Oil and Gas, Air Pollution, Water and Health in Treaty 8 Territory!
Dr. Judi Krzyzanowski BSc, MSc, PhD Treaty 8 “What’s the Drill on Oil and Gas” Fort St. John March 25th, 2015
Extensive Oil and Gas
Oil and gas wells, annually New
Cumulative/total
Contaminants in air and water
Numerous sources of air pollution
5!
6!
Emissions are dominated by upstream oil and gas
Common types of air pollutants Oxides of nitrogen (NOx) = NO & NO2 – from all combustion Sulphur dioxide (SO2) – from combustion of sulphur-containing fuels Hydrogen sulphide (H2S) – ‘sour gas’ leaks and venting Total Reduced Sulphur (TRS) – leaks, desulphurization off-gases Particulate matter (PM) = fine (PM2.5) and coarse (PM10) – from combustion, dust Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC) – leaks and fugitive emissions Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) – incomplete combustion, fugitive Ozone (O3) – secondary pollutant formed from NOx and VOCs Radiation – associated with produced water, equipment scale, gas
7!
8!
Oxides of nitrogen (NOx) = NO & NO2 – from all combustion • Responsible for ozone (‘smog’) formation • Can also form acidic aerosols (H2NO3) – a type of PM • NO2 may cause lung irritation and inflammation, cardiovascular effects or allergen sensitisation • Contributes to acidification of soil and water • Contributes to eutrophication of soil and water • Can lead to ecosystem changes • Excessive NO3 in drinking water reduces blood’s O2 carrying capacity
9!
Sulphur dioxide (SO2) – from combustion of sulphur-containing gas
• Can form acidic aerosols (H2SO4) – a type of PM • Leads to respiratory irritation, aggravates asthma • May cause injury to vegetation • Annual SO2 UNECE threshold for lichens may be exceeded • Main cause of soil or water acidification
10!
Hydrogen sulphide (H2S) – ‘sour gas’ leaks and venting • Slightly heavier than air • Has a ‘rotten egg’ smell • Odorous at very low concentrations – 0.5 ppb for 50% • Health damage begins around 10 ppm (10,000 ppb) 20,000 x that or ; AAQO = 5 ppb • Causes damage to vegetation • Also forms acidic aerosols (H2SO4) • Is often combusted to form SO2 in disposal • Flammable and explosive
11!
Total Reduced Sulphur compounds (TRS) – includes H2S, mercaptans • Often measured by the government at monitoring stations in H2S equivalents • Provincial Ambient Air Quality Objective (AAQO) is for TRS as H2S • All have a ‘rotten egg’ smell • Methyl mercaptan has health effects at higher concentrations than H2S (17 ppm or 17,000 ppb) but similar odour thresholds • Dimethyl sulphide [(CH3)2S], dimethyl disulphide (CH3SSCH3), carbonyl sulphide (CS) and carbon disulphide (CS2) are also potential air pollutants associated with oil and gas
12!
Particulate matter (PM) = fine (PM2.5) and coarse (PM10) – from combustion or dust • Associated with haze and visibility problems • A mixture, can include acidic aerosols (H2SO4, H2NO3, metals, etc.) • Difficult to characterise = diverse • Cause lung damage — associated with lung cancer and emphysema • Can fall out as ‘soot’ etc.
13!
Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC) – leaks and fugitive emissions • Some are odourous • Some are carcinogenic or mutanogenic (BTEX – benzene, toluene, ethyl benzene, xylene) • Methane, propane, butane, etc. are explosive or flammable • Some contribute to ozone formation • Some (methane) contribute to climate change
14!
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) – incomplete combustion, fugitive • Also ‘organic’ and considered to be ‘semi-volatile’ • E.g. phenanthrene or • No two oil sources have the same PAH signature • Reduce ozone in their breakdown • Like to attach to particles and travel • Some are carcinogenic or mutanogenic • Can contaminate water and soil
15!
Ozone (O3) – secondary pollutant formed from NOx and VOCs • Main component of photochemical smog • A strong oxidant • Damages tissues (lungs, vegetation, etc.) • Long-lived, travels across provincial borders, continents, etc. • Formation is dependent on solar radiation and temperature
16!
Radiation – associated with produced water, equipment scale, gas • Three main types of ionizing radiation: gamma rays, alpha- and beta-particles • Cause damage at the genetic/intracellular level • Absorbed through inhalation, ingestion, or through skin • Not generally measured or monitored • Radium in particular can be present in gas lines, produced water and equipment scale • Radium’s daughter product radon is a leading cause of lung cancer
17!
The air/water/soil interface
Health Pathways • Air • Water
• Food
• Soil
19!
90 80
Lung Cancer Mortality Respiratoy Disease Mortality Other Respiratory Mortality Lung Cancer Incidence Asthma Incidence
70
Incidence per 100,000
60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Canada
BC
Human Health
Vacouver Location
Northwest BC
Northeast BC
20!
Levels of air pollutants
BC MOE Sites Dec. 2013 – Jan. 2014
PESTS Sites Sept. 2014 – Apr. 2015
21!
Levels of air pollutants – MOE
Fort Saint John Key Learning Centre
1-hour AAQO SO2 = 170 ppm 1-hour AAQO TRS = 5 ppm
22!
MOE Readings‌ Doig River Cultural Centre
Road 197 East Tomslake
1-hour AAQO NO2 = 213 ppb 1-hour AAQ) O3 = 51 ppb 24-hour AAQO PM10 = 5 µg/m3
PESTS Readings… Taylor
23!
24!
What affects air quality measurements? • • • • •
a) day
(Oke, 1987. Boundary Layer Climates)
Meteorology Topography Surface roughness Source characteristics Pollutant specifics
25!
• SO2 and NOx lead to soil and water acidification • Freshwater (lake) representative of its basin • Depletion of base cations (Ca2+, Mg+, K+, Na2+) • Mobilization of toxic forms of aluminium (Al3+) • Can lead to death of vegetation, fish, etc.
Acidification
26!
• NOx and other rN inputs can lead to soil and water eutrophication • Multiple N inputs — not just atmospheric • Causes changes to ecosystems • Freshwater (lake) representative of its basin • Cause algal blooms, oxygen deficiency, water ‘death’
Eutrophication
27!
Modelling deposition
• 2156 km2 • 3 First Nations communities (Blueberry, Beatton, Doig) • 266 point, flare and area sources
28!
Sulphur - acidification
Nitrogen – eutrophication and acidification High
Low
Predicted deposition
29!
Acidification Risk/Sensitivity
30!
Other impacts‌.
Radiation and salinity
31!
Explosion or fire risk
32!
• There are tools to monitor or measure ecosystem change – lichens, conductivity, visible injury… • Community-based indicators can also be developed/used • Monitors becoming more affordable, easy to use, and accessible to communities
Discussion/Context
33!
Thank-you Any Questions