November 11, 2021

Page 1

THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 11, 2021 VOL. CXXXVII NO. 26

THE INDEPENDENT STUDENT NEWSPAPER OF THE UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA

FOUNDED 1885

Penn employees allege ‘dysfunctional, toxic workplace’ in Gene Therapy Program KYLIE COOPER

The Gene Therapy Program’s Translational Research Lab on Nov. 10.

Employees allege Penn has turned a blind eye to the abusive work environment at GTP, failing to hold the moneymaking program and its director, Jim Wilson, accountable PIA SINGH & CONOR MURRAY News Editors

Penn’s Gene Therapy Program is at the forefront of pioneering biotechnology developments — but employees allege a toxic workplace environment lies behind the allure and that Penn is ignoring their complaints to protect the moneymaking program. “I only lasted four months before I couldn’t take it anymore. I really couldn’t take it anymore,” Margaret Spencer, a former executive assistant, said. “It was a dysfunctional, toxic workplace on many levels, and I didn’t have anything to do ... It was exhausting.” The Daily Pennsylvanian spoke to 11 current and former GTP employees, all of whom said they endured a dysfunctional workplace environment at the hands of GTP management. Some of these employ-

Penn women’s basketball juniors, seniors suspended four games for violation of University policy The punishments will be levied over the course of the team’s first eight games MATTHEW FRANK Deputy Sports Editor

Penn women’s basketball juniors and seniors have been suspended for four games each this season, Penn Athletics announced Monday afternoon. In an email to The Daily Pennsylvanian, Director of Athletic Communications Mike Mahoney wrote that the suspension is over a violation of University policy, but did not elaborate on which policy it is. Penn Athletics has declined to offer additional comment and representatives from the women’s basketball team were not available for comment at the time of publication.

ees, both current and former, requested anonymity for fear of retaliation. The program, which employees said is marred by extreme work disorganization and inappropriate office behavior, resulted in low morale and unusually high turnover rates among employees. Several have filed formal complaints and spoken to GTP’s human resources department, the Perelman School of Medicine’s human resources department, the University’s Title IX Office and confidential Ombuds Office, and some even hired their own lawyers to demand an end to the abuse. The DP obtained email correspondence between employees and GTP, Medical School human resources representatives, and other University administrators, Slack messages between employees and GTP executives, unsolicited photos sent to employees from GTP administrative staff, written documentation of medical leave requests, and exit interview notes detailing the experiences of former employees. Despite numerous complaints to multiple University offices over at least the past decade, employees said nothing has changed. They allege that the University has turned a blind eye to the abusive work environment at GTP, failing to hold the program and its director, Jim

Wilson, accountable. Wilson is also no stranger to controversy, having come under national scrutiny nearly two decades ago for leading a gene therapy trial that caused the death of an 18-year-old, leading to several research violations by Wilson and detrimental action against the University’s affiliated research operations. Twenty years later, Penn has rekindled its relationship with Wilson. The University is financially benefitting from the Philadelphia-based genetics medicine company Passage Bio, at which he serves as chief scientific advisor, until June 2025, according to the United States Securities and Exchange Commission Report for the first quarter of 2021. Passage Bio has a research collaboration with GTP, giving the company exclusive rights, with certain limitations, to technologies developed with GTP, according to the report. Gene therapy uses genetic modification of cells in order to treat or cure diseases, including cancer, genetic diseases, and infectious diseases. The field is growing fast, with Philadelphia labeled a hub for innovation, partly because of GTP’s location. University spokesperson Stephen MacCarthy wrote in an email to the DP that the University has no com-

Penn will continue hybrid work for staff next spring, extend employee winter break EDWIN MEIJA

Women’s basketball players scrimmage at the Palestra..

The Penn women’s basketball program will stagger the suspensions over the course of the team’s first eight regular-season games. Penn is not slated to play a conference matchup in any of those eight games. This is not the first time that a team has faced a punishment of such severity. In November 2019, Penn women’s volleyball’s entire rest of the season was canceled after “vulgar, offensive, and disrespectful” signs were found in the team’s locker room. The Quakers kick off their season on Sunday, Nov. 14 at Hartford. Their next seven games span through early December, and the team’s first game back at full strength will be on Dec. 5 at home against Duke. More to come on this situation as the story unfolds.

Winter break will be extended by two days to include Jan. 3 and Jan. 4 as a show of gratitude, University administrators announced EMI TUYETNHI TRAN Senior Reporter

Penn’s hybrid work program for staff will continue through the spring 2022 semester and staff winter break will be extended an additional two days, University administrators announced in a Wednesday morning email. The email, authored by Penn President Amy Gutmann, Interim Provost Beth Winkelstein, Senior Executive Vice President Craig Carnaroli, and Executive Vice President for the Health System J. Larry Jameson, credited the success of University operations this fall to consistently low COVID-19 positivity rates on campus and high vaccination rates.

ment regarding the allegations against GTP or whether the University is aware of employee complaints submitted to the Medical School’s human resources department. Associate Vice President for Communications at Penn Medicine Holly Auer redirected the DP back to MacCarthy in response to a request for comment. Wilson did not respond to multiple requests for comment. ‘Shit falls downhill’: Employees belittled by meaningless job responsibilities All 11 current and former GTP employees who spoke to the DP alleged mistreatment and ineffective leadership by upper-level employees: namely Wilson and Jessica Alkins, GTP’s senior director of organizational strategy and operations, who leads the program’s human resources and administrative functions. Many former employees also said the program has an abnormally high turnover rate compared to biotech industry peers, largely because of the toxic environment. Multiple former employees said Alkins was responSEE GENE THERAPY PAGE 2

COVID-19 positivity rates have remained under 0.5% for the past eight weeks, and vaccination rates among students, staff, postdocs, and faculty are all over 97%, according to the email. On Oct. 12, the University announced that the vaccination rate for students reached 99%. The vaccination rate for faculty and undergraduates reached 97% in September 2021. Winter break will be extended by two days to include Jan. 3 and Jan. 4 as a show of gratitude, the email stated. Employees defined as essential workers may still have to work but are able to schedule alternative time off. Clinical Practices of the University of Pennsylvania physicians and Health System employees will follow the guidelines set by the Health System, the email stated. The administrators also encouraged members of the Penn community to get tested for COVID-19 before traveling for Thanksgiving break and winter break. In anticipation of increased testing before Thanksgiving break, COVID-19 testing center hours will be expanded to include Nov. 21, the Sunday before Thanksgiving, and the three weekdays preceding Thanksgiving. “As we approach the holiday season, we encourage you to celebrate how far we have come in the past 18 months, while remaining cautious and vigilant about our shared public health,” the email stated. “We thank you again for your resilience and flexibility as we move forward, and we wish everyone a joyful and safe Thanksgiving holiday.”

RAISE YOUR SALAD STANDARDS 3728 Spruce St

SEND STORY IDEAS TO NEWSTIP@THEDP.COM

ONLINE AT THEDP.COM

CONTACT US: 215-422-4640


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.