dn 3 10 the
dailynebraskan.com
Sbarro to be replaced
Pelini reprimanded
New pizza place will be announced later this week
Big Ten fines NU for coach’s post-game conduct
tuesday, december 3, 2013 volume 113, issue 065
race issues on campus
here to stay ASUN executive committee falls 1 vote short of two-thirds majority needed to remove senator
RACIAL INCIDENTS AT UNL
after an Association of Students of the University of Nebraska senator used racial slurs during debate and the N-word was found written in chalk in front of the Phi Kappa Psi fraternity house. Minority students and administrators can agree on one thing: Racism is a problem at UNL. But some students wonder whether
The Daily Nebraskan’s Association of Students of the University of Nebraska beat reporter Reece Ristau interviewed Sen. Cameron Murphy, a nutrition graduate student, several days before the hearing with ASUN’s executive committee that decided whether he would be removed from office. In an open-room secret vote, the committee fell one vote short of removmurphy ing Murphy from office. Daily Nebraskan: How do you feel about the various reactions to the comments you made at the Nov. 13 senate meeting? Cameron Murphy: It depends on how you look at it. I was out of the loop obviously (Murphy was in Phoenix for a family matter) for a little while and so I got back and was like, ‘Wow, there’s a lot of stuff on the Internet.’ So, there are people that say that’s offensive, which, in a way was designed to be, simply to illustrate the point that some things can be considered really offensive and some things are not, right? So, the example that I used of the dental student that had dressed up in the sombrero and the corncob for gun belts, you know, a Pancho Villa kind of thing, and they call him Husker Hombre, is that offensive? I don’t think so. Maybe to someone else it is, but the point I was getting across is if you live in a society where all of a sudden you can’t say anything offensive, well then you might as well just be in the Soviet Union, then America ceases to exist. The problem is that people like to say, ‘Hey, we want to have speech codes,’ and I read (Chancellor) Harvey Perlman’s comments and I think this whole thing went way over his head because it focused so much on this one word which was just used as an illustration of something that is incredibly offensive that everyone is offended by and it really shouldn’t be used, but I don’t think it should be banned either. Free speech is free speech. You can’t curtail it here, you’re either in support of it or you’re not, the only limitation would be the Supreme Court case of yelling fire in a crowded theater because you could cause bodily harm to someone else. You should be able to say whatever you want, whether it be popular or unpopular. And you shouldn’t be punished, especially at the university, this is supposed to be the place of ideas, where people formulate their opinions and their beliefs and formulate new ideas. DN: What would you say to students who were hurt or angered by your comments? CM: If you’re hurt by someone saying a word, I would say grow up. Honestly. Was the word directed at anybody? No, it wasn’t. That was one of the biggest things, was, you know, these were all hypotheticals to go through and say, ‘Hey, you know, this is offensive or this could be offensive,’ or maybe it’s in the correct context or true to the meaning of whatever the word is. You’re going to be offended by a lot of people’s comments in life… People have to ask themselves, ‘What if people say something to me that I find offensive, how do I react to that?’ That says a lot about your character. You just have to be able to walk away. So if someone says something that you think is offensive and they’re a bigot or whatever, you just got to walk away and I don’t know what happened with the sidewalk chalk (Murphy was referencing the Nword being written outside a fraternity house), I don’t know what that was all about and I don’t obviously support any of that kind of stuff because, that’s directed at someone, that’s a lot different than saying something generally or something to illustrate a broader point but when something like that is directed at someone that truly can be hateful and that’s wrong and students who reacted negatively, I think, you have to grow up and understand that’s the way life goes. I can see where it really cuts deep. But unless you have a personal thing and even then, you just got to – if I were to say something, you know, and you were to come up to me and say, ‘hey, that really hurt me per
racism: see page 2
q&a: see page 2
1997 The Sigma Chi chapter at UNL receives one-year probation after members burn a cross in a field outside Lincoln during an initiation ceremony. The chapter’s members are required to perform community service, interact with minority groups and complete various other tasks as part of their probation.
JUNE
2006
English professor David Hibler faces criticism from Chancellor James Moeser after emailing pieces of prose containing the N-word to several faculty members.
FEBRUARY
2010
ASUN passes legislation calling for cultural sensitivity after the University of Nebraska Inter-Tribal Exchange expresses concerns about UNL students dressing up in Native American headdresses and war paint at the Nov. 7 football game against the Oklahoma Sooners and again at the Nov. 21 game against Kansas.
APRIL
2010
Five UNL students distribute surveys asking students to draw their perceptions of Native Americans. Many students draw bottles of booze and casinos, others headdresses and tipis. And some students write instead of drawing pictures, saying Native Americans are victims and impoverished. Others write they believed that Native Americans “pay for cable before food” and that many drop out of high school.
SEPTEMBER
2012
A UNL student creates Twitter and Tumblr accounts with the name “UNL Haters” to spotlight racist, homophobic and sexist statements made by UNL students on the Internet.
OCTOBER
2013
The Latino Graduate Association voices concerns to ASUN regarding skits performed by student groups at Monday Night Live, which the organization believed to be racially offensive. Some of the skits involved students wearing sombreros, ponchos and thick mustaches.
NOV. 20,
2013
Chancellor Harvey Perlman emails students and staff citing recent cases of insensitive racial impersonations happening on campus. He called on students and staff “to not remain silent or indifferent, but to confront and speak out against such outrages and embrace those against whom they are directed.”
NOV. 21,
2013
ASUN votes to schedule a disciplinary hearing for Sen. Cameron Murphy after racial comments he made during debate at a Nov. 13 senate meeting regarding legislation that aimed to remove derogatory language from senators’ vocabulary. Murphy said the legislation was a restriction of free speech and cited comedian Chris Rock as an example of why some words are not offensive. He recited one of Rock’s routines, which used the N-word.
NOV. 25,
2013
UNL launches the campaign “Not Here, Not Now, Not Ever!” against intolerance in response to events of racial insensitivity happening on campus, including the N-word being written in chalk outside a fraternity house.
MATT MASIN | DN
Sen. Cameron Murphy waits during a deliberation portion of Monday night’s special Association of Students of the University of Nebraska meeting. Sen. Murphy was voted to remain in office in an open-session secret vote by ASUN executive committee members. REECE RISTAU DN After lengthy deliberation at a hearing Monday, an Association of Students of the University of Nebraska committee fell one vote short of the two-thirds majority required to remove Sen. Cameron Murphy from office for racial comments he made at a senate meeting last month. But a group of seven ASUN members vowed in a letter Monday night that they would search for other ways “to address Senator Murphy’s actions” and called for his resignation. The final vote was 7 for removal, 5 against. At the hearing Monday night, 12 members of ASUN and two administrators met to decide whether Murphy, a graduate student in nutrition, would keep his position with ASUN. After nearly two hours of deliberation, which was not open to the public, an openmeeting, secret vote took place. The hearing was a result of comments Murphy made at the Nov. 13 senate meeting, during which he cited comedian Chris Rock, used the N-word multiple times and made comments about other minority groups. At the following senate meeting, Sen. Annie Himes, a junior history, global studies and Russian major, pro-
posed that Murphy be removed from senate for his comments, a move that received multiple seconds and resulted in the hearing Monday. Himes did not want to comment on the outcome. Those who voted were all students and all involved in ASUN: President Eric Reznicek, a senior finance and marketing major, Internal Vice President Kaitlin Coziahr, a senior economics, finance and management major, External Vice President Jeff Story, a junior English and political science major, Sen. Jordan Hohwieler, a junior business administration major, Sen. Mary Pistillo, a senior mechanical engineering major, Sen. William Duden, a junior business administration major, Sen. Kevin Knudson, a junior political science major, Sen. Frank Stroup, a senior music education major, William Stock, a junior history major, Sen. Christina Guthmann, a junior international business major, Reed Brodersen, a junior environmental studies major and Maggie Schneider, a junior finance and management major. Also on the committee, but not participating in the vote, were Vice Chancellor for Student Affairs Juan Franco and ASUN Director Marlene Beyke. After much of the deliberation had occurred but prior to the vote, Murphy said the hearing went smoothly.
“I thought it went OK,” he said. “We had a really nice conversation and since it wasn’t so off-the-cuff like it was the first time, for me, I was really able to go through and – it was a little different because we had to stick to just one case, we couldn’t get too sidetracked.” Reznicek could not comment on the closed portion of the hearing. “The deliberation went well, but other than that I can’t say anything about what happened during the closed session,” he said. Reznicek said ASUN is examining how these events can impact the future. “We are looking at doing a lot of work, not only with campus but internally with ASUN along the lines of social responsibility and sensitivity training,” Reznicek said. He said the training would involve not only senators and members of ASUN but individual projects as well. The anonymous letter from ASUN members took a more opinionated approach. “As student representatives we find this decision appalling and against our pledge to represent all of the student body to the best of our ability,” the letter read. “In this respect we believe we have failed
murphy: see page 2
Racism persists despite campaign, students say Faiz Siddiqui and Jacy Marmaduke DN Bryan Colbert felt he had nothing to lose. So when the junior broadcasting major took the microphone on Nov. 25, after a series of prepared speeches from University of Nebraska-Lincoln administrators and student leaders – speeches carefully penned to quell a growing storm of racial tension – he didn’t hold back. “You reading your speech that you wrote out, that was very cute,” he said, addressing UNL Chancellor Harvey Perlman from the back of a packed Centennial Room in the Nebraska Union. “But you don’t know what it’s like to be a minority, sir.” Hundreds of students and faculty members shifted in their chairs. Some laughed in discomfort. Others raised their eyebrows at those around them. But all were silent as they listened to the young man in the back. “You’re disrespecting every minority student who has to work to make it in your world,” Colbert said. “We’re fighting every single day so we can be equal. We’re all fighting every day. Except you, sir. What fight are you fighting?” Perlman responded with a personal admission: He grew up the
STACIE HECKER | DN
University of Nebraska-Lincoln Chancellor Harvey Perlman speaks during the “Not Here, Not Now, Not Ever!” anti-intolerance campaign launch Nov. 25 in the Nebraska Union. only Jewish kid in town. “So I think I know a little,” he said. “Not the same as you; I don’t wear it on my face. But I’ve been there, and I understand it.” It was an uncertain start to the “Not Here, Not Now, Not Ever!” campaign, a university-led effort to unite students against intolerance in a to-be-determined series of activities, lectures and forums
Q&A with Sen. Cameron Murphy
@dailyneb | facebook.com/dailynebraskan