Mitchell’s Musings 12-30-13: Ill-Defined Benefit Plans

Page 1

Mitchell’s Musings 12-30-13: Ill-Defined Benefit Plans Daniel J.B. Mitchell Defined-benefit pensions in the public sector are under attack for creating large unfunded liabilities. Let’s put aside the pros and cons of the debate on the scope of the problem. And let’s instead discuss a particular commonly-suggested “solution” to those unfunded liabilities. In some cases, governments have changed the pension programs for new hires but have left the plans for current workers unchanged. That approach is relatively unambiguous as to what it means (apart from whether it is a good idea). In some cases, employee contributions to pensions have been stepped up. There are issues about that approach – both legal and in terms of labor market analysis and personnel policy – but, again, what is entailed is pretty straight-forward. It is easy to understand. The most extreme approach appears to be unfolding in Detroit, where pensions of both current workers and retirees may be cut. Whether that approach stands up legally - or what will happen if it does - is unclear. So let’s put the Detroit approach aside, too. Recently, an initiative was filed in California that would give public employers the right to change (make less attractive) the pension formula for existing employees going forward, but assuring them they could keep the benefits they have earned to date. Whether the group pushing that initiative will actually have or want to spend the money needed to put it on the ballot (typically $1 million to $2 million), remains to be seen. However, the approach - rather than that particular initiative - is what we want to discuss since a) it is an approach commonly proposed – not just in California - and b) while it sounds straight forward, it is actually ill-defined and potentially misleading. Specifically, what does “keep-what-you-have-earnedto-date” actually entail? Let’s start with two charts I used to show in a labor markets class when defined-benefit pensions were discussed.

1


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
Mitchell’s Musings 12-30-13: Ill-Defined Benefit Plans by Daniel J.B. Mitchell - Issuu