Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
! !" ! # "%
# $$
%$&%$'$()
!*+ *,,"
-" #".#+/ + "%
+#
!
, +/!+ "
0 1 (&$$
(2 (3
(1 (&$(
!
"
#
!
!
$%&$'&! #
# ( )
*
( ! . "
-
1 #
0 7 8 7 "
2-8 :68 "
+, /
! -
6! 7 8
$3# ! 6 )
0
(
4&
)8 (
2 0 )
-!
4&
0
8 ;
-
3
5 #
)8
/
+! % 2 $
(
+!
( !
)
0! 9
%
( <
"
" 1
$
6!
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
30
4&
#
! # <
#
!
# 1
#
4&
! # (
=
1
=
5
! # <
= #
% 8 +!
(
8 ;; 7 + "
(
8
+!
5
)
%
-
$
!1
!
6
)
+ >
1 ; ! 1
" 0
*
36
"
*
<
4&
!
0
6
! # <
6
!
#
( $3
$3=
0
#
#
(
,
4&
7!
#
! # (
5
, ,
,
0
! # < !
6 !
!
!
! # )
?
#
) 8
0 ! @
0 ;
"
$
8
"#
# )
2
8
8
6
3+B !
3 8
;
4&
(
66
66 $ 66
2
; ;
8
"#
"#
= 8
8
0
8
66
4& ;
!
2! .
8 8=
"
A ;
!
0 "
0A1 $# 2
"
& 66
" 66
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
0
#
2
# 3
! #
,
8
>
8
8
8
# ,
#
6
#
> !4 $)
>
8
8
8
8
C !&
0
#
8
#
=
# #
6 #
,
2 $
4&! #
3 3<
A
)
0
D0 4 $3)
( 4&! 0
; /
# 82
8
)
>
8
8
E* >
' $)&
#
=
8
'
#
!
G!4
# >
6
=
)
! ! 8
8
3
!
8
;
2
8
5HH
#
! ! 5HH ! 5
>
!4 # 8
8
8
I;
8 8 # ! !
#
2
6 ;
6
2
2
;
)
3
F -
7
8
2
2
8
2 ! # (
$
3; D
2 +
8
5
4&! *6
2
I
H
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
# (
8
8
?
2)
=
1
8
-
.
-
.
%
8
4 $*6
! -
.!%!
3
4
&! )
4&
2!
8
2 3
8
.!%!
$3.!%! 4&!
! ! 5HH ! 5
2
2
! ! 5HH ! 5 *6
6
A !
HH $3.!%! HH4&
$3*6 2
%
! ! 5HH ! 8
"
>
#
! )
E* K '
#
8
>
8
2
! #
)
E* -
'$ &$ &! )
8 !
8
8
2
8
B " ! #
)
)
E* -
'
2
E* -
' $ &$J&
$?&!
#
55
,
8 2
/
,
! #
3
)
E* -
2
8
4
'$ &$ &! ;
# 8
,
8 8
! ) 8
-
.
%
A ! ?
$3.!%! ? 4&
8
8
> 8 8
;
.!%! ?
2
(
!
!
8 8
#
8 ! .!%! J
HH
8 *6 ! ! ?H? !
.!%! HH ,
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
8 #
,$ ) &
! .!%! HH
! ! 5HH ! H
,
8
2
! !*+ *,,"0 ;
4! *#+"
)
0
8
8
!
8
8
8
-
8
8 #
2 "
!
8
8
! $
*/ # #
0
5
6*+! "
8
2
.!%! ;
#
; 0
!
8
! ! 5HH ! 5 ,
8
3
F-G
=
0
8 *6 8
C 55&
=
.!%! HH
2
!
.!%!
2
6 8
1
*6
4
" /
5$+&
>
!4 $)
;;
! ;
-
)
3 ;
! ! 5HH !
2
;;
;E
"
) ! E* -
'
2
6
8
3
8
-
8 *6
!4 $)
CH &! ;;;
8
''!? *6 8
! 0
8
*6
2
B ;*
) ?
.!%!
8 #
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
B )
8
!
0
)
E* -
'
8 /
=
8 2
;;;
;*
! ; E
"
2
6
3
8
8 ;
#
!4 $)
* 0 8
#
CH?&! 8
6
4 $)
C ??&
2 ;
-
*;;; 0 # (
)
/
3
*;;; -
J
2
!
! ! 5HH ! $ &
-
)
,
;* -
$%&$ &!
!"*+#"
0
8
E;
E;;
.!%! HH
,
$<&$ & 2
8 )
8
,
E;
,
8
,
8 8!
,
2
8
8 .!%!
/
?H? !
)
)
8
.!%!
8
HH
! !
, E* -
#
'$ &$ &
/
8
!
E;
8
.!%! HH
)
E* -
'
#
! ! 5HH !5J 2 , ! 8
8
E;;
4
55
E*
E;
8
.!%!
HH ,
HH
-
3 '$ &
)
8
2 E;;
,
8
! .!%! 8
2
8
! ; E;*
E* ,
"2
! '
/ ,
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
;
E;;; 0
8
2
2
3
4
8 ! .!%! HH
) ! ! 5HH ! H
8 !
8 E* -
2 8
0
8
! ! 5HH ! H
" !
'$ &$ &
.!%!
HH
2
! ! 5HH ! H$%&
,
2
2 2 8
! ;
/
2
E;;;
E*;
"
2
2
#
! <
E*;; 0
.!%! ? 2
)
/
8
8 2
)
8
#
)
H
8
2
*; 0
8 .!%!
3- 8 -
2 /
4
8
4! *#+"
?$ &
3
(
.!%! 2
! ; ;; -
1
.!%! HH
!
#7 /8 !
0
'$ & .!%! 2 8
=
# '
E* -
8 @
<
)
8
;; -
/
=
! ;
*;; 0
8
?$ &
2
4 )
.!%! B
! !+/*+4 # 7 3
0 >
*+4 8* )
0 ,
H
#
!4
2 0
8
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
8 CC
8
>
8
5!& 2 0
8
#
8
! $)
8
8
8
! $)
0
CC J!&
8 ! $)
CCJ ' H L!& #
2
) ! $)
0
C?!& #
2
0
8
# 2
8
8
8
! $)
, +/!+ "0
C
# *#+" #
!&
*"6*"" !
"
8
8
!
%$'&
$ & 0
8$ &0
# 2
0
3;
8
"
! !
A+
L? $
! )
H #
- !5
8!
!4 H 'L
8
$%&$'&
8 '
8
H&!
2
3 8 -!
J
!4 5 H A!+!
H?5 $ H?&
J # !
8
! !
2 "#
! A ! L)0 8
)0
'H
#
5 5
!
! ! )
8
8
? 'H! ;
2
8 $
! #
8
8
$ &$'&
!A !
#
" 8
8 L
!
!
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
% & H # >
- !5 5 L 5
'J5 A!+!
8
/
LL! -
8
2
! )
8 2
!
,
#
-!
5
J
?H A+
5H $ H &M ;
8
2
/ &
2 /
8
""
2
/ / ! ! $+
' = )
8 8
)
! ; 8 , &!
8
2
! 8
8
/
$ &
2
M $ &
/
8
"
2 )
8
)
)
/ ( "
8 2 86 /
C "
$
'
H&
?'
-! !
"M $ &
% 2 ! &!
! A ! ')0+
)
8
/ J '! 7
! ! ! #
)0
2
/ 8
/
$5&
)**+, ! ,-)-* CC H 5O '# & L' #
?J H C
!
8
8
H'
!+ 8
$%&$'& ? 'H C ! $+
8
2
B
$
A !
8
8
3
$
5'! 7
8
/ -
'
M
N ' !N %
/
!4 $
/
$5& 3
. ! $B
- !5 J? J' H &!
8
B /
4$ &
2
/
"# !
2
"
! !A ! ' )
0
!
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
!*+ *,,"
#
=
!-
!+/*+4 !" * *9 +" #
> ,
1
#
-
' #
!A !
)0 'H
0! 9
-
- ! 5''
#
#
6
)
)8 )
003
0 2 0
%
$
6! 7 8
(
)
" <
8
;
8
,
)
8
,
/
,
-
! !
/
-
2
8
!4 0
&
/
# "
7 "
" 1
, /
8
3 ,
2
2
! )
8
/
8
8
3
!4
0
#
, 8
5 5
CC H 5!
>
#
8
2
,
>
! 0
2
0
8
2;
8
! 0
0
2 $)8
!
>
!
-
8
$ ?J&O 2
5 A!+!
(
"
/
8 #
8
!
?55?! )
6! 7 8
"
8
2
&
! .!5
6
#
!& 2
) )
,
, 8
8
)8 !
2
)8
! )8
/ 2
2 -8
8 : 68
8 ;
2
!
I 2 !
8
!
!
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
@
#
2
8
)
!
,
,
! )8 !
!4 C 5H! $
'
!
0
#
+ )8
4
)8 2 ;
2;
2! 3)
8
2
H#
- ! 5 H'
#
!
)
!
2
2
) ! E* K'
! 0
#
2
!4 $)
C L?&! ! )
!
2
8 >
! )
8
)8 8
, 2;
!
"
)
2;
2; !
!2
2
8
8 ! )8
2
)8
)8
8! )
2 ! )8
# &
8
/ ! )
,
-
)
)
2
,
8
2
8 8
! ;
8
-
/
5' A!+!
8
,
2;
8 JJ J
,
M 3
-
8
?H' &!
)
)8
8
,
2
8
! )
8!
0
,
0
8
8
# #
! ( 7
"
2
-
! 7
= +
6
7 "
-
6
2
) -
-
) ! 0
! !
"
7 8
%
!
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
0
8 8! -
0
8 )
,
*6
! 0
2
8
# 8
/
B
,
,
8
)**+, ! ,-)-* CH! ;
8!
2
/
2
!
" 8
)
,
2 8
! )
8
0
,
<
< ?H? !
2 6
=
$ &
<
2
8
'
B
2
! =
.
# 0
!
= !
8
! ! ?H? !
0
L
0
$%&! 0
, ! !
, =
< <
! )
0 8
<
M
2
2
B <
! ; )
, 8
=
8
,
,
,
8 !
!
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
!*+ *,," !#, ; + !
# 8,, / #+7 +:8 * " 8< *7 " "87; !*+ *,," # # 5
8 > #
2
"
! ;
? 'H C ! 0 9 2
!A !
(
8 /
2
3
8
! -
0
8
8 8
7 8
2
9
8
/
/ 8
8
8 ! 0
8
!
! )
0 #
< ! -
"1
8
1
2
#
8 8
8
2
8
! 0
! ' !
8 8
8
8
8
8
) !(
1
5 0
2 #
!
2
>
8
,
8
8
8
! ;
2
8 ! )
8
8
! ; !1
2
0
)
21
! /
2
)0
)
!4 A
0
;#"
!
0
-
+ #6 !+/*+4
3
$
!
)
*,, !-
8
8
1 8
0
2
2
5
1
" 8 /
8
2
8! = 8
8 2
8
8
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
/ ! ' !
! 1
/
/
5 - + *, !*+ *,," !- 8,, / #+7 +:8 * " *,, + #6 ;#" #, ; + ! 8< *7 !*+ *,," # # !!+/*+4 7!8" ; * , =8 " / * # / "" ; * +:8 * "
+
2
8
2
2
/
! 8
#
8
!$
/
7 8
8
8 !
>
8
/ 2
!
! ' !
2
8
2
2
2 2
8
2
8 2 ! 7 8
,
!5
8
8
7 8
8 8
/
8
8
" 8
#
8 ! . 2 2
" !A ! ) " 0
2 " 7 8 8 . 8 8 H# J5H C?L > 2! ) !) 8!
> ( # 7 8
9
*6
8 >
8
8
! #
8 . 8 8 8 8
8 / 8
% !0 8
J
! ;
*6
8
5'' ! ; 8 ! ( '
>
! . 2
8 8
!7 8 /
2
7 8
#
!
1 /
! 0
!
! ;
0
8
8
8
0 /
8
*6
&
8
5
7 8
2
!7 8
+
#
8
!7 8
!
5
)0
? 'H! 0
2
!A !
8
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
#
2
8
B
>
8
8
8! # 8
8 >
O !
M
8
7
""
8 L' #
8
2
*#+"
#
;
2 2
#
8
#
! ' $
0
'&! 8
!
#
8 !
-
2 8
/
2
8
8 8 8
/
#
8!4 . 2 ! 2 /
#
3
!
'H H $3=
8
"6 %
'!
H#
- !5 ? J HL
2 ,
, 1
4&O "
8 !
2
0,
2
5 H!LJJ A!+!
8
J'H H?! # !
!
6 %
,
8
2 !
L
-
,
,
#
3 "
8
3
'
7 *#+
2
>
A!+!
8< *7
"
> ;
6 + ,# "
!
- ! 5 J? JH H5 H ? A!+!
>
=8*
2
8
7
!
8
8
B 8
8
#
2
8
"
8
4
!
8
7 8
2
,
8
8
B !*+ *,,"0 !+/*+4
2
2
8
O
8
8
!
"6 %
55?!
?
' '
L#
- ! 5 J5
7 & '
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
.
0
!
8
2
"
2
8
8
>
8
8
2 ! ;
!
2
, 8
)
8 8
8
,
/ 8
8
B
0
8
! )
8
! !*+ *,,
;*#
#8+/ !<
)
!++#
" !< *";
8
2 8 B
4!+*9! *#+! 2
8
8
2
>
O
)
- !5 5 L 5
)
8
2
8 O $ &
"
$ & 2
% & H #
!+/*+4
3$ &
B
-
,
'J5 A!+!
! J5 @!-! 555 5J5
LL $
J& $B
!
!4 8.
H -! ! J5J ?5 6!+ !
!7
5L5 5 J $ HH&&!
. 2
/ -)* $B
! ' J
' -! !
H JL 6! % &
M
!
# .
8
J? $
% 6 "
0
2
8
) ,
P
# 8
!
8
" 8! #
8 I>
> 8
0
8! 8!
2 I>
! 8
8
& J ' @!-!
8! J
#
0
1 &!
H'&&!
0
J
8
2
8
!
'
!
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
8 8
2
>
,
2
2
! ;
8
! . 2
2 8 / 0
8 ! =
.
8 0
B ! A 2
8
2
8
0
!
0
8
80 8
!
0
8 8 8
2
D
8
2
!
.
8
2
,
"
0
8 8
! 0
)
!
; 0
(
8
!
M )66 0)
,
;+- #< + #
H
0
8
!
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
Franklin County Court of Common Pleas
Date:
05-30-2012
Case Title: Case Number:
ROBERT L WALGATE JR -VS- OHIO STATE GOVERNOR JOHN R KASICH 11CV013126
Type:
MOTION GRANTED
It Is So Ordered.
/s/ Judge Timothy S. Horton
Electronically signed on 2012-May-30
page 18 of 18
Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126
Court Disposition Case Number: 11CV013126 Case Style: ROBERT L WALGATE JR -VS- OHIO STATE GOVERNOR JOHN R KASICH Case Terminated: 08 - Dismissal with/without prejudice Final Appealable Order: Yes Motion Tie Off Information: 1. Motion CMS Document Id: 11CV0131262011-12-0999890000 Document Title: 12-09-2011-MOTION TO DISMISS Disposition: MOTION GRANTED
2. Motion CMS Document Id: 11CV0131262011-12-0999970000 Document Title: 12-09-2011-MOTION TO DISMISS Disposition: MOTION GRANTED
3. Motion CMS Document Id: 11CV0131262011-12-0999900000 Document Title: 12-09-2011-MOTION TO DISMISS Disposition: MOTION GRANTED
4. Motion CMS Document Id: 11CV0131262011-12-0999980000 Document Title: 12-09-2011-MOTION TO DISMISS Disposition: MOTION GRANTED