recordings methods and machinations for detroit recordings, as a verb, represents a search for and an investigation into the potentials of tools for acting in difficult urban situations. Detroit stands in one of these situations, being one of the foremost case studies of Fordist cities in a post-industrial landscape. But the same urban difficulty has produced something akin to the “proletarian position�: a reduction to a zero level, where the conditions of daily existence are exposed and open to evaluation. The act of recording invokes the Latin cor, or the heart; a record serves to register, to commit to memory, to remember by heart. The heart, symbolic of empathy, serves as a reminder when answering the question: what do we remember? Empathy for existing efforts at renewal, as well as our collective tendency towards the diversified and the multipolar, points us towards beginning with the current network of social infrastructure in Detroit. The zero level position in this pamphlet is a series of operations that derives from this study of the city. recordings, as noun, also serves as the drawing surface for our operational notations. As an object, the record bears the marks of a progression of time and event. As a methodology, recordings is a register for the sequential layering of our initial operations, tracking the agreement and contradiction, the negotiation, the hybridisation and the wilful collision of actions. By drawing on both the urban and the organisational and searching for combinations between the two, as applied to sites throughout the city, recordings seeks a means to comprehend, inhabit and anticipate our urban futures.
NO 3765
PA35
pamphlet architecture 35
recordings
recordings methods and machinations for detroit
methods and machinations for detroit
NO 3765
as a city, Detroit is exemplary on many levels. It is one of the foremost case studies of the Fordist city in a post-industrial landscape. It stands, scarecrow-like, as a reminder of the effects that large-scale racial divisions and suburban flight can have on an urban area. And in a world facing rising inequalities in wealth, education and access to basic needs, the Detroit experience reinforces the importance of equitable distributions for sustainable growth. But Detroit is one of the few cities where cumulative urban trauma has produced something akin to the “proletarian position”1 that Slavoj Zizek describes, after Marx, as a reduction to a zero level, where the conditions of daily existence are exposed and open to evaluation. The city’s population, with its civil society, local government and private
enterprise, finds itself in the rare position of holding the trump to future placemaking. This potential is rapidly being exercised, in part by large land-holding developers, but also by community organisations and individuals. As a group that was born at the dawn of what Rem Koolhaas terms “the bonfire of neoliberalism”2, we are able to look back with acute awareness of the differences between the generation of architects that shaped the post-historical spaces in which we grew up, and ourselves. Detroit, and other cities like it, represents our fears of what our own contemporary cities could become. At the same time, it presents the possibility of testing and negotiating the terms on which urban environments are shaped, in an attempt to pre-empt their eventual decline.
recordings, as verb, represents a search for and an investigation into the potentials of tools for acting in difficult urban situations. The act of recording invokes the Latin cor, or the heart; a record serves to register, to commit to memory, to remember by heart. The heart, symbolic of empathy, serves as a reminder when answering the question: what do we remember? Empathy for the existing efforts at renewal, as well as our collective tendency towards the diversified and the multipolar, points us towards beginning with the current network of social infrastructure. This includes and highlights in particular the organisations that are currently working in Detroit. The zero level position in this pamphlet is a series of operations that derives from this study of the city. As a pair of cross-moves, the
translation of institutionally concrete but non-materialised organisational structures is coupled with its inverse of translating physically present but connectively immaterial infrastructural networks. The result is a trio of abstract actions [a, b, c] that provide starting points for understanding urban formations. recordings, as noun, also serves as the drawing surface for our operational notations. As an object, the record bears the marks of a progression of time and event. As a methodology, recordings is a register for the sequential layering of our initial operations, tracking the agreement and contradiction, the negotiation, the hybridisation and the wilful collision of actions. A trio of operations becomes a sextet of permutations: c|b|a3, b|c|a, c|a|b, a|c|b, a|b|c, b|a|c.
The formal structure of the recording process provides the guidelines for a diverse set of outcomes. At each step, notation from the previous phase is open to interpretation. The state of the drawing, as it stands, is never a static assumption; each successive actor constructs anew the relationship between the previous and current operation. This diversity in outcomes underlines the potential for the method to deal with multiple programmatic types, in a range of urban contexts. Cities such as Detroit, which have withdrawn from their historical peak in terms of land area and population size, pose a particular challenge. At the scale of the entire city, sociological patterns of withdrawal and decline of services can inform the provision of infrastructure and future allocation of scarce resources. At the
scale of the individual organisation, whether commercial enterprise or non-profit, specific gaps in community-level amenities can serve as potential points of entry. But a set of guiding principles has yet to be formulated in between those two scales. recordings moves towards such a formulation. By drawing on a combination of the urban and the organisational, as applied to a series of sites throughout the city, it seeks a means to comprehend, inhabit and anticipate our urban futures. 1
Slavoj Zizek, Demanding the Impossible
(Polity, 2013), 57. 2
Rem Koolhaas and Hans Ulrich Obrist,
Project Japan: Metabolism Talks... (Taschen, 2011), 12. 3
In other words, c, given that b, given
that a.
NO 3765
supports small-scale operations by distributing hardware and technical knowledge, as well as providing farmers with a channel for sales.
the path into Detroit, analytically speaking, can be described from a birds-eye view of the city, magnified in plan. Flights to DTW—the airport serving metropolitan Detroit as well as Windsor, Ontario—enable this view by passing over Lake Erie and the city. From the air, Detroit can be understood in terms of the highways that cut through the city. From the plan, we know that social infrastructure is plentiful when it comes to churches and fast food outlets—an archipelago of Coney Islands dot the city—but scarce where hospitals, police stations and fire departments are concerned. But the experience of entering Detroit is overwhelmingly tied to the point of view of the automobile. Visitors from Chicago join the disembarking DTW travellers on Interstate 94, while drivers approach from the south via the I-75 and from the east
over the Ambassador Bridge. It is the experience of Detroit that causes the initial perceptual confusion of the city: large scaleless industrial facilities, avenues that feel wider than they look in plan, the dimly lit streetscape at night, the vacancy of the levelled lot of Tiger Stadium. Over the course of our visit, we keep a constant driving beat while meeting with several organisations working in Detroit. PracticeSpace, a design incubator that works alongside wouldbe businesses in developing and documenting their strategic plans, that they might be able to start securing funding. Habitat for Humanity Detroit, a build-based non-profit that is working in the Morningside area, shared their approach towards neighbourhood stabilisation through housing. And Keep Growing Detroit, an urban farming collective that
We find ourselves returning to the site of the former Tiger Stadium in Corktown as a prototypical test case for our methodology. As a site it lies vacant but for the baseball diamond, laden with cultural meaning, resolutely tended to by the Navin Field Grounds Crew. Being in Corktown, it lies in a neighbourhood that has gradually become stabilised through the efforts of local organisations and investors. Needing few immediate attempts at building, but standing on the cusp of potential growth as part of the Detroit Future City plan, the aim is to develop a working set of principles to guide development.
NO 3765
level zero
This operation takes on the idea, drawn from the PracticeSpace model, that it is the projection of fragments throughout the city that generates densities and relationships. The edges of buildings in Corktown are projected infinitely outwards, terminating only where they are blocked by other buildings. Intersections indicate a point where two projected edges meet; a higher density of intersections indicates points where any intervention engages a multitude of existing urban fragments.
a
This operation draws on the Habitat for Humanity model of edge and fill by identifying porosities within the pattern of existing ownership and developing thickened street edges. Figure-ground notation indicates lots that are vacant, as well as those that are under or minimally utilised. A pathfinding algorithm is deployed to identify streets that might ordinarily see heightened activity. These lines of activity receive thickened edges that begin to converse with the previous patterns of vacancy.
b
This operation pursues a macroscopic view of Corktown through the lens of the social infrastructure of Detroit. The degree of specificity is of importance: in a food desert, for example, the presence of a Coney Island becomes a vital node of social activity. A network of connections is conjured between nodes of similar services without regard to existing street-level circulation. Multiple layers of such networks begin to define a new set of districting principles where infrastructural links are key.
c NO 3765
a|b
level one
The thickened lines in the initial operation b are read as indicating a zonal mode of working. Operation a thickens activity around the site by overlaying the lines of projection and searching for areas of density in these lines. The projected edges and the gaps between them become significant in considering the boundaries of the thickened area. Volumes push upwards and downwards to limits prescribed by the topographical diagram; the baseball field begins to assert its volumetric presence.
Each line in the network of given connections in c is thickened into a pipe, or a bar. This allows for the development of a linear passage with a thick zone between its edges. The topographical diagram of intersecting projections is overlaid onto the network. Where the topography meets the edges of the bar, it becomes carved away, delineating the zones within the bars from the areas beyond their edges. In the former, the topography is allowed to rise above the ground surface.
Trimmed by its projected edges, the topographical diagram of points in operation a undergoes a sorting process that separates it into three bands of low, mid-level and high. The fragmentary distribution of points in each band are given thickness, then volume, and combined into an aggregation of blocks. The boundaries of social activity in the form of pedestrians and Tiger Stadium are allowed to influence the limits of the mass, asserting the zonal mode of action onto the pre-existing fragments.
b|a
A network of lines is drawn from the infrastructural web in operation c. The lines form knots at their points of intersection, indicating significant positions where activities may cross each other. These knots are organised relative to a datum line that extends from the baseball field, and a jogged edge forms according to the distance between each knot and the datum. The zone in between the edge and the datum becomes a thickened area that are read alongside the areas of activity.
c|a
The thickened lines of activity from operation b are separated into their various programmatic strands. A weaving process takes place where each local strand of activity is aligned with the larger infrastructural network in c. The linear elements in the larger network are allowed to carve new streets out of the site, and the strands of activity are realigned in response.
This phase proceeds from the topographical diagram in operation a and overlays a planometric approach onto it. The boundaries of the site in c are taken as the edges of a figure, while the infrastructural network serves as the slicing mechanism that subsequently cuts the figure into smaller interstitial areas. Projecting these areas isolates the particular zones of topography that are engaged by the infrastructural net , creating a three-dimensional figure set on a two-dimensional ground condition.
a|c
b|c
c|b NO 3765
a|b|c level two
Vacant lots within Corktown, as indicated by operation b are subjected to the same organisation relative to a datum line as occurs in b|c. The lots are projected and allowed to register as the footprints of volumes on the parts of Tiger Stadium not taken up by social activity. These footprints are rotated to meet the edges of the projecting lines, then thickened. The resulting volumes are displaced upwards as a marker of their scale and distance relative to the datum line.
b|a|c The bars in operation a|c are taken as instruments for sampling vertical height, and the line of intersection with the topographical diagram the measurements. The samples are taken within the extents of the site as marked out in operation c. The measuring lines are then thickened, according to the type of activity, to produce volumes or embankments holding the topography behind it. Where the thickened volumes intrude on the zones of activity, their vertical surfaces are trimmed.
c|a|b
The volume provided in operation a|b is re-situated within its larger topographical diagram and read planometrically to carve a distinct footprint from the topography. Within this area, the topography is trimmed to its boundary and vertical measurements from operation a are allowed to emerge in place. A suggestion of the volume remains over its footprint. The topography is then further trimmed according to the site as defined by operation c.
This operation takes the two-dimensional result from operation c|b and interprets it through the topographical diagram in a. The diagram is thickened to form a solid volume over the areas indicated in the previous operation, with the topography intersecting it in particular zones. The infrastructural network from operation c is allowed to slice through this solid volume, creating lines of passage internally.
a|c|b The topographical figure sitting atop on a two-dimensional ground condition from operation c|a is sampled for vertical height. The surface receives a translation to cellular units by extrusion according to the measurements at each point. The cells are then trimmed according to the zones of activity, producing an open condition at the points where they intersect. In the place of each deleted cell is a vertical measure of the height at that point.
b|c|a The aggregated volumes from operation b|a are rotated so that they are oriented according to strong edges as defined by operation a. Lines of passage from operation c are given thickness; volumes within this thickness are identified and subjected to a second rotation so that they are oriented perpendicularly to the lines, with narrower faces serving as fronts. Overlapping volumes are united into larger agglomerations and open spaces defined in line with operation c.
c|b|a NO 3765
to the history of land ownership around Tiger Stadium and Corktown. The levelling of houses for parking around the stadium saw the consolidation of individual property tracts; the same swaths of land now lie dormant as activity today no longer reaches the same feverish heights.
a multitude of tiger stadiums Operation c|b|a, as an approach to Tiger Stadium, relies on an idea of part and fragment. Points on the site, formed by the projected edges of operation a, each generate a unit volume, or a thickening in the language of operation b. These unit volumes possess dimensions close to a single-family house, or a small commercial space. The volumes are rotated so that they front the projected edges that generated them, and displaced vertically according to the vertical measure at their origin points. Finally, circulatory paths are inserted through the massed volumes, corresponding to the infrastructural network in operation c.
Corktown’s recent growth has been characterised by efforts by individuals concerned with a lot-by-lot reclamation of the city from abandonment. This ethos nudges us towards respecting the precarious return to Tiger Stadium that the users of the baseball diamond have been nurturing. The unused stadium lot has the potential to embody this way of building, by turning away from largescale moves in favour of principles that guide smaller scale and fiscally sustainable development that may, over time, amass themselves into a larger body—a multitude of Tiger Stadiums.
In its fragmentary language, the proposal conceives of the individual as the starting point of a community, whether that individual is a person or an organisation [a body corporate]. This stands in marked contrast
c|b|a NO 3765
c|b|a NO 3765