the
Case Western Reserve University volume xlvii, issue 15 friday, 1/15/2016
Observer
Protestors, including CWRU community members, call for reforms after Tamir Rice ruling Anastazia Vanisko Copy Editor On Jan. 1, Clevelanders declared that it was a “New Year, No More.” Over 100 people marched from Impett Park to the home of Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Timothy McGinty to protest the non-indictment of Officer Timothy Loehmann for the shooting of 12-year-old Tamir Rice. Members of the Black Lives Matter movement, six of the Cleveland 8 (the activists who filed the affidavit that led a judge to find probable cause in the killing of Tamir Rice), students and anyone else who wanted to join gathered in below-freezing weather to protest the ruling. One woman held a sign reading “Centuries of Injustice,” while others carried a banner with “WE DEMAND ACCOUNTABILITY #YearWithoutTamir” written on it. For
All photos courtesy Randy Blackford Top: CWRU professor Rhonda Williams participates in a Tamir Rice protest. Left: protesters gather at Cuyahoga County prosecutor Timothy McGinty’s home. Right: Second-year student Eva Barrett joins the group of peaceful protesters. four minutes, protestors lay side-by-side on the ground—a die-in representing the four minutes that Rice was unattended by Loehmann and Officer Frank Garmback before receiving medical attention. McGinty had told the grand jury review-
ing the Tamir Rice case that he didn’t believe it was possible to convict Loehmann. This statement came more than a year after the shooting, which occurred on Nov. 22, 2014, and only after the release of enhanced surveillance video. Based on this
video, McGinty said it was “indisputable” that Rice was pulling his pellet gun from his waistband when Loehmann shot him. Under these circumstances, Loehmann was potentially taking the reasonable course of action since the police dispatch had failed to inform both him and Garmback that the gun was most likely a fake. Under the law, Loehmann only needs to prove that he was thinking as any other reasonable officer in his situation would. But reasonable means different things to different people. There were multiple facets of the case to view in the light of reasonability. Was it reasonable to drive the vehicle up to Rice at that particular speed and to stop so close to him? Or would it have been reasonable to try to deescalate the situation from farther away?
to TAMIR RICE | 2
Tobacco-free policy to be reconsidered after invalid vote, student reaction Celia Wan Staff Reporter Voted in by the Faculty Senate before winter break, the tobacco-free campus policy has now been recalled due to a lack of attendance at the last Faculty Senate meeting. At the same time, rising student attention to this policy has led to new developments in the decision-making process. Attendees at the December Faculty Senate meeting voted for a proposal
banning all tobacco-related products on campus. However Faculty Senate later realized that the last two meetings have failed to meet a quorum, meaning that the decisions made in these meetings, including the tobacco-free campus policy, now must be reconsidered. According to Dr. Roy Ritzmann, the president of Faculty Senate, the tobacco ban will be voted on again in the next Faculty Senate meeting on Jan. 21. “Given the wide positive margin in the
News
A&E
Opinion
Sports
pg. 2
pg. 7 Bowie’s musical goodbye
pg. 8
pg. 14 New coach, old hopes
Donuts now on campus
original vote, I expect the issue to still pass, but one never knows,” said Ritzmann. Following the December Faculty Senate meeting where this policy was voted in by the non-quorum assembly, the Undergraduate Student Government (USG) General Assembly passed a resolution addressing the lack of student input in the policy. Throughout the drafting, proposing and decision-making phases of the new tobacco-free policy, going back to as early as 2011, the tobacco-free proposal was
Voting could have changed Rice case
presented to USG several times by Vice President of Student Affairs Lou Stark, Assistant Professor in the School of Nursing Elizabeth Click, who helped create this policy, and Stan Gerson, M.D., director of the Case Comprehensive Cancer Center. Students were asked to contribute their opinions in two surveys, conducted in 2011 and 2014 respectively.
to TOBACCO | 4