& ' ()* + + , -./*0 11($2222
! " # $ % %
18 month
WHAT’S INSIDE
FORMIDABLE VOLUNTEERS A5
TERM DEPOSIT SPECIAL up to
Weather A2 Hunt for History A5 What’s On N.Islander Letters A8 Classifieds A12 Sports A11
2.2%
*
Ask us for d etails today!
*18 month, non -redeemable, based on new deposits with full relationship
pricing
250-336-227
2
www.comoxvalleyecho.com Tuesday April 15, 2014
Price: 57 cents plus GST
Volume 20, No. 30
Gloves off in Maple Pool legal case City vows to fight on as campground’s supporters hit back in statement By Philip Round Echo Staff The gloves are off in the Maple Pool case. On Friday the City Council revealed it had decided to fight on with the intention of winning the legal battle of the campground. And yesterday, preparing for a long haul through the courts, a group calling itself ‘Friends of Maple Pool’ attacked the council’s case for continuing, as set out in a lengthy municipal statement. City councillors met twice more in closed session last week to consider where the controversial zoning case had got to and to discuss tactics. Then on Friday, chief administrative officer David Allen issued the statement that concluded: “Courtenay Council is comprised of members from across the political spectrum, yet the majority - fully informed of the facts in the case believe that this case must continue.� There was no mention of the financial implications of pressing on, which could be huge now the action has been broadened into one including the Charter rights of vulnerable residents living there. But the City is firm on the flood safety issues involved; the liabilities taxpayers could face for not taking action; and the principled need to uphold land use zonings. The full text of the City’s statement, and the complete response from the Friends of Maple Pool - the group of citizens and businesspeople who have been working with campground owners Jin and Dali Lin to try to resolve the issue - are posted on the Echo’s website at www.comoxvalleyecho.com Key points from the municipality’s perspective include what it says is a factual analysis of the flooding issues. It notes some have commented the risk to occupants from flooding is low and limited simply to “wet feet.� But in the Council’s view, the risk “is indeed real and significant.� It notes the provincial government advises that vehicles are commonly carried off roadways “in as little as two feet of moving water;� just walking in moving water deeper than six inches “is potentially dangerous;� and “most people do not know that even minor depths, flows, and velocities of flood waters can create life-threatening conditions.� It adds the City has previously witnessed flooding of some occupied Maple Pool campsites “knee-deep or higher.� Emergency evacuation procedures for Maple Pool had been drawn up in 2010, including guidelines for which specific campsites were safe to occupy in the winter season.
Mark Isfeld students Ethan Glenwright, Nicolas Parlee, Adrian Humphry, and Damian Parlee show off their two winning robots - one will compete at the VEX World Championships in Anaheim, California late this month, and the other will be heading to Skills Canada Nationals in Toronto, June 5-7.
VALLEY STUDENTS WIN MEDALS AT B.C. SKILLS COMPETITION Now the challenge is to raise money to send five to Nationals By Michael Briones Echo Staff Four technologically skilled students from Mark Isfeld Secondary have learned the true value of reliability, durability and accuracy. These are three salient features their robot possessed that earned them top honours at the 2014 BC Skills Competitions held at Tradex, Abbotsford last week. The creation of Ethan Glenwright, Nicolas Parlee, Adrian Humphry, and Damian Parlee, also known as the Flying Circuits, worked almost like a well-oiled machine to beat other entries from different schools across the province to bag the gold medal and a spot at the national competition in Toronto. “We won because of our robot was accurate and reliable,â€? said Damian Parlee. “They compensated for the problems we had with our drivetrain, which caused our robot to sometimes stall.â€? The Isfeld quartet were among the over 30 students from School District 71 that got the opportunity to showcase their skills at the annual competition. They ended up bringing home two golds, three silvers, and three bronze medals. The other medal winners were: • Auto Mechanics: Gold, Highland, Mathew Dyck • Auto Collision Repair: Bronze, Vanier, Sam Davis (Continued on page 3)
Mathew Dyck, Highland, won gold in auto mechanics
(Continued on page 2)
Showdown at City Hall Emotions spill over as Mayor fails to identify spending cuts he wants By Philip Round Echo Staff A budget vote at Courtenay Council led to an emotion-charged clash between the Mayor and his Council on Wednesday night. After almost two hours going through the 2014 budget proposals line-by-line at a specially-convened meeting, a vote was called on whether to accept an overall 1.95 per cent increase in the money to be raised from property taxes. The five councillors present all supported the motion - but Mayor Larry Jangula voted against, saying
he would prefer to see a freeze in spending or even a reduction, because “taxpayers will blame it all on us� when they got their bills. But earlier in the evening he had called for an increase in spending on road paving and voiced support for a separate $80,000 increase in the budget to pay and equip more volunteer firefighters. So when Coun. Bill Anglin challenged him to identify items of spending or services he wanted to cut to justify his vote, he could give no specifics, other than to suggest in general terms “cultural and recreational budgets� might be reduced.
That night’s budget meeting was, he insisted, just a preliminary discussion and there was time for council to think about specifics before they got to a final vote. Anglin retorted: “This meeting is exactly what this is about. If you have ideas of services you want to cut or change, that’s what we’re sitting here for; that’s what we’re here to debate. “What specifics are you bringing forward? You can’t just say ‘I’d like to cut.’ What do you want to cut?� Jangula said he wanted to think about it, as he didn’t know at this stage.
That triggered former Mayor and now Councillor Starr Winchester to vent what she called her frustration and disappointment with Jangula. “We have just gone through this line-by-line and I haven’t heard a peep from you. You make these sort of comments over and over again, but we never hear anything definitive. “You have had since the beginning of this meeting to voice your concerns. We as a council would like to talk about it, if you would say what you are proposing.� Winchester said in casting a vote the way Jangula had was a popular thing to be doing in an election year. 2010 TOYOTA
But without being able to offer a single constructive suggestion of how it could be justified, it was not responsible. She claimed he had taken the same approach when the council spent a long time working on its strategic plan and priorities. And welling up with emotion, she demanded to know if he had looked into the budget details before he turned up at council, and when Jangula said he hadn’t had chance to go through it line-by-line she fired back: “Well I have - it’s all available.� (Continued on page 3)
MATRIX
Desirable commuter, auto, only 80,000 kms, sporty & fun! #3035
clearance price of $12,995
compare at $15,995
2008 VW
Golf City
Great hatchback w/rack, economical, fun to drive!
2003 BMW
1999 Mercedes
Z4
2.5L, 5 spd, fast & fun convertible
SL500
5L, auto, with hard & soft top, luxury and style
#3054
#C-356
#3049
$
9,995
$
13,995
$
12,995