‘Echoes of the Past,’ Chinese Buddhist Cave Art, in New York - NYTimes

12/5/12

‘Echoes of the Past,’ Chinese Buddhist Cave Art, in New York - NYTimes.com

HOME PAGE

TODAY'S PAPER

VIDEO

MOST POPULAR

Subscribe to Home Delivery

U.S. Edition

U.S.

N.Y. / REGION

BUSINESS

TECHNOLOGY

ART & DESIGN

BOOKS

SCIENCE DANCE

HEALTH

MOVIES

MUSIC

Help

Search All NYTimes.com

Art & Design WORLD

cross3...

SPORTS

OPINION

TELEVISION

ARTS

THEATER

ART REVIEW

STYLE

TRAVEL

VIDEO GAMES

‘Echoes of the Past,’ Chinese Buddhist Cave Art, in New York

REAL ESTATE

AUTOS

EVENTS

Log in to see what your friends are sharing on nytimes.com.

Privacy Policy | What’s This?

Rebirth for Cave Buddhas

JOBS

Log In With Facebook

What’s Popular Now Despite Bob Dole’s Wish, Republicans Reject Disabilities Treaty

Mayor Clinton?

Bloomberg Urged Her to Consider a Run

Librado Romero/The New York Times

“Echoes of the Past,” at the Institute for the Study of the Ancient World, displays Buddhas and bodhisattvas.

By HOLLAND COTTER Published: September 13, 2012

In the Buddhist way of thinking, all things must pass, though it seems a shame when they do, especially if they’re out­of­this­world beautiful, as so much Chinese Buddhist art is. But could that vision of transience be changing in the 21st century, as technology lets all kinds of things, including art, live on forever out there in digital clouds?

FACEBOOK TWITTER

Today's Headlines Daily E­Mail

MORE IN ART & DESIGN (1 OF 50 ARTICLES)

GOOGLE+

Sign up for a roundup of the day's top stories, sent every Stretching Her Creativity as Far as morning.

Possible

E­MAIL

Read More » Change E­mail Address | Privacy Policy

cross3@sva.edu

SHARE PRINT

Connect With Us on Twitter Follow @nytimesarts for arts and entertainment news.

Arts Twitter List: Critics, Reporters and Editors

A sortable calendar of noteworthy cultural events in the New York region, selected by Times critics.

Go to Event Listings »

Regret and hope alike run through REPRINTS the multifaceted exhibition “Echoes of the Past: The Buddhist Cave Temples of Xiangtangshan” at New York University’s Institute for the Study of the Ancient World on the Upper East Side. The show is, at heart, a salvage operation, an effort — and a moving one — to reassemble a specific body of art now scattered, revivify a place of origin beaten down by depredation, and point to a plausibly upbeat future. In important ways it meets these goals and reboots history.

In the sixth century A.D. a short­lived dynasty known as the Northern Qi (A.D. 550­577) excavated a series of

nytimes.com/2012/09/14/arts/design/echoes-of-the-past-chinese-buddhist-cave-art-in-new-york.html…

MOST E­MAILED

MOST VIEWED

1. To Stop Climate Change, Students Aim at College Portfolios 2. Removing ‘Sacrifice’ From ‘Gluten­Free’

3. Cheering U.N. Palestine Vote, Synagogue Tests Its Members 4.

OPINION

5.

DRAFT

New Love: A Short Shelf Life

The Art of Being Still

1/4

12/5/12

‘Echoes of the Past,’ Chinese Buddhist Cave Art, in New York - NYTimes.com Enlarge This Image

Buddhist cave temples from limestone cliffs in northeast China. The caves, in two main clusters several miles apart, were collectively called Xiangtangshan, meaning “mountain of echoing halls.” They were filled with carved figures — some free standing, some cut in high relief from living rock — that have long been considered among the most sublime images in Chinese art. From the dozen examples on display in this show you see why.

6. Pushing Science’s Limits in Sign Language Lexicon

The three oldest caves, referred to by archaeologists as the northern group, are also the grandest, being imperial commissions. One is genuinely king size, its roomy interior dominated by Buddhas and bodhisattvas 20 feet high.

7.

BOOMING

8.

WELL

When They’re Grown, the Real Pain Begins

For Athletes, Risks From Ibuprofen Use

9. Study Raises Questions on Coating of Aspirin 10. For Second Opinion, Consult a Computer?

Librado Romero/The New York Times

A kneeling winged monster, from sixth­ century Chinese cave temples.

Enlarge This Image

The caves in the other group, the southern group, are more modest in scale. Their figures are merely life size but conceived in a transcendently sophisticated, courtly style.

Go to Complete List »

Show My Recommendations

Stylishness was important. These shrines were meant as permanent records of dynastic taste and spending power on earth. And they projected that taste and power into the afterlife, in the hopes it would insure their patrons V.I.P. treatment there.

Whatever the standing of the Qi in paradise, the art left behind at Xiangtangshan (pronounced shahng­tahng­ shahn) was unlucky. Time and weather ate away at the caves. Over the centuries political turmoil took a toll. But the most concentrated damage seems to date from after 1900 and the rise of an international market for ancient Chinese Buddhist sculpture.

Librado Romero/The New York Times

Echoes of the Past, at Institute for the Study of the Ancient World, includes a detached hand of an ancient Buddha from a cave at Xiangtangshan.

Enlarge This Image

Librado Romero/The New York Times

“Echoes of the Past” uses 3­D projections to reconstruct how artworks from the Northern Qi dynasty looked in caves before they were looted.

The Chinese themselves weren’t collectors: to them such objects were either sacred and beyond aesthetics, or bizarre relics of an imported religion that had nothing essentially Chinese about it. The attitude in the West, and in Japan, was different.

After photographs of spectacularly decorated cave temples at Yungang and Longmen began to circulate in Paris in 1909, a feeding frenzy set in. In China looters got to work, dragging sculptures out of caves and hacking away at reliefs, chopping heads off Buddhas, slicing off hands.

Xiangtangshan was a natural target, though one of primarily local renown. Because photographers hadn’t found it, it wasn’t a celebrity site, didn’t have brand value in the West. Once a sculpture left its caves, few people could trace its source.

Into the late 20th century the situation stayed grim. Xiangtangshan, though still a pilgrimage destination, was in ruins. Much of its art was gone, scattered around the world, hugely admired but little studied. The site’s future, like its recent past, looked bleak, if not hopeless.

The 21st century has brought a turnaround, partial but significant, in its fortunes. In 2004 the Center for the Arts of East Asia, at the University of Chicago, initiated an ambitious project devoted to the site. Led by Katherine R. Tsiang, the center’s associate director, it had several aims: to identify the existing corpus of Xiangtangshan sculpture in museums and private collections worldwide; to photograph as many of these objects as possible with

Ads by Google

what's this?

Streb Forces.

MacArthur Genius Award Winner's Back With Her Latest Show.

Streb.org/Forces

nytimes.com/2012/09/14/arts/design/echoes-of-the-past-chinese-buddhist-cave-art-in-new-york.html…

2/4

12/5/12

‘Echoes of the Past,’ Chinese Buddhist Cave Art, in New York - NYTimes.com

3­D scanning; and to insert these images within digital reconstructions of the caves they came from.

The result is the adroit mix of art, history, international diplomacy and new technology found in the New York show, which is an edited version of one seen earlier at the Smart Museum of Art at the University of Chicago, and at the Arthur M. Sackler Gallery in Washington. Several sculptures have been left out along the way, but concision has value of its own. The installation at the Institute for the Study of the Ancient World, overseen by Peter De Staebler, is trim, focused and extremely effective.

The centerpieces are five fragments from the grand early imperial cave in the northern group, though “fragments” hardly seems the word for carvings that, though incomplete, have the heft of monuments. They include a pair of immense heads cut from bodhisattvas that flanked one of the cave’s three giant seated Buddhas. From one of those Buddhas comes a set of detached hands; from another a sliced­off, beatifically smiling face.

One by one the pieces are mightily impressive. And when a sense of the scale of the figures they came from kicks in, they can take your breath.

Four smaller life­size Buddhist deities, all from the southern cave group, are gripping for different reasons, beginning with the Fabergé­esque extravagance of their bangles­and­ beads attire. One figure, though, is different from the others. He’s dressed like a monk, not a prince, and holds something large and curved between two upright hands. It’s probably a lotus bud, though it could just as easily be his heart plucked from his chest and offered, still warm, for our perusal.

This sculpture has been in the collection of the University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology since 1916, when it was bought from a Chinese dealer. But what would its gesture, so clearly symbolic, have conveyed in its original cave setting, in the company of many other gesturing figures? What intended narrative of compassion or salvation might we discern in that context?

This is the sort of question that Ms. Tsiang and her Chicago colleagues are trying to approach through digital technology. A small gallery has been set aside in the show for a 3­D digital projection that reconstructs the interior of one of the Xiangtangshan caves by inserting images of dispersed sculptures back into video of their original places.

The effect is a little odd. The reinserted items, all colored bright yellow, resist visual integration into the setting. But the idea is a good one. More effective, however, is the kinetic effect of the video as a whole, which immerses you in the cave and gives you a sense of moving through it, looking around.

Such simulations may well be the wave of the museological future in China, at least in the case of archaeological environments too fragile to withstand tourist traffic. At the great Buddhist cave temple complex at Dunhuang, in northwestern China, for example, plans are under way to create an enormous visitor center that will make walk­in digital versions of the painted caves a substantial part of a visitor’s experience.

And surely some of the ancient underground tombs being discovered in China today, particularly those with wall paintings, will be publicly available only at a digital remove, which could mean on the Internet.

Needless to say, there are gains and losses built into the process of balancing access and conservation, though the issue at stake in the case of the Xiangtangshan project is a different one. Here the aim is not so much to prevent an existing environment from vanishing but to reclaim one already largely gone. And the exhibition puts this across.

The sculptures in the gallery magnificently speak of a wholeness forever passed, while the “digital cave” promises an integrative reality in progress, still to come. And that reality has

nytimes.com/2012/09/14/arts/design/echoes-of-the-past-chinese-buddhist-cave-art-in-new-york.html…

3/4

12/5/12

‘Echoes of the Past,’ Chinese Buddhist Cave Art, in New York - NYTimes.com

its own enchanting images: of art that is composed, or recomposed, from networks of coordinate lines that suggest cosmic connectors, and from pixels that, like molecules, come together, and fall apart, and come together again, in a play of change and not­change that Buddha himself might give a nod to.

“Echoes of the Past: The Buddhist Cave Temples of Xiangtangshan” can be seen through Jan. 6 at the Institute for the Study of the Ancient World, 15 East 84th Street, Manhattan; (212) 992­7800, isaw.nyu.edu.

A version of this review appeared in print on September 14, 2012, on page C23 of the New York edition with the headline: Rebirth for Cave Buddhas.

FACEBOOK

TWITTER

GOOGLE+

E­MAIL

SHARE

Get Free E­mail Alerts on These Topics Art

China

Caves and Caverns

Institute for the Study of the Ancient World

Ads by Google

what's this?

Nikon Official Site Buy Direct from Nikon for Huge Savings on Cameras, Lenses & More!

www.NikonUSA.com

INSIDE NYTIMES.COM DINING & WINE »

OPINION »

HEALTH »

BOOKS »

OPINION »

U.S. »

Editorial: Rigging the Financial System

Gluten­Free Dishes Become More Tempting

Home World

U.S.

Invitation to a Dialogue: How to Treat A.D.H.D.

N.Y. / Region

Business

For Athletes, Risks from Ibuprofen Use

Technology

Science

Health

Professor Who Learns From Peasants

Sports

Opinion

Arts

Will authorities really hold banks and bankers accountable for manipulating interest rates?

Style

© 2012 The New York Times Company Privacy Your Ad Choices Terms of Service Terms of Sale Corrections

nytimes.com/2012/09/14/arts/design/echoes-of-the-past-chinese-buddhist-cave-art-in-new-york.html…

Travel

Jobs

Penn Museum Pushes for Broader Public Appeal

Real Estate

Autos

Site Map

RSS Help Contact Us Work With Us Advertise

4/4