An architecture for dissent a critical reading of the new babylon

THEORY FOR THE SAKE OF THE THEORY

! "

#$%&'(&'')*

!

! " " + ,-

!

- ! . #/0 " 1 &''2 34*

" " / 5

#/5*

6

$%)3 $%3& !

7

"

" "

""

8

/5

9

:

! ; 5! ! #$%)4* : "

/5

"

8

"

< !

"

(

/5 /

=

"

(

"

> " "

" " -

" ! /

/

- 1 " ? : "(

!

"

@ !

"

7 /5

(

( (

1

(

"

!

"

( (

:

!

" "

- 9

!

A

!

!

"

1

"

" " ; " 1 /

- 1 "

" 1 "

= !

292

" " # $%)B $%C'* /

5

#/5* "

!

/5

"

" ( ! (

5

!

D

"

!

/

"

! (

#/0 " 1 &''2 $*

"

dĂŠtournement

8

7 !

"

8

! /5

"

-

" ? : " < 7

? : " "

1

" " "

#/0 " 1 &''2 &*

/

8

1 "

!

"

" "

!

!

E

" "

1 ! (

(9

!

"

9 "

"

#F $%%C*

"" :

!

! " " #F $%%C* 5 ( "

"

!

-

/

"

8

G "

" 7

E "

!

#/0 " 1 &''2 )2* + " " /5 9

: D , " F

/

" "

"

!

"

!

!

D " #/0 " 1 &''2 &*

:

"

!

"

!

:

"" 9

" - : " "

: " " ! !

/ A G 8

!

!

" #-

$%)B* -

" 9 G = H

293

THEORY FOR THE SAKE OF THE THEORY

"

" !

! #-

$%)B*

" 8

; " dĂŠtournement

"

" :

"

!

:

#/0 " 1 &''2 4)* /

/

" G / " #-

$%)B* 1.1. Modernist vs. unitary urbanism 5

" "

"

/

> /

"

#

* " : "

"

"

"

! #/0 " 1 &''2 )B* >

"

"

"

"

" # $%)%* -

!

: "

!

# $%)%*

" 1

&'

# $%)B* 5

"

" /

unitary urbanism 8

! #F $%)%*

"

!

"

"

"

" 1 :

#-

$%)%*

I

" 5 1

" 1

" "

!

#-

$%)%*

" G "

!

"

"

! : " #-

$%)B*

" "

! A G " "

!

1

!

"

! #-

$%)B* 5

!

"

!

! "

# $%)B*

"

" ! "

8 ! # $%)B* 5 8

8 ;

!

9

> " ! /5

!

! " H

# $%)B* >

" "

"

8

1.2. The New Babylon

"

+

" ! "

+

"

"

"

"

!

@

" :

! !

#/0 " 1 &''2 )2* + " " " 5

1 " "

" " :

"

!

!

"

!

! ! ? !

"

! D #/0 " 1 &''2 )2* +

"

:

" ( ! ( !

+

# $%)%*

!

"

"

"

( "

"

!

(

1 #

$%)%* !

9 !

"

" "

6

# $%)%*

"

! 9

.! "

"

"

"

" "

" J

J

! "

( D

# $%C2* 1.3. Direct experience vs. textual and architectural utopias ! "

/ !

/5

1 K ; 5

-"

" ! !

:

"

# ! $%)4* :

;

$%)4 $% 5! !

!

$%)B 9 D

/5

" "

!

"

"

"

295

THEORY FOR THE SAKE OF THE THEORY

( ; :

: ! #$%)4*

"

J L F #$%)&*

J

"

: ! 1

! "

"

"

"

" "

"

"

D !

"

! " "

" ! "

"

" # ! $%)4* 5 !

"

7

" "

"

"

!

" 9

" :

"

5

1

" !

6

! (

" " !

# ! $%)4* < D

:

M

"

:

!

A G< "

!

" " !

!

#

!

" " "

* # ! $%)4* ! :

"

!

8 !

!

8

" :

!

;

8

" 4F " : "

D "

! :

!

!

: "

" ! "

" "

" ! "

! ! (

" J !

D "

!

F !

"

! "

"

"

!

!

"

>

"

" : :

! "

!

5 6 ? $%CB !

:

!

296

5

! " :

!

! "

#< $%%B*

! 9 !

6

" "

! "

#/0 " 1 &''2* @ 8

! "" 9

6

!

@ !

"" 9

" @ ! !

"

" ! " "

"

"

"

D

:

: !

!

!

!

/ ! !

:

/ 5 :

I !

! /5

!

F

"

:

"" 9 !

!

: :

5

1 !

"

"

"

/

" $%)'

$%3) !

" "

!

, "

! !

" " !

"

N

> "

"

!

-

"

/

- 1 " " ( E " !

O /

("

!

: "

H

! " # <

" /

"

" "

7

N > " /

" $%)'

> "

! !

:

"

@

" !

#/0 " 1 &''2 %&(%4* 5 " ! /

" "

! "

"

"

8

!

"

1 -

8

" 5 297

THEORY FOR THE SAKE OF THE THEORY

9 " 1

"

#/0 " 1 &''2 %&(%4* "

" ! !

"

:

1

" " "

! " " "

"

"

!

"

7 : "

#/0 " 1 &''2 %&(%4* > "

"

:

! 4F "

! 5

" :

!

"

" " " "

" !

"

"

"

" " "

!

"

" "

-

"

!

-

6

"

"

@

1 ? !

;

/5

"

"

8

" 4F "

"

E @ : "

!

"

8

O

H

5

/

" "

# D ! * " " !

@ ! ! "

1 " "

/ > "

;

$ % ! % -

" 9 "

"

D

9

$%C$ " " #

$%%B -

" - ! O D &'$$* "

D !

7

" /

! !

""

#! " " $%C&(C2 # $ $%C2* 6

!

#% $ house, $%C) Seaside Bubbles $%CC & $%CC '

Suitaloon $%CC* - " "

Control and ' #$%C3* " !

!

"

" !

(

298

#$%CB($%3&* D

!

8

"

-

" "

6

" " O

" "

; " ! " : !

"

"

> "

D

!

!

" ,

! !

-

" " -

"

:

5

!

"

I

" > "

-

" D

:

! @ !

/

1 (

" " !

"

! " /

9 "

"

!

"

E

" " "

! ""

! =

"

(

D ;

@ !

! ! "

!

!

" "

1 !

! !

"

! 8

!

& $ ' ! (

> " -

"

!

! !

5

/

- 1 "

$%C' 5 : =

- 1 " #$%CB(3&* "

" :

"

: " #

"

1

! *

" #

1 "

1 " * "

"

"

" " 1

!

8 !

#

1 &''C / =

&''& K

?

&''4* / " / : "

!

'

#$%C%* "

9

!

5

"

: "

"

9 !

/

"

!

9 ! D 299

THEORY FOR THE SAKE OF THE THEORY

(

) * )

#$%3&*

D

""

" -

"

:

! !

! "

"

-

"

!

,

" "

"

- 1 " /

" "

" ! "

D !

" !

E " ! !

7 ? :

/

/

- 1 "

"

> " "

8 ! =

8 ! :

!

"

" <

!

! !

8 "

" #F $%%C*

1 " :

"

"

D -

" > "

"

!

! :

!

" ""

" ; "

+

"

1

(

+ @ !

"

" ! "

!

!

D

" !

"

" ! "

"

8

8

6 8 ! < ! (

!

9 !

=

8

"

!

Q 5

"

/

- 1 "

1

) * ! + " O / #$%$%(*

" " @ ! "

"

> " "

1

"

!

! " "

"

"

E

( 9

"

#/ $%3'* / - #

R *

" (

5

" " : " " E

!

300

" " 1 "

@ "

!

"

8

/

" D

"

!

8

" <

!

!

5

" !

!

9

; 9

"

@ !

"

!

!

" harmony

5

"

" "

" J

"

" J/

" <

" /

!

" " 9 "

!

"

-

"

/

- 1 "

! # "

* ! "

: " "

# ! * > "

-

"

" "

""

!

"" 9

! "

"

" "

" "

"

5

! " "

!

& "

"

! "

@ !

7 /5

: "

( (

1

(

(

"

!

"

( (

:

!

" "

#

" "

*

#

&''3 L

&''3*

(

" ! "

D

(! " 1

6

7 !

!

" ! "

!

! !

!

"

"

,

!

"

1 "

" "

" 1 # $%%$* !

THEORY FOR THE SAKE OF THE THEORY

" "

! "

"

! 8 ! !

1 :

( " " $ +

"

! "

" "

1

9

+

"

7 H !

" : .

A

:

:

!

!

- ' / K L #&''2* Bolo Bolo O ? #$%B)* " 1

:

" 9

8 (

- "

! ;

! "

!

9

=

=

( ""

" "

:

!

: " ) , !

"

!

" !

9

! 5

(

"

D "

!

1

"

"

"

"

" "

;

" " ! !

" 5 "

D

"

- "

!

A

!

! "

=

"

" " ; " 1 /

- 1 "

H 7

!

D

-

: "

M + ( /

Cemetery of Baghdad #&''3*

. ? 5 <

(

(

"

!

"

!

$S - : " .

# ; ATT T ! T *

8 ;

# ; ATT

* ? 8 ;

# ; ATT " TQ U *

( # ; ATT

* 302

" -

$%)B F 9

>

0

V$

" >

- @ / W

X -! A Y ; ATT

T T/5T T T3Z W- A - &'$$X -

$%)%

" . $%)' >

0

V4

" >

O @ "" W

X -! A Y ; ATT ! T

T T

" Z W- A - &'$$X @ $%%$ (1 -1 213 ( ( - 2 4

-

! ( W

X -! AY ; ATT " "T T 1[ " Z W- A - &'$$X

1 - &''C " ' 3 - 5 - @ : ! 5 $%)4 > "

"

" >

\ \ &''C W

X -! AY ; ATT

T/5T !

"Z W- - &'$$X O < $%%% - O

-

O

L &''3 67st ' 8 3 - - "%

5

9

N A O ! ? "

F L $%)& / 1 > "

" >

\ \ &''4 W

X -! A Y ; ATT

T/5T 9 " T "Z W- A - &'$$X F L $%)% /

E >

0

V4

" >

\ \ W

X -! AY ; ATT

T/5T4 E "Z W- A - &'$$X F L $%%C %: ( ;

" >

- . " ] + ^ _ A - ` a > " N &''' >

> " 5 / /

M @ Non!

3 9 - -

O $'2($$) L

&''3 -

" , =

!

0 $&A $ &% b 2B W

X -! AY ; ATT : T$' $'B'T$4)C%4$'C'$'%))%BZ W- - &'$$X K O ?

< &''4 3 & # 4 > ?

A /

K L \ &''2 / ; 8: $

" .

N `" ` _ A - ` a

$%)B + + ?

+ O ! >

0

V&

" >

O @ "" W

X -! AY ; ATT ! T

T T" " Z W- A - &'$$X

$%)% -

>

0

V4

" >

O @ "" W

X -! AY ; ATT ! T

T T 4 " Z W- A - &'$$X

$%C' F

N c >

0

V2

" >

O @ ""

W

X -! AY ; ATT ! T

T T 1 " Z W- A - &'$$X

$%C2 A -

" > -

303

THEORY FOR THE SAKE OF THE THEORY

Design 42 4'2(4')

$%CC

" > d

" e in ! V%

" F d >

? e $%3' W

X -! AY ; ATT

T (

" " Z W- A - &'$$X

$%3' A @ " K

W

X -! AY ; ATT

T " ( " Z W- - &'$$X

$%32 < ;

:

@ L " " " @ W

X -!

AY ; ATT

T ( " Z W- - &'$$X O / $%%& ( ) ? % 3 ( 0

!

- , O ? $%B) Bolo Bolo N A / " : # * / / $%%% ( ' ?5 O

! / ? ?f + &'') 9. 3

7@AE"FE ?

A O

/ O $%3' - 3 ( ' 0 ) "

K

A ?5 O

/0 " 1 + &''2 8 3 ) G

H$ ?

5

!

/ = ? &''& , 7 , 7

F

- 1 " / -- 23 &4(4C -

" - ! O D W

X -! A Y ; ATT

" "

TZ W- - &'$$X < ? $%%B '

I

3 ( / "- 8 , ; "A '$' O

< ? c &''$ ( - 8 3 ?

- ?5 O K

!

" #$

%

#

& & '

+

"

! > " !

! 1 , "

" !

"

-

9

" " =

: "

" < ""

I 8

?

"

"

!

D

!

"

N

"

" ! ! ,

(@ 1 !

"

6 $%%&(%)

E

#

*

- F O - " $

( !

"

!

A >

(@ 1 ! , /

g 5

5 !

G

!

D

#" (*

"

(@ 1 !

>

!

? "

" % -/ ' % 0 45 $ / % 6 L

(@ 1 !

! 1

O -6 " =

\ "

$&''.

$2C4 "

+; " ."

F

" \ " " D

"

" < +; "

8

" $)

5 "

" "

" 9

!

5 " 5 " 1

! $)'

? " $S F O - "

$%%)

-

@ 1 ! !

, /

>

@ 1 !

5 , /

"

!

/

>

!

#

? " *

F

g

&'''

"

" !

"

305