THURSDAY, MARCH 25, 2021 VOL. CXXXVII NO. 9
THE INDEPENDENT STUDENT NEWSPAPER OF THE UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA
FOUNDED 1885
Penn’s Alpha Phi placed on probation after repeatedly violating COVID-19 guidelines The Alpha Phi International Fraternity banned the chapter from holding in-person and virtual events until May 11 PIA SINGH News Editor
Ineligible Penn students have received the COVID-19 vaccine SUKHMANI KAUR
City officials said ineligible college students have tried to get vaccinated through walk-ins at Philadelphia’s federally run vaccination site JONAH CHARLTON Senior Reporter
Numerous Penn and Drexel University students have received the COVID-19 vaccine despite being ineligible under current Philadelphia vaccine distribution guidelines, city officials confirmed to The Daily Pennsylvanian. Philadelphia Department of Public Health spokesperson James Garrow said the city’s decision to begin allowing walk-ins on March 17 at the Federal Emergency Management Agency-run site in the Pennsylvania Convention Center in Center City has shown signs of early success in improving the racial equity of its COVID-19 vaccine distribution. It has also, however, led to a large number of local college students receiving the vaccine, despite lacking qualifications required under current Philadelphia regulations. While the city cannot entirely confirm that students are lying in order to receive the vaccine, Garrow said he
has seen social media posts from students instructing others on “the lines to use and the phrases to say” in order to get the vaccine at the FEMA clinic. On average, the FEMA clinic gives out 6,000 vaccines a day — 3,000 of which are for scheduled appointments and the other 3,000 of which are for walk-ins, Garrow said. Garrow added that of the approximately 3,000 vaccines given each day to walk-ins, a significant amount of vaccines have been administered to students, many of whom do not qualify for the vaccine at this time. Currently, only people who are included in Phases 1A and 1B of distribution and also live in one of 22 under-vaccinated zip codes — including 19104, which contains Penn’s campus — are eligible to receive the vaccine, regardless of whether or not they sign up online or do a walk-in. Phases 1A and 1B include
hospital staff, first responders, childcare workers, education providers, people ages 75 and older, and people with high-risk medical conditions. Garrow explained that those walking up and attempting to receive the vaccine are first asked to prove their residency in one of the 22 zip codes using any document that shows both their name and zip code. Garrow said the next question is whether or not they are eligible under Phases 1A or 1B. They are not, however, asked to supplement their answer with any sort of official documentation. Garrow said FEMA believes that “people who are [receiving the vaccine while ineligible] are significantly degrading operations.” SEE VACCINE PAGE 3
Penn’s chapter of Alpha Phi has been placed on probation after alleged violations of COVID19 safety guidelines, such as hosting and partaking in social gatherings without social distancing or mask wearing. The Alpha Phi International Fraternity banned the chapter from holding in-person and virtual events until May 11, at which date the chapter’s status will be reviewed again based on the University investigation, according to a March 16 email from the Alpha Phi International Fraternity to Penn’s chapter. The international fraternity placed Penn’s chapter on probation on March 12 after an internal investigation found “substantiated allegations and uncovered concerns involving the new member experience and other social activities that may have taken place.” Staff from the international fraternity and University officials similarly expressed “significant concern” about the chapter’s repeated COVID-19 violations on a call, according to the email. According to the email, Alpha Phi and its chapter members violated two aspects of the Alpha Phi International Fraternity policy: a chapter must comply with all laws and regulations set by the country, city, and state where it is located and follow all rules established by its University. “We were concerned to find the chapter members’ involvement in events while [COVID-19] guidance has been put into place and communication shared repeatedly by the University,” the international fraternity wrote in the email. University spokesperson Stephen MacCarthy, Vice Provost for Undergraduate Life Monica Yant Kinney, and Associate Vice Provost for Student Affairs Tamara Greenfield King did not respond to immediate requests for comment. Failure to comply with the order to “cease and desist” all activities and operations will result in disciplinary action for any individual member or the chapter itself, which may range from “educational terms” to membership termination for the individual, according to the email. The Daily Pennsylvanian reported on parties — without social distancing — occurring around Penn in the fall 2020 semester, even though the majority of on-campus housing was closed. In early February, the University warned Greek life members that a “completely disproportionate” number of positive COVID-19 cases on campus was linked to fraternities and sororities, particularly as cases were reaching semester highs.
Over 1,400 petition against Penn’s decision to hold commencement on Jewish holiday
UA secures climate town hall with administration
Commencement is on May 17 during the Jewish holiday Shavuot
The UA has been requesting a town hall for more than a year
TYLER HARRIS & LINDSEY PERLMAN Staff Reporters
ELIZABETH MEISENZAHL Senior Reporter
When Wharton senior Gabe Low thinks about commencement, he feels disappointment. For Low, who took two gap years to serve in the Israeli Army, the journey to commencement has been an unconventional one — six years in the making. But because commencement this year is scheduled on Shavuot, a Jewish holiday, Low and other Orthodox Jewish students must grapple with whether or not to attend. “It’s a shame because it’s really a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to graduate,” Low said. “And now, I’ve been waiting for this graduation for six years, and it’s not the outcome that I hoped for or expected.” Penn’s decision to hold commencement on May 17, which coincides with Shavuot, caused outcry among observant Jewish students, culminating in both a guest column College senior Yoni Gutenmacher authored in The Daily Pennsylvanian and a petition to move the ceremony. The petition, which was created last week, has garnered more than 1,300 signatures. University spokesperson Stephen MacCarthy did not respond to a request for comment about whether the University is aware of the petition and if it is considering moving the date of commencement. More than 45 years ago, Penn moved the 1975 commencement ceremony from its original date to accommodate Jewish students and families that celebrated Shavuot. But this year, Gutenmacher and other Orthodox Jewish students are facing a different outcome: Penn has not responded to student pleas for accommodation. “Years later, when Penn has become a much more progressive institution, it’s weird that their actions aren’t following suit,” Gutenmacher said. Student leaders in the Jewish community, including Gutenmacher, December 2020 Wharton graduate Simcha Stadlan, and College and Wharton senior and
2021 Class Board President Lizzie Youshaei, also sent an email on March 18 asking Penn administrators to reconsider moving commencement and have not received a response. Observant Jewish seniors are now forced to make a difficult choice of whether to risk infringing on their religious beliefs to attend the event. Shavuot, a two-day holiday that begins on May 16, typically entails going to religious services and forgoing the use of technology. As a result, Orthodox students who do attend graduation cannot take photos, call their family members, or go out with friends to restaurants after the ceremony. “I am forced to choose between attending a holiday that is really important to me that Jews have practiced for thousands of years, and attending the one commencement I have in my life that’s only been on the calendar for three years,” Gutenmacher said. This decision has been years in the making: Orthodox students learned of the religious conflict when the 2020-2021 academic calendar was released three years ago. Aware of the logistical issues that moving commencement would cause — particularly because Penn had planned four separate ceremonies for each college — some students felt the date was set in stone. But COVID-19 changed all of that, Stadlan said, adding that Penn could have adjusted the date as it altered its plans for the ceremony amid the pandemic. “It’s one thing that Penn didn’t consider us when they first made the date, but when they had a second chance to remedy that, they again disappointed,” Stadlan, who graduated in December 2020 and will participate in the upcoming commencement ceremony, said.
“Employers and graduate schools can relieve some stress by saying that no student, Penn or elsewhere, will be punished simply because they elected to take some classes pass/fail.” - DP Editorial Board PAGE 4 SEND STORY IDEAS TO NEWSTIP@THEDP.COM
SEE COMMENCEMENT PAGE 10
With Penn on the sidelines for this year’s March Madness, we explore some of the Quakers’ best runs in the NCAA Tournament.
The Undergraduate Assembly and Faculty Senate will cohost a Climate and Sustainability Seminar next month, allowing students and faculty to speak directly to administrators about climate-related concerns. The event — which some student and faculty leaders say is an important step in a longer process of voicing climate concerns to administrators — will take place on April 7 from 4 p.m. to 5:30 p.m. While Executive Vice President Craig Carnaroli, Chief Investment Officer Peter Ammon, Vice President of Business Services Marie Witt, and Facilities and Real Estate Services Vice President Anne Papageorge will attend to hear student concerns, questions must be submitted in advance of the event, which some student activists worry may render it ineffective. “This is an important issue and one where the University has made great progress, as outlined in our Climate and Sustainability Action Plan,” University spokesperson Stephen MacCarthy wrote in an email to The Daily Pennsylvanian. “Our hope is that this seminar will provide a broad audience access to the information and progress Penn is making.” The Climate and Sustainability Action Plan 3.0, released in October 2019, laid out a five-year plan for promoting sustainability on campus. The plan included reducing carbon emissions from campus buildings and purchasing sustainably produced food products and office equipment. At the time, Fossil Free Penn criticized the plan for not doing enough to address the University’s contribution to climate change. The plan also did not mention the University’s fossil fuel investments. College junior and UA Academic Initiatives Committee Director Tori Borlase said she and two other
NEWS
UNDERGRADUATE COVID-19 POSITIVITY RATE INCREASES PAGE 3 LARGELY DUE TO STUDENT TRAVEL
PAGE 13
UA members, as well as students from Student Sustainability Association at Penn, began trying to get the administration to hold a town hall a year and a half ago. Borlase said SSAP — an umbrella group representing 13 environmental student groups on campus, including Fossil Free Penn — told her they wanted more access to the administrators with whom the UA regularly meets. While an initial event was planned for last spring, Borlase said the COVID-19 pandemic caused administration and the UA to cancel the town hall. Since then, Borlase said getting a definite plan and getting administration to agree — or even respond to her emails — had been difficult. Architecture professor and Faculty Senate ChairElect William Braham said that last month the Faculty Senate — a representative body for faculty at Penn — offered to co-host a climate-focused seminar with the UA after the UA struggled to get administration to agree to a town hall. Since the onset of the pandemic, it has held a Faculty Senate Seminar Series that invites administrators to attend and take questions from faculty. Borlase said that while she was grateful that Faculty Senate reached out to collaborate, she was disappointed that administrators were not responding to her emails or willing to work with her until the UA joined the Faculty Senate effort. The format of the event allows students and faculty to submit questions ahead of time through a form, and no live questions will be taken, Braham said. Engineering junior and FFP Campaign Coordinator SEE UA PAGE 3
NEWS PAGE 10
POLICING, CULTURAL CENTER SPACE ARE AMONG CHIEF CONCERNS FOR NEWLY ELECTED 6B LEADERS
FOLLOW US @DAILYPENN FOR THE LATEST UPDATES ONLINE AT THEDP.COM
CONTACT US: 215-422-4640