Justice Reinvestment in Oklahoma Town Hall Meetings October 17-18, 2011 Council of State Governments Justice Center Marshall Clement, Project Director Anne Bettesworth, Policy Analyst Jessy Tyler, Senior Research Associate Robert Coombs, Senior Policy Analyst
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 1
CSG Justice Center • National non-profit, non-partisan membership association of state government officials • Represents all three branches of state government • Justice Center provides practical, nonpartisan advice informed by the best available evidence
Criminal Justice / Mental Health
Reentry Policy Council
Justice Reinvestment
Consensus Project
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 2
Funders and Partners
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 3
Oklahoma Justice Reinvestment Process Analyze Data & Develop Policy Options Collect & examine quantitative data ! Reported crime & arrests ! Court dispositions & sentencing ! DA supervision ! Probation and parole supervision ! Prison admissions, population & releases
June-October
Engage stakeholders Law enforcement Judges Prosecutors Defense bar Victim advocates/ survivors ! County officials ! Supervision agencies ! Behavioral health & treatment providers ! ! ! ! !
July-October
Develop & present a comprehensive analysis of the state’s criminal justice system
Develop a framework of policy options that together would increase public safety and reduce/ avert taxpayer spending
November-January
4
Past Justice Reinvestment States
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 5
Preliminary Analysis
!"#
$%&'()*#+,%-(##
!"#$%&''()*&+,-#.!/.0# *.(#%$1+(2#34#)3,!'(# )(2#'&)!*&#!%#*.2((#34# *.(#,&2/("*#'!5("#.&"# 6(',!%(67#
#
."#
/01(,2%3%&)#4&,# 4('&)5#&6()7(,3#%3# 7(+'%)%)89#4(8(2# )(3),(#&2(#+(!%/# "$)(29!"(6#&:(2# 2(,(&"(#4231#)2!"3%7#
:"#
;<(#1,%3&)# 1&10'=>&)#%3# 8,&?%)8@#&%6#132(# ")(%6!%/#8!,,#+(# 2(;$!2(6#*3#!%'2(&"(# '&)&'!*-#$%,(""#*.(# )3)$,&53%#/238*.#!"# 1&%&/(67#
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 6
Violent Index Crimes Reported to Police in Oklahoma Remained High =<><<<#
C0,7(,#,=*(9##
C0,7(,#
GHI#N=K#LMI#NBCK#
BA><<<# B@><<<# B?><<<#
E&,+%B'(#A=1(#
A&BB(,5#,=*(9##
A&BB(,5#
GHI#JBDK#LMI#NBAK#
B=><<<# B<><<<#
D88,=2=*(7#D33=0'*#
A><<<# @><<<# ?><<<# =><<<# <# =<<<# =<<B# =<<=# =<<C# =<<?# =<<D# =<<@# =<<E# =<<A# =<<F# =<B<# United States Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation. (September 2011). Crime in the United States, 2000-2010. From http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2010/crime-in-the-u.s.-2010.
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 7
Violent Crime Rate & Law Enforcement Staffing Per Capita 2000-2010
HI'=<&-=#J%*5#
O(2'(%*# P.&%/(#!%# $%&'()*# J,%-(#A=*(# Q## K=?# M)4&,+(-()*# /*=N)8#O(,# J=1%*=#
;0'3=#
!FG# !!G#
.G#
PG#
K=?*&)#
J# N#
L&,-=)#
.PG#
!PG# !QG# R:G#
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 8
Preliminary Analysis
!"#
$%&'()*#+,%-(##
!"#$%&''()*&+,-#.!/.0# *.(#%$1+(2#34#)3,!'(# )(2#'&)!*&#!%#*.2((#34# *.(#,&2/("*#'!5("#.&"# 6(',!%(67#
#
."#
/01(,2%3%&)#4&,# 4('&)5#&6()7(,3#%3# 7(+'%)%)89#4(8(2# )(3),(#&2(#+(!%/# "$)(29!"(6#&:(2# 2(,(&"(#4231#)2!"3%7#
:"#
;<(#1,%3&)# 1&10'=>&)#%3# 8,&?%)8@#&%6#132(# ")(%6!%/#8!,,#+(# 2(;$!2(6#*3#!%'2(&"(# '&)&'!*-#$%,(""#*.(# )3)$,&53%#/238*.#!"# 1&%&/(67#
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 9
More and More People are Being Released Unsupervised #D><<<## #?>CD=##
#?>D<<##
51%
#?><<<## #C>D<<##
released unsupervised in 2010
#C>??<##
#C>CF@## #C><@<##
#C><<<## #=>D<<## #=><<<##
#B>@DD##
#B>D<<## #B><<<##
#E@B##
#D<<##
The number of offenders released to parole dropped in half
#N####
L&#/01(,2%3%&)#
O,&B=>&)# =<<D#
O=,&'(#
=<B<#
Source: Oklahoma Department of Corrections, Evaluation and Analysis. (2011). The State of Corrections in Oklahoma: Fiscal Year, 2010 http://www.doc.state.ok.us/ newsroom/annuals/2010/annualreport2010.pdf.
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 10
Rearrests Within 36 Months of Release E>@FC#
#L%!;$(#R(,(&"("#4231#SGP#T&'!,!5("#6$2!%/#TU=<<E# :@SQS##
R@QPF#
GV(%6(2"#W3*#R(&22("*(6#!%#C@#X3%*."#
GV(%6(2"#R(&22("*(6#
!@TTT#
!@.TP#
FTQ#
U(&2#B#
U(&2#=#
U(&2#C#
#
#
DCK#
#
Y22("*(6#8!*.!%#C#-(&2"#34# 2(,(&"(# OKDOC and OSBI raw data files of 2007 Prison Releases
?EK#
W3*#&22("*(6#8!*.!%#C#-(&2"#34# 2(,(&"(# Council of State Governments Justice Center | 11
Preliminary Analysis
!"#
$%&'()*#+,%-(##
!"#$%&''()*&+,-#.!/.0# *.(#%$1+(2#34#)3,!'(# )(2#'&)!*&#!%#*.2((#34# *.(#,&2/("*#'!5("#.&"# 6(',!%(67#
#
."#
/01(,2%3%&)#4&,# 4('&)5#&6()7(,3#%3# 7(+'%)%)89#4(8(2# )(3),(#&2(#+(!%/# "$)(29!"(6#&:(2# 2(,(&"(#4231#)2!"3%7#
:"#
;<(#1,%3&)# 1&10'=>&)#%3# 8,&?%)8@#&%6#132(# ")(%6!%/#8!,,#+(# 2(;$!2(6#*3#!%'2(&"(# '&)&'!*-#$%,(""#*.(# )3)$,&53%#/238*.#!"# 1&%&/(67#
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 12
Oklahomaâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Prison Population is Growing C<><<<# =D><<<#
BFF@#N#=<B<I#JC?K# =<<<#N#=<B<I#JBDK##
#=@>@F=## B>C=C#3V(%6(2"#8(2(# +&'\,3//(6#!%#]&!,#
=<><<<#
^#
BD><<<# B<><<<# D><<<# <#
O2!"3%#O3)$,&53%# OK: OKDOC Annual Reports 2009 and 2010 National: Sourcebook of criminal justice statistics
O2!"3%#Q#Z&!,#[&'\,3/# Council of State Governments Justice Center | 13
Estimate of Growth in Prison Population (Driven by accumulation of 85% offenders) O23)&/&53%#X36(,##
U:@!!Q# C<><<<#
# PVG#O&10'=>&)##
=D><<<#
Y""$1("#BK#!%'2(&"(#!%#&%%$&,#&61!""!3%"#432#ADK#'2!1(">#+$*#)3)$,&53%# /238*.#!"#62!9(%#+-#*.(#&''$1$,&53%#34#3V(%6(2"#"(29!%/#1$'.#,3%/(2# *.&%#*.(-#.&9(#.!"*32!'&,,-7#
=<><<<# L&)WPVG#O&10'=>&)#
BD><<<#
Y""$1("#*.(#&%%$&,#)3)$,&53%#34#3V(%6(2"## #!%'&2'(2&*(6#432#%3%NADK#3V(%"("#2(1&!%"#'3%"*&%*#&*#=<BB#,(9(,"7# # _.!"#!"#%3*#&#)23]('53%#34#*.(#%3%NADK#)3)$,&53%>#+$*#2&*.(2#&#"*&5'# ("51&*(7#_.!"#".&2(#34#*.(#)3)$,&53%#1&-#!%'2(&"(#32#6('2(&"(## 6()(%6!%/#3%#&%-#'.&%/(#!%#&61!""!3%"#32#,(%/*.#34#"*&-7#
B<><<<# D><<<# <#
TU<D#
TU<@#
TU<E#
TU<A#
TU<F#
Z&!,#[&'\NL)#
TUB<#
TUBB#
TUB=#
TUBC#
TUB?#
W3%NADK#O3)$,&53%#
Oklahoma Department of Corrections, Entry and Exits, FY2005 to FY2011.
TUBD#
TUB@#
TUBE#
TUBA#
TUBF#
TU=<#
ADK#O3)$,&53%#
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 14
TU=B#
Top Nonviolent Prison Admissions (Cumulative FY05-FY10)
DOC Admissions, FY05-FY10.
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 15
Most People Admitted to Prison in 2010 Had Many Prior Arrests, But Some Had Relatively Few .Q!Q## HI'=<&-=#XHJ#D7-%33%&)3# G\,&.31&#M*&*$*(#S(`%(6#a!3,(%*# P2!1("#
VQS#
!@!V!#
SQ#
O23)(2*-#&%6#G*.(2#O$+,!'#G26(2# P2!1("#
:ST#
:@!RT#
::V#
S2$/#P2!1("#
R.:#
.@FFT#
:QS#
BNC#
?NB@#
BE##
32#132(#
b!4(51(#Y22("*#c9(%*"## d!%',$6!%/#'$22(%*#&22("*e# OSBI Arrest Data and Oklahoma Department of Corrections 2010 Reception Data
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 16
Preliminary Analysis
!"#
$%&'()*#+,%-(##
!"#$%&''()*&+,-#.!/.0# *.(#%$1+(2#34#)3,!'(# )(2#'&)!*&#!%#*.2((#34# *.(#,&2/("*#'!5("#.&"# 6(',!%(67#
#
."#
/01(,2%3%&)#4&,# 4('&)5#&6()7(,3#%3# 7(+'%)%)89#4(8(2# )(3),(#&2(#+(!%/# "$)(29!"(6#&:(2# 2(,(&"(#4231#)2!"3%7#
:"#
;<(#1,%3&)# 1&10'=>&)#%3# 8,&?%)8@#&%6#132(# ")(%6!%/#8!,,#+(# 2(;$!2(6#*3#!%'2(&"(# '&)&'!*-#$%,(""#*.(# )3)$,&53%#/238*.#!"# 1&%&/(67#
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 17
Thank You John Estus Press Secretary Office of the Speaker john.estus@okhouse.gov
www.jrioklahoma.com
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 21