DRINKING PROBLEM?

TARA MCELMURRY TMCELMUR@BUTLER.EDU NEWS EDITOR

Butler University’s core curriculum no longer faces a budget gap as the 2012-13 school year gets underway.

The core curriculum faced a budget shortfall of $400,000 last April.

“Funding for the core was never in jeopardy,” said Ben Hunter, chief of staff and executive director of public safety. “The core will always be funded.”

Hunter said numbers in the spring were preliminary before the resources for the budget were allocated.

The necessary funding for the core was found before beginning the new school year, said Bruce Arick, vice president of finance and administration.

The gap was closed with $350,000 to $375,000 from the university’s contingency fund, Arick said.

The contingency fund is a sum of money in the university’s budget that has not been committed to any specific program or area. “(The contingency fund) is money that we have if something happens that was unforeseen that we can dip into,” he said.

Arick said he likes to start the year with at least $1 million in the contingency fund.

The university was able to fund the core during the planning stages of the budget before the 2012-13 school year, Arick said. It was able to start the year with the million dollars still in the fund.

Arick said these budget gaps are not unusual.

“As we go through the year planning process, the information becomes more specific about enrollment and what colleges it will affect,” Arick said.

Arick said when budget gaps arise, the deans and faculty are the first to become aware of it. If further attention is needed, those budget issues are taken to the provost and then to her advisory committee, which is made up of the deans.

Finally, it is taken to the president’s cabinet for review and approval, if it is determined university-level funding is needed.

Getting approval for the core curriculum funding is what Interim Provost Kathryn Morris did.

“It’s my responsibility to advocate for resources to make sure we have what we need to deliver the core curriculum to our students,” Morris said.

Figuring out what resources the core needs starts with looking at which faculty members are teaching which classes already.

Then they look to see how many students will be coming in.

Finally, best estimates are made about what additions the core needs, Morris said.

Morris said most first-year students have at least one other core course in addition to their first-year seminars.

“Things are going well,” Morris said. “We’ve got the resources to support the need.”

As far as next year’s core resources, Arick said budget gaps appear annually but not always in the same spot.

“It is certainly a possibility it could be in the core,” he said.

The planning process for the 2013-14 budget will start in the spring.

Opinion: Students will get used to the undercover cops.

Page 11

ATLANTIC 10

Conference switch costs uncertain Administrators hope to cut costs with a higher revenue.

MARISSA JOHNSON MKJOHSON@BUTLER.EDU SPORTS EDITOR

Butler University will incur increased costs as a result of the move to the Atlantic 10 Conference.

However, administrators say they expect to make up the cost with increased revenue.

“We didn’t ignore the costs, but at the end of the day, those are immaterial,” said Bruce Arick, vice president of finance and administration. “The expectations down the road are that the (revenue) increase will be more than enough to offset any cost now.”

CHANGES IN POLICY However, it is uncertain whether these recommendations are being treated as changes to Butler’s alcohol policy.

Johnson said that changes were being made to the policy while Stevens said the policy itself will be reviewed during this semester and has not yet been changed.

Sarah Barnes Diaz, health education and outreach programs coordinator and co-chair of the task force, said that the confusion lies with the semantics of the phrase “changes to the policy.”

“The recommendations are what we’re now enacting,” Diaz said. “So within that, there are some shifts in policy and some changes in the student handbook.”

TRAVEL EXPENSES ADD TO COST Butler’s athletics department spent almost $13.7 million for all 17 sports in 2010, according to documents from Equity in Athletics Data Analysis.

That number is expected to increase this year due to additional costs in traveling to other A-10 schools.

The university and athletics department would not release specific numbers regarding the budget. As a private university, it is not required to do so.

Administrators also said they were hesitant to cite specific numbers with regard to the A-10 move because they would not know the exact figures until after the academic year.

President Jim Danko said he is estimating an increase of approximately $700,000 in travel expenses alone.

The actual figures are still uncertain, and Tom Crowley, associate athletic director for internal operations, said Butler is relying on estimations to determine the anticipated athletic budget.

Crowley said administrators have looked at other Midwest schools, including Xavier, Saint Louis and Dayton, to estimate and compare modes of transportation, hotel costs and the average per diem required for food.

“We looked at it from a bigpicture standpoint and decided (the conference change) was for the best,” Crowley said. “There is a cost increase, but it allows us to increase recruitment, sell more tickets and

see alcohol page 2

see a-10 page 5

COLIN LIKAS CLIKAS@BUTLER.EDU MANAGING EDITOR

With Indiana officials looking to crack down on underage and high-risk alcohol consumption on college campuses, the atmosphere of Butler University is changing.

An alcohol task force, comprised of Butler students and faculty from numerous departments, was created during the 2011-12 academic year.

CURBING ILLEGAL DRINKING ON BUTLER’S CAMPUS For the start of this academic year, the group has come up with multiple recommendations to help school administrators and the Butler University Police Department curb problem and illegal drinking.

“I think (the task force) is the best type of approach because you’re getting multiple perspectives,” said Levester Johnson, vice president for student affairs.

“But it’s most important to involve students because they can take direct ownership of this as well.”

Irene Stevens, dean of student life and co-chair of the task force, said the recommendations made by the task force cover three areas of concern: alcohol education, enforcement of alcohol laws and sanctioning of those who break alcohol laws.

Butler backs Rocky Ripple MARAIS JACON-DUFFY MJACONDU@BUTLER.EDU STAFF REPORTER

The signs all over read: Save Our Homes. We Are Indy. Don’t Cripple the Ripple.

Rocky Ripple is battling the United States Army Corps of Engineers’ plan for a 4-foot-tall, 8,200-foot-long floodwall that would exclude the neighborhood from protection.

New to the list of opposing parties are Butler University and the Butler-Tarkington Neighborhood Association.

Cosmetic concerns, concerns about the environment and restricted access along the White River Canal prompted the Butler community’s opposition.

The floodwall will cut through Holcomb Gardens and require the clearing of some trees and

vegetation.

“The university requests the Corps consider alternative options that would not impact historic Holcomb Gardens,” said Ben Hunter, chief of staff and executive director of public safety.

Hunter officially declared the university’s opposition to the Army Corps of Engineers’ plan last week.

“We are trying now to talk to the Corps about the value of the land and why it wouldn’t make sense (for the floodwall) to be built where it was proposed,” Hunter said.

Holcomb Gardens is a common running route for some Butler students, including sophomore arts administration major Haley Baas.

“I run through Holcomb Gardens every day,” Baas said. “It’s such a pretty area. But if they put up a see rocky ripple page 3

SPORTS 5 | ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT 8 | OPINION 10 | VISIBLE BULLDOGS 12

John Barth, city-county councillor at-large, sits alongside Rocky Ripple residents after speaking about concerns about a proposed flood wall.

Photo by Heather Iwinski

PAGE 2 | THE BUTLER COLLEGIAN

WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 29, 2012

Crime in Broad Ripple causes concern JEFF STANICH JSTANICH@BUTLER.EDU

STAFF REPORTER

Broad Ripple, a popular destination for Butler University students, has been hit with a recent crime trend.

A representative from one popular destination, Buffalo Wild Wings, said that any sort of crime is possible.

“We see all sorts of people around… but we do not get in their way and let the police handle any situation,” the representative said.

Crime has been on the rise for the past three months, and both the Butler University Police Department and local authorities are taking extra measures to ensure the safety of local residents.

BUPD has been warning students of the danger through email, and students are now aware of the risk they take by traveling to Broad Ripple.

“I’ve heard of other students having bad experiences, such as drugs being put in drinks and a friend being stolen from, so I don’t want to get hurt by going to Broad Ripple,” said Rachel Fish, a freshman exploratory business major.

The first step toward safety for Butler students is awareness, said Bruce Allee, a BUPD detective.

I’ve heard of other students having bad experiences...

I don’t want to get hurt by going to Broad Ripple.

RACHEL FISH FRESHMAN “We as a force do not have the manpower to cover the Broad Ripple area, but we encourage students to call us if they need an escort or help at any time they deem it necessary,” Allee said.

Students who do go out at night should make sure to keep valuables out of sight in a parked car.

“Even if a suspect sees a bag, they will break the window to look for anything they can grab,” Allee said.

And in the case that someone attacks, not fighting him or her is the best way to avoid injury.

“Do not fight with anyone over something of small value or a debit card that can be cancelled within a mere 30 minutes of the confrontation,” Allee said.

University has access to students’ email Administrators avoid diving into students’ inboxes, but the ability to do so has been beneficial in the past.

RYAN LOVELACE

RLOVELAC@BUTLER.EDU ASSISTANT NEWS EDITOR

Butler University’s Information Technology department has the ability to read students’ email, but Chief Information Officer Scott Kincaid said it chooses not to do so.

“We have the technical ability, I don’t want to deny that,” Kincaid said. “We do it very rarely. And we do it only per a policy.”

The Privacy of Personally Created Content Policy was updated after Butler filed a lawsuit for online speech against student Jess Zimmerman in 2009 when he criticized Butler’s administration.

The policy states that Butler personnel may access students’ information if there is the possibility of “substantial university risk of harm or liability.”

The policy is referring to risk associated with the Butler network, said Ben Hunter, chief of staff and executive director of public safety.

Huner said BUPD has requested information twice in the last four years--about a student suicide and missing-student case.

Kincaid said since he came to Butler in 2001, IT has accessed students’ private information fewer than six times. He said the policy is very clear about the circumstances of when a student should be notified.

“If they were threatening the whole computer system in some fashion, we would have the right to notify them afterwards,” Kincaid said.

Before accessing students’ private information, Kincaid said IT would generally need approval from himself, a vice president or dean at the university and someone from human resources.

“If I had ... any thought that someone was intending on bringing some kind of harm to individuals, I wouldn’t have to hesitate ... in order to save the community,” said Vice President for Student Affairs Levester Johnson. “Whether it was a joke or however it was intended, we’re going to follow up on something like that.”

Johnson said he thinks adding a student representative into the process of deciding when a student’s privacy should be invaded would be a greater invasion of privacy.

Student Government Association President Mike Keller said he agreed personally with not adding a student representative but would represent the student body’s voice if it felt differently.

Azhar Majeed, an attorney for the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, said while Butler has a pretty good free speech record, it may have overreacted to the case that brought about Butler suing one of its students in 2009.

Creating and switching to a private email is an option students should entertain if they are concerned about Butler’s monitoring capabilities, Majeed said.

“I know several people who use Gmail themselves just because they’re more comfortable knowing that is a more private thing to be able to utilize,” Keller said.

Johnson said students should be cautious with their language, regardless of where they say things online.

“Just like you wouldn’t and you’re not supposed to say certain things at an airport,” Johnson said. “You know what you shouldn’t be saying and insinuating and doing certain things with a computer as well.”

Photo by Rafael Porto

Students gather at restaurants and bars in Broad Ripple despite recent crime increase. BUPD encourages students to be aware.

He also said to take advantage of any transportation Butler has to offer students on the weekends to and from Broad Ripple.

“The whole purpose of the shuttle is to provide safe transportation for students to and from Broad Ripple, and it is available to

ALCOHOL: POLICIES AIM TO CURB DRINKING FROM PAGE ONE

SENDING THE RIGHT MESSAGE Sally Click, dean of student services, said in an email to The Collegian that a major point in the task force’s discussion was the message the university was sending about alcohol.

To that effect, posters are displayed around campus to make clear to all students that the drinking age in Indiana is 21.

Additionally, Stevens said an online module was created to educate new students about alcohol, drugs and sexual assault and that all new students were asked to complete the module prior to the start of classes.

Diaz said the school’s Red Cup Culture program also needed revisions.

“In the past, the focus of Red Cup Culture was very much on the consumption of alcohol being a personal choice,” Diaz said. “It almost sends the wrong message and gives permission, so we sliced some of that out of the video.”

Diaz said members of the task force felt that education on high-risk drinking and alcohol poisoning was necessary as well.

In addition, new students were prohibited from entering Greek houses before Aug. 27 so they would participate in planned Welcome Week activities, Click said.

A member of the Greek community, who wished to remain anonymous because of fraternity policy to limit the members that can speak to the media, said this policy was helpful.

“We can really get to know kids versus putting them in a social scene they’re not familiar with,” the individual said.

CHANGING HOW BU ENFORCES RULES The task force also made recommendations with regard to enforcement of alcohol laws and changes to sanctioning, but a higher power has also had a hand in making sure laws are being followed.

The Indiana State Excise Police is a unit of the Alcohol Tobacco Commission that sends undercover police officers to Indiana colleges.

When at colleges, the officers can attend parties and other gatherings where underage drinking may be occurring and ask students for a form of identification.

Stevens said she expects the excise police force to be on campus more this academic year than in recent years. This is partly due to the creation of the Intensified College Enforcement program, which is using Indiana’s excise police to try to cut down on underage drinking.

Former governor Mitch Daniels also passed the Indiana Lifeline Law earlier this year.

According to the Indiana Lifeline Coalition’s website, the law provides immunity from some alcohol violations to those who request medical assistance or have it requested for them.

The task force has suggested that BUPD be more consistent in alcohol policy enforcement, in addition to utilizing a summons arrest in appropriate situations.

A summons arrest is a ticket for public intoxication that requires the offender to appear in court, Stevens said.

any student who wants to use it,” Student Government Association President Mike Keller said.

Students can reach the BUPD at (317) 940-9396. In case of an emergency, local authorities can be reached by dialing 911.

I think that over time, we can shift the culture away from high-risk drinking.

SARAH BARNES DIAZ ALCOHOL TASK FORCE CO-CHAIR This differs from an outright arrest, which sees an offender be put in handcuffs by a police offer, and a the more rare warrant arrest, which allows police to arrest a person of interest with regard to a crime.

Ben Hunter, chief of staff and executive director of public safety, said recent alcohol incidents on Indiana campuses are causing BUPD to be stricter in handing on summons arrests.

Hunter said two under-21 students encountered by BUPD last week had ‘extremely high’ blood alcohol content levels and were example cases for a summons arrest. One student was unresponsive and the other suffered injuries from a fall.

“My preference is when we can do a referral because I don’t want to ruin resumes,” Hunter said. “But at the same time, if we find someone with alcohol poisoning or, worst-case scenario, dead, there’s going to be all kinds of scrutiny.”

The alcohol policy section of Butler’s student handbook includes state penalties for specific alcohol-related crimes, which can range from fines up to $1,000 to jail time.

Separate from fines and arrests are sanctions imposed by the university, which have also been altered.

Click said fines for breaking alcohol laws have been rejected in favor of a community restoration project, which involves individuals giving back to the Butler community in some way.

An individual who has a major alcohol violation or accumulates multiple minor ones can also be put on conduct probation, which keeps the individual from participating in Greek recruitment and from holding a number of leadership positions on campus.

Click also said that 75 to 80 percent of student conduct cases over the last several years have involved alcohol or drugs. Some sanctions in those cases included alcohol or drug assessment and attendance at an in-house alcohol seminar.

“I think it’s a really good practice to take stock of where we’re at, and that’s what the task force did,” Diaz said.

STUDENTS REACT TO COMING CHANGES A level of anxiety seems to be felt by students toward the changes, the Greek member said. “(The changes) add a layer of fear and pressure,” the individual said. “We’re under pressure to do everything right, but ultimately it’s for our safety.”

While the success of the task force’s recommendations cannot be fully examined until more time has passed, Diaz said she believes the university is handling alcohol issues in the correct manner.

“I’m confident that this is the way to go,” Diaz said. “I think that over time, we can shift the culture away from high-risk drinking.”

ALCOHOL TASK FORCE RECOMMENDATIONS • Posters displayed in residence halls and other locations around campus • Restricted access to Greek houses for new students until after Aug. 27 to encourage attendance at Welcome Week activities • Fines have been rejected and deemed not educational. Instead, a community restoration activity has been added for students.

• Anyone on conduct probation will not be able to participate in Greek recruitment or hold leadership positions, such as a Resident Assistant or Student Orientation Guide.

• BUPD will be consistent with policy enforcement to include the use of summons arrests when warranted.

Over the fall semester the Alcohol Task Force will continue to review policy changes and determine if adjustments are required.

BUPD alcohol incidents

August 18 1:39 a.m.—Possesion of alcohol by minor, injured person 7:02 a.m.—Sick/ill person, possession of alcohol by minor August 19 12:59 a.m.—Possession of alcohol by minor, possession of paraphanalia, drug arrest August 20 11:15 p.m.—Possession of alcohol by minor August 21 12:35 a.m.—Public intoxication 3:03 a.m.—Any liquor law violation August 26 12:37 a.m.—Public intoxication August 28 1:42 a.m.—Possession of alcohol by minor From BUPD Daily Crime Log

WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 29, 2012

THE BUTLER COLLEGIAN | PAGE 3

Meridian Street

67th Street

CCOM internships still strong despite change KELLY ROSTIN KROSTIN@BUTLER.EDU STAFF REPORTER

Canal Intake Structure Kessler Boulevard

This map shows the phases of the flood wall construction. The wall would run along Rocky Ripple and through Holcomb Gardens.

Riviera Club

Butler University Map courtesy of U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

ROCKY RIPPLE: RESIDENTS VOICE CONCERNS FROM PAGE ONE

wall through it and cut down the trees, it will take away the beauty.”

Not only are people concerned about the wall’s aesthetic effect, they are also concerned about protection.

“The plan for the wall as of right now will put Holcomb Gardens and Rocky Ripple neighborhood in the line of danger,” Hunter said. “We’re not the ones leading the charge, but we do want to help the neighborhood of Rocky Ripple.

“Many students live there, so the university stands ready to assist them and the Corps to help find a compromise.”

The Rocky Ripple community has held multiple demonstrations, including an enactment in which 700 people laid on the streets “displaced” to show the possible effects of a flood.

One resident leading the charge is Zorba Rose, a 12-year Rocky Ripple homeowner and Butler alumna.

“The main goal for my neighbors and myself is to be included in the renovations and, in turn, receive flood protection,” Rose said. “We are all unified in this. We

TIMELINE The canal’s history of flooding led to floodwall plans and rising levels of controversy.

don’t want homes to be destroyed.”

The Army Corps of Engineers agreed at a meeting last week to extend the start of the project for another 30 days.

During that time, those in opposition to the current plan may send letters to the Corps.

“The number one thing people can do at this point is write letters,” Rose said.

“It’s really the only thing you can do.”

“Butler plans on writing to the Corps to try to explain our position from a more technical side,” Hunter said. “The residents of Rocky Ripple are very emotionally invested, and rightly so.

Their homes are at stake. But we want to appeal to the Corps in their own language.”

The Corps claims that the already $14 million project will require an additional $35 million to avoid Holcomb Gardens and protect Rocky Ripple.

“There has to be an alternative,” Rose said. “I mean, these guys built the Panama Canal. They can definitely get creative with a flood wall.”

Anyone interested may contact the Corps at P.O. Box 59, Louisville, KY 40201-0059, during the extension period.

“We are so grateful for Butler and all they’ve been doing to help our efforts,” Rose said. “They’ve been nothing but wonderful. They are very good people.”

SEPT. 28, 2012 End of public comment period regarding the North Flood Damage Reduction Period AUG. 23, 2012 Public hearing at Meridian Street United Methodist Church MAY 12, 2011 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers issued a Notice of Intent to prepare the Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement JAN. 2007 Most recent recorded flood, which remained at an aboveflood stage for eight days JAN. 1991 15-year flood, which forced the evacuation of 500 homes MARCH 1913 Largest recorded flooding of the White River in the Indianapolis area

The dean of the College of Communication said internships will still be a part of the student experience, despite last year’s internship coordinator’s position cut.

“There never was a question that internships would go away or that there would even be a diminishing of an internship program in the College of Communication,” CCOM Dean Gary Edgerton said.

CCOM lost its internship coordinator at the end of the spring 2012 academic semester.

Ed Kanis, an instructor in the strategic communication program of CCOM, worked as the first point of contact for CCOM students looking for internships.

The loss of the internship coordinator position worried CCOM students, who depend on real-world experience of internships for their future careers.

“I was a little worried because I still feel like I need guidance in that area,” Shelby Long, senior communication studies major, said.

During her time at Butler, Long has worked a marketing internship at Huntington Bank and a news reporting internship with WISH-TV in Indianapolis.

She discovered both opportunities through Kanis.

“I feel like I’ve gotten a

(The internship program) is still strong and healthy...It will grow to become more ambitious.

GARY EDGERTON DEAN, COLLEGE OF COMMUNICATION taste of the real world,” Long said. “It’s encouraged me to look for further opportunities for networking. I made a lot of good connections through my internships.”

In response to student concerns, Gary Edgerton, dean of CCOM, said he understands the value of internships.

“Communication and its various specialty areas lend themselves to internships,” Edgerton said.

Nancy Whitmore, director of the journalism program, said in an email that internships would now be handled by the program directors of the six program areas in CCOM. These areas are communication sciences and disorders; creative media and entertainment; journalism; media, rhetoric and culture; organizational communication and leadership; and strategic communications.

This is similar to how

the internship program ran prior to June 2010.

“Whatever helps students get into the real world through internships is good,” Long said. “I’m glad the directors are helping.”

From increasing the number of local and regional internships to looking at possible international opportunities, the college is hoping to expand internship opportunities for CCOM students in the near future.

The college is currently working to solicit ideas and make plans for an improved format to the internship program for the spring semester.

Last year, 59 CCOM students had internships.

Edgerton hopes to see that number eventually hit 100 per year.

“The number of internships that are relevant for communication students is really vast,” Edgerton said.

“We hope to make all those opportunities available to our students.”

Long said she would like to see this growth in the future even though she graduates in December.

“It’s hard to tell the future because I graduate early, but I just hope that if I were to come back, maybe in May, I’d see growth in that area,” Long said. “Students can be assured that the internship program has continued,” Edgerton said. “It is still strong and healthy. In the future it will grow to become more ambitious. That’s what we’re working toward.”

Want to see more?

You can find The Collegian online at www.thebutlercollegian.com.

Get the latest in sports, news, opinion and arts whenever you want it!

For breaking news, follow us on Twitter (@butlercollegian)

The legal age for alcohol use in Indiana is 21-years-old. Consuming too much alcohol can put you and your friends in danger. The Collegian encourages you to drink responsibly.

College Avenue

PAGE 4 | THE BUTLER COLLEGIAN

WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 29, 2012

Schedules set for organization assembly meetings Student Government Association, Faculty Senate and Staff Assembly have all released their fall meeting schedules. Each of these organizations make decisions and discusses issues that affect the entire campus. All organizations encourage both voting and non-voting parties to attend meetings.

STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION WHO THEY ARE Each week, representatives from Butler University’s more than 150 student organizations meet to vote on issues affecting the student body.

WHAT THEY DO Representatives vote on budgets, events and initiatives on campus.

LAST YEAR Under last year’s administration, new student organizations were created, including a professional networking club and a dance club.

Last year, SGA had a budget of more than $700,000 collected from student fees.

THIS YEAR This year’s administrative board, under the leadership

of SGA president Mike Keller, hopes to increase student involvement.

This year’s budget will most likely increase because of the larger student body.

WHO CAN ATTEND Last year marked the first year that the meetings were open door, meaning that all students were welcome to attend.

MEETING TIMES AND LOCATION The first SGA assembly will be Sept. 5 at 4:30 p.m. in Pharmacy Building room 150.

Assembly meets every Wednesday at 4:30 p.m.

FOR MORE INFORMATION Keller can be reached by email, mrkeller@butler.edu SGA’s website is http:// www.butler.edu/sga.

FACULTY SENATE WHO THEY ARE Faculty Senate is comprised of elected representatives from the six colleges on campus. There are 14 senators from LAS, six from COPHS, five from JCFA, four from COB, three from COE and three from CCOM. WHAT THEY DO According to the Senate’s constitution, the Senate is responsible for policies, faculty productivity, curriculum and instructional practices.

LAST YEAR Last year’s senators voted on changing evaluation forms, voted for core curriculum funding and endorsed an open provost search.

They also discussed tuition increases.

Butler President Jim Danko has visited assembly in the past to address any issues that faculty members may have.

THIS YEAR Professor Margaret Brabant will continue her tenure as the chair of Faculty Senate. This

year’s Senate will most likely continue to address the core curriculum and tuition increases.

WHO CAN ATTEND All faculty members may attend and be recognized to speak on an equal basis with senators in Senate meetings.

WHAT THEY DO Staff Assembly was created in February 2001 to enhance the working environment and represent the concerns of staff.

Staff make up the second largest constituent group on campus, with more than 700 people.

LAST YEAR Last year’s Assembly provided input for the staff handbook, held the eighth annual Campus Sweep and offered personal and professional development sessions.

THIS YEAR Incoming Staff Assembly Chair Josh Downing has encouraged continued input from staff members.

This year, the Assembly will

Free Bike Share program begins this weekend JEFF STANICH JSTANICH@BUTLER.EDU

STAFF REPORTER

The Student Government Association will unveil a new bike rental system called Bike Share on campus this weekend.

SGA President Mike Keller said he hopes that students will utilize this system instead of using cars.

“I’m really excited for the bike service because Indianapolis is so accessible through the trail along the canal, and now everyone can use that with these bikes,” Keller said.

The 100 bikes were brought to campus with the purpose of offering students a new form of transportation.

“We (SGA) actually piloted this after a program in Detroit at Oakland University,” said Scott Nemeth, SGA vice president of administration. “We saw what they were doing and modeled it into a program here at Butler.”

The bikes can be checked out at

I’m really excited for the bike service because Indianapolis is so accessible through the trail along the canal.

MIKE KELLER SGA PRESIDENT the Health & Recreation Complex and can be taken wherever the student wants to go.

The bikes can be checked out for free using student ID cards and must be returned to the HRC within the 24-hour rental period.

“It comes with a lock and the option to rent a helmet for free as well,” Nemeth said.

A semester rental is also

available for $50, giving students the ability to store bikes wherever they live.

Students will be able to use the bikes until winter begins on Nov. 16, the day before Thanksgiving break.

Students are looking forward to using the bikes for several reasons, including physical fitness.

“Having a bike on campus would allow my physical wellbeing to improve,” freshman prepharmacy major Caroline Koester said.

Students have already made plans for how they will use the bikes.

“We are planning to take our unit to Broad Ripple and have lunch there by using the bikes as transportation,” junior pharmacy major Tommy Fehn said.

The Bike Share rental system is located between the HRC and Hinkle Fieldhouse and will be available for use this weekend.

MEETING TIMES AND LOCATION All meetings are held from 8 until 9:15 a.m. in Jordan Hall room 141.

Fall 2012 assembly dates: Sept. 4 Sept. 18 Oct. 2 Oct. 23 Nov. 6 Nov. 27 Dec. 4 WHO TO CONTACT Faculty senators hold weekly office hours each Thursday from 11:30 a.m. until 12:30 p.m. in Jordan Hall, room 245.

Brabant can be reached by email, mbrabant@butler.edu.

The senate’s website is http://www.butler.edu/facultysenate/.

STAFF ASSEMBLY WHO THEY ARE Staff Assembly is composed of a 12-member executive committee and six standing committees. More than 50 staff members are involved with Staff Assembly in either capacity.

Photo by Heather Iwinski

Photo by Rafael Porto

Students wait in line ready to buy or exchange textbooks. The bookstore has worked with students to get any issues resolved.

Students work with bookstore to prepare for class HOLLY BIGGS

most likely organize a team for Relay for Life and the Top Dawg Awards, a program that recognizes staff members across the university.

WHO CAN ATTEND All staff members may attend the Staff Assembly meetings.

MEETING TIMES AND LOCATION All meetings are held from 2 to 3 p.m.

2012-13 assembly meetings: Aug. 29, JH 141 Sept. 19, GH 108 Oct. 17, GH 108 Nov. 14, GH 108 Dec. 19, JH 141 Jan. 23, JH 141 Feb. 20, JH 141 March 20, JH 141 April 17, JH 141 May 15, JH 141 WHO TO CONTACT Downing can be reached by email, jdowning@butler.edu The staff assembly website is http://www.butler.edu/staffassembly.

HNBIGGS@BUTLER.EDU STAFF REPORTER

Classes at Butler University have been in session for a week, and some students still have one thing on their minds: getting textbooks.

The bookstore has given students stress stemming from not having books in stock, accidentally canceling orders or ordering the wrong books.

Not only did many students get their books at the same time, but the bookstore was also faced with serving the largest freshman class.

These two factors combined have kept the bookstore busy for the beginning of the school year.

What many are not seeing, however, is the bookstore’s effort to fix any miscommunications students are being faced with.

“They did a great job of helping me return the books that my professor said we didn’t need,” sophomore Abbie Liebl said.

Liebl said half of her books for a class were optional, but the bookstore never notified her about this. The bookstore gave her a full refund after being told by her professor she didn’t need them.

Another issue students are facing is books being out of stock, even when they were ordered in advance.

All of our homework is from the book, and since it hasn’t come in yet, I can’t start my work.

MELANIE ALBAUM SOPHOMORE Sophomore Rithvi Melanta ordered a book a week before school started so she would have it in time for class.

“I got a confirmation saying it was in, so I went to the bookstore on the first day, and it wasn’t in stock,” Melanta said. “I went there the next day, and it still hadn’t come in.”

The bookstore, however, made sure to notify Melanta’s professor that the books hadn’t come in to ensure students wouldn’t fall behind on homework.

Another case happened with EN101, a writing tutorial course. There are four sections of this class, all taught by different professors. Each section uses a different textbook.

“One book was ordered for all four sections,” said Jim Hanna,

an EN-101 adjunct professor. “It was a hassle for students because they ended up paying more, but the bookstore overnighted the correct books and worked well with the department head to fix the problem.”

College of Communication adjunct professor Glenn Carlstrand had a similar problem in which there was a mistake with what book was ordered for a sign language course.

“The bookstore was very cooperative in getting (the problem) corrected,” Carlstrand said. “I have no problem with them, and I don’t want to complain. They were very nice about it.”

Melanie Albaum, a sophomore taking this course, said that the bookstore told her to get a level-two textbook when, in actuality, the class called for level three.

“All of our homework is from the book, and since it hasn’t come in yet, I can’t start my work,” Albaum said.

“I understand, though, because the bookstore is doing the best they can.”

Carlstrand said the problem was quickly corrected, and the students should have the right book this week.

Bookstore employees and managers were asked to comment; however, none responded in time for this issue.

SPORTS

WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 29, 2012

BUTLER’S NEW ROUTE

PAGE 5

As Butler begins its inaugural season in the Atlantic 10, athletes, coaches and fans will have to adjust to the longer distances.

HOW TRIPS COMPARE Horizon League

382

Atlantic 10

895

miles traveled on the longest trip to University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee

miles traveled on the longest trip to University of Rhode Island

120

117

miles traveled on the shortest trip to Wright State University.

251

miles traveled on an average trip to an away game.

AMHERST, MA 884 miles

KINGSTON, RI

ST. BONAVENTURE, NY

miles traveled on the shortest trip to Xavier University

504 miles

549

895 miles

NEW YORK, NY 743 miles

miles traveled on an average trip to an away game.

PHILADELPHIA, PA

PITTSBURGH, PA

644 miles

362 miles

DAYTON, OH

WASHINGTON, DC

121 miles

594 miles

CINCINNATI, OH 117 miles

RICHMOND, VA

ST. LOUIS, MO

626 miles

251 miles

CHARLOTTE, NC 582 miles

Academics at forefront of move Student-athletes will face more competition both on the court and in the classroom.

St. Louis—Saint Louis University Dayton, Ohio—University of Dayton Cincinnati—Xavier University Pittsburgh—Duquesne University Philadelphia—La Salle University, Saint Joseph’s University, Temple University St. Bonaventure, N.Y.—St. Bonaventure University New York—Fordham University Amherst, Mass.—University of MassachusettsAmherst Kingston, R.I.—University of Rhode Island Washington, DC—George Washington University Richmond, Va.—University of Richmond,VCU Charlotte, N.C.—UNC Charlotte

A-10: COSTS INCREASE IN MOVE FROM PAGE ONE

be a vehicle for the university in the plan to grow.”

Finances were one of the major considerations of the A-10 when deciding whether to accept Butler or not.

“Butler is a perfect fit because of their flagship sport in men’s basketball, and academically they are a great institution,” A-10 Commissioner Bernadette McGlade said. “But we also respect their financial commitment to the program and to the success of athletics as a whole.”

BETH WERGE BWERGE@BUTLER.EDU STAFF REPORTER

Butler was attracted to the Atlantic 10 Conference for many reasons, but one of the biggest highlights was the potential effect on student-athletes’ overall academic experience.

“Academics is always our focus and priority,” President Jim Danko said in an interview last week.

“We figured out that despite the further travel, our athletes will be spending more time on campus.”

The Bulldogs began studying, competing and cheering in the A-10 this year. The A-10 made an accelerated timetable possible after Butler decided to forgo an extra season in the Horizon Leauge.

“Ultimately it was in our best interest to reach an agreement with the Horizon League for immediate departure,” Athletic Director Barry Collier said. “We are grateful to the Atlantic 10 for welcoming us into the fold a year ahead of schedule.”

The administration does not expect the new athletic schedules to take students out of any additional classes compared to previous years.

This is mainly due to differences in the setup style of schedules in the new conference.

“The structure is different,” Collier said. “The A-10 does not play as many mid-week games as the Horizon League.”

He said this is a major reason that athletes will miss fewer classes.

“Whether you’re on a bus or in a plane, you’re still missing class, but that’s not the case when we don’t have the games during the week,” Collier said.

Sonya Hopkins, coordinator of academic support for studentathletes, said she doesn’t think this schedule will have any more of an adverse effect on students than any other scheduling formats they have previously endured.

CONFERENCE TEAMS

Collegian file photo

Junior basketball player Chrishawn Hopkins, seen here in a math class last year, will be one of many athletes to compete in the A-10 in both athletics and academics.

“Our athletes are not going to miss the extensive amount of classes that people assume would be missed because of the destinations,” Hopkins said. “I think anytime you have something new, there’s going to be a level of excitement that just kind of infiltrates everything.

“But the bottom line is you’re expected to perform in the classroom no matter what.”

Collier also cites the experience of new places and the lessons that can be learned in these travels as two big factors attracting Butler to the conference.

“That is the kind of thing that can be very positive,” Collier said.

“I think, ultimately, this will be better—a better experience for (our student-athletes).”

As a whole, the athletes will be traveling to and experiencing the nation’s capital and the financial center of the world.

“Those are two pretty big

things,” Collier said. “If we don’t see beyond whether the ball goes in the hoop, you miss the big picture.”

Academically, the A-10 also poses a bigger challenge for Butler athletes.

The Horizon League named 743 student-athletes—98 from Butler— in its academic honor roll last spring, based on a 3.2 GPA requirement on a 4.0 scale.

Meanwhile, the A-10 named 1,369 students to its spring 2012 list, even with the increased requirement of a 3.5 GPA. “One of the first things we see is that, academically, Butler is a great institution,” A-10 Commissioner Bernadette McGlade said in a press conference last spring. “Institutionally, they are a perfect fit for the league and bring a tradition of excellence in academics, athletics, integrity and personnel.”

WHERE THE MONEY COMES FROM The university takes that commitment seriously, as shown by the $4.3 million allocation from the university budget to the athletic department every year.

The allocation comes from a variety of sources, including tuition and fees, net revenue, room and board fees, fundraising, endowment draw and general interest income.

Arick said he expects the allocation amount to remain the same. He added that he is going to continue working with Danko and Athletic Director Barry Collier to make sure everything works.

“I see (the move) as very manageable on the economic side, but I will work with them to cover any gaps if there are any,” Arick

A-10 athletic spending survey

Butler: $13,684,523 Xavier: $15,135,882 Dayton: $19,870,762 VCU: $21,113,708 St. Bonaventure: $7,431,261

A-10 athletic revenue survey Butler: $13,684,523 Xavier: $15,135,882 Dayton: $21,256,523 VCU: $21,113,708 St. Bonaventure: $7,597,392

*All figures from 2010 Equity in Athletics Data Analysis Cutting Tool survey

“I see the move as very manageable on the economic side.”

BRUCE ARICK V.P. OF FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION

said.

Danko said that he would be willing to use extra marketing budget money for the branding benefits of getting the university’s name out on the East Coast.

However, both Arick and Collier said they will not know specific costs until after the year is over.

“From a financial side, there is some risk because we are working with very rough estimates, but I can say comfortably it is a good move,” Arick said. “Obviously we will know for sure in a year.”

Administrators will rely on donations to make up a large part of the difference. As the university said, it hopes the athletic department’s fundraising efforts will cover the majority of extra costs.

DONATIONS COULD INCREASE WITH CHANGE Bill Lynch, associate athletic director for development, said the reaction he has received from fans and donors has been positive, but there is still pressure to raise more money.

“I think we all feel the need to continue to raise money so that we can serve all of our studentathletes,” Lynch said. “Our athletes are stepping up their level of competition, and that means we all have to step up in what we do.”

Not only does the university expect donations to increase, but Danko said he is projecting an increase in ticket sales and conference revenue sharing.

Collier said that with all of these facts taken into consideration, he is confident that it was the best move.

“We looked at this long-term and the fact is there are going to be more costs, but we think the longterm revenue will overcome that,” Collier said. “The expenses will be worth it.”

PAGE 6 | THE BUTLER COLLEGIAN

WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 29, 2012

IN BRIEF

Men’s soccer gets first win The Butler men’s soccer team picked up its first win of the season with a 2-0 victory over Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis last night at the Butler Bowl.

Scoring for the Bulldogs were sophomore Brandon Fricke and senior Tyler Pollock.

The victory came after two consecutive draws in the VCU Nike Classic last weekend.

Butler (1-0-2) started its season against College of William & Mary in a scoreless contest. The teams combined for 33 shots in the match, and 12 of those attempts were on goal.

Junior goalkeeper Jon Dawson had five saves and recorded his fourth career shutout for Butler.

The Bulldogs scored their first goal of the season early in their second match against Bucknell.

Bucknell tied the match in the 58th minute when a throw-in ricocheted off a Butler defender and into the Bulldogs goal. The match ended in a 1-1 draw.

Junior forward Austin Oldham led the Bulldogs with eight shots, including four shots on goal, in the weekend’s two matches.

-Clayton Young

BUTLER V. IUPUI, AUG. 28

SAVES

SHOTS 1st 6 1

2nd 12 7

Total 18 8

1st 0 1

2nd 3 5

Total 3 6

1st 0 0

2nd 2 0

Total 2 0

Photo by Heather Iwinski

Junior defenseman Jordan Burt, seen preparing to make a pass in the last night’s game, helped Butler record its first win of the season against IUPUI.

Volleyball starts season 2-1 at DePaul

Women’s soccer splits matches The Butler women’s soccer team looked to continue its winning streak with two nonconference games last weekend.

The Bulldogs (2-2) had their first road match of the season against Eastern Michigan (1-1-1), which ended in a 1-0 loss.

Eagles freshman forward Sarah Deakin scored the only goal of the match in the 65th minute.

Last Friday, three players scored their first goals of the season for the Bulldogs, propelling Butler to a 3-0 win over Indiana State (1-2).

The Bulldogs tallied their first goal with eight minutes remaining in the first half.

In the 57th minute, a well-placed corner kick by sophomore forward Stephanie Kaylor was deposited in the back of the net off the head of sophomore defenseman Kelly Mahoney, giving the Bulldogs a 2-0 advantage.

Moments later, sophomore forward Elise Kotsakis delivered on a penalty kick, putting the game out of Indiana State’s reach.

-Marko Tomich

Photo by Jaclyn McConnell

Sophomore Kelly Mahoney (No. 4) scored the second goal of the game with this header off a corner kick and assist from teammate Stephanie Kaylor.

The DePaul Invitational ended on a strong note for the Butler volleyball team, which defeated the host school in comeback fashion to complete a twowin weekend.

The Bulldogs (2-1) won the final match of the tournament 3-2 over the Blue Demons.

Sophomore outside hitter Belle Obert closed the event with her second double-double in three matches, tallying 16 kills and 10 digs against DePaul.

It was Butler’s second win in a row after sweeping Eastern Illinois earlier Saturday afternoon.

The first win of the season came after losing to Indiana State 3-1 in the first game of the tournament Friday night.

Leading Butler was junior middle back Maggie Harbison with 13 kills and junior setter Morgan Peterson with seven blocks.

Peterson was named the tournament’s Most Valuable Player and earned a spot on the AllTournament Team with Obert and sophomore middle back Erica Stahl.

The Bulldogs will be in Pittsburgh this weekend for the Pittsburgh Panther Invitational.

-Peter Brown

The legal drinking age for alcohol use in Indiana is 21-years-old. Consuming too much alcohol can put you and your friends in danger. The Collegian encourages you to drink responsibly.

TEAM Butler IUPUI

SCORE

WEDNESDAY, AUGUST, 29 2012

THE BUTLER COLLEGIAN | PAGE 7

Cross country teams look to start new streaks

AUSTIN MONTEITH AMONTEIT@BUTLER.EDU ASST. SPORTS EDITOR

The Butler men’s and women’s cross country teams enter the 2012 season in an unfamiliar position in their new home in the Atlantic 10 Conference.

Coach Matt Roe said that while the Bulldogs were consistently at the top in the Horizon League, the team will face a higher quality of competition in the A-10 this season.

“I think (the A-10) is a stronger conference than the Horizon League overall, and the field will be more crowded,” Roe said.

The team will find themselves looking up at La Salle in their new conference The Explorers were the winners of both the men’s and women’s A-10 titles last season.

The Butler men are coming off a streak of 14 straight Horizon League team championships.

The women’s team had won nine of the last 10 Horizon titles, including the last three.

La Salle has won eight A-10 men’s cross country titles in the last 13 seasons while the women have won seven A-10 championships in the last 11 seasons.

La Salle will be returning senior Alfredo Santana, the 2011 A-10 Most Outstanding Performer,

Collegian file photo

Members of the Butler men’s and women’s cross country teams pose for a photo with their hardware after winning the 2011 Horizon League Cross Country Championships. who won last year’s conference championship race.

The Explorers also return three top 12 finishers from last season’s A-10 conference championship race on the women’s side.

Senior Shelbi Burnett, last year’s Horizon League Female Cross Country Athlte of the Year,

said she thinks the task of being the underdogs to conference favorites La Salle will give the team additional motivation.

“It’s a good position to be in because that gives you that kind of fire,” Burnett said. “It lights a fire underneath you to train harder and be faster, and

ultimately, that’s what leads to greater success.”

Butler will be without last year’s Horizon League Male Cross Country Athlete of the Year Callum Hawkins, who was academically dismissed by the university.

First team All-Horizon League

junior Ross Clarke and sophomore Tom Curr are the top returning members on this year’s squad.

Senior Kevin Oblinger and sophomore James Martin will also be back after their top-10 finishes in last year’s conference championship race.

Burnett will return as well as four other runners from last year’s conference-championship team.

Butler will have to cope with the absences of Lauren Haberkorn and Rebecca Howarth, who finished fourth and sixth, respectively, in the 2011 conference championships. Both graduated last year.

Burnett said facing unknown opponents in the A-10 might not be much of a drawback.

“There’s a lot we don’t know, obviously, but that’s kind of an advantage because being naïve isn’t necessarily a bad thing when it comes to running,” Burnett said.

“I think the biggest challenge will be going in with the confidence that we know we can compete well, no matter the competition.”

Roe said that the teams would not change their collective philosophy because of their location in the preseason rankings.

“We’re going to prepare the same way and do the best to our ability and get the best result we can,” Roe said.

Football prepared for season with batch of new players KYLE BEERY

KBEERY@BUTLER.EDU STAFF REPORTER

The Butler football team is building a buzz around the approaching season, which kicks off tomorrow night on the road against Western Illinois.

The Bulldogs just finished up training camp, and senior captain and offensive lineman Matt Storey said the energy and effort throughout camp has led to high expectations.

“I’d say things are definitely looking a lot better than last season,” Storey said. “I think having a bit of a younger team and having a lot of competition in spots has caused people to step up their game and work a lot harder in practice.”

The team is returning only nine total starters, but the youth of the team is poised to rise to the occasion.

“We’ve got a lot of young guys that see their opportunity to play,” coach Jeff Voris said.

“They’ve worked like this is their chance.”

Voris said the energy and enthusiasm in working for the team’s goal of a Pioneer Football League title has been off the charts since January.

“We’re not going to win the PFL in one week, but I think every week, we can come closer to that goal,” senior captain and linebacker Jordan Ridley said.

Ridley, who has led the PFL in total tackles

for two consecutive seasons, was named to the Football Championship Subdivision Senior Scout Bowl Preseason All-America Football Team.

While Ridley may be a leading player, Voris said he’s surrounded by many good football players on defense.

“With us, it’s never been about one guy or about a couple players. It’s about guys fitting into the system and believing in the Butler Way,” Voris said.

The PFL contains a unique level of football with a lot of great traditions and football teams, but Voris said the that there’s not a better home stadium and a better home crowd than the Butler Bowl.

“It’s a great place to play because of the band, cheerleaders, mascot and the student section, and the more people we get excited about coming out here on Saturdays, the better we’re going to be,” Voris said.

Adding to the excitement was the announcement that the PFL will begin receiving an automatic bid next season, but Voris said it was not the most important thing to his team right now.

“When you have 96 guys like that, it’s not about some end result,” Voris said. “It’s about the journey and the little things that go into every day’s preparation and the things you get out of the game from along the journey.”

The Bulldogs lost 16 starters from last year’s team, including starting quarterback

Collegian file photo

Senior captain and linebacker Jordan Ridley (No. 59), seen leading the Butler football team onto the field in their game against Albion on Sept. 3, 2011, will be a key player and leader for the Bulldogs this season.

Andrew Huck and the top three receivers.

Huck and receiver Zach Watkins left Butler as the number one passing duo in school history.

Redshirt sophomore Wade Markley and redshirt junior Matt Lancaster have been

battling for the starting job at quarterback.

Lancaster has been named the starter for tomorrow’s game against Western Illinois.

“The nice thing is that we’ve got two guys that can win a lot of football games,” Voris said.

Meager attendance an issue for fall athletic teams PETER BROWN PBROWN1@BUTLER.EDU STAFF REPORTER

Fall sports are having a difficult time attracting people to their games and matches.

The leader in attendance of all fall sports is football, which averaged fewer than 2,600 attendees per home game last year.

Football is the only fall sport that averaged in the thousands.

Last year, volleyball averaged 382 attendees, men’s soccer had 388 fans show up and women’s soccer didn’t even average above 300.

These numbers seem even smaller compared with men’s basketball, which averaged more than 6,100 per home game.

Vice President for Student Affairs Levester Johnson said that different departments are working together to try to help the fall sports teams.

“I think we are going to be stepping things up as far as trying to get students out and attending these events,” Johnson said.

Women’s soccer coach Tari St. John said that there is room to grow when it comes to attendance.

“It can still be exciting even if you are not a soccer person,” St. John said. “We had 10 to 15 football guys here (at the match against Indiana State), and they had such an impact on the atmosphere of the game, and the kids really fed off that.”

The Butler Bowl seats

For results from Butler sports, see the briefs on page 6 or visit www.thebutlercollegian.com.

approximately 5,600 people.

This means that even football did not reach half capacity on average last season.

Despite the low attendance, Johnson said there was good turnout at the women’s soccer game against Louisville on Aug. 17. Attendance was reported at 412 people.

“Once we work with students and give them this sense of knowing that these are their classmates, people sitting right next to them in class, they’re going to come out,” Johnson said.

Photo by Jaclyn McConnell

The sparse crowd at the Butler Bowl looks on as the women’s soccer team defeaed Indiana State 3-0 on Friday night.

ARTS, ETC

PAGE 8

O

WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 29, 2012

They are everywhere.

They lie next to you as you walk to class.

They sit in little bunches, surprising you at every turn.

They stand in strategically -placed pots.

Flowers adorn Butler University’s campus, creating the park-like atmosphere that the school is known for.

But they don’t grow themselves.

The men behind the Butler blooms MARIA LEICHTY MLEICHTY@BUTLER.EDU STAFF WRITER

Photos by Maria Leichty

James Conner, left, and Kevin Steckbeck, right, pose in front of a flowerbed. Also pictured on this page: flowers bloom around campus.

In an obscure office on the corner of 52nd Street and Boulevard Place, past the Apartment Village, sit two men.

Their names are James Conner and Kevin Steckbeck.

You probably have not heard their names before, but you have seen their handiwork.

For the past 25 years, these two men have been responsible for all of Butler University’s flowers.

Conner started out as a groundskeeper at Butler by answering an ad in the newspaper. After 10 years on staff, he became the supervisor of grounds.

Steckbeck has been here 30 years.

He also started out on grounds staff and is now the lead groundskeeper.

Every November, Conner and Steckbeck go to 52nd and Boulevard to plan the flowers for each year.

“We’ve just done this for so long that we know what works well here,” Conner said.

There are around 18 flower beds and 45 pots on campus.

“We want it to remain beautiful and enlightening to the students, faculty and staff who walk by,” Gerald Carlson, director of maintenance services, said.

Conner and Steckbeck both said a well-maintained campus attracts more students.

There have been studies, Conner said, that show the aesthetics of a campus are one of the top five reasons a student picks a college.

Stephanie Klingenmeier, a sophomore, said the park-like atmosphere was part of her decision to come to Butler.

“All the flowers make Butler very peaceful and enjoyable to walk through,” Klingenmeier said.

The planting process begins in March, when they edge mulch areas for the flowers, bushes and trees.

Then they prep the flower beds

before planting and watering the seeds.

Also, they de-head the flowers and trim the bushes and trees.

And in November they plan it all again.

Conner and Steckbeck try new flowers each year. They plant them in Holcomb Gardens before they put them on campus, Conner said.

“I like to try different stuff because, after a while, the same thing gets kind of stale,” Conner said.

With the ever-changing Indiana weather, not every flower makes it.

“It’s heart breaking when we try out some flowers and a disease comes through and wipes them out,” Steckbeck said. “It’s like just missing a home run.”

Conner and Steckbeck’s work is appreciated by students and professionals alike.

Junior Nicole Sheetz walks through Holcomb Gardens every day to get to her University Terrace apartment.

“I like nature, and the flowers make Butler very homey,” Sheetz said.

Leigh Robinson is a professional photographer who owns Leigh Robinson Photography. She lives near Butler and does photo shoots in Holcomb Gardens.

“It’s beautiful and well-kept,” Robinson said. “You have the formal garden on one side, and then you have a more casual look by the steps and fountain.”

A beautiful campus is not easy to keep, Steckbeck said.

“Our jobs can range from curb appeal to cutting the biggest tree,” Steckbeck said. “But the simplest job can sometimes be the hardest job.”

Including Conner and Steckbeck, 12 employees tend to the flora on campus.

Carlson said they would like to have 18 individuals, especially with more buildings being added to campus.

While theirs might seem like a tedious job, the green thumbs at the heart of Butler’s groundskeeping also find it rewarding.

“If I didn’t like this job,” Conner said, “I wouldn’t be here this long,”

WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 29, 2012

THE BUTLER COLLEGIAN | PAGE 9

From NYC to Butler: ‘Seven’ celebrates women KARL WIERSUM CWIERSUM@BUTLER.EDU

STAFF REPORTER

Performers from Butler University and from the Phoenix Theater take on the lives and hardships of women from around the world in their production of “Seven.”

The documentary play “Seven” will be performed at Butler University’s Lilly Hall Studio Theatre next week from Sept. 5 through Sept. 8.

Though there will be performances of the play in cities around the globe later this year, including shows in Japan, Sweden and Russia.

Created in 2006, the piece tells the stories of seven women living in different parts of the world.

Despite some dark shadows cast upon the women in the piece, William Fisher, chair of Butler’s theater department, said the play has an positive tone, in a certain sense.

“(It is) not optimistic because of what these women have had to overcome in getting success, but because in every case and in every story, these are people whose work is ongoing and continuing,” Fisher said.

When seven female playwrights were commissioned by Vital Voices, an organizations working to “bring visibility to extraordinary women around the world by unleashing their leadership potential,” the result was a piece that documents women surmounting obstacles and promoting the betterment of humanity.

Among these stories is that of a congresswomen from Guatemala who has devoted her life and career to promoting the rights of the poor.

She has received death threats for her work.

Another woman, from Pakistan, was gang raped. Instead of committing suicide as is socially expected, she has become an advocate for education reform.

Unlike a fictional narrative, Fisher said this documentary play cannot be finished.

“This is not a ‘problem solved at the end of the play’ play,” he said.

“Instead, it tells us “this is what happened, this is where we are, this is what it seems to have cost and this is how we continue.”

The script will be performed as a staged reading with relatively minimal production and staging, a format which Fisher said is best suited for the structure of the piece.

Five Butler theatre students and two actresses from the Phoenix Theater will portray the seven women whose stories are told.

Fisher said that collaborating with professionals from the Phoenix Theater for this performance seemed to be a natural decision.

“Students from Butler frequently perform for their theater in roles or as interns,” he said. “It seemed intuitive to bring (members of the Phoenix Theater) to our campus under the idea of community—a

Photo by Jaclyn McConnell

The “Seven” actresses rehearse their dialogue for the upcoming performance.

From left to right: Brittany Staten, Bridgette Richards, Veronica Orech, Diane Tsao Boehm, Andrea Marie Joseph, Kate Powell and Lauren Albert particularly suitable idea for this play.”

Butler senior Kate Powell, who portrays Russian Marina Pisklakova-Parker in the production, said that the most extraordinary aspect of performing in “Seven” is how different the script sounded being spoken versus being read in her head.

“There’s so much more impact

when someone is actually speaking the words,” Powell said.

A preview will take place next Thursday, followed by shows at 8 p.m. on the following three days.

Tickets are $5 for Butler students with ID and $15 for the public.

Tickets are free on Thursday with a reservation, which can be made at www.butler.edu/theatre/ productions/reservations.

More events to be ticketed this spring KEVIN VOGEL KJVOGEL@BUTLER.EDU ARTS, ETC. EDITOR

Photo courtesy of the Butler Speech and Debate Team

Butler debate and speech team members Matt Miller, Andrew Wray, Lauren Lupowski and Molly Kordas hold awards from the Marietta College competition.

Debate team hopes to attract new members with open call SARVARY KOLLER SKOLLER@BUTLER.EDU ARTS, ETC. ASST. EDITOR Butler University and the College of Communication are calling for all sharp-tongued students with a knack for public speaking to come check out the newly resurrected debate team.

The team has a legacy of competition across the Midwest, and each year Butler students are presented with the opportunity to become a part of this tradition.

Professor Casey Ryan Kelly, director of debate, said the debate team consists of Butler students from a wide range of academic fields.

Each member will participate in either on-campus or off-campus events.

On-campus events are directed toward students eager to jumpstart their involvement on the debate team, Kelly said.

Students interested in joining the team can attend regular weekly meetings to practice debate and help promote the team around campus.

Kelly said off-campus events require the participation of more

avid student debaters.

The debate team travels with the speech team to a handful of regional competitions throughout the year.

Students interested in competitive debate partner with one other student from the Butler team, and together they work to practice rhetoric skills in anticipation of future tournaments.

Each two-person team plans its speech with the help of Kelly and other peer members.

Kelly said Ellie Pierce, assistant debate and speech coach, is also available to assist students in their debate preparation.

Kelly said that the Butler debate team only attends parliamentary debate competitions.

As opposed to a normal policy debate, a parliamentary debate is more heavily invested in rules and points of procedure, and the speech topic changes from debate to debate. Students receive the topic a half-hour before they compete.

Kelly said competitive debate instills research and reasoning skills in students that will be crucial in the future.

“It builds the ability to think critically and interpret an argument,” Kelly said. “Those things have been useful in my own professional life, and it is a lifelong professional and personal skill.”

College of Communication Dean Gary Edgerton said he recognizes the importance of the debate team at Butler.

“Members learn oral speaking skills and the ability to get up on their feet and construct a coherent argument and express themselves,” Edgerton said.

“While it’s a fun pursuit, it’s also academic and personally helpful.”

Edgerton said he feels positive that the debate team will establish a professional identity on campus this year and set good footing for the future.

“This year is about identifying some talented and interested students and mentoring them,” Edgerton said. “It’s to let people know that a functioning debate team does in fact exist at Butler.”

The first debate team call-out meeting occurred on Monday, but interested students can contact Kelly at crkelly@butler.edu for more information.

Butler University community members will see an increase in the number of ticketed art events next semester with the opening of the Howard L. Schrott Center for the Performing and Visual Arts, administrators within the Jordan College of Fine Arts said.

“We think,” JCFA Dean Ronald Caltabiano said, “that we will be able to charge some very reasonable fees to some of our largest events in Schrott to help us stay afloat.”

He stressed “we think,” as the discussions are still in the early stages.

Caltabiano could not provide a specific amount that might be considered a “reasonable fee” but was confident that the specifics would be worked out soon.

He also said there will be a student price—already the case with other Butler art events.

The change in ticketing will most impact the music department, as main-stage theater and dance productions already require paid admission.

Specifically, the change will affect large music ensembles like the Butler Symphony Orchestra, the Butler Wind Ensemble and the Lyric Theater.

Dan Bolin, chair of the music department, said charging for tickets to concerts is not new for JCFA. Both he and Caltabiano said previously it was just impractical.

With box office fees, explained Bolin, the music school was losing money by charging for tickets.

Bolin said it will be practical with the Schrott Center, which will not cost nearly as much to use as renting Clowes did.

Bolin estimated that a Butler Symphony Orchestra or Wind Ensemble concert costs $4,000 to $5,000 to produce in Clowes.

The Butler Ballet spent more than

$51,000 on “Coppélia” last spring according to the dance office, and charged $14 to $28.50 per ticket.

Larry Attaway, chair of the dance department, said the ballet completely funds itself through its revenue. Ticket sales were around $16,500 for “Coppélia.”

Caltabiano said he thinks it is important that people put a value on art.

“Musicians don’t work for free in the real world,” he said. “We think that we need to clearly say that arts are valuable and worth paying for.”

Neither Caltabiano nor Bolin knows how the prices will affect attendance.

Caltabiano said that, in his experience, a professional ensemble that charges for admission sees higher attendance rates because people see it as valuable.

“The key is to keep it affordable for students,” he said. “There’s no doubt about that.”

If the result of the change is a larger audience, Bolin noted that the entire audience interested in the performance may not fit in the new Schrott Center, which will only seat around 450.

This may cause scheduling changes for the JCFA ensembles, such as an ensemble playing twoperformance weekends. He said that this is commonplace among professional ensembles.

Robert Grechesky, director of the wind ensemble, explained that because families already pay tens of thousands of dollars in tuition each year, it does not make sense to ask them to pay extra to see the productions.

Grechesky said that there must be ticket packages for families, and Caltabiano seemed open to the idea.

The Collegian will report updates as the discussions begin to take more solid form. For now, it seems that no one quite knows how the fees will ultimately affect art at Butler.

Boyd to play monumental piano piece JOHN DANIELAK JDANIELA@BUTLER.EDU

STAFF REPORTER

Photo courtesy of Kate Boyd

Kate Boyd will perform “Sonatas and Interludes for Prepared Piano” on Tuesday at 7:30 p.m.

On Sept.

4, Butler University’s Kate Boyd will be performing the renowned “Sonatas and Interludes for Prepared Piano” by American composer John Cage in celebration of the 100th anniversary of Cage’s birth.

Boyd, the head of the piano department in the Jordan College of Fine Arts, spent her semester-long sabbatical last spring mastering the piece.

Since then, Boyd has performed the piece in Ontario, Oklahoma and England.

“John Cage has become more and more listenable as our ears and experiences have expanded.”

DANIEL BOLIN MUSIC DEPARTMENT CHAIR

“Being the 100th anniversary, I wanted to perform the piece as a way to commemorate Cage,” Boyd said.

Cage has been called

one of the most influential composers of the 20th century, and “Sonatas and Interludes” is arguably his most complex work for prepared piano.

Cage specially altered a standard concert piano by adding screws and bolts to 45 strings. This distorts the sound of the piano, producing percussive sounds.

Boyd said that one of Cage’s main philosophies is to appreciate all noise as music and understand that people should not privilege music over traffic or any other noise.

Cage composed “Sonatas and Interludes for Prepared Piano” from 1946 to 1949. The

piece contains 16 different sonatas and four interludes, combining for a total of 65 minutes.

“John Cage used to be so far out that it seemed like he was from another planet,” Daniel Bolin, chair of the music department, said, “but John Cage has become more and more listenable as our ears and experiences have expanded. He’s not a farout composer by any means anymore.”

The performance will take place in the Eidson-Duckwall Recital Hall at 7:30 p.m. next Tuesday. The show is free and open to the public.

OPINION

PAGE 10 the butler

COLLEGIAN The Butler watchdog and voice for BU students

4600 Sunset Ave. Indianapolis, IN 46208

Kill the rumors, address why TKE closed OUR POINT THIS WEEK: Administrators should have an open discussion about TKE’s closing, or be prepared for rumors to run rampant. Vote: 32-1-0

Office Information: Fairbanks Rm 210 News Line: (317) 940-8813 Advertising Line: (317) 940-9358 collegian@butler.edu Adviser Line: (317) 940-9772

Administrators have a chance to show they take risky behavior seriously.

FALL 2012 EDITORIAL STAFF Jill McCarter Editor in Chief Colin Likas Managing Editor Tara McElmurry News Editor Ryan Lovelace Asst. News Editor Reid Bruner Opinion Editor Kevin Vogel Arts, Etc. Editor Sarvary Koller Asst. Arts, Etc. Editor Marissa Johnson Sports Editor Austin Monteith Asst. Sports Editor Mary Allgier Multimedia Editor Matt Rhinesmith Assoc. Multimedia Editor Rafael Porto Photography Editor Heather Iwinski Asst. Photography Editor Lauren Stark Copy Chief Taylor Meador Design Editor Ali Hendricks Advertising Manager Adviser: Loni McKown

The Butler Collegian is published weekly on Wednesdays with a controlled circulation of 2,600. The Collegian office is located in the Fairbanks Center in room 210.

The Collegian is printed at The Greenfield Reporter in Greenfield, Ind. The Collegian maintains a subscription to MCT Services Campus wire service.

The Collegian editorial staff determines the editorial policies; the opinions expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of The Collegian or Butler University, but of the writers clearly labeled.

As outlined in The Collegian’s staff manual, the student staff of The Collegian shall be allowed the widest degree of latitude for the free discussion and will determine the content and format of their publication without censorship or advance approval. A copy of these policies is on file in The Collegian office.

The Collegian accepts advertising from a variety of campus organizations and local businesses and agencies. All advertising decisions are based on the discretion of the ad manager and editor in chief. For a copy of The Collegian advertising rates, publication schedule and policies, please call 317-940-9358 or send an e-mail to the advertising staff at advertising@butler.edu.

For subscriptions to The Collegian, please send a check to the main address above. Subscriptions are $45 per academic year.

Corrections Policy

The Collegian staff makes an effort to be as accurate as possible. Corrections of fact may be submitted to The Collegian and will be printed at the next publication date.

Letters to the Editor Policy

The Collegian accepts letters to the editor no later than noon on the Sunday before publication.

Letters to the editor must be emailed to collegian@butler.edu and contain a phone number at which you can be reached. Letters can also be mailed to The Collegian office.

The Collegian reserves the right to edit letters for spelling, style, clarity and length. Letters must be kept to a length of 450 words. Contact The Collegian for questions. Exceptions to these policies may be made at the editorial board’s discretion.

WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 29, 2012

Illustration by Jill McCarter

After an investigation, an unsuccessful appeal and the removal of three Greek letters, Tau Kappa Epsilon no longer has a place at Butler University.

Anyone not involved knows nothing about why the doors closed, and everyone who is involved isn’t talking—opening the floodgates for nasty rumors and speculation.

Butler officials are in a position to take an opportunity to show how the university takes students’ bad behavior seriously, yet they have shied away from taking a stand.

The speculation—the rumors of hazing, the thought of sexual misconduct and the possibility of poor academic standing—will be heard over their silence and vague answers.

In the end, it serves in the best interest of everyone in the Butler community to dispel the rumors and reveal why a fraternity that had been here for more than six decades suddenly disappeared from campus.

The community could have greatly benefited from having an open, honest and transparent conversation with administrators.

Instead, the Butler community was left with a vague email over the summer and general comments from university officials.

In “TKE chapter shut down” (Aug. 22), President Jim Danko said that the charges against the organization were serious enough that people were at risk.

The TKEs were not acting as they should have and were violating university policy, a communications director with the TKE’s national headquarters said.

Even more troubling is that

Danko and Vice President of Student Affairs Levester Johnson were both quick to say that TKE had been under the university’s magnifying glass for quite some time—three to four years.

If people were at risk because of what TKE members were doing, those actions should not have carried on for three to four years.

Despite university policy violations and risky behavior, the only thing any administrators or the national headquarters will reveal is a laundry list of what could have gone wrong with the chapter—anything from academic performance to dayto-day chapter operations to recruitment and hazing.

Those reasons don’t stack up evenly.

Hazing is far riskier behavior than not having enough pledges or maintaining a good gradepoint average. They should not be equated.

When administrators removed Phi Delta Theta from campus in fall 2002, rumors flooded across campus and students were coming up with their own versions of the story.

Speculations about drugs and hazing rituals littered the campus and cast a terrible light on the issue.

It wasn’t until the chapter was reinstated six years later that administrators put those rumors to rest.

It wasn’t hazing, they said, and it had nothing to do with drugs—it was because of low recruitment numbers.

Had the university been honest and upfront in the first place, it would have saved them time spent trying to clean up the damage the rumors caused.

Today, administrators find themselves in the same position past administrators were in a decade ago.

And they should do what past administrators did not—squash the rumors and address the issue at hand.

Meters Bring in Money, Help Parking Crunch Removing the parking meters on campus will not make a significant improvement for Butler’s parking situation.

If there’s a word on the lips of Butler University student, staff and faculty, that word is parking.

Last year, the university sold more than 1,400 passes more than spaces it provided.

Now, with housing at capacity and construction everywhere, parking looks like a long-term issue on campus.

Parking meters may seem like an annoying compromise, but eliminating them will not solve the parking crisis.

Students might find it easy to look at the parking shortage and offer their own solutions.

The casual observer might see parking meters as a partial fix to the parking problem.

The logic seems simple—make more spaces for pass-holders, starting with the currently metered spaces.

But with (comparably) few meters—44 by this reporter’s count—to convert, no meaningful change could be made.

Parking meters help cover costs at Butler and take only a marginal amount of space.

They also offer spaces for people in a rush and visitors.

I am not always the biggest fan of the meters.

JEREMY ALGATE

I collected a few tickets last year when I slept through my alarm and needed to get to campus fast.

As a last resort, the meters serve perfectly, but I decided to skip the change.

Parking services did not decide to skip on the tickets.

The parking meters make $12,000 to $14,000 a year, Ben Hunter, chief of staff and executive director of public safety, said.

He did not mention how much of that money came through parking tickets on a certain black Chevrolet Cobalt or any other illegally parked car.

So no one should assume the spaces go unused.

“They’re used every day,” Hunter said, but because construction blocks some of the spaces, the revenue will be down this year.

BUPD is considering upgrading the meters to be compatible with an iPhone application.

The department may apply for a grant to help make the upgrade in the future.

In the meantime, the solution to the parking crisis needs to be bigger and more dramatic.

Jury-rigging solutions—like painting spaces down Boulevard

Photo by Heather Iwinski

Place or consuming the meters— will only delay the inevitable.

The Collegian reported in April that Butler currently is searching for a private partner to help construct a parking garage.

That solution seems best: ample parking with minimal changes to

campus, assuming a partner comes forward.

In the meantime, it appears no simpler, faster solutions will do.

Contact columnist Jeremy Algate at jalgate@butler.edu

WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 29, 2012

THE BUTLER COLLEGIAN | PAGE 11

Undercover cops arrive, student safety leaves Increased crackdown at campus parties sends a message of fear, weakens trust between students and police.

DONALD PERIN

Indiana State Excise Police may look like college kids, but they do not walk into parties looking to drink and socialize.

They have come to find and cite the publicly-intoxicated, underage drinkers and those providing alcohol to minors.

The excise police recently implemented their Intensified College Enforcement program.

This program started last spring at Indiana University, DePauw University and Ball State University, according to The Indianapolis Star.

The overall goal of the excise police’s mission is to prevent high profile incidents, such as the Lauren Spierer disappearance at IU last year.

However their presence on campus creates an environment of fear and mistrust.

Butler students saw what the excise police were capable of when they issued 258 citations at IU, 57 at Ball State and 32 at Notre Dame last weekend.

Ben Hunter, Butler’s chief of staff and executive director of public safety, said that it would be unlikely to see numbers that high at Butler.

“I encourage folks just to follow the law,” he said, “have you ever been to a Butler house party with 300 kids?”

Hunter also said that the excise police have been present on Butler’s campus during each of his four years here.

“This is just a more publicized campaign, Hunter said, “[The excise police] don’t want to see Indiana students end up in the paper.”

While it is good to try to prevent students from getting into trouble or getting hurt,

creating the atmosphere of a police state is not the solution.

I equate the situation to sex education in junior high.

It’s better to inform kids about how to practice safe sex as opposed to just telling them it’s wrong.

College students will always drink alcohol, and underage students will always find ways to get alcohol.

It’s inevitable, just like kids will have sex whether they’re educated about it or not.

The state of Indiana should focus on educating college students on alcohol safety.

Sophomore dance major Rachel Schmidt said she’s too scared to go out.

“I hope they won’t be here long, but it seems like people are making a big deal about it, Schmidt said, “people will adapt but they will be less likely to seek BUPD’s help.”

Not only are upperclassmen scared to go out at night, freshmen feel frightened as well.

Freshman exploratory business major Mike Schau said he expects the excise police will be around campus occasionally to keep them on students’ minds.

“They’re affecting the campus’ atmosphere because you don’t know who to trust,” Schau said.

While the excise police may keep some students off the streets by creating a frightening atmosphere, partying will continue.

Contact columnist Donald Perin at dperin@butler.edu.

Butler should notify students about new alcohol policy Unless administrators better explain the new alcohol policy, then they should not expect students to know it.

RHYAN HENSON

If upperclassmen are as punishable as freshmen for alcohol violations, then they should receive the same information the freshman do.

Over the summer, the administration revamped the alcohol policy on campus.

The administration forbade freshmen from going inside Greek houses until after last Monday.

Another policy change is that there are no fines for alcohol violations.

Instead, students will have to do a community restoration activity that decreases the negative effects of alcohol consumption in and around campus.

Anyone on conduct probation will be prohibited from participating in Greek life and from holding a position of leadership.

These may be logical punishments, but if no one knows what activities to avoid, they become unfair.

Residence halls will be asked to hang up posters notifying students the legal drinking age is 21 Irene Stevens, dean of student life, said.

Also, they must take part in programs in the fall and spring concerning alcohol and alcohol abuse.

These program may be informational, but some students will inevitably begin drinking as school wears on.

If the administration is going to attempt to protect freshmen by keeping them out of Greek houses, then it also should protect the rest of the students and seek a better way to inform them.

Even if that is through email, at least administrators can say they told us somehow.

The most important fact that the administration failed to inform the student body about is the passing of the Indiana Lifeline law.

This law guarantees that someone can notify authorities that another individual under 21 needs medical attention due to drinking alcohol without fear of punishment.

Instead of putting up posters notifying people that the legal drinking age is 21, the administration should be telling students about these policy changes.

Most people would rather have the ability to mitigate an emergency than read about the drinking age limit, which students know unless they come from another country or lived under a rock for most of their adult lives.

The administration is taking the right steps to prevent alcohol abuse on campus, especially since Butler has witnessed an increase in alcohol-related incidents and emergencies in the past two years said Vice President for Student Affairs Levester Johnson.

The administrators could reach out a little bit more.

They could drop a quick postcard in student mailboxes.

They could send an email outlining the new policy.

Or they could just put up posters giving a quick rundown of the changes.

Honestly, any details they hand out would be beneficial.

Contact columnist Rhyan Henson at rhenson@butler.edu.

Change privacy policy now, protect future students While the updated privacy policy offers more protection than before, it could still use improvement.

REID BRUNER

Before clicking the send button, Butler University community members should remember that administrators could read their personal emails and messages.

Although Butler updated its privacy policy a few years ago, it should be further revised to ensure no one can breach students’ privacy.

Both Chief Information Officer Scott Kincaid and Ben Hunter, chief of staff and executive director of public safety, said that the administration avoids abusing this power.

“We have had to access a student email account less than a half-dozen times… over the last eleven years,” Kincaid said, “I can’t over-communicate how rare it would be.”

Hunter said he only has requested access to a student’s accounts twice.

One instance was to allow a family to see a student’s emails after the student committed suicide.

Another time, a student went missing, and Hunter requested student account access to further the investigation In both of these cases, the context of the situation may have made the breach of students’ accounts acceptable.

While the current administration’s restraint is commendable, it does not answer all concerns regarding this issue.

The present administration may avoid delving into students’ private information, but without proper safeguards, nothing

prevents future administrators from violating students’ privacy.

Butler updated its policy after the 2009 Jess Zimmerman case—Butler University vs. John Doe—which marked the first time a university sued one of its students.

Zimmerman, a sophomore at the time, wrote a private blog criticizing the administration.

After reading messages sent through his BUmail account, the administration took further action.

Eventually, this led to the university filing a lawsuit against Zimmerman.

In the end, they settled out of court.

The policy created in wake of this case— called the Privacy of Personally Created Content— handed Butler students more safeguards for their privacy than before.

Before a student’s account can be accessed, the chief information officer, the administrator who wants access and another administrator acting as a third party must approve the procedure.

Still, this fails to provide enough protection for students.

Other administrations could find ways to bypass the privacy policy years down the line by colluding when they wanted to investigate a student’s emails.

They could meet with other deans, directors or vice presidents to ensure everyone agreed to sign on.

Through this prior cooperation, they could

Photo by Rafael Porto

Through certain procedures outlined in the Privacy of Personally Created Content policy, administrators can be granted access to student accounts. use this necessary three-signature policy to single out naysayers.

This hypothetical situation might sound a bit extreme, but Butler administrators must consider how their policies may affect students in years to come.

Administrators should encourage the privacy policy’s evolution instead of letting it stagnate.

As the policy stands, students’ accounts can be accessed for a myriad of reasons, from limiting the spread of spam to acting on a search warrant.

What the policy does not address is the difference in access provided in these different situations.

Cases where administrators investigate an account because they have “reasonable suspicion” that a student will break state law or university code are possible, provided that the other necessary signatures are present.

However, when high levels of spam compromise an account, Information Technology can access the account and fix the problem without perusing students’ private messages.

This repair of a student’s account is far different from a full-blown investigation of messages.

Butler should change its policy to only allow access of student accounts during situation where the network could be damaged or a student has disappeared.

Let administrators and investigators look through public documents or do a Google search if they have concerns about a student.

Otherwise, any potential criminals will have already accomplished their goal— breaking apart community and trust at Butler.

Contact opinion editor Reid Bruner at rmbruner@ butler.edu.

PawPrints What did you forget to pack?

by Heather Iwinski

“I’m a commuter, but I’ve forgotten a notebook for class.”

Cierra Mercier junior Communication sciences and disorders

“My fitted bedsheet and my sandals.”

Lucas Shafer senior Music education

“I brought my stapler, but I forgot staples.”

Lindsey Downs freshman Exploratory

“I forgot my toothbrush holder and my toothpaste.”

Heather Tinkle junior Biology

Bulldogs about Butler Photos by Rafael Porto and Heather Iwinski

Top left: A bulldog donning a pharmacist’s coat sits in a corner of the Pharmacy Building.

Top right: A depiction of students riding a school bus is seen on the side of a bulldog in Jordan Hall.

Bottom left: A bulldog dressed as an orchestra conductor rests atop a box with piano keys painted on it inside Clowes Memorial Hall.

Bottom right: A Beethoven look-alike bulldog gives a stern glance to passersby in Lilly Hall.