WARM HORSE hi
46° |
lo
MONDAY
30°
february 27, 2012
t h e i n de pe n de n t s t u de n t n e w spa pe r of s y r acuse , n e w yor k
Supreme Court to hear affirmative action case
INSIDE NEWS
Making progress Members of SA’s Student Engagement Committee create a plan to allow for more student involvement. Page 3
By Kathleen Ronayne DEVELOPMENT EDITOR
INSIDE OPINION
Syracuse faceoff After a battle in the court, the defamation lawsuit against Jim Boeheim will be heard in Onondaga County, a decision The Daily Orange Editorial Board agrees with. Page 5
INSIDE PULP
Fun and fabulous Syracuse drag performers strut their stuff in the annual drag show. Page 9
INSIDE SPORTS
On the battlefield Syracuse pulled out a 10-9 win over Army on Sunday to improve to 2-0 this season. Page 16
lauren murphy | asst. photo editor
Top dog
FAB MELO (51) puts back a C.J. Fair miss over UConn’s Andre Drummond. The basket gave Syracuse a 71-69 lead with 31 seconds left and was the difference against the Huskies on Saturday in Gampel Pavilion. With the victory, SU clinched the outright regular-season Big East title. SEE PAGE 16
As provost of the University of Michigan in 2003, Nancy Cantor worked tirelessly to help prepare the university for a landmark affirmative action case that went all the way to the Supreme Court. On Tuesday, the court decided to hear another case challenging affirmative action policies in college admissions, this time against the University of Texas. Depending on how broadly the court rules on the case, it could overturn the 2003 decision, which ruled that public colleges and universities could use race as a factor when determining admissions. The ideological makeup of the court has changed since 2003 to a more conservative body. In 2003, the court heard two cases involving the University of Michigan: Grutter v. Bollinger and Gratz v. Bollinger. The court ruled the policy used by undergraduate admissions that admitted students based on a strict point system largely considering race was unconstitutional, but that universities could take race into account in narrowly defined ways that justify a compelling state interest. Cantor was instrumental in preparing Michigan for the cases, working with then-president Lee Bollinger to gather data that showed the compelling state interest for affirmative action. Cantor’s social science background was crucial, as the two used a number of university and national studies to prove their point. “We really argued the compelling state interest in terms of the educational benefits of diversity on a college campus for everyone,” Cantor said. Both the 2003 cases and the case
against the University of Texas are brought on grounds that affirmative action policies violate the equal protection clause in the 14th Amendment. The UT case is significant because in addition to asking the court to rule the university’s policies unconstitutional, the student and her lawyers have also asked the court to completely overturn Grutter, said Brian Fitzpatrick, an associate professor of law at Vanderbilt University Law School. If the court does rule on the broader point, “no public or private university
“We really argued the compelling state interest in terms of the educational benefits of diversity on a college campus for everyone.” Nancy Cantor
SU CHANCELLOR
in America will be able to use affirmative action. And that’s why this case is so significant,” Fitzpatrick said. UT allows any Texas student who graduates in the top 10 percent of their high school class automatic admission to the state university. This policy was adopted as a race-neutral alternative that would ensure diversity among the student body. High schools in Texas are still fairly segregated, so this plan produces significant diversity at UT, Fitzpatrick said.
SEE AFFIRMATIVE ACTION PAGE 6
Panelists talk on current media Road to Recovery founder said he is coverage of sexual abuse cases treating victim of another SU coach fine allegations
By Nicki Gorny and Shannon Hazlitt STAFF WRITERS
A panel of experts agreed the media has both great power and responsibility in reporting about sexual abuse during a symposium in the Joyce Hergenhan Auditorium on Thursday. “If it weren’t for the media exposing these issues, we would still be 20 or 30 years behind,” said Robert Hoatson, president and co-founder of Road to Recovery, a nonprofit charity based in New Jersey that aids victims of sexual abuse. Hoatson spoke as part of a panel of sexual abuse advocates during the daylong sympo-
sium “When Games Turn Grim: Can Media Cover Sports Scandals Responsibly?” presented by the S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications. The symposium addressed media coverage of sports scandals, prompted by the recent sexual abuse accusations against former associate men’s basketball coach Bernie Fine. Fine was placed on administrative leave in November when two former ball boys, Bobby Davis and Mike Lang, publicly accused Fine of molesting them from the late 1970s to the early 1990s. He was fired Nov. 27.
SEE PANEL PAGE 6
By Liz Sawyer and Breanne Van Nostrand THE DAILY ORANGE
The president of Road to Recovery, a group that supports victims of sexual abuse, said he is treating a victim who has been molested by another coach at Syracuse University. Robert Hoatson, the president and cofounder of Road to Recovery, spoke on the advocates panel during the symposium “When Games Turn Grim: Can Media Cover Sports Scandals Responsibly?” on Thursday afternoon. “By the way, I am working with a vic-
tim of another Syracuse University sport — a head coach,” Hoatson said approximately halfway through the hourlong panel. “The reason I cannot tell you who it is and why is because the person is not there yet, but the person did give me permission, just yesterday, to say, “You can say that much.’ And who knows, maybe he’ll watch today and say, ‘Maybe I’ll go a little further here,’ because these stories tend to come out in pieces.” The S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications held the symposium to examine the media’s coverage of
SEE HOASTON PAGE 6