Equine decision

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

! !" ! # "%

# $$

%$&%$'$()

!*+ *,,"

-" #".#+/ + "%

+#

!

, +/!+ "

0 1 (&$$

(2 (3

(1 (&$(

!

"

#

!

!

$%&$'&! #

# ( )

*

( ! . "

-

1 #

0 7 8 7 "

2-8 :68 "

+, /

! -

6! 7 8

$3# ! 6 )

0

(

4&

)8 (

2 0 )

-!

4&

0

8 ;

-

3

5 #

)8

/

+! % 2 $

(

+!

( !

)

0! 9

%

( <

"

" 1

$

6!

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

30

4&

#

! # <

#

!

# 1

#

4&

! # (

=

1

=

5

! # <

= #

% 8 +!

(

8 ;; 7 + "

(

8

+!

5

)

%

-

$

!1

!

6

)

+ >

1 ; ! 1

" 0

*

36

"

*

<

4&

!

0

6

! # <

6

!

#

( $3

$3=

0

#

#

(

,

4&

7!

#

! # (

5

, ,

,

0

! # < !

6 !

!

!

! # )

?

#

) 8

0 ! @

0 ;

"

$

8

"#

# )

2

8

8

6

3+B !

3 8

;

4&

(

66

66 $ 66

2

; ;

8

"#

"#

= 8

8

0

8

66

4& ;

!

2! .

8 8=

"

A ;

!

0 "

0A1 $# 2

"

& 66

" 66

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

0

#

2

# 3

! #

,

8

>

8

8

8

# ,

#

6

#

> !4 $)

>

8

8

8

8

C !&

0

#

8

#

=

# #

6 #

,

2 $

4&! #

3 3<

A

)

0

D0 4 $3)

( 4&! 0

; /

# 82

8

)

>

8

8

E* >

' $)&

#

=

8

'

#

!

G!4

# >

6

=

)

! !

8

8

3

!

8

;

2

8

5HH

#

! ! 5HH ! 5

>

!4 # 8

8

8

I;

8 8 # ! !

#

2

6 ;

6

2

2

;

)

3

F -

7

8

2

2

8

2 ! # (

$

3; D

2 +

8

5

4&! *6

2

I

H

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

# (

8

8

?

2)

=

1

8

-

.

-

.

%

8

4 $*6

! -

.!%!

3

4

&! )

4&

2!

8

2 3

8

.!%!

$3.!%! 4&!

! ! 5HH ! 5

2

2

! ! 5HH ! 5 *6

6

A !

HH $3.!%! HH4&

$3*6 2

%

! ! 5HH !

8

"

>

#

! )

E* K '

#

8

>

8

2

! #

)

E* -

'$ &$ &! )

8 !

8

8

2

8

B " ! #

)

)

E* -

'

2

E* -

' $ &$J&

$?&!

#

55

,

8 2

/

,

! #

3

)

E* -

2

8

4

'$ &$ &! ;

# 8

,

8 8

! ) 8

-

.

%

A ! ?

$3.!%! ? 4&

8

8

> 8 8

;

.!%! ?

2

(

!

!

8 8

#

8 ! .!%!

J

HH

8 *6 ! ! ?H? !

.!%! HH ,

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

8 #

,$ ) &

! .!%! HH

! ! 5HH ! H

,

8

2

! !*+ *,,"0 ;

4! *#+"

)

0

8

8

!

8

8

8

-

8

8 #

2 "

!

8

8

! $

*/ # #

0

5

6*+! "

8

2

.!%! ;

#

; 0

!

8

! ! 5HH ! 5 ,

8

3

F-G

=

0

8 *6 8

C 55&

=

.!%! HH

2

!

.!%!

2

6 8

1

*6

4

" /

5$+&

>

!4 $)

;;

! ;

-

)

3 ;

! ! 5HH !

2

;;

;E

"

) ! E* -

'

2

6

8

3

8

-

8 *6

!4 $)

CH &! ;;;

8

''!? *6 8

! 0

8

*6

2

B ;*

) ?

.!%!

8 #

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

B )

8

!

0

)

E* -

'

8 /

=

8 2

;;;

;*

! ; E

"

2

6

3

8

8 ;

#

!4 $)

* 0 8

#

CH?&!

8

6

4 $)

C ??&

2 ;

-

*;;; 0 # (

)

/

3

*;;; -

J

2

!

! ! 5HH ! $ &

-

)

,

;* -

$%&$ &!

!"*+#"

0

8

E;

E;;

.!%! HH

,

$<&$ & 2

8 )

8

,

E;

,

8

,

8 8!

,

2

8

8 .!%!

/

?H? !

)

)

8

.!%!

8

HH

! !

, E* -

#

'$ &$ &

/

8

!

E;

8

.!%! HH

)

E* -

'

#

! ! 5HH !5J 2 , !

8

8

E;;

4

55

E*

E;

8

.!%!

HH ,

HH

-

3 '$ &

)

8

2 E;;

,

8

! .!%!

8

2

8

! ; E;*

E* ,

"2

! '

/ ,

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

;

E;;; 0

8

2

2

3

4

8 ! .!%! HH

) ! ! 5HH ! H

8 !

8 E* -

2 8

0

8

! ! 5HH ! H

" !

'$ &$ &

.!%!

HH

2

! ! 5HH ! H$%&

,

2

2 2 8

! ;

/

2

E;;;

E*;

"

2

2

#

! <

E*;; 0

.!%! ?

2

)

/

8

8 2

)

8

#

)

H

8

2

*; 0

8 .!%!

3- 8 -

2 /

4

8

4! *#+"

?$ &

3

(

.!%! 2

! ; ;; -

1

.!%! HH

!

#7 /8 !

0

'$ & .!%!

2 8

=

# '

E* -

8 @

<

)

8

;; -

/

=

! ;

*;; 0

8

?$ &

2

4 )

.!%!

B

! !+/*+4 # 7 3

0 >

*+4 8* )

0 ,

H

#

!4

2 0

8

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

8 CC

8

>

8

5!& 2 0

8

#

8

! $)

8

8

8

! $)

0

CC J!&

8 ! $)

CCJ ' H L!& #

2

) ! $)

0

C?!& #

2

0

8

# 2

8

8

8

! $)

, +/!+ "0

C

# *#+" #

!&

*"6*"" !

"

8

8

!

%$'&

$ & 0

8$ &0

# 2

0

3;

8

"

! !

A+

L? $

! )

H #

- !5

8!

!4 H 'L

8

$%&$'&

8 '

8

H&!

2

3 8 -!

J

!4 5 H A!+!

H?5 $ H?&

J # !

8

! !

2 "#

! A ! L)0 8

)0

'H

#

5 5

!

! ! )

8

8

? 'H! ;

2

8 $

! #

8

8

$ &$'&

!A !

#

" 8

8 L

!

!

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

% & H # >

- !5 5 L 5

'J5 A!+!

8

/

LL! -

8

2

! )

8 2

!

,

#

-!

5

J

?H A+

5H $ H &M ;

8

2

/ &

2 /

8

""

2

/ / ! ! $+

' = )

8 8

)

! ; 8 , &!

8

2

!

8

8

/

$ &

2

M $ &

/

8

"

2 )

8

)

)

/ ( "

8 2 86 /

C "

$

'

H&

?'

-! !

"M $ &

% 2 ! &!

! A ! ')0+

)

8

/ J '! 7

! ! ! #

)0

2

/ 8

/

$5&

)**+, ! ,-)-* CC H 5O '# & L' #

?J H C

!

8

8

H'

!+ 8

$%&$'& ? 'H C ! $+

8

2

B

$

A !

8

8

3

$

5'! 7

8

/ -

'

M

N ' !N %

/

!4 $

/

$5& 3

. ! $B

- !5 J? J' H &!

8

B /

4$ &

2

/

"# !

2

"

! !A ! ' )

0

!

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

!*+ *,,"

#

=

!-

!+/*+4 !" * *9 +" #

> ,

1

#

-

' #

!A !

)0 'H

0! 9

-

- ! 5''

#

#

6

)

)8 )

003

0 2 0

%

$

6! 7 8

(

)

" <

8

;

8

,

)

8

,

/

,

-

! !

/

-

2

8

!4 0

&

/

# "

7 "

" 1

, /

8

3 ,

2

2

! )

8

/

8

8

3

!4

0

#

, 8

5 5

CC H 5!

>

#

8

2

,

>

!

0

2

0

8

2;

8

! 0

0

2 $)8

!

>

!

-

8

$ ?J&O 2

5 A!+!

(

"

/

8 #

8

!

?55?! )

6! 7 8

"

8

2

&

! .!5

6

#

!& 2

) )

,

, 8

8

)8 !

2

)8

! )8

/ 2

2 -8

8 : 68

8 ;

2

!

I 2 !

8

!

!

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

@

#

2

8

)

!

,

,

! )8 !

!4 C 5H! $

'

!

0

#

+ )8

4

)8 2 ;

2;

2! 3)

8

2

H#

- ! 5 H'

#

!

)

!

2

2

) ! E* K'

!

0

#

2

!4 $)

C L?&! ! )

!

2

8 >

! )

8

)8 8

, 2;

!

"

)

2;

2; !

!2

2

8

8 ! )8

2

)8

)8

8! )

2 ! )8

# &

8

/ ! )

,

-

)

)

2

,

8

2

8 8

! ;

8

-

/

5' A!+!

8

,

2;

8 JJ J

,

M 3

-

8

?H' &!

)

)8

8

,

2

8

! )

8!

0

,

0

8

8

# #

! ( 7

"

2

-

!

7

= +

6

7 "

-

6

2

) -

-

) ! 0

! !

"

7 8

%

!

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

0

8 8! -

0

8 )

,

*6

!

0

2

8

# 8

/

B

,

,

8

)**+, ! ,-)-* CH! ;

8!

2

/

2

!

" 8

)

,

2 8

! )

8

0

,

<

< ?H? !

2 6

=

$ &

<

2

8

'

B

2

! =

.

# 0

!

= !

8

! ! ?H? !

0

L

0

$%&! 0

, ! !

, =

< <

! )

0 8

<

M

2

2

B <

! ; )

, 8

=

8

,

,

,

8 !

!

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

!*+ *,," !#, ; + !

# 8,, / #+7 +:8 * " 8< *7 " "87; !*+ *,," # # 5

8 > #

2

"

! ;

? 'H C ! 0 9 2

!A !

(

8 /

2

3

8

! -

0

8

8 8

7 8

2

9

8

/

/ 8

8

8 ! 0

8

!

! )

0 #

< ! -

"1

8

1

2

#

8 8

8

2

8

! 0

! ' !

8 8

8

8

8

8

) !(

1

5 0

2 #

!

2

>

8

,

8

8

8

! ;

2

8 ! )

8

8

! ; !1

2

0

)

21

! /

2

)0

)

!4 A

0

;#"

!

0

-

+ #6 !+/*+4

3

$

!

)

*,, !-

8

8

1 8

0

2

2

5

1

" 8 /

8

2

8! = 8

8 2

8

8

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

/ ! ' !

! 1

/

/

5 - + *, !*+ *,," !- 8,, / #+7 +:8 * " *,, + #6 ;#" #, ; + ! 8< *7 !*+ *,," # # !!+/*+4 7!8" ; * , =8 " / * # / "" ; * +:8 * "

+

2

8

2

2

/

!

8

#

8

!$

/

7 8

8

8 !

>

8

/ 2

!

! ' !

2

8

2

2

2 2

8

2

8 2 ! 7 8

,

!5

8

8

7 8

8 8

/

8

8

" 8

#

8 ! . 2 2

" !A ! ) " 0

2 " 7 8 8 . 8 8 H# J5H C?L > 2! ) !)

8!

> ( # 7 8

9

*6

8 >

8

8

! #

8 . 8 8 8 8

8 / 8

% !0 8

J

! ;

*6

8

5'' ! ; 8 ! ( '

>

! . 2

8 8

!7 8 /

2

7 8

#

!

1 /

! 0

!

! ;

0

8

8

8

0 /

8

*6

&

8

5

7 8

2

!7 8

+

#

8

!7 8

!

5

)0

? 'H! 0

2

!A !

8

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

#

2

8

B

>

8

8

8! # 8

8 >

O !

M

8

7

""

8 L' #

8

2

*#+"

#

;

2 2

#

8

#

! ' $

0

'&!

8

!

#

8 !

-

2 8

/

2

8

8 8 8

/

#

8!4 . 2 !

2 /

#

3

!

'H H $3=

8

"6 %

'!

H#

- !5 ? J HL

2 ,

, 1

4&O "

8 !

2

0,

2

5 H!LJJ A!+!

8

J'H H?! # !

!

6 %

,

8

2 !

L

-

,

,

#

3 "

8

3

'

7 *#+

2

>

A!+!

8< *7

"

> ;

6 + ,# "

!

- ! 5 J? JH H5 H ? A!+!

>

=8*

2

8

7

!

8

8

B 8

8

#

2

8

"

8

4

!

8

7 8

2

,

8

8

B !*+ *,,"0 !+/*+4

2

2

8

O

8

8

!

"6 %

55?!

?

' '

L#

- ! 5 J5

7 & '

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

.

0

!

8

2

"

2

8

8

>

8

8

2 ! ;

!

2

, 8

)

8 8

8

,

/ 8

8

B

0

8

! )

8

! !*+ *,,

;*#

#8+/ !<

)

!++#

" !< *";

8

2 8 B

4!+*9! *#+!

2

8

8

2

>

O

)

- !5 5 L 5

)

8

2

8 O $ &

"

$ & 2

% & H #

!+/*+4

3$ &

B

-

,

'J5 A!+!

! J5 @!-! 555 5J5

LL $

J& $B

!

!4 8.

H -! ! J5J ?5 6!+ !

!7

5L5 5 J $ HH&&!

. 2

/ -)* $B

! ' J

' -! !

H JL 6! % &

M

!

# .

8

J? $

% 6 "

0

2

8

) ,

P

# 8

!

8

" 8! #

8 I>

> 8

0

8!

8!

2 I>

!

8

8

& J ' @!-!

8! J

#

0

1 &!

H'&&!

0

J

8

2

8

!

'

!

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

8 8

2

>

,

2

2

! ;

8

! . 2

2 8 / 0

8 ! =

.

8 0

B ! A 2

8

2

8

0

!

0

8

80 8

!

0

8 8 8

2

D

8

2

!

.

8

2

,

"

0

8 8

! 0

)

!

; 0

(

8

!

M )66 0)

,

;+- #< + #

H

0

8

!

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

Franklin County Court of Common Pleas

Date:

05-30-2012

Case Title: Case Number:

ROBERT L WALGATE JR -VS- OHIO STATE GOVERNOR JOHN R KASICH 11CV013126

Type:

MOTION GRANTED

It Is So Ordered.

/s/ Judge Timothy S. Horton

Electronically signed on 2012-May-30

page 18 of 18

Franklin County Ohio Clerk of Courts of the Common Pleas- 2012 May 30 9:33 AM-11CV013126

Court Disposition Case Number: 11CV013126 Case Style: ROBERT L WALGATE JR -VS- OHIO STATE GOVERNOR JOHN R KASICH Case Terminated: 08 - Dismissal with/without prejudice Final Appealable Order: Yes Motion Tie Off Information: 1. Motion CMS Document Id: 11CV0131262011-12-0999890000 Document Title: 12-09-2011-MOTION TO DISMISS Disposition: MOTION GRANTED

2. Motion CMS Document Id: 11CV0131262011-12-0999970000 Document Title: 12-09-2011-MOTION TO DISMISS Disposition: MOTION GRANTED

3. Motion CMS Document Id: 11CV0131262011-12-0999900000 Document Title: 12-09-2011-MOTION TO DISMISS Disposition: MOTION GRANTED

4. Motion CMS Document Id: 11CV0131262011-12-0999980000 Document Title: 12-09-2011-MOTION TO DISMISS Disposition: MOTION GRANTED