Vol. CXXXVI—No. 53
Nursing home looks to respond to injunction
Tuesday, April 10, 2012
columbiaspectator.com
M’ville group appoints director
FRESHMAN TENNIS STAR
BY CASEY TOLAN Spectator Senior Staff Writer A Jewish Home Lifecare spokesperson responded Monday to criticism of the organization’s plan to build a 20-story nursing home on the Upper West Side, days after the state Supreme Court temporarily halted the plan. Jewish Home wants to move from its current location, on 106th Street between Amsterdam and Columbus avenues, to a new site on 97th Street between Amsterdam and Columbus avenues—a parking lot in the middle of the Park West Village housing complex. But in an injunction last week, the state Supreme Court maintained that the Park West residents were guaranteed the parking area, meaning Jewish Home will need to get approval from a state agency before moving ahead. The Jewish Home spokesperson, Ethan Geto, CC ’65, told Spectator that the organization is figuring out how to respond to the injunction. “Jewish Home is reviewing its legal options in the litigation, but in any case is committed and determined to move forward with our plans to build on the 97th Street site,” Geto said. “I can’t say any more on the specifics of the legalities—the judgment just came down and has to be evaluated.” Some locals have argued that the Jewish Home building’s height will be detrimental to its elderly residents, which Geto called a “terribly uninformed criticism,” pointing out that many hospitals are just as high. “In Jewish Home’s present campus, there’s not one resident who lives on the ground floor,” he said. “Some of our buildings go as high as seven floors ... they’re all using elevators to get downstairs.” Furthermore, Geto said, hospital patients are often less ambulatory than nursing home residents, and many hospitals are still high-rises. The elevators in Jewish Home’s new building would be fast and modern, he added. Some critics, though, have said that Jewish Home’s new building would be the highest nursing home in the country. Geto said that “the height is irrelevant.” “Let’s say for argument’s sake it’s the tallest nursing home,” he said. “It’s also going to be the most progressive, the most modern nursing home that’s being built in an urban environment with a unionized workforce.” But Catherine Unsino, a Park West Village tenant and nursing home reform advocate who has been outspoken on the issue, said she wasn’t convinced. “There are some hospitals, of course, that are high, but people in hospitals are there for a short stay,” she said. “They’re not spending their lives in a hospital.” And needing to take an elevator would be a major inconvenience for some residents, she said. “When a person is in a wheelchair or has a walker, and if they’re frail, if you’re up many stories it can be hard to get downstairs even with an elevator,” she said. “It’s a problem in every nursing home, and none of them are 20 stories—it’s just unheard of.” Unsino, who has been a consultant for nursing homes across the country, said that she recently participated in a webinar with
Boateng to plan allocation of Harlem benefits BY JILLIAN KUMAGAI Spectator Senior Staff Writer
president, and South Africa nominated Nigerian Finance Minister Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, also on behalf of several developing nations. Ocampo has also served as Colombia’s minister of agriculture and rural development, as the United Nations’
The West Harlem Development Corporation has hired an executive director to devise a long-term plan to dole out the $76 million that Columbia promised Manhattanville. The WHDC announced on Monday that Kofi Boateng, the founder and chief executive officer of Traders International and the former chief operating officer of the World Trade Center Association, would serve as its executive director. It’s a significant logistical step for the development corporation, which has taken heat from politicians and locals for its delayed start in allocating the money that the University is giving West Harlem in the wake of its campus expansion. “I’m thrilled to be a part of the West Harlem Local Development Corporation—an organization that will make a huge difference for the people of Harlem for many years to come,” Boateng said in a statement. “Mr. Boateng’s vast experience and proven track record of managing large non-profit
SEE OCAMPO, page 2
SEE WHDC, page 2
ALYSON GOULDEN / SENIOR STAFF PHOTOGRAPHER
FOCUS AND DRIVE
|
Freshman Winston Lin’s on-court mentality has led him to a 17-1 record this season. SEE BACK PAGE.
SIPA prof Ocampo campaigning for World Bank presidency BY YASMIN GAGNE Spectator Senior Staff Writer School of International and Public Affairs professor José Antonio Ocampo will be interviewed today for the presidency of the World Bank, although he faces steep competition for the job. Ocampo, a former Colombian
finance minister who now teaches global economics at SIPA, was nominated for president of the World Bank by Brazil on behalf of several developing nations. Developing nations have been seeking to challenge United States and European dominance of the World Bank, and Ocampo said that these nations “asked for
CVs of candidates to choose who they thought were credible to represent developing countries.” “That’s why I got involved. I was asked to send my CV,” Ocampo told Spectator. “I was very skeptical.” The United States nominated Dartmouth College President Jim Yong Kim for World Bank
3333 residents meet with management BY MILES JOHNSON Spectator Staff Writer
BY EMILY NEIL Spectator Senior Staff Writer
Residents of 3333 Broadway and the building’s management company moved one step closer to resolving concerns over a new security plan last week. The new security system— which is in the process of being implemented by the management company, Urban American—requires tenants to swipe into the housing complex using special identification cards containing their pictures and other personal information, including which of the complex’s five towers they live in.
“What we have here is a failure to communicate between tenants and management.” —Alicia Barksdale, Tenants’ Association president
The building’s Tenants’ Association and representatives from Urban American met to discuss the security plans for the first time on Wednesday, following several months of tension. At the meeting, Tenants’ Association President Alicia Barksdale said that a lack of communication between management and tenants has prevented a resolution to the conflict. “Tenants are very angry or upset with management, because this is the first time they’ve
NYC health commissioner talks public health policy on campus
FILE PHOTO
SECURITY CONCERNS | Residents of 3333 Broadway met with building management over concerns about a new security system.
New York City’s top health official visited a Columbia classroom yesterday to discuss the city’s past and present public health issues. Health Commissioner Thomas Farley told the Fundamentals of Global Health class, taught by Mailman School of Public Health professors Alastair Ager and Marni Sommer, that he wanted to “talk about the way in which we think about public health in New York City.” “I’m biased in this, but I think it is a way which can help around the globe,” he said. Farley walked the class through the history of public health in New York, describing the shift from infectious diseases, which were the leading causes of death in the 19th and early 20th centuries, to chronic diseases, such as heart disease and lung cancer, which are now the leading causes of death throughout the country. Farley cited smoking, obesity, high blood pressure, alcohol use, and physical inactivity as a few of the most important individual risk factors for those diseases, saying they are the “key things we want to be focusing on.” “These are our priority health problems—or to put it this way, my to-do list as public health commissioner of New York City,” he said. Farley said that in order to combat modern chronic diseases, which are rooted in particular behaviors like smoking and bad eating habits, it is necessary to look to the “solution of the era of infectious
diseases and epidemics.” The solutions in that era, Farley said, were based in environmental changes. Those solutions included more sanitary workplaces and living spaces, and an increased effort to make safe water, safe food, and solid waste disposal available throughout the city. Farley cited recent legal efforts and social media messaging by the city’s Health Commission—aimed at reducing smoking and unhealthy eating—as similarly concrete environmental changes that will impact individuals’ behaviors.
“I was glad to know that everything I’ve learned is being applied for the greater good.” —Kainee Aguilar, CC ’15
Farley asked students in the class to discuss smoking and obesity, as well as ethical issues related to public health, choosing students at random from the class roster to answer questions. He also answered students’ questions about local health issues. In response to a question about a proposed campus-wide smoking ban at Columbia, Farley said that he would favor such a ban over the current policy, which
met with us,” Barksdale said in an interview. Doryne Isley, a portfolio manager for Urban American who attended the meeting, declined to comment. But Brian Moriarty, a spokesperson for Urban American, said on Monday that the company is working to improve communication with building residents. “Moving forward, we will communicate directly with residents as well, since it appears the Tenants’ Association has
not been providing them with the updates and information,” Moriarty said in an email. The 35-story, 1,200-unit housing complex is located on 133rd Street, where it overlooks the site of Columbia’s Manhattanville expansion project. Last spring, Columbia provided free air conditioning units to residents with windows facing the construction site, so that they could keep their windows
A&E, PAGE 7
OPINION, PAGE 4
SPORTS, BACK PAGE
EVENTS
WEATHER
Music collab. brings new artists daily
Cross-cultural affairs
Baseball faces St. John’s in Queens
Define ‘American’
Today
This week, students will get an extra dose of local music—and free food— in anticipation of Bacchanal through Postcrypt and Live at Lerner.
Seize the daylight
SEE JHL, page 2
Po Linn Chia says studying abroad teaches more than just culture.
Kathryn Brill says the best time to prioritize friendships is now.
SEE 3333, page 2
The Light Blue will attempt to defeat St. John’s for the first time in nine years before beginning divisional play against Cornell.
Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Jose Antonio Vargas shares his experiences as an undocumented immigrant. 106 Jerome Greene Hall, 6 p.m.
SEE HEALTH, page 2
61°/ 39°
Tomorrow
55°/ 41°