free
WEDNESDAY
sept. 21, 2016 high 81°, low 54°
t h e i n de p e n de n t s t u de n t n e w s pa p e r of s y r a c u s e , n e w yor k |
N • Campus update
dailyorange.com
P • Drive on
Several ongoing construction projects are making progress on the SU campus. Read about the plans for completing each project throughout this semester. Page 3
S • Still perfect
New York state drive-ins use a mix of nostalgia and luck to survive. Take a look at a local theater and how one family has kept it alive in the digital age. Page 9
BEHIND THE RANKINGS
Syracuse men’s soccer is off to its best start in program history after beating Cornell, 3-1, on Tuesday night. The Orange is 8-0 and ranked No. 2 in the country. Page 16
The factors of university rankings and what they mean Text by Taylor Watson asst. copy editor
Graphic illustration by Emma Comtois senior design editor
WHO REPORTS THE DATA?
IN COMPARISON
The U.S. News and World Report releases rankings of Best Colleges annually. Syracuse University falls into the National Universities category, as it offers a full range of undergraduate majors, master’s and doctoral programs and is committed to producing groundbreaking research.
12 Northwestern
15 Cornell University
Overall Score: 89/100
Overall Score: 85/100
20 Georgetown University
How SU’s ranking on the National Colleges list compares to its peer institutions:
15 University of Notre Dame
15 Vanderbilt University
Overall Score: 85/100
Overall Score: 85/100
32 University of Rochester
39 Boston University
Overall Score: 68/100
Overall Score: 64/100
39 Tulane University
44 Lehigh University
Overall Score: 64/100
Overall Score: 44/100
56 George Washington Univ.
31 Boston College Overall Score: 70/100
Overall Score: 78/100
BREAK THE TIE SU tied with five other schools for the 60th ranking including:
39 Northeastern University
Fordham University Purdue University – West Lafayette University of Connecticut University of Maryland – College Park Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Overall Score: 64/100
56 Southern Methodist Univ. Overall Score: 64/100
Overall Score: 60/100
60 Syracuse University
74 American University
Overall Score: 59/100
Overall Score: 54/100
SU’s RANKING
RATING INDICATORS
Here’s how SU has ranked over the past four years:
Here’s a look at the various indicators used for the study and how they are weighted:
86 Marquette University Overall Score: 51/100
70
RANKING
22.5% Graduation and retention rates 62 60
61
22.5% Undergraduate academic reputation
60
20% Faculty resources
58
12.5% Student selectivity 10% Financial resources
50 2014
2015
2016
2017
5% Alumni giving rate
YEARS
S
yracuse University claimed the No. 60 spot on the 2017 U.S. News and World Report Best Colleges Rankings in the National Universities category. These rankings are useful to prospective college students and their parents, as it is impossible for them to visit and compare all colleges, said David Rubin, professor and dean emeritus of the S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications. But he said no student would be wise to rely on the
7.5% Graduation rate performance
rankings as the reason they pick a school. Sam Gorovitz, philosophy professor and former dean of the College of Arts and Sciences, also said he would discourage students from giving high value to the rankings. While top-ranked schools may be the best choice for some students, they might not be for others, Gorovitz said. It depends on who the student is and what is going to work best for that specific student.
source: u.s. news and world report
“I would always … ask, for this particular student, what is likely to be the best match in terms of educational value, in terms of personal growth, in terms of empowerment?” Gorovitz said. Many people believe the rankings are flawed in their methodology and they should not be taken seriously, Gorovitz said. But there is also a perception that they matter. “And that means that lots of people do take see rankings page 4
Free speech experts welcome pending revisions in policy By Satoshi Sugiyama asst. news editor
Following a two-year-long process, Syracuse University recently announced it will revise its free speech policies. While experts welcomed the announcement, some expressed frustration about the amount of
time it took for the university to deal with the issue. In an email to the SU community, Chancellor Kent Syverud said earlier this month that the university will be modifying some of its free speech rules, including anti-harassment, computing and electronic communications, banners and signs display, along with when the univer-
sity can shut down a protest. Syverud’s announcement came in response to recommendations put forth last year by SU’s Working Group on Free Speech. David Rubin, dean emeritus and professor at the S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications who chaired the working group, said he is not sure how much of the
working group’s recommendations will be implemented or in what kind of form in the final version of the free speech policy. He also said Syverud did not mention when offensive speech should be both tolerated and encouraged in his email to SU community. Rubin added that the issue of free speech should have been
addressed a long time ago. He speculated that the reason for the delay is because the university has been preoccupied with other issues — such as diversity, inclusion and sexual assault — and the issue of freedom of speech on this campus was pushed down the ladder. “At first I was frustrated, then I see free
speech page 7